What do you think?
Dysphoria: A Spicy Fae and Dragon-Shifter Romantasy
The king is trapped. The chaos should be over. So why does everything feel like it's just beginning?
With the immortal king sealed away and the rebellion finally breathing, Naevyn thought she'd earned a moment to figure out who she actually is, but with her mother's growing weakness and Valthaeron growing stronger by the day, she doesn't have that luxury anymore.
Now she's hunting answers in the last place she the domain of the true dragons.
With faction lines fracturing and old loyalties curdling into something dangerous, Naevyn can't afford to trust anyone. Except maybe Cairos, who has decided that if he has to suffer, so does she. And he's very, very good at making her suffer.
But the deeper they go, the more Naevyn realizes that saving her mother might cost her everything she just fought to protect. The prophecy isn't finished with her. And the blood that saved them once?
It's going to demand a lot more than she's ready to give.
With the immortal king sealed away and the rebellion finally breathing, Naevyn thought she'd earned a moment to figure out who she actually is, but with her mother's growing weakness and Valthaeron growing stronger by the day, she doesn't have that luxury anymore.
Now she's hunting answers in the last place she the domain of the true dragons.
With faction lines fracturing and old loyalties curdling into something dangerous, Naevyn can't afford to trust anyone. Except maybe Cairos, who has decided that if he has to suffer, so does she. And he's very, very good at making her suffer.
But the deeper they go, the more Naevyn realizes that saving her mother might cost her everything she just fought to protect. The prophecy isn't finished with her. And the blood that saved them once?
It's going to demand a lot more than she's ready to give.
418 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 30, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 151 reviews
June 16, 2026
excuse me, WHAT? HUN?
what a cruel cliffhanger!!!
i was kinda procrastinating with reading this at the beginning but that changed into me not being able to put the damn book down. the story picks up exactly where book 1 ended so it was so nice to read this right after that!
i really enjoyed reading about the underneath and watching naevyn trust herself more. my heart BROKE when she and cairos fought. and omg i feel beaten up after that ending. cause (spoiler) WHAT DO YOU MEAN? they feel absolutely nothing??? THE BOND???
and now hessa is suffering too?? i genuinely can’ttttt.
book 3 can’t come soon enough!
thank you so much for the advanced copy, eliza 💗 really
what a cruel cliffhanger!!!
i was kinda procrastinating with reading this at the beginning but that changed into me not being able to put the damn book down. the story picks up exactly where book 1 ended so it was so nice to read this right after that!
i really enjoyed reading about the underneath and watching naevyn trust herself more. my heart BROKE when she and cairos fought. and omg i feel beaten up after that ending. cause (spoiler) WHAT DO YOU MEAN? they feel absolutely nothing??? THE BOND???
and now hessa is suffering too?? i genuinely can’ttttt.
book 3 can’t come soon enough!
thank you so much for the advanced copy, eliza 💗 really
June 30, 2026
I very much enjoyed the first book in this series, Vitalia, but this one made me love it even more! The circus is what drew me into the first one and even though we don’t have circus in this one, well except for one fun scene, the whole magic world, creatures and dragon shifters has me completely hooked. This one does end on a brutal cliffhanger. You could see it coming but still didn’t make it any easier. Hopefully we don’t have to wait long for the 3rd book because I need to know what happens next!
Thank you to the author for the advanced copy.
Thank you to the author for the advanced copy.
June 26, 2026
What. Just. Happened?
I mean for real, what happened? I am sitting here writing this review still reeling from that ending. Emotional devastation hit hard and true in this book. ACTUAL TEARS.
This book was absolutely brilliant Eliza Benner writes a story that brings out all of your feelings, from the good, the bad and everything in between. You become consumed with this book and the characters or the book consumes you. Either way, it is an emotional journey.
The world building. I don't think I can express how this world keeps evolving. You can just see the crystal trees, feel the shards under your feet. From the lands, to the creatures, to the dragons, to the world as it continues to grow. This book continues to draw you in by that alone. You live and breathe this world along with the characters.
Cairos, man, dragon shifter. He keeps me on a string, holds me by the throat and never lets go. He has such a presence on the paper. You want to get to know him, you want him by your side, you heart breaks with him. Naevyn, I just love getting to know her more, watching her stand on her own feet and make choices that break your heart as well as understanding why she made them.
I love the banter between the two of them, they are always ready to play but also be so serious. Cairos knows her so well, I know the choices made will only bring them closer together.
The last 10% of the book had in me tears, had me holding my breath and cradling my kindle as if I could help with the scenes playing out. You are loving the story, knowing we are getting somewhere. Knowing it's coming to an end.
Then BAM
Cliff hanger.
Done.
Ruined.
Devastation.
Thank you Eliza Benner for allowing me to read this ARC early. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I mean for real, what happened? I am sitting here writing this review still reeling from that ending. Emotional devastation hit hard and true in this book. ACTUAL TEARS.
This book was absolutely brilliant Eliza Benner writes a story that brings out all of your feelings, from the good, the bad and everything in between. You become consumed with this book and the characters or the book consumes you. Either way, it is an emotional journey.
The world building. I don't think I can express how this world keeps evolving. You can just see the crystal trees, feel the shards under your feet. From the lands, to the creatures, to the dragons, to the world as it continues to grow. This book continues to draw you in by that alone. You live and breathe this world along with the characters.
Cairos, man, dragon shifter. He keeps me on a string, holds me by the throat and never lets go. He has such a presence on the paper. You want to get to know him, you want him by your side, you heart breaks with him. Naevyn, I just love getting to know her more, watching her stand on her own feet and make choices that break your heart as well as understanding why she made them.
I love the banter between the two of them, they are always ready to play but also be so serious. Cairos knows her so well, I know the choices made will only bring them closer together.
The last 10% of the book had in me tears, had me holding my breath and cradling my kindle as if I could help with the scenes playing out. You are loving the story, knowing we are getting somewhere. Knowing it's coming to an end.
Then BAM
Cliff hanger.
Done.
Ruined.
Devastation.
Thank you Eliza Benner for allowing me to read this ARC early. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 2, 2026
Rating: Obsessed
💞 It's Always Been You (in any lifetime)
🐉 Fae Dragon Shifter x Human (❓)
✨ Fated Mates (❓) / Prophecy
🔪 Touch Her and Die
💬 Banter
🔥 Spicy Slow Burn
⏳ Age Gap (he's only...800 years old or so)
🤐 Secrets & Betrayals
Well...this one hurt. Like, emotionally assaulted by a fantasy novel hurt.
And to make matters worse, it ends on another cliffhanger. Book 3 isn't expected until DECEMBER, and, respectfully? I'd like to file a complaint.
I'm still new to romantasy, and Eliza has been the best introduction! Her writing makes the worldbuilding effortless. I can picture every setting, dragon, look between Naevyn and Cairos. As someone who usually passes on fantasy because of the worldbuilding, this has completely sucked me in.
Dysphoria picks up right where Vitalia left off, and I went into it fully intending to pace myself because I knew the wait for Book 3 was going to be brutal. I finished it in two days.
Around the halfway point, I transformed into Gollum. Dysphoria became my Precious, and no one was taking it from me. I stayed up until 3am cause I had to know what happened.
And then...
The ending ripped my soul out, stomped on it a few times for good measure, and left me staring into the void wondering what I did to deserve this. I was right there with Naevyn, feeling...nothing. First came the numbness...then the heartbreak...then the rage.
One of my favorite things about the writing is that there's this quiet tension simmering beneath the surface. She's somehow five steps ahead of me at all times, but she never makes me feel dumb for not seeing it coming. Instead, she lets me catch up just enough before peeling back a new layer.
I'm emotionally invested in every single character. I'm praying to the old gods (and the new) that all this pays off because if certain characters don't get what they deserve...
I'm starting my own dragon war. 🐉
Thank you, @elizabennerwrites, for the ARC. Also, I think it's only fair that I get Book 3 about five months early. For emotional support purposes. 🤣❤️🩹
💞 It's Always Been You (in any lifetime)
🐉 Fae Dragon Shifter x Human (❓)
✨ Fated Mates (❓) / Prophecy
🔪 Touch Her and Die
💬 Banter
🔥 Spicy Slow Burn
⏳ Age Gap (he's only...800 years old or so)
🤐 Secrets & Betrayals
Well...this one hurt. Like, emotionally assaulted by a fantasy novel hurt.
And to make matters worse, it ends on another cliffhanger. Book 3 isn't expected until DECEMBER, and, respectfully? I'd like to file a complaint.
I'm still new to romantasy, and Eliza has been the best introduction! Her writing makes the worldbuilding effortless. I can picture every setting, dragon, look between Naevyn and Cairos. As someone who usually passes on fantasy because of the worldbuilding, this has completely sucked me in.
Dysphoria picks up right where Vitalia left off, and I went into it fully intending to pace myself because I knew the wait for Book 3 was going to be brutal. I finished it in two days.
Around the halfway point, I transformed into Gollum. Dysphoria became my Precious, and no one was taking it from me. I stayed up until 3am cause I had to know what happened.
And then...
The ending ripped my soul out, stomped on it a few times for good measure, and left me staring into the void wondering what I did to deserve this. I was right there with Naevyn, feeling...nothing. First came the numbness...then the heartbreak...then the rage.
One of my favorite things about the writing is that there's this quiet tension simmering beneath the surface. She's somehow five steps ahead of me at all times, but she never makes me feel dumb for not seeing it coming. Instead, she lets me catch up just enough before peeling back a new layer.
I'm emotionally invested in every single character. I'm praying to the old gods (and the new) that all this pays off because if certain characters don't get what they deserve...
I'm starting my own dragon war. 🐉
Thank you, @elizabennerwrites, for the ARC. Also, I think it's only fair that I get Book 3 about five months early. For emotional support purposes. 🤣❤️🩹
July 16, 2026
Dysphoria is everything I hoped for in a sequel and more. Picking back up with Naevyn and Cairos felt like coming home, but the stakes are even higher, the emotions run deeper, and the world expands in exciting ways!
Naevyn continues to shine as a resilient, determined heroine whose strength comes from both her courage and her vulnerability. Cairos remains one of my favorite morally gray characters, and his unwavering loyalty and chemistry with Naevyn made every scene between them unforgettable. I also loved seeing more of the rest of gang, whose presence adds humor, heart, and depth to the story.
The twists genuinely surprised me, and the emotional moments hit even harder because of how invested I had become in these characters. Honestly, this has to be my favorite fantasy series🥹
(This is a late arc review🤦🏾♀️)
Naevyn continues to shine as a resilient, determined heroine whose strength comes from both her courage and her vulnerability. Cairos remains one of my favorite morally gray characters, and his unwavering loyalty and chemistry with Naevyn made every scene between them unforgettable. I also loved seeing more of the rest of gang, whose presence adds humor, heart, and depth to the story.
The twists genuinely surprised me, and the emotional moments hit even harder because of how invested I had become in these characters. Honestly, this has to be my favorite fantasy series🥹
(This is a late arc review🤦🏾♀️)
June 16, 2026
4,25 stars
I’m obsessed with this series. The tension, the plot. The characters. Literally everything is just great. I’m so glad I got an arc of this second book as well because the thought of having to wait for it stressed me out.
I thoroughly enjoyed this one as well as the first one. However, not quite as much. It felt a little bit like this book suffered from second book syndrome and since the main characters are apart for quite a while during this book I found it a little dragging during some parts.
But, 4,25 stars I mean obviously I still loved it.
Crossing my fingers that there will be a third book out. I’ll definitely do a reread of these either way.
Thank you so much Eliza for this ARC.
I’m obsessed with this series. The tension, the plot. The characters. Literally everything is just great. I’m so glad I got an arc of this second book as well because the thought of having to wait for it stressed me out.
I thoroughly enjoyed this one as well as the first one. However, not quite as much. It felt a little bit like this book suffered from second book syndrome and since the main characters are apart for quite a while during this book I found it a little dragging during some parts.
But, 4,25 stars I mean obviously I still loved it.
Crossing my fingers that there will be a third book out. I’ll definitely do a reread of these either way.
Thank you so much Eliza for this ARC.
June 10, 2026
*ARC REVIEW*
This is the second book in the Circus of Souls series & once again, I am left yearning for more!
Dysphoria dives into backstories and character development. Any questions you might have had from book one have been answered or have been baited to be revealed in book 3!
Eliza’s world building is warm & velvety.. it’s simply gorgeous!
I’m in love with it this series & my soul-bond is longing for book 3!
Thank you, Eliza!
This is the second book in the Circus of Souls series & once again, I am left yearning for more!
Dysphoria dives into backstories and character development. Any questions you might have had from book one have been answered or have been baited to be revealed in book 3!
Eliza’s world building is warm & velvety.. it’s simply gorgeous!
I’m in love with it this series & my soul-bond is longing for book 3!
Thank you, Eliza!
June 10, 2026
ARC REVIEW!!!
This oneeeeeee wrecked me!!! I didn’t want to put it down at any point, it’s just as good if not better than book one! My mind is still reeling from the horrible awful cliffhanger at the end, and I’m waiting with bated breath for the next one! Eliza Benner knows how to keep you wanting more, and I desperately NEED more.
This oneeeeeee wrecked me!!! I didn’t want to put it down at any point, it’s just as good if not better than book one! My mind is still reeling from the horrible awful cliffhanger at the end, and I’m waiting with bated breath for the next one! Eliza Benner knows how to keep you wanting more, and I desperately NEED more.
July 31, 2026
I am not ok...nope not one bit. This picked up right after book one which was great so no time jump. Naevyn and Cairos go through a lot, I feel like it sets up for book 3 in the fact that we're going to see if this will break them. I cant say much more because it'll give too much away. But def read and will be back for more.
July 16, 2026
Thank you Eliza Benner and Team for the opportunity to review this ARC!
✨Disclaimer ✨
My rating is based on MY enjoyment and/or displeasure with this work. It is not a guarantee that everyone or anyone else will enjoy it. My review explains the reason for my rating, why I think others who enjoy similar genres MIGHT want to give this work a read. These are solely my opinions and observations.
📚The Rundown: 📚
Rating: 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice Level: 3/5
Genre: Fantasy romance
Tropes: Found family, Hidden Identity, Yearning.
TL;DR/ Accessible rating version:
Genre(s):
Paranormal/supernatural
Fantasy
Dystopian elements
Romantasy
🚨 Trigger Warnings🚨
Psychological, Physical, and Emotional Abuse and Manipulation
Violence (combat)
Mention and description of torture
Death of Side character
Finished series: No ❌
Standalone: No❌
Tropes/Story Elements:
FMC with hidden powers and identity
Mutual falling falls first
Traumatic pasts and origins
Reincarnation - love across lifetimes
Morally Grey MC
Soul Bonded Mates
25 y/o FMC, Immortal MMC
Dragon Shifter
Tortured/Brooding MMC
Touch him and die
Touch her and die
Found Family
Representation:
LGBTQIA Side Character
Story: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
POV: Dual POV (FMC) 👩🏽👨🏽
Plot twist: 💥💥💥
Plot predictability: ⭐️⭐️⭐️Main story contains only a couple of predictable plot twists.
Spice content: (forgot the chapters this time, but it starts a little bit sooner and there is a little more in this installment.) 🔥🔥 🌶🌶 The Quality is okay, and there isn't a whole lot of it.
Cliffhanger ending: ✅
Combat: ⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️
Overall writing quality: ✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽 ✍🏽
Romance: 💖💖💖
Hetero romance: ✅
LGBTQ romance: ✅
Character Development: ✨✨ There is a little more character development in this sequel, particularly with Naeevyn, who begins to get a little more confident in both her role as a reluctant heroine, and fated mate to Cairos.
Overall Enjoyment: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I really enjoyed this sequel, it definitely delivered on the intrigue, raising the stakes, and the heartbreak. I did get a bit more world building, and we learned WHY the humans became enslaved and used to mine shadowstone. A few questions were answered and a lot of revelations were made.
Recommended for readers who like:
Quicksilvers by Callie Hart
Silver Elite by Dani Francis
📍📍Mild Spoilers ahead! 📍📍
Full rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
💕"Even you had best not be stupid enough to face the original dragons." 💕
Synopsis:
Naevyn, our FMC, has successfully trapped King Valthaerion. Unfortunately, this does not at all make things easier, because Not only do we learn who is trapped in the garden statue, but we also learn that Valthaerion is soul bound to that captive, and is slowly siphoning her energy.
The fae faction loyal to the crown are poised to attack the other factions to try to sieze power.
Only the Dragons- the true dragons who are hidden away have the power to break the soul bond between the trapped king Valthaerion and the captive in the statue, before the trapped captive is killed by the siphoning of her lifeforce.
And this is the crux of Naevyn's new quest, which of course, is not nearly as straightforward as we would hope.
My Thoughts and Reading Experience 🤔:
Eliza's writing is really digestible. If you want an easy read, this is the book for you. Although that is not my style, and I prefer to tease out implications on my own, I appreciate this writing style that makes everything very clear, though it walks a fine line of over-explaining. Still this wasn't a deterrent for me.
This story has a lot of very familiar elements presented in a way that doesn't make it feel repetitive, and the twist on the sinister circus is an excellent start.
None of this book felt like a drag or a slog to get through, and the pacing is excellent.
What I liked😊
• The story concept overall.
• The banter! It was even better in book two, especially with Gileon tagging along.
• The yearning - turned up even more.
• The twists were still satisfying, and I had my suspicions about at least two, and one I did NOT see coming at all! Especially the very end. The last couple of chapters are nothing but heartbreak.
What I didn't Like 🙁
• Sable's fate.
• I actually need to understand how Naevyn was able to breathe underwater for extended periods of time, and I feel this could've been explained a bit.
🌟Standout Moments 🌟
****Light spoilers ahead!****
Favorite dynamic:
Gileon and Hessa
Scene that lingered:
Gileon holding Nessa in the aftermath.
Favorite Quote:
Cairos: "I've been watching it (His mouth) for 600 years. Hasn't helped."
Final Thoughts
OMG that ending. My heart is broken, because no one is not suffering! Everything Naevyn thought she knew is wrong. Everything has changed.
I enjoyed watching Naevyn grow and become more confident. I loved the tender moments between Naevyn and Cairos, and I was really rooting for Hessa.
The banter was even more hilarious, the stakes were dialed up to 100 and I honestly am FURIOUS for Sable, and honestly, what happened to her is basically Sexual Assault. Soul Assault? Idk but it’s terrible.
I am extremely excited to read the next installment, and I look forward to seeing the world building, the character development, and the progression of this story into a cataclysmic conclusion.
I would recommend this book (and will!) to anyone who likes stories of fae, dragon shifters, political intrigue, and soul bonds.
Rating legend/explanation:
Spice content: 🔥 = very little or poor quality spice
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 = max spice or high quality spice
🌶= Very little amount of spice
🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶 = Spice throughout the book
Plot predictability:
⭐️= very predictable
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️= blindsided
Plot twist:
💥 = not enjoyable; incongruent and/or not true to characters, does not follow the plot/story/world logic
💥💥💥💥💥= congruent; enjoyable and or fits Characters flawlessly, follows the plot/story/world logic
Romance:
💖= Poor quality romance development/relationship
💖💖💖💖💖= God Tier quality Romance development/relationship
Combat:
⚔️ = light combat/fight scenes
⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️ = heavy combat/fight scenes
Overall writing quality:
✍🏽 = poorly written/ too many typos or grammatical errors
✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽= superior writing/ no typos or grammatical errors
✨Disclaimer ✨
My rating is based on MY enjoyment and/or displeasure with this work. It is not a guarantee that everyone or anyone else will enjoy it. My review explains the reason for my rating, why I think others who enjoy similar genres MIGHT want to give this work a read. These are solely my opinions and observations.
📚The Rundown: 📚
Rating: 4/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice Level: 3/5
Genre: Fantasy romance
Tropes: Found family, Hidden Identity, Yearning.
TL;DR/ Accessible rating version:
Genre(s):
Paranormal/supernatural
Fantasy
Dystopian elements
Romantasy
🚨 Trigger Warnings🚨
Psychological, Physical, and Emotional Abuse and Manipulation
Violence (combat)
Mention and description of torture
Death of Side character
Finished series: No ❌
Standalone: No❌
Tropes/Story Elements:
FMC with hidden powers and identity
Mutual falling falls first
Traumatic pasts and origins
Reincarnation - love across lifetimes
Morally Grey MC
Soul Bonded Mates
25 y/o FMC, Immortal MMC
Dragon Shifter
Tortured/Brooding MMC
Touch him and die
Touch her and die
Found Family
Representation:
LGBTQIA Side Character
Story: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
POV: Dual POV (FMC) 👩🏽👨🏽
Plot twist: 💥💥💥
Plot predictability: ⭐️⭐️⭐️Main story contains only a couple of predictable plot twists.
Spice content: (forgot the chapters this time, but it starts a little bit sooner and there is a little more in this installment.) 🔥🔥 🌶🌶 The Quality is okay, and there isn't a whole lot of it.
Cliffhanger ending: ✅
Combat: ⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️
Overall writing quality: ✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽 ✍🏽
Romance: 💖💖💖
Hetero romance: ✅
LGBTQ romance: ✅
Character Development: ✨✨ There is a little more character development in this sequel, particularly with Naeevyn, who begins to get a little more confident in both her role as a reluctant heroine, and fated mate to Cairos.
Overall Enjoyment: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I really enjoyed this sequel, it definitely delivered on the intrigue, raising the stakes, and the heartbreak. I did get a bit more world building, and we learned WHY the humans became enslaved and used to mine shadowstone. A few questions were answered and a lot of revelations were made.
Recommended for readers who like:
Quicksilvers by Callie Hart
Silver Elite by Dani Francis
📍📍Mild Spoilers ahead! 📍📍
Full rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
💕"Even you had best not be stupid enough to face the original dragons." 💕
Synopsis:
Naevyn, our FMC, has successfully trapped King Valthaerion. Unfortunately, this does not at all make things easier, because Not only do we learn who is trapped in the garden statue, but we also learn that Valthaerion is soul bound to that captive, and is slowly siphoning her energy.
The fae faction loyal to the crown are poised to attack the other factions to try to sieze power.
Only the Dragons- the true dragons who are hidden away have the power to break the soul bond between the trapped king Valthaerion and the captive in the statue, before the trapped captive is killed by the siphoning of her lifeforce.
And this is the crux of Naevyn's new quest, which of course, is not nearly as straightforward as we would hope.
My Thoughts and Reading Experience 🤔:
Eliza's writing is really digestible. If you want an easy read, this is the book for you. Although that is not my style, and I prefer to tease out implications on my own, I appreciate this writing style that makes everything very clear, though it walks a fine line of over-explaining. Still this wasn't a deterrent for me.
This story has a lot of very familiar elements presented in a way that doesn't make it feel repetitive, and the twist on the sinister circus is an excellent start.
None of this book felt like a drag or a slog to get through, and the pacing is excellent.
What I liked😊
• The story concept overall.
• The banter! It was even better in book two, especially with Gileon tagging along.
• The yearning - turned up even more.
• The twists were still satisfying, and I had my suspicions about at least two, and one I did NOT see coming at all! Especially the very end. The last couple of chapters are nothing but heartbreak.
What I didn't Like 🙁
• Sable's fate.
• I actually need to understand how Naevyn was able to breathe underwater for extended periods of time, and I feel this could've been explained a bit.
🌟Standout Moments 🌟
****Light spoilers ahead!****
Favorite dynamic:
Gileon and Hessa
Scene that lingered:
Gileon holding Nessa in the aftermath.
Favorite Quote:
Cairos: "I've been watching it (His mouth) for 600 years. Hasn't helped."
Final Thoughts
OMG that ending. My heart is broken, because no one is not suffering! Everything Naevyn thought she knew is wrong. Everything has changed.
I enjoyed watching Naevyn grow and become more confident. I loved the tender moments between Naevyn and Cairos, and I was really rooting for Hessa.
The banter was even more hilarious, the stakes were dialed up to 100 and I honestly am FURIOUS for Sable, and honestly, what happened to her is basically Sexual Assault. Soul Assault? Idk but it’s terrible.
I am extremely excited to read the next installment, and I look forward to seeing the world building, the character development, and the progression of this story into a cataclysmic conclusion.
I would recommend this book (and will!) to anyone who likes stories of fae, dragon shifters, political intrigue, and soul bonds.
Rating legend/explanation:
Spice content: 🔥 = very little or poor quality spice
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 = max spice or high quality spice
🌶= Very little amount of spice
🌶🌶🌶🌶🌶 = Spice throughout the book
Plot predictability:
⭐️= very predictable
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️= blindsided
Plot twist:
💥 = not enjoyable; incongruent and/or not true to characters, does not follow the plot/story/world logic
💥💥💥💥💥= congruent; enjoyable and or fits Characters flawlessly, follows the plot/story/world logic
Romance:
💖= Poor quality romance development/relationship
💖💖💖💖💖= God Tier quality Romance development/relationship
Combat:
⚔️ = light combat/fight scenes
⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️ ⚔️ = heavy combat/fight scenes
Overall writing quality:
✍🏽 = poorly written/ too many typos or grammatical errors
✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽✍🏽= superior writing/ no typos or grammatical errors
Review of advance copy received from Author
⭐️ 3.75
ARC READER REVIEW OF MY HONEST OPINION
This is the second book in the Circus of Souls series. We’re following the group from the first group on a mission to find a way to save Bellamine/ Naevyn’s mother from shadowstone without releasing Valthaeron.
The journey takes us on a mission where Cairos is captured and Naevyn has to venture into the Dragon realm, the Underneath, without him. She needs to find the dragon responsible for the very curse that has affected Cairos and the rest of the group, Voryn. Many secrets come to light, on this journey and deals are made. Saving Orlia might cost Naevryn more than she is willing to give. Or more than she can sacrifice on her own.
I love that we get some world building, some background on Bellamine, Cairos and the true dragons. I enjoyed 2/3 of the book and then things kinda took a turn for me. Mostly Naevyn pissed me off royally and i’m still raging! (Spoilers below)
We also get a few big new plot points and end on a cliffhanger. I’m very ready to see what happens!
****** Spoilers
Bellamie’s origin story she’s actually the daughter of the God of Chaos, who created the shadow stalkers which is why they are so protective of her. Cairos is off to seek out the God’s and the true dragons are rising. I’m curious why Cairos is going to see the gods when they don’t create soul bonds.
Neavyn drove me crazy this book. First, she knows she needs to ask certain questions but just conveniently decides to keep letting it slide until it’s too late!? I hate when characters so clearly know to ask about important and relevant things but just…don’t. She does it with Cairos, she does it with Voryn. Then she (in my opinion) overreacts to Cairos “lie of omission”. Shes mad he tried to protect his friends the only way he thought was right and made a decision for them. Honestly I cannot believe I would ever utter the words / defend a man about a lie of omission but here I am, telling Naevyn she needs to chill out and not demand things of him that have ZERO to do with her and he’s been dealing with for 600 years. As if all that isn’t enough, SHE IMMEDIATELY BECOMES THE BIGGEST HYPOCRITE AND MAKES THE DECISION TO BREAK THE SOUL BOND WITHOUT EVEN TALKING TO CAIROS ABOUT IT!? For a mother she doesn’t even remember from her past life. Like yes Orlia deserves freedom but Cairos would have helped her if she asked!
The last straw is that once again she doesn’t ask for extremely valid information before making this deal. She doesn’t ask WHAT OR WHY Voryn wants the soul bond? What he plans to use it for? What happened to all the other soul infused shadow stone he’s traded for 600 years !? Just nope, she’s mad Cairos kept things secret so let’s go make a deal in the heat of an overreaction and lose all intelligence?? I just lost it at this point. This isn’t the same FMC from the first storyline. I know characters need growth and arcs and book 2 in series is often about hurdles and the “third act break up” but I hate that trope and think how this all played out was a bit ridiculous.
Favorite Quotes:
- "Touch her," Cairos says, and his voice drops, low and deadly, "and there is nowhere in either realm where you will be safe from me. Nowhere in the depths of Hell where you could escape from me."
- "I love you," he says. "And I choose you every day. Every morning I wake up, and every night I close my eyes, I choose you."
ARC READER REVIEW OF MY HONEST OPINION
This is the second book in the Circus of Souls series. We’re following the group from the first group on a mission to find a way to save Bellamine/ Naevyn’s mother from shadowstone without releasing Valthaeron.
The journey takes us on a mission where Cairos is captured and Naevyn has to venture into the Dragon realm, the Underneath, without him. She needs to find the dragon responsible for the very curse that has affected Cairos and the rest of the group, Voryn. Many secrets come to light, on this journey and deals are made. Saving Orlia might cost Naevryn more than she is willing to give. Or more than she can sacrifice on her own.
I love that we get some world building, some background on Bellamine, Cairos and the true dragons. I enjoyed 2/3 of the book and then things kinda took a turn for me. Mostly Naevyn pissed me off royally and i’m still raging! (Spoilers below)
We also get a few big new plot points and end on a cliffhanger. I’m very ready to see what happens!
****** Spoilers
Bellamie’s origin story she’s actually the daughter of the God of Chaos, who created the shadow stalkers which is why they are so protective of her. Cairos is off to seek out the God’s and the true dragons are rising. I’m curious why Cairos is going to see the gods when they don’t create soul bonds.
Neavyn drove me crazy this book. First, she knows she needs to ask certain questions but just conveniently decides to keep letting it slide until it’s too late!? I hate when characters so clearly know to ask about important and relevant things but just…don’t. She does it with Cairos, she does it with Voryn. Then she (in my opinion) overreacts to Cairos “lie of omission”. Shes mad he tried to protect his friends the only way he thought was right and made a decision for them. Honestly I cannot believe I would ever utter the words / defend a man about a lie of omission but here I am, telling Naevyn she needs to chill out and not demand things of him that have ZERO to do with her and he’s been dealing with for 600 years. As if all that isn’t enough, SHE IMMEDIATELY BECOMES THE BIGGEST HYPOCRITE AND MAKES THE DECISION TO BREAK THE SOUL BOND WITHOUT EVEN TALKING TO CAIROS ABOUT IT!? For a mother she doesn’t even remember from her past life. Like yes Orlia deserves freedom but Cairos would have helped her if she asked!
The last straw is that once again she doesn’t ask for extremely valid information before making this deal. She doesn’t ask WHAT OR WHY Voryn wants the soul bond? What he plans to use it for? What happened to all the other soul infused shadow stone he’s traded for 600 years !? Just nope, she’s mad Cairos kept things secret so let’s go make a deal in the heat of an overreaction and lose all intelligence?? I just lost it at this point. This isn’t the same FMC from the first storyline. I know characters need growth and arcs and book 2 in series is often about hurdles and the “third act break up” but I hate that trope and think how this all played out was a bit ridiculous.
Favorite Quotes:
- "Touch her," Cairos says, and his voice drops, low and deadly, "and there is nowhere in either realm where you will be safe from me. Nowhere in the depths of Hell where you could escape from me."
- "I love you," he says. "And I choose you every day. Every morning I wake up, and every night I close my eyes, I choose you."
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received an ARC of Dysphoria in exchange for my honest review. Thank you, Eliza Benner for sending me an ARC of your magical book. I was sucked into this world the moment I stepped into the first instalment, Vitalia. I feel like this book built upon the previous story's foundation, and built something strong and beautiful for us to enjoy. I rate it 4 stars!
✩₊˚.⋆☾⋆⁺₊✧⋆.ೃ࿔ ݁ ˖*༄*ੈ✩‧₊₊˚.⋆☾⋆⁺₊✧⋆.ೃ࿔ ݁ ˖*༄*ੈ✩‧₊
☾ This is a tale brimming with intrigue, interesting characters and impossible choices. There are strong elements of found family and friendship. We see the characters we have grown to know and love interact with one another, in a time of uncertainty. The events of the previous book bring the characters together, and solidify their bonds. Hessa, again, was a prominent character for me. I love her and her kindness. She is gentle and sweet, whilst suffering no fools. I want the very best for her always, and I will always be cheering her on from the sidelines. There are a myriad of familiar faces, and a whole host of new ones too. The story feels stronger for these new characters and story lines. They feel like they inject more life into this world.
☾ I am unsure if other readers interpreted Cairos and Naevyn the same way as I did, but I felt like they were quite flawed in this instalment. I mean this in a positive way! They were thrown into awful situations and navigated them in the best way they knew, allowing their moral compasses to guide them along the dangerous paths they found themselves on. There was a lot of push and pull between the two main characters. This paired well with the intense yearning they felt. I don’t want to elaborate too much, in fear of spoiling anything, but the twist at the end pertaining to these characters was so interesting. I simultaneously didn’t want it to happen but was morbidly curious to see how they will navigate their relationship going forward.
☾ I enjoy when an author doesn’t make their characters these perfect, infallible beings. I often prefer characters to be flawed and to watch them make mistakes and learn. There were times when I really rooted for Naevyn, but also wanted her to be better to the people around her. She suffered from a bit of tunnel vision. However, this only added to the layers of her character, and I look forward to seeing how this develops in the next book.
☾ It wouldn’t be a book set in Herethia if the world wasn’t jaw-droppingly beautiful. We are treated to new and old locations. I commend Eliza’s imagination and the world she has created. The beauty of this land is incredible, and pulls you in at first sight, but there are undercurrents of wrongness that seeps deep into your bones the longer you stare. It feels like a pearlescent serpent that holds your affection with its beauty, so you don’t notice the way it winds its way around your neck. Magic flows through Eliza’s words and through this world. The imagery of this story is one of its most prominent features, in my opinion. Her imagination is incredible, and she graciously invites us inside her creativity.
☾ Dysphoria encapsulates what is great about Romantasy. The story ebbs and flows in a way that is satisfying. It allows us to take a breath and enjoy the scenery, but also knows when to ramp up the tension and the pace, to keep us moving through the story. If you love found family, beautifully crafted worlds, DRAGONS and heart-wrenching yearning, you will enjoy your journey through these pages.
✩₊˚.⋆☾⋆⁺₊✧⋆.ೃ࿔ ݁ ˖*༄*ੈ✩‧₊₊˚.⋆☾⋆⁺₊✧⋆.ೃ࿔ ݁ ˖*༄*ੈ✩‧₊
☾ This is a tale brimming with intrigue, interesting characters and impossible choices. There are strong elements of found family and friendship. We see the characters we have grown to know and love interact with one another, in a time of uncertainty. The events of the previous book bring the characters together, and solidify their bonds. Hessa, again, was a prominent character for me. I love her and her kindness. She is gentle and sweet, whilst suffering no fools. I want the very best for her always, and I will always be cheering her on from the sidelines. There are a myriad of familiar faces, and a whole host of new ones too. The story feels stronger for these new characters and story lines. They feel like they inject more life into this world.
☾ I am unsure if other readers interpreted Cairos and Naevyn the same way as I did, but I felt like they were quite flawed in this instalment. I mean this in a positive way! They were thrown into awful situations and navigated them in the best way they knew, allowing their moral compasses to guide them along the dangerous paths they found themselves on. There was a lot of push and pull between the two main characters. This paired well with the intense yearning they felt. I don’t want to elaborate too much, in fear of spoiling anything, but the twist at the end pertaining to these characters was so interesting. I simultaneously didn’t want it to happen but was morbidly curious to see how they will navigate their relationship going forward.
☾ I enjoy when an author doesn’t make their characters these perfect, infallible beings. I often prefer characters to be flawed and to watch them make mistakes and learn. There were times when I really rooted for Naevyn, but also wanted her to be better to the people around her. She suffered from a bit of tunnel vision. However, this only added to the layers of her character, and I look forward to seeing how this develops in the next book.
☾ It wouldn’t be a book set in Herethia if the world wasn’t jaw-droppingly beautiful. We are treated to new and old locations. I commend Eliza’s imagination and the world she has created. The beauty of this land is incredible, and pulls you in at first sight, but there are undercurrents of wrongness that seeps deep into your bones the longer you stare. It feels like a pearlescent serpent that holds your affection with its beauty, so you don’t notice the way it winds its way around your neck. Magic flows through Eliza’s words and through this world. The imagery of this story is one of its most prominent features, in my opinion. Her imagination is incredible, and she graciously invites us inside her creativity.
☾ Dysphoria encapsulates what is great about Romantasy. The story ebbs and flows in a way that is satisfying. It allows us to take a breath and enjoy the scenery, but also knows when to ramp up the tension and the pace, to keep us moving through the story. If you love found family, beautifully crafted worlds, DRAGONS and heart-wrenching yearning, you will enjoy your journey through these pages.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thank you Eliza for this eARC of Dysphoria.
Vitalia was my very first arc and it will always hold a special place in my heart, so being able to read book two as an arc as well was so exciting.
3.5 Stars
I think Eliza writes in a way that’s really easy to love. She has the tool belt to write great fantasy books. I’m going to be honest. I don’t know how to feel about book 2. Part of me loved it. The world building, the eloquent writing, but I’m really upset about the choices Naevyn made and frankly, the ending.
Hear me out, I loved that we got some more backstory about Bellamie, Cairos’s past and the true Dragons, but I really hope that book 3 isn’t going to be a hunt for more people entombed in shadowstone. The cliffhanger ending could definitely mean a few different things, but I feel like we were told a specific story snip at the end and it would lead the reader to assume that end note means we are going hunting for a specific person in shadowstone. I really hope not, because it would feel like a book 2 repeat to me. I will be reading book 3 because I have to know where it goes and if we get some redemption, because right now, I’m straight up mad at Naevyn. I know Cairos lied by omission, but her berating him over it and then making worse choices on her own and omitting that to him is so hypocritical it hurts me and it feels like a betrayal to her strong FMC energy to be a coward about it. Overall, I love the world, and the story elements, and I NEED TO KNOW MORE but this one left me with a bitter taste.
Come back after you’ve read the book for the spoilers below to understand why.
SPOILERS from here, so STOP here if you haven’t read this book yet. You have been warned
I’m sorry. Maybe it’s because I’m a husband’s girlie, but I could never give up my husband for anyone, except maybe my children if I had them, but I don’t so I can’t say. But I could NEVER give up my love/bond with my husband for my mom that I don’t even remember and then NOT tell him until after I’ve already sealed the deal. You should talk about everything because communication is the most important thing in a relationship and the fact that she got mad at him for not telling her about the dragons and then immediately sold off their bond in a fit of anger like an emotional child; oooh that left me steaming. I was loving the book until that moment. She was such a hypocrite! How can you love someone so deeply then throw it all away for your mom you don’t remember without even talking to him about what was happening. If she had told him, I feel like he would have been upset of course, but would have understood and probably would have agreed to give it up for her to have her past life's mom back because he would do anything for her. OR they maybe could have found another way. I did appreciate the hate sex, but I would’ve preferred they work through it together instead of breaking the bond feeling like a heavy betrayal. If that was the only way, they would have come together in sadness for their loss but instead I think they both felt so empty because the decision was made in haste and without consulting the other. I can’t believe she did that to him after all he went through to get to her. Like I said, I will be reading book 3 because at this point, I’m so invested in this story, but ooh Naevyn, you are on my list girl.
Vitalia was my very first arc and it will always hold a special place in my heart, so being able to read book two as an arc as well was so exciting.
3.5 Stars
I think Eliza writes in a way that’s really easy to love. She has the tool belt to write great fantasy books. I’m going to be honest. I don’t know how to feel about book 2. Part of me loved it. The world building, the eloquent writing, but I’m really upset about the choices Naevyn made and frankly, the ending.
Hear me out, I loved that we got some more backstory about Bellamie, Cairos’s past and the true Dragons, but I really hope that book 3 isn’t going to be a hunt for more people entombed in shadowstone. The cliffhanger ending could definitely mean a few different things, but I feel like we were told a specific story snip at the end and it would lead the reader to assume that end note means we are going hunting for a specific person in shadowstone. I really hope not, because it would feel like a book 2 repeat to me. I will be reading book 3 because I have to know where it goes and if we get some redemption, because right now, I’m straight up mad at Naevyn. I know Cairos lied by omission, but her berating him over it and then making worse choices on her own and omitting that to him is so hypocritical it hurts me and it feels like a betrayal to her strong FMC energy to be a coward about it. Overall, I love the world, and the story elements, and I NEED TO KNOW MORE but this one left me with a bitter taste.
Come back after you’ve read the book for the spoilers below to understand why.
SPOILERS from here, so STOP here if you haven’t read this book yet. You have been warned
I’m sorry. Maybe it’s because I’m a husband’s girlie, but I could never give up my husband for anyone, except maybe my children if I had them, but I don’t so I can’t say. But I could NEVER give up my love/bond with my husband for my mom that I don’t even remember and then NOT tell him until after I’ve already sealed the deal. You should talk about everything because communication is the most important thing in a relationship and the fact that she got mad at him for not telling her about the dragons and then immediately sold off their bond in a fit of anger like an emotional child; oooh that left me steaming. I was loving the book until that moment. She was such a hypocrite! How can you love someone so deeply then throw it all away for your mom you don’t remember without even talking to him about what was happening. If she had told him, I feel like he would have been upset of course, but would have understood and probably would have agreed to give it up for her to have her past life's mom back because he would do anything for her. OR they maybe could have found another way. I did appreciate the hate sex, but I would’ve preferred they work through it together instead of breaking the bond feeling like a heavy betrayal. If that was the only way, they would have come together in sadness for their loss but instead I think they both felt so empty because the decision was made in haste and without consulting the other. I can’t believe she did that to him after all he went through to get to her. Like I said, I will be reading book 3 because at this point, I’m so invested in this story, but ooh Naevyn, you are on my list girl.
July 17, 2026
ARC Review | Spoiler Alert!
This sequel picks up fast. The transition back into the story is a little abrupt, but once I found my footing, I was hooked all over again.
Now that the slow burn from book one has finally paid off, watching Naevyn and Cairos interact is honestly so much fun. Their chemistry is effortless, and every scene between them had me grinning. Separating them for a large portion of the story was also a smart choice. It gives both characters a clear goal—finding their way back to one another—which kept the story moving and prevented the romance from becoming too predictable. Also, the big scene at the end had me feeling so uneasy!!
One thing I think this book specifically does even better than the first is the occurrence of our side characters. They’re much more involved this time around, and I’m so glad because they add so much personality to the story. I appreciated that we aren’t just seeing more of the side characters; we’re actually learning more about them. Voryn, in particular, ended up being one of my favorites. The whole “supposed-to-be-the-villain-but-is-super-nice?” thing gave me major Erik from The Phantom Of the Opera vibes, which I absolutely loved as we are all well aware. 🤭🥀
The writing itself continues to be one of the strongest points of this series. The descriptions are just as vivid as they were in the first book, and I could picture every scene with complete clarity. The pacing also makes the book incredibly easy to read. I never struggled to stay invested. The twists just kept on coming, and several of them genuinely caught me off guard.
That said, I still have a few of the same criticisms I had with book one. The Bellamie storyline continues to feel a little awkward, and every time it’s brought back up, it pulls me out of the story. Occasionally, the story also feels like events are happening simply because the plot wants them to, rather than because they develop naturally.
Though, I think that this was a really strong sequel. It expands the world, gives the supporting cast much more time to shine, and somehow manages to make the MC’s even more lovable. And that ending? Absolutely cruel. The cliffhanger has me needing book three like, yesterday.
3/5⭐️⭐️⭐️
This sequel picks up fast. The transition back into the story is a little abrupt, but once I found my footing, I was hooked all over again.
Now that the slow burn from book one has finally paid off, watching Naevyn and Cairos interact is honestly so much fun. Their chemistry is effortless, and every scene between them had me grinning. Separating them for a large portion of the story was also a smart choice. It gives both characters a clear goal—finding their way back to one another—which kept the story moving and prevented the romance from becoming too predictable. Also, the big scene at the end had me feeling so uneasy!!
One thing I think this book specifically does even better than the first is the occurrence of our side characters. They’re much more involved this time around, and I’m so glad because they add so much personality to the story. I appreciated that we aren’t just seeing more of the side characters; we’re actually learning more about them. Voryn, in particular, ended up being one of my favorites. The whole “supposed-to-be-the-villain-but-is-super-nice?” thing gave me major Erik from The Phantom Of the Opera vibes, which I absolutely loved as we are all well aware. 🤭🥀
The writing itself continues to be one of the strongest points of this series. The descriptions are just as vivid as they were in the first book, and I could picture every scene with complete clarity. The pacing also makes the book incredibly easy to read. I never struggled to stay invested. The twists just kept on coming, and several of them genuinely caught me off guard.
That said, I still have a few of the same criticisms I had with book one. The Bellamie storyline continues to feel a little awkward, and every time it’s brought back up, it pulls me out of the story. Occasionally, the story also feels like events are happening simply because the plot wants them to, rather than because they develop naturally.
Though, I think that this was a really strong sequel. It expands the world, gives the supporting cast much more time to shine, and somehow manages to make the MC’s even more lovable. And that ending? Absolutely cruel. The cliffhanger has me needing book three like, yesterday.
3/5⭐️⭐️⭐️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 9, 2026
I’ve been sitting on the review for Dysphoria by Eliza Benner for a few days to let it settle in my brain and see how my feelings change.
There were some real strengths and some weaknesses to this book which made me really struggle to finish it. I don’t think there’s a way for me to honestly review this book without some spoilers, so continue at your own risk.
This book brought up some compelling questions about fated mates. Are they mates because they loved each other? Or do they love each other because they’re mates? There is a distinct difference which I think may be explored more in book three.
It also raised questions about the main couple. They love each other, but I often struggled to see mutual respect between them, which made some of the emotional beats less convincing for me. Do they really think very highly of each other? Deeply questioned by this reader.
This book expanded further on what is clearly a well thought out world that is visually interesting and expansive. It really has that going for it! But despite the strength of the worldbuilding, I often found the character decisions difficult to reconcile with what had been established earlier in the series.
A big plot point in the first book was needing to get the brother and best friend (who I thought was a sister for most of the first book. Whoops) back. But in this book the main characters leave them behind without even a word of dialogue. They’re a footnote. As an older sister who found that element really compelling in book one, that was jarring.
Some plot points were closed off in a way that made me go “wow, I hadn’t even realised that was a breadcrumb earlier!” And there has been some good set up potentially for the next book. At the same time, a major fight between the two main characters happens because of a particular event. But when I went back and checked, that event hadn’t even happened in the way they were arguing about. Which undermined the conflict for me. Things like that consistently took me out of it and ruined my enjoyment of the book.
If details, continuity, and emotional realism are important to your reading experience, this probably isn’t the book for you.
There were some real strengths and some weaknesses to this book which made me really struggle to finish it. I don’t think there’s a way for me to honestly review this book without some spoilers, so continue at your own risk.
This book brought up some compelling questions about fated mates. Are they mates because they loved each other? Or do they love each other because they’re mates? There is a distinct difference which I think may be explored more in book three.
It also raised questions about the main couple. They love each other, but I often struggled to see mutual respect between them, which made some of the emotional beats less convincing for me. Do they really think very highly of each other? Deeply questioned by this reader.
This book expanded further on what is clearly a well thought out world that is visually interesting and expansive. It really has that going for it! But despite the strength of the worldbuilding, I often found the character decisions difficult to reconcile with what had been established earlier in the series.
A big plot point in the first book was needing to get the brother and best friend (who I thought was a sister for most of the first book. Whoops) back. But in this book the main characters leave them behind without even a word of dialogue. They’re a footnote. As an older sister who found that element really compelling in book one, that was jarring.
Some plot points were closed off in a way that made me go “wow, I hadn’t even realised that was a breadcrumb earlier!” And there has been some good set up potentially for the next book. At the same time, a major fight between the two main characters happens because of a particular event. But when I went back and checked, that event hadn’t even happened in the way they were arguing about. Which undermined the conflict for me. Things like that consistently took me out of it and ruined my enjoyment of the book.
If details, continuity, and emotional realism are important to your reading experience, this probably isn’t the book for you.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 5, 2026
ARC Review❣️
❤❤❤❤❤ hearts
I genuinely don't know how Eliza Benner keeps doing this, but somehow Dysphoria was even better than Vitalia.
I finished the last page and just sat there staring at my Kindle, trying to process everything that had happened. The ending completely wrecked me. I laughed, I smiled, I stressed, I cried... and that final stretch? It absolutely destroyed me.
One of the things I love most about this series is the worldbuilding. It doesn't just exist in the background, it feels alive. Every new place, every creature, every shard, every dragon adds another layer to this incredible world. The descriptions are so vivid that I could picture everything as if I were standing beside the characters.
And then there's Cairos...I don't even know where to begin. He completely owns every scene he's in. Powerful, protective, fiercely loyal, yet emotionally vulnerable in all the right ways. His love for Naevyn isn't just shown through actions it's in every word he speaks.
Naevyn continues to grow into such a strong heroine. She makes impossible choices, stands back up every time she's knocked down, and never stops fighting for the people she loves. Watching her journey has been incredibly rewarding.
Together, Cairos and Naeuyn are everything I wanted and more. Their banter, their trust, their chemistry, and the way they understand each other make them one of my favorite fantasy couples.
Then came the last 10%. I knew something big was coming, but nothing could have prepared me for it. My heart was racing, tears were falling, and I honestly forgot to breathe while reading those final chapters.
And then...
That ending.
That cliffhanger.
Eliza... respectfully... HOW COULD YOU?
Now I'm left counting the days until Book 3 because I desperately need answers.
This series has completely stolen my heart, and Dysphoria proves that it only gets better 🤍
❤❤❤❤❤ hearts
I genuinely don't know how Eliza Benner keeps doing this, but somehow Dysphoria was even better than Vitalia.
I finished the last page and just sat there staring at my Kindle, trying to process everything that had happened. The ending completely wrecked me. I laughed, I smiled, I stressed, I cried... and that final stretch? It absolutely destroyed me.
One of the things I love most about this series is the worldbuilding. It doesn't just exist in the background, it feels alive. Every new place, every creature, every shard, every dragon adds another layer to this incredible world. The descriptions are so vivid that I could picture everything as if I were standing beside the characters.
And then there's Cairos...I don't even know where to begin. He completely owns every scene he's in. Powerful, protective, fiercely loyal, yet emotionally vulnerable in all the right ways. His love for Naevyn isn't just shown through actions it's in every word he speaks.
Naevyn continues to grow into such a strong heroine. She makes impossible choices, stands back up every time she's knocked down, and never stops fighting for the people she loves. Watching her journey has been incredibly rewarding.
Together, Cairos and Naeuyn are everything I wanted and more. Their banter, their trust, their chemistry, and the way they understand each other make them one of my favorite fantasy couples.
Then came the last 10%. I knew something big was coming, but nothing could have prepared me for it. My heart was racing, tears were falling, and I honestly forgot to breathe while reading those final chapters.
And then...
That ending.
That cliffhanger.
Eliza... respectfully... HOW COULD YOU?
Now I'm left counting the days until Book 3 because I desperately need answers.
This series has completely stolen my heart, and Dysphoria proves that it only gets better 🤍
Review of advance copy received from Author
Picking up right where book one left off, Dysphoria pulls you back into the adventure. The change in setting was fantastic, expanding the world-building and making it incredibly easy to feel invested in the plot alongside the characters.
What I Loved:
The Pacing: The scenes move quickly, and the new conflict brilliantly tackles the aftermath of book one. I loved the balance of action and tenderness, and that the characters are quick, realistic problem-solvers.
The Supporting Cast: The secondary characters are fantastic! Watching their believable, evolving dynamics with each other was a highlight.
Individual Arcs: Naevyn and Cairos solo storylines were fantastic. Being on her own brought back the version of Naevyn I loved at the start of book one.
What Didn't Work For Me:
The Romance & Spice: I really dislike Naevyn and Cairos as a couple, making their shared plot hard to get through. While the author successfully delivers on the spicy romantasy premise, some of their spicy scenes pulled me right out of the story during what I thought were crucial plot moments.
Dropped Threads: The sibling storyline from book one felt completely left behind, and some new characters lacked proper introductions, leaving me with questions.
The Lore: I’m still confused about the prophecy and how the dragon/fae/shade stalker systems actually function. The explanations tended to just repeat known info rather than deepening the world.
Despite my personal disconnect with the main romance, Eliza Benner has written a solid, fast-paced, and engaging second installment. If you love immersive fantasy adventures and great ensemble casts, this series is well worth the ride. I'm definitely curious to see what book three brings!
What I Loved:
The Pacing: The scenes move quickly, and the new conflict brilliantly tackles the aftermath of book one. I loved the balance of action and tenderness, and that the characters are quick, realistic problem-solvers.
The Supporting Cast: The secondary characters are fantastic! Watching their believable, evolving dynamics with each other was a highlight.
Individual Arcs: Naevyn and Cairos solo storylines were fantastic. Being on her own brought back the version of Naevyn I loved at the start of book one.
What Didn't Work For Me:
The Romance & Spice: I really dislike Naevyn and Cairos as a couple, making their shared plot hard to get through. While the author successfully delivers on the spicy romantasy premise, some of their spicy scenes pulled me right out of the story during what I thought were crucial plot moments.
Dropped Threads: The sibling storyline from book one felt completely left behind, and some new characters lacked proper introductions, leaving me with questions.
The Lore: I’m still confused about the prophecy and how the dragon/fae/shade stalker systems actually function. The explanations tended to just repeat known info rather than deepening the world.
Despite my personal disconnect with the main romance, Eliza Benner has written a solid, fast-paced, and engaging second installment. If you love immersive fantasy adventures and great ensemble casts, this series is well worth the ride. I'm definitely curious to see what book three brings!
July 7, 2026
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️ 🌶️🌶️
Themes:
Touch Her and D!e 🖤☠️
Slow Burn 🔥
Dragon Shifters 🐉
Summary:
The king is trapped. The chaos should be over. So why does everything feel like it's just beginning?
With Valthaeron sealed away and the rebellion finally breathing, Naevyn thought she'd earned a moment to rest, grieve, and figure out who she is in this new life. But her mother has been imprisoned in shadowstone for six hundred years, and the longer Orlia stays bound to Valthaeron's trapped soul, the weaker she becomes. Now Naevyn is hunting answers in the last place she expected: the domain of the true dragons. With faction lines fracturing and old loyalties curdling into something dangerous, Naevyn can't afford to trust anyone. Except maybe Cairos, who has decided that if he has to suffer, so does she. And he's very, very good at making her suffer. But the deeper they go, the more Naevyn realizes that saving her mother might demand a price she never saw coming. She gave her blood to stop Valthaeron. What this world wants from her next is so much worse.
Review:
After reading the first book I was so ready for this one. The story continues right where the first one left off and you get to learn more about what the MMC is feeling and experiencing. There is love, betrayal, yearning (SO MUCH YEARNING), and dragons! I loved every minute of it, but it also kinda broke my heart. Be prepared for a cliffhanger that will leave you to suffer the cruel wait until the next book is released.
Favorite Quote:
“Touch her, and there is nowhere in either realm you will be safe from me. Nowhere in the depths of Hell where you could escape from me.”
Thank you to Eliza Benner for the gifted eARC!
Spice: 🌶️ 🌶️🌶️
Themes:
Touch Her and D!e 🖤☠️
Slow Burn 🔥
Dragon Shifters 🐉
Summary:
The king is trapped. The chaos should be over. So why does everything feel like it's just beginning?
With Valthaeron sealed away and the rebellion finally breathing, Naevyn thought she'd earned a moment to rest, grieve, and figure out who she is in this new life. But her mother has been imprisoned in shadowstone for six hundred years, and the longer Orlia stays bound to Valthaeron's trapped soul, the weaker she becomes. Now Naevyn is hunting answers in the last place she expected: the domain of the true dragons. With faction lines fracturing and old loyalties curdling into something dangerous, Naevyn can't afford to trust anyone. Except maybe Cairos, who has decided that if he has to suffer, so does she. And he's very, very good at making her suffer. But the deeper they go, the more Naevyn realizes that saving her mother might demand a price she never saw coming. She gave her blood to stop Valthaeron. What this world wants from her next is so much worse.
Review:
After reading the first book I was so ready for this one. The story continues right where the first one left off and you get to learn more about what the MMC is feeling and experiencing. There is love, betrayal, yearning (SO MUCH YEARNING), and dragons! I loved every minute of it, but it also kinda broke my heart. Be prepared for a cliffhanger that will leave you to suffer the cruel wait until the next book is released.
Favorite Quote:
“Touch her, and there is nowhere in either realm you will be safe from me. Nowhere in the depths of Hell where you could escape from me.”
Thank you to Eliza Benner for the gifted eARC!
Review of advance copy received from Author
REVIEW OF ADVANCE READER COPY FROM AUTHOR
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5
I didn’t think Eliza Benner could pull me back into this world harder than Vitalia did, but somehow Dysphoria completely consumed me 🖤
After finishing this book, I genuinely don’t know what to do with myself. 😭
The worldbuilding continues to be one of my favourite things about this series. Every new revelation, every hidden secret, every piece of history we uncover just makes the world feel bigger and more fascinating. I was constantly trying to piece everything together alongside the characters.
And Cairos... 😭
That man had me stressed, intrigued, and obsessed all at the same time. Half the time I wanted answers from him, and the other half I didn’t want the mystery around him to end.
I also loved Naevyn. She’s strong without feeling unrealistically perfect, and watching her navigate all the secrets, dangers, and revelations around her made me root for her the entire time.
And the chemistry between them completely stole the show.
It was incredible from the start, but what really got me was the banter. Every conversation between them felt effortless. They challenged each other, frustrated each other, made me laugh, and somehow made me fall in love with them even more.
What I loved most was how perfectly the romance and plot balanced each other. Neither one overshadowed the other. The mysteries kept me hooked, while Naevyn and Cairos kept me emotionally invested.
Needless to say, by the end I was completely invested in this world and these characters. The wait for the next book is going to be brutal 😭
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5
I didn’t think Eliza Benner could pull me back into this world harder than Vitalia did, but somehow Dysphoria completely consumed me 🖤
After finishing this book, I genuinely don’t know what to do with myself. 😭
The worldbuilding continues to be one of my favourite things about this series. Every new revelation, every hidden secret, every piece of history we uncover just makes the world feel bigger and more fascinating. I was constantly trying to piece everything together alongside the characters.
And Cairos... 😭
That man had me stressed, intrigued, and obsessed all at the same time. Half the time I wanted answers from him, and the other half I didn’t want the mystery around him to end.
I also loved Naevyn. She’s strong without feeling unrealistically perfect, and watching her navigate all the secrets, dangers, and revelations around her made me root for her the entire time.
And the chemistry between them completely stole the show.
It was incredible from the start, but what really got me was the banter. Every conversation between them felt effortless. They challenged each other, frustrated each other, made me laugh, and somehow made me fall in love with them even more.
What I loved most was how perfectly the romance and plot balanced each other. Neither one overshadowed the other. The mysteries kept me hooked, while Naevyn and Cairos kept me emotionally invested.
Needless to say, by the end I was completely invested in this world and these characters. The wait for the next book is going to be brutal 😭
Review of advance copy received from Author
My Review: Dysphoria (Circus of Souls, #2)
My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5 Stars)
Release Date: 06/30/2026
"An Absolute Must-Read Masterpiece—I Couldn't Put It Down!"
I was fortunate enough to receive an Advanced Review Copy of Dysphoria, and to say I was completely consumed by it would be an understatement. I literally could not put this book down, and any time real life or work forced me to take a break, I was absolutely itching to get back to the story.
Picking up after the brutal battle against Valthaeron, this sequel hits the ground running and never lets up. Being reunited with Cairos, Naevyn, Gileon, Hessa, and Fenric felt like coming home to the best kind of chaos. The stakes are higher than ever, and Eliza Benner handles the fallout of book one with absolute perfection.
The highlights of this book for me were twofold:
The Romance: The slow-burn romance in this series continues to absolutely burn. The tension is exquisite, and watching their connection deepen amidst the chaos is everything a romantasy reader could ever want.
The Emotional Stakes: Watching what Naevyn is willing to sacrifice to save her mother’s life was utterly gut-wrenching. The emotional depth in this installment is raw, powerful, and beautifully written.
The character growth across the entire gang is phenomenal, and the trajectory of this journey has me completely hooked. Dysphoria is a spectacular sophomore novel that easily avoids the dreaded "second book syndrome." I am already desperate to get my hands on Book 3 to see where this incredible journey goes next!
Thank you to Eliza Benner for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
My Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5 Stars)
Release Date: 06/30/2026
"An Absolute Must-Read Masterpiece—I Couldn't Put It Down!"
I was fortunate enough to receive an Advanced Review Copy of Dysphoria, and to say I was completely consumed by it would be an understatement. I literally could not put this book down, and any time real life or work forced me to take a break, I was absolutely itching to get back to the story.
Picking up after the brutal battle against Valthaeron, this sequel hits the ground running and never lets up. Being reunited with Cairos, Naevyn, Gileon, Hessa, and Fenric felt like coming home to the best kind of chaos. The stakes are higher than ever, and Eliza Benner handles the fallout of book one with absolute perfection.
The highlights of this book for me were twofold:
The Romance: The slow-burn romance in this series continues to absolutely burn. The tension is exquisite, and watching their connection deepen amidst the chaos is everything a romantasy reader could ever want.
The Emotional Stakes: Watching what Naevyn is willing to sacrifice to save her mother’s life was utterly gut-wrenching. The emotional depth in this installment is raw, powerful, and beautifully written.
The character growth across the entire gang is phenomenal, and the trajectory of this journey has me completely hooked. Dysphoria is a spectacular sophomore novel that easily avoids the dreaded "second book syndrome." I am already desperate to get my hands on Book 3 to see where this incredible journey goes next!
Thank you to Eliza Benner for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC REVIEW
⭐️ 3,5
I really enjoyed this storyline a lot more than I thought I would - it was adventurous and went a bit deeper with the worldbuilding compared to the first book, which I appreciated. I was invested in the story the entire time, although it might be a bit simple - it would have been interesting if the mysteries with the different monsters and the Gods was being further investigated alongside the main plot.
I also really enjoyed the humorous characters and the new world that was added. Eliza has a way with building scenes that I really, really enjoy. I can see exactly what she describes and she is able to add a lot of depth to the scenes and the emotions as well, making me feel like I’m in the story.
I didn’t find any major plotholes as I did in the first book which made the reading experience a lot more smooth and enjoyable, but I was pulled out of the story quite often by a somewhat repetitive writing. There were a lot of ”just”, and ”like” and ”something” that eventually made me focus more on the wording than the actual book. This was compensated by the great sceneries though.
I liked the dual POV, but honestly - most of all I liked how Naevyn and Cairos were separated for most of the book. I really can’t stand the man for so many reasons and I’m struggling to see what Naevyn loves about him. I am questioning whether he is truly the main love interest? I feel like the morally grey theme went more towards cowardice and that Cairos has neither moral nor spine, making him a little bit pathetic in my eyes.
All and all, I enjoyed the book and I am curious about what happens in the next one!
⭐️ 3,5
I really enjoyed this storyline a lot more than I thought I would - it was adventurous and went a bit deeper with the worldbuilding compared to the first book, which I appreciated. I was invested in the story the entire time, although it might be a bit simple - it would have been interesting if the mysteries with the different monsters and the Gods was being further investigated alongside the main plot.
I also really enjoyed the humorous characters and the new world that was added. Eliza has a way with building scenes that I really, really enjoy. I can see exactly what she describes and she is able to add a lot of depth to the scenes and the emotions as well, making me feel like I’m in the story.
I didn’t find any major plotholes as I did in the first book which made the reading experience a lot more smooth and enjoyable, but I was pulled out of the story quite often by a somewhat repetitive writing. There were a lot of ”just”, and ”like” and ”something” that eventually made me focus more on the wording than the actual book. This was compensated by the great sceneries though.
I liked the dual POV, but honestly - most of all I liked how Naevyn and Cairos were separated for most of the book. I really can’t stand the man for so many reasons and I’m struggling to see what Naevyn loves about him. I am questioning whether he is truly the main love interest? I feel like the morally grey theme went more towards cowardice and that Cairos has neither moral nor spine, making him a little bit pathetic in my eyes.
All and all, I enjoyed the book and I am curious about what happens in the next one!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 30, 2026
4.5/5 stars!
Eliza, girl, why did you rip my heart out like that??! I really enjoyed book 1 Vitalia. The unique deadly circus theme, and discovering all these new character, found family.. all of it...SO unique. Well....book 2 Dysphoria, also did not disappoint. While we dont have the main story circling around the deadly circus (with exception of one particular chapter, back in the silks🔥🥵 oh Daddy Cairos), the new worlds we get thrown into, the dragons (yes, more dragons!), and new twists that took me down all these possible paths...I felt book 2 was just as good as book 1.
If you've had a bit of a time frame between book 1 and book 2, the first several chapters might have you rewiring your brain into a new dynamic of relatiomships BUT, TRUST, hang in there, new plot and world building to start but then, SWOOSH! 🤯it just sweeps you back into the adventure and tense situations Naevyn seems to always find herself in and we're off (this time way down deep)!
I could not stop reading once Eliza pushes the pedal to the floor! The last 1/4 of this book is so heart breaking, you see it coming, she TELLS you its coming, but it doesnt make it any better when it hits..... REAL tears 😭 and the way Eliza writes, oof, you feel it all! DEV-A-STATED 😭 You want to punch someone in the face and then go find someome for a hug. I just cant with that ending. The only plus, is theres still hope 🙏 because there IS a book 3 coming!! (You'll have to read Dysphoria till the last page to find the name release!) So go, NOW! Read this series!!
Thank You Eliza for an early gifted copy! I loved it!
Eliza, girl, why did you rip my heart out like that??! I really enjoyed book 1 Vitalia. The unique deadly circus theme, and discovering all these new character, found family.. all of it...SO unique. Well....book 2 Dysphoria, also did not disappoint. While we dont have the main story circling around the deadly circus (with exception of one particular chapter, back in the silks🔥🥵 oh Daddy Cairos), the new worlds we get thrown into, the dragons (yes, more dragons!), and new twists that took me down all these possible paths...I felt book 2 was just as good as book 1.
If you've had a bit of a time frame between book 1 and book 2, the first several chapters might have you rewiring your brain into a new dynamic of relatiomships BUT, TRUST, hang in there, new plot and world building to start but then, SWOOSH! 🤯it just sweeps you back into the adventure and tense situations Naevyn seems to always find herself in and we're off (this time way down deep)!
I could not stop reading once Eliza pushes the pedal to the floor! The last 1/4 of this book is so heart breaking, you see it coming, she TELLS you its coming, but it doesnt make it any better when it hits..... REAL tears 😭 and the way Eliza writes, oof, you feel it all! DEV-A-STATED 😭 You want to punch someone in the face and then go find someome for a hug. I just cant with that ending. The only plus, is theres still hope 🙏 because there IS a book 3 coming!! (You'll have to read Dysphoria till the last page to find the name release!) So go, NOW! Read this series!!
Thank You Eliza for an early gifted copy! I loved it!
July 8, 2026
Hanging out for book three!
Her power isn’t done demanding sacrifices yet in Dysphoria.
Picking up from the end of book one, Naevyn and Cairos are dealing with the fallout of toppling a king. Despite the fact that he is trapped in shadowstone, his followers are hellbent on restoring him. To prevent that and to rescue Naevyn’s mother, they need to find the true dragons.
Facing external challenges they didn’t expect, Naevyn and Cairos are also feeling the strain within their bond. But those feelings are only temporary for an immortal, unbreakable bond…right?
This fantasy romance was full of adventure and some serious challenges. Nothing comes easily in the story - every win is hard won, and there are definitely setbacks. You cannot read this book without the first - it will make no sense.
The story also gets pretty emotional towards the end. Reader, I cried. I very rarely cry in books. This one had tears streaming down my cheeks.
Romance wise - they’re already established as a couple. We see the relationship grow at times and struggle at others. The spice is open door and nicely spicy but it is not the main point of the book by any means. If you’re the kind of person who skips the spice - do yourself a favour and don’t do it in this book. It is crucial for the development of the relationship.
There’s some heavy topics here - particularly torture, spending centuries trapped in a stone, non-consensual stuff (not to do with sex) and imprisonment.
If you are after a fantasy romance series where most characters are morally grey stuff and sometimes make the wrong choices, check out the Herethia series now.
Her power isn’t done demanding sacrifices yet in Dysphoria.
Picking up from the end of book one, Naevyn and Cairos are dealing with the fallout of toppling a king. Despite the fact that he is trapped in shadowstone, his followers are hellbent on restoring him. To prevent that and to rescue Naevyn’s mother, they need to find the true dragons.
Facing external challenges they didn’t expect, Naevyn and Cairos are also feeling the strain within their bond. But those feelings are only temporary for an immortal, unbreakable bond…right?
This fantasy romance was full of adventure and some serious challenges. Nothing comes easily in the story - every win is hard won, and there are definitely setbacks. You cannot read this book without the first - it will make no sense.
The story also gets pretty emotional towards the end. Reader, I cried. I very rarely cry in books. This one had tears streaming down my cheeks.
Romance wise - they’re already established as a couple. We see the relationship grow at times and struggle at others. The spice is open door and nicely spicy but it is not the main point of the book by any means. If you’re the kind of person who skips the spice - do yourself a favour and don’t do it in this book. It is crucial for the development of the relationship.
There’s some heavy topics here - particularly torture, spending centuries trapped in a stone, non-consensual stuff (not to do with sex) and imprisonment.
If you are after a fantasy romance series where most characters are morally grey stuff and sometimes make the wrong choices, check out the Herethia series now.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review (thank you BookFunnel). This review, though technically for 'Dysphoria' on its own, will inevitably reflect both it, and the first book in this ongoing series, 'Vitalia', as I read both back to back in preparation for this book's release.
That being said, their quality, pacing, tone are so similar that I think it's fair to rate them collectively. I felt basically the same when I was reading each volume, and that feeling was mostly "this is fine". Not terrible. Not incredible. Nothing extreme in either direction. It's a true middle of the road experience in terms of what I've come to expect from the genre. The character dynamics were very basic. The plot was disjointed, but serviceable. The concepts explored were all over the place, and convoluted, but inoffensive. It was all just fine.
In regards to the narrative, there was a constant, melodramatically swing from the highs to the lows. Everything was described as the most of this, or the least of that. It was a bit cringe at times, and it became so noticeable the most when Naevyn (FMC) and Cairos (MMC) interacted. This is honestly the crux of the issue throughout both volumes. I craved more subtlety and care in the descriptions and dialogue. But it was so over the top in such an unearned way, that I constantly was pulled out of my suspension of disbelief at the melodrama and bathos of it all.
Some parts were fun; that's why it's not a one star read. But, at this point, I'm not excited about the next volume, and don't have any plans to continue reading on.
That being said, their quality, pacing, tone are so similar that I think it's fair to rate them collectively. I felt basically the same when I was reading each volume, and that feeling was mostly "this is fine". Not terrible. Not incredible. Nothing extreme in either direction. It's a true middle of the road experience in terms of what I've come to expect from the genre. The character dynamics were very basic. The plot was disjointed, but serviceable. The concepts explored were all over the place, and convoluted, but inoffensive. It was all just fine.
In regards to the narrative, there was a constant, melodramatically swing from the highs to the lows. Everything was described as the most of this, or the least of that. It was a bit cringe at times, and it became so noticeable the most when Naevyn (FMC) and Cairos (MMC) interacted. This is honestly the crux of the issue throughout both volumes. I craved more subtlety and care in the descriptions and dialogue. But it was so over the top in such an unearned way, that I constantly was pulled out of my suspension of disbelief at the melodrama and bathos of it all.
Some parts were fun; that's why it's not a one star read. But, at this point, I'm not excited about the next volume, and don't have any plans to continue reading on.
July 1, 2026
4.5⭐️
(ARC received in exchange for an honest review.)
This book completely destroyed me emotionally. Seriously… that ending left me absolutely devastated and heartbroken, and now I have to wait for the third book. When they reach the point where they look at each other and feel nothing, the emotional impact makes everything that happened before hurt even more. It was completely unnecessary… or at least that’s what I keep telling myself while being in total denial.
I still can’t decide whether I loved this one more than the first, so for now, they’re tied.
In this installment, the relationship between the main characters is truly put to the test, and much of the story follows them as they try to navigate everything they’re forced to endure together.
The pacing remains excellent. I found this book to be a little slower than the first, but I was completely invested from beginning to end.
One of my favorite aspects was the FMC’s development. We see her grow significantly in confidence and independence, relying less on Cairo to make decisions and face the challenges ahead.
We also learn much more about Cairo’s past, which I thought was essential for understanding both his motivations and the person he has become.
Overall, this was a fantastic sequel that had me completely hooked from start to finish—and it ended in the absolute worst way possible for readers: heartbroken, emotionally wrecked, and desperately waiting for the next book.
(ARC received in exchange for an honest review.)
This book completely destroyed me emotionally. Seriously… that ending left me absolutely devastated and heartbroken, and now I have to wait for the third book. When they reach the point where they look at each other and feel nothing, the emotional impact makes everything that happened before hurt even more. It was completely unnecessary… or at least that’s what I keep telling myself while being in total denial.
I still can’t decide whether I loved this one more than the first, so for now, they’re tied.
In this installment, the relationship between the main characters is truly put to the test, and much of the story follows them as they try to navigate everything they’re forced to endure together.
The pacing remains excellent. I found this book to be a little slower than the first, but I was completely invested from beginning to end.
One of my favorite aspects was the FMC’s development. We see her grow significantly in confidence and independence, relying less on Cairo to make decisions and face the challenges ahead.
We also learn much more about Cairo’s past, which I thought was essential for understanding both his motivations and the person he has become.
Overall, this was a fantastic sequel that had me completely hooked from start to finish—and it ended in the absolute worst way possible for readers: heartbroken, emotionally wrecked, and desperately waiting for the next book.
July 6, 2026
While Vitalia set up a fun, high-stakes premise, Dysphoria expands the universe in a way that feels far richer, darker, and more atmospheric. The middle act pacing stumbles slightly, but the overall worldbuilding and Cairos’s character arc make this a fantastic 4-star read.
What I loved:
Rich Dragon Realm Worldbuilding: Moving beyond the circus setting into the dragon domain breathed fresh life into the story. The sensory details—like glass trees shimmering under shifted light and the oppressive weight of ancient strongholds—make the world feel tangible and unpredictable. The magic mechanics, bloodline curses, and soul-bindings feel dangerous and well-crafted. She really steps it up in book 2.
Cairos’s Character Arc: Watching Cairos grow was easily the best part of this installment. He starts off relying on sharp wit, violence, and possessive control to mask centuries of trauma. His path toward redemption isn't sudden or easy—it's slow, painful, and deeply human. Watching his protectiveness evolve from controlling instincts into a genuine, equal partnership with Naevyn gives his character incredible emotional depth.
If you enjoy dark fae lore, dragon-shifters, high-stakes political fracture, and heavy slow-burn tension, Dysphoria delivers a very satisfying continuation to the Circus of Souls series! Cannot wait for the 3rd book! This cliff hanger OMG! Leave me on the edge of my seat why don't you!!
What I loved:
Rich Dragon Realm Worldbuilding: Moving beyond the circus setting into the dragon domain breathed fresh life into the story. The sensory details—like glass trees shimmering under shifted light and the oppressive weight of ancient strongholds—make the world feel tangible and unpredictable. The magic mechanics, bloodline curses, and soul-bindings feel dangerous and well-crafted. She really steps it up in book 2.
Cairos’s Character Arc: Watching Cairos grow was easily the best part of this installment. He starts off relying on sharp wit, violence, and possessive control to mask centuries of trauma. His path toward redemption isn't sudden or easy—it's slow, painful, and deeply human. Watching his protectiveness evolve from controlling instincts into a genuine, equal partnership with Naevyn gives his character incredible emotional depth.
If you enjoy dark fae lore, dragon-shifters, high-stakes political fracture, and heavy slow-burn tension, Dysphoria delivers a very satisfying continuation to the Circus of Souls series! Cannot wait for the 3rd book! This cliff hanger OMG! Leave me on the edge of my seat why don't you!!
Review of advance copy received from Author
First, I want to thank Eliza Benner for the opportunity to read this ARC. It’s book two in the ‘Circus of Souls’ series, Dysphoria.
This book has evolved exponentially from book one. I absolutely loved book one! Loved it! After reading Dysphoria, it felt like Vitalia was merely a warm-up. Dysphoria has built on and expanded upon the previous book, Vitalia.
I found the growth of the characters surprising. Naevyn, despite her origins and life of drudgery, has seamlessly adapted to this new life with grace and style. This demonstrates her strength and resilience.
Cairos, a Fae/Dragon Shifter, has revealed a more human side. The ‘mated bond’ between these two suggests that life and love should be smoother with such a connection. There’s a genuine human element that makes you relate.
While navigating love, there’s still life to contend with. An evil king to keep imprisoned, a mother to free from a 600-year-old prison, the original dragons to find, another realm to discover, and a cliffhanger that leaves you craving more.
Reading this book was a rollercoaster of emotions. I felt angry, frustrated, annoyed, sad, disbelief, excitement, elation, and even had to fan myself a few times during the steamy scenes. I couldn’t help but giggle in some spots too.
Eliza Benner, you’ve done it again! I couldn’t put this book down and I can’t wait for the next one.
This book has evolved exponentially from book one. I absolutely loved book one! Loved it! After reading Dysphoria, it felt like Vitalia was merely a warm-up. Dysphoria has built on and expanded upon the previous book, Vitalia.
I found the growth of the characters surprising. Naevyn, despite her origins and life of drudgery, has seamlessly adapted to this new life with grace and style. This demonstrates her strength and resilience.
Cairos, a Fae/Dragon Shifter, has revealed a more human side. The ‘mated bond’ between these two suggests that life and love should be smoother with such a connection. There’s a genuine human element that makes you relate.
While navigating love, there’s still life to contend with. An evil king to keep imprisoned, a mother to free from a 600-year-old prison, the original dragons to find, another realm to discover, and a cliffhanger that leaves you craving more.
Reading this book was a rollercoaster of emotions. I felt angry, frustrated, annoyed, sad, disbelief, excitement, elation, and even had to fan myself a few times during the steamy scenes. I couldn’t help but giggle in some spots too.
Eliza Benner, you’ve done it again! I couldn’t put this book down and I can’t wait for the next one.
June 29, 2026
Thank you to Eliza for the ARC in exchange for an honest review of Dysphoria - book two in Circus of Souls
I was a huge fan of book one, literally devoured it in a few days. The first 2/3 of this book was quite slow for me, and I had a hard time reconnecting with the characters. Cairos didn’t really hit for me (unlike book 1) as he came off much more self centred and immature. I did enjoy his and Naevyn’s time apart in the book, because I felt like I learned a bit more about each character during this time. But I wasn’t feeling the overall plot of this book, nor did I understand how it fully helped move the series plot forward. I also felt like our new side characters felt a little flat (I’m looking at you Gileon).
That being said - the last 1/3 of the book really turned around for me. I really liked the introduction to Voryn, he was my favourite character of the entire book. I’m very invested in the outcome of his actions at the end, and what that means for Cairos and Naevyn - I really hope my appreciation of Cairos returns in book three, and I’m excited to learn more about Sable and what she can bring to the table. I also really like where Naevyn’s family history seems to be going.
Overall what started slow for me, really did turn around and I’m looking forward to continuing the series because there are a lot of well loved tropes but also enough originality throughout.
I was a huge fan of book one, literally devoured it in a few days. The first 2/3 of this book was quite slow for me, and I had a hard time reconnecting with the characters. Cairos didn’t really hit for me (unlike book 1) as he came off much more self centred and immature. I did enjoy his and Naevyn’s time apart in the book, because I felt like I learned a bit more about each character during this time. But I wasn’t feeling the overall plot of this book, nor did I understand how it fully helped move the series plot forward. I also felt like our new side characters felt a little flat (I’m looking at you Gileon).
That being said - the last 1/3 of the book really turned around for me. I really liked the introduction to Voryn, he was my favourite character of the entire book. I’m very invested in the outcome of his actions at the end, and what that means for Cairos and Naevyn - I really hope my appreciation of Cairos returns in book three, and I’m excited to learn more about Sable and what she can bring to the table. I also really like where Naevyn’s family history seems to be going.
Overall what started slow for me, really did turn around and I’m looking forward to continuing the series because there are a lot of well loved tropes but also enough originality throughout.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I arc read Vitalia in January and fell in love with this world, the story, Cairos, and Naevyn.
Dysphoria picks up right where Vitalia left off. To be honest, it took a second for me to remember what was going on at the end of book 1 and the characters.
Naevyn continues to be a strong FMC who carries lot on her shoulders. Cairos is still as snarky and sexy as ever. There was some separation between the core group, but luckily it wasn't the entire book or a significant amount of time. I liked that the characters had their own story happening and could stand apart from each other and still be interesting.
The spice was spicen in this book. I loved the dream sequences and the teasing that went on. However, what I didn't love was when they finally got together, Cairos was so OOC and angry. I don't love that it gave dub-con feels. Naevyn owing him sex because of a lie/betrayal rubbed me the wrong way, which is why this wasn't a 5 star read for me.
Speaking of the lie/betrayal, Cairos was 1000% valid in his anger. I personally didn't love that she gave him a hard time for something that he did 600 years prior to her and then she turns around and does something way worse. I'm going to be here for Cairos’s anger era, I just hope the angry dub con spice doesn't come back. I have faith that Eliza will reunite them and will figure out a way for them to reunite without the bond.
Dysphoria picks up right where Vitalia left off. To be honest, it took a second for me to remember what was going on at the end of book 1 and the characters.
Naevyn continues to be a strong FMC who carries lot on her shoulders. Cairos is still as snarky and sexy as ever. There was some separation between the core group, but luckily it wasn't the entire book or a significant amount of time. I liked that the characters had their own story happening and could stand apart from each other and still be interesting.
The spice was spicen in this book. I loved the dream sequences and the teasing that went on. However, what I didn't love was when they finally got together, Cairos was so OOC and angry. I don't love that it gave dub-con feels. Naevyn owing him sex because of a lie/betrayal rubbed me the wrong way, which is why this wasn't a 5 star read for me.
Speaking of the lie/betrayal, Cairos was 1000% valid in his anger. I personally didn't love that she gave him a hard time for something that he did 600 years prior to her and then she turns around and does something way worse. I'm going to be here for Cairos’s anger era, I just hope the angry dub con spice doesn't come back. I have faith that Eliza will reunite them and will figure out a way for them to reunite without the bond.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is book two of The Circus of Souls series by Eliza Benner and picks up almost immediately after the events of book one. Naevyn and Cairos are coming to terms with what happened and the consequences of that day when they learn that Orlia is dying due to the bond with Valthaeron. They spend the book trying to learn what they can and convince the people with the knowledge they need to help them.
I really enjoyed this book. The new characters added new elements to everything and raised the stakes for book 3. There was a new comic relief that was actually heart breaking, a tragic new romance, and a new villain that was very unsettling. The ending hurt more than I thought it would, actually devastating.
It did fall into the second book trap for me. It felt like a information gathering quest where not much happened which is insane because a lot did happen. I think it was because they spent most of the book in one location and the first one they traveled a lot more.
I find this authors writing style to be very comforting and it feels familiar, it's strong and well developed without being too overwhelming. Even though this is only the second book I've read of hers it feels like she's an author I've been reading for years. It's very similar to how I felt when I first started reading Ali Hazelwood books.
I received an early copy of this book from the author.
I really enjoyed this book. The new characters added new elements to everything and raised the stakes for book 3. There was a new comic relief that was actually heart breaking, a tragic new romance, and a new villain that was very unsettling. The ending hurt more than I thought it would, actually devastating.
It did fall into the second book trap for me. It felt like a information gathering quest where not much happened which is insane because a lot did happen. I think it was because they spent most of the book in one location and the first one they traveled a lot more.
I find this authors writing style to be very comforting and it feels familiar, it's strong and well developed without being too overwhelming. Even though this is only the second book I've read of hers it feels like she's an author I've been reading for years. It's very similar to how I felt when I first started reading Ali Hazelwood books.
I received an early copy of this book from the author.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 151 reviews