OK, LISTEN UP.
"believe what you want about me." -eris, acowar
here is my case for an eris vanserra redemption arc.
because he deserves it and has so much potential. sarah's been planting seeds this whole time. i don't know where to start, so i'll just jump into the thick of it.
*MAJOR SPOILERS FOR ALL ACOTAR BOOKS*
*MAJOR ACOSF SPOILERS*
his home life sucks a lot
lucien has said before that the autumn court is basically awful and cutthroat and it sucks. we know that eris is tortured by his father and has most likely been multiple times. canon physical abuse, my friends:
------
"Always mix truth and lies, General. Didn't those warrior-brutes teach you how to withstand an enemy's torture?"
"Beron tortured you?"
"Who cared what my father does to me? He believed my story about the shadowsinger's spies informing him that a valuable asset had been kidnapped by Briallyn and that you lot were disgusted to arrive and find it was me, rather than someone from the Summer or Winter courts, or whoever stoops to associate with you."
Cassian unpacked every word. Beron had tortured his own son for information, rather than thanking the Mother for returning him. But Eris had held out. Fed Beron another lie. And then there was the way Eris had spoken about the other courts. Something had been off in his words, his tight expression. Was the male jealous?" (acosf)
-------
i mean.
his father is a total asshole and eris is not exempt from that influence. also, there's no chance he has anyone to comfort him or to tell him to stand up to his father. eris is alone, as far as we know, and that sucks a lot.
he acts in the best interests of prythian and the autumn court.
cassian says it in acosf. he takes the antidote. he wants to be high lord because beron is awful at it. he doesn't tell bri-whateverhernameis anything.
also he's nice about taking the antidote, so there's that.
he is not a bad person in the path that he is taking- he is allied with the ic and he wants the best for prythian, from what we've seen.
the mor thing.
yeah, there are conflicting reports on that. eris, multiple times, has said that the ic doesn't have the whole story.
-------
"so what's the asking price, eris?" mor demanded. "another little bride for you to torture?"
"i don't know who fed you those lies to begin with, morrigan."
"you never gave any evidence to the contrary. certainly not when you left me in the woods."
"there were forces at work that you have never considered, and i am not going to waste my breath explaining them to you. believe what you want about me." (acowar, left out irrelevant parts bc i don't feel like typing them out.)
-------
"Get that pitying look off your face."
"Why did you leave Mor in the woods that day?"
"You're not the person I want to explain myself to."
"I doubt Mor will want to listen."
-------
there is more (haha, mor/more) to this story, guys. and I'm willing to bet, because it's sjm, that it doesn't cast eris in a negative light.
the lucien thing.
conflicting reports again. tamlin says, in the first book, that eris was there when lucien's lover was killed. eris refutes this, and so does rhys (i think? idk about this, but i think i read that rhys said he wasn't somewhere). anyways, who do we believe- tamlin, or eris? it's worth thinking about. eris claims that:
-------
"and what of the brother you hunted down alongside of me? the one whose lover you helped to excecute before his eyes?"
"you know nothing about what happened that day. nothing."
-------
"how do you think he made it to the spring border? i wasn't there- when they did it. ask him. i refused. it was the first and only time i have denied my father anything. (more emotional abuse from beron! eris has never had to courage to deny him anything but that.) he punished me. (this is what i mean by making a case for him being physically abused multiple times.) and by the time i got free... they were going to kill him too. i made sure they didn't."
-------
so yeah? I mean, that's kind of a big deal. and eris seems distressed enough that i can't see how this would be a lie- especially because it'd be so easy to fact-check his story with lucien.
he is generally being an asshole, but...
is he an asshole to cass/az? yes, ofc. he says stuff with the intention of hurting them, and that's not ok at all. nothing can excuse that, but i'm almost certain he's jealous of them.
cassian says it himself: (in acosf) that eris has everything on paper (wealth, status, pureblood (for lack of a better word lol)) but he has no one that loves him, no friends- everything the inner circle has, eris lacks.
and eris always is as asshole to az and cass about their lineage. he calls them bastards all the time because he's jealous that even though they have nothing on paper, they're happy. they have friends and love, and while eris may have pure blood, he has none of that. even two bastard-born nobodies are happier and richer than he is, in the ways that matter.
cassian also notes, in the quotes i included above (the first one) that eris sounds jealous of the ic's friends.
yes, he is an asshole, but he has his reasons. they are obviously wrong, but he's not mean to be mean- he's mean because he's jealous and lonely. he can learn to recognize that, heal, and apologize.
under the mountain/literally the rest of his life
there is so much we don't know about him.
"because eris... what had it been like for him, under the mountain? what games had he played- what had he endured?"
also he has a few centuries of life to sort through, so... y'know. we know nothing about him. personally, i ship him in m/m relationships just because it seems to fit him. bi eris, please. my point is that we only know the biased povs of the inner circle and we know that they are not reliable narrators.
everyone's instincts say that there's more to him
"beron studied his son with a scrutiny that made some small, small part of me wonder if eris might have grown to be a good male if he'd had a different father. if one still lurked here, beneath centuries of poison." -feyre pov, acowar
"You know Eris, I think you might be a decent male, deep down, trapped in a terrible situation. I grew up surrounded by monsters. I've spent my existence fighting them. And I see you, Eris. You're not one of them. Not even close. I think you might even be a good male. You're just too much of a coward to act like one." -cassian to eris, acosf
misc. quotes and points
-------
"Only Beron was stupid enough to scoff. Eris was just angling his body in his chair--blocking the path to his mother."
ok, so eris is protective of his mother. interesting.
-------
"beron entered... his remaining sons sneered at us... their father didn't bother to check them. but eris did. a step behind his father, eris murmured "enough" and his younger brothers fell into line. all three of them."
interesting.
-------
also i don't think the fact that he wanted to marry nesta is a negative character trait. i want to marry nesta. he didn't know really anything about what was going on in acosf, so like... i can't fault him for liking nesta. great. also we don't know his logic behind that request.
-------
""who knew that a cock could be so persuasive?"
"father." eris's voice was low with warning."
eris didn't need to stand up for rhys there, not at all.
-------
he is a redeemable person.
all i'm saying is that i would bet a lot of money that he gets his arc, and i want him to so badly. please, sjm. redeem eris.
edit: sjm please make azriel and eris mates because it would be funny and i would find it entertaining