Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

If We Were Cursed - a deliciously dark and gothic YA fantasy with slow burn romance for fans of The Dagger and the Flame

Rate this book
Prepare for swoon like no other in this heart-racing gothic
fantasy romance for fans of For She Is Wrath and The
Dagger and the Flame

Bellamy Fray is convinced that detestable, suave Jules
Everidge and his occultist family are swindlers, exploiting desperate
people with their séances and curse-breaking. Preying
on people like Bellamy's own mother until she recently passed away.
Now, Bellamy will stop at nothing until she's proven that
the entire family are frauds.


Bellamy pretends to have a "curse" to infiltrate and expose the
Everidges. Yet as she and Jules work together to break it, Jules
is convinced that she is, in fact, quite cursed. Bellamy is certain
this is part of the con, but she swears she can sometimes
feel breath at her neck and an eye in a mirror watching her.
And she starts to question everything.


Her life-long friend Archie tries to help her through her grief,
but as Bellamy begins to spend more time with Jules she's caught
between the safe warmth of Archie, who has always cared for her,
and the wild, magnetic Jules, who may be the only one who can
save her
.



An atmospheric, edge-of-your-seat fantasy you won't be
able to put down
Deliciously dark and gothic, with slow-burn love-triangle
tension
throughout
Perfect for fans of the revenge of For She Is Wrath,
with the addictive romance of The Dagger and the Flame

300 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 8, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lisa M. Sylvan

2 books7 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2 (9%)
4 stars
11 (50%)
3 stars
8 (36%)
2 stars
1 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews
Profile Image for Abi.
2,078 reviews657 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 29, 2026
Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher and Lisa M. Sylvan for the ARC.

I liked the setting and the gothic tone of If We Were Cursed, but I found the characters, romance and plot to all just be fine. I didn't hate any of it, but I didn't feel invested in the story or characters enough to love it unfortunately.

At times this felt a little too young for me. As a reader who loves YA but isn't in the YA age bracket, this can sometimes happen and it's not the books fault at all.

While it didn't work for me, I can really see a lot of readers loving it. It's a classic Romantasy with a gothic feel and I'm sure it'll be a hit for the right audience.
Profile Image for Odette.
229 reviews6 followers
October 17, 2026
Spooky season hath arrived.

This was an incredibly easy read. The writing isn't the kind you can immerse yourself in, the sort where you are watching everything play out though a window where your breath fogs on the glass. Though it definitely makes it super fast to read. Not sure how everyone's poor actions were justified or forgiven by the end but Pearl was brilliant and I could have done a whole lot more with her.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for the ARC
Profile Image for Naomi.
22 reviews4 followers
October 22, 2026
A fun, easy to read, gothic tale with curses, a love triangle, and spooky demons

4⭐️ - a very light read but perfect for getting in the mood for spooky season!

Thank you to Scholastic for gifting me a copy to review 💕
Profile Image for Natasha  Leighton .
864 reviews461 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 5, 2026
Eerie, gothic and so very compulsive, Lisa M. Sylvan’s If We Were Cursed was the perfect book to kick off my spooky season with!

It follows teen Bellamy, who, months after her mother’s passing, is still angry at the local occultist family (the Everidges) for swindling on her mum (with seances and “curse” breaking rituals.) And impulsively decides to prove they’re frauds by fabricating a curse of her own and seeing how they “fix” it.

Only, once her classmate Jude Everidge and his family begin investigating, the curse doesn’t feel quite so fake. in fact, it’s beginning to feel like she’s experiencing the same thing her mother did before she died. And if they can’t find a solution in time, she’ll meet the same tragic fate…

I had such an enjoyable time reading this! It’s gorgeously atmospheric, with an dark, unsettling undercurrent that I found utterly intriguing.

I will say it was pacier than I anticipated, but did add a layer of urgency to the emotional pressures Bellamy faces, as she navigates (and mirrors) her mother’s last weeks alive.

Add in her best friend (supernatural sceptic), Archie, who she recently shared a grief fuelled kiss with. Jude, the boy she’s slowly being drawn to (as he helps her track down a way out of certain death) and we get a love triangle dynamic to thoroughly swoon over as well.

But personally, despite the romance and the creepy, otherworldly elements it was the focus on Bellamy and her emotional journey, as she begins to let go of her anger, find closure (and feel even more connected to her mum) that really made this such a standout read. And I think anyone who’s ever experienced loss will really resonate with Bellamy and all she endures.

Overall, an enjoyably immersive YA Fantasy that captures grief, healing and teen emotions in such a unique way.

Also, thanks to Scholastic UK & Insta book tours for the PB copy.
Profile Image for Claire.
120 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy
October 1, 2026
I was interested in the book from the get go as, one, I love slow burn, just dump all those slow burn books on me. And, two, being a fan of The Dagger and the Flame, peaked my interest.

I was so happy that instabooktours picked me to be part of their tour as this book did not disappoint.

If We Were Cursed is a gothic fantasy that blends eerie magic, tangled friendships, and slow‑burn romance into a story that feels both haunting and heartfelt. I absolutely loved the atmosphere in this book as its set in a small town with secrets and magic dripping with eerie vibes.

The story follows Bellamy Fray as she tries to expose the Everidge family for the occult “curse‑breaking” she believes contributed to her mother’s death. Determined and grieving, she fakes a curse to infiltrate their world only to find herself caught between eerie, unexplainable happenings and two boys who pull her in opposite directions. Jules is all dangerous charm and shadowy intensity, while Archie is the steady warmth she’s always relied on. As séances, whispers, and strange rituals blur the line between con and curse, Bellamy begins to question everything she thought she knew.

It blends gothic atmosphere with mystery: séances, whispered legends, strange rituals, and the unsettling possibility that curses might be real. It’s about grief, belief, and the dangerous comfort of wanting answers

It’s a dark, atmospheric gothic fantasy with slow‑burn tension, messy emotions, and a love triangle that feels beautifully human. The story balances eerie magic with real grief, making it addictive, moody, and impossible to put down.
🌙🕯️💀✨

Profile Image for Maria.
381 reviews18 followers
October 13, 2026
If we were Cursed is the perfect book for the ‘ber months! It has such a good balance between emotions, eeriness, ghosts and plot! The synopsis instantaneously draw me into this book but I ended up devouring this in one sitting: both the writing and plot execution are spot on!

We have Bellamy that has just lost her mum and will not stop until she gets answers; then we have Jules Everidge, whose family is in the business of the occultism, ghosts and mediums - also, whose family Bellamy is blaming for her mum’s erratic last weeks and doom. Carrying the false pretence of being “cursed”, she is very focused on proving the Everidge family is selling scams. Until, they are not and Bellamy is in fact very cursed.

The gothic atmosphere was spot on with the theme of the book, the grief was palpable and the fear could be cut with a knife in some instances! This book was actually a lot more eerie and ‘darker’ than I expected, which made it such a fantastic read for this season! The writing was really really good bringing all the vibes into this experience!

The way Bellamy and Jules grow closer gelt organic and real, although I think the author could have stretched the way they end up falling for one another - it felt rather too quick for me, but at the same time, they are teenagers so I can accept it and it didn’t damped my experience at all!
Profile Image for Abbie.
86 reviews7 followers
October 5, 2026
Thank you Scholastic and Insta Book Tours for the gifted copy!

I really enjoyed this! A fairly quick read, but filled to the brim with mystery, suspense and a little bit of romance ✨
Profile Image for Abbeigh.
246 reviews31 followers
October 5, 2026
This is a brilliant little read, perfect for the darker nights and spooky season! It’s eerie, it’s atmospheric, and I really enjoyed the plot.
Profile Image for Lumie.
836 reviews2 followers
October 20, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Scholastic UK for the ARC.

Plot 4.25/5
Characters 4/5
Ending 4/5
Interest 4.5/5

Overall 4.25/5

-This book was such a beautiful mix of gothic haunted house vibes and a great cursed plot with compelling characters. As a whole, I really enjoyed reading about a curse, breaking said curse and how everything impacts our main characters. It was thoroughly entertaining.

-Overall I really liked the characters. Though sometimes they did irritate me a just a tad. Jules felt rude at times, not just nonchalant but rude and then, I can sort of understand, but I wish Archie was treated a little better. But those are simply details a few moments, as a whole the characters were great.

-The ending was fine for this book. It didn’t particularly blow me away but I appreciate it not dragging for a long time. It was simple and sweet and just what I needed to read.
Profile Image for Claire Smith-Simmons.
442 reviews19 followers
November 14, 2026
Thank you to RB media for my audiobook copy. All opinions are my own.

This book caught me by surprise, the premise sounded interesting and the combination of the narrator and the story really drew me in. I was hooked from the beginning with the tragic opening chapters, and feeling the anger, the despair and the grief all wrapped up in Bellamy.

The atmosphere was brooding and pensive, the occult adding to the growing tension.

I liked Bellamy and enjoyed seeing the love triangle play out in a way that was part of the story but never overpowering.

Overall a good YA mystery with tension and a touch of romance
Profile Image for Jess Twibey.
256 reviews26 followers
September 29, 2026
Not quite an enemies to lovers, more a one sided hatred turned to maybe falling in love

Imagine you’re a teen girl, you’re mum just died and you think the spooky fake family in town is to blame. It’s hardly a surprise Bellamy hates them all and plans to expose them for the fakes she knows they are, like fair I’m 100% behind you… except, maybe they’re not all that fake. People in the supernatural world are bound to seem fake and eccentric to outsiders, and who doesn’t love a misunderstood love interest. Bellamys plan is flawless, lie and prove them to be fakes, except her lie unbeknownst to her is actually true and now, just like her mother before her, she’s relying on this family to help save her life before a demon takes it. I love the fact we have a golden retriever best friend who she’s into, until he doubts her, tells her dad what’s she’s done and said behind her back, the reality being she wouldn’t believe anyone else either but the trust between them is broken and will never be the same. A curse that’s so unbelievable, anyone who doesn’t believe in the supernatural is more likely to try and hospitalise you, a lonely curse that’s forces you to spend your last days alone.. or would if it wasn’t for that annoyingly helpful and actually real spooky family.

I really loved this one, although Bellamys beliefs felt shaken very easily she’s been through so much losing her mum and now seeing glimpses of what killed her mum and is coming for her next. Very age appropriate love interest (yay) and a focus for the nightmare of demons as well as the overwhelming power of grief.
Displaying 1 - 11 of 11 reviews