What do you think?
Rate this book
Every Given Day
Inspired by true events, Christy Hall of Fame author Cathy Gohlke delivers a powerful new historical novel weaving together the discovery of insulin―a breakthrough that revolutionized modern medicine―and one woman’s brave fight to cling to her family and hope against unspeakable odds.
New York City, 1918. When schoolteacher Gwendolyn Armstrong learns of her sister’s worsening illness, she travels to Marion’s stately home to tutor her young niece and nephew, kept from school by the Spanish flu outbreak. Though the family lives in luxury, Gwen is wary of Marion’s sophisticated, often-absent husband, Russell, who once cast Gwen aside for her sister, leaving wounds that never fully healed.
As Marion’s health declines, a sense of foreboding settles over the family. Gwen observes strangers coming and going from Russell’s study at all hours, and her lingering distrust turns to suspicion that he is hiding something that could threaten the family’s safety and security. But when the deadly flu claims victims among the family and mansion staff, Gwen and her nephew, Alistair, are forced to accept terrible losses caused by the epidemic followed soon after by his own fatal diagnosis of juvenile diabetes.
When a compassionate doctor becomes both an advocate and friend, chasing down every promising medical development in the race for a cure, Gwen clings to each shred of hope. But as Russell’s clandestine dealings erupt into a shattering revelation, she must summon every ounce of courage she possesses. With Alistair’s life hanging in the balance, Gwen pleads for a faith she doesn’t yet possess, realizing she must surrender him to God and the possibility of a miracle that could save him and reshape her future in ways she never imagined.
Gripping, hope-filled Christian fiction with a dash of romance inspired by true events Perfect for book clubs and fans of historical women’s fiction by Lynn Austin, Rachel Fordham, and Jennifer Chiaverini Includes discussion questions and themes of family, forgiveness, and redemption
New York City, 1918. When schoolteacher Gwendolyn Armstrong learns of her sister’s worsening illness, she travels to Marion’s stately home to tutor her young niece and nephew, kept from school by the Spanish flu outbreak. Though the family lives in luxury, Gwen is wary of Marion’s sophisticated, often-absent husband, Russell, who once cast Gwen aside for her sister, leaving wounds that never fully healed.
As Marion’s health declines, a sense of foreboding settles over the family. Gwen observes strangers coming and going from Russell’s study at all hours, and her lingering distrust turns to suspicion that he is hiding something that could threaten the family’s safety and security. But when the deadly flu claims victims among the family and mansion staff, Gwen and her nephew, Alistair, are forced to accept terrible losses caused by the epidemic followed soon after by his own fatal diagnosis of juvenile diabetes.
When a compassionate doctor becomes both an advocate and friend, chasing down every promising medical development in the race for a cure, Gwen clings to each shred of hope. But as Russell’s clandestine dealings erupt into a shattering revelation, she must summon every ounce of courage she possesses. With Alistair’s life hanging in the balance, Gwen pleads for a faith she doesn’t yet possess, realizing she must surrender him to God and the possibility of a miracle that could save him and reshape her future in ways she never imagined.
Gripping, hope-filled Christian fiction with a dash of romance inspired by true events Perfect for book clubs and fans of historical women’s fiction by Lynn Austin, Rachel Fordham, and Jennifer Chiaverini Includes discussion questions and themes of family, forgiveness, and redemption
368 pages, Paperback
First published September 8, 2026
About the author
Cathy Gohlke
16 books1,429 followersBestselling, Christy Hall of Fame, and Carol and INSPY Award-winning author, Cathy Gohlke writes novels steeped with inspirational lessons, speaking of world and life events through the lens of history. She champions the battle against oppression, celebrating the freedom found only in Christ. Her critically acclaimed novels include Every Given Day, This Promised Land, Ladies of the Lake, A Hundred Crickets Singing, Night Bird Calling, The Medallion (Christy Award), Until We Find Home, Secrets She Kept (Christy Award; Carol Award; INSPY Award); Saving Amelie (INSPY AWARD); Band of Sisters; Promise Me This (listed by Library Journal as one of the Best Books of 2012); I Have Seen Him in the Watchfires (Christy Award, American Christian Fiction Writers Award and listed by Library Journal as one of the Best Books of 2008) and William Henry Is a Fine Name (Christy Award).
Cathy has worked as a school librarian, drama director, and director of children's and education ministries. When not traveling to historic sites for research, she and her husband, Dan, divide their time between Northern Virginia and the Jersey Shore, enjoying time with their children and grandchildren. Visit her website at www.cathygohlke.com and find her on Facebook at CathyGohlkeBooks. Follow her on BookBub.
Cathy has worked as a school librarian, drama director, and director of children's and education ministries. When not traveling to historic sites for research, she and her husband, Dan, divide their time between Northern Virginia and the Jersey Shore, enjoying time with their children and grandchildren. Visit her website at www.cathygohlke.com and find her on Facebook at CathyGohlkeBooks. Follow her on BookBub.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
September 8, 2026
This story resonated with me in so many ways!
I was caught up in a wonderful story about a teacher, Gwendolyn Armstrong, who came to the aid of her sister during the Spanish Flu outbreak in 1918. Gwendolyn strengthened her relationship with her niece and nephew by tutoring them when the schools were closed during the pandemic. It’s during this time in their home that Gwendolyn becomes suspicious of her brother-in-law’s secretive meetings, and before long, the Spanish Flu claims those close to home, and she realizes that she’s in too deep to let go.
Love in its many forms pushes Gwendowlyn to the edges of her abilities and causes her to develop faith in a higher power so that she can be brought through the experience and so that a cure can be found. I enjoyed the faith story, the romance, the theme of sacrifice and was caught up in an intriguing connection between the Spanish Flu and Covid with the onset of Diabetes. I did not see the twist coming, but in hindsight, I shouldn't have been surprised.
Beautiful cover - just as I’d imagined Gwendolyn and Malcolm!
I was gifted his copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
I was caught up in a wonderful story about a teacher, Gwendolyn Armstrong, who came to the aid of her sister during the Spanish Flu outbreak in 1918. Gwendolyn strengthened her relationship with her niece and nephew by tutoring them when the schools were closed during the pandemic. It’s during this time in their home that Gwendolyn becomes suspicious of her brother-in-law’s secretive meetings, and before long, the Spanish Flu claims those close to home, and she realizes that she’s in too deep to let go.
Love in its many forms pushes Gwendowlyn to the edges of her abilities and causes her to develop faith in a higher power so that she can be brought through the experience and so that a cure can be found. I enjoyed the faith story, the romance, the theme of sacrifice and was caught up in an intriguing connection between the Spanish Flu and Covid with the onset of Diabetes. I did not see the twist coming, but in hindsight, I shouldn't have been surprised.
Beautiful cover - just as I’d imagined Gwendolyn and Malcolm!
I was gifted his copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4.7 stars (5/10 hearts). I haven't read anything else by Cathy Gohlke but I'm definitely seeking out her writing now, because this was so unexpected and so enjoyable! First of all, I loved the backdrop of the 1918 Spanish Flu and the emerging Roaring Twenties. The suspense of Russell's shadowy activities, mixed with the anxiety over first Alistair's diabetes after the flu, made for a gripping plot. Gwen, though occasionally aggravating (WHY WAS RUSSELL THE SLIGHTEST BIT ATTRACTIVE, WOMAN) was such a relatable character—her baggage and her feelings of worthlessness & uncertainty really spoke to me. As for the doctor, he was a later addition but an enjoyable one. I really appreciated the truths he shared—it's so unusual for a trad published book to have such a clear Gospel-sharing scene, in my experience! Some parts of the story felt a bit jerky, but that's more of a personal issue, I suspect; anyways, I enjoyed the Egyptology aspect, and as a Canadian, this reminded me of why Banting is one of our national heroes. Overall, this was a great read and one of my favourite trad published books this year!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
June 18, 2026
[ARC Review - digital copy from Tyndale Fiction & NetGalley]
Every Given Day completely surprised me. I knew I was picking up historical fiction, but I didn’t realize how deeply rooted it would be in real historical events like the Spanish flu pandemic, tuberculosis outbreaks, and the aftermath of World War I.
This book is filled with grief, loss, hope, faith, and healing. Every major character is carrying some form of pain, and watching them navigate their struggles felt incredibly real and emotional. Gwen, Allistair, Mrs. Barrie, and Malcolm all had journeys that were equally compelling, and I loved how each perspective added something meaningful to the story.
I liked that the author addressed difficult topics, illness, parenthood, childhood trauma, love, loss, and societal expectations, without making any of them feel rushed or overlooked.
I was also fascinated by the historical details surrounding Diabetes and the early development of insulin.
This was my first book by Cathy Gohlke, and it won’t be my last. Emotional, beautifully written, and full of hope even in its darkest moments, this is easily one of my favourite books of the year.
Every Given Day completely surprised me. I knew I was picking up historical fiction, but I didn’t realize how deeply rooted it would be in real historical events like the Spanish flu pandemic, tuberculosis outbreaks, and the aftermath of World War I.
This book is filled with grief, loss, hope, faith, and healing. Every major character is carrying some form of pain, and watching them navigate their struggles felt incredibly real and emotional. Gwen, Allistair, Mrs. Barrie, and Malcolm all had journeys that were equally compelling, and I loved how each perspective added something meaningful to the story.
I liked that the author addressed difficult topics, illness, parenthood, childhood trauma, love, loss, and societal expectations, without making any of them feel rushed or overlooked.
I was also fascinated by the historical details surrounding Diabetes and the early development of insulin.
This was my first book by Cathy Gohlke, and it won’t be my last. Emotional, beautifully written, and full of hope even in its darkest moments, this is easily one of my favourite books of the year.
September 10, 2026
Gohlke is an author I heard a lot about before I finally picked up one of her books, and now I’m hooked on her writing. This is the third book I’ve read by her in the last year, and every single one of them has been a five-star read for me.
As someone interested in medical topics, I was intrigued that this book is about the discovery of insulin. I loved following Gwen as she worked to be the very best aunt she could be to Alistair, and grieved with her as she struggled with one setback after another. This is quite the picture of the barely post-WWI America (the book actually starts before the end of the war), and getting to see things like the Spanish Flu and how that affected people was startling and sometimes horrifying. Then there’s the whole diabetes thing, which didn’t appear as early in the story as I thought it might, but it sure packed a punch when it did show up. I loved how Dr. McNeill loved fully and sacrificially, and did whatever he could to fight for Alistair—that was beautiful!
The faith element of the story was also done well. I loved watching Gwen slowly grow closer to the Lord, and I could identify with her struggles and questions she had as she faced what often felt impossible. Somehow, Gohlke pulled out beautiful biblical truths without being preachy—I admire an author who can do that!
If you’re looking for a book that will both delight and confront you, teach you some history while giving a solid story, this is quite possibly the book for you. It was quite the read, and made the perfect travel companion—it had depth and richness, and was also gripping enough that even when I’d normally be distracted with other things, its siren song had me making time for it wherever I could. Highly recommended!
I was given a complimentary copy of this book, and this is my honest opinion of it.
As someone interested in medical topics, I was intrigued that this book is about the discovery of insulin. I loved following Gwen as she worked to be the very best aunt she could be to Alistair, and grieved with her as she struggled with one setback after another. This is quite the picture of the barely post-WWI America (the book actually starts before the end of the war), and getting to see things like the Spanish Flu and how that affected people was startling and sometimes horrifying. Then there’s the whole diabetes thing, which didn’t appear as early in the story as I thought it might, but it sure packed a punch when it did show up. I loved how Dr. McNeill loved fully and sacrificially, and did whatever he could to fight for Alistair—that was beautiful!
The faith element of the story was also done well. I loved watching Gwen slowly grow closer to the Lord, and I could identify with her struggles and questions she had as she faced what often felt impossible. Somehow, Gohlke pulled out beautiful biblical truths without being preachy—I admire an author who can do that!
If you’re looking for a book that will both delight and confront you, teach you some history while giving a solid story, this is quite possibly the book for you. It was quite the read, and made the perfect travel companion—it had depth and richness, and was also gripping enough that even when I’d normally be distracted with other things, its siren song had me making time for it wherever I could. Highly recommended!
I was given a complimentary copy of this book, and this is my honest opinion of it.
September 10, 2026
📖Every Given Day
✍🏻Cathy Gohlke
🎉Published September 8, 2026
(I finished the book a couple weeks ago and then totally forgot to post my review by the pub date.)
Thank you to @netgalley and @tyndalehouse
for the advance copy of this ebook. I was gifted the book in exchange for my honest review.
This book is set in the early 1900s at the end of WWI, the Spanish flu outbreak, and into the 1920s. The main focus of the book is the discovery of insulin for type 1 diabetes.
At the start of the book we meet Gwendolyn Armstrong who is going to live with her sister, Marion, to take care of her children as her tuberculosis worsens. Gwen soon discovers strangers coming and going from the house at all hours. Her sister’s husband claims it is for his antiqueties business but Gwen questions if there is something more sinister going on. When the flu claims the lives of family members, Gwen is thrust into the role of sole caretaker of her nephew, Alister. When he is diagnosed with juvenile diabetes a fight for his life starts. Will a cure be found before the disease takes his life?
This story took me on an emotional rollercoaster. I felt love, sadness, grief, anger, fear, and joyful elation. As I read closer to the ending I just kept saying to myself, “This book better not break my heart.” I won’t tell you if it did or not. I want you to read it for yourself to find out.
Some things I loved about the book:
•While this is a fictional story there were real doctors and events woven into the story.
•The plan of salvation was clearly given several different times.
•The author so poignantly depicted the many emotions felt by the families of children with T1D.
•There was a touch of mystery
•The whole story was full of hope and trust in a God who can take care of us through all of life’s events.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Cathy has a talent for drawing me into her stories, almost like she’s invited me over for a cup of tea - for just me and her characters. As we sit and take in the story as she elegantly describes each character, each event, each place and plot.
There are many twists and turns, some I could predicted and many I could not. The grief, loss of all apparent hope, and the gentle reminder of God’s redemption and grace create a beautiful tapestry.
The history of the world at the time - prohibition, the Spanish flu pandemic, and the discovery of insulin for people with diabetes - all were thoroughly researched and made the story even more powerful.
I have received an advance copy of this book from Tyndale House Publishers and NetGalley. My review is my own opinion.
#everygivenday #netgalley #newrelease #whattoreadnext
There are many twists and turns, some I could predicted and many I could not. The grief, loss of all apparent hope, and the gentle reminder of God’s redemption and grace create a beautiful tapestry.
The history of the world at the time - prohibition, the Spanish flu pandemic, and the discovery of insulin for people with diabetes - all were thoroughly researched and made the story even more powerful.
I have received an advance copy of this book from Tyndale House Publishers and NetGalley. My review is my own opinion.
#everygivenday #netgalley #newrelease #whattoreadnext
June 15, 2026
This is the second book I have read by this author though the first one I read was a while ago so I would still consider her a new-to-me author. I went into reading book unsure if it would read slowly since it is historical but surprisingly it did not. I was interested in reading this because not only did it sound incredibly interesting but it is based on true events. The chapters varied between short and what I would say is medium in length. I was drawn in by the interactions between Gwen, her sister, her niece and her nephew. I loved how you could feel the love they had for each other. I also loved the housekeeper, Mrs. Barrie. However, I was not a fan of Russell. He was a well-written pompous self-centered jerk of a man. There are several parts of this novel where you may need a box of tissues by your side. It was such a great read. I highly recommend it to those who like not only historical books but ones that are based on true events.
I received a complimentary copy from the author. The opinions in this review are my own.
I received a complimentary copy from the author. The opinions in this review are my own.
September 10, 2026
5+ stars!
Completed: Sep. 9/26
Format: digital ARC from Net Galley & audiobook (Audible)
Narrator: Aimee Lily - stupendous job!
Challenge Prompt: BR’s “author I am thankful for”
Book #76 of 2026: (I have no spoilers in this review but I DO have lots and lots of words!)
I’m going to take the book nerd liberty of turning an author’s name into a verb! I’m not even apologetic because it’s a high compliment. Cathy Gohlke has OUT-GOHLKE’d herself with this novel!
I’ve read a number of her books and have always been blown away by how mesmerizing they are. I have always struggled to decide which one is my favorite; but, Every Given Day has decided it for me. 👑 🥇 🏆
I was swept away right off the bat-and stayed there-much to the chagrin of my To Do list. It lacked in a significant number of checkmarks. Oh, well! Tomorrow is another day. Usually I do lots of things while listening to a book but this one had me riveted.
Gwen answers her ill sister’s desperate plea to move to New York City and teach her two children. (Did I mention their father was her boyfriend before he was her sister’s husband? Awkward….) Yet, she takes on the task with joy and vigor. The housekeeper, Mrs Barrie is amazing. The sisters are able to heal the past. Marion asks Gwen to raise her kids as her own by marrying Russell - after tuberculosis takes her life.
Tragedy strikes with the loss of Gwen’s sister, and others, through the dreaded Spanish Flu. The resilient Gwen rises to the occasion and carries on through and past the mourning.
Home-once-in-a-VERY-blue-moon Russell (the father) is a character whom readers want to send to a really remote island far away. NO RETURNS! The author crafted a very suave, charismatic, yet completely appalling man. Not only does he seem nearly heartless, he also leaves the reader guessing. Is he a great businessman? Is he a crook? Where in the world does he go over and over? And who are the people he allows to make deliveries on a regular basis under the dark of night? How can work be more important than being a father?
Dr. Callahan is the very antithesis of Russell. He is an open, hardworking man of faith. He is also a man of honor, integrity, compassion, dedication, and loyalty.
Young Alistair, Gwen’s nephew, is a delight! When a terrifying diagnosis of juvenile diabetes is given, Alistair has his steadfast aunt, Mrs. Barrie, and Dr. Callahan to champion for him, despite the grim outlook and no cure or medication to help.
This novel has conflict, mystery, medical issues, the fascination of Egyptian artifacts, history, immense love, deep pain, a little romance, and the remarkable discovery of insulin.
There is also a beautiful ribbon of faith throughout this story. Gwen’s path to faith is wrought with doubt, questions, anger, disappointment, and pain. Alistair’s is one of surrender and trust. Mrs. Barrie and Dr. Callahan are faithful prayer warriors as well as good sprinklers of mustard seeds! They allow God to use them where He sees fit.
Toward the end of the book is a scene with Gwen and an incredibly unwell Alistair. She is reading Psalm 23 by his request. It is truly one of the most touching and meaningful scenes I’ve ever read in a novel. I was so moved. I had a lump in my throat and tears in my eyes. I felt ministered to. The title for the book falls neatly into place toward the conclusion.
What an absolute gem of a novel! Buy it, borrow it, look over someone’s shoulder!! READ. THIS. STORY.
NOTE: Though I had an advance digital copy, I was also able to listen to this book. I purchased the audiobook and began the day of release (yesterday!). The narrator, Aimee Lily, did a superb job in every way, including the Irish brogue of both Mrs. Barrie and Dr. Callahan.
* Huge thanks to Tyndale Fiction and Net Galley for a digital advance reader copy of this novel! My rating is my opinion and my review is in my own words.
Completed: Sep. 9/26
Format: digital ARC from Net Galley & audiobook (Audible)
Narrator: Aimee Lily - stupendous job!
Challenge Prompt: BR’s “author I am thankful for”
Book #76 of 2026: (I have no spoilers in this review but I DO have lots and lots of words!)
I’m going to take the book nerd liberty of turning an author’s name into a verb! I’m not even apologetic because it’s a high compliment. Cathy Gohlke has OUT-GOHLKE’d herself with this novel!
I’ve read a number of her books and have always been blown away by how mesmerizing they are. I have always struggled to decide which one is my favorite; but, Every Given Day has decided it for me. 👑 🥇 🏆
I was swept away right off the bat-and stayed there-much to the chagrin of my To Do list. It lacked in a significant number of checkmarks. Oh, well! Tomorrow is another day. Usually I do lots of things while listening to a book but this one had me riveted.
Gwen answers her ill sister’s desperate plea to move to New York City and teach her two children. (Did I mention their father was her boyfriend before he was her sister’s husband? Awkward….) Yet, she takes on the task with joy and vigor. The housekeeper, Mrs Barrie is amazing. The sisters are able to heal the past. Marion asks Gwen to raise her kids as her own by marrying Russell - after tuberculosis takes her life.
Tragedy strikes with the loss of Gwen’s sister, and others, through the dreaded Spanish Flu. The resilient Gwen rises to the occasion and carries on through and past the mourning.
Home-once-in-a-VERY-blue-moon Russell (the father) is a character whom readers want to send to a really remote island far away. NO RETURNS! The author crafted a very suave, charismatic, yet completely appalling man. Not only does he seem nearly heartless, he also leaves the reader guessing. Is he a great businessman? Is he a crook? Where in the world does he go over and over? And who are the people he allows to make deliveries on a regular basis under the dark of night? How can work be more important than being a father?
Dr. Callahan is the very antithesis of Russell. He is an open, hardworking man of faith. He is also a man of honor, integrity, compassion, dedication, and loyalty.
Young Alistair, Gwen’s nephew, is a delight! When a terrifying diagnosis of juvenile diabetes is given, Alistair has his steadfast aunt, Mrs. Barrie, and Dr. Callahan to champion for him, despite the grim outlook and no cure or medication to help.
This novel has conflict, mystery, medical issues, the fascination of Egyptian artifacts, history, immense love, deep pain, a little romance, and the remarkable discovery of insulin.
There is also a beautiful ribbon of faith throughout this story. Gwen’s path to faith is wrought with doubt, questions, anger, disappointment, and pain. Alistair’s is one of surrender and trust. Mrs. Barrie and Dr. Callahan are faithful prayer warriors as well as good sprinklers of mustard seeds! They allow God to use them where He sees fit.
Toward the end of the book is a scene with Gwen and an incredibly unwell Alistair. She is reading Psalm 23 by his request. It is truly one of the most touching and meaningful scenes I’ve ever read in a novel. I was so moved. I had a lump in my throat and tears in my eyes. I felt ministered to. The title for the book falls neatly into place toward the conclusion.
What an absolute gem of a novel! Buy it, borrow it, look over someone’s shoulder!! READ. THIS. STORY.
NOTE: Though I had an advance digital copy, I was also able to listen to this book. I purchased the audiobook and began the day of release (yesterday!). The narrator, Aimee Lily, did a superb job in every way, including the Irish brogue of both Mrs. Barrie and Dr. Callahan.
* Huge thanks to Tyndale Fiction and Net Galley for a digital advance reader copy of this novel! My rating is my opinion and my review is in my own words.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Gwen has spent her entire life taking care of others. First, her Mother who slowly and painfully died from Tuberculosis. That then left her to care for younger sister, Marion, who stole her boyfriend and ran from home to marry him, rather than helping care for their alcoholic Father.
It’s 1918 and the Spanish Flu is ravaging the country. Gwen recently buried her Father and is looking forward to living her own life. She’s been to college and is currently teaching school and loves it. A most unexpected letter arrives from the selfish sister she hasn’t seen in 12 long years. Marion is very ill, dealing with the same disease that killed their Mother: Tuberculosis. She begs Gwen to come help, to teach her children quarantined at home and restore their fractured relationship.
Leaving the life she’d waited so long for, in Paradox, PA was difficult but the opportunity to meet her niece and nephew and to reconnect with Marion, was too much to ignore. Gwen boards a train for NYC where trouble greets her or doesn’t…
Author, Cathy Gohlke, has crafted a layered plot with engaging, well designed characters. The early 20th century setting is haunting: post WWI instability, financial depression, Spanish Flu, medical therapies and discoveries, disparities between economic classes, women’s rights and so much more.
Architecture, art, clothing, jewelry, furnishings, news and communication are well integrated. If this story was turned into a movie or series, the set designer, prop designer and costume designer would have no trouble at all.
Issues of faith are expertly woven thru the narrative: God’s faithfulness regardless of our recognition and His redemptive power are themes. Additionally, the story revolves around themes of: family, forgiveness, coming alongside, love, trust, hope and acceptance.
A large portion of the book is devoted to medical care and research. I found it fascinating to read about the historical developments regarding Flu in pandemic circumstances and the implications for other seemingly unrelated diseases. Two different doctors represent competing philosophies and treatment courses for the same disease that devastate Gwen’s nephew who becomes a focal point for this historical novel.
Another plot line concerns the character, Russell. He’s Gwen’s teenage boyfriend, Marion’s husband, Father to the two children and a man with many secrets; an excellent but disturbing character. Uncovering his secrets adds understanding that’s not an excuse for his behavior that’s sure to aggravate most people.
At times, this book is difficult to read. I found the emotional elements to be quite encompassing and had me grabbing a tissue box. Gohlke created a world where readers can participate from inside the story and care about the characters; for sure, an immersive experience.
Highly recommended for those interested in Historical Fiction, Medical Fiction, Early 20th Century Fiction, Family Fiction, Women’s Fiction and well written, multi layered stories with strong characters📚
I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley e-ARC via Kindle with thanks to the publisher and author.
It’s 1918 and the Spanish Flu is ravaging the country. Gwen recently buried her Father and is looking forward to living her own life. She’s been to college and is currently teaching school and loves it. A most unexpected letter arrives from the selfish sister she hasn’t seen in 12 long years. Marion is very ill, dealing with the same disease that killed their Mother: Tuberculosis. She begs Gwen to come help, to teach her children quarantined at home and restore their fractured relationship.
Leaving the life she’d waited so long for, in Paradox, PA was difficult but the opportunity to meet her niece and nephew and to reconnect with Marion, was too much to ignore. Gwen boards a train for NYC where trouble greets her or doesn’t…
Author, Cathy Gohlke, has crafted a layered plot with engaging, well designed characters. The early 20th century setting is haunting: post WWI instability, financial depression, Spanish Flu, medical therapies and discoveries, disparities between economic classes, women’s rights and so much more.
Architecture, art, clothing, jewelry, furnishings, news and communication are well integrated. If this story was turned into a movie or series, the set designer, prop designer and costume designer would have no trouble at all.
Issues of faith are expertly woven thru the narrative: God’s faithfulness regardless of our recognition and His redemptive power are themes. Additionally, the story revolves around themes of: family, forgiveness, coming alongside, love, trust, hope and acceptance.
A large portion of the book is devoted to medical care and research. I found it fascinating to read about the historical developments regarding Flu in pandemic circumstances and the implications for other seemingly unrelated diseases. Two different doctors represent competing philosophies and treatment courses for the same disease that devastate Gwen’s nephew who becomes a focal point for this historical novel.
Another plot line concerns the character, Russell. He’s Gwen’s teenage boyfriend, Marion’s husband, Father to the two children and a man with many secrets; an excellent but disturbing character. Uncovering his secrets adds understanding that’s not an excuse for his behavior that’s sure to aggravate most people.
At times, this book is difficult to read. I found the emotional elements to be quite encompassing and had me grabbing a tissue box. Gohlke created a world where readers can participate from inside the story and care about the characters; for sure, an immersive experience.
Highly recommended for those interested in Historical Fiction, Medical Fiction, Early 20th Century Fiction, Family Fiction, Women’s Fiction and well written, multi layered stories with strong characters📚
I received a copy for review purposes. All opinions are honest and mine alone.
Read and Reviewed from a NetGalley e-ARC via Kindle with thanks to the publisher and author.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This book invites you to live inside history, to feel its fears and fragile hopes as if they were your own. Christy Hall of Fame author Cathy Gohlke weaves together the devastation of the 1918 influenza pandemic with one of the most life-altering medical breakthroughs of the modern age: the discovery of insulin.
Set during the Spanish flu, the story follows Gwendolyn Armstrong, a schoolteacher drawn into her sister’s increasingly fragile household. What begins as a practical journey—to tutor children kept home by illness—quickly becomes something far more complicated. The family’s outward wealth cannot mask the significant fractures within, particularly the lingering tension surrounding Gwen’s brother-in-law, Russell, whose past choices still echo painfully in her life.
Gohlke’s careful research is evident throughout. The historical backdrop presses in on every page. The flu’s relentless toll is rendered with sobering clarity, and the novel thoughtfully explores a lesser-known consequence: the apparent rise in juvenile diabetes cases following the epidemic. Against this backdrop, the race to discover insulin carries the weight it must have held at the time—a fragile, almost unimaginable hope that, in context, reads like a miracle unfolding in real time.
At the heart of the novel is loss—layered, compounding, and almost unbearable. Gwen emerges as a compelling center of gravity, a woman asked to hold together what grief threatens to unravel. She is not alone: a loyal housekeeper offers wisdom and strength, and a determined physician—personally invested in the fight for a cure—brings both urgency and compassion. A thread of romance appears, but remains secondary to the deeper emotional and spiritual currents at work.
Those currents run especially deep in Gwen’s interior life. Her questions of faith are neither simplistic nor neatly resolved. Instead, they unfold through suffering, through surrender, and through the costly work of trusting in something she cannot yet fully see. The redemptive arc offers light without denying the darkness that precedes it.
This is, undeniably, a somber story in places. One family endures more than its share of heartbreak, and the shadow of a dysfunctional patriarch seriously deepens the pain. And yet, the novel does not leave the reader there. The integration of faith—honest, searching, and ultimately hopeful—lifts the narrative, reminding us that even in seasons of profound loss, grace can take root.
For readers who appreciate richly detailed historical fiction with a strong spiritual dimension, this is a deeply satisfying and thought-provoking read—one that lingers, not just for its history, but for its quiet insistence that hope is never entirely extinguished.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."
Set during the Spanish flu, the story follows Gwendolyn Armstrong, a schoolteacher drawn into her sister’s increasingly fragile household. What begins as a practical journey—to tutor children kept home by illness—quickly becomes something far more complicated. The family’s outward wealth cannot mask the significant fractures within, particularly the lingering tension surrounding Gwen’s brother-in-law, Russell, whose past choices still echo painfully in her life.
Gohlke’s careful research is evident throughout. The historical backdrop presses in on every page. The flu’s relentless toll is rendered with sobering clarity, and the novel thoughtfully explores a lesser-known consequence: the apparent rise in juvenile diabetes cases following the epidemic. Against this backdrop, the race to discover insulin carries the weight it must have held at the time—a fragile, almost unimaginable hope that, in context, reads like a miracle unfolding in real time.
At the heart of the novel is loss—layered, compounding, and almost unbearable. Gwen emerges as a compelling center of gravity, a woman asked to hold together what grief threatens to unravel. She is not alone: a loyal housekeeper offers wisdom and strength, and a determined physician—personally invested in the fight for a cure—brings both urgency and compassion. A thread of romance appears, but remains secondary to the deeper emotional and spiritual currents at work.
Those currents run especially deep in Gwen’s interior life. Her questions of faith are neither simplistic nor neatly resolved. Instead, they unfold through suffering, through surrender, and through the costly work of trusting in something she cannot yet fully see. The redemptive arc offers light without denying the darkness that precedes it.
This is, undeniably, a somber story in places. One family endures more than its share of heartbreak, and the shadow of a dysfunctional patriarch seriously deepens the pain. And yet, the novel does not leave the reader there. The integration of faith—honest, searching, and ultimately hopeful—lifts the narrative, reminding us that even in seasons of profound loss, grace can take root.
For readers who appreciate richly detailed historical fiction with a strong spiritual dimension, this is a deeply satisfying and thought-provoking read—one that lingers, not just for its history, but for its quiet insistence that hope is never entirely extinguished.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own."
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
When I first saw this book available to read on Netgalley, I thought it looked pretty. Then I read the description which caused me to be interested in it. What I didn't expect was that I would be blown away and sucked into the story. It totally reads like I am watching a movie!
This book is in three parts. Each part, I feel, has a different feeling or subject matter. In the first part, we learn that the main character, Gwen, is a schoolteacher. She receives word from her sister Marion, whom she had not seen in several years, that she was sick. Marion wanted to know if she could help teach her children and help out with them while she was in the hospital getting treated. The one problem with this is that Gwen married Gwen's former beau Russell. She still had some hurt from that. However, she wanted to see the children and help out. This part focuses on settling in and being with her family as well as getting to know the household.
In the second part, the Spanish Flu begins. This was an incredibly sad part and I think that it captured a lot of the essence of the damage that was done from the outbreak. It was really well written. In this, we also start to learn more about a shady business that Gwen's brother-in-law is involved in. He is supposedly an antique dealer with ancient Egyptian items and more, but she thinks there is a lot more involved with it.
In the third part, a lot of it focuses on an illness that Gwen's nephew has that is leftover from the Spanish Flu (which happened to many people in that time). She does her best to receive the best treatment for him and help him out. She also forms a friendship with the Scottish doctor who has started helping out the doctor they had been seeing for the past few years.
Throughout this book, faith is weaved in and I absolutely loved it. It was really uplifting and showed how Gwen wrestled with her faith and what questions she has for those who have faith. I loved the conversations she has with different people throughout the story when trying to understand God. The faith especially shown from Alistair, her nephew, made me cry (and more than just a couple tears. . dripping in tears where I was sniffling a bunch and my husband thought something was wrong).
If you want a book that is not focused on romance, this one is a good one for that. It is focused on a woman loving her sister and sister's children. It is also about friendships formed. There is only a very slight bit of romance in it.
I very much enjoyed this book and can't stop thinking about how it was written and how lovely it was.
content: there is death in this book and mentions of children dying as well, there are lies and deceit, there is slight violence brought up (mainly overheard). There are illnesses mentioned as well as the way it can affect people
This book is in three parts. Each part, I feel, has a different feeling or subject matter. In the first part, we learn that the main character, Gwen, is a schoolteacher. She receives word from her sister Marion, whom she had not seen in several years, that she was sick. Marion wanted to know if she could help teach her children and help out with them while she was in the hospital getting treated. The one problem with this is that Gwen married Gwen's former beau Russell. She still had some hurt from that. However, she wanted to see the children and help out. This part focuses on settling in and being with her family as well as getting to know the household.
In the second part, the Spanish Flu begins. This was an incredibly sad part and I think that it captured a lot of the essence of the damage that was done from the outbreak. It was really well written. In this, we also start to learn more about a shady business that Gwen's brother-in-law is involved in. He is supposedly an antique dealer with ancient Egyptian items and more, but she thinks there is a lot more involved with it.
In the third part, a lot of it focuses on an illness that Gwen's nephew has that is leftover from the Spanish Flu (which happened to many people in that time). She does her best to receive the best treatment for him and help him out. She also forms a friendship with the Scottish doctor who has started helping out the doctor they had been seeing for the past few years.
Throughout this book, faith is weaved in and I absolutely loved it. It was really uplifting and showed how Gwen wrestled with her faith and what questions she has for those who have faith. I loved the conversations she has with different people throughout the story when trying to understand God. The faith especially shown from Alistair, her nephew, made me cry (and more than just a couple tears. . dripping in tears where I was sniffling a bunch and my husband thought something was wrong).
If you want a book that is not focused on romance, this one is a good one for that. It is focused on a woman loving her sister and sister's children. It is also about friendships formed. There is only a very slight bit of romance in it.
I very much enjoyed this book and can't stop thinking about how it was written and how lovely it was.
content: there is death in this book and mentions of children dying as well, there are lies and deceit, there is slight violence brought up (mainly overheard). There are illnesses mentioned as well as the way it can affect people
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Wow. I knew that Cathy Gohlke has always packed a punch in her books. They have always hit me hard with their topics and their messages. This latest release is no different.
Must start off with trigger alerts:
*dying mother
*Spanish flu plague and deaths
*abandonment
*child death
*grief
This book had many punches to the gut. But they were all needed to really capture the faith message that the author was pushing. What will it take to quit fighting God when He doesn't seem to be listening or caring about what you and your loved ones are going through? When will we accept that our trials do not make God less good and worthy to be trusted and loved?
You know...how many times do you hear people say
"Well I can't trust a God who let's babies die..."
"How can God be good when He lets this violence continue unchecked?"
"Why would I give my life to a God who might not answer my prayers the way I want Him to?"
These are the battles that our lead character Gwen goes through...and let me tell you. She will fight to the bitter end of the story.
I read a quote today that said, "how can you let God open doors for you, when you refuse to take your hand off the doorknobs?"
This. This is what this book drives home...
I was not prepared for the second half of the book. I can't talk about it or it will give it away. But it's even more intense then the "faux" climax in the middle.
Unlike many books, you don't meet the main guy until at least halfway through the book. A different take, but it wasn't bad.
There are three POVs--Gwen, the housekeeper, and the doctor--but mostly Gwen.
Finally--I had no idea there was the post Spanish Flu surge in the disease that's mentioned. I'm now going to learn more about that. And it's interesting because the author adds in her notes that it happened to her own family Post-Covid. and that it's also a little "surge" happening today.
I must give this story 5 stars. I truly wasn't 100% sure how it was going to end. But it was the perfect ending.
*Thank you to NetGAlley and the publisher for my ARC of this novel. All opinions are 100% my own.
Must start off with trigger alerts:
*dying mother
*Spanish flu plague and deaths
*abandonment
*child death
*grief
This book had many punches to the gut. But they were all needed to really capture the faith message that the author was pushing. What will it take to quit fighting God when He doesn't seem to be listening or caring about what you and your loved ones are going through? When will we accept that our trials do not make God less good and worthy to be trusted and loved?
You know...how many times do you hear people say
"Well I can't trust a God who let's babies die..."
"How can God be good when He lets this violence continue unchecked?"
"Why would I give my life to a God who might not answer my prayers the way I want Him to?"
These are the battles that our lead character Gwen goes through...and let me tell you. She will fight to the bitter end of the story.
I read a quote today that said, "how can you let God open doors for you, when you refuse to take your hand off the doorknobs?"
This. This is what this book drives home...
I was not prepared for the second half of the book. I can't talk about it or it will give it away. But it's even more intense then the "faux" climax in the middle.
Unlike many books, you don't meet the main guy until at least halfway through the book. A different take, but it wasn't bad.
There are three POVs--Gwen, the housekeeper, and the doctor--but mostly Gwen.
Finally--I had no idea there was the post Spanish Flu surge in the disease that's mentioned. I'm now going to learn more about that. And it's interesting because the author adds in her notes that it happened to her own family Post-Covid. and that it's also a little "surge" happening today.
I must give this story 5 stars. I truly wasn't 100% sure how it was going to end. But it was the perfect ending.
*Thank you to NetGAlley and the publisher for my ARC of this novel. All opinions are 100% my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke is a Christian historical fiction novel set during the 1918 Spanish influenza pandemic. The main character, Gwen, is a schoolteacher who travels to New York City when her sister asks her to tutor her children during one of the most devastating public health crises of the time.
One of the most fascinating aspects of this novel was reading about the Spanish flu outbreak through the lens of a modern reader who has experienced a more recent pandemic. The similarities were obvious: schools shutting down, people wearing masks, decreased staff, households relying on home deliveries instead of traditional shopping, etc. It drew me into the story quickly, and I was invested in what would happen to Gwen and her family.
This story focuses on character development. I especially enjoyed Gwen’s growing bond with her nephew, Alistair. Their relationship develops with patience and tenderness. It became one of the emotional highlights of the story. I also loved Gwen’s friendship with Mrs. Barrie, the family’s housekeeper.
Because Every Given Day is primarily a character-driven plot, the pacing was slower than I expected. After the first several chapters about the flu outbreak, the story slows down significantly. I wished for more engaging content.
This is a story about family (both biological and found), faith, and hope. While this novel is written for a Christian fiction audience, readers who enjoy early 20th-century historical fiction, especially stories exploring medicine and social change in history will find something to appreciate in its pages.
Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke is a Christian historical fiction novel set during the 1918 Spanish influenza pandemic. The main character, Gwen, is a schoolteacher who travels to New York City when her sister asks her to tutor her children during one of the most devastating public health crises of the time.
One of the most fascinating aspects of this novel was reading about the Spanish flu outbreak through the lens of a modern reader who has experienced a more recent pandemic. The similarities were obvious: schools shutting down, people wearing masks, decreased staff, households relying on home deliveries instead of traditional shopping, etc. It drew me into the story quickly, and I was invested in what would happen to Gwen and her family.
This story focuses on character development. I especially enjoyed Gwen’s growing bond with her nephew, Alistair. Their relationship develops with patience and tenderness. It became one of the emotional highlights of the story. I also loved Gwen’s friendship with Mrs. Barrie, the family’s housekeeper.
Because Every Given Day is primarily a character-driven plot, the pacing was slower than I expected. After the first several chapters about the flu outbreak, the story slows down significantly. I wished for more engaging content.
This is a story about family (both biological and found), faith, and hope. While this novel is written for a Christian fiction audience, readers who enjoy early 20th-century historical fiction, especially stories exploring medicine and social change in history will find something to appreciate in its pages.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke is a compelling and beautifully written story by a very talented author. Gohlke weaves together the devastating 1918 Spanish flu outbreak with one of the greatest life-saving medical discoveries in history—insulin. This outstanding work of historical and Christian fiction is filled with suspense, emotion, and hope, and it kept me reading until the very end.
Gwen, the main character, travels to New York to help care for her very sick sister and her two children during the flu outbreak. As illness, family secrets, and a suspicious brother-in-law create increasing concern, Gwen finds herself in several perilous situations. When her young nephew is diagnosed with juvenile diabetes, his diagnosis is essentially a death sentence in a time before insulin. Gwen clings to hope when a new doctor begins pursuing the latest medical breakthroughs in the treatment of diabetes. But will the discovery come soon enough to save her young nephew?
This story is filled with emotion, including heartbreak, anger, sadness, forgiveness, family, love, and the difficult lessons of learning to trust and let go when life is uncertain. I especially enjoyed how the historical events and medical discoveries were woven into the story, making the history feel both fascinating and personal.
Every Given Day is a well-written Christian historical fiction novel, but I think readers who also enjoy historical fiction—especially stories centered around medical breakthroughs—will find a lot to appreciate here. I highly recommend it!
Thank you to NetGalley and Tyndale House Publishers for providing me with an advance copy of this book.
Gwen, the main character, travels to New York to help care for her very sick sister and her two children during the flu outbreak. As illness, family secrets, and a suspicious brother-in-law create increasing concern, Gwen finds herself in several perilous situations. When her young nephew is diagnosed with juvenile diabetes, his diagnosis is essentially a death sentence in a time before insulin. Gwen clings to hope when a new doctor begins pursuing the latest medical breakthroughs in the treatment of diabetes. But will the discovery come soon enough to save her young nephew?
This story is filled with emotion, including heartbreak, anger, sadness, forgiveness, family, love, and the difficult lessons of learning to trust and let go when life is uncertain. I especially enjoyed how the historical events and medical discoveries were woven into the story, making the history feel both fascinating and personal.
Every Given Day is a well-written Christian historical fiction novel, but I think readers who also enjoy historical fiction—especially stories centered around medical breakthroughs—will find a lot to appreciate here. I highly recommend it!
Thank you to NetGalley and Tyndale House Publishers for providing me with an advance copy of this book.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Cathy Gohlke’s books always surprise me. Not because they aren’t exquisitely written or because she tackles topics most authors avoid, but because she creates suspense so organically that I’m suddenly on the edge of my seat, turning pages as fast as I can. EVERY GIVEN DAY delivers on all counts—a powerful historical novel set against the discovery of insulin, a medical breakthrough that changed the world, and one woman’s courageous fight to hold on to her family, her hope, and her faith against unimaginable odds.
The Story: In 1918 New York City, schoolteacher Gwendolyn Armstrong travels to her sister’s home to tutor her niece and nephew during the Spanish flu outbreak. As illness, family secrets, and a suspicious brother-in-law create mounting danger, Gwen finds herself caring for her nephew after he is diagnosed with juvenile diabetes. A compassionate doctor becomes both her ally and a potential love interest as he tirelessly pursues every promising treatment for the boy. As Gwen clings to hope, she must confront her fears, surrender what she cannot control, and learn to trust God for a miracle.
5 STARS BECAUSE Gohlke pours her heart and soul into every book, and that commitment to story, historical authenticity, believable characters, and unwavering faith makes EVERY GIVEN DAY another treasure. Learning about the torturous journey toward a treatment for juvenile diabetes was both illuminating and deeply moving. This one is firmly on my shortlist of top picks for 2026.
I received an ARC from the author for my honest review.
The Story: In 1918 New York City, schoolteacher Gwendolyn Armstrong travels to her sister’s home to tutor her niece and nephew during the Spanish flu outbreak. As illness, family secrets, and a suspicious brother-in-law create mounting danger, Gwen finds herself caring for her nephew after he is diagnosed with juvenile diabetes. A compassionate doctor becomes both her ally and a potential love interest as he tirelessly pursues every promising treatment for the boy. As Gwen clings to hope, she must confront her fears, surrender what she cannot control, and learn to trust God for a miracle.
5 STARS BECAUSE Gohlke pours her heart and soul into every book, and that commitment to story, historical authenticity, believable characters, and unwavering faith makes EVERY GIVEN DAY another treasure. Learning about the torturous journey toward a treatment for juvenile diabetes was both illuminating and deeply moving. This one is firmly on my shortlist of top picks for 2026.
I received an ARC from the author for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Gwen, a teacher, receives a letter from her sister, Marion, who lives in New York. Marion is suffering from tuberculosis and needs Gwen’s help tutoring her children at her house due to the epidemic that’s raging in New York. So Gwen quits her job and goes to Marion’s house but learns that she has left her house and is now staying in the sanatorium getting treatment. Gwen starts getting the children into a routine and wonders why Marion’s husband, Russell, is always away on business in Cairo, Egypt. Strange men are coming and going from his office and Gwen suspects that Russell is involved in something illegal.
A year later, Marion comes home and as time goes on, influenza is taking the lives of friends and loved ones. When things can’t get worse, Gwen is told that her nephew has juvenile diabetes, which is known as a death sentence because there has not been a medical breakthrough to control it. Gwen has little faith left but realizes she has to surrender her nephew to God.
This story is inspired by true events that weaves together the discovery of insulin. It is an incredible book that flows of faith, family, forgiveness, and redemption. We are reminded that He is the God of miracles and we must trust Him even when we have our doubts. This is my second book by Cathy Gohlke and I’m becoming more of a fan because of how her characters have such passion and depth. I’ll definitely be reading more of her books in the future.
A year later, Marion comes home and as time goes on, influenza is taking the lives of friends and loved ones. When things can’t get worse, Gwen is told that her nephew has juvenile diabetes, which is known as a death sentence because there has not been a medical breakthrough to control it. Gwen has little faith left but realizes she has to surrender her nephew to God.
This story is inspired by true events that weaves together the discovery of insulin. It is an incredible book that flows of faith, family, forgiveness, and redemption. We are reminded that He is the God of miracles and we must trust Him even when we have our doubts. This is my second book by Cathy Gohlke and I’m becoming more of a fan because of how her characters have such passion and depth. I’ll definitely be reading more of her books in the future.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Every Given Day is a Christian historical fiction novel by Cathy Gohlke. This is one of the best books I have read for some time. The story is so well written, it is easy to follow and enjoy. It is very evident that the author has done a lot of research to write this story to make it as realistic as possible. This story grabbed my attention at the very beginning, held it to the very end and left me wishing for more. Gwen gives up her teaching position, and the man that longs to be with her, to go to her sister’s aid. With her sister away for medical treatment, it is up to Gwen to teach her niece and nephew. With their father gone so much of the time, the family is left on their own with the mansion’s staff.
This is such a great story! I just love how strong and caring Gwen is with helping her sister and dealing with children she does not know. It’s enjoyable to read of how the children develop a relationship with her. I especially enjoyed the strength Alistair has to continue dealing with his illness and the strong faith he has. I appreciate his young character having such a strong understanding of the Bible and his belief in it.
This story touches on several life-threatening illnesses during the early 1900’s. Tuberculosis, the Spanish Flu and juvenile diabetes are delicately written about along with a lot of history with the development and early use of insulin is given.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book; this is my honest review.
This is such a great story! I just love how strong and caring Gwen is with helping her sister and dealing with children she does not know. It’s enjoyable to read of how the children develop a relationship with her. I especially enjoyed the strength Alistair has to continue dealing with his illness and the strong faith he has. I appreciate his young character having such a strong understanding of the Bible and his belief in it.
This story touches on several life-threatening illnesses during the early 1900’s. Tuberculosis, the Spanish Flu and juvenile diabetes are delicately written about along with a lot of history with the development and early use of insulin is given.
I voluntarily received a complimentary copy of this book; this is my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Every Given Day is another compelling novel by very talented storyteller Cathy Gohlke. Cathy’s novels always have very real characters facing challenging circumstances in a historical setting. The novel covers such historical events as the end of World War I, the Spanish Flu, tuberculosis, Prohibition, the craze over Egyptian artifacts, and the discovery of insulin for people with diabetes. The historical research the author did before writing her story is very evident. In the notes from the author at the end of the book Gohlke reveals her inspiration for writing this novel, as well as, some aspects of the story that were based on actual people or events.
Gwen is a dynamic character who is an advocate for her nephew who is diagnosed with diabetes during a time that sent fear into the lives and families of those contracting this disease with little hope of the future.
There is a strong faith element in this novel. The faith of Alistair, the young boy with diabetes, is very uplifting. His conversation with his Aunt Gwen on Psalm 23 is especially touching. The novel is a story of redemption, hope, and trust. I highly recommend this book. It will be an excellent book for discussion in book groups.
Thank you, Tyndale House, and NetGalley for an advanced e-copy for this book. The thoughts are my own.
Gwen is a dynamic character who is an advocate for her nephew who is diagnosed with diabetes during a time that sent fear into the lives and families of those contracting this disease with little hope of the future.
There is a strong faith element in this novel. The faith of Alistair, the young boy with diabetes, is very uplifting. His conversation with his Aunt Gwen on Psalm 23 is especially touching. The novel is a story of redemption, hope, and trust. I highly recommend this book. It will be an excellent book for discussion in book groups.
Thank you, Tyndale House, and NetGalley for an advanced e-copy for this book. The thoughts are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I always love reading a book by talented author Cathy Gohlke, because I know I’m going to be in for a great, inspirational story steeped in history. Set in New York during the end of World War I in 1918 and amid the Spanish flu epidemic, Every Given Day stars schoolteacher Gwendolyn Armstrong who rushes to her ill sister’s home in New York to tutor her niece and nephew. When members of the family and staff pass away from the flu, Gwen takes over the care of her nephew Alistair who has contracted juvenile diabetes, which was always fatal at that time.
Dr. Malcolm McNeill has been keeping up with research on diabetes treatment and steps in as a friend and advocate for Alistair and Gwen. Hoping for a cure before it’s too late for Alistair, Malcolm works tirelessly to get him in new drug trials.
Beautifully written and carefully researched, this story is both a captivating story and a fascinating history lesson. It’s a wonderful example of why I enjoy reading historical fiction. I love learning about little slices of history while reading an absorbing story. The addition of inspirational faith elements to the tale deepened my enjoyment. I recommend this book and author to those who enjoy well-written historical fiction that leaves a lasting impression.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
Dr. Malcolm McNeill has been keeping up with research on diabetes treatment and steps in as a friend and advocate for Alistair and Gwen. Hoping for a cure before it’s too late for Alistair, Malcolm works tirelessly to get him in new drug trials.
Beautifully written and carefully researched, this story is both a captivating story and a fascinating history lesson. It’s a wonderful example of why I enjoy reading historical fiction. I love learning about little slices of history while reading an absorbing story. The addition of inspirational faith elements to the tale deepened my enjoyment. I recommend this book and author to those who enjoy well-written historical fiction that leaves a lasting impression.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
This review by librarian Christine Barth was first published in the July 2026 issue of Library Journal.
At first glance, this novel seems like a typical Progressive Era story in which Gwendolyn Armstrong has spent her whole life suppressing her own desires to care for her family, including her ailing sister, who happens to married to Russell, Gwendolyn's first love.
Russell's wealth appears unlimited, but abrasive characters visit in the night, raising Gwendolyn's suspicions. Gohlke (This Promised Land) shakes up the narrative with the influenza epidemic reaching its ugly claws past the mansion's quarantine.
Grieving many deaths, Gwendolyn's nephew Alistair changes before her eyes, becoming belligerent and ravenous. A driven doctor diagnoses him with juvenile diabetes, an immediate death sentence in an era before the mass production of insulin, but there is a sliver of hope in a controversial diet that pushes young patients to the brink of starvation.
Readers will alternately cry and cheer as Gwendolyn becomes a fierce medical advocate, racing against time, wrestling with her faith, and hoping against grim odds.
VERDICT: Gohlke brings history to life with urgent, vivid prose that will engage modern readers.
At first glance, this novel seems like a typical Progressive Era story in which Gwendolyn Armstrong has spent her whole life suppressing her own desires to care for her family, including her ailing sister, who happens to married to Russell, Gwendolyn's first love.
Russell's wealth appears unlimited, but abrasive characters visit in the night, raising Gwendolyn's suspicions. Gohlke (This Promised Land) shakes up the narrative with the influenza epidemic reaching its ugly claws past the mansion's quarantine.
Grieving many deaths, Gwendolyn's nephew Alistair changes before her eyes, becoming belligerent and ravenous. A driven doctor diagnoses him with juvenile diabetes, an immediate death sentence in an era before the mass production of insulin, but there is a sliver of hope in a controversial diet that pushes young patients to the brink of starvation.
Readers will alternately cry and cheer as Gwendolyn becomes a fierce medical advocate, racing against time, wrestling with her faith, and hoping against grim odds.
VERDICT: Gohlke brings history to life with urgent, vivid prose that will engage modern readers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke shows a unknown story of the affects of diabetes on a young boy before the introduction of insulin. The plot does take a winding path to get to this aspect. Gohlke spends time setting up the family situation and how the Spanish flu affects their family before getting to this aspect of the plot. I love the mystery element with the husband, Russell. It was interesting and kept me guessing what was really going on. As for the romance, there really isn't much. At the end, there is a happily-ever-after moment, but the entire plot does not focus on this budding romance, which I liked. Gwen, the heroine, is a strong, fiesty woman who is not afraid to stand up to her brother-in-law as he deals with his own issues. I like her fierceness of fighting for Allistair's life. Even when others told her to stop. Overall, Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke has a strong heroine, which Allstair needs, and a plot that shows a the history of insulin and diabetes with a mystery. I liked the well-crafted story, and the ending made me smile.
I received a complimentary copy of Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke from Tyndale Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
I received a complimentary copy of Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke from Tyndale Publishing, but the opinions stated are all my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This was an interesting read about the discovery of insulin and the Spanish flu of 1918.
I don’t even know how to summarize this story as there were so many moving parts. It’s a story about family – strained relationships and the ability to forgive. It’s also set in New York City against the backdrop of prohibition, smuggling, and the discovery of insulin. It moves between New York and Toronto. It’s heartbreaking, difficult, and shocking.
There’s quite a large cast of characters for each part of the story (which is divided into Part One and Part Two). I didn’t like many of the characters – even Gwen at times. She made some silly decisions even though she knew she shouldn’t have.
As always, there was rich detail in setting and events. I could almost picture the seaside town where Gwen takes her nephew at one point in the story.
If you love immersive historical novels, put this one on your list.
I received a copy from the publisher through Net Galley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
“My flesh and my heart faileth: but God is the strength of my heart, and my portion forever.” Psalm 73
As the country says “goodbye” to the Great War and “hello” to the roaring 20s, cultural and technological advances sweep in for the benefit of those who can survive long to enough to enjoy them. This compelling story kept me on the edge of my seat, lost in the narrative as I learned things from that time in history that I never knew before. Having grown up in Massachusetts, and now living in the Rochester, NY area, many familiar places were referenced in the book, which was an added layer of interest for me. A well-written cast of characters and an unpredictable ending made for an unforgettable trip to the past that has far-reaching consequences for the present and future. Most importantly, hope and faith are forefront, no matter how dark things seem. This author is now on my must-read list!
*I received a complimentary copy of this e-book from the publisher through NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
As the country says “goodbye” to the Great War and “hello” to the roaring 20s, cultural and technological advances sweep in for the benefit of those who can survive long to enough to enjoy them. This compelling story kept me on the edge of my seat, lost in the narrative as I learned things from that time in history that I never knew before. Having grown up in Massachusetts, and now living in the Rochester, NY area, many familiar places were referenced in the book, which was an added layer of interest for me. A well-written cast of characters and an unpredictable ending made for an unforgettable trip to the past that has far-reaching consequences for the present and future. Most importantly, hope and faith are forefront, no matter how dark things seem. This author is now on my must-read list!
*I received a complimentary copy of this e-book from the publisher through NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
4.5 ⭐ rounded to 5
Top-notch Historical Novel
Every Given Day was the first book I've read by Cathy Gohlke, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it. The characters and their story sucked me in, and even though the plot point concerning diabetes doesn't come until around the halfway mark, Gohlke does a phenomenal job developing the characters and setting: a very detailed and important backdrop for the rest of the story. I enjoyed how tastefully she wove the faith elements into the story--they felt real, not forced, preachy, or fake. I took my rating down half a star only because I would have liked to have a few more details at the ending--it was good objectively, but being the sap I am, I wish she had lengthened the ending with just one last bit more of her lovely character development. All in all, it was a great read. I look forward to what I'll learn from the next Cathy Gohlke novel.
*I received an ARC of this book from the publisher via Netgalley. The opinions expressed above are completely my own.
Top-notch Historical Novel
Every Given Day was the first book I've read by Cathy Gohlke, and I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it. The characters and their story sucked me in, and even though the plot point concerning diabetes doesn't come until around the halfway mark, Gohlke does a phenomenal job developing the characters and setting: a very detailed and important backdrop for the rest of the story. I enjoyed how tastefully she wove the faith elements into the story--they felt real, not forced, preachy, or fake. I took my rating down half a star only because I would have liked to have a few more details at the ending--it was good objectively, but being the sap I am, I wish she had lengthened the ending with just one last bit more of her lovely character development. All in all, it was a great read. I look forward to what I'll learn from the next Cathy Gohlke novel.
*I received an ARC of this book from the publisher via Netgalley. The opinions expressed above are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Cathy Gohlke has written another wonderful novel with Every Given Day. This book is in two parts, and it's as if we're getting two stories about the Bennett family. I feel as if I truly know these characters. Some choose forgiveness, selflessness, and commitment to family. Others choose dishonesty, selfishness and status.
There are some heartbreaking times in the novel. Some characters learn to persevere while relying on God to see them through. One character leads another to a closer relationship with God, sharing how to trust and have His peace. It was so moving that I cried.
By the last few chapters my adrenaline was pumping, and I couldn't read fast enough! Characters' safety was in question, and a miracle was needed. I accepted that the story could end in a couple of different ways, and I had already been encouraged by one character's testimony, so I was willing to accept any outcome.
Every Given Day reminded what am amazing novelist Cathy Gohlke is, and I highly recommend this book.
There are some heartbreaking times in the novel. Some characters learn to persevere while relying on God to see them through. One character leads another to a closer relationship with God, sharing how to trust and have His peace. It was so moving that I cried.
By the last few chapters my adrenaline was pumping, and I couldn't read fast enough! Characters' safety was in question, and a miracle was needed. I accepted that the story could end in a couple of different ways, and I had already been encouraged by one character's testimony, so I was willing to accept any outcome.
Every Given Day reminded what am amazing novelist Cathy Gohlke is, and I highly recommend this book.
September 8, 2026
While Every Given Day is a work of fiction, it is built on a very real historical era, the time leading up to and following the discovery of insulin for the treatment of type 1 diabetes. The story also includes characters impacted by the Spanish flu and tuberculosis. The health challenges make for tension in the story, and in come cases grief. Other sources of tension that move readers are strained familial relationships and illegal behavior that puts everyone in the household at risk. Tension may not be great in real life, but it certainly makes for great reading. This story will give readers all the feels as some would say. The theme of perseverance and the gradual way in which key characters come to faith, and of course the journey to true love, will encourage readers and balance out the more disheartening elements.
I highly recommend Every Given Day and am very grateful to Tyndale House Publishers for providing me with a complimentary copy via NetGalley without obligation. All opinions expressed here are my own.
I highly recommend Every Given Day and am very grateful to Tyndale House Publishers for providing me with a complimentary copy via NetGalley without obligation. All opinions expressed here are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I think there is something so fascinating about the history of medicine. This is a field where we are still seeing constant breakthroughs and changes, so a look back at how illnesses were viewed and treated just over 100 years ago in 1918? Like I said, fascinating... and really what intrigued me most about this story. But it was also heartbreaking. This story at its core truly is a story about the unbelievable losses Gwen's family faces... only then for her nephew to receive a diagnosis of juvenile diabetes... a diagnosis that would have been a death sentence at that time. While the history of that drew me in, it was these characters who truly kept me captivated. Theirs was a story of loss, yes, but it was also a story that was filled with faith... and one that I thought was very beautifully done. If you love Christian historical fiction, this is one not to be missed!
**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.
**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This is a beautifully written Christian read, and I loved unwrapping it.
As the story begins the year is 1918, and we are still in the Great War, but the Spanish Flu is also rearing its ugly head.
We are given family, love and loss. A sister taking the boyfriend of another, and in the end it is as it should be.
There is a fascination with Egypt, and their antiquities, and this continues to the second generation.
A lot of loss happens here, with the flu, consumption, and then the wasting disease.
When you read the author's notes, you see how personal this story becomes, and why you find her heart and soul in this book.
This is a read that made me want to read fast, but then I didn't want to get to the end to quickly, I need answers, but wanted to stay involved in this families lives!
I received this book through Net Galley and Tyndale House Publishers, and was not required to give a positive review.
As the story begins the year is 1918, and we are still in the Great War, but the Spanish Flu is also rearing its ugly head.
We are given family, love and loss. A sister taking the boyfriend of another, and in the end it is as it should be.
There is a fascination with Egypt, and their antiquities, and this continues to the second generation.
A lot of loss happens here, with the flu, consumption, and then the wasting disease.
When you read the author's notes, you see how personal this story becomes, and why you find her heart and soul in this book.
This is a read that made me want to read fast, but then I didn't want to get to the end to quickly, I need answers, but wanted to stay involved in this families lives!
I received this book through Net Galley and Tyndale House Publishers, and was not required to give a positive review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Every Given Day by Cathy Gohlke is one of the best Christian historical fiction novels I’ve read. The story is beautiful and engaging from the very first page. It is clear the author did extensive research to bring the early 1900s to life. I quickly became invested in Gwen as she leaves behind her teaching career and the man she loves to care for her sister’s children. Watching the relationships within the family grow was one of my favorite parts of the book. I also appreciated how thoughtfully the author handled difficult topics like tuberculosis, the Spanish flu, and juvenile diabetes, while weaving in the history of insulin. This was an emotional, faith-filled story that stayed with me long after I finished, and I highly recommend it. I received an advanced reader copy from #Netgalley. Thank you to the author and publisher!
Review of advance copy received from Author
1918-1923 New York City
Although not a suspense novel this one had me on pins and needles wondering how things were going to turn out.
Gwen leaves her job as a teacher in Pennsylvania to help her ill sister's family in New York City. Initially, Gwen has a difficult time finding allies in the home...the children resent her, the housekeeper thinks she's a traitor and her brother-in-law is not a good person. Despite all that, Gwen perseveres.
This novel includes details about the Spanish Flu, but even more so about diabetes. It was both fascinating and sad to learn the impact and treatment of diabetes at that time.
Another engaging author by the talented Cathy Gohlke. My gratitude to the author for a complimentary ARC of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Although not a suspense novel this one had me on pins and needles wondering how things were going to turn out.
Gwen leaves her job as a teacher in Pennsylvania to help her ill sister's family in New York City. Initially, Gwen has a difficult time finding allies in the home...the children resent her, the housekeeper thinks she's a traitor and her brother-in-law is not a good person. Despite all that, Gwen perseveres.
This novel includes details about the Spanish Flu, but even more so about diabetes. It was both fascinating and sad to learn the impact and treatment of diabetes at that time.
Another engaging author by the talented Cathy Gohlke. My gratitude to the author for a complimentary ARC of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews