What do you think?
Sweetwater Peak #2
Free Falling: A Sweetwater Peak Novel
Old haunts, new feelings.
The #1 New York Times bestselling author of the Rebel Blue Ranch series returns to the haunted town of Sweetwater Peak for another love story, this one featuring an antique shop owner and a farmer who fake a relationship to save their legacies…but will they be able to fool the ghosts of their past?
Clarke Cartwright probably needed to get out more. She just had a lot to do. Running Toade’s Antiques was no small feat, especially considering that the roof was in shambles and half her merchandise was unsellable. But dealing with that felt easier than her other two third-wheeling with her best friend…again, or chatting it up with the ghost of her childhood crush’s father, who just can’t seem to leave her alone.
Leith Wilkes has spent his life preparing to take over his family's farm. Well, he’s actually spent most of his life flirting, but now he’s ready to buckle down, which has nothing to do with an oddly specific clause that his dad left in his inheritance. Leith is pretty sure he’s the only one who knows about it…until Clarke drunkenly spills that she knows, too, along with a bunch of other Wilkes family secrets.
Leith starts to wonder if there’s more to Clarke than she lets on…and if his dad has something to do with it. And if she is keeping secrets of her own, maybe she won’t mind helping him with his.
The #1 New York Times bestselling author of the Rebel Blue Ranch series returns to the haunted town of Sweetwater Peak for another love story, this one featuring an antique shop owner and a farmer who fake a relationship to save their legacies…but will they be able to fool the ghosts of their past?
Clarke Cartwright probably needed to get out more. She just had a lot to do. Running Toade’s Antiques was no small feat, especially considering that the roof was in shambles and half her merchandise was unsellable. But dealing with that felt easier than her other two third-wheeling with her best friend…again, or chatting it up with the ghost of her childhood crush’s father, who just can’t seem to leave her alone.
Leith Wilkes has spent his life preparing to take over his family's farm. Well, he’s actually spent most of his life flirting, but now he’s ready to buckle down, which has nothing to do with an oddly specific clause that his dad left in his inheritance. Leith is pretty sure he’s the only one who knows about it…until Clarke drunkenly spills that she knows, too, along with a bunch of other Wilkes family secrets.
Leith starts to wonder if there’s more to Clarke than she lets on…and if his dad has something to do with it. And if she is keeping secrets of her own, maybe she won’t mind helping him with his.
315 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 22, 2026
About the author
Lyla Sage
10 books17k followersLyla Sage lives in the Wild West with her loyal companion, a sweet, old, blind rescue pitbull. She writes romance that feels like her favorite things: sunshine and big blue skies. She is also the author of Done and Dusted. When she’s not writing, she’s reading.
Instagram: @authorlylasage
TikTok: @authorlylasage
Threads: @authorlylasage
https://linktr.ee/authorlylasage
Instagram: @authorlylasage
TikTok: @authorlylasage
Threads: @authorlylasage
https://linktr.ee/authorlylasage
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 569 reviews
September 21, 2026
⭐️ 3.5 ⭐️ Paranormal, where?
I've been looking forward to this for a year! Soul Searching was such a flop in the paranormal love department, so I was very hopeful that this would be better than the first book. The issues that were present in book one unfortunately still carried over into book two and I felt that I was basically reading the same book just with a different love interest. The plot was extremely thin. Not enough happens and the book felt too quiet. There was so little emotional/romantic tension, character development and personal resolution that it almost didn't feel as intimate as a small town romance should. Small town romances have more of a character-driven storyline vs plot-line but I felt that I didn't get to know the main characters well enough to like or dislike them. There were a few heartfelt moments but overall I think it lacked that 'tug' I was looking for. Also, unlike book one, this book did not have enough paranormal content..where did it go? Clarke has the ability to speak to ghosts. There was room for the author to divulge a bit in that regard but aside from few ghosts here and there, the paranormal content is almost nonexistent in this novel.
I loved her Rebel Blue Ranch Series and while this is no cowboy romance, I'd take a small town romance anyday! Hopeful that thirds time will be the charm.
I've been looking forward to this for a year! Soul Searching was such a flop in the paranormal love department, so I was very hopeful that this would be better than the first book. The issues that were present in book one unfortunately still carried over into book two and I felt that I was basically reading the same book just with a different love interest. The plot was extremely thin. Not enough happens and the book felt too quiet. There was so little emotional/romantic tension, character development and personal resolution that it almost didn't feel as intimate as a small town romance should. Small town romances have more of a character-driven storyline vs plot-line but I felt that I didn't get to know the main characters well enough to like or dislike them. There were a few heartfelt moments but overall I think it lacked that 'tug' I was looking for. Also, unlike book one, this book did not have enough paranormal content..where did it go? Clarke has the ability to speak to ghosts. There was room for the author to divulge a bit in that regard but aside from few ghosts here and there, the paranormal content is almost nonexistent in this novel.
I loved her Rebel Blue Ranch Series and while this is no cowboy romance, I'd take a small town romance anyday! Hopeful that thirds time will be the charm.
September 22, 2026
Thoughts
First off, YES this book is my top favourite from the series so far and NO me starting this book again has absolutely nothing to do with the book itself I wasn't in the right head space felt like I was just reading words. I picked back up again at 11pm and lo n behold the reading faires consumed me🥲 this was so fucking beautiful from dot to the end and the author's note??? Oh Lyla my darling girl I just wanted to hug her🥹 she always does emotional intros and outros but this one specifically spoke to my soul -- actually after reading the note and the way she wrote Clarke in terms of personality and dialogues I just know she POURED her soul into that FMC ❤️🩹 but little does she know she was mirroring all my feelings in the process--- I highlighted 112 lines from this book to be exact ( romance plot included ) so there's that.
The MCs
Clarke And Leith :
When you know from the very first encounter that a couple belong together like two peas in a pod that's when you also know the book is gonna hit hard on them being vulnerable and oh my God my heart could swell up from the happiness I experienced reading and witnessing their relationship develop 😭 they're both equally as closed off, scarred from "walks of life " as they say and both know loneliness just as much as the other not to mention the stubbornness😂 -- on that note the banter was so fucked good especially with Clarke being her awkward self😂 ughhhh I ADORE THEM 😭😍
This book officially earns a spot in the books I won't accept criticism on pile
Plot Summary
Clarke is struggling to keep her antique shop afloat while dealing with a ghost from her past. When she accidentally reveals that she knows one of Leith's family secrets, he begins to wonder what else she’s hiding. As they grow closer, they find themselves uncovering more secrets than either expected.
My Bookstagram
First off, YES this book is my top favourite from the series so far and NO me starting this book again has absolutely nothing to do with the book itself I wasn't in the right head space felt like I was just reading words. I picked back up again at 11pm and lo n behold the reading faires consumed me🥲 this was so fucking beautiful from dot to the end and the author's note??? Oh Lyla my darling girl I just wanted to hug her🥹 she always does emotional intros and outros but this one specifically spoke to my soul -- actually after reading the note and the way she wrote Clarke in terms of personality and dialogues I just know she POURED her soul into that FMC ❤️🩹 but little does she know she was mirroring all my feelings in the process--- I highlighted 112 lines from this book to be exact ( romance plot included ) so there's that.
The MCs
Clarke And Leith :
When you know from the very first encounter that a couple belong together like two peas in a pod that's when you also know the book is gonna hit hard on them being vulnerable and oh my God my heart could swell up from the happiness I experienced reading and witnessing their relationship develop 😭 they're both equally as closed off, scarred from "walks of life " as they say and both know loneliness just as much as the other not to mention the stubbornness😂 -- on that note the banter was so fucked good especially with Clarke being her awkward self😂 ughhhh I ADORE THEM 😭😍
This book officially earns a spot in the books I won't accept criticism on pile
Plot Summary
Clarke is struggling to keep her antique shop afloat while dealing with a ghost from her past. When she accidentally reveals that she knows one of Leith's family secrets, he begins to wonder what else she’s hiding. As they grow closer, they find themselves uncovering more secrets than either expected.
My Bookstagram
August 23, 2026
Happy pub day to one of my top 5 books of the year 🩷
arc review: I can’t lie, Soul Searching was a huge miss for me. I was a little hesitant to read this one, but I am truly so surprised by how much I loved this. A new favorite!! Top 5 of 2026 so far!! Clarke is truly a soul character for me like that’s my girl. I could relate so deeply to her that I really think she is what made the book for me. She’s my favorite type of fmc: a little prickly, independent, people pleaser. Aka me. I also really adored Leith. Golden retriever mmc perfection who yearned!! Who was down BAD!! Their history and tension were so good. The fake dating trope (one of my faves) was also super fun and added a lot to the story. I loved the small town setting and seeing all the characters and locations again. I also REALLY loved how the ghosts played such an important role in this book. I felt like that was missing from Soul Searching but was definitely made up for in this one. I just really loved every page of this book. Clarke was absolutely the highlight of the book for me and her character growth and acceptance by the end was so good. I loved the romance too of course, the side characters, and the fake dating plot. I also think this is Lyla’s writing at its best. SUCH a surprise hit 😭🩷 thank you so much to the publisher for the arc
arc review: I can’t lie, Soul Searching was a huge miss for me. I was a little hesitant to read this one, but I am truly so surprised by how much I loved this. A new favorite!! Top 5 of 2026 so far!! Clarke is truly a soul character for me like that’s my girl. I could relate so deeply to her that I really think she is what made the book for me. She’s my favorite type of fmc: a little prickly, independent, people pleaser. Aka me. I also really adored Leith. Golden retriever mmc perfection who yearned!! Who was down BAD!! Their history and tension were so good. The fake dating trope (one of my faves) was also super fun and added a lot to the story. I loved the small town setting and seeing all the characters and locations again. I also REALLY loved how the ghosts played such an important role in this book. I felt like that was missing from Soul Searching but was definitely made up for in this one. I just really loved every page of this book. Clarke was absolutely the highlight of the book for me and her character growth and acceptance by the end was so good. I loved the romance too of course, the side characters, and the fake dating plot. I also think this is Lyla’s writing at its best. SUCH a surprise hit 😭🩷 thank you so much to the publisher for the arc
August 23, 2026
4.5
I really enjoyed Soul Searching and was so excited for Clarke’s story. I adored Collins, but Clarke definitely has a special place in my heart. My god, I related to her so hard as a character and just wanted to give her a hug.
I do wish we’d gotten more of the twins together. I felt like Collins came back very late into the story, and some of my favourite parts were when the two of them were together.
The plot was rather basic but I’ve found that both of these books are much more character-driven than plot-driven, which I don't mind to be honest. I love Collins and Clarke enough that it worked for the series.
I absolutely adored the MMC, Leith. He had such strong golden retriever energy, the twins definitely have something in common there, and he was perfect for Clarke. I also loved how their history was intertwined throughout the story rather than relying on flashbacks to show us their past. I’m not always the biggest fan of friends-to-lovers, but this worked very well.
My only gripe would be that the story felt a little unfinished, particularly Leith’s storyline with his father. I also wish the epilogue had focused more on the twins, who were really the heart of this duet.
But otherwise, another solid series from Lyla Sage.
I received an advanced reading copy for free through NetGalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I really enjoyed Soul Searching and was so excited for Clarke’s story. I adored Collins, but Clarke definitely has a special place in my heart. My god, I related to her so hard as a character and just wanted to give her a hug.
I do wish we’d gotten more of the twins together. I felt like Collins came back very late into the story, and some of my favourite parts were when the two of them were together.
The plot was rather basic but I’ve found that both of these books are much more character-driven than plot-driven, which I don't mind to be honest. I love Collins and Clarke enough that it worked for the series.
I absolutely adored the MMC, Leith. He had such strong golden retriever energy, the twins definitely have something in common there, and he was perfect for Clarke. I also loved how their history was intertwined throughout the story rather than relying on flashbacks to show us their past. I’m not always the biggest fan of friends-to-lovers, but this worked very well.
My only gripe would be that the story felt a little unfinished, particularly Leith’s storyline with his father. I also wish the epilogue had focused more on the twins, who were really the heart of this duet.
But otherwise, another solid series from Lyla Sage.
I received an advanced reading copy for free through NetGalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 14, 2026
Lyla look away …
I didn’t like Soul Searching but I had hope that this one might turn out better BUT NO
the characters have no chemistry, no depth, nothing except for the very big feelings that are tied to their specific storyline
The dialogue feels forced and doesn’t flow
There is nothing in this book that a real person would say out loud
Lyla I’m so sorry but babes I think you need to take a breather — every book there seems to be an authors note talking about how writing this was a struggle…well I fear it’s very evident
thank you netgalley 🫣
I didn’t like Soul Searching but I had hope that this one might turn out better BUT NO
the characters have no chemistry, no depth, nothing except for the very big feelings that are tied to their specific storyline
The dialogue feels forced and doesn’t flow
There is nothing in this book that a real person would say out loud
Lyla I’m so sorry but babes I think you need to take a breather — every book there seems to be an authors note talking about how writing this was a struggle…well I fear it’s very evident
thank you netgalley 🫣
September 22, 2026
dnf @ 67%
i would rather a bird shit on my head then continue reading this slop
i would rather a bird shit on my head then continue reading this slop
remind-me-once-out
January 25, 2026I knew there had to be more 🤩
September 24, 2026
Free Falling by Lyla Sage
Liked this one so much more than Soul Searching
How did he not know about the will stipulation after almost 5 years?
Hoarders antique shop, small town gossip, FMC dealing with depression, fake dating, I see dead people, ridiculous will stipulations
Thanks to NetGalley, Hachette AU & NZ and Lyla Sage for the ARC, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
Liked this one so much more than Soul Searching
How did he not know about the will stipulation after almost 5 years?
Hoarders antique shop, small town gossip, FMC dealing with depression, fake dating, I see dead people, ridiculous will stipulations
Thanks to NetGalley, Hachette AU & NZ and Lyla Sage for the ARC, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
September 7, 2026
6 ⭐️
honestly i think this may be my fav of lyla’s yet (sorry emmy and luke)
honestly i think this may be my fav of lyla’s yet (sorry emmy and luke)
May 1, 2026
☆ 4 stars
Free Falling is the second and final instalment in the Sweetwater Peak duet by author Lyla Sage. I was so excited to get my hands on this book as soon as possible after the small insight into Clarke’s character throughout Soul Searching piqued my interest and determination to know more about her life. This book was exactly the type of story that I needed in the moment and I’m a firm believer that some books are meant to find you at the right time. I became invested into the story of our two main characters with ease and found myself unwilling to put the book down until reaching its conclusion within one sitting. Something I always credit Sage for is knowing how to create complex and compelling characters that you want to root for which is something that I believe was executed to perfection throughout Free Falling. I love the sense of community that has been established within Sweetwater Peak amongst both the living and the deceased, and the way that the existence of these characters always seems to come full circle. I really enjoyed the paranormal elements in the way that it seamlessly intertwines with present events whilst also acting as a window into the rich history and lore of this spooky small town. The paranormal aspect did feel more understated in comparison to book one, however this makes sense to me due to the opposing experience that both sisters have with their gift. The exploration of depression was handled with the upmost care and I cannot express just how deeply this resonated with me. I really appreciate the way that it became a focus of Clarke’s journey and my ability to connect to her on a more emotional level as a result. Free Falling is a beautiful conclusion to an emotional and character-driven duet that I know I will be returning to reread time and again in the very near future… because home is not always just a place.
Clarke Cartwright is a wonderfully complex character that I have loved getting more insight into throughout her own point-of-view. I found it really easy to feel connected to Clarke throughout her exploration as she undertakes a deeper realisation and recognition of herself and the life that she greatly desires to experience. Underneath a tough exterior is a soft and gentle woman who yearns to find a lifelong partner that will not only share the heavy weight of her burdens, but also somebody who can see her more than anybody else has; a whole person outside of her sister and her identity as a twin who is allowed to make mistakes of her own, and be forgiven for them. A partner that is a safe place to land during times of struggle that she can trust to catch her when she falls. The depiction of Clarke’s depression greatly resonated with me on a vulnerable level in the way that it is represented and explored. This isn’t something that you just wake up on a random morning in recognition of. It’s a plethora of different things that sneak up on you and consumes your entire being. The inclusion of burnout, fatigue and stress were all huge indicators to me that I recognised from within myself and it really means a lot to see a character being explored so vulnerably… and yet, still deserving of being loved fully and loudly. The majority of my kindle highlights are of Clarke’s dialogue and I just know that I’ll find myself revisiting them again and again in the way they made me feel seen and understood. Her complex relationship with her mother and the strain that their mutual involvement in the family business acts as a division felt wholly realistic and well executed, albeit slightly resolved a little more swiftly than I had been anticipating. Clarke is a woman that loves wholly without restraint for the small number of people that she allows into every aspect of her life, and it made me thrilled to see her learn how to open herself up to more people who prove that they want care for her. Seeing her combat her fear of the paranormal and the acceptance that they’re just as much a part of her as she is to them felt significant, and in the end I couldn’t be happier for the send-off that we leave Clarke with.
One thing you can rely on throughout this duology (ans Lyla in general) are green flag men with Leith Wilkes being another shining example of this. Leith is a kind, funny and hardworking man that values his family and community above all else. There is no level that is too deep to steep to in protection of his family and his legacy, and I had nothing but respect for his ability to adapt and overcome all of the struggles that came his way. His reputation as Sweetwater Peak’s ‘golden boy’ made him the perfect contrast to the woman that he had quietly yearned for from afar since his teenage years. I laughed to myself on several occasions throughout Leith’s dialogue that showed on the inside he’s still that young boy that attempts to rile up his crush just so that she will recognise his existence. The stability and silent strength that he presents himself with is one of the many attributes that makes him to perfect partner for Clarke in his refusal to let her go through her struggles alone... even when his entire perception on reality is challenged. I adored Leith’s gentleness and the way that he made communication a priority whilst also respecting boundaries whenever Clarke struggles to voice her feelings. His patient and calm demeanour was a great attribute to his role throughout the story, and most of all I loved getting to witness Leith’s close relationship with his teenage niece that he is one of the primary caretakers of. His role as an uncle, stand-in father and a friend to Lainey felt beautifully explored with intent and I adore getting to witness a family that loves one another without condition. I’m truly thrilled with the conclusion to Leith’s story and the way that he has managed to achieve that life that he dreamed of after thinking it to be impossible. A life where he gets to live for himself outside of the shadow and expectations of his deceased father… whilst also honouring his family legacy and the needs of his community.
Free Falling was a fast-paced and endearing follow-up to Soul Searching that I greatly enjoyed from beginning-to-end. The implementing of a fake dating dynamic made for a fun and irresistible read that I will eat up every single time. I was thrilled to see even more wonderful Rebel Blue Ranch cameos throughout this one and I selfishly hope that this isn’t the last time we’re get to see these characters that I have loved and connected with over the years. I’m sad to be saying goodbye to the heartwarming residents of Sweetwater Peak, however I look forward to see where author Lyla Sage will take us next in her upcoming endeavours.
𝐓𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐤 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐩𝐮𝐛𝐥𝐢𝐬𝐡𝐞𝐫 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐞𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐭𝐨 𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐝 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰 𝐩𝐫𝐢𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐨 𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞.
The 'Sweetwater Peak' duology:
1. Soul Searching - 4.5 stars
2. Free Falling - 4 stars
Free Falling is the second and final instalment in the Sweetwater Peak duet by author Lyla Sage. I was so excited to get my hands on this book as soon as possible after the small insight into Clarke’s character throughout Soul Searching piqued my interest and determination to know more about her life. This book was exactly the type of story that I needed in the moment and I’m a firm believer that some books are meant to find you at the right time. I became invested into the story of our two main characters with ease and found myself unwilling to put the book down until reaching its conclusion within one sitting. Something I always credit Sage for is knowing how to create complex and compelling characters that you want to root for which is something that I believe was executed to perfection throughout Free Falling. I love the sense of community that has been established within Sweetwater Peak amongst both the living and the deceased, and the way that the existence of these characters always seems to come full circle. I really enjoyed the paranormal elements in the way that it seamlessly intertwines with present events whilst also acting as a window into the rich history and lore of this spooky small town. The paranormal aspect did feel more understated in comparison to book one, however this makes sense to me due to the opposing experience that both sisters have with their gift. The exploration of depression was handled with the upmost care and I cannot express just how deeply this resonated with me. I really appreciate the way that it became a focus of Clarke’s journey and my ability to connect to her on a more emotional level as a result. Free Falling is a beautiful conclusion to an emotional and character-driven duet that I know I will be returning to reread time and again in the very near future… because home is not always just a place.
Clarke Cartwright is a wonderfully complex character that I have loved getting more insight into throughout her own point-of-view. I found it really easy to feel connected to Clarke throughout her exploration as she undertakes a deeper realisation and recognition of herself and the life that she greatly desires to experience. Underneath a tough exterior is a soft and gentle woman who yearns to find a lifelong partner that will not only share the heavy weight of her burdens, but also somebody who can see her more than anybody else has; a whole person outside of her sister and her identity as a twin who is allowed to make mistakes of her own, and be forgiven for them. A partner that is a safe place to land during times of struggle that she can trust to catch her when she falls. The depiction of Clarke’s depression greatly resonated with me on a vulnerable level in the way that it is represented and explored. This isn’t something that you just wake up on a random morning in recognition of. It’s a plethora of different things that sneak up on you and consumes your entire being. The inclusion of burnout, fatigue and stress were all huge indicators to me that I recognised from within myself and it really means a lot to see a character being explored so vulnerably… and yet, still deserving of being loved fully and loudly. The majority of my kindle highlights are of Clarke’s dialogue and I just know that I’ll find myself revisiting them again and again in the way they made me feel seen and understood. Her complex relationship with her mother and the strain that their mutual involvement in the family business acts as a division felt wholly realistic and well executed, albeit slightly resolved a little more swiftly than I had been anticipating. Clarke is a woman that loves wholly without restraint for the small number of people that she allows into every aspect of her life, and it made me thrilled to see her learn how to open herself up to more people who prove that they want care for her. Seeing her combat her fear of the paranormal and the acceptance that they’re just as much a part of her as she is to them felt significant, and in the end I couldn’t be happier for the send-off that we leave Clarke with.
One thing you can rely on throughout this duology (ans Lyla in general) are green flag men with Leith Wilkes being another shining example of this. Leith is a kind, funny and hardworking man that values his family and community above all else. There is no level that is too deep to steep to in protection of his family and his legacy, and I had nothing but respect for his ability to adapt and overcome all of the struggles that came his way. His reputation as Sweetwater Peak’s ‘golden boy’ made him the perfect contrast to the woman that he had quietly yearned for from afar since his teenage years. I laughed to myself on several occasions throughout Leith’s dialogue that showed on the inside he’s still that young boy that attempts to rile up his crush just so that she will recognise his existence. The stability and silent strength that he presents himself with is one of the many attributes that makes him to perfect partner for Clarke in his refusal to let her go through her struggles alone... even when his entire perception on reality is challenged. I adored Leith’s gentleness and the way that he made communication a priority whilst also respecting boundaries whenever Clarke struggles to voice her feelings. His patient and calm demeanour was a great attribute to his role throughout the story, and most of all I loved getting to witness Leith’s close relationship with his teenage niece that he is one of the primary caretakers of. His role as an uncle, stand-in father and a friend to Lainey felt beautifully explored with intent and I adore getting to witness a family that loves one another without condition. I’m truly thrilled with the conclusion to Leith’s story and the way that he has managed to achieve that life that he dreamed of after thinking it to be impossible. A life where he gets to live for himself outside of the shadow and expectations of his deceased father… whilst also honouring his family legacy and the needs of his community.
Free Falling was a fast-paced and endearing follow-up to Soul Searching that I greatly enjoyed from beginning-to-end. The implementing of a fake dating dynamic made for a fun and irresistible read that I will eat up every single time. I was thrilled to see even more wonderful Rebel Blue Ranch cameos throughout this one and I selfishly hope that this isn’t the last time we’re get to see these characters that I have loved and connected with over the years. I’m sad to be saying goodbye to the heartwarming residents of Sweetwater Peak, however I look forward to see where author Lyla Sage will take us next in her upcoming endeavours.
𝐓𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐤 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐩𝐮𝐛𝐥𝐢𝐬𝐡𝐞𝐫 𝐟𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐞𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐭𝐨 𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐝 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰 𝐩𝐫𝐢𝐨𝐫 𝐭𝐨 𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐞.
The 'Sweetwater Peak' duology:
1. Soul Searching - 4.5 stars
2. Free Falling - 4 stars
September 1, 2026
I am SO surprised by how much I loved this book 😭❤️
The first book in the series, Soul Searching, was a bit of a miss for me, but Free Falling had me hooked from the very beginning. I instantly fell in love with these characters and genuinely didn’t want to put it down!
Clarke was absolutely the highlight of this book for me. She is truly a soul character, and I related to her SO deeply. She’s exactly my favourite type of FMC — a little prickly, fiercely independent, and a total people pleaser underneath it all. Watching her character growth was just so good. And Leith?? Golden retriever MMC perfection. The yearning. Their history, chemistry, and tension were everything, and I loved watching their relationship develop.
The fake dating trope (one of my absolute favourites!) added another layer to the story that I really enjoyed. I also loved being back in the small-town setting and I loved the role the ghosts played in this book. They felt so important to the story and added such a unique element.
Such a hit! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The first book in the series, Soul Searching, was a bit of a miss for me, but Free Falling had me hooked from the very beginning. I instantly fell in love with these characters and genuinely didn’t want to put it down!
Clarke was absolutely the highlight of this book for me. She is truly a soul character, and I related to her SO deeply. She’s exactly my favourite type of FMC — a little prickly, fiercely independent, and a total people pleaser underneath it all. Watching her character growth was just so good. And Leith?? Golden retriever MMC perfection. The yearning. Their history, chemistry, and tension were everything, and I loved watching their relationship develop.
The fake dating trope (one of my absolute favourites!) added another layer to the story that I really enjoyed. I also loved being back in the small-town setting and I loved the role the ghosts played in this book. They felt so important to the story and added such a unique element.
Such a hit! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
September 26, 2026
4.5 ⭐️ i’m sooo sad this is the end of sweetwater peak 😭 i love these sisters so much. i really related to clarke on so many levels, and leith was the perfect book boyfriend! i overall highly recommend these books 💓 especially for fall!!
June 21, 2026
This was unfortunately not a hit for me. Don’t get me wrong, I love Lyla Sage’s characters, settings, writing, and storylines, but the romance was a tad lackluster in my opinion. You have Clarke who can see ghosts, and Leith who needs to get married to save his family farm. They’re not really *friends* per se, but they’ve known each other for years and years and had crushes on each other in school. So when they start up this fake dating scheme, I thought there would be MORE. Instead, they went from “I’ll help you out” to “we’re totally into each other but neither of us will say it so this fake dating will transition to real dating without communication” and it just felt rushed and odd to me. Maybe it was a lack of secondary characters, because I loved when Leith’s cousin Lainey would show up and when we got Collins back in town, plus the Cam cameo was super fun. Maybe it was the underdeveloped emotional side of things? Everything felt like it almost hit the line of ‘oh, this could go somewhere good’ and then never went anywhere, almost like certain plot points were forgotten about. I wanted to feel more connected to the characters, but that’s hard when almost everything gets cut off before it has time to develop.
I still had fun reading it, I still eat up everything Lyla Sage and will continue to do so, but this just didn’t hit the mark for me. Thank you to NetGalley and Dial Press for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!!
I still had fun reading it, I still eat up everything Lyla Sage and will continue to do so, but this just didn’t hit the mark for me. Thank you to NetGalley and Dial Press for the eARC in exchange for an honest review!!
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
Clarke Cartwright has a lot on her plate: Running her family's antique shop after it almost got taken over by corporate slop, fixing her family's antique shop, keeping everyone in town happy, and remaining the civil and easygoing Cartwright girl.
Leith Wilkes has taken over his family farm after his father's death almost five years ago. While his relationship with his father was rocky, Leith is glad that his farm is able to provide so much for the economy despite it not being the path he would've chosen for himself. When Clarke randomly approaches him and tells him he needs to check the will, Leith realizes that his lawyer- and conveniently the town's only lawyer still hasn't gotten back to him about that. The two decide to sneak into his office and look at the papers themselves, only to realize there was a secret clause: If Leith isn't married within five years of his father's death, the farm goes to the next relative waiting in line.
When the doorknob of the office door shakes, Leith and Clarke share a steamy kiss to hide their breaking and entering. The rumor mill spreads fast in Sweetwater Peak, and soon the two decide to fake date: Leith will get closer to keeping his farm, and in exchange he'll help Clarke fix her shop.
I enjoyed this a lot! I really like Lyla Sage, so I knew this book would be lots of fun. The slight paranormal element is always enjoyable, but at the same time, like the first book, sometimes the ghosty parts felt a little out of place. It didn't quite flow.
I love a childhood crush story, and Leith and Clarke were PERFECT! I wish we got more of a glimpse into those young moments because I would've enjoyed it even more. They are GOOD together. There's no third-act breakup (sorry if you think that's a spoiler!), and these two get along immediately. It was almost so good that it just didn't make sense to have a fake dating plot when they could've just been actually dating. In the beginning, it almost seems like Clarke was annoyed by his presence, but that fizzled out fast to the point where I just forgot about it. As for their chemistry, MY GOD. LEITH?!?!!? This man BEGS for her.
There are a few moments in this series that don't flow well for me: the paranormal aspect and the FUCK CORPORATIONS of it all, but I still enjoyed it. They just feel shoehorned in in a way that doesn't feel natural. They work, for sure, but I don't know; it doesn't feel placed properly.
This title is set to release on September 22, 2026 from Dial Press! My review is based on the ARC copy, thank you!
Leith Wilkes has taken over his family farm after his father's death almost five years ago. While his relationship with his father was rocky, Leith is glad that his farm is able to provide so much for the economy despite it not being the path he would've chosen for himself. When Clarke randomly approaches him and tells him he needs to check the will, Leith realizes that his lawyer- and conveniently the town's only lawyer still hasn't gotten back to him about that. The two decide to sneak into his office and look at the papers themselves, only to realize there was a secret clause: If Leith isn't married within five years of his father's death, the farm goes to the next relative waiting in line.
When the doorknob of the office door shakes, Leith and Clarke share a steamy kiss to hide their breaking and entering. The rumor mill spreads fast in Sweetwater Peak, and soon the two decide to fake date: Leith will get closer to keeping his farm, and in exchange he'll help Clarke fix her shop.
I enjoyed this a lot! I really like Lyla Sage, so I knew this book would be lots of fun. The slight paranormal element is always enjoyable, but at the same time, like the first book, sometimes the ghosty parts felt a little out of place. It didn't quite flow.
I love a childhood crush story, and Leith and Clarke were PERFECT! I wish we got more of a glimpse into those young moments because I would've enjoyed it even more. They are GOOD together. There's no third-act breakup (sorry if you think that's a spoiler!), and these two get along immediately. It was almost so good that it just didn't make sense to have a fake dating plot when they could've just been actually dating. In the beginning, it almost seems like Clarke was annoyed by his presence, but that fizzled out fast to the point where I just forgot about it. As for their chemistry, MY GOD. LEITH?!?!!? This man BEGS for her.
There are a few moments in this series that don't flow well for me: the paranormal aspect and the FUCK CORPORATIONS of it all, but I still enjoyed it. They just feel shoehorned in in a way that doesn't feel natural. They work, for sure, but I don't know; it doesn't feel placed properly.
This title is set to release on September 22, 2026 from Dial Press! My review is based on the ARC copy, thank you!
September 22, 2026
The Acknowledgements got me with this book. I could really tell that Lyla really put her heart into this book. It was way faster paced than her others, but it worked for the story. I loved Leith and Clarke's relationship it worked so well and their banter was so much fun. I wish there was more build up but given the circumstances I get why it was faster paced. There is not a book that Lyla writes that I will not love, each one hits in a different emotional way and gets you thinking about yourself more.
September 25, 2026
Such a cute and cozy paranormal romance, perfect for the fall! It was so great returning to Sweetwater Peak!
September 22, 2026
After enjoying the first book in this series last year, I was thrilled to have the chance to read this one too, and it was just as quirky, romantic, and charming!
To save their respective family legacies, a hyper-independent antique shop owner who secretly sees ghosts enters a fake-dating arrangement with her former childhood crush. Supernatural elements, small-town atmosphere, romance, and spice mix with family drama, adding even more emotional depth.
Told in dual POV, the writing has a conversational tone, and the story is well-paced, so it's easy to settle in and enjoy the atmosphere. The small-town setting is cozy, with a dash of spooky from the ghosts, and it all feels like fall. The romance between the MCs is endearing and big hearted, with lots of open communication, which I appreciated.
I loved Clarke, and think she will be relatable to a lot of readers. In contrast to her adventurous, high spirited twin sister, Clarke stayed behind to handle things at home. She's happy living in Sweetwater Peak, she's just carrying a lot. Highly capable and independent, she deals with so much, including severe migraines. Her strong exterior guards an overwhelmed, somewhat lonely interior. Her character arc and growth were as satisfying to me as the romance.
The books are interconnected standalones, so you can jump in here. I enjoyed this book so much. It was a fun and romantic return trip to Sweetwater Peak!
Megan Wicks and Robert Hatchet narrate the audiobook beautifully. Both had voices that are easy to listen to, which was good since I hardly paused this one once I started! Wicks nailed Clarke's anxiety, exhaustion, and dry wit and Hatchet makes Leith come across as warm, protective, and unconditionally loving. Very entertaining and swoony on audiobook!
To save their respective family legacies, a hyper-independent antique shop owner who secretly sees ghosts enters a fake-dating arrangement with her former childhood crush. Supernatural elements, small-town atmosphere, romance, and spice mix with family drama, adding even more emotional depth.
Told in dual POV, the writing has a conversational tone, and the story is well-paced, so it's easy to settle in and enjoy the atmosphere. The small-town setting is cozy, with a dash of spooky from the ghosts, and it all feels like fall. The romance between the MCs is endearing and big hearted, with lots of open communication, which I appreciated.
I loved Clarke, and think she will be relatable to a lot of readers. In contrast to her adventurous, high spirited twin sister, Clarke stayed behind to handle things at home. She's happy living in Sweetwater Peak, she's just carrying a lot. Highly capable and independent, she deals with so much, including severe migraines. Her strong exterior guards an overwhelmed, somewhat lonely interior. Her character arc and growth were as satisfying to me as the romance.
The books are interconnected standalones, so you can jump in here. I enjoyed this book so much. It was a fun and romantic return trip to Sweetwater Peak!
Megan Wicks and Robert Hatchet narrate the audiobook beautifully. Both had voices that are easy to listen to, which was good since I hardly paused this one once I started! Wicks nailed Clarke's anxiety, exhaustion, and dry wit and Hatchet makes Leith come across as warm, protective, and unconditionally loving. Very entertaining and swoony on audiobook!
September 26, 2026
Я щось так розчарована, що навіть не знаю, з чого почати. Історія вийшла якась ніяка - рівна, мов дорога, без особливих підйомів чи моментів, які хочеться згадати. За відчуттями, вона сира й недоопрацьована. Післясмак пригніченості не покидає.
Кларк і Лейт - окрема історія. Я взагалі не зрозуміла їхніх почуттів. Хімії між ними для мене нуль. А те, що вони нібито стільки років були таємно закохані одне в одного, зовсім не відчувалося. Їхні стосунки не зачепили й не переконали.
І паранормальна частина теж пішла зовсім не туди. Досі не розумію, чому взаємодії з привидами так мало. Там же був простір для чогось справді цікавого... то чому цю лінію майже не розвивати? У результаті маємо шикарний задум і посередню реалізацію.
Коротше, щось пані Сейдж перемудрила у цій серії. Шкода, бо потенціал був.
Кларк і Лейт - окрема історія. Я взагалі не зрозуміла їхніх почуттів. Хімії між ними для мене нуль. А те, що вони нібито стільки років були таємно закохані одне в одного, зовсім не відчувалося. Їхні стосунки не зачепили й не переконали.
І паранормальна частина теж пішла зовсім не туди. Досі не розумію, чому взаємодії з привидами так мало. Там же був простір для чогось справді цікавого... то чому цю лінію майже не розвивати? У результаті маємо шикарний задум і посередню реалізацію.
Коротше, щось пані Сейдж перемудрила у цій серії. Шкода, бо потенціал був.
September 23, 2026
I don’t know if I have the words for this special book and how much it means to me, but I will try!! Happy pub day to Free Falling, one of my FAVORITE books of the year and a book that will stay with me for a long time. Thank you to @prhaudio for the free ALC 🎧🤍
Free Falling is the second book in the Sweetwater Peak dulogy, following Clarke and Leith. Clarke has been struggling since returning to Sweetwater Peak and running Toad’s Antiques. When Leith Wilkes, the guy that she has had a crush on since she was a kid, approaches her to fake date him to attempt to save his family farm, she finds herself caught up in so many emotions for the first time in a long time.
From the very beginning of this book with the author’s note, I knew I would love this story. Clarke struggles with depression and burnout in this book and goes through such a long journey not understanding why she is feeling so blue. Lyla has talked about how she wrote this book based on her own experience dealing with a depressive episode that crept up on her. And I felt so seen by Clarke’s character.
Another thing I loved about this book?? How Lyla clearly wrote it as an ode to Western culture. I loved the discussion of the importance of farms, small towns and the ecosystem that small farms support. You can just tell how much Lyla loves and respects her Western roots.
Clarke and Leith’s relationship was EVERYTHING!! The audiobook is a dual narration and I genuinely was swooning every time Leith spoke. I love that each were so down bad for each other but caught up in their own problems, slowly working their way through their feelings.
Lyla Land is such a comforting, special place to me and in my opinion, Free Falling is by far the BEST book. As someone who has struggled with depression throughout my entire life and has gone in and out of different stages of depression, I think Clarke’s story is so important and beautiful. I hope you all find comfort the way I did with Lyla’s words 🥹
Free Falling is the second book in the Sweetwater Peak dulogy, following Clarke and Leith. Clarke has been struggling since returning to Sweetwater Peak and running Toad’s Antiques. When Leith Wilkes, the guy that she has had a crush on since she was a kid, approaches her to fake date him to attempt to save his family farm, she finds herself caught up in so many emotions for the first time in a long time.
From the very beginning of this book with the author’s note, I knew I would love this story. Clarke struggles with depression and burnout in this book and goes through such a long journey not understanding why she is feeling so blue. Lyla has talked about how she wrote this book based on her own experience dealing with a depressive episode that crept up on her. And I felt so seen by Clarke’s character.
Another thing I loved about this book?? How Lyla clearly wrote it as an ode to Western culture. I loved the discussion of the importance of farms, small towns and the ecosystem that small farms support. You can just tell how much Lyla loves and respects her Western roots.
Clarke and Leith’s relationship was EVERYTHING!! The audiobook is a dual narration and I genuinely was swooning every time Leith spoke. I love that each were so down bad for each other but caught up in their own problems, slowly working their way through their feelings.
Lyla Land is such a comforting, special place to me and in my opinion, Free Falling is by far the BEST book. As someone who has struggled with depression throughout my entire life and has gone in and out of different stages of depression, I think Clarke’s story is so important and beautiful. I hope you all find comfort the way I did with Lyla’s words 🥹
September 17, 2026
Thank you to the publisher for approving me to read this book, rating it 3.75 rounded up to 4.0stars.
I will read absolutely anything by Lyla Sage, it’s a guaranteed good time.
I enjoyed this small town romance vibe with a twist, it’s the 2nd book in this interconnected series that has a supernatural undertone.
This story follows an FMC struggling with a fear of her identity and some other struggles rear their head. Our MMC comes into the picture as the resident golden boy, charming and family orientated plus a hottie. There’s definitely some fantastic tension and natural banter between the two characters that develops throughout the book, but at the core is a friendship that sets the foundation of anything else. Our MMC is in a battle for his inheritance and that’s where Clarke comes in prompted by the MMC’s fathers ghost, yes you read that correctly. This makes for a unique, spicy and engaging read.
I will read absolutely anything by Lyla Sage, it’s a guaranteed good time.
I enjoyed this small town romance vibe with a twist, it’s the 2nd book in this interconnected series that has a supernatural undertone.
This story follows an FMC struggling with a fear of her identity and some other struggles rear their head. Our MMC comes into the picture as the resident golden boy, charming and family orientated plus a hottie. There’s definitely some fantastic tension and natural banter between the two characters that develops throughout the book, but at the core is a friendship that sets the foundation of anything else. Our MMC is in a battle for his inheritance and that’s where Clarke comes in prompted by the MMC’s fathers ghost, yes you read that correctly. This makes for a unique, spicy and engaging read.
September 22, 2026
ONE DAY, binged this in a single day. Absolutely an amazing read!
When I originally read Soul Searching, I knew I couldn't wait for Clarke's book, and I was not disappointed.
If you know me, you know I am a SUCKER for any kind of fake dating/engagement this trope is my FAVORITE and Lyla knocked it out of the park. I loved being back in Sweetwater Peak, I loved being back at Toads, and I was so glad to be back with our ghosty talking twins! Leith and Clarke haven known one another their entire lives which also just adds such a depth to the relationship, they know each other on a different level and the way that man just knows Clarke better than she knows herself SWOON.
The duet narration by Megan Wicks and Robert Hatchet was so good! It really brought both MCs to life.
If you are looking for a completed duology look no further than Sweetwater Peak! I'll miss this little haunted Wyoming town.
When I originally read Soul Searching, I knew I couldn't wait for Clarke's book, and I was not disappointed.
If you know me, you know I am a SUCKER for any kind of fake dating/engagement this trope is my FAVORITE and Lyla knocked it out of the park. I loved being back in Sweetwater Peak, I loved being back at Toads, and I was so glad to be back with our ghosty talking twins! Leith and Clarke haven known one another their entire lives which also just adds such a depth to the relationship, they know each other on a different level and the way that man just knows Clarke better than she knows herself SWOON.
The duet narration by Megan Wicks and Robert Hatchet was so good! It really brought both MCs to life.
If you are looking for a completed duology look no further than Sweetwater Peak! I'll miss this little haunted Wyoming town.
May 7, 2026
Ooooh I think this is my fave from Lyla Sage yet!!! There’s something about this small town friends to lovers x fake dating and Clarke/Leith that just worked. Seriously, chefs kiss!
I instantly gravitated to these characters and loved seeing this second chance happen for them. This one vibed with me much more than Collins story (the previous book in this series), and I think that’s because I saw a lot of myself in Clarke that I empathized with. And Leith, he’s definitely golden boy / golden retriever vibes and the way he took care of Clarke and his family.. swoon!!
If you want your sweet small town romance with a dash of ghostie vibes, check this one out 👻
Disclaimer: I received an e-arc of this copy on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
I instantly gravitated to these characters and loved seeing this second chance happen for them. This one vibed with me much more than Collins story (the previous book in this series), and I think that’s because I saw a lot of myself in Clarke that I empathized with. And Leith, he’s definitely golden boy / golden retriever vibes and the way he took care of Clarke and his family.. swoon!!
If you want your sweet small town romance with a dash of ghostie vibes, check this one out 👻
Disclaimer: I received an e-arc of this copy on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
June 20, 2026
QUEEN Lyla, you can do no wrong.
Lyla’s writing has always like a safe place to land, but Sweetwater peak felt like coming home. Clarke resonated with me on a level I could never have expected. This book injects a spooky fun ghosty edge into a story that at its core is about finding yourself when you didn’t realize you were lost. Lyla’s way of writing about depression and burnout truly had me in shambles.
Leith and Clarke were awkward, adorable, and so much fun. Leith was everything I wanted for Clarke and then some - a loyal, down bad man who will do anything for those he loves. The dichotomy of their personalities was perfection.
I love love loved this book and I will continue to read every single thing Lyla writes.
Lyla’s writing has always like a safe place to land, but Sweetwater peak felt like coming home. Clarke resonated with me on a level I could never have expected. This book injects a spooky fun ghosty edge into a story that at its core is about finding yourself when you didn’t realize you were lost. Lyla’s way of writing about depression and burnout truly had me in shambles.
Leith and Clarke were awkward, adorable, and so much fun. Leith was everything I wanted for Clarke and then some - a loyal, down bad man who will do anything for those he loves. The dichotomy of their personalities was perfection.
I love love loved this book and I will continue to read every single thing Lyla writes.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
LYLA SAGE I LOVE YOU!!!!!! THIS BOOK WAS EVERYTHING. Clarke and Leith were just so cute. Leith was down so bad for Clarke, and I ate it up. I love how this book also dealt with anxiety and depression in a real way. I am someone who has extremely bad anxiety, so I could very much relate to that. This book was funny, real, and spicy. This was one of my most anticipated books of the year, and it exceeded all of my expectations. This was just so good. I have loved all of Lyla’s books, but this might be my new favorite.
Thank you so much, Dial Press, for the best surprise book mail. I did, in fact, freak out ( and cry a little) when I opened this book mail. This book comes out tomorrow.
Thank you so much, Dial Press, for the best surprise book mail. I did, in fact, freak out ( and cry a little) when I opened this book mail. This book comes out tomorrow.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
"Grief if a roller coaster and a spiderweb all wrapped into one"
Lyla Sage’s “Free Falling,” the second novel in the “Sweetwater Peak” series, is a fake-dating romance between a farmer and an antique shop owner who team up to save a family farm from a developer.
Unlike her twin, Collins, Clarke Cartwright rarely embraces her paranormal ability to see and communicate with ghosts. Instead, she tries to push them away. Their presence can feel overwhelming, and when too many ghosts are nearby, Clarke experiences their vibrations as an intense pressure in her head. After leaving New York, Clarke has found her way back to Sweetwater Peak, Wyoming, where she is helping repair her parents’ shop, Toades Antiques, and has even adopted an animal along the way.
Leith Wilkes’s father, Wilder, died nearly five years ago, leaving behind a stipulation in his will: ownership of Wilkes Farm will go to Leith if he is married and can demonstrate his commitment to maintaining the farm. Otherwise, the farm will pass to the next person in line. Leith is unaware of this clause until Clarke communicates with Wilder’s ghost and encourages him to take another look at the will.
The clock is ticking, because if Leith cannot meet the conditions of the inheritance, the farm will go to Flynn, the father of Delainey. Flynn abandoned Delainey and relinquished his parental rights when she was five. Knowing how important Wilkes Farm is to the community, Clarke agrees when Leith proposes that they enter a fake relationship. But what Leith doesn’t know is that Clarke has had feelings for him since childhood.
As the two work together to save the farm, they must also navigate the feelings that have been quietly building between them for years. More importantly, they have to learn to communicate honestly about what they want and need if they hope to avoid heartbreak.
Sage’s sequel is stronger than the first book in the series. One of the novel’s biggest strengths is the way it handles grief. Rather than making grief the loud, all-consuming focus of the story, Sage incorporates it subtly and realistically, allowing it to exist in the background of the characters’ lives in much the same way it often does in reality. I don’t think I have ever read a character who feels so remarkably similar to my own inner thoughts and feelings. Clarke’s fears, her constant need for connection, her desire not to be overbearing, and her deep-seated need to be liked all felt incredibly familiar to me. She is constantly surrounded by people and constantly giving to others, but when she is alone, everything she has been holding together begins to crumble. Her loneliness and struggles with self-worth felt painfully real, and I felt them to my bones.
Sage’s weakness, however, is in how neatly everything comes together. By the end, nearly every strained relationship is repaired and every conflict receives a happy resolution. Sisterly estrangement, neglected friendships, parental miscommunication, and years of resentment are all wrapped up into a very tidy bow. While I understand the appeal of a happy ending, some of these resolutions felt too convenient given the depth of the problems that had been established.
I also felt that Collin’s arrival back in town was an unnecessary part of the plot. It seemed included primarily to give readers more time with characters from the previous book, when much of that information could have been handled through a phone call. Boone’s appearance, which amounted to only a handful of pages, also felt unnecessary and did not add enough to the story to justify his inclusion.
That said, I really appreciated what Sage didn't do. There was no third-act breakup, no angry ex-girlfriend or other woman brought in to manufacture conflict, and no frustrating miscommunication driving the couple apart. Instead, Leith and Clarke are given the opportunity to actually communicate and work through their feelings. In a genre that so often relies on manufactured drama, I found that incredibly refreshing.
I received an ARC with Edelweiss via Dial Press and Penguin Random House in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Soul Searching 3/5
Free Falling 4/5
Lyla Sage’s “Free Falling,” the second novel in the “Sweetwater Peak” series, is a fake-dating romance between a farmer and an antique shop owner who team up to save a family farm from a developer.
Unlike her twin, Collins, Clarke Cartwright rarely embraces her paranormal ability to see and communicate with ghosts. Instead, she tries to push them away. Their presence can feel overwhelming, and when too many ghosts are nearby, Clarke experiences their vibrations as an intense pressure in her head. After leaving New York, Clarke has found her way back to Sweetwater Peak, Wyoming, where she is helping repair her parents’ shop, Toades Antiques, and has even adopted an animal along the way.
Leith Wilkes’s father, Wilder, died nearly five years ago, leaving behind a stipulation in his will: ownership of Wilkes Farm will go to Leith if he is married and can demonstrate his commitment to maintaining the farm. Otherwise, the farm will pass to the next person in line. Leith is unaware of this clause until Clarke communicates with Wilder’s ghost and encourages him to take another look at the will.
The clock is ticking, because if Leith cannot meet the conditions of the inheritance, the farm will go to Flynn, the father of Delainey. Flynn abandoned Delainey and relinquished his parental rights when she was five. Knowing how important Wilkes Farm is to the community, Clarke agrees when Leith proposes that they enter a fake relationship. But what Leith doesn’t know is that Clarke has had feelings for him since childhood.
As the two work together to save the farm, they must also navigate the feelings that have been quietly building between them for years. More importantly, they have to learn to communicate honestly about what they want and need if they hope to avoid heartbreak.
Sage’s sequel is stronger than the first book in the series. One of the novel’s biggest strengths is the way it handles grief. Rather than making grief the loud, all-consuming focus of the story, Sage incorporates it subtly and realistically, allowing it to exist in the background of the characters’ lives in much the same way it often does in reality. I don’t think I have ever read a character who feels so remarkably similar to my own inner thoughts and feelings. Clarke’s fears, her constant need for connection, her desire not to be overbearing, and her deep-seated need to be liked all felt incredibly familiar to me. She is constantly surrounded by people and constantly giving to others, but when she is alone, everything she has been holding together begins to crumble. Her loneliness and struggles with self-worth felt painfully real, and I felt them to my bones.
Sage’s weakness, however, is in how neatly everything comes together. By the end, nearly every strained relationship is repaired and every conflict receives a happy resolution. Sisterly estrangement, neglected friendships, parental miscommunication, and years of resentment are all wrapped up into a very tidy bow. While I understand the appeal of a happy ending, some of these resolutions felt too convenient given the depth of the problems that had been established.
I also felt that Collin’s arrival back in town was an unnecessary part of the plot. It seemed included primarily to give readers more time with characters from the previous book, when much of that information could have been handled through a phone call. Boone’s appearance, which amounted to only a handful of pages, also felt unnecessary and did not add enough to the story to justify his inclusion.
That said, I really appreciated what Sage didn't do. There was no third-act breakup, no angry ex-girlfriend or other woman brought in to manufacture conflict, and no frustrating miscommunication driving the couple apart. Instead, Leith and Clarke are given the opportunity to actually communicate and work through their feelings. In a genre that so often relies on manufactured drama, I found that incredibly refreshing.
I received an ARC with Edelweiss via Dial Press and Penguin Random House in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Soul Searching 3/5
Free Falling 4/5
September 27, 2026
4.25 stars ⭐️ Happy pub week to this lovely, ghosty book! I love Lyla, and this was such a pleasure to read.
The mental health representation here was very cathartic to read, and I felt like I was healing along with Clarke.
The ghosts also played a much more significant role in this, which was a much needed improvement from Soul Searching for me.
If you are a looking for a spooky small town book to add to your fall TBR, I cannot recommend Free Falling enough. And if you are an audiobook listener, I highly recommend reading via audio. The narrators were perfect. ☺️
Thank you to Random House/Dial Press and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy and for the opportunity to give my honest feedback. I will read anything Lyla Sage writes, forever and always, so keep on sending them my way.
A small sidenote - SPOILER - Something super small, but FMC mentioned that Emmy looked familiar towards the end of the book, and I was really hoping that meant we knew who a certain ghost was, but it wasn’t mentioned again…so I guess not? Maybe I just missed it, but it just seemed like such a specific reference.
The mental health representation here was very cathartic to read, and I felt like I was healing along with Clarke.
The ghosts also played a much more significant role in this, which was a much needed improvement from Soul Searching for me.
If you are a looking for a spooky small town book to add to your fall TBR, I cannot recommend Free Falling enough. And if you are an audiobook listener, I highly recommend reading via audio. The narrators were perfect. ☺️
Thank you to Random House/Dial Press and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy and for the opportunity to give my honest feedback. I will read anything Lyla Sage writes, forever and always, so keep on sending them my way.
A small sidenote - SPOILER - Something super small, but FMC mentioned that Emmy looked familiar towards the end of the book, and I was really hoping that meant we knew who a certain ghost was, but it wasn’t mentioned again…so I guess not? Maybe I just missed it, but it just seemed like such a specific reference.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
Absolutely loved this one!
Lyla Sage is 100% an auto-read (and buy) author for me, and I was so excited to see what would be happening in the second installment in her Sweetwater Peak series! This book did not disappoint at all!
I love going back to a series where we get to see the same town and people (for the most part) that we have seen through the eyes of someone else, and I loved reading Clarke (FMC) and Leith's (MMC) POVs.
I am so glad that we were able to get some more closure on a ghostly romance from book 1 because that was a loose end that I was hoping would be tied up a little bit. Clarke has the special ability of seeing and hearing ghosts (and of course she can talk to them - if she decides to acknowledge them!), an ability that she shares with her sister Collins.
Leith is the current owner of his family's farm and it may all be changing underneath him if he doesn't see his father's Will to see any stipulations that were put into place....the only problem is that the town lawyer is dragging his feet.
I love seeing Clarke and Leith work together to help save his family's farm and watch the romance fully blossom between the two!
This book has some of my *favorite* microtropes and I absolutely loved these two!
Thank you to Dial Press and Penguin Random House for the eARC via Edelweiss.
Lyla Sage is 100% an auto-read (and buy) author for me, and I was so excited to see what would be happening in the second installment in her Sweetwater Peak series! This book did not disappoint at all!
I love going back to a series where we get to see the same town and people (for the most part) that we have seen through the eyes of someone else, and I loved reading Clarke (FMC) and Leith's (MMC) POVs.
I am so glad that we were able to get some more closure on a ghostly romance from book 1 because that was a loose end that I was hoping would be tied up a little bit. Clarke has the special ability of seeing and hearing ghosts (and of course she can talk to them - if she decides to acknowledge them!), an ability that she shares with her sister Collins.
Leith is the current owner of his family's farm and it may all be changing underneath him if he doesn't see his father's Will to see any stipulations that were put into place....the only problem is that the town lawyer is dragging his feet.
I love seeing Clarke and Leith work together to help save his family's farm and watch the romance fully blossom between the two!
This book has some of my *favorite* microtropes and I absolutely loved these two!
Thank you to Dial Press and Penguin Random House for the eARC via Edelweiss.
September 23, 2026
5 ⭐️ This book holds such a special place in my heart. Lyla handled a topic like mental health with so much care and kindness while still keeping it incredibly real. i absolutely loved book 1, so I was a little worried that book 2 wouldn’t live up to the hype I had built up in my head. But somehow, this book was just as good (if not better)!!!! Who doesn’t love a little romance with a side of paranormal? Yes, this book had fewer paranormal plot points compared to book 1, but Clarke is actively pushing away her abilities, so it completely makes sense! Lyla, your intro and outro to the audiobook were absolutely beautiful and really spoke to me. Thank you for putting so much care and heart into this story.
September 9, 2026
4.25⭐️
Free Falling was such a cozy, atmospheric small-town romance with a supernatural twist. I really enjoyed the fake dating setup between Clarke and Leith, especially with all the secrets and history surrounding them. The haunted elements added a unique layer to the story and I liked seeing Clarke embrace her abilities over the course of the book. Her chemistry and banter with Leith kept me invested and the whole story had that charming small town vibe that worked so well. It was a little bit like if Gilmore Girls also had ghosts. This was a sweet and steamy romance with meaningful emotional moments and a whole cast of characters to root for.
Free Falling was such a cozy, atmospheric small-town romance with a supernatural twist. I really enjoyed the fake dating setup between Clarke and Leith, especially with all the secrets and history surrounding them. The haunted elements added a unique layer to the story and I liked seeing Clarke embrace her abilities over the course of the book. Her chemistry and banter with Leith kept me invested and the whole story had that charming small town vibe that worked so well. It was a little bit like if Gilmore Girls also had ghosts. This was a sweet and steamy romance with meaningful emotional moments and a whole cast of characters to root for.
August 10, 2026
*ARC REVIEW*
Lyla Sage is a freaking magical badass woman. I love everything she writes but this was just so good. Leith is my MAN.
Also - I’m so dumb for not realizing Boone was THAT Boone and Cam was THAT Cam 🤦🏻♀️
Lyla Sage is a freaking magical badass woman. I love everything she writes but this was just so good. Leith is my MAN.
Also - I’m so dumb for not realizing Boone was THAT Boone and Cam was THAT Cam 🤦🏻♀️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 569 reviews