Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Falling For #2

Falling for Her

Rate this book
A divorced detective who is all about order gets more than he bargained for when his new nanny sends his life--and his heart--spinning out of control in the latest spicy romance by USA Today and Wall Street Journal bestselling author Natasha Madison.

Finley Westbook's life just blew up. Now, the only thing she wants is for her husband to sign their divorce papers. Just one he wants half of her, and her family's, fortune. When her best friend tells her a man in her hometown needs a short-term, live-in nanny for his eight-year-old son, it sounds like the perfect escape from the mess her life has become. Sure, Finley has never had a job, but how hard can it be to take care of an adorable kid?

Single dad and small-town detective Lincoln Burke doesn't have time for chaos. But just as his ex-wife is about to leave for her honeymoon, a major case hits his desk. He's desperate to find a nanny, and it seems Finley is his only option. She's a walking disaster in his kitchen, can never follow a schedule--and is a dangerous temptation in his home.

The chemistry between them is impossible to ignore, but Lincoln won't risk his heart again--especially not with his employee. Yet, the more Finley pushes his buttons, the harder she is to resist. When danger closes in, what started as a temporary arrangement may cost them far more than they ever expected.

338 pages, Paperback

Published October 13, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Natasha Madison

117 books8,904 followers
When Wall Street Journal and USA Today Best Selling Author's nose isn't buried in a book, or her fingers flying across a keyboard writing, she's in the kitchen creating gourmet meals. You can find her, in four inch heels no less, in the car chauffeuring kids, or possibly with her husband scheduling his business trips. It's a good thing her characters do what she says, because even her Labrador doesn't listen to her...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,416 (50%)
4 stars
1,032 (36%)
3 stars
305 (10%)
2 stars
32 (1%)
1 star
10 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 727 reviews
Profile Image for Mairi Swan.
690 reviews59 followers
Review of advance copy
September 30, 2026
*Single father
*Detective MMC
*Trust fund FMC
*Nanny
*Off limits
*Hurt/comfort
*Small town

Finley's life has been turned upside down and she visits her friend to get away from her soon to be ex-husband. Lincoln is looking for a nanny to babysit his son while at work but the options are not good. Until Finley decides to take the offer as a way of distracting her even though she has absolutely no idea about babysitting, cooking, doing laundry or even having a job.
I LOVED Finley! Seriously when he blurb is talking about a trust fund baby I imagined her being a brat with a nose up in the air. But she's way too cute and level headed and so down to earth that I would have liked her to be my friend. She's so hilarious making mistake after mistake as she really has no idea what she's doing but she owns with confidence.
Lincoln is a grumpy but softy inside. He's kind of bitter with the way he was treated by his ex-wife but he sees everything under a new light the moment he meets Finley.
I really loved their relationship. The banter, the teasing, the uncertainty were all there to make you feel connected to them. And the angst when Finley has the accident and Lincoln almost loses it. Ugh I wish I could get into more details but that would be me spoiling and I don't want to.
And Asa, Lincoln's son, is the cutest and sneakiest 8 year old. I loved how Asa and Finley bonded after spending so much time and at the same time so soon together
I received this arc and this is my honest opinion
Profile Image for Alexandria Williams.
1,059 reviews83 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 6, 2026
Finley’s life is an absolute mess when she escapes to her friend’s small town trying to get her soon to be ex husband to sign the divorce papers. She’s been financially taken care of her entire life, she’s never really had to work, and she’s agreeing to become a live in nanny for an eight year old.

So babes….what could possibly go wrong? EVERYTHING.😂

Finley wasn’t just running away from her divorce, she was finally figuring out who she was outside of the life everyone else had built for her. And then there’s Lincoln.😏
Grumpy. Protective. Single dad. Detective. Need I say more?

Lincoln likes order. He likes schedules. He likes knowing exactly what’s happening.
And then Finley walks into his life like a freaking tornado.😂 Their banter was probably one of my favorite parts of this entire book. The way they pushed each other’s buttons, teased each other, and started bringing out sides of each other that had been buried for a long time. Finley made Lincoln loosen up, while Lincoln gave Finley the stability and safety she desperately needed.

With Lincoln being a detective and Finley dealing with the fallout from her marriage, there’s definitely some danger lurking around the edges. But listen… Natasha made me WAIT.😂🔥 The chemistry is basically there from the beginning, but Lincoln and Finley have to fight that attraction because, hello, he’s her employer. The tension keeps building, the banter gets better, the feelings get deeper, and when things finally start heating up…WHEW. 🌶️🌶️🌶️

Falling for Her was such a fun romance!

🏡 Small Town Romance

👨‍👦 Single Dad

🧸 Nanny Romance

🔥 Grumpy/Sunshine

🔑 Forced Proximity

💞 Opposites Attract

🫶🏾 Found Family

🐢 Slow Burn

🚨 Romantic Suspense

🌶️ Spicy Romance

👀 Dual POV
Profile Image for ItaPixie.
1,334 reviews161 followers
October 13, 2026

Falling for Her was a great read.
Natasha Madison beautifully wrote a suspenseful, angst and humorous story that made me eager to know the end.

Finley is forced to flee her home, fortunately she can run to her best friend's little town to wait for her divorce to be final. Here to not be an hindrance, she decides to get a job as a nanny, even if she has never did it. What could possibly go wrong?

Finley is a sassy woman, Lincoln is a grumpy man, together they are dynamite. Their chemistry is steamy and their bantering is pure entertainment. Finley keeps Lincoln on pins and needles, never letting him win an argument.
I think Finley and Lincoln found each other at the right time, she needed to be loved as the beautiful person she is, and he needed someone who brightened up his life.

I fell in love with these characters while they fell in love with each other.
I recommend this novel.


Copy kindly provided by the Publisher/Author.

Profile Image for Lauren (lololovesthings).
1,139 reviews103 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 7, 2026
4.25 stars.

I really enjoyed "Falling for Her" by Natasha Madison. It's quite engaging. Finley (FMC) and Lincoln (MMC) have a great enemies-to-lovers, grumpy x sunshine, forced-proximity dynamic going on. Finley grew up privileged as a trust-fund baby, but she was cheated on by her awful, slimy, gross, cheater ex-husband, who is holding their divorce hostage unless he gets half of her trust fund. Because of this, she needs a place to go and regroup, so she goes to stay with her best friend, Collins (from "Falling for You," book one!). While in Montgavin, Finley takes a job as Lincoln's son Asa's temporary nanny despite not having any experience. Lincoln is a police officer, so he works odd, long hours. He is also responsible for Asa full-time for an entire month while his ex-wife, who is *also* a cheater, goes and marries the guy she cheated on him with! Ick to their exes! Despite not having any nannying/cooking/cleaning/*any* relevant experience of which to speak, Finley and Asa get along swimmingly, and he loves her as his nanny. Lincoln is very grumpy and growly, having closed himself off after his divorce. When Finley does things with Asa without asking first, like taking him fishing or horseback riding, Lincoln doesn't approve of her laissez-faire style of doing things, which causes a lot of early arguments between them. Still, the closer in proximity they are to one another, the more their mutual attraction starts to become more than just lust. All the while, Finley is being harassed by someone she assumes is her increasingly and escalatingly violent ex-husband. She doesn't want to open up to Lincoln about it, though, which may put her in more danger than she knows. Finley and Lincoln have terrific chemistry with one another. They have a *sort of* enemies-to-lovers vibe going on, but they don't really dislike one another. Their constant butting heads leads to a lot of hilarious interactions, witty and biting banter, and eventually, a ton of "will they, won't they?" tension. The spice between them is GREAT as well! Finley's obliviousness to the way the 99% live is also a great source of entertainment and laughs. Her entire argument about how the lake was actually a beach had me howling. She must be a Taurus with that amount of stubbornness. Lincoln is clearly a devoted dad to Asa, but his new job on a special task force is getting in the way of the dad he wants to be. Asa takes to Finley quite well, and I loved their interactions with one another throughout the story. I also adored Samantha Brentmoor and Teddy Hamilton's dual audiobook narration. They are two of the best to ever do it, so they bring these characters to life with pizzazz and dynamic charm.

Thank you to Natasha Madison and The Author Agency for the complimentary ARC of this book. All opinions are my own. I was not compensated for this review.
Profile Image for Randi (randi_reads).
1,776 reviews363 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 4, 2026
Falling for Her is book two in the Falling For series. It features detective, Lincoln Burke, and city girl, Finley Westbrook. She flees town when her cheating husband won't grant her a divorce and heads to see her friend, Collins.

Lincoln is in need of a live-in nanny for a month for his son and Collins and Theo (from book one) suggest Finley, which I really didn't understand. Finley is nowhere near the nanny type. She's never worked a day in her life or spent time with children. Besides, Lincoln and Finley have a disaster of a meeting before he even knows who she is.

I have to admit that Finley was a hoot. She tried to learn how to do things (cooking, laundry, etc.) with the help of YouTube, but it just didn't go her way. LOL But, her relationship with Asa, Lincoln's son, was wonderful, and Lincoln couldn't deny that. He also couldn't deny his growing feelings for her.

Read this if you like:

Dual POV
Single dad/Nanny
Detective MMC/ Trust fund baby FMC
Small town romance
Opposites attract

I listened and read this. The audiobook is narrated in DUAL format by Samantha Brentmoor and Teddy Hamilton. These two always give wonderful voice acting performances.

Thank you to the author and Blackstone Publishing for the advanced readers copy. Thank you to the author for the advanced listeners copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Profile Image for sabrina (books.with.sabrina).
458 reviews685 followers
October 7, 2026
✨ Rating: 4⭐️
🫧 Vibes: falling hard and fast
🎶 Song: something bout' a woman - teddy swims
📖 Favourite Quote: "Falling for her is one of the best things that has ever happened to me, and I’m going to spend my life showing her."
📚 Would I recommend? yes!
💬 tldr thoughts: a sweet and tender romance with great banter!

In the package:
📦 nanny to more
📦 found family
📦 single dad
📦 grumpy x sunshine

Plot: Finley is looking for an escape from her soon-to-be cheating ex husband and flees to her best friend's town. She's never worked a day in her life but Lincoln is looking for a nanny for his son and he's running out of options. As she accepts the job, Finley grows closer to Asa, Lincoln and the small town life.

Thoughts: This book was absolutely adorable!! I am loving the "Falling For" series. The banter and teasing throughout this book was perfection. The way Lincoln and Finley were constantly pushing each other's buttons was hilarious and endearing. I loved Finley's relationship with Lincoln's son as well and how much she grew to be protective of him. While she's a trust fund baby but insanely down to earth, strong and witty. The mystery/suspense plot was also a great addition!

Thank you Natasha Madison for the ARC!

✩⁺₊✩☽⋆ follow me on instagram ⋆☾✩⁺₊✩
Profile Image for AJ.
3,352 reviews1,083 followers
October 14, 2026
4 stars

A sweet, fun, and sexy opposites-attract, single-dad/nanny romance, this is such a gorgeous read!

This is the second book in the Falling For series. The characters from the previous book appear, and there’s a whole heap of cameos from Natasha’s other books which is fun. But this book can absolutely stand alone.

Finley is a pampered trust fund girl who is desperate to get out of a bad marriage. Escaping to her best friend’s small town, she applies for her very first job as a live-in nanny for single dad, detective and all-round-great-guy, Lincoln. Lincoln has just picked up a new case at work and is desperate for help with his adorable 8-year-old son, Asa.

Lincoln and Finley don’t get off to the greatest start, and though she’s woefully underqualified, she gets the job. Asa immediately loves her, and Finley is a delightfully bright spark who adores him right back, but the dynamic between Lincoln and Finley is completely different. They snark and bicker, Lincoln tries to have the upper hand, and Finley comes right back at him. It’s funny and entertaining, and I so enjoyed their interactions.

The build-up between them is great. Their attraction grows, the shift feels natural, and seeing them come together is so satisfying. They’re wildly passionate for each other, but there’s a deeper connection there, and they are so open and honest with each other. They’re sweet and affectionate and so freaking cute and I fell right along with them.

"Falling for her is one of the best things that has ever happened to me, and I’m going to spend my life showing her."

The characters are great. Lincoln is a complete sweetheart with a filthy mouth. He loves deeply, and I loved how protective he was. Asa is a delight and such a cutie. But for me, it was Finley who stole the show. She’s sweet, kind, strong, funny, and sarcastic, and though she may be privileged, she’s very down to earth. She cares so much for Asa and genuinely wants to do the best for him. She slides into small-town life like a dream, and given her backstory and everything she’s going through, I loved seeing her find such peace and happiness.

There is drama outside of the relationship with the case that Lincoln is working on, and with Finley’s ex, and the ending brings some great emotion and intensity. But overall, this is an easy, angst-free read with great characters and a beautiful love story that left me smiling.

Such a gorgeous read. 4 stars.

I listened to this as an audiobook, narrated by Samantha Brentmoor and Teddy Hamilton, and they do a wonderful job! This book is such a great one to listen to.




Profile Image for Kristina Maysonet.
2,035 reviews38 followers
October 13, 2026
Falling for Her is the second book in the Falling For series. It can be read as standalone. I didn’t realize how much I was missing a single dad x nanny until this book! Natasha gave us another incredible story with Finley & Lincoln.

𝑪𝒉𝒂𝒓𝒂𝒄𝒕𝒆𝒓 𝑵𝒂𝒎𝒆𝒔: Lincoln Burke & Finley Westbrook + Asa
𝑺𝒆𝒕𝒕𝒊𝒏𝒈: Montgavin

Finley is one of my favorite characters ever. She is a rich girl who hasn’t done much for herself in the past but she is so full of life and so much energy. She comes to town to visit a friend while waiting for her husband to sign the divorce papers. Lincoln is a single dad who needs extra help while his son’s mother is away. Finley isn’t exactly the best person for the job on paper, but she develops such a close relationship with Asa, and the antics that they get into had me laughing so much! Finley and Lincoln were so perfect together. Complete opposites who just fit together. Finley brought the light to Lincoln’s life that he didn’t even realize was missing.

The audiobook was narrated by Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor. It serves as a great reminder of why dual audiobooks are still amazing and we shouldn’t count them out. I enjoyed the way these brought the story to life.
Profile Image for Melissa Mejia.
606 reviews78 followers
October 3, 2026
I had the pleasure of receiving this as an e-ARC/ALC and voluntarily will be giving my honest review. This is the second book in The Falling for Series and I absolutely loved the audiobook the narration was spot on!! I lo e the chemistry between the two!! She was getting away from an abusive husband and he was recently divorced dad. She was hired as his son’s nanny and one thing lead to another!! Phenomenal storyline!! Can’t wait for the next book in this series.

“A divorced detective who is all about order gets more than he bargained for when his new nanny sends his life--and his heart--spinning out of control in the latest spicy romance by USA Today and Wall Street Journal bestselling author Natasha Madison.”
Profile Image for Jamie.
2,350 reviews119 followers
October 21, 2026
Oh how I loved this one!!! The banter in this one was so good! Although I wasn't shocked. Natasha Madison is the queen of banter.

Finley was perfect. I will never understand why she fell for Davis, because the girl we got to know would NEVER fall for someone like him. I loved how she was with Asa and Lincoln. We get to see the real her.

The attraction between her and Finley is instant, but it really is a slow burn. Finley and all her googling had me laughing.

I loved the epilogues. I just wish it wouldn't have ended. These two had me laughing and crying in this one. So good!!!
Profile Image for rickies.reads.
382 reviews17 followers
September 7, 2026
Lincoln, Finley & Asa
infinity stars- no notes
Book 2/3 in the series

Tropes:
- Detective MMC
- Sassy FMC
- Single dad x Nanny
- Forbidden
- Romantic Suspense

Do you know how emotionally hard it is for me to try and find the words that do this book the justice it deserves? my head say's there's no way in heck I will ever be able to tell everyone how much i loved this book. Even before I knew it was dedicated to me- I loved this book. While beta reading it, it was absolutely messing with my mind the amount of times I stopped and just stared into space because I felt like I was reading something I would actually do or say. SUPPEERRR SURREAL.

anyways back to the book.
Lincoln Burke is in DESPERATE need for a nanny, and FAST. He has is son full time for a month and he may have waiting to long to figure out what he is going to do. COLOR HIM SHOCKED when Finley shows up to interview. There is so way the slightly unhinged woman he ran into at the bakery is the one Theo told him about.

Burke is a straight laced, by the book, doesn't have room for chaos kinda man. Meanwhile Finley is running from her crap husband who won't give her a divorce until she gives him half of her trust fund. She has never cooked, watched a child, had a real job, or actually done anything but be a princess her entire life.. until right now. How hard can it be to keep an 8 year old boy alive fro 30 days? no big deal, right? Out of the gate the author has us rolling with the unhinged things Finley say's to Burke. He hates to love it but it is just so freaking good. The suspense aspect was shocking and a definite plot twist. I loved reading about all the things Finley try's to do while keeping Asa alive.

huge thank you to the author and her team for the chance to beta read back in 2025, and I devoured the ALC. Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor did such an amazing job at bringing both characters to life and really giving them a voice.
INFINITY STARS ALL THE WAY AROUND!
Profile Image for Megan Coggins.
837 reviews200 followers
August 15, 2026
I am always down bad for a cop MMC.
Throw in Lincoln is a single dad.
And you’ve got one hot man.

Finley
I absolutely loved her personality.
Her humor and attitude and little remarks
And OMG the comedy of some of her special moments, we will call them 🤣
Never had a job

This is small town cop and rich city girl vibes.
He’s in need of a live in nanny.
He’s divorced.
She’s in the process of getting divorced. He sucks.

Found family vibes

There’s a suspense element to it.
Some twists I didn’t see coming.

Arc review ✨
Profile Image for MNHockeymomreads (Heather).
455 reviews28 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 12, 2026
Natasha Madison is really the queen of banter! And dare I say that Finley and Lincoln brought that banter to a whole new level! From their first interaction there was tension, attraction, and oh so much chemistry!
Lincoln, normally a calm, cool and collected police detective, doesn't know what to do about Finley. And I can honestly say that is what I love most about it- she keeps him on his toes throughout the whole book! Lincoln is a little jaded by love but he is a great father to Asa.
FInley needed a change of scenery and pace- and she sure got it! This big city trust fund girl is now in a slow southern small town with a job! I love how she so quickly fell into a routine, and tried soooo hard to be the best nanny for Asa. It is clear that Finley has so much to offer and thrives being around people- while she might have had a steep learning curve to domestic life she fit right in a small town.
One of my favorite parts of the book were the adventures that Finely and Asa had! While she may have not had a lot of experience with kids she was always putting Asa first and enjoying the time she got to spend with him. All while softening Lincoln’s heart.
I was one of the luckiest that I also was able to listen to the audiobook of Falling for Her, too! Samantha Brentmore and Teddy Hamilton did such a fantastic job with the voice inflections, tension, and banter throughout this entire book! This was small town goodness at its best and I love that Natasha brought us back to Montgavin- I can’t wait for what is next in this series!
Profile Image for Shannon Shafer-Gordon.
168 reviews5 followers
October 10, 2026
I absolutely adored this book! Finley and Lincoln are perfection. In the beginning I thought Finley would be incompetent, whiny, conceited and spoiled. But she proved me wrong so hard. She is smart, determined, funny, resourceful and sassy and I love her. Lincoln is smoking hot and oh so dreamy. While he’s grumpy he’s also a very dedicated single dad and officer, he can cook and he has tattoos and he’s really all smushy inside. I mean. Enough said. They have great chemistry, lots of tension and are explosive once things get started. Watching them learn to navigate their new situation and seeing Finley open up and grab ahold of her new life and this cute small town is so sweet and endearing. They’re both fantastic and the storyline is also so good but please beware of trigger warnings. Finley’s life has darkness that gets much worse before it gets better. But they do get their HEA, just not in a linear fashion! I would absolutely recommend this book and will be reading the next one!
Profile Image for Maddie Corder.
156 reviews
September 30, 2026
Arc received in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.

4.5 stars ⭐️

Ahhhh I love this book and this world so much!! Every time I get to come back to it, I remember why I love it so much. Single dad/nanny trope will always be top tier for me. And watching our GRUMPY single dad slowly become a softie for his nanny? Yeah that’s gonna do it for me every single time.

The best part? There were two subplots that kept me just as intrigued and wanting to know more. It’s an action packed romance novel and I ate it up.

So so good!!
Profile Image for HolleeJane.
554 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 4, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 Stars

🌶️🌶️🌶️ 3 Chili Peppers

Falling for Her by Natasha Madison
Series: Falling series
Narrated by: Teddy Hamilton & Samantha Brentmoor
Format: ALC/Audiobook
Runtime: 10 hours, 30 minutes

This was my first Natasha Madison book, and I absolutely DEVOURED it. Five freaking stars. I loved Lincoln. I loved Finley. I loved the family dynamic, the banter, the small-town setting honestly, I loved everything about this book.

Finley Westbrook’s life has completely blown up. After only three months of marriage, she’s trying to divorce a cheating husband who seems far more interested in her family’s money than he ever was in her. Finley grew up incredibly wealthy but also incredibly lonely. Her parents sent her off to boarding school when she was young, and while her grandparents gave her the love and family she desperately needed, she lost them in her early twenties. Now she’s basically on her own and desperately needs an escape.

Enter Lincoln Burke.

Lincoln is a grumpy, divorced detective and single dad who suddenly needs a live-in nanny for his eight-year-old son while his ex-wife leaves for her honeymoon. Finley somehow ends up being the answer to his problem.

Except this woman has NEVER had a job.

She can’t cook. She can’t do laundry. She doesn’t know how to take care of a house. She’s had practically everything done for her her entire life, and I genuinely thought I wasn’t going to like her.

I WAS SO WRONG.

Finley completely won me over. She’s strong, witty, sarcastic, outspoken, and absolutely refuses to take anyone’s crap. She knows what she wants and isn’t afraid to say exactly what she’s thinking or demand what she needs.

But what made me really love her was how willing she was to try.

She watches YouTube videos. She Googles how to take care of an eight-year-old. She attempts the laundry. She attempts to cook and listen, the girl REALLY cannot cook. But she keeps trying. She doesn’t care if she fails spectacularly; she gets back up and figures out another way.

Watching her slowly become part of Lincoln and his son’s life was EVERYTHING. I absolutely loved the family dynamic and seeing Finley experience this kind of connection and belonging.

And then there’s Lincoln.

Grumpy single dad Lincoln Burke had me from the beginning. He’s structured, responsible, protective, and completely unprepared for the hurricane that is Finley entering his perfectly ordered life.

The banter between these two was AMAZING. Their personalities play off each other so perfectly, and I loved watching them bicker while desperately trying to ignore the chemistry building between them.

This is definitely a slow burn. The spice doesn’t really hit until around the 60% mark, but I didn’t even care because the buildup was SO GOOD. Watching Lincoln and Finley fight their attraction and eventually their feelings was one of my favorite parts of the entire book.

And once that slow burn finally catches fire?

HELLO. 🌶️🌶️🌶️

There is also a little mystery and suspense woven underneath the romance as danger starts creeping closer to Finley. I really enjoyed how that storyline gradually unfolded without ever overpowering the romance or family aspects of the story.

The pacing was also pretty much perfect for me. Nothing felt rushed, but nothing felt unnecessarily drawn out either. The romance, humor, emotional moments, family dynamics, suspense, and spice all had room to breathe. It was just so well balanced.

And I HAVE to talk about this audiobook because it was FREAKING AMAZING.

Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor absolutely crushed this narration. I LOVE when these two work together. They are easily one of my favorite narrator pairings, and their chemistry together is just so freaking good.

They brought Lincoln and Finley to life perfectly. The banter, emotional moments, tension, humor, and spice all HIT. Teddy was everything I wanted for Lincoln, and Samantha was absolutely perfect for Finley’s strong, sarcastic, slightly chaotic personality.

I already love both of these narrators individually, but together? They’re probably my favorite duo to listen to. If you’re an audiobook reader, I HIGHLY recommend the audio for this one. The narration took an already five-star story and made the entire experience even better.

I laughed. I swooned. I fell completely in love with these characters.

If you’re a fan of Laura Pavlov or Catherine Cowles, I definitely think this is one to pick up. It gave me that same combination of small-town romance, family, emotion, banter, a protective hero, and a little bit of suspense that I absolutely eat up.

Five freaking stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Natasha Madison officially has a new fan because I will absolutely be reading more from her. And give me Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor narrating together any day I am THERE.

Tropes/Vibes:
Single Dad • Nanny Romance • Grumpy/Sunshine • Small Town • Slow Burn • Forced Proximity • Found Family • Romantic Suspense
441 reviews24 followers
Read
October 25, 2026
I’m not rating this one, and I’ll explain why.

This is the second book in the series, and although I really enjoyed the first one, I think if I went back and read it now, I’d probably rate it a lot lower. My reading preferences have changed, and I’ve realised that these really cute, low-angst romances just aren’t my thing anymore. I need high angst, betrayal, heartbreak, drama, something that keeps me on the edge of my seat. 😂

So I don’t think it would be fair for me to rate this book when I know I’m not really its target audience.

That being said, this was a cute story.

We follow Finley and Lincoln. Finley is going through a divorce and comes to town hoping to escape everything that’s happening in her life. Lincoln is a divorced single dad, a police officer, and a bit of a grump. His ex-wife cheated on him, and he’s now raising his daughter.

Finley ends up becoming his daughter’s nanny, despite having absolutely no experience looking after children.

Their relationship was sweet. There was chemistry pretty much from the moment they met, some funny banter, lovely moments, and that whole grumpy/sunshine dynamic. I enjoyed watching them get to know each other, especially as Finley was completely out of her comfort zone.

However, there was one thing that really irritated me, and that was Finley’s characterisation.

I cannot stand when a female character is written to be overly ditzy or dopey. Finley is a woman in her twenties who comes from a wealthy family, and apparently she can’t do anything. She can’t cook, can’t clean, can’t use a washing machine, can’t do basic everyday things.

And look, I understand that not everyone grows up learning these skills, especially if they’ve had a privileged upbringing. That’s absolutely fine. But it was the way she was portrayed that bothered me. It felt like her lack of basic life skills was constantly being used to make her seem silly, and I just didn’t enjoy that. I wish she’d been written with a little more common sense.

Apart from that, I don’t really have many complaints about the actual story. There isn’t any other-woman drama between the main characters, there’s a little subplot involving what’s happening around town, and we get introduced to other characters who I assume will have their own books later in the series.

The spice was moderate. There were a few scenes, but nothing excessive. The focus was definitely more on the romance, their growing relationship, and the sweet family moments.

My biggest issue was simply that I got bored. A lot.

It took me three days to finish the audiobook, which is quite unusual for me. I just wasn’t desperate to pick it back up. Nothing was really making me think, I NEED to know what happens next!

But I genuinely think that’s more about my mood and reading preferences than the quality of the book.

I’ve read other books by this author, and I do enjoy the writing. It’s easy to follow, the characters have good chemistry, and there are some genuinely lovely moments.

If you enjoy sweet, funny, relatively low-angst romances with a grumpy single dad, a sunshine nanny, some spice, and a happy ending, I think you’ll really enjoy this.

For me, though, I needed something with a little more emotional damage. 😂

No rating from me, because sometimes a book can be perfectly good and still not be the book you’re in the mood for.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Sonja Charters.
3,461 reviews156 followers
Review of advance copy
October 7, 2026
It's only been a few months, but I'm already back with book 2 of the Falling For series.

As I said in my last review, this series is also set in Montgavin (same as the Dream series) and feels so cosy coming back to spend time here.

 

I loved the connection we had between this book and the last and so we do see a fair amount of Theo and Collins through this book, so just if you want to avoid spoilers, I'd recommend reading these in order from the start.

 

However, having said that, this still would read absolutely fine as a standalone as Lincoln and Finley's story plays out in full here.

 

I was instantly drawn to Finley as we meet her preparing to divorce her cheating husband.

I definitely got bad vibes from him from the start and I was so happy that she fled - even if it wasn't the best idea to leave him in their house!

 

Her arrival at her best friend's for some respite, saw Collins helping her to escape and reflect on her situation at home.

 

This is where we find Lincoln, divorced dad in need of a nanny for a few weeks while he navigates having his son, Acer to stay and juggling his police work too.

 

I loved the combination of Lincoln's case at work, Finley's divorce situation and the development of the pair's relationship - but I loved how funny it was watching Finley try to get by as a nanny with the barest of adulting skills!

Being from a rich upbringing, she's literally never done any housework or cooking in her life and the scrapes she was getting into made for some fun times.

 

Of course, we saw exactly where things were heading with our main couple but this just flowed nicely along with the other threads of story.

 

I wasn't expecting how things turned out towards the end with Finley's husband - but this was a great way to give Lincoln that last little push and for them to be open about their feelings.

 

Another brilliant read - never in doubt! - and I'm already hooked in for the next book - yep, there were some (not so subtle) hints where this one might go - and I already cannot wait!

 

 

 
 
Profile Image for Carmen Rae.
1,756 reviews186 followers
October 13, 2026
I can't stress enough how much I love Natasha Madison's writing. Her books are an automatic one click for me and I don't bother with the blurb. So I jumped in and to be honest I don't really remember either Finley or Lincoln from the last book. But once I started to get into it I remembered how deeply I was hit by the feels with Collins. So when the feels hit me here I would like to say I was prepared but I would be lying.

Finley was so much more than I could have predicted. I thought she would be shallow and maybe a little vapid and we would get to know her and she would grow. But I loved her from the start. She literally had everything she could ever ask for. Yet she was so prepared to step out of her comfort zone. And she was such a sweet person she was awesome to get to know better.

Lincoln was such a great dad and honestly I was expecting him to be bitter and reluctant to see Finley for who she could be. But once he decided to take a chance on her he really saw her and the lengths she went to for Asa to be happy and safe. And watching him fall and not even slightly fight it was hot.

Asa was a great addition and I loved watching him interact with Finley. There were so many different ways that this could have played out that when the drama hit I wasn't expecting it to play out like that. I would have loved to see a little more vengeance being rained down but I am a little blood thirsty. And everything was resolved beautifully. The epilogues were a perfect cherry on top.
Profile Image for Catherine (catisbookedup).
399 reviews26 followers
October 13, 2026
2nd in this wonderful series. After rating the first book 5 stars it was great re-visiting some of these characters. Natasha Madison doesn't fail to deliver level headed MMCs you can completely fall for. Lincoln is a protective single Dad trying to make the best situation for his son after his wife cheated on him with her now new husband. Natasha tends to give a bit more variety with her FMCs. In this case we have Finley a down to earth rich girl coming out of a bad situation after her new husband conned her into marriage for her trust fund and cheated on her all over town. You completely root for her as she tries to escape him. The obvious trope for me here was dislike to lovers. The two main characters were actually very different from one another and I get it, their banter and attraction was there from the start, however my issue here was that I felt like their sexual attraction basically just made them accept each other rather than genuinely fall in love with each other. As much fun as the spice was and it was a lot of fun, I get a feeling they were just horny for each other. I also have mixed feelings on the damsel in distress angle. So as much as I enjoyed myself with this book I still prefer the first book.
The audiobook as always was perfection, both narrators delivered on every front.

Many thanks to Natasha Madison and Shauna Casey from The Author Agency for providing me with a copy of the audiobook for review.
Profile Image for Katie Thayer.
547 reviews70 followers
October 15, 2026
Falling For Her
(Book 2 in The Falling For Series)
(Immersive Read)
By Natasha Madison

Getting involved with my boss is not something that I should be doing. But Lincoln makes me do and say things that push me out of my comfort zone.

“I’ve never felt like this before, never felt like I was going to come out of my skin. Never had the need to be touched so badly before.”

“With me, you can always be you. I want to see the real you.”

I loved my immersive read of Finley and Lincoln’s story! We see Finley go from city girl to small town lover and learning to enjoy the little things in life. Finley’s relationship with Asa, Lincoln son is the cutest! Those two become fast friends and it will melt your heart seeing that love bloom. When we first meet Lincoln he is a stressed out single dad. Trying to balance work life and home life. When Finley comes on to nanny for Asa, slowly we see Lincoln start to relax and enjoy each day. There’s also a light mix of suspense that was a really great layer to this story! Now let’s talk about the narrators! Funky and Lincoln’s story is narrated by Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor! Yes amazing audiobook! Really enjoyed this read!

Tropes:
Single Dad x Nanny
Opposites Attract
Small Town Romance
Forbidden Romance
Detective Hero
Damsel In Distress

Spice Starts at: 62%

Spice: 2/4
Stars: 4.5/5

Available on Kindle Unlimited
Profile Image for Cokiereads.
813 reviews37 followers
October 14, 2026
What a great second book. Now, this one really can be read as a stand-alone. 100%!

Finley Westbrook's life is... easy. A trust fund woman, she thought she had her husband. When she finds out that he cheats, and now wants to steal half her trustfund, she doesn’t know what to do. He won't leave!

She has a great friend to run to though. Collins (the sweetheart from book 1) even suggests a job for her. As a nanny. What will someone whos never had a job do? The hijinks she gets up to... Honestly reminded me of that show The Simple Life. But in a super sweet way.

The guy she's nannying for? He's a detective, who's got a big case on his hands. Lincoln Burke is a divorced dad who's trying to bring down a drug ring. While also fighting his attraction to Finley.

Finley and Asa (Lincoln's son) are really sweet together together. Finley tries her best but in some ways she seems kinda helpless. Not in an idiot kinda way, but someone who has lived a super sheltered life. SUPER sheltered.

There's some mystery going around too. He's working on a big case, she's got an ex who won't be an ex without a payday. And when the job ends, where will Finley go?

Can't wait for book 3!!!!!
Profile Image for Jen Altman.
600 reviews70 followers
October 6, 2026
Finley Westbrook’s life is in total chaos after walking away from a cheating ex who was only after her family's money. Needing a completely fresh start, she somehow lands a job as a live-in nanny for Lincoln Burke, a grumpy, divorced detective and single dad. The catch? Finley grew up privileged, has never held a job in her life, and couldn't cook or do laundry if her life depended on it. I wasn't sure if I'd connect with her at first, but she completely stole my heart. Watching her Google her way through parenting, attempt domestic life with relentless determination, and fueled by a deeply relatable iced matcha addiction, made her transition into Lincoln and his son Asa's world feel like she was meant to be there all along.

Lincoln is rigid, protective, and totally unequipped for the whirlwind that Finley brings into his quiet routine. Their back-and-forth banter is elite, building up a delicious slow-burn tension that turns into absolute fire once it finally explodes. The spice was SPICY between these two!

As a big fan of Natasha Madison's small-town romances, I looked forward to a swoonworthy and heartwarming romance, but I wasn't expecting the romantic suspense aspect that kept me glued to the pages and made even more engaging by the incredible audio narration. I was lucky enough to be able to immersive read this one and let me tell you - the audio is a real treat! Narrated by the incredible duo Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor, their dynamic here is on another level. Teddy delivers that deeply grounded, protective energy that Lincoln needs, while Samantha perfectly captures Finley’s chaotic and fiery spirit. Every bit of humor, emotional depth, and spicy tension is felt in their performance!
Profile Image for Julie.
317 reviews
October 7, 2026
Falling for Her
🎧🎧🎧🎧🎧
Natasha Madison
Narrators: Teddy Hamilton & Samantha Brentmoor

Natasha Madison did it again by this next book in this amazing series and thank you for the gifted ALC/ARC!

She really knows how to do romantic suspense right and then you have the audiobook with this dream team of Teddy Hamilton and Samantha Brentmoor so how can you go wrong.

This book is about Finley and Lincoln with Asa (Lincoln’s son) who deserve to be mentioned as he is just so cute and funny!

But Finley is just the right amount of sassy to keep Lincoln on his toes and decide to let himself think about being with another woman.

Then we have the crazy things that start happening and since Lincoln is a cop he thinks it’s the case he’s working on but it turn out to be so much more!

I did not see the end coming and it had me gasping and tearing up a bit.

You can go wrong with this book if you love single dad, small town and found family!

Oh and get the audiobook and thank me later! 😉
Profile Image for Jen (jensdreamylittlereads).
1,020 reviews124 followers
Review of advance copy
October 9, 2026
Oh my goodness. This series hooked me with Falling For You, but it just completely stole my heart with Falling For Her. I simply could read stories set in Montgavin forever!

GAH! I just freaking loved Finley and Lincoln so much! I loved their chemistry and their whole vibe. I loved how (ultimately) sweet they were, and how organic their relationship felt. I am a sucker for single dad romances and possibly an even bigger sucker for grumpy/sunshine romance, and Falling For Her delivered on both fronts. It delivered all the butterflies and swoons that I ever could have asked for.

In the end, I gobbled this story up with gusto, lost myself for an entire weekend between these pages. And it was sweet, swoony, sexy, and smart. I am having so much fun reading this series and I cannot wait for the next one!
Profile Image for Tasha Thrall.
312 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 12, 2026
They say, “Don’t judge a book by its cover.” Well, I certainly did! I absolutely adore this cover. I initially expected a lighthearted Rom-Com focusing on a single dad and his nanny, but it turned out to be so much more!

I appreciate that this book surprised me; it not only delivered Rom-Com vibes but also added a touch of suspense that kept me eagerly turning the pages. I loved how Finley had no clue what to do and relied on Google for everything, yet she never gave up. Her sassiness and ability to get under Lincoln's skin only intensified the tension!

I genuinely enjoyed it and can’t wait to dive into the next book in the series!

Thank you for this amazing opportunity to read the eARC, and I am happy to provide my honest review in return.
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 8, 2026
Falling For Her by Natasha Madison
My Rating: ★★★★★

I keep saying this with every release Natasha puts out, but her books just keep getting better and better and this one was no different! I absolutely loved Finley and Lincoln’s story and ate up every single word of this book!

Finley’s fun personality mixed with Lincoln’s serious side was a recipe for the perfect mesh up! The back and forth banter, the delicious chemistry that developed and Finley’s relationship and love for Lincoln’s son Asa had me hooked! The suspenseful side to the story with Finley’s ex and Lincoln’s job added even more intensity to their story which had me not able to put this book down until the very end!

I listened to the audiobook and read the ebook in tandem and doing an immersive read was the perfect way to take in this story! Samantha Brentmoor and Teddy Hamilton were the perfect duo for the narration of this book and I highly recommend listening to this one!

What to Expect:
Small Town
Found Family
Detective Hero
Forced Proximity
Opposites Attract
Single Dad x Nanny
Profile Image for Büşra.
769 reviews72 followers
November 19, 2026
Eğer Christmas zamanında yazılsaydı tam bir film olurdu bu arada gerçekten hem çok eğlenceli hem hem de çok tatlıydı. Erkek karaktere sinir olduğumuz bazı yerler oldu ama o da bizi dinlemeden ufacık kızdığı için😂 5 saniye geçmeden pişman oldu ve açıkçası güzel süründürdük kadın karakterimiz asla geri adım atmadı😁 ve çok tatlıydı atışmaları😁😁
Zaten bence bu yazarın çok çerezlik yazmasının sebebi bu hem çok sıkıcı hem de cidden yormuyor olaylar. Sevdimmm💗
Profile Image for Kelsey Camp.
47 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 5, 2026
Overall, this book was a cute single dad/nanny. I love when the dad is a sheriff as well. Asa was a cute addition, and he made everything just a little bit cuter. Finley went through so much and the way Lincoln was protective about her was cute! When he got a call about her and he was SO worried! Finley felt like she couldn’t burden others with information and Lincoln just wanted to know. Overall, a good book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 727 reviews