Jump to ratings and reviews

Win a free print copy of this book!

10 days and 06:01:46

2 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book

Guard My Heart

Win a free print copy of this book!

10 days and 06:01:46

2 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book
A girl who dreams of being a D1 ice hockey goalie meets a hot hockey player who offers a deal to boost her skills in this young adult hockey romance!

Hit me with your best shot . . .

RYLEIGH VENTO has one goal—literally. She dreams of becoming an all-star goalie on a Division 1 women’s ice hockey team. Senior year is her last shot, and she can’t afford distractions. Not injuries. Not family drama. And definitely not a relationship.

Enter Jett Robitaille, the school’s new hockey god. He wants Ryleigh to be his fake girlfriend to make another girl—Ryleigh’s nemesis—jealous. Ryleigh’s answer? To block his goal. Until Jett ups the stakes: He’ll train her, push her, and use his own skills to help her become the best goalie in the league. As the season heats up, Ryleigh has to decide if letting Jett in will make her stronger—or throw her completely off her game. Because sometimes the hardest save isn’t on the ice . . . it’s guarding your heart.

336 pages, Paperback

Published October 13, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Sabrina Fedel

5 books154 followers
Thanks for stopping by to learn about me:)
I grew up in a house filled with books. I mean, floor-to-ceiling filled with books. My dad’s field of study was Anglo-Irish literature (written in English rather than Gaelic), and our house was often filled with Irish writers and poets as well as their books. I had no idea this wasn't normal, and that it was special.
I have always loved reading and stories and spent a lot of time as a kid daydreaming myself into the stories other people created for me. (Okay, they weren’t creating them for me specifically, but it often felt that way).

I wanted to become an English major in college and write, but my dad discouraged me because he thought it was too hard to make a living as a writer (he was right about that.) So I did other things and eventually came back to writing.

My YA debut, Leaving Kent State, (Harvard Square Editions) has won multiple awards, and my latest YA Romance is forthcoming from Delacorte Press in Summer '24. It's called All Roads Lead to Rome and it tells the story of Story Herriott, a girl who gets pulled into a fake dating scheme while trying to start a charity to honor her dad, who died when she was eleven.

I also write short stories and poetry, and you can links to my other work, via my website, www.sabrinafedel.com

I hope you’ll enjoy reading my work as much as I’ve enjoyed creating it. Happy reading!

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
18 (19%)
4 stars
48 (51%)
3 stars
23 (24%)
2 stars
3 (3%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews
Profile Image for ellie .
339 reviews789 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 6, 2026
— 3 ☆ .ᐟ 🏒 spoiler free + mini review
⤷ very cute and very much worth the read YAY!
୨ arc @netgalley

⋆˚࿔ 95th review of the year

⌗ ꒰ my thoughts ꒱ 🫂
⤷ this was such a fun and peaceful read!! defintely what i needed in the moment <3 overall this was very solid, real, and a great depiction of what its like to be in sports sometimes. espc if you kind of have a "disadvantage" but EEK, i loved sabrina's past books so picking this up was a no brainer!

of course, as a reader my preferences vary so if it is just a cute little YA romcom i don't rate it much more than a 4.5! unless it REALLY impacts me. but this was SO solid despite the avg 3 star rating so don't let that deter you 🙂‍↕️ i think what i loved most about this one was that the girl was on a hockey team and the goalie! i have some people in my life who are like her and felt that representation <3 for the mmc, i didn' connect to him much but they were cute together! can't wait to see what sabrina does next 💐


⌗ ꒰ tropes ꒱
⋆ she's off limits
⋆ she plays hockey
⋆ forced proximity
⋆ fake dating

⌗ ꒰ info ꒱
⤷ find my book review on goodreads @elliexreads
⤷ this is recommended for young adult readers (12+)
⤷ YA contemporary sports romance
publish date: oct 13, 2026

₊‧ all ratings and opinions are my own ₊‧
⤷ thank you so much to underlined and netgalley for the digitial and physical arc!! love ya'll

-----------------

🏒 — pre-read .ᐟ ⌗

𐔌 ♯┆10.6.26
⤷ YAYYY another hockey romance and a new book by sabrina fedel!! so honored to be reading this, thank you underlined and netgalley! im REALLY loving this, espc for the rep of young girls in sports 🤞this is super relatable and i can already see myself recommending this in all my future ya recs! BUT ANYWAY can we also talk about the new goodreads update about stars.. FINALLLLYY.
Profile Image for Sim-fully Ever After.
1,017 reviews96 followers
October 13, 2026
3.25🌟 | 0🌶️

Fake dating and hockey are two things I can rarely resist, and Jett and Ryleigh had some genuinely cute moments!

Their banter and slow-burn chemistry kept me turning the pages, although I did wish we got more time with them as a couple. This is very much a YA romance with barely any physical intimacy, but their connection still had its swoony moments.

Jett’s sunny personality and the way he encouraged Ryleigh were definite highlights. Watching her rebuild her confidence and chase her hockey dreams was satisfying, especially since she had her own ambitions outside the relationship. I also enjoyed the family dynamics and hockey setting, though I would’ve liked a little more depth to both characters’ development.

The third-act breakup wasn’t my favourite, even if I could understand Ryleigh’s reaction, and some interactions felt repetitive. Her stubbornness frustrated me at times, too. Still, this was a sweet, easy read with an adorable romance and plenty of charm.

This is a good pick for readers who enjoy wholesome YA romance and a little romantic tension.

~~~~

A sincere thank you to Sabrina Fedel, Random House and NetGalley for the ARC! 🥰📚

I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
Profile Image for Liralen.
3,605 reviews323 followers
September 13, 2026
For Ryleigh, hockey is just about everything—or, if not everything, it's at least her first love and (she hopes) her ticket to an elite university. Dating is definitely not in the plan. An attractive Canadian hockey player is definitely not in the plan.

Formula 1 books are on the rise, but in the meantime the sports romances all seem to be hockey hockey hockey. I suspect we all know what is responsible for this...and while I don't have a particular affinity to hockey books (no objection, of course, just no specific interest), here we are.

There's quite a bit to like here. First, although Ryleigh is good—she's a goalie and she knows her stuff—she's not the best or the strongest one out there. She can hold her own, but her last season was rough, and she knows that her college options may be limited. On the one hand this feels like a small thing (obviously not everybody can be the best!), but on the other hand I read so many YA books that have quite a lot of wish fulfilment in them—teenager gets a major publishing deal, wins a major science prize, is valedictorian, etc.—that it's always nice to read about teenagers who have dreams but a) have to work for them and b) have to be realistic about those dreams.

The romance is also nice. Ryleigh is a little prickly at first, but she loosens up once she starts to trust Jett a bit; Jett, for his part, manages to be an all-around good guy. (Having read one too many "she's a doormat and he's a raging asshole" books, it's always a relief when he's not a raging asshole. Did I say one too many? I might have meant a hundred too many.) There is a wee bit of wish fulfilment in their romance (he's the hottest new thing at school, smart and attractive and as sure a bet for the NFL as you can get, and he's spending all his free time with Ryleigh, etc. etc.), but I'll take that if it means we get a decent person in the mix.

I do have quibbles. First, Ryleigh is quite small for a hockey goalie (probably for a hockey player at all), and this is mentioned repeatedly—enough to remind me of the romance trend of "she's so little and he's so big, oh my" that, well, I wished she'd just been a bit taller and it wasn't a plot point. Second, there's a mean-girl plot, and although it's not the most dramatic mean-girl plot I've seen, I'm of an age where I'd just rather see more about platonic friendship and less about mean girls who are on the prowl. And finally...there's significant discussion in the book of what schools might be possibilities, and Cornell is one of the schools in play. The potential for a scholarship is one of the discussion points here, and it's not an insignificant one—Ryleigh's one of several kids, her family isn't wealthy, they're probably still paying off medical bills, etc. But: The Ivy League schools don't give athletic scholarships. This policy has been in place since the 1950s, and they (including Cornell) only give need-based scholarships. Now, I'm not saying that this policy has never been flaunted—I'm sure that creative recruiters have found ways to sweeten the deal for student athletes. But generally...as I understand it, it's not a thing. I did read an ARC, so this might be fact-checked and corrected before publication, but in a book that is so enthusiastic about hockey I found it a bit odd that nobody looked into what scholarships are likely from what schools.

Overall fun and nicely balanced; a couple of Fedel's other books have been on my radar for a while, and it's probably time to track them down.

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
459 reviews77 followers
November 8, 2026
She is sooo small and mighty and he has nooooo chance !!! Fake dating on a whole new level and it had me grinning the whole time. Ryleigh doesn’t want to date cause she is focused on her game !!! Jett is focused on a different game and proposes fake dating to get what he wants and he will help her with her hockey. Match made in heaven !! Fake dating is quickly becoming a favorite trope of mine and it was sooo cute in this one. Adored these two together. If you like sports romance or faking dating romance in general this is a fantastic read !!!
Profile Image for lydia {67} ୨ৎ {christmas time is here}.
193 reviews40 followers
October 19, 2026
review:

thanks to netgalley, publisher, and author for this arc in exchange for my honest review!

✨✨✨✨ ~ 4 stars


first off I have to say, this was marked as an "age-relevant" book which just had me cackling, not because it wasn't, but because that has to be stated now with how much content is put into ya books.

this book was a cute, fake-dating-with-a-plot-twist ya hockey romance, and I liked it. sure, the fmc was annoying about everything--don't even get me started on the fact that she "doesn't have a rivalry with Peyton" (yes you do babe we can read between the lines)--and the mmc was just a LITTLE too perfect for my liking (except when he lied), and my other itty bitty no-no was the end was very rushed bc the fmc and mmc didn't make up until 97% which left about 6 pages left which is not enough to enjoy their new romance but I'm crossing my fingers there's some sort of sequel because I absolutely ADORED jett's little brother and would love to see more of his whole family since they felt under-represented the entire time. overall, a cute d1 hockey romance that I would definitely recommend! 🏒🤭💕



preread:

got this arc and it looks so cute!! 🤭✨
Profile Image for OneMadReader.
188 reviews27 followers
October 26, 2026
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice: 🌶️
Language: None
Drug/Alcohol Content: None
Other Content: the FMC's mom almost died from cancer

This was really sweet! It was interesting learning/reading about women's hockey, and I loved Ryleigh's determination to be the best she could be. Her relationship with Jett felt pretty real, but I did feel like they said "I love you" too soon. Other than that, this was a sweet, clean romance that would be perfect to read in the winter.

*I received an advanced review copy for free from Net Galley and the publisher/author, and I am leaving this review voluntarily; opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for Giselle in Chapters ☾.
44 reviews
August 3, 2026
★★★★☆ (4.5⭐ rounded to 4)

If I didn’t have responsibilities, I genuinely think I would’ve finished this book in one sitting.

This was one of those books where I kept saying, “Okay one more chapter,” and suddenly another hour had gone by. I genuinely did not want to put it down.

I’ll start by saying this is definitely more YA than adult romance. If you’re looking for spice, this isn’t that book. There’s basically none. And honestly? I didn’t even care.

The chemistry between Jett and Ryleigh was so good that I never felt like anything was missing.

The banter? Adorable.

The fake dating? One of my favorite tropes.

The slow build? Exactly what I wanted.

I was fully invested in these two from beginning to end.

What really surprised me, though, was how emotionally relatable both characters were.

Jett comes across as someone who has everything going for him. He’s talented, optimistic, always smiling, and somehow manages to make everyone around him feel better. But underneath all of that, he’s carrying his own struggles while still choosing to show up for everyone else. That part of his character honestly made him feel so real to me.

Then there’s Ryleigh, who’s carrying the weight of everything she’s been through while trying to prove herself. Watching her slowly regain confidence in herself, and seeing how Jett believed in her even when she couldn’t, was one of my favorite parts of the book.

Their relationship was so cute. Like, legitimately kicking-my-feet cute.

I loved watching them slowly fall for each other, and every time Jett spoke French to her, I absolutely melted.

Did I love the third-act breakup? No 😂 I’m pretty sure I’ve accepted that I’ll never be a third-act breakup girl.

That being said, I actually understood why it happened. Given everything Ryleigh had been through, her reaction made sense, and I appreciated that the conflict didn’t drag on forever before it was resolved.

I also loved the hockey setting, the family dynamics, the friendships, and honestly just the writing in general. Sabrina Fedel made it ridiculously easy to keep turning the pages.

The only reason this wasn’t a full five stars for me is because I would’ve loved just a little bit more after they finally got together. (And yes, the romance reader in me would’ve happily accepted some spice if this had been written for an adult audience 😂)

Overall, this was such a sweet, addictive romance that completely reminded me you don’t need spice to write incredible chemistry. If you love fake dating, sports romances, slow-burn tension, and characters you’ll immediately start rooting for, I absolutely recommend picking this one up.
Profile Image for Sails and Scales.
479 reviews26 followers
October 21, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐

Thank you to the publisher for the copy so I could review it

Favorite things:

💜 This felt like an ACTUAL hockey book! So many it’s vaguely the setting, but in this one, there’s a lot of time on the ice, talking about hockey, and even hockey terms. Absolutely loved it.

💜 I really loved the tension of how she thought he had everything going for him but eventually learned that he really didn’t. I liked how it evolved during their relationship and helped her mature a little in her perspectives too.

💜 The romance is adorable. They’re adorable.

Less favorite things:
☔ Chem nem. I… I hated this phrase. It was used TEN TIMES.

☔ I understand a third act breakup is part of these things, but sometimes they feel a little strained. I didn’t mind the initial breakup at first, but it seemed to take her way too long to get over it considering the details of the situation.

☔ I wish we’d had a bit more of them being a couple.

Overall thoughts:

Fake dating and hockey? Oof, my greatest weaknesses! This was such a cute high school romance. They have great chemistry, and the romance stays very YA without a lot of physical intimacy. I adored how Jett was always encouraging her toward her dreams and didn’t give up even when she was a little prickly.

One of my major gripes with sports romance books is when sports is barely mentioned at all other than one of them being a sports person. I loved that we got real hockey action in this game from both perspectives. I adored everything about that.

Overall, I thought this was really cute. I’d definitely hand this to any teen romance reader who has even the slightest interest in hockey.

You can find me with more book content on Threads and Instagram at @sailsandscales
Profile Image for HeadCanonHeadCase.
1,575 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 20, 2026
3.5

Ryleigh needs an impressive year to make it to a D1 program. Jett moved to town to play for a junior team and ends up as Ryleigh’s lab partner. He offers to help her on the ice if she pretends to be his girlfriend to make someone else jealous. But is that all there is to their relationship?

Read if you like:
-YA Sports Romance
-Fake Dating
-Athlete x Athlete
-Lab Partners

Guard My Heart was super cute. I love how Ryleigh’s confidence grew over the course of the book. She started as a girl who was hoping and wishing with everything she had and by the end she knew she had what it took to make it in a D1 program. Some of the drama with the girl Jett said he was trying to make jealous didn't quite sit quite right with the overall theme of the book, but I still enjoyed Guard My Heart a lot.
Profile Image for Cait | GoodeyReads.
3,137 reviews683 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 27, 2026
Thank you Get Underlined for the gifted copy and PHR Audio for the gifted audiobook.

CUTE YA.

BLOG || INSTAGRAM || TIKTOK

This is one of those books that didn’t quite HIT for me but I can absolutely see the merits for the true young adult audience. The characters felt realistic to their age and regards to thought processes and actions, while also not having excess language or anything more than kisses. It’s a sweet young adult hockey romance with some fake dating.

I did love that the FMC is a player too!! And a goalie. Loved this so much. Having both of the leads be athletes was a good dynamic for the story. I liked the banter and that you could see the friendship turn into more. I liked the themes of never knowing what someone is going through and how being kind is key. Both of the MC’s are carrying things that are hard for an adult, even more so for a teen. There’s a pretty classic third act break up that goes back to my first paragraph about this fitting better for a younger audience and that’s okay haha.

🎧: I liked the narrator for the audiobook. Sometimes Jett’s voice wasn’t great and he sounded younger than 17, but otherwise it was fine! I did about 3/4 as audio and it’s a solid format choice for reading Guard My Heart.

Overall audience notes:
- YA Sports Romance
- Language: none
- Romance: kisses
- Violence: low
- Content warnings: loss of a parent from cancer (recounted), a parent who is in remission from cancer
Profile Image for Preri.
1,611 reviews478 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 6, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advance copy of this book.

This was a sweet book with some cute moments. If you like hockey romance, fake dating, and wholesome YA, then this is a good fit for you. Unfortunately, the book lost me with the third-act breakup and the angst surrounding that whole issue. It seemed abruptly inserted and unnecessarily prolonged, and took me out of the story. Nevertheless, the book as a whole was easy to get through and cute overall.

And I'm out.
Profile Image for lex loves reading :).
173 reviews1 follower
September 27, 2026
I would’ve ate this up in high school. It was cute enough, but just too young for me. The end did make me slightly nostalgic for family dinner after school in high school. A couple really cringey moments (“you look slay in that jersey”) just took me out. It was a fun and cute YA romance, but not for me at this age.
2.75⭐️
Profile Image for Blondie the Bookworm .
57 reviews
November 12, 2026
“He makes people happy just by being him, the way the North Star makes you happy you stopped to look at the night sky”

“I love Jett so much. I want to love the world for him. I want to love the world with him”

IDK how to feel. If you are looking for a cute fake date, look elsewhere because theres really no fake dating. They were good enough but I like Ryleigh and Jett better as friends.
Profile Image for Susan.
1,208 reviews84 followers
November 4, 2026
A very sweet read but I wish Ryleigh had gotten her head on straight sooner
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
15 reviews
November 15, 2026
FINALLY one of these books written by someone who KNOWS THE SPORT thank you sabrina. i see you girl
Profile Image for Punkin’ .
412 reviews6 followers
Did Not Finish
August 27, 2026
This was just to young for Me. That’s not to say this wasn’t cute read! Just was not for me or my personal tastes! Thank you!
Profile Image for Chelsea.
282 reviews10 followers
August 9, 2026
In this fake-dating sports romance, Ryleigh is determined to get into a D1 school for hockey, but she knows she needs to work hard to get noticed. Her history with teams and coaches is rocky. She was previously on a team that felt suffocating and limited her autonomy, ultimately leading her to leave, and leaving her with a blow that set her training back. Now, she’s with a coach who believes in her and is helping push her toward her goals. What she doesn’t realize she needs most is someone skilled and talented enough to give her some extra training, guidance, and support.

Enter Jett, an exchange student from Canada, hockey god, and all-around genuine good guy. He needs Ryleigh to make another girl jealous, while Ryleigh needs him to help coach her. So, why not fake date to help each other get what they want?

As these two spend more time together, they slowly open up, genuinely enjoy each other’s company, and bond over their shared drive for hockey. Of course, somewhere along the way, they start falling for each other.
This was such a sweet and fluffy YA romance that managed to have some solid characters who actually grew throughout the story, along with a plot that made sense. I especially loved the support both characters received from their families. It really helped keep them focused while also reminding them that they were cared for.

The third-act breakup was crap, but that’s pretty normal for me, it’s my least favorite thing about most books. 😂 It’s all about communication, and while I understand the drama is necessary, I still have a hard time getting through those parts without wanting to scream, “JUST TALK TO EACH OTHER!” 😂
Overall, this was such a cute, feel-good romance with plenty of hockey, fake dating, and two characters who were easy to root for. I loved watching Ryleigh and Jett grow individually while also becoming each other’s biggest supporters. If you’re looking for a sweet YA sports romance with a fun fake-dating setup and lots of heart, this one is definitely worth picking up.
Profile Image for Alexandra Elek.
21 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 5, 2026
Thank you to Penguin Random House and Sabrina Fedel for providing me with this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

If you’re looking for a beginner-friendly romance with no explicit content and a cute hockey romance storyline, this could be a great fit. One thing I especially appreciated was that the FMC plays hockey herself. In many hockey romances, the female character can sometimes feel like she’s there mainly to support the male character, so it was refreshing to see a girl who is just as passionate about the sport, with her own goals, ambitions, and identity outside of the romance.

I think this book will work well for its intended audience. Unfortunately, the female main character wasn't particularly easy for me to connect with. For much of the story, she insists the MMC is a terrible person despite him being consistently kind, thoughtful, and patient, and I found it difficult to understand why she held onto that opinion for so long. She also tends to assume the worst of people and is reluctant to accept help because she wants to earn everything on her own. While her difficult backstory helps explain some of these behaviors, I personally would have liked to see her character growth happen more gradually throughout the story, rather than feeling concentrated in the second half of the book. The conflict surrounding the breakup also didn't quite land for me. Given the MMC's actual motivation, the fallout felt much bigger than the situation seemed to warrant, so I found it difficult to fully understand the FMC's reaction. As someone who is not at the emotional level of a high schooler, I found it difficult to fully connect with some of the FMC’s reactions to the conflict.

That said, I do think the story achieves what it's setting out to do for a younger YA audience. For readers in that age range, the pacing and romance will likely be enjoyable. As someone who tends to gravitate toward YA that also appeals strongly to older readers, I found the story a little repetitive at times, with similar interactions and emotional beats recurring throughout, making it feel lower stakes than what I’m typically used to. I also would have loved to spend more time with the side characters. Dom, in particular, was such a fun presence, and I think the supporting cast had a lot of potential that I would have enjoyed seeing explored further.

Ultimately, I can see this being a really sweet and enjoyable read for its intended audience. The wholesome romance, hockey storyline, and FMC’s genuine love for the sport give it a lot of charm, and I think younger YA readers in particular will find plenty to enjoy here. I’m glad I gave it a chance and can definitely see this being a great choice for readers looking for a clean, lighthearted hockey romance.

Note: A more in-depth review was provided to NetGalley and the book’s publisher.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Shayna greycoupon.
66 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 12, 2026
Guard My Heart is a YA hockey-romance fake-dating book. 17-year-old Ryleigh is a hockey goalie who dreams of playing for a D1 college. A family situation really took its toll on her during her junior year, and her playing suffered. Now it’s her senior year,, and she’s determined to be the best she can be to impress scouts and earn a scholarship. Enter Jett, a brilliant hockey player from Montreal who is billeting with a family in Ryleigh’s town in Connecticut while he plays for the local Juniors team. Jett wants to make the most popular girl in school jealous so she will go out with him. He and Ryleigh strike a deal. He will get her extra ice time and personally train her if she pretends to be his girlfriend.



This is a very cute and very clean romance. It’s YA, so obviously no spice is expected, but it's wholesome to the point that Ryleigh says "heck" instead of "hell." Hockey romances are fun, and I love that the female main character is a player herself and not just cheering from the sidelines. The book has some really unfortunate timing, since the D1 school both Ryleigh and Jett get recruited to is Cornell. On top of that, a major plot point is that Jett has to go back to Canada to be the captain of Team Canada at the World Juniors Championship.

I’m not actually sure why Jett is Canadian, except possibly as an ode to Sidney Crosby, who he has the same number as. Crosby is never referenced by name in the text, but many French-Canadian players are. The book seems to assume the reader knows nothing about hockey and stops to define hockey terms and gameplay. While it doesn’t take up much space, I suspect it might get annoying if you are a big hockey fan. For example, the book never mentions Jett billeting, only that he lives with a host family, and when he starts calling Ryleigh “Tendy,” it explains that it is short for “goaltender. The PWHL is never mentioned in the book. I realize it has only been around a couple of years and the players are underpaid; not even floating the idea she could play professionally seems like a missed opportunity.”

The romance is very sweet, but the characters felt very immature. I get the feeling this book is aimed at readers much younger than the characters. Ryleigh was very stubborn, and it got frustrating at times. Besides getting into and paying for college, their relationship has no real external angst. While briefly dealing with the past loss of a parent and a parent surviving cancer, it is a very happy and cozy book. Thanks to Sabrina Fedel and Random House for the e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Charlene.
365 reviews26 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
August 30, 2026
4.5*
Thank you, GetUnderlined and Sabrina Fedel, for this physical ARC.
OMG. I LOVED this book. I think it was everything I needed. It was absolute hockey perfection. I needed a lighthearted pick-me-up, and this gave me everything I needed.
These characters were amazing. I really enjoyed reading from Ryleigh’s POV. She was very kind and caring, but she also thought before she acted, which I really enjoyed. I really connected with her perfectionist tendencies and her internal pressures.
I loved Jett so much. I loved his character development and his positivity. He had such a great character, even when he made mistakes. You could tell Jett was very genuine throughout the whole book. His backstory was so wonderful, and it made him very easy to love. I wish both Jett and Ryleigh’s development was explored more, but I was still very impressed with everything that was explored.
The romance between Jett and Ryleigh was amazing. Jett continued to bring the best out of Ryleigh and help her grow and develop. They balanced each other out very well. It definitely gave black cat and golden retriever vibes. I adored their tension and romance.
The side characters were cute. I would’ve loved to see more of them, but I am glad that it was focused on the main couple. I hope this extends to a series because I would love to see more of this world and the characters. Plus, I loved Ryleigh’s family so much. It was really sweet to see how much they care for both Ryleigh and Jett.
The hockey element was woven in really well. The terminology was well explained, and I never felt confused, which is great. I felt like a true hockey fan when I caught all the references and jokes. I really loved the hockey elements in this one.
Overall, a really age-appropriate romance for younger readers that’s super fun and easy to read!
There were a few kisses.
Profile Image for Sukie QZ.
13 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 6, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review.

What makes Guard My Heart stand out in the current wave of sports romance is its refreshing premise: a high school hockey story where the female lead isn't just on the sidelines, but is a fierce, competitive goalie herself. Ryleigh is deeply passionate about her sport, navigating set-backs, college ambitions, and family responsibilities, while Jett—the star new player—is consistently patient and supportive. For readers seeking a clean, lighthearted, and wholesome YA romance where both characters love the game, there is plenty of charm in their dynamic.

While the setup has strong potential, the overall execution and pacing hindered the reading experience for me. For instance, scene transitions felt abrupt—jumping mid-beat from the rink straight into the locker room without spatial grounding—alongside hyper-specific descriptions that felt forced. I felt at times that the writing was also relying heavily on tell-heavy exposition and dialogue tags, repeatedly emphasizing how 'elite' or talented characters are for instance, rather than letting those qualities speak for themselves as the story progresses. I also felt a bit turned off whenever Ryleigh held onto a rigid prejudice against Jett long after he demonstrated his kindness, making her growth felt delayed. When the third-act conflict arrives, the miscommunication fallout felt disproportionate to the actual situation, followed by a resolution that wraps up quite quickly at the end, which led the ending to feel rushed.

Overall, this sweet hockey romance offers a great premise for younger YA readers looking for an ambitious FMC, hockey romance, and fake dating trope.
Profile Image for Hillary.
674 reviews18 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 11, 2026
🏒💙 Guard My Heart ARC Review 💙🏒

Thank you so much to Sabrina Fedel and Delacorte Romance for the opportunity to read and review this book!

Guard My Heart is a standalone YA hockey romance. Ryleigh had a dream of becoming a star hockey goalie and she won't let anything get in her way. But when she finds herself in a game relationship with her school's hockey start in exchange for hockey training, will she soon realize she signed up for more than she bargained for?

This was a cute read. I enjoyed Ryleigh and her growth in this book. She went through a lot and I liked the support she received from her friends and family in this book. Jett was a fun character and I felt like he was a perfect match for Ryleigh. I did struggle a little bit with some of Ryleigh's choices and did find myself wanting some of Jett's PoV in the book, but I liked the story overall

This was an enjoyable the start read. While I struggled a little bit with the characters' choices, I did like the general story. This book does have some potential triggers, so please check if you're sensitive. Though this book has a sweet romance, there's YA levels of on page spice, so one flame for spice

If you're a fan of YA hockey romance with interesting characters, an engaging story and fake dating vibes, then absolutely pick this one up.
August 12, 2026
This was a very hard book to rate.

Overall, I give the book 3.5 stars rounded up to 4.

This is a no-spice book as it's a YA/Teens book.

I fully believe the plot was there. It was understandable and easy to follow. It was easy to be able to tell what was going on a little early though. Being single POV, we got to see how Ryleigh was navigating obstacles to her dream: becoming a D1 goalie.

Obstacles were her size, the treacherous previous year in her career as a goalie and hockey player. Jett enters and it's sort of a hard entry where they don't get along at all for a moment but quickly find out how to help each other. But it seemed he had slightly ulterior motives.

What kept pulling me out of the book was strictly formatting. There was a lot of texts back and forth, but it wouldn't stay in a text bubble so sometimes it was hard to see if it was an actual text sent or thoughts inside her head at some point.

Additionally, while it is a shorter story I feel like there could have been more development in Jett's life. He's kind of just there. But there was so much potential before... well, that would be a spoiler.

Either way, I did enjoy reading the book. Thank you Sabrina, Random House, and Netgalley for allowing me to be an ARC reader for this book!
16 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 4, 2026
Something about hockey in the fall makes life so much better! I think I could summarize this book in a few words; fake dating, hockey, and romance. What more could you want? From witty banter to intense coaching on the ice, tension is in the air as Ryleigh and Jett slowly become closer. One of my favorite parts of the fake dating trope is how close it brings the couple together. When they meet each other's families and friends or go on not-so-fake dates, the relationship building slowly starts to progress.
Now let's take a closer look at the MMC. First of all, he is your typically hockey boy, the hair and the smile to the max. Second, he is completely dedicated and so swoony! I might have loved him more than Ryleigh! I love how he treats their relationship and how everything works out perfectly for them. The kisses are sweet and stay sweet!
Time for a little bit of advice. From reader to reader, go to your favorite bookstore, get a cute drink, and pick up this new release! I can't wait to hear more about how much readers will adore this novel! As always, thank you to Netgalley for this reviewing opportunity, reviews will be posted on Goodreads, Fable, TikTok, Amazon, Barnes and Nobels, and Instagram!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Courtney.
92 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 24, 2026
Guard My Heart is an adorable, feel-good high school hockey romance that completely charmed me from beginning to end.

One of my favorite things about this story was that the female main character is a hockey player herself. It was so refreshing to see a heroine chasing her own dream of being recruited after high school instead of hockey being reserved solely for the male love interest. It added a unique dynamic to the romance and made me even more invested in her journey.

The romance is sweet, wholesome, and full of heart. If you’re looking for a clean romance that leaves you smiling, this one delivers. The characters were easy to root for, and the story struck a wonderful balance between personal goals, first love, and the excitement of the sport.

Overall, Guard My Heart is a heartwarming read that proves you don’t need high drama or spice to tell a meaningful love story. I would absolutely recommend it to readers who enjoy clean YA romance, hockey stories, and uplifting happily-ever-afters.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Liza Buss.
150 reviews2 followers
October 23, 2026
irst of all, can we take a second to admire this COVER?! 😭💙

Now, onto the book! This was such an amazing read for me, and I think part of the reason I loved it so much was how much I connected with Rye.

As a former D1 athlete who had a no-dating rule until college because my sport was simply too important, I FELT Rye in so many ways. 🥹 It’s hard to explain what it’s like to dedicate so much of your life to a sport, to have it become such a huge part of your identity, and to sometimes forget why you fell in love with it in the first place. I really loved how Sabrina reminded us of that through this story. ❤️

This book was SO CUTE! We have plenty of hockey, lots of laugh-out-loud moments, a golden retriever boyfriend, and a black cat goalie girl. WHAT MORE COULD I ASK FOR?! The dynamic was adorable, and I had such a good time reading this one.

Sometimes, all you need is a fun, feel-good sports romance that makes you laugh, swoon, and remember why you love the game. And this book delivered! 🏒💕

Definitely a new favorite for my sports romance-loving heart! Thank you Getunderlined for the ARC copy! I love you guys!
Profile Image for Alexandreya Laney.
78 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 10, 2026
3.5 ⭐️

Thank you to the author/publisher and Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This was a good book! Fake-dating is one of my favorite tropes in a book, and this one did things differently in a way that was very new to me! I can’t explain more without spoiling so I will update this review when the book is released if I can remember to, lol.

While the story was good and I did enjoy the characters, this book definitely felt like it was geared more towards a younger audience, which is perfectly okay! The characters just felt a bit too young for me, and a little less mature in their actions and reactions than I typically enjoy from my books, but I think this would make a great book for the younger audiences or people who like easy reads without too much drama or complexity.

I did like the relatability with the Jett and Ryleigh, and it was fun to see them come together fully, even if I did feel it was a little bit rushed, but even that is very on par with high school relationships. Overall this was a solid read!
Profile Image for Makiyah.
3 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 20, 2026
4.5 ☆


I really enjoyed this book, and I especially loved how much background information the author provided about the sport. The fake dating aspect was so sweet, and watching the two of them develop their relationship felt natural and realistic. The book also had such great humor that had me smiling throughout. I flew through this book and genuinely enjoyed every moment of it.

I also really appreciated the way Sabrina Fedel incorporated deeper and more emotional topics into the story. Some of the more serious scenes genuinely made me emotional, but there was still a lightness throughout the book that kept it feeling like the cute romance I was expecting. I thought this balance was handled really well and added more depth to the story without taking away from the romance.

If you enjoy Lynn Painter and her writing style, I definitely think you’ll enjoy this book! The romance and banter gave me similar vibes, and I found myself excited to keep picking it up and see what would happen next. Overall, this was such a fun and enjoyable read!
Profile Image for Ella.
318 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 4, 2026
4.25 ⭐️

I love me a YA Hockey Romance and this was no exception! This story was the cutest fake dating, friends to lovers EVER!!

Ryleigh and Jett were both such amazing characters, and I truly loved their friendship and romance. This was super age appropriate, and just so sweet to read. These two were so perfect for each other, and I loved how passionate they were about hockey.

This story also got so many hockey details right which I really appreciated! The way Jett was willing to help Ryleigh out with extra practice so she could achieve her goals was so sweet, and made me instantly love him. The friendship between them truly made this book, as well as the friendships with other characters.

I also adored our family dynamic with Ryleigh and her family, they were all so close and felt so special to me. They showed up for Ryleigh so much, and embraced Jett with open arms. They were totally rooting for the two of them this whole book, which was just so sweet.

Overall if you are a fan of Heart Check by Emily Charlotte, or Fake Skating by Lynn Painter, you will absolutely LOVE THIS BOOK!

Thank you to Underlined for the gifted ARC in exchange for my honest review!
138 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 29, 2026
My heart was aching through the entire first half of this book. I honestly don’t know if it was Ryleigh’s heartbreaking history with her mom, the trauma from her past hockey coach, or just seeing how little she truly believed in herself, but my chest was literally hurting!
Ryleigh is such a resilient character, and her journey on and off the ice was so emotional to follow. Then enter Jett Robitaille. OMG, Jett. He was the absolute sweetest! His relationship with Ryleigh, his whole vibe, and his amazing family and brothers were just so special and welcoming (same goes for Ryleigh’s family!).
Did Ryleigh exaggerate a little bit during their fight? Honestly, yeah, I thought she overreacted a smidgen—but Jett remained so supportive, patient, and sweet through it all that I couldn't even stay mad.
My only slight wish is that we got a little bit more of an epilogue! I was dying to see more of their life together at Cornell and what their future looked like, but it was still a genuinely beautiful, heartwarming ending.
If you love fake dating, high-stakes sports romance, emotional growth, and a hero who will completely melt your heart, definitely put this on your TBR!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advanced reader copy (ARC) in exchange for an honest review!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews