The time to hide is over. The time to fight has come.
Silverfell doesn’t know why her element is different from everyone else’s. She doesn’t know why her father’s eyes fill with fear when he looks at her. She doesn’t know what wild song calls to her blood, pulling her to run. But when she receives a nightmare vision on the eve of her sixteenth birthday, one thing suddenly becomes clear.
Her home is in danger.
And she is the key to saving it…or dooming it.
Silver is the Sky combines the powerful fantasy romance storytelling of ACOTAR with the mystical vibes of Caraval and the faith themes of Chronicles of Narnia! First in a five book series!
I’m going to start this by saying that reviews are for readers and not for the author and they are not for friends or fans of the author who feel like defending someone they like on the internet.
My review is for readers/consumers who are looking for my thoughts on a book I read.
On a line level, this is poorly crafted. Sentence structure isn’t great and even things like characters names being spelled differently from paragraph to paragraph popped up. I would’ve let that slide (and by that I mean, given this two stars) if it had but one other single redeeming quality. The story has not a single interesting character who is fully fleshed out, and the story is definitely not a page turner. And my goodness, there is not a lick of worldbuilding in here. There’s no explanation of the magic system, the backstory of the spiritual warfare issue (the evil demon takes until like chapter 24 or so to get brought up), the countries are wildly underexplained, and on and on. Again, I could’ve given it two stars. But the discussion on spiritual warfare is the same as it is in every other book like this I’ve read, completely uninspired. And then the discussion on doubt was so underwhelming which is ultimately the greatest disappointment here. As an agnostic, I welcome books to give me a character that is journeying with doubt even when (actually, especially when) their journey with doubt ends with them coming back to their faith. But not like this, where it is trite and shallow. I want something to really chew on, whereas this has all the caloric density of a communion wafer. We could’ve done something with these topics and just…opted not to? Why? I beg for a bold new take. Give me something fresh that makes me want to turn the pages, even if I disagree. At least surprise me.
Ultimately, this did nothing of substance in any capacity. Not with the circus, not with vampires, not with its conversation on doubting your faith. Nothing. What a shame.
I received this ebook arc in exchange for an honest review. I tried, I really did, but I couldn’t keep into this book. I had no idea what was going on. It was so confusing and I was just lost. Maybe it was the writing style or the story itself. It was very dark and evil feeling. I didn’t really see any glimpses of light or Christian themes. It just wasn’t for me unfortunately.
(Now that the book has more reviews and the bad ones have been balanced out by the good, I’m changing my rating to the one I actually wanted it to be)
Okay, I’m finally reviewing this (I finished it three days ago, but I haven’t had time to write my review 🙈)
Content:
Sexual content: None
Language: Definitely none
Violence/gore: A character is impaled, there’s vampires (so blood-lust and blood sucking are a thing), then there’s some other things (decapitation, strangling, killing, etc.)
If you start this book and think, “Mmm, this is really not for me,” Then keep reading.
Also, to note, though this book can be read separately from the authors other series, it has many elements that are better understood if you have read the series first. I didn’t, so I will exclude worldbuilding or lore negatives from my review in near entirety because I don’t think you should cry about things you don’t have proper context for. (THOUGH IN MY OPINION EVERYTHING MADE SENSE, EVEN IF I DIDN’T READ THE OTHER BEFORE HAND)
I almost DNF’d. That first 10% was annoying. I don’t like the characters and the decisions they made seemed so pointless, but as I kept reading, it got better. That doesn’t mean I don’t have qualms with the book over that though. 😗
Our FMC, Silverfell (or Sil/Silver) is a rebel. The book starts on the eve of her 16th birthday. I’d give her grace for that, but I’m almost 18 and she annoyed the ever lovin’ crap out of me. A lot of the book. 😒 But she isn’t why I kept reading. (More on that later.)
There’s a point where her teacher is telling her about the circus and it says, “Silver gripped her skirts in her fists, her heart racing at the new information.” WHEN HAS ANYONE EVER BEEN LIKE THAT OVER VAGUE INFORMATION ABOUT A CIRCUS?? WHEN? 🤨🤨🤨 Have you? I sure haven’t.
Also, we are told REPEATEDLY that Silvers mom is bad. She’s angry, she is narcissistic, she is selfish, she is etc…. And yet, the first time we see her, she’s fine. She’s actually the opposite of everything Silver describes her as. We are only ever told that about her, never shown. What we are shown contradicts the narrative. Maybe that’s intentional on the authors part, but if I was supposed to be surprised with Silver at her mother’s reaction to Silver wanting to run away, I wasn’t.
Speaking of that… WHAT!? Her mom comes to Silver after Silvers friend dies saving her and essentially says, “I know you have to do it. You have to run away. I did when I was your age. You have my permission to leave.” HUH!? Yeah girl, run away. Get out there! Girlboss it! 🤦 Spare me. Shoot me. Get me out of here!
She was a pick me, let’s be so for real.
On the run, she comes across this village. A little girl is getting water and Silver asks about food. Little girl says her parents are happy to feed her. Silver puts little girl on fire bike (authors version of a motorcycle but powered by fire) and takes girl to her house. Girls mother comes out, appalled that a random stranger has her daughter on a dangerous contraption she’s never see before (NATURALLY), woman demands answers (as she should, bc her daughter was literally picked up by a stranger), and Silver says, “I was hungry. She said you had food.” No explanation, no politeness, no respect, nada. Just brat-holery (you’re welcome for that word). Woman NATURALLY gets mad at that answer and tells Silver to leave, points a finger at her, and Silver says, “Please get your finger out of my face.”
GIRL! I WOULD SLAP HER!
Anyway, the mom ends up giving her food. Read it to find out why. And she mentions that a city on Silvers way is a place for sinners and bad types (of people), and Silvers inner monologue is legit, “It sounded like her kind of place.”
She rides to this city after rudely leaving the house of the strangers, and when she sees it says, “One persons rock was another persons gem. She had a feeling she’d fit in here better than at home.” Sure princess. Rebel. Baddie. Girl-boss. Whatever. OH YEAH! Did I mention that Silver is a literal PRINCESS!? A butthole of one, but a princess nonetheless.
Back at the palace, Silvers dad is freaking out bc of what her mom did (literally telling Silver to run away), and says, “I tried. I tried to protect her, to keep her close, so when the moment came I could stop the prophecy.” And everyone is like, “What prophecy, Gerald???” (Idk his name, so that’s my filler). HE’S YELLING AT EVERYONE FOR NOT DOING WHAT HE WANTED THEM TO EVEN THOUGH HE DIDN’T TELL ANYONE WHAT WAS ALLEGEDLY PROPHESIED!
And no one told Silver she was having partial visions (which had prophesied her friends death multiple times), so she just thought they were nightmares, but then the event leading to her friend’s death was because of a vision. A FULL VISION THAT HER PARENTS KNEW SHE WAS GOING TO HAVE AS SOON AS SHE TURNED 16! THEY JUST DIDN’T TELL HER! In my opinion, they’re fully at fault for her friend’s death. He died saving her because she got distracted by that vision she didn’t know she was supposed to have.
Side note: It’s implied that when the clock struck midnight she had the vision (bc that would have started her 16th birthday), but unless she was born at 12am, that doesn’t really work.
The whole vision aspect of the book was kinda ditched half-way through.
It just felt a little like the author was forcing the inciting incident, rather than letting the story unfold.
Anyway, once we got past all of that, it started getting better (bc Kay 🖤🖤🖤).
Something that took me out of the world multiple times was the authors use of “language” from these characters. One teenage (16-18) biker boy says “goodness knows” at one point. I’ve never in my life heard a teenage boy say that. Especially not one like him. Also, at one point, there’s some guys messing with Silvers firebike and one says, “Is this yours?” To which she replies, “Yeah, and your runty backside is touching it.” 😃🔫
Honey, what? I can’t take that seriously at all. But there’s not any in-world language either… so that’s what the author used. 😭
Also, there’s not any creative naming in here (regarding worldbuilding). At all. Capital of the fire nation? Fire City. Bike powered by fire? Firebike. Moth type bug? Moon-moth. Monkey with tusks? Mammoth monkey. Demon lord? High Prince of Demons. And so-on and so-forth. 😁🔫
MOVING ON!
I FREAKING LOVE KAY! I ADORE HIM! 😩 He’s such an intriguing character! At first you kinda hate him, then you kinda like him, then you definitely love him but don’t know if you can trust him, and then… I can’t say. You’ll have to read. If there’s one thing you should know about him, though, it’s that I FREAKING LOVE HIM! 😭 I could go on for days about him! He’s definitely the most alluring character.
I also loved Nayway! He was great! Really have no idea what he’s about… but I liked him a lot. Shipped him with Silver WAY more than I EVER shipped Rain with her.
I hate Rain. He’s supposed to be the MMC, as far as I know… but he’s there for maybe two chapters and then disappears for most of the book. When we see him again, he’s not even the same. His whole vibe goes from aloof stranger with mystery to broody bad boy in that gap. 😑 This is why I love Kay. He’s consistent.
(Also, I guessed the plot-twist with Rain as soon as I saw him in the tavern)
I don’t want to talk about him. He annoys me too much.
Nayway was better. 💅🏻
It felt like there were three potential love interests though. Kay, Rain, and Nayway. I can’t ship her with Kay bc he deserves so much better… but I can ship her with Nayway bc I feel like he wouldn’t take her crap and he’d call her on it. I won’t ship her with Rain bc he’s every basic enemies-to-lovers MMC ever. There were parts I liked him (the entirety of the first chapters we see him in, and a few moments later on), but most times I didn’t.
Back to Silver. Her whole hating El plot was SO pick-me and SO annoying. I couldn’t have cared less about it.
Away from Silver and back to Kay bc I can’t stay away from him… I HAVE SO MANY QUESTIONS ABOUT MY BOY! He’s a conscriptor (vampire). But this caught me off-guard (slight spoiler, but not for the plot, just a character):
(Silver:)“So. Conscriptors can cry.” Kay lifted a finger and touched the wet track on his face, pulling his hand back and staring at it. “No. They can’t.” ????????????????????????????????????????????
WHAT!? HE IS DEFINITELY A CONSCRIPTOR SO I DON’T UNDERSTAND!? I’m SO excited to see more of him, more of his story, and more of his plot! He is the main (potentially only) reason I plan on reading the sequels. It was a good book, but it would be so basic without Kay!
Let me put a quote here for y’all. A Kay quote:
“No matter how fast he ran, he would be late.”
You know why I love Kay? Things like this. You know why Rain is boring? Bc things like what happened before this.
Another Kay quote:
“You do your act as normal. Rain will be the ground act, mostly as eye candy, of course; the shirt will have to go.”
Back to Silver. Don’t even get me started on that whole Phoenix situation. Silver handled that SO wrong! The whole thing throughout the whole book! The phoenix deserves someone like Kay. She knows it too.
Silver refused to kill the vampires. Multiple times they are overwhelming and trying to kill (or successfully killing) people around her, and he refuses to “take away their song”. KILL THEM. OH MY GOSH! KAY IS SPECIAL, BUT MOST OF THEM ARE EVIL! 😤 I can’t with characters like that. She’d sooner watch innocent people die than kill a vampire (that literally happens).
“Still.” She heaved her sword, and a conscriptor head rolled. “Easier to take care of them that way.” Horror flooded Silver. “He was defenseless,” she hissed through bared teeth, taking a threatening step toward [name redacted].
So was everyone he’s bitten and drank dry.
The Dal-Ishnadi chick (gonna call her Dal) was so… Disney villain most of the time. “You live a little longer. In case I need more leverage than I’ve got. But make no mistake; you will die. And your death will be agonizing.” Wooooooow. I’m terrified. She slapped a vampire and the vampire fell to the ground in pain. Why? Idk. Vampires are stronger than that, even in this book. But Dal just likes to bully her servants (as every evil overlord does).
Also, the fact that Kay and Nayway had been on Silvers side for forever, and Rain just reappeared after abandoning her and yet she never once tried to save Kay or Nayway, instead choosing to SACRIFICE HER HUMANITY for Rain. Both Kay and Nayway have done so much for her, but she’s a complete and total jerk to both of them (especially Nayway, but she’s not much better to Kay).
Anyway, this is a long review. After reading it, you may wonder, “Why did you rate it so highly???”
The answer is Kay. He’s the reason I’m gonna buy the next books. He’s amazing.
HOWEVER, just bc this wasn’t totally my vibe rn doesn’t mean I won’t like future books! And it doesn’t mean you won’t like this one! Just read it and find out.
I revived this copy as an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
I received this ebook arc in exchange for a honest review. This is my first arc read and my first book by D.E. Carlson. And I really only signed up for this book because it is dedicated to Charlie Kirk and it is supposed to be Christian. I tried, i really did. But I had such a hard time getting into it. I had no idea what was going on and was just so lost and confused as to what was going on. It felt very dark and evil for me and I didn’t see hardly any light or Christian themes. The dark theme did make me feel kinda uncomfortable. This book just wasn’t for me unfortunately and I truly do feel bad. I will be going and reading her other books because they have been on my TBR for a while. I did unfortunately DNF at 12%:(
I received this book as an ARC from the author. All thoughts are honest and my own.
This book is REALLY good. It has everything we love in a YA fantasy, like prophecy, a chosen one, betrayal, magic, and friendship, while also bringing in some really unique elements like circus acts and firebikes.
There’s no language, no spice, and very minimal romance with no kisses either, plus some faith themes woven in.
It keeps you guessing about who the MMC is, and the plot twists are 🔥. I cannot wait for book two. Thank you so much to the author for sending me this early copy 🫶
I’ve never been one to go for a vampire book, but I’m so glad I picked this up because Dorothy never disappoints. What you need to know: - fantasy/adventure setting - Illustrative, not graphic - Absolutely zero spice (I have a low-to-no tolerance for spice and Dorothy consistently delivers fabulous tension while never once crossing the line) - Well-developed, dimensional characters with individual arcs (heroes, villains, and even minor side characters) - The vampires in this story are not true to regular tropes, and by no means act as a crutch to the writing (by the time they entered the story I had forgotten that was the premise because of everything else going on) - In general, the writing is a cut above mainstream fantasy. Not to be a troll to anyone else but honestly this is just better. - Lots of Easter eggs and references to EOAS but easily stands alone.
This author is openly Christian and her works are infused with those themes in a way that serves to add vibrancy and depth without sacrificing quality. As a Christian who hesitates to read “Christian fantasy” novels for fear of The Cheese, I highly recommend this author!
YA fantasy has never really been my preferred genre, so I may not be the ideal target reader for this book, but even early on I can genuinely recognize this author’s talent. While the genre itself isn’t a personal fit for me, the writing is undeniably strong. The author does an incredible job of creating vivid atmosphere and immersive detail, making it easy for readers to clearly picture the world around them. The pacing is fast, exciting, and engaging, pulling the story forward in a way that fans of YA fantasy will likely appreciate even more. It’s clear this book was written with skill, care, and imagination. Readers should give it a fair chance based on its actual content rather than outside assumptions, because for the right audience, this could be a truly enjoyable read.
I started the book, became frustrated with the characters, and then put it down for 3 weeks. 😅 I’m very glad I picked it back up! The best books make you feel all the feels and make you self reflect on your life. So persevere! It is worth finishing in the end! 🙌
This was my first ever ARC read and to be honest I signed up almost entirely due to the fact that it's dedicated to Charlie Kirk. This is also my first D.E. Carlson book, which I now realize was a mistake on my part. I'm putting this at like 3.25 stars, but I think if I had read her other series first it would be 4 stars. I really enjoyed the story as a whole, but the magic system was very confusing to me. And now I know why 😅 there's a few other aspects of the book that I had trouble with, but those might have been due to this being a next generation novel as well. Definitely need to read the Empire of Ash and Song series to fully grasp all the background info. All in all tho, a pretty great read!
Too many plot holes, too many unanswered questions, and nothing was accomplished. It felt like the book was written in less time than it took to read it
I received this book as an Advanced Readers Copy in Exchange for an honest review.
My first impression is that it’s very different from what I expected. I’ve read books from this author before and this is very different, it’s more modern and dark. It was very difficult for me to get into but after about halfway through I enjoyed it. The Christian themes are there, though few, though I imagine there will be more as the series progresses.
If you’re into rebellious teenagers, vampire like creatures, and dark circuses then this book is for you! The writing is wonderfully done as always, just a bit too dark for my tastes.
(Maybe small spoilers?) I gotta say I was disappointed with where Besaun and Casandra ended up with their family, it seems so broken and sad. They’re my favorite in this story universe and to see them like that made me sad. I enjoyed many of the new characters though!
I did receive this book as an ARC, but my opinions are my own.
I am so excited to jump back into the world of this author’s previous series. Somehow I missed the memo that this book is in that same world. I think I was just excited to see she was writing more books. Ha ha.
It did take me a minute to get into things. But a few pages in, I was hooked. It is much darker than the previous series. There is honestly a lot that is truly difficult to articulate concerning this book. It made me feel a lot of different things. Some good, and some bad. I am so sad in the direction the Traders have taken. But on some level I understand it as well. I always hope for redemption, but in real life, not everyone makes that choice. So even though I do read mostly for escapism and entertainment, sometimes I’m OK if everything doesn’t end in rainbows and butterflies.
I wish those that DNF’d it would give it more of a chance. It does have the darker elements, but so do some of our struggles through this world. Christian or not. I really feel the author captures this throughout her writing. I will be buying and reading pretty much anything she writes.
The hardest part is waiting for the next installment. Sigh.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
No one writes spiritual warfare quite like D.E. Carlson, and she has done it yet again! While I’ve seen some reviews that complain of how dark this one gets, that’s exactly why I love this so much. Finding Christian fiction that deals with the heavier things and the hard questions that so many of us experience is so hard to find, and yet this book does just that while also sucking us in with the world we fell in love with when we read To Bind Fire. This book took me through every emotion and also had a twist that I absolutely did not see coming, and was exactly the book I needed at the time.
Silver is the Sky took me on a journey I wasn’t expecting.
To be completely honest, I was not a fan of Silver at first. I found myself frustrated with her choices and didn’t want to root for her. In fact, part of me wanted her to fail. But the deeper I got into the story, the more my perspective changed.
When I began viewing Silver through a biblical lens, everything shifted. What I initially saw as frustrating became heartbreaking. Instead of judging her, I found myself feeling compassion for her brokenness, desperately wishing she would turn to El and surrender to the Light pursuing her.
And that’s what makes this story so unique.
D.E. Carlson doesn’t simply tell a fantasy story. She creates an experience that forces readers to wrestle with darkness, redemption, pride, betrayal, and the relentless pursuit of grace. The dark circus atmosphere is unsettling and captivating all at once, creating a world where evil feels tangible and every choice carries weight.
What surprised me most was realizing that I wanted to pray for a fictional character. That has never happened to me before.
Silver is the Sky is unlike anything I’ve read. It’s dark, thought-provoking, emotionally challenging, and ultimately a story about light finding its way into the darkest places. Add in found family, betrayal, unforgettable characters, and D.E. Carlson’s distinctive writing style, and you have a book that lingers long after the final page.
Thank you D.E. Carlson for the ARC! The elemental bikes were my favorite aspect of the story. Love a cool magic invention. Magic system was hard to grasp, if I'm being honest. To be fair, magic systems can be tricky to make unique in the age of booktok. Biggest highlight for me in this story, without getting into spoilers, was the final chapter. Solid set up for the sequel. Always love it when we get a glimpse of the next story in a new series debut. Besides that, it was a little difficult getting into the story beyond chapter one. Maybe because it's YA, maybe it's the writing style, or my struggle to connect with the characters. I'm reading the other arc reviews, and I have to agree with a lot of them. I think readers will find it easier to enter this world if they read the preceding trilogy. Can't remember if I finished the series, but I wish this was a separate story instead of a continuation.
This is my first time reading a Christian fantasy book......It's wild that this book opens with a quote from itself...!!!!! Quoting a line from a previous book you have written can be understood but quoting from the book we are about to read...... Now that's new and weird....This is supposed to be a romantasy right..!!! I'm 70 percent into the book and I still don't know who the main love interest is... If they meant it to be a slow burn, I don't think it worked... Because I love a slow burn... But in the case of this book, I didn't even care.....
The writing isn't good... The world building is incomplete... The description of the book starts with "Two sisters, One empire".... But the truth is that we know very little about Dia.... The entire book focuses on Silverfell.... Then why mention anything about 2 sisters at all.... Dia have very less pov, even Kay has more povs.... I felt like Dia is just a side character in this book.... And another thing I'm not sure about is whether there is a song they sing when they perform magic....it's not at all clear. Some parts of the book where she is summoning lightning reminded me of Fourth Wing... This author is clearly inspired by that..... And what's with The Originals... Did she mean TVD spinoff...??!!! This was just bland.....!!
Oooh, my first Christian fantasy novel with vampires? Here's my thoughts. First, if you don't like darker fantasy at all, this isn't for you. Plain and simple. But if you do, then this might hit the spot. Despite the fantasy being darker, (especially more so in the beginning), I didn't find it hopeless. There are themes of hope whispered and woven throughout the book, and stronger toward the end. It is darker, yes. But it is not hopeless. And if you don't want fluffy fantasy, this book could be for you. This book moves at a fast pace and it has interesting aspects with the vampires and The Circus. As for how the vampires were done, I think they were portrayed well. They're not the cool characters: they're the bad blood suckers that they are. (Also, the White Phoenix was cool! I really liked her <3 the poor creature <3) Silverfell was not a character that I found I related to a whole lot, but she was by no means dull. She's conflicted, confused, and she is trying to do the right thing- even if her ways of going about it are questionable and rebellious. And yes, I did feel for her- guilt is never an easy burden to bear, and I'm more than a little intrigued by her gift. Did I want to shake her shoulders a few times? Absolutely. Am I excited for her to realize the truth? Definitely. (And points because her name is cool.) (To be honest, I did find Silverfell reflective of our youth in general. She's trying to figure things out- but she also thinks she already has things figured out lol. She's prideful, but she's also deeply broken.) As for romance, it was definitely there. There might have been some hints of a love triangle? But after that ending *cough* I don't know what direction things will go. Things never went too far, in my opinion, it is completely spice free. Ah yes, the ending. That twisty ending. It was pretty charged and a little gut wrenching, and yeah... wow. Overall, I did enjoy this book and I am definitely curious to see where it this series will go. I'll be keeping an eye out for the next one!
Thank you to the author for kindling providing an ARC for review. All opinions expressed are my own and in no way affected by this.
A fun and interesting fantasy that had me asking, "What is going to happen?" the whole way through! I finished this book in two days because the story kept me in its grip, and I DID NOT expect the ending (hello plot twists). Can't wait for book two! Author sent me this book, but this is not a paid review. *no-spice *no language *great Christian allegory
I couldn't put it down. It was intriguing, fresh and had my jaw on the floor by the end of the first chapter. If you're looking for a good, clean story with biblical themes, this is definitely your book. DE is an amazing lady and fantastic author. Can't wait for book two
This unique, eerie, and mystical fantasy had me entranced from the very first page.
Silver, as the female main character, is imperfect, yet in a human, coming of age, and relatable kind of way. From her trying to understand her magic, to her distance emotionally and physically from her family, to her decision to leave what she knows behind to save her kingdom, it all had me on an emotional roller coaster of a ride. The magic in this story was very unique, featuring a bit of a darker magic with vampires, but also tied in some classic elemental magic aspects that I love. The unusual found family at the circus is one of my favorite parts, and while this story does get dark and a bit bleak, goodness and hope shimmer at the surface. And the love interested hinted at for Silver had me swooning! I will admit that I was not prepared for the crazy twist at the end and did not see it coming. But once it did, everything made perfect sense to me.
I can’t wait to see what comes next and I am impatiently waiting on book 2!
Romantic Content: ❌ No Spice
CW: Death of Loved One, Vampire Magic (Nothing Descriptive), Demon-Like Entities, Fantasy Violence, Betrayal, Loss, Manipulation
If you are a fan of the author's first fantasy series, Empire of Ash and Song, you will love this because we get to see some familiar characters referenced. The story follows Silver, a royal who is completely unusual because, unlike normal Firebloods who wield fire, her element is lightning. Because she struggled to control it, a catastrophic incident occurred that led to the death of her good friend. Seeking atonement and a solution to her powers, she leaves the confines of her land and journeys to the "dark side"—a mysterious place known as the circus.
This book definitely has a dark tone to it, filled with vampires (conscriptors), werewolves (shifters), and mentions of blood and gore. Amidst all this tension, Silver is also going through a deep internal crisis of belief, doubting the God-figure her parents believe in. It adds such a fantastic layer of internal conflict to the story!
Along her journey, Silver meets a very intriguing, mysterious guy named Rain who hardly talks but is always there to save her from perilous situations. I also loved the scene where she bonds with a magnificent White Phoenix! That moment has such huge significance, and I really want to see what else she is capable of doing with the phoenix in book two.
You guys, the drama and intrigue in this book are beautifully written, but I am still heartbroken over that ending. When Silver eventually returns home to warn her father about the evil demons that are out there roaming the world, his response is so incredibly disappointing. He actually throws her into a prison! And without giving away any spoilers... there is a massive betrayal from someone she trusted and was fully invested in. I cannot believe he did that to her, and I am praying he gets a redemption arc in the sequel so we can get an explanation!
An intense, beautifully written fantasy full of tension, cool magic, and jaw-dropping betrayal. Highly recommend!
Thank you for allowing me to read this book! I was happy to support, especially in lieu of all the negativity it has received. My rating: 4ish stars, but I’m giving it 5 to counter the 1 star reviews (which infuriate me)
I have not read the authors other books which hold more lore for this world. So as someone who has not read them, I actually was able to read this book and follow along pretty well. Sure things were a little confusing sometimes but things are always confusing at the beginning of fantasy books haha.
Unfortunately, the main characters were not my favorite, which always makes a book enjoyable. The only character I really enjoyed was Kay, which surprised me! When he first was introduced I thought he’d be my least favorite but wow he was so complex, I adored him. Silver, the FMC is not my favorite but I’m hoping she especially grows more in the second book which I will read. Rain also was not a favorite which was unfortunate because I thought their relationship ship would be more strong and present, one again, maybe that’s more in book 2.
As some have said, this is a much darker book, so if you’re not used to that or done like it then I wouldn’t suggest this book. Especially if you like Christian fiction and haven’t read dark Christian fiction, I can see how this story would be startling to some. This definitely is a story with niche taste, but there’s definitely an audience who loves these sorts of things; vampire, werewolves, circus creepy vibes.
I will say I was hooked from page one and Dorothy is a very talented author! She has a way with words and I did find the prose very hauntingly beautiful!
Thanks again for letting me read. I hope goodreads will take down these 1 star reviews because they’re incredible unfair.
Personally, the book is good but not fully great. While most of the characters had at least a main goal, they still often needed more development: the why of their goals, a clear definition of their internal conflicts and misbeliefs, and there were many actions taken by them made no sense if compared to their goals. Besides, there were too many short scenes that didn't give readers any new information beyond Silver being hungry or tired - they basically served no purpose.
Now, I know the story doesn't end with this book and there's quite a few things unsolved, ergo character arcs need to be finished, so I won't go too deep in certain parts of the character transformation cause I know there's still more to come. This is a sequel to the original series set in the same world, which, as a disclaimer I'll admit I have not read, so I won't go too deep in wordbuilding either.
I want to start by saying that I love the metaphors in this book! Having the circus trap people inside it and have the vampires inside feed on them is basically like saying that entertaiment can lure one in without you realizing, become a sort of trap in a person's life and drain them of things like energy or even family time if it becomes an addiction.
However...
Silver, a princess of the fire empire and heir to the throne, just wants to spend her birthday with her friends riding bikes. She escapes the palace at night and meets her friends at an old amphitheater. This scene is crucial in the story but it is missing a few things. For one, we get hints of what's Silver's internal conflict and misbelief is, I deducted it to be something along the lines that her lightning song/power is a mistake, something that should've never been. But the story takes quite a few pages to get there, which meant that I was scouring the pages for a long time to figure out who Silver, as a character, was. Secondly, the death of one of the characters in this scene partially acts as the inciting incident for the book because of his relationship with Silver. Yet, the minute interactions they have before his tragedy don't even establish their relationship well enough. We get that he at one point was a love interest for Silver but, why? What did Silver like about him? What was their reationship like? What was their bond like? I get that they were close friends, and anyone would've been horrified if the person they liked died in the way he did, but we as readers never get to experience that relationship between them enough so that we feel that death as deeply as Silver. And I would argue we need to feel that death deeply because of the fact that that tragedy hunts the protagonist for the rest of the book and because of things that happen near the end. Simply, I would've liked the author to give these two a bit more time together before he died, or at least show more of it during flashbacks all across the book, maybe in the moments Silver was traveling to the circus she could've been thinking more about him.
There were scenes, as I mentioned before, that simply seemed to serve little to no purpose at all in the story. Namely many of the instances where Silver is riding her fire bike to the circus and she simply feels tired or hungry, and a few of the training moments while she's on the circus. Silver traveling to the circus was the perfect opportunity to have her relive moments of her past with her friend that died, to explore the relationship and what it was that made him specifically special for her. We could've also had moments - thoughts that Silver had, trinkets or objects that reminded her of it, etc. - that would expand upon Silver's relationship with her kingdom and why she wanted to save it so badly. Of course she gets the vision that tells her something or someone will destroy her kingdom and she believes it because that vision's the cause for her friend's death, of course that's her home and most people would fight to protect her home if they were in a similar situation. But Silver didn't seem to love her life on inside her kingdom that much, why would she go through all that trouble to save it? Also, while she doesn't seem to particualrly love her kingdom, we don't really know because we never see how she truly feels about her city, her kingdom, or even at the most minimum, her family. There are hints, but nothing concrete. As a consequence, we don't ever truly know what she wants: does she really want to save her city/kingdom? Or does she simply want redemption for what happened to her friend? Is she leaving simply because she wanted to escape her life? If she truly wanted to save her kingdom, why did she spend so many days/weeks on the circus trying to become a trapeze artist? There are hints that she did it to find out more about what was happening inside the circus and figure out what exactly was the threat to her kingdom, but this information comes in too late, by which time I had too many questions about why she was doing what she was doing. Every scene should have a character persuing their goal, but when she first tried hard to be good at the trapeze, readers get zero reason as to why, it's not even conected to her goal.
Characters like Nayway, Rain, and Hannah are each missing some crucial components. Nayway has a vague goal which is fine, but why? Why does he want that? Why would he risk his whole life for it? In his case, I'm not sure if he appears in the other series and if so he may have more of a complete character arc there, so I won't go too hard on him. Still though, he really didn't do much of anything other than tell Silver about the circus; yet he keeps appearing randomly throughout the book. For Rain, I just wish we would've gotten more little details about what he was doing that maybe foreshadowed for the revelation at the very end or that simply gave him more of a characterization other than just getting mentions of his amber eyes so often. I simply would've liked to see more of how he was (e.g. quirks, habits, trinkets he wore, etc.) that would say more about who he was. For Hannah, while she didn't really need much more since she's a flat character intentionally, I would've still liked to know why did she invite Silver to join the circus in the first place, why did she continue training her? I would've also liked to spend even if just a tiny bit more time with the other characters in circus, since by the time I reached the final battles where Silver found the other circus performers, I couldn't remember anybody.
The prose was good for the most part, but I there were moments where I think a few tweaks could've made certain scenes much more impactful. Moments like when Silver first sees the circus felt sort of unclimactic after all the buildup for it. I liked the fact that the author used the technique of giving some information that answers one or two questions but creates three more for most of the book. Yet, I feel like she didn't give too many answers to satisfy readers until like 60% of the book and was only creating questions.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I picked up this book because I have loved everything I've read from Carlson so far.
I didn't really know anything about this book before reading it (I like to keep things a surprise)... and was I ever surprised (in a good way!). I wasn't sure what I was getting myself into. Jaw dropping moments. Intriguing characters. Angsty teen. Beginning was a bit quick jumping between what was going on, but once I got reading, I didn't want to stop! Moments leaving you asking questions (and wanting to know more).
I read about the author portraying some harder/deeper topics, but they are portrayed subtly yet in your face (read for yourself to find out). Easier read for me once I got through the beginning (once the journey began and she got to the location, I was locked in). Definitely some darker moments, violence & gore at the end. This covers a darker aspect of what's out there and I applaud the author for stepping out to write this.
Not necessarily for the faint of heart or younger audience.
Every time I thought there couldn’t be another twist- I was proven wrong.
Themes - Vampires - Dark Circus - Elemental Powers - Struggle with Faith - Good Vs Evil - Clean fantasy
I’m so grateful I had the opportunity to be an ARC reader for Silver is the Sky. I found it very engaging with good pacing and storytelling that kept me engaged every time I opened it. Silver is the Sky is the first in a new five book series, however it takes place several years after DE Carlson’s first completed series, Empire of Ash and Song. I loved seeing characters from the original series pop up, it was like reuniting with old friends (mostly). Silver is the Sky can definitely be read and enjoyed without reading Empire of Ash and Song, however I would recommend reading the first series to have full enjoyment of Silver is the Sky.
The only negative I have to say about it is that I have to now wait for 4 more books to be released 😫 the anticipation might just kill me!
This book was so incredible. The plot was so unique and I loved the magic system. Silver is such a cool character, and I really liked reading her struggle trying to figure out what was morally crossing the line. She wants to be good, but she starts to see how not everything is just black and white. This book also represented spiritual warfare really well. Her doubt in El and how the demons are constantly waiting to pounce is so relevant to everyday life. All of these characters are so well developed and written. I went from hating Hanna to loving her to feeling sorry for her. Kay also was a character I hated but then grew to love. I’m super excited to see what happens with Rain. The whole circus element was so complex and fun to read. The multiple plot twists at the end were crazy, and now I am on the edge of my seat waiting for Silver is the Sea. This writing was so so fun to read and I am super excited to read the next in the series. Thank you so much to D. E. Carlson for this arc!