Okay, I hate to be the overly negative guy, but everyone seems to praise this story into the sky and I feel the need to challenge that. The first start of the story is badly written. I don’t mean that it isn’t my cup of tea, just that it’s bad. See the first time Sakura meets with the new Sasuke:
Sasuke: Hi. I’m evil now and I’m going to torture you because you’re annoying.
Sakura: Say whaaat? I know I used to a bitch to you and stuff, but that seems like, way harsh?
This should be a major chararcter-defining moment that sets the entire stage for the rest of the story, but the way it is written falls completely flat. It also suffers from all of the usual problems with fandom to an extreme degree: Not only are we told that all of the characters the author dislikes are terrible, but he goes so far as to describe how Sasuke has a small penis and is bad at sex. Thanks, guy. Also, Hinata tortures half of the village for half an eternity, but that’s okay because they were mean to Naruto so she’s still a good guy. Uh-huh. For this reason alone it does not deserve to be called a rational story, IMHO.
In fact, the entire first part is so badly written that it took me several honest-to-goodness attempts to get through it, and I strongly suspect that the only reason it got so popular is because of the gratuitous lesbian sex. It’s not that I’m strictly against that sort of thing, but really, it’s just not a valid replacement for good writing.
After that it does get more interesting as the first rational elements start to show up: Sakura stops screwing around (literally) and starts munchkining the world. Here the author shows some real creativity in how she goes about gathering power. It then falls prey to the usual problems of loop fics however, as the story drags on forever with no real plot tension to give it any force. At some point I think she meets the gods as well as a demon who wants to torture everyone the author doesn’t like (of course). I can only assume she also ends up sleeping with her, because I skipped a few chapters at this point, not gonna lie.
Still, I have to admit that the finale is AMAZING. The author’s writing skills greatly improve, and the final fight scenes go a great length to redeeming this story as being both epic and somewhat rational. The resolution to the climax is a bit of a let-down, but at that point I’m sufficiently giddy that I don’t really care anymore. I have to hand it to the author, this part really does deserve all the praise it gets.
So overall, I can understand why people love this story if they started reading it 8 years ago when there wasn’t much competition, and they only remember the originality and the amazing ending. But reading it again after seeing such gems as The Waves Arisen, I have to say, this story did not age well.