Disclaimer: I’m not Wiccan and haven’t identified as Wiccan since I was an impressionable 13yr old who had just finished watching “The Craft” (that’s not meant as an insult to Wiccans, it’s a jab at young me for not doing research or giving much forethought into what I believed and just diving into something because it looked cool, which is rude) so my impression of this book is not coming from a practitioner standpoint. I do (and have) identified as a Pagan since high school though and have a rather laidback/eclectic view on things which has evolved many times over the past couple decades. Also, heavily (and openly) agnostic, hello!
So now that that’s out of the way...where do I start? Well, I read this book because I never have and figured I might as well since it’s at the top of everyone’s list for Beginner Pagans/Wiccans to see what all the hubbub was about. (And I’m trying to bust out my Reading Goal for 2018 lol) I will say that as an introductory book, it does a pretty fair job at explaining itself (though a lot appears to be mostly the author’s personal path/view of Wicca so I hesitate to say it’s a *perfect* guide for a completely in the dark Pagan novice), so it definitely isn’t useful for long time practitioners. It could potentially be a good “this will help explain me” book to give to your parents/friends if you truly are Wiccan and you follow this particular way of viewing Wicca.
There does appear to be some shade thrown at Christianity throughout the book which seems a bit unnecessary, but it’s not blatantly cruel. And the explanations on the tools, while easily understood, seemed lacking but I can’t place why. I also wasn’t a huge fan of his thing against what he calls “black or dark magic” since Wicca is supposed to be a religion that celebrates duality, so that came off as weird and contradictory. “You can’t heal, if you can’t hex” or so I heard somewhere before 😜
The big thing I can’t get passed is the woo-woo. Maybe it’s because it’s Wicca or maybe it’s just Cunningham, but gods damn the woo-woo shit drove me batty. I work in science so magic is already a difficult concept to grasp but I attempt to at least see reason in focusing intention through meditation, but this guy is writing about how if you rub your hands together really fast, then hold them apart slightly then that tingly warm feeling that comes is the magical energy you conjured up. Like, yes heat is a type of energy and the friction of rubbing your hands together did raise that, but that’s not magic, that’s physics so I just can’t wrap my head around that idea. He also had an example about casting a spell for money to pay a phone bill and...ugh, I just can’t. You can absolutely focus your intention and motivation to reach a financial goal, but it requires actual work as well.
All in all, if you’re somewhat new to Wicca and not sure about joining a coven, then this book could be a good stepping stone to at least explain the bare bones. However, I would strongly suggest you read more sources and take a grain of salt with books that don’t offer much history of Paganism in them and admit to being based purely off of the author’s experience (which, to his credit, Cunningham says the same). I do have another book of his I plan on reading that is a bit more earth based, but I’m definitely going into with a side eye now 😕🤷🏼♀️