A riveting, in-the-room account of the pivotal six months in 1941 that turned the tide of World War II, as Churchill and Roosevelt forged a crucial alliance and Hitler squandered his early advantage—from the New York Times bestselling author of Road to Surrender
“A vital, compelling story told brilliantly and beautifully by a master of dramatic narrative . . . No one does minute-by-minute history better than Evan Thomas.”—Jon Meacham
In the summer of 1941, Winston Churchill was desperate—for two years, Britain had stood alone against Germany, heavily battered by the Blitz as another season of grinding war loomed. Franklin D. Roosevelt, the ally Churchill needed most, was coyly evading any commitment to join the war; Americans, FDR knew, weren't worried enough about the Axis to risk sending their sons overseas. Meanwhile for an arrogant Adolf Hitler, whose war machine had already swept across Europe and now looked poised any day to take Moscow, the continent seemed all but won.
By late December, though, Churchill would be lighting the White House Christmas tree with Roosevelt as an open ally, while in Berlin, basic supplies would be running out in an omen of the years to come. In the course of a few months, the war's direction was critically, permanently reversed—a result of crucial strategic calls made by the Allies, and of equally vital missteps by the Axis. Hitler's early advantage, once fumbled, would never be regained.
To bring these heart-pounding decisions to life, historian Evan Thomas vividly takes us into the war rooms of Roosevelt, Churchill, and Hitler. Placing us inside the span of a few months that would redefine the course of the war—as Churchill implores Roosevelt at a secret meeting in the Atlantic, as Hitler tries to parse German intelligence reports from D.C.—The Hour Strikes grants us intimate access to the men who would redefine a world.
Evan Thomas is the author of nine books: The Wise Men (with Walter Isaacson), The Man to See, The Very Best Men, Robert Kennedy, John Paul Jones, Sea of Thunder, The War Lovers, Ike’s Bluff, and Being Nixon. Thomas was a writer, correspondent, and editor for thirty-three years at Time and Newsweek, including ten years (1986–96) as Washington bureau chief at Newsweek, where, at the time of his retirement in 2010, he was editor at large. He wrote more than one hundred cover stories and in 1999 won a National Magazine Award. He wrote Newsweek’s fifty-thousand-word election specials in 1996, 2000, 2004 (winner of a National Magazine Award), and 2008. He has appeared on many TV and radio talk shows, including Meet the Press and The Colbert Report, and has been a guest on PBS’s Charlie Rose more than forty times. The author of dozens of book reviews for The New York Times and The Washington Post, Thomas has taught writing and journalism at Harvard and Princeton, where, from 2007 to 2014, he was Ferris Professor of Journalism.
In a genre which is heavily saturated, it is hard to find anything totally new in World War II nonfiction. This is especially true when the focus is on the leaders such as Churchill and FDR as well as the very murderous Stalin and Hitler (proof you don't need to be a good person to get books written about you!).
Imagine my surprise when I picked up Evan Thomas's The Hour Strikes and found it to be written in the present tense and character focused! What you end up with is a narrative that feels almost like a play, where the military maneuvers are beside the point and conversations drive the action. This plot is about very different people (with gigantic egos) playing off each other with ulterior, if not blatant, motives. Specifically, this looks at the time period right before the U.S. joins the war officially.
I also appreciate Thomas's willingness to call it like it is. I have read many books which either highlight unnecessarily or ignore the failings of their subjects. FDR and Churchill were not saints even if they were fighting against Satan on earth. It is okay to see them for the flawed human beings doing the best with the situation they found themselves in.
Thomas's last book, Road to Surrender, was full of revelations for me into the thought process of the Japanese government towards the end of the war. I wouldn't say this book is going to provide significant revelations as far as cold, hard facts are concerned. Instead, this is about the storytelling aspect and keeping the focus on the humans involved as they navigate what might be the end of their world.
(This book is provided as a review copy by Random House.)
Since graduating from college with a degree in Modern European History (focused on WW1 to WW2) I have read an untold number of books regarding the Second World War and visited many sites in person. Not until reading The Hour Strikes: Churchill, Roosevelt, and Hitler at the Hinge of History, 1941 by Evan and Oscie Thomas, did I imagine putting the stories and experiences of major war figures from summer 1941 until the attack at Pearl Harbor side by side.
To any avid reader of WW2 history there may be no new information. The experience is in the unique viewpoint presented. The Thomas' move between perspectives of Churchill, Roosevelt, Hitler, many of their primary advisers, and add in the Japanese plotting and executing the December 7, 1941 attack. It is riveting and noteworthy for the presentation.
The sources are copious and well detailed, a hallmark of any good history book. The notes will lead one astray, as they should.
Any history buff should add this to their reading list.
Thanks to Net Galley for the advance readers copy.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy of The Hour Strikes: Churchill, Roosevelt, and Hitler at the Hinge of History, 1941.
The Hour Strikes is a compelling examination of one of the most consequential years in modern history and the three leaders whose decisions helped determine the future of the world.
Rather than presenting 1941 as a distant sequence of military campaigns and political events, the authors take readers inside the offices, war rooms, and private lives of Winston Churchill, Franklin Roosevelt, and Adolf Hitler. We see history unfolding through decisions made under extraordinary pressure, often without knowing whether those choices would lead to victory, disaster, or something in between.
What fascinated me most was the contrast between the leadership of these three men. Churchill’s determination, Roosevelt’s political calculation, and Hitler’s growing confidence and destructive hubris each influenced the direction of the war. Examining their choices alongside one another reveals how personality, courage, ego, and judgment can shape events far beyond the walls of a government office.
The present-tense, moment-by-moment approach gives the book a sense of urgency, even when the outcome is already familiar. The extensive research and firsthand accounts also reveal personal details that make these historical figures feel more immediate and human. At times, the amount of detail slowed the narrative slightly, but it also demonstrated how thoroughly the authors reconstructed this pivotal year.
This book was a powerful reminder that history is not inevitable. It is shaped by people making difficult decisions while living through uncertain events, without the benefit of knowing how the story will end. That message feels especially meaningful today.
Thoroughly researched, engaging, and thought-provoking, The Hour Strikes brings new life and urgency to a familiar period of history. An excellent choice for readers interested in World War II, political leadership, and the decisions that changed the modern world.
An account of the six pivotal months in 1941 “when the directions of WWII completely turned around.” At this time Britain had stood alone against Hitler for two years and had endured the Blitz. FDR wanted to help Britain but due to American public aversion to sending men into war, he had made no firm commitment to helping Churchill. Meanwhile Hitler was marching toward Moscow and it was looking like a win for him.
In December 1941, as we all know, fate would change the war. But in this book, Evans takes us on a narrative journey by giving us a series of moments in time with Churchill, FDR, and Hitler in their strategizing and decision-making - often showing contrasting styles of leadership in the process. We are taken inside a crucial secret meeting between Churchill and FDR in the Atlantic where Churchill implores FDR for help. Meanwhile Hitler “tries to parse intelligence reports from DC.”
I liked the present-tense writing. It puts you “there” as a participant in this crucial period of the war. Hitler’s hubris as supplies were running out in Berlin and Barbarossa (code name for the Russian invasion) would soon fracture at Stalingrad is revealed - never taking advice from anyone. This contrasts with Churchill and FDR who took a more reasoned approach and sought counsel in decision-making. In applying this contrast to today it’s not unreasonable to see how a narcissist creates his own doom.
I also liked the section entitled “BLITZ(ED). While not a deep dive into how the German troops were doped up with methamphetamines, it gives insight into the German military strategy. For more detail on this the book “Blitzed: Drugs in the Third Reich” by Norman Ohler is a must read. In fact all the subheadings in the chapters are kind of fun for their revealing take on what happens in that section. The Epilogue is entitled “ What Kind of a People?” is an insightful analysis of the men who lead their nation and those who surrounded them. It’s Christmas Eve and Churchill speaks “of light against the dark” while Hitler ranted about nonsense.
I gave this book five stars for its reexamination of a pivotal moment in history with a look at how fighting for “the dignity and worth of every human being” is what real leaders do; for its clever structure in making history feel real and for being well researched and written. Kudos to the authors.
My thanks to NetGalley and Random House for granting me access to this ARC.
I was given an advanced copy of this book by NetGalley in return for my unbiased review and opinions. The book’s subtitle is Churchill, Roosevelt, and Hitler at the Hinge of History, 1941. I wanted to read it because I have always admired FDR. This was a significant time in his presidency.
Essential people in the book: Winston Churchill (WC): Prime Minister of Great Britain Franklin D Roosevelt (FDR): President of the United States Adolf Hitler: Fuhrer of German Third Reich Clementine Churchill: Winston’s wife Sarah Churchill: Winston’s daughter Pamela Digby Churchill: Wife of Winston’s son, Randolph Eleanor Roosevelt: Franklin’s wife Lt Gen Friedrich Von Boetticher: military attaché at the German Embassy in DC Col William Donovan: Intelligence adviser for FDR Joseph Goebbels: Hitler’s propaganda minister Gen Heinz Guderian: German panzer commander Lord Halifax (Edward Wood): British ambassador to the US Averell Harriman: US envoy to Britain for Lend-Lease Crown Princess Martha of Norway: FDR’s friend and confidante Joachim Von Ribbentrop: German foreign minister Henry Stimson: US Secretary of War Senator Burton Wheeler: Leading anti-interventionist and America Firster John Gilbert Winant (Gil): US ambassador to Britain Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto: Commander of the Japanese Fleet
WC and FDR: The two of them shared a common faith in democracy and a common bond of decency. FDR understood that his power came from the people.
It was very interesting to read the different managerial styles of the three leaders: Hitler: not someone who should ever have been such a leader. His confidence grew much more than it ever should have, and frequently over misunderstandings of what was going on. He definitely had destructive hubris. His arrogance and excessive pride blocked him from actually understanding situations. "He lived in a world of his own delusions, in which power and the will for power were all that really mattered."
Churchill: extreme determination! He would not let anything stand in his way if something was at all possible that he thought was necessary. He was a masterful communicator. He had unwavering courage and resilience. He had strategic vision and was decisive under pressure. Yet it was usually optimistic and enthusiastic.
Roosevelt: similar to Churchill, FDR was usually optimistic and enthusiastic. He was pragmatic, yet flexible. FDR would not let himself be pushed into decisions until he was ready to make them. This drove Churchill a little crazy at times. FDR had resilience and determination. He had excellent political acumen--he could manage complex political factions with strategic skill. Also like Churchill, FDR was an exceptional communicator.
Most of the next are quotations. I think they give you the tone and content of the book and are helpful for you to decide if you’d like to read it. I think it’s an important book.
Churchill and Roosevelt coveted power and wielded it freely. But they were joined by a human understanding essential to their political culture: power unchecked will always corrupt. Humility was hardly their defining trait, but they were each humbled by the ancient lessons that pride goeth before the fall, and that Narcissus died of self-love.
Eleanor gave Churchill a bit of knowing advice, born of experience: “You know, Winston, when Franklin says yes, yes, it doesn’t mean he agrees with you. It means he’s listening.”
Prime Minister Winston Churchill vowed, “We will never surrender.” Unfortunately, “the entire British Empire, lacked the manpower and the industrial strength to produce enough bullets and bombs, ships and planes, to defeat a European continent under Nazi rule.”
In the Battle of Britain, the RAF proved more than a match, and the Luftwaffe lacked the planes and firepower to break the spirit of the British people.
Summer and Fall, 1941: WC quote: “I cannot forecast to you the action of Russia. It is a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma: but perhaps there is a key. That key is Russian national interest”—Winston Churchill, speaking before Parliament (as First Lord of the Admiralty) after Germany and Russia signed a nonaggression pact in August 1939. “All in all, he (WC) is delighted by the prospect of Hitler and Stalin fighting like scorpions in a bottle.”
The PM explains to his young aide that he has “only one single purpose—the destruction of Hitler,” and that his life is “much simplified thereby.” WC: “We have but one aim and one single irrevocable purpose. We are resolved to destroy Hitler and every vestige of the Nazi regime. . . . Any man or state who fights on against Nazidom will have our aid. Any man or state who marches with Hitler is our foe. . .”
Churchill has a message for America, too: [Hitler’s] “invasion of Russia is no more than a prelude to an attempted invasion of the British Isles. . . .
“He wants the Reich—most of the Eurasian landmass—to become an autarky, a state that is self-sufficient and not dependent on an empire of far-flung colonies that can be cut off and blockaded. He knows he must have global military supremacy to exercise true domination over the rest of the world.”
Hitler spews that America is being despoiled by Jews and negroes. He scoffs, “What is America but millionaires, beauty queens, stupid [music] records, and Hollywood?”
“In strident speeches to the faithful," he says that "President Roosevelt is a lickspittle to a cabal of Jewish financiers." “A terrible flogging of Roosevelt,” Goebbels wrote in his diary in 1939
Hitler had been deathly afraid of the water since he almost drowned as a child
“The Japanese may not be Aryans, but Hitler appreciates their instinct for racial purity and their warrior tradition.” “Hitler sees Japan as a potential ally, not only against Russia but also against America and Britain in the final struggle for global dominance.”
After the American Congress declares war on Germany, Roosevelt invites Churchill: “Delighted to have you here at the White House.”
The perilous voyage to America is scheduled to take seven days zig-zagging through U-boat hunting grounds at twenty knots. The battleship carrying Churchill and his party is the Duke of York, the brand-new sister ship of the late Prince of Wales.
Churchill is in a puckish mood. When one of his military chiefs of staff warns him to be cautious about asking things from the Americans, his face lights up with a wicked leer. “Oh, that is the way we talked to her when we were wooing her,” he says. “Now that she is in the harem we talk to her quite differently.”
While on the way to Washington DC, in a long letter to Clementine, Churchill paraphrases the eighteenth-century writer Samuel Johnson: “Being in such a ship in such weather as this is like being in a prison, with the extra chance of being drowned.” Lord Beaverbrook jokes over dinner, which has few takers, that he has never traveled in such a large submarine. The weather is so bad that the Duke of York’s destroyer escorts, tossed about like bathtub toys, cannot keep up. The battleship presses on alone. In the dark storm-tossed night, the captain assures Churchill that the ship is more likely to ram a German U-boat than be sighted and sunk.
I have read many WWI books, watched lots of movies and documentaries, and have been privileged to travel to sites such as Normandy, Berlin (one of the most fascinating cities I've visited) and Dachau, among others. The Hour Strikes: Churchill, Roosevelt, and Hitler at the Hinge of History, 1941, is fascinating not just because it focuses on six months in 1941 that literally changed the path of the war from despair on the part of Britain for standing mostly alone against Adolf Hitler, to a long-awaited alliance with the United States after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, as well as Germany's foolish declaration of war against the U.S.
Evan Thomas, and his wife, Oscie Thomas, did a meticulous job researching and writing the account. I actually enjoyed reading the notes sections that followed the end of the narrative. What really stood out to me was how situations, conversations and actions are re-created in present tense, alternating between Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Hitler, along with their various loved ones, aides and military leaders. I, as a reader, felt like I was actually listening in on private conversations, and while much of what happened is well-known, I still learned a lot about the personalities of the people involved. Roosevelt, despite his debilitating paralysis after suffering from polio, was quite the ladies' man (although not to his wife, Eleanor). Churchill favored interesting one-piece garments, was stubborn but with a great charisma, and constantly pressured the U.S. to offer military support. But it was Hitler's personality and leadership style that were most eye-opening (and scary when you look at current times). Hitler made snap decisions and refused to listen to anyone who disagreed with him -- and he would blame his advisors when decisions did not go as he planned; he called those he disliked derogatory names (he referred to FDR as "the cripple"); he had a limited attention span: he went off on tangents and tirades, he wanted to re-name Berlin "Germania" and foresaw a "grandiose civilization" that would be "controlled by monumental party headquarters." Hopefully, we all learn from history.
This is a book that I highly recommend. Thanks to NetGalley, the authors, and Random House for the eARC and the opportunity to read this book. All opinions are my own.
My thanks to NetGalley and Random House for an advance copy of this work of popular history dealing with the months before the United State's entry into World War II, the maneuvers and schemes, plots, and failures, both diplomatically and militarily, that made these days the most uncertain of War.
I don't know what made me so interested in history, but I know it began with War. I am sure the first book I read was a book about the Doolittle Raid's on Tokyo during the Second World War, a book I checked up repeatedly from my middle school library. War was my entry point, and something, like most young boys, I enjoyed reading about. After my Grandmother died, my Grandfather became a huge reader, and he would pass on the books he would read to get through the day. One of these was a Barbara Tuchman, about the First World War. Thinking it was a war book I gave it a read, and was lost in the story. Of humans, trying to survive, politicians blinded by ambition, military men lost in the glory of their reputations. This book, think was when I truly began to like history. Events that lead to war, the little things that change history, a friendly relationship, listening to a valued aide, even lying to a fellow leader. These events are what Evan Thomas writes about so well, and this book showcases that skill. The Hour Strikes: Churchill, Roosevelt, and Hitler at the Hinge of History, 1941 by Evan Thomas and Oscie Thomas, is a story about the dark days of the war, when Germany seemed ascendant, when Britain was losing in all ways but spirit, with a hope that America, across the seas and enjoying their solitude, would join the fight.
The book covers the year of 1941, a dark time, with Germany moving through Europe, and the Japanese forces rattling sabers. Europe was occupied, England was alone, and America, well was happy being far away. Many in the States did not want war, the memory of the First World War still fresh in a country recovering from a Great Depression. Many people, some famous, some Senators, talked about America First, and America isolated. One man, Winston Churchill, Prime Minister of England, married to an American, a fan of America knew he needed the United States as an ally. For material, munitions, and even hopefully men. Plans were made, oceans were crossed, intelligence agents set loose, to make America an ally. One that the President of the United States, Franklin Roosevelt was not opposed to, but one he understood would be a difficult sell. Thomas covers the meetings, of daring trips across the Atlantic, the close affairs of English women and American diplomats, in more ways than one. The difficult line that Roosevelt tried to walk, along with Roosevelt's constant indecision. Until a military attack changed everything, followed by a very large German mistake.
I have enjoyed everything I have read by Evan Thomas. Thomas writes in the Afterword about being a popular history writer, and this is no slight. To write history is to write about different people, different times, different ways of thinking, and making them clear to people today. This can be impossible, as one can see when Generation X talks to Zoomers. Thomas really does a good job of conveying thoughts, actions and even more the reasons why. Thomas is really good at adding in things that don't seem important, but fill out why people act the way they do. The various affairs between Ambassadors and daughters-in-law of Prime Ministers. Harry Hopkins slowly dying of cancer, wondering why he couldn't be stronger to help his friend Roosevelt. Even the aides around Hitler, have little moments, that makes one understand why being in that cauldron must have been like.
The writing is quite good, and the book moves like a thriller. One knows the end result, Pearl Harbor and Hitler declaring war on the United States. However it is the way there, the plots, the schemes, the reason why certain people might dance after getting tragic news that makes this a story worth reading. Another fine book from Thomas, an author who I have come to look forward to reading.
This is a well documented, almost day by day revealing of the relationship between Roosevelt and Churchill leading up to the entrance of the United States into World War II. It also weaves in what Hitler was doing/thinking or not thinking during the same time span. A very good read.