Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Beneath The Ice

Rate this book
For as long as he can remember, Weston Hale has relied on a layer of ice to protect himself. It was how he learned to survive—by feeling less, asking for nothing, and never relying on anyone.
But in the aftermath of Luke’s injury, Wes is forced to look beneath the ice—to confront his fear, his guilt, and the damage his silence has caused.
Slowly, Wes begins to believe that moving forward might be possible.
But the past isn’t finished with him yet.
When new information comes to light, Wes learns there was far more to Kai’s death than he ever knew. The discovery fractures everything he thought he had come to terms with. It feels like losing Kai all over again—not just the man he loved, but the trust he believed they shared.
As grief resurfaces in a new and devastating form, Wes risks undoing everything he’s worked to rebuild.
Loving Luke means unlearning the silence that once kept him safe.
Failing means letting the ice form again—and losing the future he fought to believe was possible.

487 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 17, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Raya J. Su

4 books12 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
82 (68%)
4 stars
32 (26%)
3 stars
5 (4%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
1 review
September 19, 2026
I have read a lot of books. Hundreds, maybe thousands in fact. I have read countless Goodreads reviews I have thought about writing my own reviews more times than I can count, and yet I have never actually sat down and written one.

Until Beneath the Ice.

I read Shift Change during the summer and immediately fell in love with these characters, so I have genuinely been counting down the days for the release of Beneath the Ice. I had such high hopes for this book, and somehow Raya J. Su still managed to exceed every single one of them.

This book was everything.

Utterly incredible. Beautifully devastating. Emotional in a way that completely consumed me. I cried SO much reading this book, and even now, after finishing it, I feel like I’m still carrying these characters around with me.

Raya J. Su has an incredible ability to make you feel what her characters are feeling. Not just understand their emotions from the page, but actually experience them alongside them. There were moments where it genuinely felt like I wasn’t reading about Wes and Luke — I was them. Their pain, their fear, their hope, their frustration, their love… all of it felt so incredibly real.

And Wes.

Watching his journey, his progress, the major setback, and then watching him slowly find his feet again was heartbreaking and beautiful. I felt so invested in every little step forward and every moment where things became harder again. His journey felt human. Raw. Messy. And so incredibly emotional.

And then there’s Kai.

That sweet boy absolutely broke my heart. His story is devastating, and learning more about what he had suffered through made everything surrounding him hurt even more. There is such a deep sense of I wish someone could have saved him when you learn his story. You just want to reach into the pages and protect him from everything he endured.

And then there is Luke. Sweet, sweet Luke.

I honestly think Luke has become one of my favourite characters I have ever read. He is everything. Supportive beyond belief. Patient. Kind. Gentle. Understanding. He shows up. Again and again and again. The way he loves and supports Wes absolutely destroyed me in the best possible way.

Everybody needs a Luke.

The relationship between these characters is what made this book so special for me. The connection, the tenderness, the vulnerability, the way they understand each other — it all felt so genuine. I cared so deeply about all of them, and I don’t think I’ll be forgetting them anytime soon.

There are books you enjoy, books you love, books you can’t put down… and then there are books that stay with you.

This is one of those books.

I finished it feeling emotionally wrung out, completely heartbroken, ridiculously happy, and somehow grateful for every single tear. There were moments I had to stop reading because I was feeling too much. And honestly? I wouldn’t change a thing.

This book made me laugh, ache, cry, hope and fall completely in love with its characters.

And the fact that this is the book that finally made me write my first Goodreads review after reading hundreds of books probably says more than anything else I could write.

Raya J. Su, you absolutely broke my heart and I loved every second of it.

Beneath the Ice was everything. ❤️

P.S. Someone please, PLEASE option the TV/film rights to this book because I am telling you now — this would make EPIC television. The characters, the storyline, the emotion, the heartbreak… I need to see Wes, Luke and Kai brought to life. I NEED IT. 😭
Profile Image for Mrss_yoshi.
240 reviews7 followers
August 28, 2026
I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This book Is without a doubt the saddest book I have ever read. I came into this knowing there would be tears but I wasn't prepared for just how many.
The ultimate hurt/comfort, grumpy X sunshine couple, Wes is the grumpy one with a dry sense of humour and Luke is just like a ray of sunshine, always trying to make everyone smile, happy (most of the time),eager to please and just the sweetest boy.

Shift Change was heartbreaking and this book carries on straight from where that left off, in the hospital after Luke's accident.
What follows is some of the toughest and saddest chapters to read.
Watching Luke's recovery and Wes being pretty much helpless (apart from making sure he eats/takes his medicine) as Luke wants nothing to do with him after what he said.
My heart broke for Wes, yes I was angry at him but he still had not come to terms with Kai's death and in turn took it out on Luke.
My heart was mended a little bit when they started to work things out only for the:

'hey, Sweetheart ' line and oh my god I was a sobbing mess, it was not pretty.

Chapter 22, 23 ,24, 25, 26 were the roughest chapters of the book and at one point I thought I wouldn't be able to continue, I didn't think I had any tears left.


“He was already gone,"

“He was sitting right there with us.” His voice cracked. “But our Kai was already gone.”

Those line from chapter 23 stuck with me through the whole book.

This was the beginning of Wes downfall if you like, What transpired afterwards was the kick start he needed to let himself heal.

Watching Wes start to deal with his grief to then have all that progress ripped away when it came to light what poor poor sweet Kai had gone through was the hardest bit of this book. That poor boy, thinking that the only thing he could do was remove himself.
I knew what Kai had gone through was gonna be bad and I'm so glad we didn't actually find out as I really would not have been able to cope with it.

The Bahamas trip, oh my god that chapter broke something in me , the dream he had of Kai. But at the same time it was the breakthrough Wes needed in his journey.


"Kai is gone, Wes. Luke isn’t. Say what you need to say there, so when you go home, you can be present with the person who is still waiting for you."

But Raya, why oh why did you have to bring the glass back into play, that scene in Shift Change broke something in me and seeing it again broke that even more.
There is so much of this book I loved too, Benny and Beck were absolutely hilarious and the comedic relief that was needed in the darkness, I cannot wait to read their book to see what happened between them.

The ending was absolutely perfect, they deserved everything good that happened to them.

To think that this is the authors second book is something else entirely, the writing, the characters and character development is phenomenal.
Raya J. Su is now an auto buy/auto read author for me now.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Rianne.
61 reviews4 followers
October 24, 2026
This was perfection ❤️ I had to put the book away because I didn't want to sob around other people.
Everything was very well thought out and came together, the smallest of details. Wow.
❤️❤️
60 reviews
August 29, 2026
I received an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

Wes and Luke (and Kai)

I don’t know why I thought this follow up to Shift Change would be a less emotional read. After reading the first part of the story of Kai and Wes and Luke, I have no excuse for being unexpectedly wrecked the way I was.

First of all - another great book. Beautifully written continuation of the story of Wes and Luke and the work Wes must do to be able to love again.

Second of all - so many tears, sobs, ugly cries and snot. We know from Shift Change more will eventually be revealed about Kai’s tragic story, but I didn’t realize I would start tearing up in Chapter One, or for that to be the fist of many increasingly emotional moments throughout the book.

This is a continuation of the story of Wes and Luke and picks up where we left them in the last book. Wes had been a complete asshole to Luke. Luke is a sweetheart who wears his heart on his sleeve and has been through some things so he absolutely did not deserve any of Wes’ bullshit. And although we knew what set Wes off, our sweet Luke had no idea about Kai and blamed himself for not being enough for Wes. And then something bad happened to Luke.

So at the beginning of this book Luke needs to recover from an injury and Wes convinces Luke’s brothers he should stay at Wes’ house so he can look after him. Luke, still feeling the hurt from the last time he was with Wes, doesn’t want to be there and and does everything he can to keep Wes away from him and be uncooperative.

Eventually Luke thinks he knows some things and has a panic attack and we get this exchange:

“I’ll take whatever you’re willing to give me,” Luke said, his voice cracking. “If all you want is a fuck buddy, I can do that. I can give you that.”

And my heart shattered. Cue the first of many sobs. Luke feels so broken and so unloveable that your heart just breaks for him and this scene really kicks off the first of several beautiful heartfelt moments in the book. Both men are able to eventually let their guard down and be vulnerable as they communicate honestly and try to help eachother through eachother’s own unique kind of pain.

As Wes and Luke get closer and begin to fall in love, Wes continues to work through the grief and regrets he carries from his relationship with Kai. And he does pretty good until the details of the last few months of Kai’s life come to light. This immediately throws Wes (and me) into a downward spiral and eventually leads Wes to the big crash out. And I get it because I crashed out too.

This is a beautiful love story — no, actually this is two beautiful love stories and both have to find a way to coexist in the midst of tragedy and loss.

This author writes the grief, the loss, the pain, the guilt, the internal dialogue, the self-destructive coping mechanisms so accurately and with so much authenticity that you’re right there with Wes and everyone else as they’re experiencing it all.

And amongst all that she’s still weaving together these heartfelt love stories filled with connection and desire and some damn good spice.

Some things you’ll find -
* There is more the one loving supportive family.
* There are some great friends and side characters.
* We have another grumpy/sunshine
* There is mental health rep for sure

The author teases 2 more books in this series and I cannot wait to get my hands on them.

Easy 5 out of 5 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Highly recommend.
40 reviews2 followers
September 20, 2026
*I received this book in exchange for an honest review*

I thought Shift Change crushed my heart, but Beneath The Ice shredded it some more and then slowly put it back together. There are many taboo and heavy topics that these books cover, but these topics are incredibly important. People deserve to know they're not alone and it's ok to talk about things. The author does an amazing job immersing you into these topics. Your mental health matters, so please be sure to read the warnings prior to reading this series.

If you made it this far into my review.... where do we even start?! This book immediately picks up where Shift Change left off. Luke was seriously injured and Wes finds himself by his side as often as he is allowed to be.

I am glad the author split this story into two books. This second story explores so much more about each character, their past, the hurt they have experienced and the things that have happened to shape them into the character that they are. Kai.. sweet Kai.. there is SO much that is explained to why he took the route that he ultimately did. Kai had an amazing support system, but ultimately he struggled in silence.

Wes continued to struggle in this book, but the growth.. the growth between his relationship with himself, his memory of Kai, his relationship with his mom, his relationship with Luke. There was so much growth, but it wasn't easy, wasn't pretty, and there was no specific timeline on how his grief progressed. When he thought he had things under control something changed that made him feel otherwise. He went to therapy and worked through a lot.

Luke spent a significant amount of time recovering from his injury. Things were so rocky with him and Wes in the beginning of his healing that I honestly thought they were not going to be able to make it through things. Luke's own pain and trauma were also revealed as the story progressed. He was willing to accept being a f-buddy just to have a piece of Wes while Luke deserved SO much more, and over time Wes realized what he was offering Luke wasn't enough. Luke handled the grief with Kai with so much grace and effort. He wanted to be there for Wes, support him as much as he could, and it led to them creating something amazing to honor Kai and his legacy.

I feel like I could go on about this book forever, but this series is one I will absolutely continue to recommend. I am so honored to have been part of this ARC team.
Profile Image for Helen.
149 reviews1 follower
November 3, 2026
Just when I thought I'd recovered from the heartbreak of Book 1, Cracks in the Ice, along came this next instalment to have me crying ugly tears in the middle of the night all over again!

As with the first book, this is a beautifully told story that explores deeply emotional themes of love, loss and the challenge of surviving and healing from overwhelming grief. In particular, it explores the hope, fear and guilt that come with finding new love while still deeply mourning and honouring the love you've lost.

The next chapter of Wes and Luke's story starts happily enough, and for the first half of the book, their relationship goes from strength to strength. But when unexpected and deeply troubling truths about Kai's death come to light, they threaten to turn everything Wes thought he knew upside down. Unable to cope with what emerges, Wes begins to spiral, and it isn't long before he risks being completely consumed by anger and rage on behalf of the man he loved.

My heart broke for both Luke and Wes all over again in this book.

Luke's character is beautifully portrayed. Even through Wes's darkest moments, he remains unfailingly kind, tender and supportive. He does everything he can to be there for Wes through his grief, including embracing and honouring Kai's memory. But as Wes sinks deeper into his torment and memories of the past, Luke's own hurt and sense of rejection grow, and he begins to fear that he'll never be enough to heal Wes's heart. The fact that he never walks away, despite his own devastation, says everything about what an incredible human being he is.

And as for Wes... well, he's a gruff bear of a man who feels everything incredibly deeply but struggles to put those feelings into words. His love for Kai runs deep through his bones, but he's also desperate to love Luke in the way he deserves. Fortunately, with the help of a good therapist, Wes finally begins to understand that loving Luke doesn't mean he has to let go of the love he had for Kai. And with that realisation, the hope of a happy ending finally starts to emerge.

This was a tough read emotionally. It's a non-stop rollercoaster of joy and pain, and I honestly feel a little wrecked now that I've finished it! While it's not without its flaws (I felt the first half was slightly overlong, and I still found the hockey content a little too detailed), it's such a gorgeous, moving book that it's still very deserving of 4.5/5 stars.


Profile Image for Alexa Leigh.
16 reviews1 follower
September 5, 2026
I received an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.

I have been thinking about Wes, Kai, and Luke since the moment I finished Shift Change. And I genuinely did not know how you follow a six-star read with ANOTHER six-star read, but somehow Raya managed to do exactly that.

This story broke everything inside of me.

In book one, I cried and mourned what could have been for Wes and Kai. In this story, I cried for Kai all over again, but this time, I hurt thinking about the pain he must have felt in his final days. There is something so incredibly heartbreaking about getting more of his story and understanding even more of what he was carrying.

And Luke. Oh my god, Luke. 😭

The amount of strength this man has is incredible. I’m literally crying again just writing about him. His love and support for Wes is EVERYTHING. All Luke wanted was to be loved by Wes, and he was willing to accept that love in whatever way Wes was capable of giving it. He never tried to erase Kai. He never asked Wes to stop loving him. He simply loved Wes through all of it, the grief, the guilt, the pain, and everything that came with loving someone who had already experienced an unimaginable loss.

The way Kai was brought back into this story without ever making it feel like it was taking something away from Wes and Luke is such a testament to Raya’s writing. Kai’s presence felt necessary. It felt beautiful. It hurt like hell, but it belonged there.

I genuinely cannot formulate the words to explain how this story made me feel. I know I’ll be thinking about all of these characters for a very, very long time, not just Wes, Luke, and Kai, but Kai’s parents, Wes’s teammates, Luke’s family... everyone.

Another six stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I am completely obsessed with this story and these characters.

But PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE buckle up before you start this one because I don’t think I have ever shed this many tears over a book. I am emotionally devastated and would apparently like to stay that way. 😭
Profile Image for JustCollin.
22 reviews
September 24, 2026
Yes. Just- Yes. I don’t even know how to adequately review this book.

I cried through so much of Shift Change, but Beneath the Ice made me cry in an entirely different way. The first book gave me heartbreak tears. This one gave me healing tears.

What makes this story so beautiful is that the pain doesn’t come from two people constantly hurting each other. It comes from life being painful, complicated, and sometimes unbelievably unfair, and from watching two people choose to face those things together.

This book understands something about grief that I think is incredibly difficult to put into words: healing does not require you to stop loving what you lost.

Love doesn’t have to erase grief. Moving forward doesn’t mean leaving someone behind. And finding happiness again doesn’t diminish the love that existed before it.

There is something incredibly powerful about a relationship where love becomes the safe place to experience all of that. Where someone doesn’t try to fix your grief, compete with it, or ask you to make it smaller so there is more room for them. They simply make room for all of you.

That is what destroyed me about this book.

Not heartbreak.

Healing.

This duology is easily one of the most moving love stories I’ve read. I haven’t been this emotionally affected by a book since The Fall by Tal Bauer.

Absolutely beautiful. I know I’ll be thinking about this one for a very long time.
Profile Image for Sabrina - Brina's Book Nook.
74 reviews1 follower
September 21, 2026
5/5
Spoliers
ARC Review

I was emotionally hungover for days after reading the first book, Shift Change and couldn’t wait for this to come out. If you need a good cry, read Shift Change and then this one.

Wes and Luke have gone through so much together and apart. The tension between Wes and Luke during recovery is heartbreaking. Luke is struggling with the injury and keeps snipping at Wes, and Wes takes it because he loves him and feels he deserves it. The scene where Wes tells Luke what happened with Kai and how he feels about it was heartbreaking. I cried like a baby. The news about what happened with Kai just made an already hard situation for Wes and Luke even harder to navigate. Wes was already feeling so much guilt from Kai's death and what happened between him and Luke before he got hurt; he just didn’t know how to process it without feeling like he was drowning. Luke had so much heartache from his past that the thought of losing Wes added to his already existing self-doubt. Even though he was recovering from his own trauma, he was there for Wes as much as he could be. Wes and Luke needed each other to heal from their past and future traumas. The proposal was so perfect; it was exactly what you expect for them it hits you right in the feels.

It took so much heartbreak, fear and happiness to bring the love Luke and Wes deserved.
Profile Image for Josephine Thornton.
201 reviews7 followers
September 1, 2026
I received an advance copy of Beneath The Ice via Author. All opinions are my own.

Beneath The Ice
by Raya J. Su

Rating: 5 / 5

Beneath the Ice picks up where Shift Change left off. It describes the events following Luke's accident, Wes's emotional journey, and the sorrow he experiences after Kai's death, his first love. Following the accident, Wes focused on personal growth and processing his grief to support Luke. Similar to the first book, this one was incredible. Reading this book made me feel just as emotional as the first one did. It was painful to witness Wes's difficult struggle with his upbringing, his anger, and his grief, but the transformations he underwent were beautiful. What happened to Kai and how his family and Wes found out was devastating. Luke's whole journey with his accident and learning to forgive was written so well.

Raya is great at making characters feel real. She poured a lot of emotion into these books. Wes's story will forever remain with me. I hope it's as well-loved by others as it was by me. This is particularly recommended for fans of emotional love stories.

Content warnings: Check the Triggers


66 reviews1 follower
September 25, 2026
I didn’t think that this second book could possibly be as beautifully devastating as the first book in the series. I was wrong. I’m grateful that I did not read Shift Change until Beneath the Ice was released. I don’t even know how to summarize all of the ways this story and these characters broke my heart. The way that Kai’s family truly became Wes’ family and how they were so accepting of his new relationship. Mary walking Wes down the aisle nearly did me in. I’m grateful Luke alluded to his past relationship history in his vows and that he came to realize what he had before was not love. I’ve got way too many thoughts right now but I love the characters, the friends who become family, the emotional healing and letting go of the guilt. So many books that are known to be emotionally devastating don’t even pull a tear from me but this is one of the few over the last couple of years that truly had me sobbing. The duet is already on my reread list and I am looking forward to others in this universe.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Sophie.
4 reviews2 followers
September 18, 2026
After the first book ripped open my heart and made me uncontrollably sob more than a book ever has, I was worried on the emotional roller coaster I was going in with this book.
But whilst this book did make me sob and break me apart, it also felt like I was being put back together along with the characters.

Seeing the relationship between Luke and Wes grow the way it did, was beautiful. But also lesrning about what happened to our sweet boy Kai was utterly heartbreaking, and reading the devastation through Wes did break me. The grief was written so beautifully, but also so raw and honest.
If I could give this whole story more than 5 stars I would, it is worth every smile, laugh, tear and heart break. And this is one that will stick with me and will now be held as one of my favourite books. So thank you for writing this story and sharing it🤍
19 reviews
October 11, 2026
First, if you are triggered in a way that feels unhealthy or unsafe, do not read these books. They are heavy and full of all the bitter and the sweet that make up life. They are full of the best and worst of human nature and how that affects people.
That being said, these books are beautiful. They must be read in order. The characters grow and deepen as the story continues, and the two novels are definitely one story in two acts. The supporting characters are also deeper than those found in most books and the reader develops affection for them.
If you are looking for a typical m/m romance, this isn’t it. There is plenty of romance, but I felt they were equally about the flip side, the grief that comes from loss of love and trust. There is deep trauma here that is given the weight it deserves.
I look forward to the next book by this author,
2 reviews1 follower
August 29, 2026
ARC review.

Wow, what can I say? I was so excited to read this follow-up to Shift Change and finally see Wes and Luke get their happy ending.

This book took me on such an emotional journey. It really is a rollercoaster ride through finding love, learning to trust each other, dealing with heartbreak, and tackling some really tough topics. There were so many emotions along the way, and I loved every minute of it.

I think this book is beautifully written, and I highly recommend reading Shift Change first before diving into Beneath the Ice so you can fully experience Wes and Luke’s story.

I guarantee you won’t be disappointed!

I’m already looking forward to reading more books by Raya J. Su. ❤️
Author 3 books55 followers
September 17, 2026
I received an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions and crash outs are my own.

Shift Change ends on a cliffhanger that left me sobbing so I had to get my hands on Beneath the Ice right away. I buddy read this with two besties and the whole chat was just a flood of tears. I am the type of reader that does not forgive characters easily. Wes did a LOT to PMO in book 1 and he had to do a LOT of groveling in book 2 for me to see him as worthy of Luke. My heart broke for Kai all over again in this book. Their grief felt like my grief. This duology broke my heart and stitched it back together (though it will never be quite the same again). Raya, you are so talented and your hockey IQ is unmatched. Your ability to make me sob is frankly alarming.
Profile Image for Jessica Stronell.
1 review
August 30, 2026
This book was the PERFECT sequel to Shift Change it picks up straight after the ending and It’s equally as heartbreaking at times but in all the best ways. You will need tissues!
It does deal with some difficult topics that add a whole new dimension,depth and understanding to Kai’s story.

Watching Wes deal with grief and guilt and finally allowing himself to be loved in a way he never thought he deserved was the ultimate pay off for me 💙 but the development of both Wes and Luke was beautifully written, and these characters have become some of my favourites!

I can’t wait to read more by Raya and I’m particularly excited for benny and becks story!

Profile Image for K. Dawn .
18 reviews
September 18, 2026
tears and more tears

If you haven’t read Shift Change & Beneath the Ice you are SERIOUSLY missing out! These books broke my heart and put it back together numerous times. I’ve never read a book like this. These books brought out so many thoughts and emotions that I will always remember and cherish. Love these books and can’t wait to see what comes next from Raya! Read them. I promise you won’t be disappointed!
Profile Image for Danielle Munday.
90 reviews
September 19, 2026
that was a hell of a emotional rollercoaster

Damn I thought this book was gonna heal me as the first one broke me but no…. This destroyed me even more before putting me back together ohhhh so much better than I ever began!! Il NEVER forget Wes Luke and Kai!! Luke was the living embodiment of the angel Kai had become. I am sooo glad I got to read these books and cannot wait for more!!
18 reviews1 follower
September 22, 2026
I don’t think I can properly put into words how beautiful this series is! I cried on and off throughout this whole book. The author did an amazing job showing Wes’s grief, while also showing his growth and love towards Luke.

The way Kai’s family remained a constant in the story also healed me.

SO well written! 6 ⭐️

I already know this is going to be a yearly re-read for me! Can’t wait to see what the other books bring!
Profile Image for K. Dawn .
18 reviews
September 18, 2026
If you haven’t read Shift Change & Beneath the Ice you are SERIOUSLY missing out! These books broke my heart and put it back together numerous times. I’ve never read a book like this. These books brought out so many thoughts and emotions that I will always remember and cherish. Love these books and can’t wait to see what comes next from Raya! Read them. I promise you won’t be disappointed!
Profile Image for Inda Deleon.
144 reviews12 followers
September 18, 2026
ufff what a masterpiece

I don’t think I expected what I got from this duet. The cover makes it seem like just another jockey romance but while the first book was absolutely devastating this second book healed my heart(after some more heartbreak) absolutely loved it. 10/10, no notes.
Profile Image for Lizzy.
22 reviews
September 20, 2026
Wow, just wow. I am going to miss Wes and Luke like crazy. What an emotional book in the best way- I was laughing and crying all throughout. I really admire how well it touches on grief and how realistic it all felt. This is truly a love story for the ages and I can’t wait for more people to discover these books. An ABSOLUTE must read ❤️
Profile Image for Ashley.
1 review
September 24, 2026
Wow. I read both books in 48 hrs. Not sure there are words to explain just how beautiful and important this story is. I have never sobbed that hard while reading, but the tears are so worth it. Even the side characters will steal will your heart. You will sob and you will swoon. If necessary, check your triggers. But if you can handle going in blind, then i definitely suggest doing so.
5 reviews
October 19, 2026
Best book review.

Well I ended book 1 crying and pretty much cried the whole way through this one. It is one of the best books I read in a while. For a book to bring out such emotion and keep it there is amazing. Well worth a read. Can't wait to see what else the author has to offer.
Profile Image for Christina.
15 reviews5 followers
October 26, 2026
This book and the first one in the series Shift Change were amazing. I don’t think I have ever cried more reading a book series. The grief and love were palpable. It is hard to believe this was an author’s debut series. So good. I look forward to reading more of their work in the future.
Profile Image for Karrie Letts.
3 reviews
August 29, 2026
I don't have words. Heartbreaking, emotional, growth, healing. I bawled. What a stunning work. Wish I could read it again for the first time
3 reviews
September 30, 2026
Loved it so so soo much.
Wes and Luke will always stay close to my heart (Kai too).
16 reviews2 followers
October 5, 2026
Waited so long for this second part of Wes and Luke's story and it did not disappoint! The way Raya writes about love, grief, healing, and forgiveness is just so raw and beautiful.
Profile Image for Jocelyn M.
51 reviews
October 4, 2026
Its so hard to put my feeling on this book into words. I read it almost 2 months ago and after I finished it I swore I would never read it again. Spoiler alert: I read it again. Overwhelming feelings of grief, betrayal, guilt and love all piled up on Wes's shoulders while he tried not to lose himself. Overall this is a beautiful story about forgiveness that had me in tears the ENTIRE book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews