A dark, atmospheric YA fairy tale about two girls whose fates become intertwined when an old family curse comes to collect its due—perfect for fans of THE THIRTEENTH CHILD and A SORCERESS COMES TO CALL.
Every family buries secrets. This one buries bones.
Sixteen-year-old Briar Marlowe has lived her entire life sheltered away in a cliffside castle with her sisters, ailing father, and domineering mother. But after a stranger comes to call one day, she begins to notice unsettling details about her quaint life, and disturbing lapses in her memory. And then, she finds bones buried in the gardens.
In the village of Clove across the starlit sea, another girl named Lark grows up under the watchful eye of a strict father, and a caretaker who tells her forbidden tales of magic in the dark. But are they just stories, or is the truth even darker?
Unbeknownst to them, Briar and Lark's fates are connected, and their futures intertwined. For when one family secret is unburied, someone must pay the price.
Delve into a riveting, twisted tale of deceit and cursed magic in this intricately webbed tale about two girls seeking their own happy ending. But at what cost?
Amanda Linsmeier has been a book nerd as long as she can remember, and it was that great love of reading—especially R.L. Stine novels and fairytales—that eventually brought her to writing her own stories. In high school, she won the senior class vote for “Most Romantic Girl”, a title she’s still ridiculously pleased with. She feels most joyful when writing, scream-singing her favorite songs, playing in the water, and laughing with her beloved family. She lives in a magical place with a man who smells like maple syrup and woodsmoke, their wonderfully wild children, a dog, and an assortment of half-feral cats.
As the author, just a quick note before early copies of GARDEN GIRLS trickle out (which always comes sooner than I expect):
This is a book I'm incredibly proud of and one that was the most difficult to write-- not only technically (lots of twisty threads! my first dual POV which got tricky at times! etc etc), but emotionally. I've left a very tender authors letter inside its pages (please note-- there may be SPOILERS in the letter, so I suggest you save for after you read), and I dearly hope that you enjoy this story. Though it started with grief, in the end, it is a celebration of love and empowerment. The characters are some of my favorites I've ever written-- wild girls and thieves, liars and lovers, sisters and twisted family dynamics. I'm grateful for the gorgeous cover too (thank you Micaela Alcaino)!
(Content guidelines are noted in the book & more on my website amandalinsmeier.com)
Thank you so much for reading. I hope you love sinking into this dark fairytale of a book. And I hope you know how much it means to me to be able to share it.
Garden Girls was a very good, atmospheric read! Many thanks for the free eARC in exchange for an honest review!
What I liked: -This was a book to be savored! I was unsure about the sometimes detailed paragraphs, but in the end I think the art of it really fit the atmosphere of the story. -Once the story began to pick up, I was very invested! I thought the plot twists and turns were well-executed and clear to follow. The payoff was good and went a way I didn’t expect! -I lovedddd the unreliable narrator. I was theorizing about what was real and what wasn’t in the best of ways! -The ending tribute was incredibly touching and meaningful!
What I wanted more of: -I don’t think we ever got a clear explanation of the family curse and why there were so many gruesome deaths prior to the main events of the novel. Perhaps I missed something but was it all just a coincidence? I’d love a little more detail on this in the ending.
What could be improved: -I truthfully didn’t feel engaged in the story until chapter five. I just didn’t find the first four chapters exciting or interesting. I likely would have put the book down if I hadn’t been reviewing the eARC. -The blurb feels a bit misleading. Some of the parts being used to hook the reader are events that happen very late in the novel. -Much of the early dialogue feels stilted. There are many times where the dialogue is telling the reader the story, but it doesn’t feel like a natural conversation between characters.
Overall, this was a fun journey and I really think would be a delight for a re-read, knowing both the inspiration for the story and looking for the foreshadowing of all the endgame reveals!
thanks so much to macmillan/henry holt for the digital arc!
wow... i don't know exactly what i was expecting when i went into this book, but it hit so many notes. after reading the author's note, the story is nothing less than a stunning display on the importance of keeping memories for yourself while also learning to let go. while that message alongside the undertones of love is complex and sometimes complicated, especially when generational trauma comes into play, are very cliche teaching moments from fairy tales; however, linsmeier was able to craft it in such an intriguing way. each switch between briar and lark's chapters kept stoking the flame for the mystery/climax (i.e., when are these characters going to meet, how are they connected, what does this mean for the marlowe family curse, etc.). and once everything unravels, it doesn't feel so thrown together, instead perfectly paced that kept me on my toes.
i will say, i don't think the epilogue was necessary since the last chapter already felt like a fitting conclusion and ultimately felt redundant.
This is a young adult fairy tale novel and typically I’m very anti young adult because I feel like they are truly for young adult’s simply by the way they word things or the lack of depth; but this, this was so good. It kept me engaged and needing to know more. I enjoyed the characters and the atmosphere described within the book. It honestly was a full circle book of emotions. Simply stunning and really made me rethink my current disinterest in YA. I guess I’ll just be more choosy!
I received this from ebook from NetGalley in return for my honest review.
I do realize I’m hyping this up and yet only gave 4 stars; my only reason being is that I’m truly skeptic that most YA can be like this with how many I have read before.
Also, this platform won’t let me do 1/2 star ratings.
I loved the atmospheric gothic vibes of this book! The setting was beautifully described and was almost a character in itself. Mysterious family lives in a beautiful house along the cliff sides, that alone pulled me in. I enjoyed the relationships of the sisters and overall the complicated family dynamics presented. I will admit, I struggle with dual-narrative books, especially when it’s hard to distinguish between the voices. Lark and Briar have very similar stories and I kept asking myself, how are their stories connected and when are they going to start to come together? It takes a while to get there, but I do think the inevitable pay off is worth it. But it was a struggle to differentiate them along the way.
I was a little on the fence at first. It was described as two fairytales blending and I love a good fairytale retelling. There are a few nods I recognize from the classics, but it didn’t really feel like a retelling to me. And it’s dual POV. Chapters alternate which girl’s story we get. Not my favorite format, but it was easy to follow and worked really well this time.
The second half our ladies start really going through it, but also getting tougher. And that last 10-15% ?!?! Omg when it comes together, it really comes together in the most messed up but amazing way possible! When I was finally able to devote some time to reading, I devoured this in about 2 days and can’t wait to find more by this author!
If Amanda Linsmeier writes it… I will read it! Garden Girls is another riveting story created by that unique mind of Linsmeier. Two different lives. Two different girls. Somehow their tales will intertwine and connect. Memories that faded…slowly becoming fuzzy and unveiling. Another life feeling so worthless. Living in the shadows of their sister. One father holds love. The other hate. How could these two worlds possibly collide? What’s hidden in the garden? This story left me seeking answers. What was going to happen? Who would survive? The ending left me shocked and surprised, as the truth was carefully placed before me.
An absolutely stunning novel about magic, love, the family you know and the family you didn't realize you knew. There is a delicate balance between two timelines and two young girls, both touched with magic. Through each perspective the author begins to weave small threads of mystery and itrigue that cause you to question every word you have read so far. When the two timelines finally come together all of those threads pull together in a beautiful tapestry that captures all of the ways love and loss affects the characters. This was the first novel by Amanda Linsmeier I have read, but it will not be the last!
This was an interesting book, that you didn't find out at all how the two different main character arcs connected until about 90% of the way through, which was interesting. I felt like most of the book was just me trying to plow through it, for the sake of finishing it. I wasn't really really invested in any of the characters or what was happening. Different - concrete moments were fascinating to read - but not the book overall. I'm glad that I got an ARC via NetGalley for this book, as I would have been disappointed if I had to have paid for it. I really wanted to like it, the premise sounded fascinating, but it was just ok for me honestly.
Briar and Lark start off oblivious to how deeply their family histories are bound together, they quickly become intertwined when an ancient family curse resurfaces to collect its due. unburied secrets forces them both to confront the same dark legacy…. Both girls strive to claim their own freedom and peace only to discover that breaking a long-standing family curse will require a very steep sacrifice
Troupes/themes: gothic fairytale, generational curses, folk horror, hidden family secrets. Thank you to netgalley for this arc
Garden Girls has a gothic feel with more than a touch of magic. Two girls, Lark and Briar, are from different families and different villages, but their lives, we find, are profoundly intertwined. There’s a white castle on a hill, a family curse, an evil father, and a girl with a “gift.” And those are just a few hints of what you have waiting for you in the pages of this book. Sometimes the dual narratives can be a bit confusing, but the story itself is interesting and has more depth than I expected.
Thanks to NetGallery for the opportunity to read and review this book.
Frtc - just finished and I think this is 5 for me, or maybe something like 4.75. it was so, so good! I need time to process that ending - it shocked me, in the (amazing) way The Silent Patient did. Rating may change a little as I process and write the review tomorrow. We'll see. Highly recommend if you enjoy gothic YA fantasy.
Garden girls was a very interesting read. It took a minute to get going with the story. I don't normally read this genre, but the description sounded interesting. I was honestly surprised by the plot twist. I was waiting to see how the story came together. An interesting story about familial relationships and the things we'll do for love.