Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Hell to Pay

Not yet published
Expected 30 Mar 27
Rate this book
The riveting, darkly humorous, and deeply strange story of three roommates whose everyday struggle to survive in New York is complicated by the intestine-eating demon who haunts their apartment.

Leni was kidnapped and almost sacrificed to the devil as a child, but now she’s perfectly fine. Aside from the fact that she has four reflections in the mirror…and one of them wants her to poison people.

Emerson was a leading heart surgeon until The Incident that left his patient dead. Now he’s too sick to work, keeps finding severed fingers in his water bottles, and is followed around by a faceless Girl Scout with a creaky red wagon.

Jasper is a line cook with a criminal record, just trying to keep his chosen family together. Sure, he sees a man in the shadows who likes the taste of blood, but he’s very good at ignoring that. He would do anything for Leni and Emerson. Anything.

They’re fine. They’re normal. They’re roommates making it work in New York City.

That is, until a demon leaves his sigil on their wall.

Now, they have seven days to bring Sychar a sacrifice, or he’ll tear off their skin. Who knew demon-slaying wasn’t a valid excuse to miss work? Why are murder supplies so expensive? Just how is a low-income household supposed to afford a human sacrifice?

As their personal ghosts grow louder and Sychar’s deadline draws nearer, Leni, Emerson, and Jasper discover just how far they’ll go to protect each other.

Hardcover

Expected publication March 30, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kylie Lee Baker

20 books3,572 followers
Kylie Lee Baker grew up in Boston and has since lived in Atlanta, Salamanca, and Seoul. Her work is informed by her heritage (Japanese, Chinese, & Irish) as well as her experiences living abroad as both a student and teacher. She has a BA in creative writing and Spanish from Emory University and is pursuing a master of library and information science degree at Simmons University. In her free time, she plays the cello, watches horror movies, and bakes too many cookies. The Keeper of Night is her debut novel.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
20 (22%)
4 stars
36 (41%)
3 stars
20 (22%)
2 stars
9 (10%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
Profile Image for Jamie.
548 reviews1,008 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 23, 2026
What the ever-loving ducknoodles did I just read, you guys? I just … it … I don't even … how … why would … huh.

This book was definitely not what I was expecting. Despite the blurb's promises, it is neither “riveting” nor “darkly humorous.” Hell, I'm not even sure that you can call it horror. Instead you've got three whiny, broken main characters (all of whom need some major — major! — therapy) who spend 300+ pages obsessing over wanting to shag each other. Like, the whole demon thing is basically a subplot to the moping and aspirational banging. Did you know that Leni and Jasper and Emerson all love each other and would die for each other and complete each other and care about each other and live for each other? No? Well, you certainly will by the end of this novel because sweet baby kittens on a cracker they never fucking stop talking about it.

Also I am just about as liberal as they come, but even I got sick of hearing about how much life sucks for poor, underpaid minorities with awful bosses and evil landlords. (“Life is pain, Highness, so maybe shut the hell up about it every once in a while?” — the Dread Pirate Roberts after reading this book, probably)

And how did we just gloss over the whole fucking thing? A certain character should be in a mental institution for the the criminally insane, not flopping around Flushing thinking dirty thoughts about their roommates. Actually, now that I think about it, all three of the main characters should be in goddamned Arkham Asylum because really?? What a freaking ridiculous storyline.

And on a related note, WTF (x2) was that ending? Like … I just don't … uh … what? If you want a spoiler as to how things end, here you go: . You're welcome for that mental image, but also you're welcome because now you never have to read this stupid book.

Seriously, though, Kylie Lee Baker should have to issue a public apology to New York City for setting this book there. I was an outlier with Japanese Gothic and I imagine I'll be an outlier with this one too, but holy kitty whiskers was this a tedious and irritating read.

1.25 stars.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Hanover Square Press for providing me with an advance copy of this book to review (even if they probably wish they hadn't). Its expected publication date is March 30, 2027.
Profile Image for Maggie ♡ (Hiatus).
206 reviews236 followers
Want to Read
June 11, 2026
Pre-release: Finding out about this book few days after having finished Bat Eater and Other Names for Cora Zeng and I'm sat 🙂‍↕️💚
Profile Image for DianaRose.
1,331 reviews528 followers
Want to Read
June 11, 2026
thank you to the publisher for an arc! i can't wait to dive in, as i have absolutely loved all of kylie lee baker's books, but especially her horror novels: she definitely has found her genre in horror, and it was so exciting to have heard about this next novel at the release party of japanese gothic 🤍
Profile Image for Jessi ❤️ H. Vojsk [if villain, why hot?].
993 reviews1,045 followers
July 27, 2026
But this was setting yourself on fire to keep someone else warm.
This was holding a hurricane inside your rib cage.
This was handing someone else your wet, beating heart.


Story 🌟🌟🌟🌟
A book filled with unmistakable yearning, an absolutely crazy plot of a house trying to kill you if you don’t eat someone in seven days and one of my favorite writing.

While trying to manage asshole bosses and landlords, Jasper, Emerson and Leni each struggle with their mental health, having all lives through different kind of traumas. While trying to live the hell of a life they’re forced to live, they find solace in each other.

This was so so depressing and also batshitcrazy.
I loved it.
Especially the end.

Characters 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Leni, once nearly killed by human sacrificers now lives with two guys she found on the Internet. She also works in publishing, forced to watch others live her dream.

One of her roommates is Jasper, who made a really dumb mistake in his youth and still struggles trough the aftermath, working in a hellish environment.

And Emmerson, a former doctor who was weakened by long covid so much that he feels like he could fall apart any minute.

All three struggle with their lives, but found a save place in each other.
While I was mostly depressed by the lives these three lived, i absolutely loved the way they cared and loved each other. The silent yearning was exceptional.

Relationships 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Jasper, Emerson and Leni found each other in their darkest times.
While being scooped up in a horrible cold apartment, they care for each other as good as they could, in their own kind of way.

My bisexual heart is so so happy, not only was this a throuple aka real love triangle, it was filled with an incredible yearning, that I devoured.
Not only do I love unhinged plots, my favorite thing ever is when unhinged people would do anything for the people they love.

Writing 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Slowly but steady Kylie Lee Baker became on of my favorite horror writers. Her writing is incredible and I can’t wait to read through all her work.


__________________

I feel so honored and absolutely excited to have an arc for this ✨🥹🥰
Can’t wait to read it! (Literally, I’m gonna start right now)

Thank you edelweiss and HarperCollins for the opportunity to read this masterpiece 🙏🏻
Profile Image for Becky Spratford.
Author 5 books948 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 16, 2026
Reading for review in the January 2027 issue of Library Journal

Three Words That Describe This Book: trauma, character centered, extreme unease

Baker's post COVID, capitalism critical, character focused demon story delves deeply into trauma and the horror it spawns.

I love how Baker directly takes on the Asian American stereotypes. Yes she addresses the outright anti-Asian racism, but she also addresses the fact that mainstream America assumes every single Asian American is going to be uber successful financially. In this book all three characters are fully formed. All three have serious trauma in their past, trauma that literally haunts them -- whether or not it is supernatural-- the scars this haunting causes are real.

The POV is swapped between Leni, Emerson, and Jasper. All are sympathetic even though we know they are also unreliable. And when they make bad choices we are not surprised, but will still adore them and we Leo their devotion to each other as a very real found family-- they have each lost their related family over their past trauma-- that stuff was very real and traumatic.

We see inside their heads-- the good and the bad. We see their ghosts (literally), we understand how they sustained serious trauma that they have no way to share or heal from. We also see how they don;t share the truth with each other. That unreliability builds the unease to extreme levels until it all bursts open (literally) in a cathartic if extremely unsettling ending.

We meet them each quickly and then a demon levels his mark on the living room wall of their terrible, crumbling, barely habitable Queens apartment (but it is all they can afford to not be homeless). From Leni's trauma she knows this means they have 7 days before the demon will come eat them if they don't kill a person and eat its intestines.

All three of the characters are interesting on their own, but I sorta wish they each had their own novel too. There are some un-tied up ends for all three that I really need to know. There are details from their stories that were revealed and not followed through on. There are intriguing details in this novel that hinted at more, that I thought would come back to be important, that were not. Again, I think it would have been too long. But the point here is that Leni, Emerson, and Jasper-- all three were so well built that I wanted to have a novel for each of them.

This story will go places you expect and don't expect at the same time. For example, at its most intense and escalating dread there is a moment of dark humor that is hilarious and awful. I definitely enjoyed that. There is dark humor throughout for sure, but it is well placed and droll and dry. It is subtle but when you notice-- laugh out loud funny. That is well done as well.

Paul Trembly-- horrible things happen, but there is heart here. Also is it real or supernatural? Up to the reader. Horror Movie or The Pallbearers Club are great readalikes here.

The Burn Line-- found family, anti-capitalism, demons.

Rivers Solomon in general and Model Home specifically is the best readalike here-- familial trauma and haunting. Is it real or not? Does it matter in terms of the horror? no.

I thought about The Library at Hellebore while reading this (Cassandra Khaw) except I cannot tell you why. On the surface they are very different stories. But the characters and their struggles and their trauma....all of that I thought about. How the system was set up to fail them, how they were victims, how they fought back but also how they were all not perfect people as well.
Profile Image for Sidney.
236 reviews203 followers
Want to Read
March 6, 2026
i don't care what it's about...just take my money!
Profile Image for Sara. (supergirled).
396 reviews28 followers
Want to Read
March 1, 2026
KLB can write about the horrors of waking up to find your phone didn't charge through the night and I'd be seated
Profile Image for jenny reads a lot.
840 reviews1,378 followers
they-told-me-to-read-it
July 26, 2026
Ready to make this my whole personality. Kylie Lee Baker is hilarious and knows how to write scary.

| IG | TikTok |

Thank you HTP for the gifted book. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for nika.ex.libris.
403 reviews48 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
September 16, 2026
No more horror books by Kylie Lee Baker for me....

I honestly don’t even know what to say, the plot of this book was so gross. I read the author’s last two horrors and they were also creepy and disgusting in their descriptions, but at least they were atmospheric—this book took the gross descriptions to a whole new level, though. Why did I keep reading her horror books? I have no idea. They’re short and fast reads, so I kept going hoping I might eventually like something. But nope! It was boring, terrifying, upsetting for the characters, and just straight-up disgusting.

If that’s your thing, you’ll probably love it. It has 3 POV chapters following characters who are barely surviving together in an apartment. Each of them has a dark, heavy past, but now they have each other—and no matter how dark their thoughts are, they’re all in the same boat.
Profile Image for makilah.
83 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 7, 2026
3.5⭐️

I was really excited when I heard Kylie Lee Baker was coming out with another horror novel so soon. I really enjoyed Bat Eater, and Japanese Gothic was one of my favorite reads of last year, so I was immediately interested in this one. The premise of this one really caught my attention: three roommates struggling to survive in New York City post-COVID are haunted by a demon named Sychar, who demands a sacrifice within seven days, or he’ll tear off their skin.

One thing I absolutely love about KLB’s horror novels is how descriptive they are. There are moments in this book that go beyond creepy or unsettling and become genuinely disturbing. A few scenes had me thinking about how terrifying it would be to watch if this were ever made into a movie. I also really liked how Baker intertwines paranormal horror with more mundane, everyday horrors. The characters aren’t just dealing with a literal demon. They’re also struggling with poverty, horrible bosses, an awful landlord, and the general stress of trying to survive in an expensive city. That combination really made the supernatural elements feel even more oppressive.

I think my rating would have been higher if I had connected more with the characters. The three roommates are shown to be incredibly devoted to one another, to a pretty concerning degree (iykyk), but I never fully understood why. Beyond all three being in desperate situations and being attracted to one another, I didn’t quite buy why they were willing to go to such extreme lengths for each other. I guess you could say it was trauma bonding? Maybe it would have been more impactful if they had actually confided in each other at all. All three characters also deal with a lot of self-loathing, which made the reading experience feel pretty bleak at times. The constant miscommunication between them was also frustrating.

I was also a little let down by the ending. The confrontations between the characters and their more human “demons” felt pretty underwhelming to me, especially Leni’s confrontation with her sort-of nemesis, Felicity Sun. I also couldn’t help thinking of R. F. Kuang when reading Felicity, although I have no idea if that was intentional. I was pretty let down by the eventual reveal involving Sychar, but it did make for a funny "are you kidding me?!" kind of moment.

I still enjoyed Hell to Pay overall, though I think I enjoyed the first half much more than the rest of the book. It made for a great spooky season read, though, and I’m definitely looking forward to whatever KLB writes next.

Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Megan Magee.
1,060 reviews5 followers
August 11, 2026
One thing I love about a KLB book is her ability to stick and move. Despite the fact that some might be deterred by this one not being "like" her usual, I found this one very much a trademark of this author with how much I enjoyed her savvy candor in writing alone. Descriptive horror and sadness embodies itself into the most beautiful words while we learn about three roomies in New York who are struggling past rent spikes and COVID blindness. While vastly nowhere near the same as her prior works, again, I loved this one, the way the characters worked themselves out of situations, and how darkly funny it was. Thank you to Harlequin Trade Publishing for the eARC.
Profile Image for Ashley.
742 reviews3,088 followers
Review of advance copy
November 7, 2026
Unfortunately this one was a hard pass for me. I don't usually get queasy but there were so many parts I had to skim through because I couldn't stomach it.

So far I have really enjoyed everything I have read by Kylie but this one just isn't for me.
Profile Image for B (mostly-offline).
813 reviews950 followers
not-released-yet-tbr
June 15, 2026
15/6/26: this sounds so interesting!! can't wait 👀
Profile Image for Megan Middlebrooks.
196 reviews23 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 28, 2026
4.5
Things I liked:
-I really liked our main characters. They each felt unique, had their own traumas that they were trying and failing to deal with. I also liked the group dynamic though it was not exactly...healthy. The side characters felt like they had enough development as well to feel like to feel real.
-The horror elements also worked for me. There was a good mix of supernatural/magical realism horror mixed with real life horror, like bad bosses and debilitating medical issues.
-I thought that the tension and pacing were really good because it kept me wanting to turn the page and read the next chapter. I read this book very quickly because I kept wanting to know what was going to happen next.

Things I didn't like:
-From the blurb, I thought the demon would play a more prevalent role in the book but it was more of a backseat plot driver than an active participant. I don't think this is the book's fault as it was probably more of a marketing issue.
-I wasn't sure how I felt about the ending. Some things were unresolved/unexplained and I don't know what I think about the last decision the group makes. On one hand, it was cathartic but on the other hand, it felt a little in conflict with the previous scenes.
Profile Image for Gretal.
1,215 reviews93 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 8, 2026
Quite possibly my new favorite Kylie Lee Baker book! It's hard to say because it's been quite awhile since I read Bat Eater, but what I do know for a fact is that this was a much more enjoyable book to read. It was also incredibly romantic, which I hadn't expected at all, but absolutely loved. Leni and Jasper and Emerson are just really great, and I was rooting for them the entire time.

All that gushing said, I do have to mention that I felt like there were a few inconsistencies that I'm not sure were intentional, and while they didn't really bring my enjoyment of the book down, they did stop and give me pause, mainly when it came to the precautions Jasper and Leni were said to be taking re: COVID and to help keep Emerson safe. This was an ARC though, so things might change ahead of the finished edition.

All in all, highly recommend this! I love what Kylie Lee Baker is doing in horror, and I can't wait to read what she writes next.
Profile Image for litch! (cryptidcasanova).
55 reviews3 followers
September 10, 2026
Review courtesy of an ARC provided by Edelweiss.

Whatever you’re expecting from the third major Kylie Lee Baker release, it is almost certainly not this.

In a similar vein to Cora, this novel is set in a post-COVID New York City, where we are introduced to our three major characters: Emerson, Jasper, and Leni. The trio shares a too-small, highly dysfunctional apartment managed by a neglectful slumlord who never misses an opportunity to rip them off and raise the rent. Despite being down on their luck and offering highly depressive individual perspectives as they navigate the racist landscape of the city outside, the love they share between them is magnetic and sets up a unique and exciting polyamorous love triangle.

Each character is fighting an emotional battle fraught with past traumas, mental and physical illness, career nosedives, and a general lack of purpose in a world that seems determined to keep them each pinned down by the neck without egress. This novel was a quick read, but because of this, the tone was consistently bleak - almost absurdly so, at times. I adore “unlikable” main characters in the horror genre especially, and still found the level of whinging in this a little difficult to care for.

That said, this is a story about learning to live with your demons, literal and figurative, so I appreciate Baker’s balls-to-the-wall bloodbath approach now that I’ve properly digested (iykyk) it! Hell to Pay is gory, kind of super insane, and pretty sexy. While it isn’t my favorite, it does deserves its flowers.

(And there’s a recurring bit about severed hands and fingers that I cannot get out of my head.)

Thank you to Hanover Square Press and the kind folks at Edelweiss for the opportunity to review this heavily anticipated release early.
Profile Image for Mary Wirth.
102 reviews1 follower
Want to Read
June 10, 2026
I cannot WAIT to read this!! I can honestly say Bat Eater and Japanese Gothic are two of my favorite books I've ever read!
Profile Image for Siara.
149 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 3, 2026
2.5⭐️

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the advance reader copy.

I have no idea what I just read.
I was leaning towards 3 stars for most of the book, but the clusterfuck of an ending ruined that.

So first off, Bat Eater and Japanese Gothic were both amazing and made this author an auto buy for me, but this one is such a drastic drop in quality that she might no longer be.

Bat Eater and Japanese Gothic both had great character development and intriguing fantasy elements driving the horror, but it seemed Hell to Pay was just gross with very little world building or anything noteworthy. The characters had some backstory and I think Jasper felt like he had the most intentional writing, but it felt like it was placed on the back burner in favour of miscommunication and whatever freaky shit these 3 had going on.

Side note: I feel we also need to reassess our definitions of morally grey, because there’s morally grey and then there’s whatever the hell is going down in this book.
Profile Image for Ashley.
352 reviews26 followers
November 15, 2026
I LOVED this!! Definitely not as much as I loved Bat Eater and Japanese Gothic, but this was still a very solid read for me. I'll be honest, all my favorite authors automatically receive one star before I even start a book, and Kylie has firmly been on "I'd read her grocery list" for a while now.

I know this states it's kind of a 'dark horror comedy', but it felt too dark and filled with too much trauma to even be funny. Like yes, it had its absurd and funny moments, but the comedy aspects of that didn't hit as everything about the story felt so sinister lmao I will say, compared to her other works that yes it definitely leans more funny.

The only thing that held me back from full five stars is that the pace was a tiny bit too slow for me. It took almost 50% for them to start communicating and working together about the demon issue. They spent too much time wallowing in self-pity and hatred in the first half. After that, it got genuinely insane. Like I could not guess where this was going.

ALSO, did not expect this to have some slight smut lmfaooo so take that as you will.

I do fear I can't really yap without giving spoilers, but this was the same magic Kylie always gives. Creepy and absolutely disgusting. I don't know how she comes up with her gore scenes but YUCK. Well written (of course) with complex and compelling characters.

Thank you to Harlequin and netgalley for the arc!!
Profile Image for Lucky.
114 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
October 1, 2026
Equal parts riveting and sickening, Hell to Pay has the bravery to (correctly) say that amid some truly bone-chilling supernatural circumstances, the real horror is having to afford rent.

The promise of unconscionable violence hovers Damocles-like above every scene, tightening the tension, heady and inescapable as gravity. The only thing I wanted more than to look away from the demons, the abuse, the remnants of their vicious pasts was to keep reading to see what happened next.

Leni, Emerson, and Jasper each have strong, individuated voices, and I never stopped rooting for all three of our leads, even and especially when they were tempted to violence. I was not anticipating the juicy romantic subplots or the marrow-deep yearning they stoked, but they stole my whole heart.

Kylie Lee Baker has once again proven herself a must-read author. If you are a fan of Asian American bisexual wrongs, of the stomach-twisting horrors of modern life, or if you really really hate your job or landlord— this is the book for you. I adored it.
Profile Image for Tiffany.
137 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
October 29, 2026
Thank you to Edelweiss and Hanover Square Press for the advance reader copy.

Hell to Pay is a strange and unsettling horror novel from Kylie Lee Baker that follows Leni, Emerson, and Jasper, three roommates living in a tiny, run-down apartment in the New York area. They’re already struggling to make ends meet when their landlord raises the rent to an unaffordable level. And to top it all off they have a demon problem. They have one week to find a sacrifice and appease the demon or else. But as the week progresses each of the roommates also has to deal with their own personal demons.

This story does get downright unhinged towards the end, but I was totally along for the ride. I was invested. This book is dripping with trauma, found family, and the horrors of capitalism. There’s a lot to chew on here. I do think readers who need all the answers by the end of a book might find some of the loose ends unsatisfying. I’m generally comfortable with ambiguity, but there were some major details that seemed to fall away unresolved that didn’t quite feel natural. That being said, I really enjoyed this one overall. Definitely check it if you’re a fan of weird horror. Looking forward to reading more from Kylie Lee Baker!
Profile Image for Kristen.
2,095 reviews41 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 5, 2026
Netgalley provided me a DRC of this title in exchange for an honest review.

I wonder what my face looked like while I read the last pages of this book because...uh...yeah. I mean...what the fuck? I had wondered, when reading reviews, what people could possibly be so riled up about and, well...okay. I get it.

Here's the thing, though...I didn't hate it. Was it completely f*#cked up? Yes. Did it feel a little out-of-left-field? Maybe. But people seem so mad about the whole demon-coming-in-seven-days storyline ending they way it did when, for me, the three MCs personal demons were WAY more interesting and creepy throughout the whole story. I cared more finding possible resolution/closure there than from the haunted apartment thing. Plus it's fast-paced and kept me reading.

I haven't read any of Baker's other stuff but she sure knows how to write absurd, holy-shit-what-did-I-just-read horror. Just...be forewarned about that ending because...yeesh.
Profile Image for Kara Taghon.
37 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 16, 2026
This book had turns I thought I could anticipate, but I was proven wrong. The winding traumas, cultural horrors and an ending that had my body and a 90 degree angle while I ran to the end. Paralyzing, haunting and greasy.
Profile Image for Georgia Meagher.
429 reviews45 followers
July 30, 2026
Thank to the publisher (netgalley and edelweiss) for an early review copy. I was (kind of?) on board until the last scene.

They have an orgy over a man’s dead body. I think I’m good on reading anything else by this author. Full review to come closer to pub date.

How do we get from Japanese gothic (a near perfect book) to this mess?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Brynx.
73 reviews
August 13, 2026
Bat Eater was my favorite book of 2025 and since then I have requested any and everything that Baker has written. While Bat Eater was a 5 star read for me and Japanese Gothic was a 4 star, Hell to Pay unfortunately ended up being 2 stars.

Hell to Pay follows roommates Leni, Emerson, and Jasper as they navigate poverty and a rent hike from their predatory landlord. But when their apartment is marked by a demon, they have to decide how far they will go to not only keep their apartment, but their lives.

The premise for this book is really cool and I loved the cover. The story is easy to follow along and I enjoyed the first portion. BUT the characters are insufferable. They are all “woe is me” for the entire book and the character’s morals did not match their actions. I love a romance in horror, but the final coming together of the three characters in the way/ place/ time that it does was just so cringey and did not make sense. You can read spoiler reviews to know exactly what I'm referring to. The Emerson/ finger situation seemed ludicrous. Quite a few plot points were doing way too much unnecessarily. I think this book needs to cook a bit more / flesh out the characters, motivations, and make sure morality is matching their decisions.

Thank you, Harlequin Trade Publishing, Harper Collins, and Netgalley, for the ARC E-book in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews