Pride and Practicality

by Pepper Basham

A newly appointed rector and a woman whose reputation is in ruins work together to save the orphaned children of St. Groves while fighting an attraction that could ruin his career and her restored future. An opposites-attract Regency rom-com, Pride and Practicality will delight fans of Eloisa James and Julia Quinn looking for a low-spice alternative.

Thomas Bridges, the new rector of St. Groves, has a simple gain the support of local wealthy parishioners to finance a boarding school for the orphans of St. Groves. With his stellar reputation and good heart, everything seems to be working well, even if he has to avoid his mother's matchmaking with the eligible ladies of the town. But his plans are rerouted when the "lost" sister of Lord Ravenscross returns and she happens to be the same woman in which he shared a secret and unexpected kiss eight months before.

Arianna Reeves has returned home a secret heiress, trying to redeem her past. With money to spare, a desire to earn back the favor of those she loves, and a hope of being useful she not only puts herself in harm's way to help the children of St. Groves but creates an "anonymous benefactress" to support Thomas Bridges' plan. However, their mutual attraction threatens to not only defrock Thomas but also ruin all their best-laid plans for the children.

When a man from Arianna's past comes to St. Groves with a plan to expose Thomas and Arianna's secret, their characters and hearts are tested. Could the truth about one unexpected kiss ruin their futures? After all . . . it was just a kiss, right?

Genres: Historical Fiction, Romance, Christian Fiction, Regency, Historical Romance, Historical, Audiobook

398 pages, Kindle Edition

Expected publication November 3, 2026

About the author

Pepper D Basham has been telling tales ever since she was a little girl. When her grandmother called her a “writer” at the age of ten, Pepper took it as gospel and has enjoyed various types of writing styles ever since. A native of the Blue Ridge Mountains, mom of five, speech-language pathologist, and lover of chocolate, Pepper enjoys sprinkling her native Appalachian culture into her fiction wherever she can. She currently resides in the lovely mountains of the New River Valley in Virginia.

Reviews

[CatsBnB · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley, Pepper Basham, and Thomas Nelson Fiction Audio for granting me access to the audiobook in exchange for an honest review. The narration was wonderful and added another layer of emotion to the story, making the romantic and humorous moments even more enjoyable.

Pride and Practicality was such a charming Regency romance with a lovely mix of humor, warmth, drama, scandal, and emotional depth. The prologue immediately pulled me in, and I was completely invested in the story from there.

Thomas and Arianna were the heart of this story for me. I loved both of them and found myself cheering for them every step of the way. Thomas's strong sense of right and wrong especially resonated with me. He was determined to do what he believed was right in God's eyes, even when it meant going against society's expectations. I admired the way he could look past reputation and rumor and see Arianna for who she truly was. His genuine heart for the orphan children and his dedication to serving others made him even more endearing. The sweet chemistry between them was one of my favorite parts, and their witty banter brought such a fun spark to the story. Thomas's fierce protectiveness of Arianna and the way she cared for him in return made their relationship even more meaningful. Watching them learn to trust each other and face their hardships side by side was one of the most rewarding parts of their journey.

Arianna was equally compelling heroine. She was determined and brave, with a deep compassion for those in need. I admired the grace she extended to others, even when it would have been easier not to. And her friendship with Emme was such a lovely part of her story.

The Christian themes were woven throughout the story through faith and prayer. Themes of redemption, forgiveness, hope, truth, and grace added so much heart to the story and beautifully reflected the choices Thomas and Arianna faced.

There are definite echoes of Pride and Prejudice, but this is not a retelling. I would describe it more as a loose inspiration, so readers shouldn't go into it expecting an Austen retelling. Although this is the second book in the Regency romance series, I had no trouble reading it as a standalone, though I suspect I might have enjoyed it even more if I had read the first book.

My only hesitation was the pacing. The book felt a little too long for me, and the middle in particular became quite slow and drawn out. At times, I had a hard time staying fully immersed in the story, though the momentum picked back up toward the end.

I was pleased with how the story came together in the end. It also left me thinking about how quickly people can judge someone based on rumors and assumptions rather than seeking the truth for themselves. Arianna's experience was a poignant reminder of how unfairly women could be judged by society's standards, while the men involved were often given far more grace. The weight of the shame and judgment fell on her, even when she was not the one in the wrong.

I highly recommend this to readers who enjoy Christian Regency romance filled with humor, witty banter, heartfelt emotion, and a love story woven with faith, hope, and redemption.💕⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

[Tatum - nuggetybooks · Rating 5 out of 5]

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
- Book 2 in Series
- Regency Romance
- Dual POV, third person
- Closed door
- Christian themes
- Forbidden romance
- Protective MMC
- Working together to serve their community

✨ a few of my favorite things:
- THOMAS
- Arianna’s attitude
- Arianna & Emme’s friendship
- Both MCs are NOT afraid to say the hard truth or call people out
- Both MCs have so much attitude, joy, and purpose/passion
- Their chemistry is insane
- The world of St Groves
- How much Thomas takes care of & protects Arianna
- Arianna taking care of Thomas 😭
- The PLOT TWISTS

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I’m absolutely obsessed with this book. The story had so much heart. It was entertaining and inspiring. It is filled with so much hope and truth of the Bible. It is a wildly fun story to read but also hits right in the heart. The story is highly character driven but there are some major plot twists in there that change the character’s trajectory. I cannot recommend enough if you want drama, scandal, fun, quick quips, and intense longing.

I appreciated seeing the main characters’ character arcs. (You could read this as a standalone but book 1 grants so much more context and gravity for these characters). They both find what truly matters and where their priorities lie. They decide which sacrifices are worth it and which are not.

The side characters are also phenomenal. I did want a bit more Lottie in the end cause I hoped that they would mend their relationship more. But she left lots of room for more books 😉

The whole world the author created is so immersive. I feel like I was dropped right into the time period and this town. I could picture everything because of the authors clear and vivid imagery. I hope we get more from Pepper in this world because I want to be back in St Groves.

This is a closed door regency romance with no cursing, little to no innuendo, and only kissing.

**Thank you so much to Pepper and Thomas Nelson for letting me read this gifted ARC via NetGalley. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**

[Sara Hickman · Rating 4 out of 5]

In true Pepper Basham fashion, Pride and Practicality is highly driven by the characters. We have the MMC who wants to do what is right in God's eyes and values justice, a FMC who has a history but is trying to restore her reputation (while also not harming her family), and a cast of supporting characters who bring heart and laughter.

While it isn't necessary, I think reading Sense and Sensibility first lends to the understanding of characters. I loved seeing Lottie in here and hope we get to hear her story. If you are a fan of clean Regency romances, this is a must. You'll be laughing, your heart will hurt, and then it will mend.

Thanks to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson Fiction for this complimentary ARC. All thoughts are my own

[Amber · Rating 4 out of 5]

Arianna Reeves Is a woman with a ruined reputation after a disastrous run-in with a rake.

Thomas Bridges is the new rector at St. Groves.

After sharing a secret, unexpected kiss months prior, they find themselves working together to help local orphans. As they work together, they grow closer, in spite of St. Grove’s strict societal expectations.

Can they overcome all the expectations of their parish and their families, or will all of the obstacles and rumors drive them apart?

I enjoyed reading Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen, so when I saw this novel, I knew I wanted to read it. It is a low spice, Regency romance with a clergy man as the male love interest. The #teamhawkes girl in me loved that detail! This book had lots of witty banter that I enjoyed. I adored Thomas’s character and loved watching Arianna’s character growth throughout the novel.

Read if you enjoy:
💜Regency romance
💜Pride and Prejudice
💜opposites attract
💜witty banter
💜gossipy small towns
💜defying expectations
💜themes of faith
💜low spice

🎧The audio was performed by Fiona Hardingham and Alex Wyndham. They did a great job bringing the story to life.

Thank you to NetGalley, Thomas Nelson Fiction, and Thomas Nelson and Zondervan Fiction Audio for the advance copy of this ebook and audiobook. All opinions are my own.

[Marlene]

" 'I know it's been a year or two,' she interrupted, her tone quick and light, but her eyes . . . her eyes were pleading. 'But I would never forget your kindness in rescuing me from the rather shameless of advances of a rake?' . . . 'Naive grieving women are easy prey for wolves, Mr. Knight.' "

Pride and Practicality (Release date: Nov 3, 2026, Thomas Nelson) is apparently the sequel to Sense and Suitability by Pepper Basham in an as-of-yet unnamed series. The female lead in S&S is an important secondary character in this book.

Pride and Practicality is a standalone Regency romance. I skipped the first book and had no trouble following this one. I requested this book as an arc because:
1) Thomas Nelson is a Christian publisher,
2) and the author writes chaste romances,
3) but mainly because the title hints at a Pride and Prejudice connection.

Rating: 4 stars

Is it clean/chaste? yes
Other content issues?: References to words such as seducer, fallen women, ruined are used to describe the heroine and her situation.
Christian publication?: Yes
Any reference to God or the Bible?: Yes; Biblical references are not heavy-handed and are organic to the storyline.

Backstory: Prior to the beginning of this book, the heroine ran off to elope with a curate. Upon discovering that his intentions were not honorable, she escaped with her virtue intact. However, the damage to her reputation was already done, so she chose not to return home.

The heroine (female lead): The book opens with the heroine, initially dubbed as Miss Pugh, entering a ballroom in distress. She makes a desperate plea for help to a kind young man unfamiliar to her, who gives her some funds and the name of a woman who can give her safe refuge. "Miss Pugh," is, in fact, Arianna Reeves, sister of viscount Simon Ravenscross.

The hero (male lead): Initially dubbed Mr. Knight, the hero Thomas Bridges, the third son of a gentleman, is actually the newly appointed rector of St. Groves with a heart for helping others. Mr. Bridges is a very good rector, and he very much desires to open a school for disadvantaged children . . . which falls in line amazingly well with the heroine's own desires.

What I liked:

*the fantastically drawn main characters, as well as the secondary ones
*the storyline
*the damsel in distress trope
*the theme of doing what IS right, as opposed to what is deemed acceptable by society ("He hated this pretense of propriety masking cruelty.")
*accidental kiss

What I didn’t like:

*The Pride and Prejudice connection felt shoehorned in. I would've preferred it left out. I disliked it. Fortunately, it only popped up every once in a while.


The bottom line: Delightful clean Regency romance. Readers may enjoy the similarities drawn between the original P&P and this story even though I didn't. (I did love the story otherwise.)

I look forward to reading more by Pepper Basham. I might read the first in this series to learn Arianna's sister-in-law's story, Sense and Suitability.

My thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a review copy of the book.

[lindsey's_literary_likes · Rating 4 out of 5]

She's running from the mistakes of her past, he keeps coming to the rescue....

Miss Arianna Reeves is trying her best to redeem her ruined reputation after falling prey to a scandalous rake. Making her way back home she encounters "Mr. Knight" after he comes to her rescue and they share an unexpected secret kiss. Months later, Arianna meets a newly appointed rector and she recognizes something familiar in his captivating gaze. Her "Mr. Knight" turns out to be Mr. Thomas Bridges, who by all accounts should most adamantly steer clear of Miss Reeves if he wishes to remain the rector and continue the work he was called to do by establishing a school for the less fortunate children of St Groves, yet he can not seem to get Miss Reeves out of his head or his heart.
As the two end up teaming together for a worthy cause, they encounter obstacles that threaten not only their mutual endeavors but also the love that's beginning to bloom between them.

This was everything I adore in a regency romance and the more I read, the more exciting the story became. Great characters, witty banter, a flirtatious MMC (who knew a rector could be so charming), a capable FMC, adventure and of course a HEA. I also loved the Pride & Prejudice references throughout!

If you love clean, closed door regency that's exciting, uplifting and has all the swoon, this one is for you!

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson Audio for providing an advanced listener copy of this amazing book. I very much enjoyed the audio performance by both narrators however, I was slightly more engaged during Fiona Hardingham's performance who did a fantastic job! (I think it was just personal preference).

Content:
Kisses only
no language
Themes of faith

[Christine Gustin (christinebookstagram) · Rating 4 out of 5]

Another delightful historical romance from Basham! If you’re a fan of regency romance with all the steam and zero spice, this is for you!

This book is technically a standalone, but I highly recommend reading it after reading Sense and Suitability.

You’ll love this book if you love:
•Kisses only romance
•Banter (literally the best)
•Regency England
•Sacrificial Love
•Redemption
•Strong and Kind MMC
•Fierce and Strong FMC
•Love for the “least of these”
•Dynamic Families

I really enjoyed this book! The only reason it wasn’t a 5 star book for me personally was that it felt really long. I kept thinking that I was nearing the end and would then realize I had hours left in the story 🤣 If you love long stories, this might be a bonus for you. If you prefer books that you can finish in a few shorter reading sessions, stick it out and finish this book! I adored the ending and I’m so glad I read the whole thing.

Age rating: older teen and adult. Some more mature themes related to abandonment, attempted assault, betrayal and illness. Zero explicit content and no language.

Huge thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for allowing me to read an eARC of this book! All thoughts expressed here are my own.

[Randi Sampson · Rating 4 out of 5]

Historical or contemporary, Pepper Basham is one of those authors who I know is going to deliver an enjoyable story regardless of the genre. And this one was certainly no exception. Regency is a genre that can be hit and miss for me, but I found Thomas and Arianna very quickly drew me in. I loved how Thomas protected her, even when it would have been easier/more acceptable of the times not to do so. They had a really sweet chemistry between them and their story truly was as heartfelt as it was humorous... truly, a perfect balance of the two. This is the second of Pepper's Austen inspired Regency romances, and while this could be enjoyed as a standalone, I do recommend the first as well. If you enjoy Christian Regency romance with heart and humor, this is certainly one worth checking out.

**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.

[Jessica Brown · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was such a fun and heartfelt read!! I thoroughly enjoyed every minute of reading it 💕

I loved both of the main characters, and their romance was SO sweet!!

The plot flowed beautifully, and the conflict was very well done. I’ll be thinking on this one for a while! 💛

[Clean Book Hoarders · Rating 5 out of 5]

This could definitely be read as a standalone, but I was so excited to continue on with these characters from Sense and Suitability. This book is such a wonderful, clean, historical tale. Arianna and Thomas definitely have a swoon worthy romance! The couple faces challenges and struggles, but it was delightful to have characters focused on doing good works for others. I definitely recommend Pride and Practicality!

Thank you to Net Galley and Thomas Nelson for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

[Julia (Rooted Reading) · Rating 5 out of 5]

A delightful, witty, and heartwarming Regency romance perfect for fans of Jane Austen! Basham's second Austen inspired Regency "dramedy" is a perfect balance of sparkling banter and emotional depth.

Arianna Reeves returns home to St. Groves and Ravenscross as a "ruined" woman after escaping the grip of a devilish rake. Upon arrival, she realizes that making her way back into society's good graces will prove much more difficult than those of her estranged family.

Thomas Bridges, principled and passionate, is the newly appointed rector in St. Groves. His predecessor was marred by scandal and he knows the line he must walk to keep his position... and his dreams of starting a school for underprivileged children alive. To make matters worse, his mother, famous for her matchmaking, is dead set on his marrying a woman of proper breeding and reputation.

When their paths cross, for the second time, will their ever deepening affection for one another be enough to risk their reputations? Will the good of those less fortunate and the good of their own hearts be enough?

Pepper Basham has done it again, y'all! This story is one of my favorite Regency-era romances. Ever. How can I even put into words all that I love about this book?

First of all, I thoroughly enjoyed Sense & Suitability and it was so good to see the same characters from that book. Thomas, Emme's cousin and literary/business associate, was one of my favorite characters from the first book and I am thrilled he got his own story!! I would suggest reading that book first and then reading this one.

The main characters- Arianna and Thomas- were so loveable and relatable, in my opinion. I loved Arianna's wit, determination, and her seriously big heart for those with less. She is the picture of grace and grit. The way she bravely returns home after her disappearance and owns up to her part in the whole scandal was just perfect. It really gave her so many dimensions that Pepper masterfully pulled from throughout the book. Thomas, my heart! I love him so dearly. He reminds me of my own clergy man, my sweet husband. His tender heart for the children and his fierce devotion to those whom he loves just endeared me to him in such a way! His patience with his mother was another feather in his cap, because- whew- what a character she was. Thomas saw past society and what was deemed "appropriate" and saw God's heart. I think that is a good reminder for us as Christians today- what truly matters and what is trivial?

The BANTER!!!! In true Pepper fashion, this book was full of witty banter not just from the main characters, but from many side characters as well. I laughed out loud so many times I lost count!

This was a clean, kisses-only romance. There were several kisses throughout the book, but none were distasteful, in my opinion. If I were a parent, I would feel comfortable with my older teen (16/17+) reading this book.

If you are looking for a Regency romance that will make you laugh on one page and bring tears to your eyes the next, please give this one a try (after you read Sense & Suitability, of course).

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

[Sara Wise · Rating 5 out of 5]

** “But the purest gratitude requires no payment — just as a good deed performed from a good heart does not seek compensation.” **

Pepper Basham once again takes on a Jane Austen tone with her latest novel, “Pride & Practicality,” a story of overcoming reputation, helping others who need our help and always doing what is right.

Picking up after her Regency era novel “Sense & Suitability,” featuring Simon Reeves and his now wife Emme, Simon’s sister Arianna finds herself at a ball in a compromised position. She seeks help from the one man who looks kind and compassionate, new rector Thomas Bridges, who helps her escape the blackguard who has taken advantage of her.

When she eventually finds herself back home, she’s shocked to learn her “Mr. Knight” is indeed Thomas. But as they find their paths constantly converging, they learn they have something in common — the desire to help the less fortunate. And what Thomas doesn’t realize is Arianna’s recent past has put her in the position to be more helpful than he even realizes.

Can they deal with the building chemistry between them, all while protecting his image and rebuilding hers?

Basham again does an incredible job of creating an Austenian story reminiscent of “Pride and Prejudice” and “Sense and Sensibility,” the former which Arianna enjoys reading and can relate to. She develops a great cast of characters, including some supportive friends and family, not-so-nice “neighbors,” some adorable children, and a squirrel named Rosie.

She also fills her novel with several great themes, like seeking that which is brighter, simpler and less stained with brokenness; death is a tool best used to help others; everyone deserves a chance at redemption; good deeds don’t require or seek compensation; true kindness and love do not come with strings attached; “sometimes doing what is right matters more than doing what is safe”; we don’t deserve love, it is a gift and is far greater than fear; we should all seek to work for the common good; and “God had a tendency to choose the unlikely for some of His greatest work.”

Fans of Jane Austen will obviously love “Pride & Practicality,” which is due out Nov. 3, as well as authors like Joanna Davidson Politano, Sarah E. Ladd and Abigail Wilson.

Five stars out of five.

Thomas Nelson provided this complimentary copy through NetGalley for my honest, unbiased review.

[Sophie Toovey · Rating 4 out of 5]

Pride and Practicality is an utterly delightful regency romance that balances heart, humour, and a beautifully tender love story. Basham gives us a heroine with a stained reputation — a woman determined to rise above social censure and use her inheritance for genuine good. Her resilience and quiet strength make her instantly endearing, especially as she navigates a world that is far too eager to judge.Opposite her stands an idealistic pastor doing everything in his power not to fall for her. His inner conflict — duty versus desire, calling versus connection — adds such rich emotional tension. Their chemistry is threaded with swoon, restraint, and that delicious slow‑burn ache Basham excels at.
The dialogue sparkles with wit, especially in the moments that poke fun at society’s expectations. Lines like “Men’s minds are perilous in marriage. Either too fixed or too fickle, and either way, misery follows” had me grinning, while “Of course, she will point out your faults. It is a wife’s right by marriage.” is exactly the kind of playful banter that makes regency romance irresistible. And my personal favourite — “This is precisely what comes of reading novels. First sympathy, then ruin.” — feels like a wink straight at every book lover.
Beyond the humour, the story carries real emotional depth. Reputation, whispered judgments, and the weight of past mistakes create meaningful stakes, yet the narrative never loses its warmth. It leans into grace, redemption, and the beauty of seeing someone for who they truly are.
If you love regency settings, complicated reputations, earnest heroes, and heroines who shine despite the world’s attempts to dim them, Pride and Practicality is a joy. Sweet, swoony, and full of heart — a truly uplifting read.

[Ash · Rating 4.5 out of 5]

4.5⭐️
Thank you so much to Thomas Nelson and NetGalley for the E-ARC, and to Thomas Nelson and Zondervan Fiction Audio for the ALC.

I really, really loved this one! 💗

First of all, don’t go into this expecting a straightforward Pride and Prejudice retelling. It’s much more of a “what if?” story centred around Lydia. What if she had tried to get away from Mr. Wickham? What if she hadn’t gone through with the marriage and had the chance to make different choices and redeem herself? I really enjoyed seeing the story explore that possibility.

At the same time, it still carries some of the core themes of Pride and Prejudice especially pride, prejudice, and how easily people can believe things that confirm what they already think about someone. I thought that aspect was handled really well.

But honestly, even without the connection to the classic, this book stands really well on its own. I absolutely loved Thomas! He was such a great hero, and Arianna was such a fierce and wonderful character. I loved watching their relationship unfold, seeing them fall in love, overcome hardships together, and actually work through things as a team. Their banter was so much fun, and their romance was definitely one of my favourite parts of the book. 🥹💗

The audiobook was also fantastic! The narration really enhanced the story for me and made the reading experience even more enjoyable.

My only issue was that, at times, the book felt a little too long for me. But honestly, that’s about it!

I’d definitely recommend this if you enjoy Regency romance, fun and loose retellings, or stories that explore those “what if this classic character had made a different choice?” scenarios. This was such a fun read, and I genuinely loved it! ✨

[Anne · Rating 4.25 out of 5]

I’m a huge Regency fan so this novel checked that box even though there were some actions that could have been a bit impractical for the period. I’m also a huge fan of Alex Wyndham as a narrator so anything he narrates ups the book in that regard! He really is such a fabulous voice actor and brings Thomas to life.

Basham is a gifted writer, keeping readers engaged with steady pacing, witty banter, and swoony romance. The introspection of her characters allows the reader to get to know them, faults and all, and we may not always like them or their decisions. That doesn’t detract from the story for me in this case, though. As I age, I realize I want my fiction to reflect a little more struggle and deeper emotional turmoil than some of the ‘bonnet’ books depict. Pride & Practicality does this for me with its flawed characters.

I do love how Arianna and Thomas both have a heart for orphans and want to care for them through providing housing and education. Of course, if they’d had some honest conversations with each other much of their angst could have been avoided, but therein lies the tension between them. :)

If you’re a fan of Mimi Matthews, even though she writes Victorian era romance, I recommend you give Basham a go. What have you got to lose? Maybe you’ll find a new favorite author!

I received an audio copy for early review from NetGalley and the publisher. No compensation has been received. These are my thoughts on Pride & Practicality by Pepper Basham.

[Tennille Marie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for an ARC copy of Pride and Practicality by Pepper Basham. I absolutely love Pepper Basham! Her books are wonderfully written, the characters are expertly drawn, and the stories are uplifting and light-hearted. This story is no different. I loved that we got to see how Emme and Simon were doing from the previous book and I loved how the story carried on with Arianna, Simon's sister, and Thomas, Emme's, cousin. I loved the characters and watching their tender story developed. The emotional chemistry, the banter, the connection, the longing, all showed that a romance doesn't need spice to pack a punch. If you are looking for a romance with faith, humor, and swoony, endearing moments then this is the book for you. I'd recommend this book to anyone who loves a good romance. This book is safe for teens.

[Christel Nance · Rating 4 out of 5]

Pepper Basham hits tropes that make me happy. I’ve read more than five of her books, and I’ll keep reading them.

Arianna is a woman who recently came home after running away from a man who didn’t like the word no. Thomas is the new rector and finds himself wanting to be closer to Arianna. Together they prioritize orphans and love.

I love a good regency novel, and when I know it’s written by a Christian author? Bring it on, literally every day. The characters were entertaining, including Arianna’s siblings and new sister in law. The sister in law was the best.

The narrator of the audiobook had the perfect voice and tone for this book. She has the kind of voice and accent that makes a book so easy to listen to in one or two sittings.

I received this ARC from NetGalley for my honest review.

[Hannah Walker · Rating 1 out of 5]

DNF at 26%

I really wanted to enjoy Pride and Practicality, but unfortunately, I struggled to get into this one.

I went into the book expecting a standalone romance, not realizing it was connected to a previous story. While it’s intended to work as a standalone, I found the beginning difficult to follow, particularly with the frequent switching between names and identities. It was hard to keep track of the characters and their relationships, which made it difficult to become invested in the story.

Beyond that, I struggled with the writing style and pacing. The story just wasn’t holding my attention, and I found myself having to push through rather than looking forward to picking it back up.

After reaching 26%, I ultimately decided not to finish. I think readers who enjoy Pepper Basham’s writing style or are already familiar with the characters may have a better experience, but this one unfortunately wasn’t for me.

Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for providing an advance copy in exchange for my honest review.

[Dawn Wagner · Rating 5 out of 5]

🎧Another sweet romance from Pepper Basham! Loved getting to be back in this town and get to know some new people.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy of this book. All thoughts are my own.

[Abby Noel · Rating 5 out of 5]

OBSESSED. I absolutely adored this book, and the characters. Thanks to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson for the advanced listening copy!

[Whitney Frasier · Rating 4.5 out of 5]

Perfectly delightful. If you like Jane Austen or The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion, you will likely enjoy this. It was like those mixed with Francine Rivers. So cute! I loved it!

[Renee Gentry · Rating 5 out of 5]

Oh, how I love Thomas Bridges! He was a great friend and cousin to Emme in Sense and Suitability, and he makes a wonderfully swoony hero in Pride and Practicality. Poor Arianna doesn't stand a chance in her efforts to rebuff him at the beginning of the story. I absolutely adore the love story between Thomas and Arianna. Their vision for helping people is so similar, it's wonderful to see them finally working together toward a common goal, even if there are passionate arguments along the way. And of course, it's delightful to visit with Simon and Emme again, as well as Lottie, William, and Fia.

If swoony, ultra-protective heroes are your cup of tea, this is the book for you. Grab said cup of tea and settle in for a sweet, sweet romance.

[Michael C · Rating 1 out of 5]

Thomas, a clergyman, rescues Arianna whose reputation has been ruined by an unscrupulous fortune-hunting curate, and sends her to the shelter of a charitable aristocratic acquaintance. When she finally returns to her family and the town where they live, her reputation follows her. Thomas is a local rector. She and Thomas grow to love each other, and she helps Thomas in his endeavours to help destitute children, but scandal threatens, along with the possible loss of Thomas's living. All of course comes well in a melodramatic ending.

The storyline is promising in outline, and there is a good sense of the spiteful tittle-tattle of the town. Unfortunately, the execution of the book is poor, and there is little else that is good to say of it.

The characterisation is simplistic. There is inadequate portrayal of the changing chemistry between Arianna and Thomas: too much telling, not showing. Some of Thomas's behaviour is highly improbable, including his kissing Arianna when he initially rescues her. He makes no effort to establish whether Arianna has arrived safely at his acquaintance's home and does nothing to prepare his acquaintance for her arrival - this seems uncaring and implausible, and makes the subsequent romance less convincing.

The writing style of the book came across to me as if it might have been suitable for a teenage readership. There is quite a bit of repetition of descriptions of feelings and attitudes, at times in almost exactly the same words. Things are spelt out too much. The book could probably have been edited down to half its length without any significant loss. Adjectives like "feline" are used excessively.

Arianna talks to an almost entirely illiterate young waif in very educated language which he would have had trouble understanding: she would have adjusted her language when speaking to him.

At some key points, major coincidences strain credulity. Thomas feels he need to obtain his uncle's consent to his marriage: this would not have been unnecessary.

There are some historical inaccuracies which a little research would have eliminated. For instance, the elite of the town are referred to as the "ton": that word was confined to the exclusive upper-class set who came together in London for the main social season. Thomas is Rector of Greenleigh Chapel: it would be exceptional for any chapel in a town in this period to have a rector: he would have been Rector of a parish church, not a chapel. And the church would have been dedicated to a saint, and known by the saint's name.

References to Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice" recur in the novel (and its title is of course a variation on Austen): these are very forced.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for letting me have a complimentary copy of the book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.

[Jamie Gordy · Rating 5 out of 5]

Thank you to Pepper Basham, Thomas Nelson Fiction, and NetGalley for giving me access to an eARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Arianna Reeves had fled from St. Groves because of trusting the wrong man. In the process of running, she crossed paths with a man who helped her and sent her to a friend who could help her. This friend later passed away and left part of her fortune to Arianna. At this point, Arianna decided to return home even though she knows her reputation is in tatters. Thomas Bridges, the Curate of St. Groves, is worried about trying to repair the office he is fulfilling, due to the actions of the man who filled the position before him. However, he can’t get the girl out of his mind that he helped all those months ago. Surprise- that girl shows up, and surprise, she turns out to be his cousin’s missing sister-in-law! Arianna wants a good way to use her inheritance, and Thomas, meanwhile, is looking for a way to start a school for underprivileged children. These two must work together to help the poor of the area, even though there are plenty of reasons they need to stay apart.
I adored this book. The number of highlighted quotes I have from this book should attest to this. Although this book obviously alludes to Jane Austen’s novel, Pepper is not trying to retell Pride and Prejudice, which I appreciate. The only real tie-in is themes of the danger of pride and, of course, the Regency setting and the mentions of the book itself. I loved the characters, Arianna and Thomas; they are both such strong characters who are willing to change when necessary. I was curious about Arianna from book one, and I loved Thomas in book one and was hoping we would get his story. I had a feeling that this book would tie them together. This book now makes me curious about a new character, Thomas’s printer friend- I hope we will get his story. Mrs. Bridges is still very much an annoying character, even though she has less of an active role in this book. If I had one small criticism of this book, that would be the complete absence of Emme’s immediate family. I am hoping that at least we will see her sister again in a future book. The faith is very present in this book, but it is well done and natural, and it does not feel at all preachy.
If you love Jane Austen’s novels or books set in the Regency period, specifically faith-filled ones, you will love this book. If you don’t like humorous books, or books that make you take a hard look at your pride and prejudices, then maybe avoid this one.

[Angela · Rating 2 out of 5]

Thank you to the publishers and Netgalley for an arc copy of this novel.

Pride and Practicality immediately piqued my interest, but after the first few chapters things quickly went downhill.

I don’t think there is any reason to have Pride and Prejudice allusions in the book or with the title. It’s a cultural zeitgeist for a reason and I think trying to use it to sell this story–both literally in the marketing sense and figuratively with the storyline–is a poor choice. It felt shoehorned in when the novel was mentioned in the story and it didn’t really even make sense in the scene. Ariana is clearly modeled off of Lizzie Bennett, but where Lizzie’s pride is in response to feeling snubbed, Ariana just comes off as foolhardy.

Thomas is his own mess. While prejudice was traded for practicality, I’m not sure Thomas is really all that practical. Practical means experience in practice rather than the theoretical and yet we spent sooo much time in the theoretical with our MMC. He lacks common sense. He consistently makes the wrong decision, particularly as it relates to Ariana. He spends inappropriate amounts of time and attention on her (publicly) and for a man who is so desperate to project a certain air, he doesn’t do much work to that end. Now this could be explained away that his feelings are so strong he can’t help it, and if we go that route then fine. But the practical choice in that instance would be to simply do the logical, appropriate (i.e. practical) thing like talking to his uncle, courting Ariana, etc. Also, why would a clergyman not want to lead by example and welcome an outcast into his flock?? I understand that historically it wouldn’t work this way, but this is fiction and there are already other historical inaccuracies!

The characterizations are really small potatoes. The meat of my issue is how we are constantly being told and not shown. So much introspection happens in this story. It felt like one page of interaction and six pages of internal dialogue for each character; this would be annoying on its own, but adding in that it was constantly retreading ground became grating. I’m convinced Ariana and Thomas simply fell in love with the idea of who the other person is in their heads.

Because of all the above, nothing really happens until about the 70% mark of the story, which made it very difficult to even get to that point. I wanted to love this book as an avid regency romance reader and as a devoted fan to Pride and Prejudice. Alas, this book left me severely disappointed.

[addicted_to_audiobooks · Rating 4.25 out of 5]

Thank you for providing this complimentary copy through NetGalley for my honest, unbiased review.

In a Snap shot: A story inspired by the world of Jane Austen.
Pepper Basham takes us back to the world of the Ravenscroft family. Arianna Reeves left her family, and returns a “ruined” woman . Since having been gone, deceived by a man who she had thought had the best of intentions, been stranded and forced to walk 20 miles, shown kindness by a stranger, and learned a little about what charity can mean for someone who really needs it. Oh, and she also has a few secrets—one being she is now an heiress.
Ariana is surprised when her return St. Groves and Ravenscross brings her face-to-face with the stranger who provided assistance in her time of need. Oh, and he happens to be the new town rector. With each meeting she learns a little more about the generous man, who is stealing her heart, piece by piece. The problem is, can she keep her tarnish reputation from taking down the man she is falling for.

Format: audiobook
Narrator: Fiona Hardingham and Alex Wyndham
Narration: 5/5
POV: DPOV
Spice: 🌶 1/5
Tropes: Regency era rom-com, Austin inspired, character driven, cozy, redemption

The good: This is NOT a retelling or a reimagining. I saw one review noting that it closely followed Pride and Prejudice (a story I love); however, the comment led the to wonder if they had even read the book. This story is inspired by the themes and lessons of Pride and Prejudice, while also maintaining a completely new storyline. While I do enjoy a good reimagining, I loved the breath of fresh air brought by this book.

Pepper Basham’s story does a fabulous job showing (not telling) the reader what it must have been like to be a woman in this time. They are so easily brought down or discredited. A few simple words, or a hint of scandal, and a she is “ruined.” She has little in the way of options. She cannot simply go out and get a job. Slanderous gossip brought up at a dinner party cannot be addressed directly by the person it seeks to destroy, she must be remain ladylike after all. However, at the same time, she has the ability to bring down men who are apparently otherwise so powerful. A man caught up in scandal, must have been all the temptress woman’s fault!

What I would change: I love a good regency era book, which tends to be slow in pace; however, there were some moments in the story I would have edited down a little.

Overall: This was a cozy (closed door) regency era rom-com, which will quench Austen nostalgia.

[Julianne Harkleroad · Rating 5 out of 5]

"'Hope,' He said with fondness, 'has a rather mischievous way of sticking it out no matter the odds.'"

This book has bewitched me, body and soul and I love, I love, I love it! 💖😭

Out of the 150 books I've read these last two months, Pride and Practicality is my favorite! I usually devour books, but delighted in slowing down and savoring this one. Very rarely do I find such an intelligently written, humorous ode to my favorite book, peppered with biblical truths, without spice, gore, or language. I was very impressed with the biblical knowledge and clever application throughout the book. While not the main focus of this novel, each mention was encouraging to read, and aligned each character's motives and personality. It takes a well-versed author to pick the smaller stories that fit perfectly for each reference- brava!

I love how both main characters clearly express their interest for the other person to readers, even though proprietary doesn't allow them to explore or pursue those feelings. Readers are left joyfully looking for the stolen moments, hopefully longing alongside our main characters for more. The banter is witty and compelling. The older style of English easy to comprehend. The squirrel scenes are hilarious and I chuckle to imagine cast and crew filming them one day! Pride and Practicality gives happy reading wiggles, huge smiles while staring at my kindle, hand to your heart, butterflies in the belly feelings.

I loved Emme and Charlie! Charlie reminds me of the same energy Harry Windover from the Sarah M Eden Lancaster Series gives! I hope his novel is next!

Addressing themes such as immaturity, assumption, not giving the benefit of the doubt (1 Corinthians 13:7), pride, self-sacrifice, serving others, forgiveness, reconciliation, and real love, Basham hits every nail on the head! I just wish there was already a book club to discuss it with others!

"I cannot preach faith while shrinking from its costs."

Troupes: Christianity, ruined woman, secret identities, knight, redemption arc, forgiveness, reconciliation, villain, fight for love, grand gesture, serving others, HEA
Spice: 0/5 🌶️
Gore: 0/5 🩸
Language: 0/5 👀
Triggers: assault- not vivid at all, near drowning

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you to Thomas Nelson Fiction and NetGalley for this ARC!

[Gena Bessire · Rating 5 out of 5]

One chance meeting can leave a lasting impact.

Arianna Reeves is running from grief, misplaced trust, and a ruined reputation when she crosses paths with Thomas Bridges, who sees a woman in trouble and does what he does best: provides care. It is a night neither of them will forget, despite believing they will never see each other again.

With Thomas’s compassionate help, Arianna lands on her feet and returns to her family, hoping to rebuild her life. She comes home humbled and ready to serve both her family and her community. To her surprise, she finds her brother much changed and a new sister-in-law who is delighted to welcome her back. Although forgiveness does not come easily from her other siblings or the community, Arianna is determined to make amends through her actions.

Thomas is a newly appointed clergyman stepping into a position left vacant after his predecessor’s scandal. He has a difficult path to navigate as he seeks to shepherd his congregation, set a worthy example, and care for the orphaned children in his community, his true passion. Arianna’s unexpected return complicates his carefully ordered life, especially when she repeatedly puts herself in danger while trying to help the same children he longs to protect.

Pride and Practicality is a joy to read. It is filled with humor, compassion, and, of course, two well-meaning people falling in love. I loved Arianna’s strength. She is doing the hard work of confronting her past mistakes and growing from them without allowing shame to stop her from caring for others.

Thomas is equally delightful. I appreciated his tender heart, kind nature, and willingness to sacrifice for those around him. When Arianna and Thomas finally stop resisting their connection, they realize they are working toward the same goal and that joining forces makes their mission far more attainable. This is a beautifully written story about grace, service, second chances, and the unexpected ways love can help rebuild a life.

While you can read Pride and Practicality as a standalone, I think it is most rewarding to read it after the first book.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Pepper Basham and Thomas Nelson Fiction. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

[Caren | Hopefulwords · Rating 5 out of 5]

I received a complimentary advance copy of this book. This is my honest and voluntary review.

Rating: 4.5 rounded up to 5

Pride and Practicality shows exactly why a historical romcom works — it has all of the charm, yearning, and challenges of the time period, along with humor and warmth that make these characters feel like you know them.

The nods to Pride and Prejudice are well done, and I particularly enjoyed a clever reference to Mr. Collins.

The writing is engaging with word choices that make you feel, not just know.

There are familiar characters, if you’ve read Sense and Suitability, but this story can be read as a standalone. I enjoyed the return of Thomas’s mother, and while I feel for him and any other recipients of her superior advice, she is a character that I would like to see again in the future.

Some parts were absolutely heartbreaking, and I’m amazed at how those moments are balanced with lighthearted scenes and descriptions throughout the book. I love the deeper message of faith in action, whether that is through forgiveness, mercy, or serving others.

As for the main characters, these two fit together perfectly. I think Thomas may be one of the swooniest MMC’s that this author has ever written! He puts the “gentle” in gentleman, he’s passionate about his calling, and he’s a fierce protector. Arianna is emotionally wounded when we meet her, but there’s a deep strength in her character. She learned difficult lessons, which shaped her, but they didn’t harden her. She’s a kind and generous person who loves deeply.

The banter between them is excellent, and I love how they met and what that brought to the story. Usually, anticipation builds to such a moment, but with these two, there’s this glimpse and then incredible yearning for what they can’t have — a future together.

Overall, this is a beautifully written story, and I’m so glad I read it!

Content:
Faith Themes
Historical Romance
Romcom-feel with deeper themes
Intimacy level: Kisses Only
Language: “Good ****” and the like

[Arlene Harris · Rating 5 out of 5]

Thank you NetGalley for granting me access to this audiobook in exchange for my honest review. It's a very nice historical romance. From the similar title, it's around the same time as Pride and Prejudice! I like that the audiobook has more than one narrator. It's 12h 15m.

The two main characters are Thomas Bridges and Arianna Reeves.

Thomas is the new rector at St Groves. He intends to raise money to start a boarding school for orphans in connection with the church. Thomas' mother is determined that he shall marry and soon. With his situation and plans, he clashes many times with societal expectations of him. Thomas does have an influential and wealthy uncle who he wants to impress and get to help support his boarding school.

Arianna had previously made mistakes that were disastrous to her social standing. She had been rescued from public humiliation by Thomas. She then had left but is now returning. Hoping it has been enough time to start over and become accepted. She returns to Lord Ravenscross', her brother--Simon Reeves', estate. When she first meets Thomas again, she does not let him know who she actually is. She is surprised that Thomas is now the new rector of the local church.

The two have very different personalities. Arianna is spunky and still pushes societal boundaries. Thomas has high convictions and is typically openly honest. Their discussions frequently result in lively, sharp dialogs.

Thomas learns early in the story about Arianna's situation. They develop a mutual respect for each other. Thomas treats her with grace and values her generous soul. Arianna deeply respects his integrity; she works selflessly to protect and improve his ambitions.

I enjoyed this story immensely. I haven't yet read the first book in this "series without a name"--Sense and Suitability. The "series" is inspired by Jane Austen's fabulous books and even bring some of those characters into it. These books have interconnected character arcs and seem to center on character growth and grace.