What do you think?
Rate this book
A Scattering of Light
A Scottish drover spirited into servitude. A young Quaker woman wounded by loss. Their meeting will leave no heart unchallenged, no life unchanged.
Colonial Virginia 1734
Mourning her wayward brother’s death, Verity Wilde has turned her back on Williamsburg society, striving to live by her notion of true to keep oneself unspotted from the world. But when she boards a ship to claim an indentured Scottish clerk, she’s unprepared to find another Scotsman, starved and gravely ill, left on deck untended. With scarcely more knowledge of the man than his name and place of origin—William Crockett of Skye—pity compels Verity to purchase his indenture too, meaning to provide the compassionate death denied him by the ship’s crew. Only he doesn’t die.
Will Crockett’s survival upends Verity’s carefully circumscribed life, while he awakens to find his world shattered beyond recognition. As they seek to reconcile their broken pasts, bitterness and fear vie with hope to chart their futures. Can they find the courage to trust each other, and a God who scatters light in the darkness?
Colonial Virginia 1734
Mourning her wayward brother’s death, Verity Wilde has turned her back on Williamsburg society, striving to live by her notion of true to keep oneself unspotted from the world. But when she boards a ship to claim an indentured Scottish clerk, she’s unprepared to find another Scotsman, starved and gravely ill, left on deck untended. With scarcely more knowledge of the man than his name and place of origin—William Crockett of Skye—pity compels Verity to purchase his indenture too, meaning to provide the compassionate death denied him by the ship’s crew. Only he doesn’t die.
Will Crockett’s survival upends Verity’s carefully circumscribed life, while he awakens to find his world shattered beyond recognition. As they seek to reconcile their broken pasts, bitterness and fear vie with hope to chart their futures. Can they find the courage to trust each other, and a God who scatters light in the darkness?
447 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 17, 2026
About the author
Lori Benton
15 books1,002 followersLori Benton was born and raised east of the Appalachian Mountains, surrounded by early American and family history going back to the 1600s. Her novels transport readers to the 18th century, where she brings to life the Colonial and early Federal periods of American history, creating a melting pot of characters drawn from both sides of a turbulent and shifting frontier, brought together in the bonds of God's transforming grace.
When she isn’t writing, reading, or researching 18th century history, Lori enjoys exploring the mountains with her husband.
Burning Sky, Lori's debut novel, was a finalist for the ECPA 2014 Christian Book Award, and winner of the 2014 Christy Award for First Novel, Historical, and Book of the Year.
When she isn’t writing, reading, or researching 18th century history, Lori enjoys exploring the mountains with her husband.
Burning Sky, Lori's debut novel, was a finalist for the ECPA 2014 Christian Book Award, and winner of the 2014 Christy Award for First Novel, Historical, and Book of the Year.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
April 15, 2026
“Looking from Simon’s dismay-struck face to Will’s, I fell to giggling. Had I kent what would come of it all, I wouldn’t have.”
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
If you’re a fan of historical romance…listen up, because this one is for you 👏
A Scattering of Light takes you to Colonial Virginia and beyond, where a grieving Quaker woman crosses paths with a broken Scottish man whose survival changes everything she thought she understood about faith, purpose, and love.
What I loved most about this story was how it unfolds over time—layer by layer—through split timelines that reveal just how far someone will go for revenge… and what’s left behind for those trying to rebuild after losing everything.
This is a true journey book. One filled with ups and downs, heartbreak and hope, and characters who feel larger than life because of everything they endure. You’re not just reading their story—you’re walking through it with them.
The historical detail is rich and immersive. From colonial America to Scotland, the settings feel vivid and lived-in, giving you a glimpse into lives and struggles so different from our own. The language/accents might take a few chapters to get used to (they are strongly written), but after a few chapters you should get into a flow.
And at its core, this is a story of redemption. Of learning to trust God even when life doesn’t make sense. Of choosing forgiveness when bitterness might feel easier. Those themes were woven in so beautifully and gave the story a deeper meaning that really stayed with me.
If you love historicals similar to A. L. Sowards, this is absolutely one to add to your list.
This one is available now!
Happy Reading📚
Content/Trigger: mention of suicide, mention of a married couple waking up together, mild suspense/peril/violence, revenge/redemption/forgiveness themes, romance—kisses only
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
If you’re a fan of historical romance…listen up, because this one is for you 👏
A Scattering of Light takes you to Colonial Virginia and beyond, where a grieving Quaker woman crosses paths with a broken Scottish man whose survival changes everything she thought she understood about faith, purpose, and love.
What I loved most about this story was how it unfolds over time—layer by layer—through split timelines that reveal just how far someone will go for revenge… and what’s left behind for those trying to rebuild after losing everything.
This is a true journey book. One filled with ups and downs, heartbreak and hope, and characters who feel larger than life because of everything they endure. You’re not just reading their story—you’re walking through it with them.
The historical detail is rich and immersive. From colonial America to Scotland, the settings feel vivid and lived-in, giving you a glimpse into lives and struggles so different from our own. The language/accents might take a few chapters to get used to (they are strongly written), but after a few chapters you should get into a flow.
And at its core, this is a story of redemption. Of learning to trust God even when life doesn’t make sense. Of choosing forgiveness when bitterness might feel easier. Those themes were woven in so beautifully and gave the story a deeper meaning that really stayed with me.
If you love historicals similar to A. L. Sowards, this is absolutely one to add to your list.
This one is available now!
Happy Reading📚
Content/Trigger: mention of suicide, mention of a married couple waking up together, mild suspense/peril/violence, revenge/redemption/forgiveness themes, romance—kisses only
June 13, 2026
I loved the characters in this story. Lori Benton does a fantastic job at pulling your heartstrings while also showing hope and light.
The early American history mixed with Scotland roots was a great pairing. I especially loved how it all wrapped up.
*Thank you to the author for a complimentary book. All thoughts are always my own.
The early American history mixed with Scotland roots was a great pairing. I especially loved how it all wrapped up.
*Thank you to the author for a complimentary book. All thoughts are always my own.
April 19, 2026
(I received a complimentary copy of this title. All opinions expressed are my own.)
Lori Benton is a beloved author, so please excuse the three stars I gave this book—this is obviously a me problem!
I loved the settings of this book: Isle of Skye (Scotland) and Colonial Virginia! This book is set in the mid 1730’s in the years leading up to the French Indian War and the American Revolution after that.
This story is told in dual POV and also in multiple timelines. I love it when stories are written this way!
One thing I really appreciated was the way the author wove faith throughout the story—especially about God’s sovereignty, grace, and goodness, even in trying times and circumstances.
I really loved the characters individually, but I’m afraid I didn’t love them as much as a couple. I just didn’t find their love believable! (I don’t want to say more without spoiling.)
Additionally, I normally love when an author writes in an accent or uses some proper language for the time/setting, but this time it brought me out of the story often and made it difficult for me to understand some conversations—again, a me problem. :)
Even though this story wasn’t for me, I know it’s going to be a new favorite for lots of readers, and I would still absolutely recommend the story based on reader preferences.
Lori Benton is a beloved author, so please excuse the three stars I gave this book—this is obviously a me problem!
I loved the settings of this book: Isle of Skye (Scotland) and Colonial Virginia! This book is set in the mid 1730’s in the years leading up to the French Indian War and the American Revolution after that.
This story is told in dual POV and also in multiple timelines. I love it when stories are written this way!
One thing I really appreciated was the way the author wove faith throughout the story—especially about God’s sovereignty, grace, and goodness, even in trying times and circumstances.
I really loved the characters individually, but I’m afraid I didn’t love them as much as a couple. I just didn’t find their love believable! (I don’t want to say more without spoiling.)
Additionally, I normally love when an author writes in an accent or uses some proper language for the time/setting, but this time it brought me out of the story often and made it difficult for me to understand some conversations—again, a me problem. :)
Even though this story wasn’t for me, I know it’s going to be a new favorite for lots of readers, and I would still absolutely recommend the story based on reader preferences.
May 10, 2026
Benton writes with such METICULOUS detail and feeling. This story absolutely swept me into the time and place whether in Scotland or Virginia. The characters are so real I feel like I should be able to look them up to learn more. DO listen to some lute music as part of this experience. Exquisite.
Also, THANK YOU Lori for the reappearance of a certain character late in the story. I think you'll know which one I mean when you get there.
Also, THANK YOU Lori for the reappearance of a certain character late in the story. I think you'll know which one I mean when you get there.
March 26, 2026
Lori, please don’t read this review. I love your books, I really do!
This book took me a long while to get into. I ended up skipping the prologue and that seemed to help. I enjoyed the story for the most part, however, I would not consider this a romance at all. I honestly didn’t like Verity and Will together or believe that they were in love. Will spent most of the book pining for his missing, then dead, wife. There was zero indication that they had any sort of feelings for each other until the very end. Maybe I glossed over them falling in love because the story dragged on so long.
Lori Benton is one of my favorite authors. I own and have read all of her adult books. I absolutely love her writing, unfortunately this book did not feel like her others. Her books always wreck me and put me back together. I usually love her characters and root for them. This book, while dealing with heavy topics, felt very surface level. It didn’t feel as deeply emotional as her books. I don’t think the characters were fleshed out very well and seemed very 1 dimensional. I was honestly bored through most of this book and I hate that. I was so looking forward to this. Maybe I built it up too much in my own mind.
*I was sent a complimentary copy with no expectation for a favorable review.
This book took me a long while to get into. I ended up skipping the prologue and that seemed to help. I enjoyed the story for the most part, however, I would not consider this a romance at all. I honestly didn’t like Verity and Will together or believe that they were in love. Will spent most of the book pining for his missing, then dead, wife. There was zero indication that they had any sort of feelings for each other until the very end. Maybe I glossed over them falling in love because the story dragged on so long.
Lori Benton is one of my favorite authors. I own and have read all of her adult books. I absolutely love her writing, unfortunately this book did not feel like her others. Her books always wreck me and put me back together. I usually love her characters and root for them. This book, while dealing with heavy topics, felt very surface level. It didn’t feel as deeply emotional as her books. I don’t think the characters were fleshed out very well and seemed very 1 dimensional. I was honestly bored through most of this book and I hate that. I was so looking forward to this. Maybe I built it up too much in my own mind.
*I was sent a complimentary copy with no expectation for a favorable review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 9, 2026
This is a difficult book to review.
Ever since I first read Lori Benton’s book, “The Wood’s Edge”, she became my favorite author—hands down.
I’ve yet to find another Christian author who has the ability to weave words and phrases and the raw beauty of the gospel of Jesus into a story the way she does.
She is a gifted writer in so many ways and reading her books are a blessing and such a treat.
When I heard about this book’s up-and-coming release, I immediately jumped on Amazon and preordered a copy. If Lori Benton is involved, making a purchase is more like muscle memory than anything.
I don’t think, I DO. Add to cart. Place order. Try not to obsess over the slow passing of time until her latest book is released.
I want to state plainly how much I respect and admire Lori Benton as a gifted author and fellow Christian.
Her earliest books will always have a permanent place on my bookshelf.
As for this book….
It didn’t speak to me the way Lori’s other books do.
The characters didn’t feel fleshed out like Reginald, Lydia, Anna, William, Good Robe, Two Hawks and so many others did in “The Wood’s Edge”.
While I don’t mind a slower paced book that takes its time in unfolding, this one was so slow-paced that I had a hard time getting through some parts of the story.
Some of the backstory between Will and Simon, Verity and Michael felt laborious. Also, I personally felt like this story contained too many subplots. Treasure, murder, banishment, suicide that was—yet again—another murder, child abduction, a missing Indian, etc.
It wasn’t enough that Simon hated Will and wanted Jenny for himself. Somehow he went full psychopath and decided to murder her father by poisoning, have Will and Jenny banished, then steal their treasure.
Likewise, it wasn’t enough that Michael Lanier’s pride was wounded by Verity’s repeated rejections of his marriage proposals. For reasons unknown, he went off the deep end by murdering her twin brother, stealing a baby that wasn’t his, trying to steal some of the treasure, shooting and beating Will nearly to death, then fleeing.
Lastly, I just couldn’t connect to Verity and Will.
I really tried. But neither one of them made me feel much of anything. Verity was plain and simple.
Will was angry and bitter. Nothing about them made me feel like they were truly in love or felt anything other than indifference towards each other.
Their love story felt so stiff and unbelievable.
They SAID they loved each other, but nothing they did showed it. And I need showing more than telling.
I wanted to love this book. I wanted to gush about it to my family and friends and pass it along to the next person who, like me, loves all things Lori Benton.
Unfortunately, this book didn’t provoke that level of interest or excitement. I’m giving this book ⭐️ ⭐️ because I will always have respect for Lori’s work and her unparalleled talent as a wordsmith.
I wish this book had contained less subplots, and that more of Verity and Will’s romantic story had been fleshed out in a believable way.
Ever since I first read Lori Benton’s book, “The Wood’s Edge”, she became my favorite author—hands down.
I’ve yet to find another Christian author who has the ability to weave words and phrases and the raw beauty of the gospel of Jesus into a story the way she does.
She is a gifted writer in so many ways and reading her books are a blessing and such a treat.
When I heard about this book’s up-and-coming release, I immediately jumped on Amazon and preordered a copy. If Lori Benton is involved, making a purchase is more like muscle memory than anything.
I don’t think, I DO. Add to cart. Place order. Try not to obsess over the slow passing of time until her latest book is released.
I want to state plainly how much I respect and admire Lori Benton as a gifted author and fellow Christian.
Her earliest books will always have a permanent place on my bookshelf.
As for this book….
It didn’t speak to me the way Lori’s other books do.
The characters didn’t feel fleshed out like Reginald, Lydia, Anna, William, Good Robe, Two Hawks and so many others did in “The Wood’s Edge”.
While I don’t mind a slower paced book that takes its time in unfolding, this one was so slow-paced that I had a hard time getting through some parts of the story.
Some of the backstory between Will and Simon, Verity and Michael felt laborious. Also, I personally felt like this story contained too many subplots. Treasure, murder, banishment, suicide that was—yet again—another murder, child abduction, a missing Indian, etc.
It wasn’t enough that Simon hated Will and wanted Jenny for himself. Somehow he went full psychopath and decided to murder her father by poisoning, have Will and Jenny banished, then steal their treasure.
Likewise, it wasn’t enough that Michael Lanier’s pride was wounded by Verity’s repeated rejections of his marriage proposals. For reasons unknown, he went off the deep end by murdering her twin brother, stealing a baby that wasn’t his, trying to steal some of the treasure, shooting and beating Will nearly to death, then fleeing.
Lastly, I just couldn’t connect to Verity and Will.
I really tried. But neither one of them made me feel much of anything. Verity was plain and simple.
Will was angry and bitter. Nothing about them made me feel like they were truly in love or felt anything other than indifference towards each other.
Their love story felt so stiff and unbelievable.
They SAID they loved each other, but nothing they did showed it. And I need showing more than telling.
I wanted to love this book. I wanted to gush about it to my family and friends and pass it along to the next person who, like me, loves all things Lori Benton.
Unfortunately, this book didn’t provoke that level of interest or excitement. I’m giving this book ⭐️ ⭐️ because I will always have respect for Lori’s work and her unparalleled talent as a wordsmith.
I wish this book had contained less subplots, and that more of Verity and Will’s romantic story had been fleshed out in a believable way.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 20, 2026
I have been a Lori Benton fan for a long time. Well since her first book released years ago I suppose. I was SO excited to dive into this new adventure and this is terrific historical fiction. I emphasize the historical. This is a realistic portrayal of lives in the 1720s-1730s. I love the heart of the heroine, Verity. I love how the characters grow in their faith in the Lord when life throws unimaginable hardships into their path.
The plot kept me guessing at times and the story bittersweet.
I really enjoyed and I am eager for her next book!
The plot kept me guessing at times and the story bittersweet.
I really enjoyed and I am eager for her next book!
June 11, 2026
“His blessings freely scattered like light—readily seen if one didn’t close her eyes for fear of the darkness.”
If you are a fan of Christian historical fiction by Laura Frantz, Michelle Griep, or Shannon McNear, you will love Lori Benton. I first read her books years ago, but this book, A Scattering of Light, has been percolating for many years. I, for one, am ecstatic to re-welcome Lori Benton back to the historical romance world.
Benton re-enters with a smash-hit! A young Scotsman ( Will Crockett) is rescued from certain death aboard a slaver ship and his indenture sold to a young VA Quaker woman (Verity Wilde) and her musical, odd father. When Will actually survives, Verity must rethink his place on their small plantation. Will has but one thought on his mind, that of his wife, Jenny, who was conscripted with him, but who is unaccounted for.
A Scattering of Light is such a rich book it’s hard to know where to begin to describe it! It is full of diverse 18th century characters and their different levels of faith (from deep, hope-filled faith to none at all). The writing itself is both lyrical and dialect- rich. While there is plenty of action, the novel is also very character-driven. Will, with his take on righting wrongs and taking revenge, has to learn that man’s plans are not final. What a different story this would have been if they were. Jenny, kept apart from her husband, but a staunch believer, bids both Will and Verity via letter to trust the Almighty. “If all we ever dreamt for ourselves came true, but God was no’ in it … ’twould prove the worse for us.” Jenny trusts God with an impossible situation. Will retains an anger at God for the longest time. Verity, a professing Quaker, while kind and merciful,holds herself as spiritually superior to any who don’t keep exactly to her rigid beliefs. Again, Jenny with her soft ways and firm belief wears down some of the hardness of Verity’s heart. And, Verity’s friend whom she is constantly writing in the book, reminds her that in her severe observance of being “Plain,” she may be denying herself some of the blessings God has for her. “Was her hesitance not the godly prudence she believed it to be, but merely indication of what Jane cautioned her against? Rejecting God’s good gifts.”
These characters! So many great, noble ones that I loved. Great secondary supporting characters include Verity’s father Christopher, her father’s niece, Lucy Many-Beads and Judah Looking-Wolf. Each is such a great support to Verity. While Christopher himself shows great growth in this novel, I am hoping for a story that tells more of Judah’s future.
Do yourself a huge favor and read this book! I bought an ebook and also a paperback for the keeper shelf. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Will kent the look—the burden of not knowing, a grief not fully embraced, therefore never allowed to heal.” - Will
“I’d long held the Almighty to account for all I’ve lost, as though he was beholden to do my will, no’ the other way ’round.” - Will
“…my Religion is become a List of Works to perform, and those through more willing Hands, a far cry from what thee possesses, a Faith that shines in the Face of Losses as grievous as my own.” - Verity
“God always makes a way forward—and nearer to Him. Oft ’tis the hard things that work the greatest good in that way.” -Jenny
“Everywhere I turn I see the Almighty’s blessings, and as he never changes, why should the future worry me? Whatever we need, he’ll see it provided.” -Jenny
If you are a fan of Christian historical fiction by Laura Frantz, Michelle Griep, or Shannon McNear, you will love Lori Benton. I first read her books years ago, but this book, A Scattering of Light, has been percolating for many years. I, for one, am ecstatic to re-welcome Lori Benton back to the historical romance world.
Benton re-enters with a smash-hit! A young Scotsman ( Will Crockett) is rescued from certain death aboard a slaver ship and his indenture sold to a young VA Quaker woman (Verity Wilde) and her musical, odd father. When Will actually survives, Verity must rethink his place on their small plantation. Will has but one thought on his mind, that of his wife, Jenny, who was conscripted with him, but who is unaccounted for.
A Scattering of Light is such a rich book it’s hard to know where to begin to describe it! It is full of diverse 18th century characters and their different levels of faith (from deep, hope-filled faith to none at all). The writing itself is both lyrical and dialect- rich. While there is plenty of action, the novel is also very character-driven. Will, with his take on righting wrongs and taking revenge, has to learn that man’s plans are not final. What a different story this would have been if they were. Jenny, kept apart from her husband, but a staunch believer, bids both Will and Verity via letter to trust the Almighty. “If all we ever dreamt for ourselves came true, but God was no’ in it … ’twould prove the worse for us.” Jenny trusts God with an impossible situation. Will retains an anger at God for the longest time. Verity, a professing Quaker, while kind and merciful,holds herself as spiritually superior to any who don’t keep exactly to her rigid beliefs. Again, Jenny with her soft ways and firm belief wears down some of the hardness of Verity’s heart. And, Verity’s friend whom she is constantly writing in the book, reminds her that in her severe observance of being “Plain,” she may be denying herself some of the blessings God has for her. “Was her hesitance not the godly prudence she believed it to be, but merely indication of what Jane cautioned her against? Rejecting God’s good gifts.”
These characters! So many great, noble ones that I loved. Great secondary supporting characters include Verity’s father Christopher, her father’s niece, Lucy Many-Beads and Judah Looking-Wolf. Each is such a great support to Verity. While Christopher himself shows great growth in this novel, I am hoping for a story that tells more of Judah’s future.
Do yourself a huge favor and read this book! I bought an ebook and also a paperback for the keeper shelf. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Notable Quotables:
“Will kent the look—the burden of not knowing, a grief not fully embraced, therefore never allowed to heal.” - Will
“I’d long held the Almighty to account for all I’ve lost, as though he was beholden to do my will, no’ the other way ’round.” - Will
“…my Religion is become a List of Works to perform, and those through more willing Hands, a far cry from what thee possesses, a Faith that shines in the Face of Losses as grievous as my own.” - Verity
“God always makes a way forward—and nearer to Him. Oft ’tis the hard things that work the greatest good in that way.” -Jenny
“Everywhere I turn I see the Almighty’s blessings, and as he never changes, why should the future worry me? Whatever we need, he’ll see it provided.” -Jenny
April 18, 2026
Hidden treasure, shocking betrayals, surprising twists, redemption, & second chance romance made A Scattering of Light unforgettable! Once I got into this inspirational historical saga, I found myself eagerly turning the pages. From the Isle of Skye to Virginia, Lori Benton weaves a compelling story with endearing characters, achingly sweet romance, & faith.
In 1734 Colonial Virginia, Verity Wilde has essentially isolated herself from her fellow Quakers & Williamsburg society after her brother’s tragic death. In need of a new clerk, she boards a ship from Scotland to claim her indentured servant, but also spies another Scotsman left for dead. Mercy & compassion drive her to rescue him & care for him until he dies. Instead, under her careful ministrations, he recovers. The handsome William Wallace Crockett proves a helpful addition to their household, & Verity finds herself drawn to him. But when she learns more of his troubled past, she determines to help him find answers, even if it breaks her heart.
Wow, this was intense! It took me a few chapters to fully grasp everything that was happening, but once I did, I was completely absorbed. The story begins in Scotland in 1721 and shifts between the past & 1734 Virginia. Will Crockett’s life as a drover, his rivalry with a particularly nasty Scotsman, hidden treasure, & courtship with a beautiful woman named Jenny all lead to his present circumstances in Virginia. I loved piecing together the past as events unfolded in the present. Will experiences so much & is truly an honorable man who learns to rely on faith through life’s turmoils.
Verity is such an admirable woman. Though she admires Will, she keeps her heart in check when she learns of his past, & her longing is palpable even as she tries not to show it. She willingly sacrifices everything to help him. I loved seeing her orangery evolve & her sweet, compassionate nature.
The mystery surrounding her brother’s death, along with Will’s treasure & past, weaves a spellbinding story that kept me riveted. I also enjoyed the side characters, who added so much. Looking forward to continuing this amazing story.
Highly recommend to historical fiction & Laura Frantz fans! I received an advanced copy from the author but also purchased in Kindle Unlimited. All opinions are completely my own & provided voluntarily.
In 1734 Colonial Virginia, Verity Wilde has essentially isolated herself from her fellow Quakers & Williamsburg society after her brother’s tragic death. In need of a new clerk, she boards a ship from Scotland to claim her indentured servant, but also spies another Scotsman left for dead. Mercy & compassion drive her to rescue him & care for him until he dies. Instead, under her careful ministrations, he recovers. The handsome William Wallace Crockett proves a helpful addition to their household, & Verity finds herself drawn to him. But when she learns more of his troubled past, she determines to help him find answers, even if it breaks her heart.
Wow, this was intense! It took me a few chapters to fully grasp everything that was happening, but once I did, I was completely absorbed. The story begins in Scotland in 1721 and shifts between the past & 1734 Virginia. Will Crockett’s life as a drover, his rivalry with a particularly nasty Scotsman, hidden treasure, & courtship with a beautiful woman named Jenny all lead to his present circumstances in Virginia. I loved piecing together the past as events unfolded in the present. Will experiences so much & is truly an honorable man who learns to rely on faith through life’s turmoils.
Verity is such an admirable woman. Though she admires Will, she keeps her heart in check when she learns of his past, & her longing is palpable even as she tries not to show it. She willingly sacrifices everything to help him. I loved seeing her orangery evolve & her sweet, compassionate nature.
The mystery surrounding her brother’s death, along with Will’s treasure & past, weaves a spellbinding story that kept me riveted. I also enjoyed the side characters, who added so much. Looking forward to continuing this amazing story.
Highly recommend to historical fiction & Laura Frantz fans! I received an advanced copy from the author but also purchased in Kindle Unlimited. All opinions are completely my own & provided voluntarily.
April 14, 2026
I discovered Lori Benton not long after I joined the bookstagram community. The first book I read became an immediate all time favorite. I proceeded to purchase all of her backlist, read them voraciously, tell all of my friends that they had to read her, and gushed endlessly on my IG about her ability to fill my heart and touch my soul with her beautifully written words.
Her new release, A Scattering of Light, the first book of her series Crockett’s Landing, is a tale that takes us from the breathtaking shores of Scotland to the equally stunning colonial Virginia and the heart of Appalachia, the Blue Ridge Mountains. The settings alone makes my heart smile. Lori’s rich descriptions and immersive writing bring the past to life in a most vivid way.
Verity Wilde, a Quaker woman who has endured much loss and heartache, becomes a Good Samaritan when she discovers a man clinging to life on board the ship that brings her the indentured servant who is to help with her father’s business. The man, William Wallace Crockett, IV, has been left for dead by the captain and Verity begs purchase of his indenture as well, in an act of compassion, knowing his life will not be long for this world.
Yet, Willam proves determined to not leave this world. As he regains his consciousness and bearing, the gravity of his situation and depravity of his unwilling arrival in the new world is a shock to all. This chance encounter between Verity and William sets the course for danger, discovery, and a plan designed by good and faithful God.
Lori’s historicals are driven by an intriguing plot, where imperfect characters learn to rely on a perfect God. Her romances are organic and tender. The friendships uplifting and inspiring.
I will say in this story the romance is unusual and understated, as Verity and William have a complicated journey. But it is still satisfying and fulfilling in the end.
Thank you, Lori, for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
Christian Fiction
Historical Fiction
Colonial Fiction
Frontier Fiction
Her new release, A Scattering of Light, the first book of her series Crockett’s Landing, is a tale that takes us from the breathtaking shores of Scotland to the equally stunning colonial Virginia and the heart of Appalachia, the Blue Ridge Mountains. The settings alone makes my heart smile. Lori’s rich descriptions and immersive writing bring the past to life in a most vivid way.
Verity Wilde, a Quaker woman who has endured much loss and heartache, becomes a Good Samaritan when she discovers a man clinging to life on board the ship that brings her the indentured servant who is to help with her father’s business. The man, William Wallace Crockett, IV, has been left for dead by the captain and Verity begs purchase of his indenture as well, in an act of compassion, knowing his life will not be long for this world.
Yet, Willam proves determined to not leave this world. As he regains his consciousness and bearing, the gravity of his situation and depravity of his unwilling arrival in the new world is a shock to all. This chance encounter between Verity and William sets the course for danger, discovery, and a plan designed by good and faithful God.
Lori’s historicals are driven by an intriguing plot, where imperfect characters learn to rely on a perfect God. Her romances are organic and tender. The friendships uplifting and inspiring.
I will say in this story the romance is unusual and understated, as Verity and William have a complicated journey. But it is still satisfying and fulfilling in the end.
Thank you, Lori, for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
Christian Fiction
Historical Fiction
Colonial Fiction
Frontier Fiction
April 13, 2026
3.5 stars rounded to 4!
A faith-filled adventure story that spans the distance from Scotland to Colonial Virginia.
As always, Lori Benton delivers a truly unique tale that brims with rich historical detail and strong faith themes that edify and educate as well as entertain. I especially enjoyed the strong salvation message we get to witness because of the male protagonist.
Grieving quaker Verity only bought ailing Will Crocket's indenture out of compassion because she wanted to ease his suffering during his last moments on earth. But when he survives, he finds his life has been stripped of all he once held dear. It is up to Verity to help him regain what was taken from him, but the way forward will require them both to place their faith in God--and in each other. But only the True Light can shine through the darkness and work good from even their greatest struggles.
I enjoyed this book overall and would describe it as a clean historical fiction/romance that I'd recommend to lovers of Colonial history, Scottish history, and historical Christian fiction in general. There are some twists and turns throughout, and the romance between the main characters is a very slow-burn--so slow, you wonder if it will ever happen! I like that it broke the predictable romance mold in that way. I also appreciate the Christian themes of salvation, trusting God when things don't go our way, rejecting greed, forgiving those who have wronged us, putting others above ourselves, and finding God's peace and joy in the midst of grief.
Objectionable content: A character's suicide is referenced throughout the book. There is some violence. A married couple shares a moment in bed, but nothing happens on page. A side-character is said to have become pregnant after a SA.
Special thanks to Lori Benton for the early copy in exchange for this review! Looking forward to the next books in the series!
A faith-filled adventure story that spans the distance from Scotland to Colonial Virginia.
As always, Lori Benton delivers a truly unique tale that brims with rich historical detail and strong faith themes that edify and educate as well as entertain. I especially enjoyed the strong salvation message we get to witness because of the male protagonist.
Grieving quaker Verity only bought ailing Will Crocket's indenture out of compassion because she wanted to ease his suffering during his last moments on earth. But when he survives, he finds his life has been stripped of all he once held dear. It is up to Verity to help him regain what was taken from him, but the way forward will require them both to place their faith in God--and in each other. But only the True Light can shine through the darkness and work good from even their greatest struggles.
I enjoyed this book overall and would describe it as a clean historical fiction/romance that I'd recommend to lovers of Colonial history, Scottish history, and historical Christian fiction in general. There are some twists and turns throughout, and the romance between the main characters is a very slow-burn--so slow, you wonder if it will ever happen! I like that it broke the predictable romance mold in that way. I also appreciate the Christian themes of salvation, trusting God when things don't go our way, rejecting greed, forgiving those who have wronged us, putting others above ourselves, and finding God's peace and joy in the midst of grief.
Objectionable content: A character's suicide is referenced throughout the book. There is some violence. A married couple shares a moment in bed, but nothing happens on page. A side-character is said to have become pregnant after a SA.
Special thanks to Lori Benton for the early copy in exchange for this review! Looking forward to the next books in the series!
May 5, 2026
"His blessings freely scattered like light - readily seen if one didn't close her eyes for fear of the darkness."
When Scottish drover Will Crockett gains consciousness on a different continent, it is gravely apparent that he has lost everything dear to his heart. Under the roof of a kind young Quaker woman by the name of Verity Wilde, Will discovers that he was indentured to the Wildes as a way of saving his life, although Verity originally sought only to grant him a compassionate death and burial, for he barely had breath when they scooped him up off the deck of the ship that had delivered him to colonial Virginia. Miraculously, he lived.
Like Will, Verity had suffered great loss and was at an impasse about how to move forward in her life. Her strict religious parameters were a stark contrast to Will's obvious discomfort of all things pertaining to the Almighty, yet both are constrained by misconceptions of their own choosing. As circumstances continue to unravel outside the bounds of their every desire, can the two battered souls perceive the scatterings of light, God's abundant blessings relentlessly peeking through the shrouds of darkness, begging them to navigate beyond what they see, and hold fast to the truth of "every good and perfect gift . . . comes from the Father of lights".
While this story took awhile to develop, it was time well spent, for it was a story meant to savor rather than taste and to absorb rather than simply acknowledge. The character development was exceptional, the author giving her portrayals plenty of time to both succeed and fail, toil and rest, sympathize and adore. And for those still wondering if the darkness ever conquers the light, the message is clear, it does not.
A fabulous book with incredible depth and profound spiritual impact!
When Scottish drover Will Crockett gains consciousness on a different continent, it is gravely apparent that he has lost everything dear to his heart. Under the roof of a kind young Quaker woman by the name of Verity Wilde, Will discovers that he was indentured to the Wildes as a way of saving his life, although Verity originally sought only to grant him a compassionate death and burial, for he barely had breath when they scooped him up off the deck of the ship that had delivered him to colonial Virginia. Miraculously, he lived.
Like Will, Verity had suffered great loss and was at an impasse about how to move forward in her life. Her strict religious parameters were a stark contrast to Will's obvious discomfort of all things pertaining to the Almighty, yet both are constrained by misconceptions of their own choosing. As circumstances continue to unravel outside the bounds of their every desire, can the two battered souls perceive the scatterings of light, God's abundant blessings relentlessly peeking through the shrouds of darkness, begging them to navigate beyond what they see, and hold fast to the truth of "every good and perfect gift . . . comes from the Father of lights".
While this story took awhile to develop, it was time well spent, for it was a story meant to savor rather than taste and to absorb rather than simply acknowledge. The character development was exceptional, the author giving her portrayals plenty of time to both succeed and fail, toil and rest, sympathize and adore. And for those still wondering if the darkness ever conquers the light, the message is clear, it does not.
A fabulous book with incredible depth and profound spiritual impact!
Review of advance copy received from Author
In this book, Lori Benton pens such an epic tale of loss, grief, redemption, and faith with unforgettable characters and sweeping and majestic backdrops. I loved how the story flowed in dips and swells, like I was hearing this lore sitting by a roaring fire, told by a master storyteller. 1734 Scotland was beautiful but life was not easy there. I appreciated how the dialogue stayed true to the dialect though it took me a few chapters to get acclimated. 1734 Virginia was fascinating and I enjoyed learning about brickmaking and also about the way of the Quakers. The installation of an orangery was wildly imaginative and it was exciting to see Verity's success with it. Verity was a lovely heroine - tender, loyal, determined, and hard-working. How she learned to repent and forgive and grow deeper in her faith was inspiring. Will was an atypical hero; he wasn't an alpha male but easily moved by emotion, impulsive yet protective and fiercely loyal. Will's salvation moved me to tears. The whole cast of secondary characters - Jenny, Christopher, Lucy, Judah, Rob and even Hamish - was wonderful and how God moved in each and every person's life was wondrous to behold. I'm hoping for a story about Judah next....
I received a complimentary copy courtesy of the author and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy courtesy of the author and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
April 30, 2026
William Wallace Crockett is a Scottish drover wrongfully stolen away from his home and left for dead, his freedom sold for a pittance. Verity Wilde is a young Quaker woman, who has mercy on his situation taking him into her household.
A compelling story of betrayal, loss, and God's providence. Verity carries the weight of her brother's death, while helping her father in his business. Verity has dreams, as well as a big heart for others. Judah is a wise and loyal family member, who walks the line between his two heritages, I like dhis protectiveness of Verity and his friendship with Will.
A rugged and realistic view of early America, full of promise and hope in a wild and untamed land. Will is determined and hardworking, a clever young man full of dreams and the grit to make them come true. I liked how Jenny gently encourages him, while gracefully enduring the hardships as they came.
Overall, a compelling novel that takes us from the hills of Scotland to colonial Virginia. Filled with heartache, and loss, but also inspiring courage and sacrifice, with a solid core of faith. A well told story, that brings to life early America in a story of betrayal, faith, and hope. Definitely recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
A compelling story of betrayal, loss, and God's providence. Verity carries the weight of her brother's death, while helping her father in his business. Verity has dreams, as well as a big heart for others. Judah is a wise and loyal family member, who walks the line between his two heritages, I like dhis protectiveness of Verity and his friendship with Will.
A rugged and realistic view of early America, full of promise and hope in a wild and untamed land. Will is determined and hardworking, a clever young man full of dreams and the grit to make them come true. I liked how Jenny gently encourages him, while gracefully enduring the hardships as they came.
Overall, a compelling novel that takes us from the hills of Scotland to colonial Virginia. Filled with heartache, and loss, but also inspiring courage and sacrifice, with a solid core of faith. A well told story, that brings to life early America in a story of betrayal, faith, and hope. Definitely recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I think this is the first time I have ever had a true book hangover. I have no desire to read anything else. Except maybe another Lori Benton book.
Some of the novel is set in Scotland with most of it set in the U.S. in Virginia. There are some Scottish words, a couple I already knew and some I had to look up. I can't wait to hear the audiobook! But Lori Benton's writing is always beautiful and her word usage is never simplistic. Her research is impeccable, so her historical terminology is accurate.
The plot - oh my. There were a few surprises. I had goosebumps. I don't cry at the sad parts of books, I cry at the "God moments," aka the plot twist, the reveal or the breakthrough. I cried at least 3 times. I can't even share my favorite quote that made me bawl because it's a spoiler. But now it's even swoony. Sigh.
The heart of this story is Jesus. Characters share their struggles and their faith. They encourage each other, disciple and witness to others. They offer forgiveness, and they truly care about others. They change lives because of and for Jesus.
A Scattering of Light will definitely be one of my top reads this year! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
I received an early copy of this book from the author. Opinions are my own.
Some of the novel is set in Scotland with most of it set in the U.S. in Virginia. There are some Scottish words, a couple I already knew and some I had to look up. I can't wait to hear the audiobook! But Lori Benton's writing is always beautiful and her word usage is never simplistic. Her research is impeccable, so her historical terminology is accurate.
The plot - oh my. There were a few surprises. I had goosebumps. I don't cry at the sad parts of books, I cry at the "God moments," aka the plot twist, the reveal or the breakthrough. I cried at least 3 times. I can't even share my favorite quote that made me bawl because it's a spoiler. But now it's even swoony. Sigh.
The heart of this story is Jesus. Characters share their struggles and their faith. They encourage each other, disciple and witness to others. They offer forgiveness, and they truly care about others. They change lives because of and for Jesus.
A Scattering of Light will definitely be one of my top reads this year! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!
I received an early copy of this book from the author. Opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
"I’ll go—and trust to God, as Sarah did with Abraham—only saying this last on the matter. The mind of a man plans his way, but the Lord directs his steps.”
I was completely blown away with this phenomenal, hauntingly beautiful tale by masterful wordsmith, Lori Benton—exemplifying the power of forgiveness, the innocent intensity of a first and everlasting love, and two souls wounded by devastating loss.
A lovely and virtuous Quaker, Verity Wilde, purchases the indenture of Scottish drover, William Crockett, and inadvertently changes the course of both of their lives. Verity endeavors to live a life unspotted by the world by serving others, while Will pretty much exists solely for his sweet, godly Jenny . . . a young woman he loves with every fiber of his being.
An expertly researched and brilliantly written novel set in colonial Virginia—this unpredictable story deals with bitterness, grief, despair, and broken pasts—joyously healed by God's love and redemptive power! Highly recommend!
*I received an ARC of this book & was not required to write a positive review & no monies or discounts were exchanged. I posted my honest opinion.*
I was completely blown away with this phenomenal, hauntingly beautiful tale by masterful wordsmith, Lori Benton—exemplifying the power of forgiveness, the innocent intensity of a first and everlasting love, and two souls wounded by devastating loss.
A lovely and virtuous Quaker, Verity Wilde, purchases the indenture of Scottish drover, William Crockett, and inadvertently changes the course of both of their lives. Verity endeavors to live a life unspotted by the world by serving others, while Will pretty much exists solely for his sweet, godly Jenny . . . a young woman he loves with every fiber of his being.
An expertly researched and brilliantly written novel set in colonial Virginia—this unpredictable story deals with bitterness, grief, despair, and broken pasts—joyously healed by God's love and redemptive power! Highly recommend!
*I received an ARC of this book & was not required to write a positive review & no monies or discounts were exchanged. I posted my honest opinion.*
April 18, 2026
I'm very happy to read a new Lori Benton novel!
I'm not sure that I would call this book a romance (in case that's what you're looking for); there is some romance, but the story is very character-driven. Both Verity and Will have quite a journey - grief, anger at God, fear. And I never expected some of the events of the middle of the book; I was expecting a typical romantic journey for them, and this very much wasn't. It was good; just not at all what romantic fiction has taught me to expect.
I enjoyed Verity's eclectic household; she a Quaker, her adoptive father a brilliant if socially anxious musician, her practical Cherokee aunt a lover of colonial fashion, her half-breed cousin divided between two worlds yet a steady rock on which the family leans.
Assuming there are more Crockett's Landing novels to come, I hope we get Judah Looking Wolf's story - he's one of my favorite side characters, and his mother is quite the entertaining character. I could do with spending more time with her too!
I'm not sure that I would call this book a romance (in case that's what you're looking for); there is some romance, but the story is very character-driven. Both Verity and Will have quite a journey - grief, anger at God, fear. And I never expected some of the events of the middle of the book; I was expecting a typical romantic journey for them, and this very much wasn't. It was good; just not at all what romantic fiction has taught me to expect.
I enjoyed Verity's eclectic household; she a Quaker, her adoptive father a brilliant if socially anxious musician, her practical Cherokee aunt a lover of colonial fashion, her half-breed cousin divided between two worlds yet a steady rock on which the family leans.
Assuming there are more Crockett's Landing novels to come, I hope we get Judah Looking Wolf's story - he's one of my favorite side characters, and his mother is quite the entertaining character. I could do with spending more time with her too!
April 27, 2026
Another Amazing Book!
I am glad I read it! This was not just any book but it was a beautiful journey through the past, through a period that came to life through words that could transcend time and geographical boundaries. I have never been to Scotland, nor seen the mountains of Virginia but through this well written story I can actually see these places when I close my eyes.
Most importantly was how Lori was able to portray the different stages of faith in our path through life. I loved Jenny‘s faith. Her faith was astounding and a marvel. Our Lord marveled at the Centurion‘s faith and I marveled at Jenny‘s faith. She was actually the star of the show although all the characters were all so brilliantly created and portrayed.
I would have loved to hear more of Christopher Wilde‘s story and I hope Lori will bring this soft but I believe very strong character back as the star of the show.
I hold my breath as I wait for Lori‘s next book. I pray the Almighty will give her another story to witness to the world the love of our Savior.
I am glad I read it! This was not just any book but it was a beautiful journey through the past, through a period that came to life through words that could transcend time and geographical boundaries. I have never been to Scotland, nor seen the mountains of Virginia but through this well written story I can actually see these places when I close my eyes.
Most importantly was how Lori was able to portray the different stages of faith in our path through life. I loved Jenny‘s faith. Her faith was astounding and a marvel. Our Lord marveled at the Centurion‘s faith and I marveled at Jenny‘s faith. She was actually the star of the show although all the characters were all so brilliantly created and portrayed.
I would have loved to hear more of Christopher Wilde‘s story and I hope Lori will bring this soft but I believe very strong character back as the star of the show.
I hold my breath as I wait for Lori‘s next book. I pray the Almighty will give her another story to witness to the world the love of our Savior.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
A Scattering of Light
Lori Benton
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Verity Wilde has isolated herself from Williamsburg society following the death of her beloved brother. When she accompanies her father to claim an indentured Scottish clerk from a ship, she encounters a Scotsman, seriously ill, and left for dead on deck. Determined to provide the stranger a measure of comfort in his final hours, Verity purchases his indenture as well. But under Verity's care, William Crockett begins to regain health and strength. He awakens to a very different life than the one he left on the Isle of Skye, and turns upside down the uncomplicated life Verity had chosen for herself.
This novel showed the peace God can provide in the life of a Christian who is completely walking in His light. Difficult hardships are not removed but trusting in His goodness makes it possible to bear them and lights the way for others. Unbelief and fear create barriers that block that light, but God waits patiently to shine His truth in the darkness.
Readers of Benton's earlier novels will notice mentions of some familiar characters and locations.
We received an advance copy of the book. This is our honest review.
Lori Benton
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Verity Wilde has isolated herself from Williamsburg society following the death of her beloved brother. When she accompanies her father to claim an indentured Scottish clerk from a ship, she encounters a Scotsman, seriously ill, and left for dead on deck. Determined to provide the stranger a measure of comfort in his final hours, Verity purchases his indenture as well. But under Verity's care, William Crockett begins to regain health and strength. He awakens to a very different life than the one he left on the Isle of Skye, and turns upside down the uncomplicated life Verity had chosen for herself.
This novel showed the peace God can provide in the life of a Christian who is completely walking in His light. Difficult hardships are not removed but trusting in His goodness makes it possible to bear them and lights the way for others. Unbelief and fear create barriers that block that light, but God waits patiently to shine His truth in the darkness.
Readers of Benton's earlier novels will notice mentions of some familiar characters and locations.
We received an advance copy of the book. This is our honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Author
“I’ve been eagerly looking forward to Lori Benton’s next novel, and her new release lives up to everything I expected from this author. A narrative that sweeps readers from the Isle of Skye to Virginia, A Scattering of Light is the first book of what promises to be an epic historical romance series of the American frontier in the decades leading up to the French and Indian War. Beautifully envisioned, with evocative depictions of compelling characters set against a background of true historical events and underlaid by deep spiritual themes, A Scattering of Light is a must-read for all lovers of gripping historical fiction. I received a copy of the manuscript from the author for review, and all opinions are my own, freely given.” --J. M. Hochstetler, author of The American Patriot Series
Review of advance copy received from Author
This is a wonderful book about courage, trust, and brokenness, and what it means to be whole, valued, and worthy.
Author Lori Benton introduces us to two broken characters; a young Quaker woman and a Scotsman, and, against the backdrop of 1730s Virginia and the Isle of Skye, shows us the value of kindness and of working together to forge a future. Benton’s amazing sense of time and place allows readers to immediately walk beside her characters. I learned lots about indentured servitude, drovers, courage, trust, practiced my Scottish accent, and finished, thankful for those who allowed God’s light to scatter in my times of darkness.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
Author Lori Benton introduces us to two broken characters; a young Quaker woman and a Scotsman, and, against the backdrop of 1730s Virginia and the Isle of Skye, shows us the value of kindness and of working together to forge a future. Benton’s amazing sense of time and place allows readers to immediately walk beside her characters. I learned lots about indentured servitude, drovers, courage, trust, practiced my Scottish accent, and finished, thankful for those who allowed God’s light to scatter in my times of darkness.
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
July 10, 2026
While Verity Wilde is picking up an indentured servant for the family business, she sees a man left for dead on the deck of the ship. Wanting to provide him with a respectful death, Verity purchases the indenture of William Crockett and takes him back to her home. Only Will doesn't die, changing both of their lives forever.
A Scattering Of Light by Lori Benton is the first book in the new series Crockett's Landing. This historical fiction is set in Colonial Virginia in the mid-1730s, with Will's backstory in Scotland. I spent the first part of this novel thinking there was going to be two couples, so it was difficult to get invested in the romance. I did like the story, and the letter at the end wrapped things up nicely.
I purchased a paperback copy of this book.
A Scattering Of Light by Lori Benton is the first book in the new series Crockett's Landing. This historical fiction is set in Colonial Virginia in the mid-1730s, with Will's backstory in Scotland. I spent the first part of this novel thinking there was going to be two couples, so it was difficult to get invested in the romance. I did like the story, and the letter at the end wrapped things up nicely.
I purchased a paperback copy of this book.
April 6, 2026
Welcome to Williamsburg, Virginia in the 1730s where God is going to weave together the lives of multiple people to serve His greater purpose. This book was incredibly immersive and I appreciated the historical details. The dialogue from the characters matched the time period and their upbringing and really brought them to life. I loved the way the author wove in the Gospel and made faith a central part of this story. I did find the book to drag in some places. I did not always enjoy the long monologues given by some of the characters since it made the story a little harder to follow in my opinion. Overall, I did enjoy this story and would recommend to anyone looking for an immersive Christian historical fiction. 4 stars
I received a copy of the book. All opinions expressed are my own.
I received a copy of the book. All opinions expressed are my own.
May 19, 2026
Lori Benton is a captivating storyteller and this book may be her best so far. From the island of Skye (Scotland) to the mountains of Virginia, she carries us on a vivid journey of hidden treasure, heartbreaking betrayal, unexpected twists, and learning what it means to truly trust in a God who can work all things for good.
The main characters are imperfect and relatable, each struggling in their own way to come to grips with the heartache they’ve suffered. The supporting characters are beautifully varied, adding both depth and balance to the story.
I listened to this one on audiobook and I’m so glad I did. The narration is exceptional! 10 out of 10 recommend.
The main characters are imperfect and relatable, each struggling in their own way to come to grips with the heartache they’ve suffered. The supporting characters are beautifully varied, adding both depth and balance to the story.
I listened to this one on audiobook and I’m so glad I did. The narration is exceptional! 10 out of 10 recommend.
May 26, 2026
The storyline was interesting — particularly life in Williamsburg at this time and the process of growing an orangery.
But it was really hard to get into because of all of Lori's authentic use of Scottish.
I couldn't tell who was speaking — male? female? And I didn't understand what it all meant, which was frustrating.
The story picked up once we reached North America, but there was still confusion for me with names, and now the introduction of another tribe. (Native Americans in this case).
A lot happens in this novel. As a genealogist with family living in Williamsburg at this time, I loved reading about society and life in general.
But it was really hard to get into because of all of Lori's authentic use of Scottish.
I couldn't tell who was speaking — male? female? And I didn't understand what it all meant, which was frustrating.
The story picked up once we reached North America, but there was still confusion for me with names, and now the introduction of another tribe. (Native Americans in this case).
A lot happens in this novel. As a genealogist with family living in Williamsburg at this time, I loved reading about society and life in general.
May 22, 2026
The plot here was hard to follow. Between the different locations, jumping timelines, and speech patterns the beginning was tediously slow.
Beyond that, I don’t understand what would possess the author to have the FMC end up with Will. Why would you think it’s a good idea to write a MMC as a man married to someone else and in love with his wife for 70% of the book? And even in the last part, there is no development of their relationship. Verity did everything for Will and he only looked to her when he was going west and needed a woman and mother for his son. This was no “romance.”
Beyond that, I don’t understand what would possess the author to have the FMC end up with Will. Why would you think it’s a good idea to write a MMC as a man married to someone else and in love with his wife for 70% of the book? And even in the last part, there is no development of their relationship. Verity did everything for Will and he only looked to her when he was going west and needed a woman and mother for his son. This was no “romance.”
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 23, 2026
I’d been looking forward to this new historical fiction by Lori Benton and it was everything that I wanted in a story. To mention just a few things: wonderful characters, an intriguing storyline and historical details. I especially appreciated the realistic struggles of faith which turn into life changing lessons. I enjoyed the depth of the novel with all those splendid layers. I have no idea how she does it, but I can’t wait until she does it again. I’m ready for book 2!
April 23, 2026
always a good story
She’s a good storyteller! And several times during the book I thought, Wait! What!? But I was still happy at the end. God does use all the things of life to bring people to Him.
She’s a good storyteller! And several times during the book I thought, Wait! What!? But I was still happy at the end. God does use all the things of life to bring people to Him.
April 16, 2026
A beautifully imagined story with themes of grief, vengeance, forgiveness, redemption and love.
April 21, 2026
What a wonderful book. It took me a while to get into it, but once I got interested in the storyline, I couldn't put it down Well done!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews