For three hundred years, Alaric Blackwood has watched over Pumpkin Hollow as a ghost, cursed to witness the town he died protecting but never touch it again.
Rosalin Graves has spent her entire life believing she's the weakest necromancer in her family—until a chance accident awakens the town's legendary founder. Suddenly, she's the only person who can see him, hear him, and hold him.
As they unravel the centuries-old curse binding Alaric to the cemetery, friendship blossoms into an impossible love. But freeing him may mean losing him forever, and some ghosts are far harder to let go than they ever expected.
Three hundred years of being dead, and somehow the ghostly activities were still underwhelming.
Soooo... I was kind of disappointed? 😭 I really wanted to love this one, and I genuinely expected so much more from it. Especially because THE COVER?! Absolutely gorgeous. The cover alone had me ready to fall in love with a dead man. Unfortunately, the actual story didn't quite live up to the expectations it gave me 🤷🏻♀️
I mean, COME ON. A centuries-old ghost from the 1800s? A necromancer who believes she's the weakest witch in her family? A cursed cemetery? A man who's been dead for approximately 300 years and a woman who's the ONLY person who can see him, hear him, and physically touch him?!
THE POTENTIAL WAS RIGHT THERE. ON A SILVER PLATTER. WITH A LITTLE GHOST-SHAPED BOW ON TOP.
We have Alaric Blackwood, the legendary founder of Pumpkin Hollow, who died protecting his town and has spent the last three centuries trapped as a ghost because of a curse. Three hundred years of watching the world move on without him, unable to physically interact with the living.
Then there's Rosalin Graves, a necromancer who's always believed she's the weakest member of her family. That is, until an accident awakens Alaric, and she discovers she's the only person capable of actually interacting with him.
Naturally, the two end up working together to unravel the mystery surrounding his curse, and somewhere between investigating supernatural nonsense and spending time together, their friendship develops into something romantic.
And listen, I genuinely liked the concept!
There's something ridiculously romantic about a man who's been unable to experience physical affection for centuries suddenly meeting the one woman who can hold him. The possibilities for yearning, desperation, emotional intimacy, and absolute devotion were ENDLESS.
Three hundred years without physical touch? Sir, I expected you to be absolutely FERAL 😭
And that brings me to my biggest disappointment.
THE SMUT. OR RATHER, THE LACK OF ACTUAL GHOSTLY CREATIVITY IN THE SMUT.
Because excuse me???
WE HAVE A GHOST.
A LITERAL GHOST.
A MAN WHO IS DEAD.
AND THEY HAVE SEX.
Yet somehow, there was barely anything particularly interesting happening with the fact that HE IS A GHOST?!
I don't know what I expected exactly, but I certainly expected more creativity involving his supernatural anatomy, the mechanics of intimacy with someone who technically doesn't have a living body, and the endless possibilities that come with having a paranormal love interest.
I'm not saying every supernatural romance needs to become an anatomical research paper, BUT IF YOU'RE GIVING ME A GHOST BOYFRIEND, PLEASE DO SOMETHING INTERESTING WITH THE GHOST PART.
I came for paranormal romance, not regular romance with a man who happens to have a death certificate.
And maybe that's where my disappointment really comes from. I had built up certain expectations because the premise was genuinely so intriguing.
I wanted more exploration of Alaric's existence as a ghost. More of the strange, fascinating complications of being physically involved with someone who's been dead for centuries. More of that supernatural element woven into their intimacy instead of it feeling like an interesting concept that wasn't explored nearly enough.
Because the whole point of a ghost romance, at least for me, is that he's a GHOST. Give me the weird paranormal details! Give me the impossible becoming possible! Give me something I couldn't get from a romance between two perfectly ordinary living people!
If I can replace your ghost with a regular man and barely notice the difference during the spicy scenes, we have a problem 😭
I also think the emotional side had so much potential. Alaric's isolation, Rosalin's insecurities about her abilities, and the possibility that breaking his curse might mean losing him could have made for such a beautifully bittersweet romance.
And I did appreciate the underlying idea of Rosalin being the one person who could reach him when nobody else could. There's something lovely about the woman who thinks she isn't powerful enough being the only person capable of doing something extraordinary.
But overall, I just wanted MORE.
More yearning. More supernatural weirdness. More creativity. More emotional intensity. MORE GHOST 👻
I don't think it was a bad book, and I can absolutely see the appeal for someone wanting a quick, spooky-season paranormal romance with a cute supernatural premise. The atmosphere and concept certainly have their charm.
It just wasn't quite what I was hoping for.
Final verdict:
Gorgeous cover? Absolutely 🖤
Interesting premise? Definitely.
A three-hundred-year-old ghost boyfriend? Sign me up.
Did the execution satisfy my expectations? Unfortunately, not really.
Did I expect the sex scenes to take considerably more advantage of the fact that one participant was technically deceased? YOU BET YOUR HAUNTED ASS I DID. 💀
So, three stars it is. Not terrible, not amazing, just a little underwhelming considering how much potential the premise had.
Apparently, even death couldn't save this man from being a little too ordinary in bed.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A spicy novella in which a young necromancer accidentally summons the ghost of the town founder and they both catch feelings for one another.
Alaric Blackwood has watched over the citizens of Pumpkin Hollow for three hundred years. Destined to exist in a cursed limbo, he finds joy in witnessing the world changing and listening to a lonely necromancer talk to herself. Rosalin “Roz” Graves has always let her family down. She may be a death witch, but she’s not able to do much magically. That is, until she accidentally spills her blood on Alaric’s grave and suddenly can see him. Roz learns that Alaric has been cursed to never pass on and that he has enjoyed her company for the last several years. Roz is desperate to let Alaric free, but she can’t help but fall for the gentlemanly ghost as she conducts her research.
This is the first book I’ve read by Katryna Lalock, and the second to last book in the “Pumpkin Hollow” series. I’ve had quite a mixed ride with this series, so I’m happy to be approaching the end. Thank you so much Katryna Lalock for the eARC of this one to read!
The first thing I noticed about this one is that Roz shares many similarities with her sister, Delia, who was one of the love interests in “They Were Broommates.” They are twins who sucked their death magic out of each other, so they both view themselves as worthless due to their lack of powers compared to the rest of their family. They both tend to confine themselves to solitude, and the townsfolk tend to avoid them in general. I really felt for these two sisters, especially once we got into Roz’s head; she is really self-conscious and filled with self-doubt. It’s nice to see her gain confidence in herself and her abilities as this book goes on, because I already knew that she was capable of unknowingly raising the dead due to some instances in a previous installment. It was painful that she viewed herself as worthless and I’m glad her perception of herself changed greatly before this book was done.
The entire dating a ghost thing was definitely interesting. I was hoping that since Alaric is an intangible ghost it would force these two to really get to know each other on an emotional level, but that ended up being so far from the truth. With a little bit of blood magic, Alaric could touch Roz as much as he wanted and this led to them having sex almost immediately. And then out in public. And so on and so forth. I was a bit disappointed by how fast the spice came on in this one, but it seems on brand for Pumpkin Hollow at this point.
The conflict in this one is pretty major but also not at the same time. Roz is researching how to break the curse on Alaric, which is a big deal, but there is also no urgency that comes from this. It’s pretty easy to surmise how the ending of the book will go, which had me a bit bored towards the end.
I did think the messages about how far one would go for love were cute, even if the entire relationship was a bit sudden. Alaric had gotten to know Roz over the years and she was quite lonely before she met him, so it could be less realistic that these two are willing to risk everything for the other. There are certainly some sweet bits about their relationship, but it wasn’t anything crazy special either.
Overall, “Grave Expectations” is a spicy novella that is a perfect read for spooky season. The romance between Roz and Alaric moves rather fast and there are quite a few spicy scenes early on in the story. The conflict was a bit drab, but if one is looking for a sweet romance filled with spice between a necromancer and a ghost, this one may be worth giving a quick read.
Notes: I want more books published within this world. Books that aren’t novellas. The only problem I have with novellas is that they are too short and I’m left wanting more. I want to know MORE about the magic system and the different types. I would love to read a full sized novel of Roz and Alaric. I’ll be looking into other books by this author for sure!
Quotes: “You may die, but your soul will remain to watch. You will watch as we find your witches, as we hold them accountable for their crimes. Your body may burn upon the pyre, but your soul will spend eternity staring at the ashes of the very people you tried -- and failed -- to protect.” - Page 10 (Kindle Edition)
**Spoilers Ahead:** I really enjoyed this book. It blew my expansion out of the window within the first 25% of the book. I love that I somehow picked the book with the founder of Pumpkin Hollow (Alaric). Roz is super cute. I hate that everyone avoids her, but love that she’s able to succeed where others failed.
Selma is the best and I would LOVE a story with her as the main character. I bet she would get up to some crazy mischief.
Something that’s not concluded by this book, but maybe somewhere in the future: Can Roz get pregnant by Alaric? (Also Roz thought this RIGHT AFTER I thought it. It was pure gold.)
This book was such a fun cozy read that I’d suggest anyone looking for something light hearted and fun this spooky season to pick it up.
What I loved: All of Pump Hollow seems to be super intertwined. Like the authors sat down and planned out their characters and how they’d be related and any events happening within their world. There are mentions of Roz’s twin (Delia) and her broommate, the broomstick races at the festival, and other locations. I’m hoping to see Selma appear in Delia’s story. The author quoting bible verses as reasons why you’d be hung as a witch does give me the Salem Witch Trails vibes. I don’t know how accurate the references are without researching them. But I’m still vibing with it. This world is BEAUTIFUL. I can’t wait to read more of this series and see what is in store for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Thank you to the author for a gifted physical copy!
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rosalin is a necromancer who takes care of the local graveyard. Alaric is the town founder, trapped as a ghost though no one can see him until Rosalin takes a spill by his statue. Can they break the curse keeping him from moving on?
Part of what I’ve been loving about the Pumpkin Hollow collection is all the different magic each witch or warlock has, and this entry was no different. I love the exploration of different facets of magic within necromancy. To know that Rosalin has been disrespected by her family because past generations wanted to forget that type of magic is awful. I love how each type is described and the balance within them, like the universe is keeping equilibrium. The discussions of life and rot in particular have made me incredibly excited to read another book in the collection, to see the difference in magic between the sisters and how that impacts their ability to communicate with ghosts.
Knowing that Alaric has not only not been able to communicate with anyone in several centuries, but has watched Rosalin for years, feels like the epitome of yearning. What do you mean this man paid attention for so long, even with the knowledge that he might never be able to interact with her? If he wanted to, he would.
I think Rosalin and I would be best friends. Her vibe is impeccable, and despite the basically shunning she experiences from the town because she’s a necromancer, she really takes it in stride. While it’s clear it’s taken a lot of emotional toll to get to that point, I really respect and admire her ability to let the stares and whispers roll off her back.
I absolutely adored Grave Expectations!!!! This should not be surprising to anyone here since I’ve been working my way through all the books in this series! This particular novella is centered around Roz and Alaric. It was cheeky, sweet, cozy and had such a great storyline that perfectly ties in with the other books in this series.
Roz comes from a long line of necromancy witches but never really manifested powers on her own…or did she 👀. Let’s just say…Roz may have had something to do with the zombie outbreak that her twin Delia had to deal with in “They Were Broommates”. This whole ordeal begins when Roz is doing her job at the cemetery and maintaining the graves. She regularly talks to the tombstones, but this time there’s a little accident and essentially an injury leads to a connection to Alaric, Pumpkin Hollow’s founder, who has been cursed to watch in the afterlife but never interact. I really enjoyed the exploration of how Pumpkin Hollow came to be and its connection to the witch trials. We love a backstory!!
It’s the first time anyone has ever been able to connect with Alaric too. They set out to find a way to help him pass on. However…they catch feelings along the way! Oops! Alaric is quite cheeky and certainly doesn’t let being a ghost stop him from experiencing things lmao. Roz is SO sweet and genuine so it’s no wonder he kind of has a hard time truly wanting to pass on. He helps Roz learn more about her family’s magic, which is how she learns about the power she actually holds! Now remember, I mentioned that Alaric is pretty cheeky, and he’s definitely not shy lmao. So the spice is excellent along with all the flirting! I don’t want to spoil anything here so you’ll have to read the book, heheheh. Currently I have the e-book, but a physical copy is gonna be joining my collection very soon since my goal is to acquire all of them for my shelves 😌👍🏻.
This was a spicy fun time in the cemetery. Rosalin is living the dream with her obsessed ghost turned man who wants nothing more that to fuck her in public. 🥵😮💨
Good for you Rosalin. I'm not jealous at all. Not one bit. Enjoy your cinnamon rolls and simp. I'll just be over here reminding my husband to put his dishes in the dishwasher.
Something to know about me: if he’s a ghost, invisible to everyone but her and wants to eat her like a starved man in public? You’re getting five stars lmao! These two were fun and since he’s centuries old, he wanted to “court” her and was just in love with her, it was precious:)
Roz is a failed necromancer who lives in a village that shuns her. Alaric is the ghost who has protected the town in life and death. When Roz activates her magic, and starts to bring Alaric to life, everything changes. Roz wants to keep Alaric with her, but doesn't want to deprive him of crossing over. As they work to break the curse that was cast on him a deep bond of love is formed.
My only complaint is that this book was repetitive, the same ideas expressed over and over when once would have been enough. I did find the story very entertaining and creative, especially the end. However it needed to be shorter or different ideas needed to be expressed.
Pumpkin Hollow was a really fun town, with an eccentric group of residents. A fun, enjoyable story.
“For centuries, I’ve not been able to make my own plans. And now I have a choice, and if you’ll allow me, I’d like to choose you.”
I’ll haunt you until you’re old, and when you finally cross, I’ll be there. I’d take the curse again if it meant being here to watch you, even if you can’t see me.”
This was the cutest little Halloween novella. The plot was fun, the spice was light and well written. The characters had great chemistry. Our MMC is a cursed spirit who founded the town and is accidentally summoned by our necromancer Roz when she falls and bleeds on his statue. The Halloween vibes were fantastic.
It gave small town, accidental summoning, ghost x necromancer, insta love/lust, cozy romance.
Just finished this, and absolutely loved it! A different take on a witch.
She has no powers or so she thought till suddenly she can talk and see the founder of their town. Hes been dead 300 years but never found peace, cursed to watch but never seen or heard. She has been talking to his tomb for 10 years unaware he is there.
Now they need to break the curse and for him to move on... but does he want too?
Like your MMCs cheeky, a dirty talker who doesnt care where you are to take care of your needs? Hes for you...
Book quote: “Subtlety is a lost art,” Alaric said. “In my day, you’d truly wait for someone to pass before whispering about them.”
This was such a good story! I honestly think it’s one of the most interesting novellas I’ve ever read. Even though it was short, it did an amazing job of drawing me in and making me fall in love with both the characters and the storyline. I always love a good book about witches, but this one added such a cute and unique twist to the love story. I loved how the magical elements blended with the romance, making the story feel both charming and entertaining. It was such a sweet, fun read, and I found myself wishing it were longer because I wasn’t quite ready to say goodbye to these characters. Definitely a novella I would recommend!
This was a cute, fun little fall read. It’s a romance between a necromancer and the ghost of the town’s founder, who died trying to stop the witch trials. The novella length was perfect, even though I honestly would’ve loved a little more of them. There were a few spicy scenes but they were well balanced by the overall plot.
This is the best written novella out of the pumpkin hollow series so far. I absolutely adored the story line and can get down with a starved man (ghost). There was a whole magic system created in less than 200 pages - incredible. I did notice some repetition in the story that didn’t need to be clarified since it’s already such a short read. If it wasn’t for that, this would’ve been 5 stars.
I really enjoyed it! It was fast paced and cute! As an author I don’t have time to read very long books so I enjoyed this short novella I give it 5 stars and the spicy scenes were amazing
This was such a cute novella! I found Roz so relatable! The ending was cute and clever for being a ghost paranormal romance! If you liked Good Spirits by B.K Borison I think you really like this novella! Fun and perfect for Halloween!
The cover does NOT show a man from the 1600s (I’m a stickler for historical accuracy and would’ve preferred him in his robes)! And a little more of a slow burn would’ve been nice, but overall a cute and cozy read!
This was a short and sweet halloween novella. I liked the characters and their story. I do wish that the lore surrounding necromancers and his curse werent so vague. I enjoyed their happily ever after.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.