What do you think?
Rate this book
The Weaver's Loom
Edith Ashton is the last of her kind. But the world thinks she’s dead.
1893 London. Witches live uneasily alongside humans after a treaty that stripped them of their immortality in exchange for living out in the open. In that aftermath, Death Witches were hunted down and eradicated.
All but one.
Edith hides in plain sight as an investigator with the First Council, solving murders with her magic. She can see a victim’s last moments of life. It’s a convenient gift. An inconspicuous one. And it keeps her true power a secret.
But when a witch’s death exposes the disappearance of five more, she is forced into a case that rips into her past. The trail leads to the Sparrows - a long-dormant order that wiped out every Death Witch in England - including Edith’s family.
As the full moon draws near, more witches vanish. When a witch she has sworn to protect is abducted, she won’t stay hidden any longer.
To stop them, Edith will have to unmask a magic she has spent decades burying.
And once the Sparrows know that a Death Witch still lives, they will finish what they started.
1893 London. Witches live uneasily alongside humans after a treaty that stripped them of their immortality in exchange for living out in the open. In that aftermath, Death Witches were hunted down and eradicated.
All but one.
Edith hides in plain sight as an investigator with the First Council, solving murders with her magic. She can see a victim’s last moments of life. It’s a convenient gift. An inconspicuous one. And it keeps her true power a secret.
But when a witch’s death exposes the disappearance of five more, she is forced into a case that rips into her past. The trail leads to the Sparrows - a long-dormant order that wiped out every Death Witch in England - including Edith’s family.
As the full moon draws near, more witches vanish. When a witch she has sworn to protect is abducted, she won’t stay hidden any longer.
To stop them, Edith will have to unmask a magic she has spent decades burying.
And once the Sparrows know that a Death Witch still lives, they will finish what they started.
378 pages, Kindle Edition
Published June 1, 2026
About the author
Jessi St. John
4 books60 followersJessi writes fantasy filled with dangerous magic, mythic worldbuilding, and complex women. Her stories range from gaslamp historical fantasy set among witches and foggy London streets to epic imagined worlds where prophecy and power reign.
She is drawn to antagonists who are neither right nor wrong and heroines who are strong in unique ways.
She is drawn to antagonists who are neither right nor wrong and heroines who are strong in unique ways.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 254 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
This review was originally published on Grimdark Magazine
3.75 stars
The Weaver’s Loom promised me witches, dark mystery, paranormal fantasy, rich Victorian atmosphere, and a sprinkle of slow-burn romance all brewed together in a gothic little cauldron, and that is exactly what Jessi St. John delivered. But then at the same time it was also not exactly what I expected and by the end I was sitting there utterly bewitched and mildly emotionally disoriented, just trying to figure out what exactly had just happened to me. Mostly in a good way, I think?
Now, the first chapter alone had me completely hooked with its addictive air of dark mystery and intrigue, and I think it perfectly set the ominous tone for the rest of the book. Edith Ashton immediately captured my heart as a protagonist, and I loved the high-stakes set-up of her being the last Death Witch hiding in plain sight while working as an investigator for the very people who would happily kill her if they knew the truth inst. Like, the stress alone should have killed her, and would have killed me honestly.
Every glimpse into her backstory made me love and respect her more, because she really proves herself to be such a force to be reckoned with while also being deeply soft-hearted, emotionally messy, vulnerable, morally gray, and honestly just kind of exhausted by life in a way that felt extremely relatable. I loved how she felt so powerful without ever coming across as untouchable, and her internal struggle surrounding her forbidden connection with Death and her journey of learning to embrace that part of herself was so powerful to me.
I do think Edith overshadows most of the other characters for me, but even so I really enjoyed the found family vibes, especially with Ben and Old Bess. And while I have to admit that I was expecting maybe a bit more from the romantic elements of The Weaver’s Loom, I can’t deny that the tension was absolutely agonizing in the best way. St. John really takes slow-burn to the next level, to the point that I almost found myself wondering who the romantic interest was even supposed to be at times. I was eating up the crumbs though, we live for the suffering.
The world of The Weaver’s Loom also just feels so rich and immersive, and I loved how Jessi St. John brought this alternative magical Victorian London setting to life through her atmospheric prose. Seeing the dynamic and tension between the witches, shifters, fairies and elves with all their ancient grudges was so captivating to me, and the way that the lore and (murder) mystery surrounding the vanishing witches was woven so expertly into both the complicated history between these races as well as the internal journeys of our main cast just had me in a complete chokehold.
I do have to admit that The Weaver’s Loom ended up being way more complex and grand in scope than I initially gave it credit for, which was both exciting and slightly concerning for me. On the one hand, I really enjoyed the unexpected multi-POV storytelling because it allowed this fascinating dark world and all its different magics and creatures to fully come to life through different perspectives. But then on the other hand, I can’t help feeling like it occasionally pulled focus away from the emotional core of the story a little too much, and sometimes it just felt like there was some connective tissue between scenes missing for me to believe in the development and escalation of stakes and relationships. By the end I found myself slightly less invested in certain characters than I wanted to be because, which made some emotional beats fall a bit flat for me.
Still, I honestly have to respect how much St. John managed to pack into this relatively tight novel, and the ending was so strong that I will absolutely be back for the next instalment in The Last Death Witch series when that drops. The Weaver’s Loom might not be perfect, but I think it is an impressively ambitious debut, and I would definitely recommend it if you are in the mood for a darkly addictive gothic paranormal fever dream adventure through a magical Victorian London.
Thank you to the author for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. The Weaver’s Loom is scheduled for release on June 1st 2026.
3.75 stars
The Weaver’s Loom promised me witches, dark mystery, paranormal fantasy, rich Victorian atmosphere, and a sprinkle of slow-burn romance all brewed together in a gothic little cauldron, and that is exactly what Jessi St. John delivered. But then at the same time it was also not exactly what I expected and by the end I was sitting there utterly bewitched and mildly emotionally disoriented, just trying to figure out what exactly had just happened to me. Mostly in a good way, I think?
Now, the first chapter alone had me completely hooked with its addictive air of dark mystery and intrigue, and I think it perfectly set the ominous tone for the rest of the book. Edith Ashton immediately captured my heart as a protagonist, and I loved the high-stakes set-up of her being the last Death Witch hiding in plain sight while working as an investigator for the very people who would happily kill her if they knew the truth inst. Like, the stress alone should have killed her, and would have killed me honestly.
Every glimpse into her backstory made me love and respect her more, because she really proves herself to be such a force to be reckoned with while also being deeply soft-hearted, emotionally messy, vulnerable, morally gray, and honestly just kind of exhausted by life in a way that felt extremely relatable. I loved how she felt so powerful without ever coming across as untouchable, and her internal struggle surrounding her forbidden connection with Death and her journey of learning to embrace that part of herself was so powerful to me.
I do think Edith overshadows most of the other characters for me, but even so I really enjoyed the found family vibes, especially with Ben and Old Bess. And while I have to admit that I was expecting maybe a bit more from the romantic elements of The Weaver’s Loom, I can’t deny that the tension was absolutely agonizing in the best way. St. John really takes slow-burn to the next level, to the point that I almost found myself wondering who the romantic interest was even supposed to be at times. I was eating up the crumbs though, we live for the suffering.
The world of The Weaver’s Loom also just feels so rich and immersive, and I loved how Jessi St. John brought this alternative magical Victorian London setting to life through her atmospheric prose. Seeing the dynamic and tension between the witches, shifters, fairies and elves with all their ancient grudges was so captivating to me, and the way that the lore and (murder) mystery surrounding the vanishing witches was woven so expertly into both the complicated history between these races as well as the internal journeys of our main cast just had me in a complete chokehold.
I do have to admit that The Weaver’s Loom ended up being way more complex and grand in scope than I initially gave it credit for, which was both exciting and slightly concerning for me. On the one hand, I really enjoyed the unexpected multi-POV storytelling because it allowed this fascinating dark world and all its different magics and creatures to fully come to life through different perspectives. But then on the other hand, I can’t help feeling like it occasionally pulled focus away from the emotional core of the story a little too much, and sometimes it just felt like there was some connective tissue between scenes missing for me to believe in the development and escalation of stakes and relationships. By the end I found myself slightly less invested in certain characters than I wanted to be because, which made some emotional beats fall a bit flat for me.
Still, I honestly have to respect how much St. John managed to pack into this relatively tight novel, and the ending was so strong that I will absolutely be back for the next instalment in The Last Death Witch series when that drops. The Weaver’s Loom might not be perfect, but I think it is an impressively ambitious debut, and I would definitely recommend it if you are in the mood for a darkly addictive gothic paranormal fever dream adventure through a magical Victorian London.
Thank you to the author for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own. The Weaver’s Loom is scheduled for release on June 1st 2026.
June 4, 2026
Omg what a storyline this is gonna be huge, the world-building and characters are so good and the character development is just perfect.
It’s definitely one of my top 10 books of the year so far, I can’t wait for the next one to arrive, this is a new book to read and it’s exceeded all my expectations, I wasn’t ready for this level of writing, and storytelling.
The author is a great writer to keep an eye on for future books, I definitely will be. I’ll also recommend him to read by everyone.
A definite five-star book for me and well done Jesse St for this wonderful book and I hope to arc for you again.
Thank you so very much.
It’s definitely one of my top 10 books of the year so far, I can’t wait for the next one to arrive, this is a new book to read and it’s exceeded all my expectations, I wasn’t ready for this level of writing, and storytelling.
The author is a great writer to keep an eye on for future books, I definitely will be. I’ll also recommend him to read by everyone.
A definite five-star book for me and well done Jesse St for this wonderful book and I hope to arc for you again.
Thank you so very much.
June 16, 2026
What a debut!
The Weaver’s Loom’s historical fantasy storyline gripped me from the beginning, from the tension in the mystery and murder, found family, magic system, and the journey of survival and self-empowerment.
The plot and multi-pov enthralled me. The writing is immersive, invoking a gothic atmospheric setting and somehow giving this cozy comfort feeling.
Edith Ashton, hides in plain sight as an investigator for First Council. It’s no fault of hers that she has to protect her truest self, especially after witches are going missing. She is determined, caring, and extremely intelligent. But once she unveils herself, she is a force!
The romance is the subplot, with the slowest slow burn. It is literally leaving me with uncertainty about who the actual love interest is. Although, I’ve already decided on what team I’m on😏🫣
4.5⭐️
As for the revelations, I did guess right a few times, but was still so intrigued through the end. I was left shook; a cliffhanger leaving the reader anxiously waiting for book 2.
I think this gave me a bit of “A Discovery of Witches” vibes which I absolutely love! This has suspense, a bit of folklore, and witch lore- I highly recommend!
Thank you to the author for the e-arc 🫶🏽🖤
The Weaver’s Loom’s historical fantasy storyline gripped me from the beginning, from the tension in the mystery and murder, found family, magic system, and the journey of survival and self-empowerment.
The plot and multi-pov enthralled me. The writing is immersive, invoking a gothic atmospheric setting and somehow giving this cozy comfort feeling.
Edith Ashton, hides in plain sight as an investigator for First Council. It’s no fault of hers that she has to protect her truest self, especially after witches are going missing. She is determined, caring, and extremely intelligent. But once she unveils herself, she is a force!
The romance is the subplot, with the slowest slow burn. It is literally leaving me with uncertainty about who the actual love interest is. Although, I’ve already decided on what team I’m on😏🫣
4.5⭐️
As for the revelations, I did guess right a few times, but was still so intrigued through the end. I was left shook; a cliffhanger leaving the reader anxiously waiting for book 2.
I think this gave me a bit of “A Discovery of Witches” vibes which I absolutely love! This has suspense, a bit of folklore, and witch lore- I highly recommend!
Thank you to the author for the e-arc 🫶🏽🖤
April 24, 2026
If you loved the eerie, whispering magic of One Dark Window, the tension of Heartless Hunter, and the gothic atmosphere of Anathema, this one will absolutely pull you in.
Set in a fog-drenched 1893 London, this story trades whimsical magic for something far more dangerous, controlled, hunted, and steeped in grief. Edith Ashton, the last Death Witch, is a quietly compelling protagonist, hiding her power while using it to investigate murders. Like One Dark Window, her magic feels intimate and unsettling, something she keeps tightly contained until it begins to crack.
The mystery element adds a steady, rising tension, similar to Heartless Hunter, where every step closer to the truth risks exposure. And the presence of the Sparrows, a secret order responsible for a brutal past, brings that same heavy, gothic dread you feel in Anathema.
It starts slow and controlled, but builds into something sharper and more urgent as Edith is forced to confront both her past and her power. Dark, tense, and atmospheric, it’s a story about survival, and what it costs to stop hiding.
Set in a fog-drenched 1893 London, this story trades whimsical magic for something far more dangerous, controlled, hunted, and steeped in grief. Edith Ashton, the last Death Witch, is a quietly compelling protagonist, hiding her power while using it to investigate murders. Like One Dark Window, her magic feels intimate and unsettling, something she keeps tightly contained until it begins to crack.
The mystery element adds a steady, rising tension, similar to Heartless Hunter, where every step closer to the truth risks exposure. And the presence of the Sparrows, a secret order responsible for a brutal past, brings that same heavy, gothic dread you feel in Anathema.
It starts slow and controlled, but builds into something sharper and more urgent as Edith is forced to confront both her past and her power. Dark, tense, and atmospheric, it’s a story about survival, and what it costs to stop hiding.
May 17, 2026
“He was treating her like an unknown quantity, a science experiment that wasn’t behaving the way he expected it to.”
✨ Gaslamp fantasy
✨ Murder mystery
✨ Slow burn
✨ Witches
✨ Found family
✨ Hidden identity
This one has such an interesting setup. Edith is basically living a double life in 1893 London, solving murders for the First Council while hiding what she really is. I really liked her as a character, she’s very controlled, very careful, like she’s constantly holding part of herself back on purpose.
I did want a bit more from her magic though. You can feel it sitting just under the surface the whole time, and I kept waiting for it to properly break loose.
“He was an elf; no more, no less, a golden Adonis, standing on the grubby cobblestones beside her, reminding her she had a job to do.”
The mystery itself is solid and definitely kept me engaged. It has that slow pull where you don’t realise how deep you’re in until things start connecting back to her past.
“He was the most inconvenient person Edith could imagine being partnered with in this case… the pitfalls were endless; there was little time to admire his eyes.”
Her dynamic with Coren is more restrained slow burn tension than anything overt, but it works for the tone. It’s more that constant “we shouldn’t be doing this but also we are absolutely noticing each other” energy.
The hidden identity angle also quietly ramps up in the background, especially as the stakes get higher and it shifts from staying hidden to “okay… this might not be optional anymore”.
“The world is full of people who are afraid but act anyway.”
There’s a nice thread through this one about fear versus action, especially with Edith slowly pushing past the version of herself she’s been forced into.
“She didn’t want to run anymore, and though her mother had told her to hide— the fears of a mother for her child— she thought her mother would be proud of her.”
Such a solid gaslamp mystery with a really interesting magic system at its core, and a main character who feels like she’s only just starting to step into what she actually is.
Chaos, vibes, and opinions are all my own ✨ please give credit if you share.
✨ Gaslamp fantasy
✨ Murder mystery
✨ Slow burn
✨ Witches
✨ Found family
✨ Hidden identity
This one has such an interesting setup. Edith is basically living a double life in 1893 London, solving murders for the First Council while hiding what she really is. I really liked her as a character, she’s very controlled, very careful, like she’s constantly holding part of herself back on purpose.
I did want a bit more from her magic though. You can feel it sitting just under the surface the whole time, and I kept waiting for it to properly break loose.
“He was an elf; no more, no less, a golden Adonis, standing on the grubby cobblestones beside her, reminding her she had a job to do.”
The mystery itself is solid and definitely kept me engaged. It has that slow pull where you don’t realise how deep you’re in until things start connecting back to her past.
“He was the most inconvenient person Edith could imagine being partnered with in this case… the pitfalls were endless; there was little time to admire his eyes.”
Her dynamic with Coren is more restrained slow burn tension than anything overt, but it works for the tone. It’s more that constant “we shouldn’t be doing this but also we are absolutely noticing each other” energy.
The hidden identity angle also quietly ramps up in the background, especially as the stakes get higher and it shifts from staying hidden to “okay… this might not be optional anymore”.
“The world is full of people who are afraid but act anyway.”
There’s a nice thread through this one about fear versus action, especially with Edith slowly pushing past the version of herself she’s been forced into.
“She didn’t want to run anymore, and though her mother had told her to hide— the fears of a mother for her child— she thought her mother would be proud of her.”
Such a solid gaslamp mystery with a really interesting magic system at its core, and a main character who feels like she’s only just starting to step into what she actually is.
Chaos, vibes, and opinions are all my own ✨ please give credit if you share.
June 9, 2026
If you love a gothic fantasy set in 1880’s Victorian London. Look no further. This is a slow burn romance that gives all the gothic feels.
Edith a death witch, and the only one alive. Is hiding her identity and powers while using them to try and uncover what happened to the death witches.
Edith a death witch, and the only one alive. Is hiding her identity and powers while using them to try and uncover what happened to the death witches.
May 9, 2026
Oh I just loved it all the way through! From start to finish. It’s a slow build from the very first chapter, drawing you into Edith’s latest murder investigation, then watching as all the scattered pieces come together to a thrilling and horrific climax, ending life as he knew it. It’s dark, and mysterious, with smatterings of comic relief. The trail we followed in the story kept me constantly on my toes wondering where it would lead and whether or not Edith would do what she must to save not only those she loves, but the whole of her kind from a war torn fate. The friendships made, the subtle hints of something more, it’s not a romantasy, per se, it’s a witchy magical mystery with a bit of romantic subplot. This is an EASY 5 stars from me and I WILL be reading the second installment as SOON as I can possibly get my hands on it!
I’d like to give all my thanks to Jessi St. John for the great honor and privilege of reading this outstanding debut novel!! Please consider me as another early reader for your second as well, because, selfishly, I really don’t want to wait any longer!
I’d like to give all my thanks to Jessi St. John for the great honor and privilege of reading this outstanding debut novel!! Please consider me as another early reader for your second as well, because, selfishly, I really don’t want to wait any longer!
Read
May 7, 2026Edith Ashton is the last witch of her kind, only no one knows it. Through excellent lore telling and fantastic prose Jessi's debut novel tells the story of the Aliis first council investigator looking for missing witches and why they're going missing, multiple perspectives give views on how they are viewing their world in that moment. Mixing a Sherlock like investigation with fae, magic and mystery, The Weavers Loom brings you into a new world full of intrigue at full pelt. I could not recommend this enough. Even to new readers.
May 5, 2026
The Weaver’s Loom by Jessi St. John is set in 1983 London during a time when witches lived in the open with humans. The world building is well-written which made it easy for me to picture the atmosphere, crowded streets, characters and architecture of that time period. Edith Ashton is the last living Death Witch and has been hiding her true powers for years, only letting a small amount out to aid in solving murders. She is a complex character who is tasked with solving the murder of a witch and the disappearance of other witches while struggling with her true identity. The mystery and tension builds throughout the story and there are multiple plot twists to keep the reader on the edge of their seat. While the ending was heart-breaking, I am eagerly looking forward to what happens in the next book.
Highly recommended for readers who love fantasy books with witches, tension and intrigue. This will definitely be one of my favorite books of the year!
Highly recommended for readers who love fantasy books with witches, tension and intrigue. This will definitely be one of my favorite books of the year!
May 5, 2026
Wow! That was my first reaction upon finishing The Weaver's Loom. Kudos to Jessi St. John for making her debut novel a standout!
I could not put this book down, so addictive! One of my top books of the year!
I was transported to 1800's London and didn't want to leave. The Weaver's Loom is magical. Follow Edith's journey as the last death witch and lead investigator of a murder mystery. I loved Edith as an FMC and watching her grow in confidence throughout the book.
This book is full of magic, found family, mystery, and slow burn goodness.
Thank you to Jessi St. John for the ARC!
I could not put this book down, so addictive! One of my top books of the year!
I was transported to 1800's London and didn't want to leave. The Weaver's Loom is magical. Follow Edith's journey as the last death witch and lead investigator of a murder mystery. I loved Edith as an FMC and watching her grow in confidence throughout the book.
This book is full of magic, found family, mystery, and slow burn goodness.
Thank you to Jessi St. John for the ARC!
May 14, 2026
This was a captivating Victorian detective novel that has a unique magical system. I loved the FMC, she was strong, smart and compassionate and I liked her coming into her own throughout the novel. I especially enjoyed the dynamics of the magical system that included witches, faeries, and shifters. Everyone’s magic was different and individual to themselves. I loved the authors descriptions I felt like I was right there with the character! Can’t wait for book 2.
May 4, 2026
Wow what a great read! I’m so grateful this was my first book as an ARC reader! I fell in love with the story line very early on. The world building and intrigue grew simultaneously at a near perfect pace. I loved the concept of a mystery fantasy, right up my alley. Loved the way the main character is evolving into herself throughout the book. There were plenty of twists and turns to keep you thinking and wondering who could be trusted.
This book was a wonderful escape and I can’t wait for the next one in the series! Well done Jessi St. John!
This book was a wonderful escape and I can’t wait for the next one in the series! Well done Jessi St. John!
May 4, 2026
This was a great steady read and flow. The characters are all amazing, and the mystery is unraveled in perfect timing. The idea of London witches with other magical beings losing their immortality was very interesting indeed. Not everyone was happy about that and so war begins. Or should I say a witch hunt.
There are also plenty of lovely bachelors for our FMC to ogle at and get close to! Tides have shifted at the end though so I’m eagerly waiting for book 2 conclusion?!
There are also plenty of lovely bachelors for our FMC to ogle at and get close to! Tides have shifted at the end though so I’m eagerly waiting for book 2 conclusion?!
May 4, 2026
I am so happy to have received this arc! This book grabbed me from the beginning and kept my interest the whole way through. The magic! The mystery! It never lost my interest once. This book is beautifully written and I love the characters. Edie is my favorite and I so need book two asap because that ending, just wow!
April 21, 2026
thank you to the author for the chance to be an ARC reader!
This fantasy novel gave a whole new take on witchcraft and how it integrates into society. I loved the twists and turns and how the magic was (forgive me) woven into the history and relationships.
I was certainly not expecting the ending (trying to stay vague here).
Huge claps to the editorial team and to Jessi St John for putting together such an incredible book! I have already preordered the official copy and can’t wait to experience it again!
This fantasy novel gave a whole new take on witchcraft and how it integrates into society. I loved the twists and turns and how the magic was (forgive me) woven into the history and relationships.
I was certainly not expecting the ending (trying to stay vague here).
Huge claps to the editorial team and to Jessi St John for putting together such an incredible book! I have already preordered the official copy and can’t wait to experience it again!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 21, 2026
Hello, guys!
First of all, let me mention that this book is the first book in the series The Last Death Witch.
This is one of the most addictive novels I have read. From the first page, the author puts us in her world, takes us by the hand and captivates us, like an invisible cloak that slowly envelops us.
In the story, there is a strong element of mystery, darkness, intrigue, secrets and suspense. The world building is not only wonderful but also enchanting and rich. The same goes for its heroes.
The protagonist is Edith, who is a character that the reader admires and remains rooted in his heart. Also, her character is structured with a combination of vulnerability, sentimentality and dynamics.
Of course, there are other characters who win over and become dear to every reader, but I think that Edith, due to the author's portrayal, remains deeply engraved in his soul.
And this writing of hers is so full, emotional, shocking, captivating, enjoyable, rich, magical, enchanting, stormy, lively and cinematic.
Of course I can't wait to read the sequel!
Thank you very much to the author and Iris PR for the eARC!
This is my honest review!
First of all, let me mention that this book is the first book in the series The Last Death Witch.
This is one of the most addictive novels I have read. From the first page, the author puts us in her world, takes us by the hand and captivates us, like an invisible cloak that slowly envelops us.
In the story, there is a strong element of mystery, darkness, intrigue, secrets and suspense. The world building is not only wonderful but also enchanting and rich. The same goes for its heroes.
The protagonist is Edith, who is a character that the reader admires and remains rooted in his heart. Also, her character is structured with a combination of vulnerability, sentimentality and dynamics.
Of course, there are other characters who win over and become dear to every reader, but I think that Edith, due to the author's portrayal, remains deeply engraved in his soul.
And this writing of hers is so full, emotional, shocking, captivating, enjoyable, rich, magical, enchanting, stormy, lively and cinematic.
Of course I can't wait to read the sequel!
Thank you very much to the author and Iris PR for the eARC!
This is my honest review!
June 1, 2026
The Weaver’s Loom completely pulled me into its dark and atmospheric version of 1890s London. Foggy streets, hidden magic, murder investigations, and witches living under uneasy treaties made this feel incredibly immersive from the very first chapter.
Edith Ashton was such a compelling main character. As the last surviving Death Witch, she carries so much grief and isolation while hiding in plain sight as an investigator solving murders with forbidden magic. Her ability to witness a victim’s final moments added such a chilling layer to the mystery.
The gothic atmosphere was one of my favorite parts of this book. Every scene felt heavy with danger, secrets, and tension. The mystery itself kept me invested the entire time, especially as the disappearances connected back to the order responsible for wiping out Edith’s family.
I also loved the slow burn romance woven throughout the story. It never overshadowed the mystery but added emotional depth and tension in all the right ways.
If you enjoy dark fantasy, gothic settings, witchy magic, murder mysteries, and strong female leads, I highly recommend this one.
Perfect for fans of Penny Dreadful and Sherlock Holmes with a witchy twist.
Edith Ashton was such a compelling main character. As the last surviving Death Witch, she carries so much grief and isolation while hiding in plain sight as an investigator solving murders with forbidden magic. Her ability to witness a victim’s final moments added such a chilling layer to the mystery.
The gothic atmosphere was one of my favorite parts of this book. Every scene felt heavy with danger, secrets, and tension. The mystery itself kept me invested the entire time, especially as the disappearances connected back to the order responsible for wiping out Edith’s family.
I also loved the slow burn romance woven throughout the story. It never overshadowed the mystery but added emotional depth and tension in all the right ways.
If you enjoy dark fantasy, gothic settings, witchy magic, murder mysteries, and strong female leads, I highly recommend this one.
Perfect for fans of Penny Dreadful and Sherlock Holmes with a witchy twist.
June 18, 2026
Edith Ashton is the kind of fmc I can't help but love. She is strong, intelligent, and carrying the weight of secrets that could destroy her! Watching her unravel a string of mysterious deaths while confronting the ghosts of her past kept me hooked the entire time.
The Victorian setting added so much atmosphere, and the blend of witchcraft, murder investigation, and hidden history created a story that felt both eerie and immersive. Every new discovery seemed to raise the stakes, and I found myself constantly trying to piece together the mystery right alongside Edith.
The story isn't just about solving murders, no...it's so much deeper than what's on the surface. It's about survival, loss, and finding the strength to face the things we'd rather leave buried.
If you love dark fantasy with gothic vibes, compelling magic, and a mystery that keeps you guessing, The Weaver's Loom is absolutely worth picking up. I can't wait to see what Jessi St. John has in stor for the next book!
The Victorian setting added so much atmosphere, and the blend of witchcraft, murder investigation, and hidden history created a story that felt both eerie and immersive. Every new discovery seemed to raise the stakes, and I found myself constantly trying to piece together the mystery right alongside Edith.
The story isn't just about solving murders, no...it's so much deeper than what's on the surface. It's about survival, loss, and finding the strength to face the things we'd rather leave buried.
If you love dark fantasy with gothic vibes, compelling magic, and a mystery that keeps you guessing, The Weaver's Loom is absolutely worth picking up. I can't wait to see what Jessi St. John has in stor for the next book!
May 16, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Weaver’s Loom is, without question, one of my favorite reads of the year. Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and Victory Editing for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is the Jessi St. John’s debut novel and it does not disappoint! From the start, the novel manages to accomplish something surprisingly difficult: it is deeply gothic and unsettling while also feeling strangely cozy and intimate. From the opening chapters, the story pulls you into a richly layered world filled with death magic, mystery, folklore, and carefully woven lore that unfolds naturally. There is a quiet, candlelit quality to the novel that lingers even in its darker moments, creating a reading experience that feels eerie, melancholic, and comforting all at once.
The multiple POVs are distinct and easy to follow, the worldbuilding is immersive without becoming dense, and the central mystery unfolds with genuine confidence and restraint. Rather than relying on shock value or endless twists, the novel trusts its atmosphere, characters, and mythology to carry the story. Every reveal feels earned.
I am already anxiously anticipating the next installment in this series!
The Weaver’s Loom is, without question, one of my favorite reads of the year. Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and Victory Editing for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is the Jessi St. John’s debut novel and it does not disappoint! From the start, the novel manages to accomplish something surprisingly difficult: it is deeply gothic and unsettling while also feeling strangely cozy and intimate. From the opening chapters, the story pulls you into a richly layered world filled with death magic, mystery, folklore, and carefully woven lore that unfolds naturally. There is a quiet, candlelit quality to the novel that lingers even in its darker moments, creating a reading experience that feels eerie, melancholic, and comforting all at once.
The multiple POVs are distinct and easy to follow, the worldbuilding is immersive without becoming dense, and the central mystery unfolds with genuine confidence and restraint. Rather than relying on shock value or endless twists, the novel trusts its atmosphere, characters, and mythology to carry the story. Every reveal feels earned.
I am already anxiously anticipating the next installment in this series!
June 9, 2026
Thank you Jessi St John and Crowns and Chaos PR for the gifted book.
I intended to just read a few chapters of The Weaver's Loom for a PR post. By the time I finished chapter 3 I couldn't put the book down and postponed several responsibilities so I could keep reading. Edith and her ragtag family drew me into their home and along for the adventure!
I love to watch characters mature and come into their full power. This story does not disappoint and Edith is no damsel in distress. She is smart and courageous. The men surrounding her are also capable, but do their best to trust and support her. The end had me in tears and now I am anxious for book 2!
"To everyone who grew up scared or hiding. There is no right time to step out of the shadows. We all get to write our own stories." ~Jessi St John The Weaver's Loom
I intended to just read a few chapters of The Weaver's Loom for a PR post. By the time I finished chapter 3 I couldn't put the book down and postponed several responsibilities so I could keep reading. Edith and her ragtag family drew me into their home and along for the adventure!
I love to watch characters mature and come into their full power. This story does not disappoint and Edith is no damsel in distress. She is smart and courageous. The men surrounding her are also capable, but do their best to trust and support her. The end had me in tears and now I am anxious for book 2!
"To everyone who grew up scared or hiding. There is no right time to step out of the shadows. We all get to write our own stories." ~Jessi St John The Weaver's Loom
May 20, 2026
This is a NetGalley ARC review — To Be Published 06/01/26. A high-stakes, nicely paced, witchy fantasy mystery, with enjoyable characters and an immersive world — in a debut book? Impressive.
Although the beginning is slightly slow, with some funky pacing issues, the story quickly gains momentum. The clunky start does not foreshadow the rest of the book. I highly recommend hanging in there, as this is a surprisingly refreshing read.
Edith is the witchy ‘Sherlock’ of this story, set in 1800’s London, solving the abduction of several witches. This historical fantasy setting includes witches, fairies, shifters, elves, and humans. Even though there isn’t any spice, there is some romance. If you like female empowerment, witches and magic, a strong FMC, and historical fantasy with a side of witchy, you’ll love this.
Although the beginning is slightly slow, with some funky pacing issues, the story quickly gains momentum. The clunky start does not foreshadow the rest of the book. I highly recommend hanging in there, as this is a surprisingly refreshing read.
Edith is the witchy ‘Sherlock’ of this story, set in 1800’s London, solving the abduction of several witches. This historical fantasy setting includes witches, fairies, shifters, elves, and humans. Even though there isn’t any spice, there is some romance. If you like female empowerment, witches and magic, a strong FMC, and historical fantasy with a side of witchy, you’ll love this.
May 18, 2026
In The Weaver's Loom, Edith’s investigation into a string of deaths and disappearances draws her into a haunting journey through both the past and the future, slowly unravelling the people around her and the ways they have shaped her life. Set against an atmospheric London backdrop, the story weaves together witches, shifters, and fae with mystery and self-discovery to create an immersive fantasy world. I especially enjoyed how the relationships and revelations unfolded alongside Edith’s growing understanding of herself and those closest to her.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
May 19, 2026
A huge shoutout to Jessi St. John on her debut novel, The Weaver’s Loom!
This book was the perfect blend of historical fantasy and murder mystery, with a subtle romance subplot woven throughout. The magic system was incredibly unique, and every character stood out in a way that made them truly memorable.
And that plot twist… I did NOT see it coming
Now I’m left impatiently waiting for the next book because I need to know what happens next.
Thank you to Jessi St. John and NetGalley for my ARC.
This book was the perfect blend of historical fantasy and murder mystery, with a subtle romance subplot woven throughout. The magic system was incredibly unique, and every character stood out in a way that made them truly memorable.
And that plot twist… I did NOT see it coming
Now I’m left impatiently waiting for the next book because I need to know what happens next.
Thank you to Jessi St. John and NetGalley for my ARC.
June 7, 2026
4.5 ⭐️
This book was great from start to finish! The pacing was great and loved all the characters. Edith’s backstory was written beautifully and loved how we continued to receive tiny snip bits of her past throughout the book. I love her friendship with Ben, it is a true definition of found family. This story has the little glimpses of romance, which I enjoy, as someone who likes slow burns.
I am excited to see how the story continues to develop! This story is exactly as advertised and if you love witches, mystery, and historical fantasy, add this to your TBR!
This book was great from start to finish! The pacing was great and loved all the characters. Edith’s backstory was written beautifully and loved how we continued to receive tiny snip bits of her past throughout the book. I love her friendship with Ben, it is a true definition of found family. This story has the little glimpses of romance, which I enjoy, as someone who likes slow burns.
I am excited to see how the story continues to develop! This story is exactly as advertised and if you love witches, mystery, and historical fantasy, add this to your TBR!
Read
May 11, 2026𝗲𝗔𝗥𝗖 𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
“The world is full of people who are afraid but act anyway.”
What an intriguing concept for a book. Set in 1890s London, witches now live uneasily alongside humans after a treaty stripped them of their immortality in exchange for living openly. In the aftermath, Death Witches were hunted to extinction… all except one - our FMC.
I was initially drawn in by the blurb because I usually adore witchy stories and unique magic systems, and this book definitely delivers on that front. It blends historical fiction, mystery, and fantasy into a 1890s witch‑hunt whodunnit, complete with disappearing witches and no one able to prove their abductions.
The magical creatures were a standout for me - croaxes and drealyx were so unique, and honestly I’d love my own charmbrella. A charm bracelet that turns into an umbrella when it rains? I’d use that daily.
This book will really shine for readers who love witches, historical fantasy, mystery, and high stakes without a whole lot of romance or spice. I’m definitely more of a romance‑girlie, so this was a different vibe for me, but I’m grateful for the opportunity to read this ARC.
A huge thank you Jessi St John for the opportunity to read an eARC of The Weaver’s Loom.
“The world is full of people who are afraid but act anyway.”
What an intriguing concept for a book. Set in 1890s London, witches now live uneasily alongside humans after a treaty stripped them of their immortality in exchange for living openly. In the aftermath, Death Witches were hunted to extinction… all except one - our FMC.
I was initially drawn in by the blurb because I usually adore witchy stories and unique magic systems, and this book definitely delivers on that front. It blends historical fiction, mystery, and fantasy into a 1890s witch‑hunt whodunnit, complete with disappearing witches and no one able to prove their abductions.
The magical creatures were a standout for me - croaxes and drealyx were so unique, and honestly I’d love my own charmbrella. A charm bracelet that turns into an umbrella when it rains? I’d use that daily.
This book will really shine for readers who love witches, historical fantasy, mystery, and high stakes without a whole lot of romance or spice. I’m definitely more of a romance‑girlie, so this was a different vibe for me, but I’m grateful for the opportunity to read this ARC.
A huge thank you Jessi St John for the opportunity to read an eARC of The Weaver’s Loom.
June 23, 2026
I am so glad I got to be apart of the ARC team for this book and can’t wait for book two. Thank you for not leaving us on a cliffhanger 🙏🏼 the last 100 pages had me in a chokehold and I was SAT!!
Can’t recommend this book enough an amazing blend of historical fiction and fantasy!
Can’t recommend this book enough an amazing blend of historical fiction and fantasy!
June 28, 2026
Summary:
We follow the witch detective Edith, who uses her ability as a death witch to figure out how other people died. However, as death witches have been hunted and thought extint, she must hide who she really is, while uncovering the mystery disappearances and one murder of witches.
Spoiler free review:
A murder mystery in the 1800s, with witches?? The premise of this book was already so exciting, and I would say it absolutely delivered! There was mystery, intrigue, friendships, and overall a very believable world and characters that truly had me hooked on every chapter as I just needed to know more! There was also a lot of show don’t tell, so the magic system, while never fully explained, it tells you enough that you believe whatever is happening and the limits it has.
Plot:
I loooove a good mystery, and I was heavily invested in this one, turning every page and excited to see what we would do next to uncover the kidnappings and the murder of the witches.
Characters:
Every single character, big or small, felt like were given a lot of care in terms of personality. Everyone, even if I don’t remember their name, I remember the impression they gave. And I loved the few chapters we had from other character’s POV, letting you in on secrets that our FMC did not know, adding a excitement for her to find out.
Spoiler review:
We follow the witch detective Edith, who uses her ability as a death witch to figure out how other people died. However, as death witches have been hunted and thought extint, she must hide who she really is, while uncovering the mystery disappearances and one murder of witches.
Spoiler free review:
A murder mystery in the 1800s, with witches?? The premise of this book was already so exciting, and I would say it absolutely delivered! There was mystery, intrigue, friendships, and overall a very believable world and characters that truly had me hooked on every chapter as I just needed to know more! There was also a lot of show don’t tell, so the magic system, while never fully explained, it tells you enough that you believe whatever is happening and the limits it has.
Plot:
I loooove a good mystery, and I was heavily invested in this one, turning every page and excited to see what we would do next to uncover the kidnappings and the murder of the witches.
Characters:
Every single character, big or small, felt like were given a lot of care in terms of personality. Everyone, even if I don’t remember their name, I remember the impression they gave. And I loved the few chapters we had from other character’s POV, letting you in on secrets that our FMC did not know, adding a excitement for her to find out.
Spoiler review:
May 7, 2026
4.5 Stars
This was such a good story! The Weavers Loom is a Dark eerie Fantasy with Murder and Mystery! Think Penny Dreadful Vibes!! i really enjoyed the Types of witchcraft in this story so much! You never knew who you could trust and I have always loved stories that have mysteries and intriguing plots. This book doesn’t disappoint!!
Jessi St John’s writing is fantastic making the reader feel like they are right there apart of the story. i really didn’t want this book to end. I will definitely recommend it and be continuing the series!
This was such a good story! The Weavers Loom is a Dark eerie Fantasy with Murder and Mystery! Think Penny Dreadful Vibes!! i really enjoyed the Types of witchcraft in this story so much! You never knew who you could trust and I have always loved stories that have mysteries and intriguing plots. This book doesn’t disappoint!!
Jessi St John’s writing is fantastic making the reader feel like they are right there apart of the story. i really didn’t want this book to end. I will definitely recommend it and be continuing the series!
June 24, 2026
6 stars 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
Good lord, this book wrecked me and has me dying for book 2.
Genres, settings, categories, themes: gaslamp fantasy, historical fantasy, murder, atmospheric, witches, magic, shifters, faerie, elves, romantic subplot (M/F), 1890s London, found family, death (as in Death as a character & a "death witch")
I guess technically mystery also (but it was more about like...hunting them down than it was about figuring out who did it, no?)
💗 Tropes: 💗
> Chosen One
> Coming of Age
> Hidden Identity
> Slow Burn
> H is not clear in this book, but Partners in Fighting Crime & a little bit of Hate to Love might be applicable also
all about tropes here
Series/Sequencing Style: 1st in an dynamic series, cliffhanger isn't massive, but I definitely want books 2 & 3!
understanding series types: dynamic, static, anthology - source 1, source 2
Format: ebook (e-ARC)
🔽🔽🔽
Overall ratings
Heat level: 🍓 0/5 sweet 🍓
(from Ampersand’s guide to heat levels in romance novels – (0) sweet, (1) mild sizzle, (2) sensual steam, (3) spicy seduction, (4) red hot, (5) erotic)
~ Heroine/FMC (Edith) ~ 4.75/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Male Main Characters ~ Ben, Roswick, Coren all 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Other characters ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Plot ~ 4.5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗 see minor notes below
~ Pacing ~ 4.75/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕 just that taking it down from perfect
~ World building ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Writing ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Reading enjoyability & fun ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Depth & tone (1 light & fun --> 5 more serious, addresses heavier topics?): 3
~ Sadness level: 4/5
Will I read more by this author? yes!!
🔽🔽🔽
❗CW/Triggers:❗blood, death of loved one, death of parents, fire, forced imprisonment, kidnapping, knife wound, murder, witches hunted to extinction
🔽🔽🔽
📝 Review/Notes 📝
Immediately immersive!
Superb gaslamp fantasy world with witches, elves, faeries, and shifters. Obsessed with these characters. Was totally absorbed the whole time. Slowww burn romance that I’m gagging for in book 2!!!
More great things about it
• Impeccable cast
• Layered, badass, atmospheric
• Easy enough to follow, but still nicely layered, magic system
Didn't love as much...
I’m not sure I can forgive St. John for
My only (minor) critiques (other than wishing ) are that the end fight scene felt a little rushed and blurred, although I suspect that was on purpose since readers already knew what was coming. But it was a little confusing how
And then my only other critique was
Will order these books for my bookshelf when they're out in paperback!
🔽🔽🔽
🤠 Recommended for: fans of gaslamp fantasy, if you want to be sat & consumed..& maybe a little broken
Good lord, this book wrecked me and has me dying for book 2.
Genres, settings, categories, themes: gaslamp fantasy, historical fantasy, murder, atmospheric, witches, magic, shifters, faerie, elves, romantic subplot (M/F), 1890s London, found family, death (as in Death as a character & a "death witch")
I guess technically mystery also (but it was more about like...hunting them down than it was about figuring out who did it, no?)
💗 Tropes: 💗
> Chosen One
> Coming of Age
> Hidden Identity
> Slow Burn
> H is not clear in this book, but Partners in Fighting Crime & a little bit of Hate to Love might be applicable also
all about tropes here
Series/Sequencing Style: 1st in an dynamic series, cliffhanger isn't massive, but I definitely want books 2 & 3!
understanding series types: dynamic, static, anthology - source 1, source 2
Format: ebook (e-ARC)
🔽🔽🔽
Overall ratings
Heat level: 🍓 0/5 sweet 🍓
(from Ampersand’s guide to heat levels in romance novels – (0) sweet, (1) mild sizzle, (2) sensual steam, (3) spicy seduction, (4) red hot, (5) erotic)
~ Heroine/FMC (Edith) ~ 4.75/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Male Main Characters ~ Ben, Roswick, Coren all 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Other characters ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Plot ~ 4.5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌗 see minor notes below
~ Pacing ~ 4.75/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕 just that taking it down from perfect
~ World building ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Writing ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Reading enjoyability & fun ~ 5/5 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌕
~ Depth & tone (1 light & fun --> 5 more serious, addresses heavier topics?): 3
~ Sadness level: 4/5
Will I read more by this author? yes!!
🔽🔽🔽
❗CW/Triggers:❗blood, death of loved one, death of parents, fire, forced imprisonment, kidnapping, knife wound, murder, witches hunted to extinction
🔽🔽🔽
📝 Review/Notes 📝
Immediately immersive!
Superb gaslamp fantasy world with witches, elves, faeries, and shifters. Obsessed with these characters. Was totally absorbed the whole time. Slowww burn romance that I’m gagging for in book 2!!!
More great things about it
• Impeccable cast
• Layered, badass, atmospheric
• Easy enough to follow, but still nicely layered, magic system
Didn't love as much...
I’m not sure I can forgive St. John for
My only (minor) critiques (other than wishing ) are that the end fight scene felt a little rushed and blurred, although I suspect that was on purpose since readers already knew what was coming. But it was a little confusing how
And then my only other critique was
Will order these books for my bookshelf when they're out in paperback!
🔽🔽🔽
🤠 Recommended for: fans of gaslamp fantasy, if you want to be sat & consumed..& maybe a little broken
Review of advance copy received from Author
The Weaver's Loom is a Gaslamp (Victorian-era fantasy + magic setting) novel about Edith Ashton, a witch and an Investigator for the First Council (governmental body) in London, investigating a series of witch kidnappings and murders.
Personal Reaction
This book is a ton of fun. The magic and its mechanics is new and fun, and I was especially excited by the possibilities in the dynamic between Edith and "the voice in her head (trying to avoid spoilers here). Jessi St John does a fantastic job of setting an extremely gritty, foreboding environment in Victorian era London while bringing to life one of the most inspiring, selfless heroines I've had the fortune to accompany through this adventure. It is a slow build-up, but once the action begins, it's fast and extremely exciting. I highly recommend this book to all flavors of fantasy readers.
The Magic of Gaslamp London
Jessi St. John does a wonderful job of taking the time to explain the detailed magical life of London in this novel. We learn about the races, the kinds of magic wielded, and is very efficient about focusing on magical mechanics that matter to the characters and the plot. The author sprinkles additional magical details throughout her writing that adds color and flavor without weighing down the pacing of the plot.
Character Development and Arcs
The gentle climb to conflict in this story lends credibility and sympathy to the main characters in the story, especially Edith Ashton. She is a young witch who, through certain traumatic experiences, was determined to keep her magic secret. The pacing at which Jessi St John takes us through her discovery, conflict, and decision makes her conviction and action later in the novel feel more compelling. The consistency of strength, courage, and integrity shown by a female lead without feeling like the author was pandering to feminist notions was uniquely refreshing to read. This was a genuinely tough woman making her way in a sea of sharks, and she owned it. In this aspect, Edith reminded me of few indomitable heroines who take control and get the job done. I cannot wait to see what happens next for Edith Ashton.
Coren Blackstone is a Chief Inspector of the First Council, officially assigned to help her in investigating these kidnappings and murder, and has the second biggest arc in the story. He is a tracker elf armed to the teeth with charm, but he harbors a dark past that reveals itself later in the story.
Plot, Pacing
The pacing of the plot is necessarily slower at the beginning of the novel as the world, its magic, and our characters and their contexts are carefully laid out and developed. As the story reaches conflict and climax, the pace accelerates and plot points play out very quickly and intensely. Because of the careful exposition provided earlier, however, the choices made and consequences that ensue are compelling and feel true to the characters driving the story.
The ending of the story, while poignant, is very satisfying. There is a loose thread so to speak, hanging at the end of this novel that may be a tantalizing cliffhanger for the next book. I full-heartedly give this book five stars for character development, thematic consistency and strength, storytelling, and pacing.
Personal Reaction
This book is a ton of fun. The magic and its mechanics is new and fun, and I was especially excited by the possibilities in the dynamic between Edith and "the voice in her head (trying to avoid spoilers here). Jessi St John does a fantastic job of setting an extremely gritty, foreboding environment in Victorian era London while bringing to life one of the most inspiring, selfless heroines I've had the fortune to accompany through this adventure. It is a slow build-up, but once the action begins, it's fast and extremely exciting. I highly recommend this book to all flavors of fantasy readers.
The Magic of Gaslamp London
Jessi St. John does a wonderful job of taking the time to explain the detailed magical life of London in this novel. We learn about the races, the kinds of magic wielded, and is very efficient about focusing on magical mechanics that matter to the characters and the plot. The author sprinkles additional magical details throughout her writing that adds color and flavor without weighing down the pacing of the plot.
Character Development and Arcs
The gentle climb to conflict in this story lends credibility and sympathy to the main characters in the story, especially Edith Ashton. She is a young witch who, through certain traumatic experiences, was determined to keep her magic secret. The pacing at which Jessi St John takes us through her discovery, conflict, and decision makes her conviction and action later in the novel feel more compelling. The consistency of strength, courage, and integrity shown by a female lead without feeling like the author was pandering to feminist notions was uniquely refreshing to read. This was a genuinely tough woman making her way in a sea of sharks, and she owned it. In this aspect, Edith reminded me of few indomitable heroines who take control and get the job done. I cannot wait to see what happens next for Edith Ashton.
Coren Blackstone is a Chief Inspector of the First Council, officially assigned to help her in investigating these kidnappings and murder, and has the second biggest arc in the story. He is a tracker elf armed to the teeth with charm, but he harbors a dark past that reveals itself later in the story.
Plot, Pacing
The pacing of the plot is necessarily slower at the beginning of the novel as the world, its magic, and our characters and their contexts are carefully laid out and developed. As the story reaches conflict and climax, the pace accelerates and plot points play out very quickly and intensely. Because of the careful exposition provided earlier, however, the choices made and consequences that ensue are compelling and feel true to the characters driving the story.
The ending of the story, while poignant, is very satisfying. There is a loose thread so to speak, hanging at the end of this novel that may be a tantalizing cliffhanger for the next book. I full-heartedly give this book five stars for character development, thematic consistency and strength, storytelling, and pacing.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 254 reviews