Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Frost Lake High #3

Faking for Now

Rate this book
Surviving senior year at a rival school is hard enough. Falling for her fake boyfriend--the school's golden-boy soccer star? Even harder.

When a sudden school boundary change uproots Summer's senior year, she's forced to transfer to Frost Lake High--the rival school she's spent years competing against. New hallways, new teammates, and a daily reminder that nothing is going according to plan makes starting over feel impossible. All Summer wants is to survive her final year while playing the game she loves most--soccer.

Rowan, Frost Lake's charming soccer star, has a very different problem. His future is already mapped out by his parents, complete with college admissions events and expectations he's never questioned--until now. Rowan has dreams of his own but admitting that might mean disappointing everyone he loves.

When Summer and Rowan's paths collide, a fake dating arrangement seems like the perfect solution. Rowan will help Summer fit in with her new team, and in return, she'll help make his ex-girlfriend jealous. It's strictly pretend. No feelings allowed.

But as lines blur between what's fake and what's real, Summer and Rowan must decide if following the plan is worth giving up something that finally feels right.

336 pages, Paperback

Published August 25, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rebecca Jenshak

58 books7,715 followers
Rebecca Jenshak is a new adult romance author.
Sign up for her newsletter: https://www.subscribepage.com/rebecca...

Amazon: https://goo.gl/6VtdGu
Facebook: https://goo.gl/ix1kB2
Instagram: https://goo.gl/MQw2FW

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
111 (32%)
4 stars
149 (43%)
3 stars
63 (18%)
2 stars
13 (3%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews
Profile Image for aimz ꕤ。˚⋆♡.
218 reviews3 followers
August 9, 2026
4.7 ⭐️

[3:44pm — 21/08/2026]

𐙚⋆°💜⋆♡ 𝘁𝗿𝗼𝗽𝗲𝘀

⤷ fake dating
⤷ sports romance
⤷ young adult
⤷ rivals to lovers

𐙚⋆°💜⋆♡ 𝘀𝗼𝗻𝗴 𝗼𝗳 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗯𝗼𝗼𝗸

❛❛𝐢 𝐡𝐨𝐥𝐝 𝐨𝐧 𝐭𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭 𝐰𝐡𝐢𝐥𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐰𝐨𝐫𝐥𝐝 𝐤𝐞𝐞𝐩𝐬 𝐬𝐩𝐢𝐧𝐧𝐢𝐧𝐠.❜❜
⤷ 𝒄𝒂𝒓𝒓𝒊𝒆 𝒃𝒓𝒂𝒅𝒔𝒉𝒂𝒘 by 𝗸𝘆𝗹𝗶𝗲 𝗰𝗮𝗻𝘁𝗿𝗮𝗹𝗹

-`♡´- 𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄 𝘁𝗶𝗺𝗲 -`♡´-

"I thought there was no way you couldn't feel how absolutely obsessed I am with you."

Is it too early to say this book's the best in the series?

It's always a bittersweet feeling when a series comes to an end, and I don't want to say goodbye to Frost Lake High, but it's time. I don't want to. I love this series so much. In a world full of hockey romance girlies, I will always be a football romance girlie. They all mean so much to me. Now, enough sulking. Besides, I am excited to write this review, so let's get into it!

Starting with Summer. Oh, she's a diva. There's something about her character which makes you want to root for her. I immediately fell in love with her. She carries a sweet and spicy essence, which is perfectly balanced. Having to start a new school in your last year of school, and no less your rivals, is difficult. I'm glad Summer adopted a 'fake it till you make it' personality, whilst also capturing how strong and front-footed she is.

I have nothing bad to say about her character because she genuinely was a delight to read. She is by far my favourite female lead in this series. A comfort character, some might say. Her relationship with everyone around her is amazing. Her dynamic with Rowan was hilarious, and I like that because it gave them a foundation of friendship. She can hold a grudge, but she does it for the people she cares about. You see that shine through with many characters in this book. Specifically, one character, but I'm not saying much. Read it to find out!

Moving on to Rowan. I always knew the third book would be about him, and I'm glad I was correct, because Rowan quickly became my favourite male lead in this series too. It's safe to say I love the leads in this book lol. Anyways, there are many reasons I enjoyed Rowan's character. He had good character development/growth. I like how the author showed his flaws and how he worked to be better for himself and for Summer.

Now, fake dating your rival's sister is something I'll always find hilarious and fun. This exceeded my expectations big time. I'm trying to keep this spoiler-free as possible, so take my word for it. Rowan is wonderful, actually beyond that. His communication skills are amazing, better than most people. Thank you, Rebecca, for making them communicate.

On to the plot, this book had all the tropes I love. I love 'rivals to lovers' so much because it shows the intensity between two characters, but it was mostly one-sided. Summer did not like Rowan because her brother and Rowan were rivals. But the rival aspect of this book fizzled too quickly, in my opinion. I wish we got more intense scenes, because I believe it would've made the book more vibrant.

As for the fake dating aspect, oh my, it was wonderful. I devoured it; it was so buzzy, and I was smiling the whole night. I have no complaints because it's exactly how I expected it to be in a high school setting. I love how they're both footballers.

There aren't many female footballers in books, and I'm glad Rebecca changed the narrative here. It made the football all the more enjoyable because I saw myself in Summers's passion for the sport. And that's healing, if anything. Also, the football aspect of this book was much better than the first one. It was interesting, and exactly how I envisioned it.

As for the side characters, I loved them here. Amanda, Rowan's ex, was a complicated character, but everything worked out. Seeing Claire & Austin along with Lacey & Vaughn was sweet. I love all of them, and I loved Vaughn so much in this book. He was still the same, but in love and amazing; Lacey and him couldn't be more perfect for each other. Same with Claire and Austin.

The dynamic this group had contributed a lot to the book. It has a found-family feel and ties the series up very well. There's this one particular scene of all the boys talking that I loved. It shows how much they care for each other on the pitch and off the pitch. Overall, it was what tied it all together.

Time to wrap up. I was on the hunt to find football romance books because I love football. However, it's a very deprived market, so when I found this series, I captured it immediately. I fell in love with all the characters, and that kept me here.

I came for the football, but stayed for Frost Lake High.

I love you, Rowan and Summer.

[5:20pm — 21/08/2026]
Profile Image for Ailín.
57 reviews42 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 29, 2026
𝙍𝙖𝙩𝙞𝙣𝙜: 4⭐️

𝜗𝜚⋆₊˚ 𝓖𝓮𝓷𝓻𝓮𝓼, 𝓣𝓻𝓸𝓹𝓮𝓼 & 𝓣𝓱𝓮𝓶𝓮𝓼 𐙚⋆.˚

★ YA High School Romance
★ Sports Romance (Soccer)
★ Fake dating
★ Rivals to lovers
★ Third book in series

࣪ ִֶָ☾. ✨ 𝓢𝓾𝓶𝓶𝓪𝓻𝔂 ❣️ .𖥔 ݁ ˖

When a sudden school boundary change uproots Summer's senior year, she's forced to transfer to Frost Lake High—the rival school she's spent years competing against.
When Summer and Rowan's paths collide, a fake dating arrangement seems like the perfect solution. Rowan will help Summer fit in with her new team, and in return, she'll help make his ex-girlfriend jealous. It's strictly pretend. No feelings allowed.
But as lines blur between what's fake and what's real, Summer and Rowan must decide if following the plan is worth giving up something that finally feels right.

. ݁₊ ⊹ . ݁݁ . ⊹💌 𝓜𝔂 𝓽𝓱𝓸𝓾𝓰𝓱𝓽𝓼 🧸ྀི☁️⊹ . ݁ . ⊹ ₊ ݁.

This book came at the perfect time because I miss the World Cup so much lol

Just as good as Playing with forever. Rebecca Jenshak has done it again and she’s officially one of my favorite romance authors 🧚🏻‍♀️

Even though I’m an adult and this book follows high schoolers, it was still so entertaining and enjoyable. I read it in four days, so easy to read. The premise was so fun, cliche but still fun.
Super lighthearted. There was little to no spice (which was a plus because it’s not always needed). And I liked all the characters.

Loved seeing Lacey and Vaughn from Playing with forever and Claire and Austin from Stealing for keeps (even though I haven’t read Stealing for keeps yet). Not going to lie, Amanda AND Silas were getting on my nerves a little bit but something that I LOVE: characters that communicate. Oh my god! How much I love you Rebecca for not using the miscommunication trope. Thank you 🫶🏻🫶🏻

𝙎𝙋𝙄𝘾𝙀 𝙇𝙀𝙑𝙀𝙇: 🌶️

💝Thank you NetGalley, Bloom Books and Rebecca Jenshak for the ARC copy💝
Profile Image for Gosia.
418 reviews13 followers
August 21, 2026
Rebecca always delivers such good time reads!

This was simply a good time book giving exactly what I expect from YA romance.

I read mostly contemporary romance and lately I prefer characters in their 30s or 40s, but every once in a while I like to read something about high schoolers and I can always count on Rebecca to provide exactly what I love about this genre!

This book was cute and messy in the exact way late teen years tend to be.
Summer’s dad said: “You’re seventeen. Your problems are supposed to be small but feel big.” And you know what? That’s exactly how this book felt.
Summer has to change school for her senior year, and not only that, now she has to play soccer as part of the team that was her biggest rival.
Rowan has a bit of situationship drama on his plate, on top of figuring out his future and breaking the news about it to his mostly absent parents.
The writing style was nothing complex and made this book super bingeable, and it was mostly lighthearted and cute, but both characters had some seriousness in their backstory that added depth - just the perfect amount not to make this book depressing or overwhelming, but enough to give them something deeper and make it interesting.

It’s YA but there was one kind of open door scene. It was not very explicit but I wouldn’t call it completely closed door.

I haven’t read Rebecca’s book that wasn’t at least strong 4 stars for me and this one once again hit the mark!

It works well as standalone! Reading the whole series is obviously encouraged, but you can pick your own order, I can confirm books 2 and 3 work absolutely well on their own.

Thank you SOURCEBOOKS Bloom Books for NetGalley eARC.
Profile Image for Christi.
2,997 reviews1,636 followers
July 20, 2026
Faking for Now is a fake dating YA romance, where they both play soccer, and she moves schools her senior year (used to go to the rival school). This is the 3rd standalone in the Frost Lake High series. This series has been such a delight from Rebecca Jenshak who usually writes adult sports romances. There is something about reading coming-of-age characters with emotions and tensions running high, and their whole lives ahead of them with so many decisions to make.

In this book we follow Summer and Rowan. Rowan is one of the soccer players for Frost Lake High, he plays with the other players we have followed in the series. Summer is from a rival school but because of school boundaries changing, she got uprooted her senior year and had to transfer to FLH too. She’s wanting to fit in to the new school and with her new team, while he’s wanting to make an ex jealous…so they start fake dating, but very real feelings start to emerge!

I loved seeing the other characters in the series in this one all make appearances. I definitely felt for both Rowan and Summer. Her trying to find her place and be accepted with her new team. Him realizing his parents don’t know much about him since they’ve always put their careers first and travel/are away from home more often than they’re home. It was sweet seeing Rowan and Summer’s connection with one another and seeing how the fake dating played out! All the soccer time was fun and he was her older brother’s former soccer rival/her brother hates him. The epilogue was definitely fun!

I received an ARC, all thoughts in this review are my own.
Profile Image for Ana | SheSaidYestoBooks.
2,089 reviews177 followers
August 20, 2026

That’s what I’ve been talking about Rebecca! Their dynamic was sweet and easy. Their relationship developed naturally. We could really see their feelings were genuine and it was turning into something more. I fell for both Summer and Rowen. This is my favorite in this series so far.
Profile Image for Jordan Vogel.
300 reviews33 followers
June 29, 2026
HAPPY PUB DAY 🎉

4.5 ⭐️

I ADORE this series! I'm not a big YA reader (I'd argue this is the least-YA book in the series, but I'll get more into that in a second), but these books are some of the most wholesome and entertaining stories set in high school that I've read and I will read 100 more if Rebecca Jenshak keeps writing them.

There's something so different about reading high school based stories, and I understand it's not for everyone, but being swept up in character conflicts like overbearing parents, the forced proximity of seeing your crush at school every day, the drama that is unavoidable for teenagers, figuring out what life looks like after high school, sporting events or school dances- it all just feels very nostalgic and I love it.

I will say this wasn't my favorite in the series so far, but I love how the FMC was also a soccer player and how we got to see glimpses of the four characters from the previous books! And like I said above, for being a YA story, this book has some spicy content... so just proceed with caution on that front. But excited to see if this series continues!

Read if you like:
- high school romance
- soccer player MCs
- fake dating
- she used to play for the rival high school
- small town

Thank you so much to Rebecca and Bloom for the early copy!
Profile Image for laly.
193 reviews
August 29, 2026
I loved this book and Summer & Rowan so much! It was such a cute read and sweet read. I don't typically read YA books but I was hooked from the start. I loved the found family dynamic that their group of friends created. Summer and Rowan had me intrigued as their dynamic developed from friends to lovers. I love anything that Rebecca writes and reading this book was really refreshing as I typically don't read YA. Thank you netgalley, Rebecca, & Bloom books for the ARC copy!
74 reviews
August 27, 2026
i know this is YA but finger banging on a bus surrounded by y’all’s soccer team is pretty wild for high school students 🤣 i think im done with YA romances
Profile Image for Amity Bailey.
469 reviews61 followers
July 28, 2026
4.5 ⭐️

This one sucked me in so fast! I absolutely loved Rowan & summer! I was waiting for his story and it didn’t disappoint!!

Summer is the new girl and just trying to be excepted at the new school, Rowan immediately is pulled to her & the banter between them is perfection!! Rowan is also struggling with his own family struggles, but watching him pull to summer & help her feel like she has a place made my heart swoon!! The fake dating between these two was so cute and fun!!

This book has so many lovable characters and I loved getting to see the other couples from this series!! If you love fun characters, banter, chemistry, and a slow burn that will have you falling right along with them, this is definitely for you!!

Thank you bloom/sourcebook, NetGalley, & Rebecca for this early copy!!!
Profile Image for _goldenchapter.
140 reviews5 followers
July 21, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley, Bloom Books, and Rebecca Jenshak for the advanced copy. I’m so grateful I had the chance to read it early!

I absolutely loved Summer and Rowan! The fake dating trope is one of my favorites and it completely worked for them. They were such a cute couple, and while the story definitely had some cheesy moments, it felt exactly right for a YA romance. Their banter, chemistry, and the way they slowly became each other’s biggest supporters made it impossible not to root for them.

What I loved most was how Rebecca Jenshak captured what it feels like to be a high school senior. At that age, every decision feels like it will shape the rest of your life, and every problem seems so much bigger than it probably is. Add in Summer having to start at a brand-new school during her senior year. I loved getting to see both Summer and Rowan grow while also helping each other become more confident.

There’s something comforting about returning to characters you love and this book continues to remind me why I enjoy Rebecca Jenshak’s writing so much.
Profile Image for Priscilla Stanfield.
1,076 reviews35 followers
August 17, 2026
4⭐️ • 1🌶️

This has been such a cute series and honestly, I just love anything by Rebecca Jenshak. This is the third book in an interconnected standalone series and was a character I was ever excited to read about. Then it ended up being fake dating and rival’s sister and I just loved it even more. It was such a cute story and had a lot of YA elements to it. But personally, I wouldn’t say this is completely YA. To me, a YA book can assume the characters having sex with a fade to black scene. This book had some slightly more graphic things that I don’t think should be in a YA book. But this is all a matter of opinion and everyone may have a different one. But for me knowing that it’s YA and some of the scenes in here my rating did go down slightly for that. But if it was marketed as a new adult with very minimal space I would for sure rate it much higher. It was cute, and the characters are fun. I don’t know if we’ll get another book in this series. She doesn’t really set them up as if we will so we will have to see what happens.
Profile Image for Karen B.
2,179 reviews33 followers
August 25, 2026
A sweet, young adult romance between two seniors at Frost Lake High. The representation of the pressure that high school seniors face, how they are expected to figure out their future, how they want to succeed at every part of their life, how they have to deal with friends that have hidden agendas…this was all balanced with an honest and realistic fake dating to realistic romance between two soccer stars, Rowan and Summer. This is a great series to have on shelves in a high school.
(For YA: only one quick, low spice, intimate scene)
Thanks to the author and publisher for the eARC via NetGalley
Profile Image for Reading with Dany .
84 reviews1 follower
September 6, 2026

Thanks to Diana from Sourcebooks for providing me with an ARC of this one! (It’s out now! Sorry for my reading slump, I’m barely free from it 😭)

First of all, I wanted to say that I LOVE Rebecca!!! She writes such good books, and I especially love her YA books!! Now THIS is how you write a fake dating trope in a high school setting. I truly enjoyed the story and Rowan and Summer were SO SOSOSO cute!!! Honestly, I had such a fun time reading this one!
Profile Image for Crystal.
12 reviews
Read
September 1, 2026


Also, even though the scenes were super short I definitely don't want to read smut between two high schoolers.
Profile Image for Staci.
297 reviews9 followers
August 14, 2026

This is the sweetest high school series. I don’t usually like reading books with younger MCs but this series is written in a way that pulls you in and has you hooked.
Summer has to transfer to Frost Lake from the rival high school due to boundary line changes. She wants to connect with her new soccer teammates but no one trusts her. Rowan is the golden boy of Frost Lake and he has an instant pull to Summer. Rowan has recently had his heart broken though and wants to get his ex back. They strike a deal to fake date so they both can get what they want. What they don’t count on is developing real feelings for each other.
This was such a sweet and lighthearted book. And I can’t wait for what’s next!

Thank you Rebecca and Sourcebooks for the arc!
Profile Image for Books, Booze & Bon Voyage (Krista Webster) .
1,205 reviews34 followers
August 26, 2026
Faking For Now by Rebecca Jenshak is book three of her Frost Lake High series but can easily be read as a standalone. You will meet the couples from the previous books because the guys are all best friends and teammates. This is a YA High School Romance between Rowan Blakenship and Summer Lindsey. A fake dating, enemies to lovers, soccer romance.

Rowan is a take it easy guy, always having fun, making people laugh and never taking anything seriously. He is a cocky charmer who is always happy and enjoys playing soccer with his friends.
The captain of the girls team is his ex Amanda and he is hoping for a second chance with her. They have been on and off for ages but he’s not a relationship type of guy even though seen his friends all fall.

It is the start of the senior year at Frost Lake High School and the boys soccer teams are having their annual scrimmage against the girls team. A girl with red hair catches his attention. She is a
talented midfielder and plays with an intensity like needs to prove she good enough. Her determination intrigues him so he baits her during the game. He notices she seems left out and how her team doesn’t pass to her. Rowan is shocked when Vaughan recognises her as Silas Lindsey’s sister. He played for their rival school Oakley and hates them so what is she doing at there school. He introduces himself but she knows who he is and walks away.

Summer was looking forward to her senior year with her friends Charlotte and Jill at Oakley school. Then during the summer they changed the district map and turned her life upside down. She now finds herself at Frost Lake. Home life is hard as her mum is always working because her dad has MS and her brother has left for college. Her boyfriend has dumped her and now she finds herself the enemy in the soccer team. She desperately needs a good season to get a soccer scholarship Frost Lake University.

Rowan is sweet when he shows her around school and she starts to like him which annoys her intensely. He then suggests a fake relationship to help him win back Amanda by making her jealous and in return he’ll help Summer make friends and use his connections to get her in FLU. Can Summer make the best out of a bad situation to help her survive senior year. She knows he has never dated before so will they be convincing so can they both get what they want. She is meant to hate him because he has history with her brother due to an incident on the soccer pitch but he is making it impossible not to like him.

He is being kind and thoughtful towards her and it turns out he’s a great fake boyfriend. I loved how she teases him and it was funny how her mood ring is always purple around him. We learn about his poor relationship with his parents, how little he sees them and how they are planning his future. Also how toxic, dramatic and hurtful his time with Amanda was. Things start getting very real as the feelings between them develop. Who is pretending it’s still fake and who will admit their feelings are real. A kiss ignites the sparks between them and he know he’s never felt this way before. She’s confused over the way he behaves with her compared to when he was with Amanda.

I liked how supportive MJ the goalie was to Summer and Lacey and Claire helped her settle in.
Vaughn and Austin understood what she was going through and the Whitlock twins were so funny. Amanda was annoying at first but did change by the end. I felt sorry for Summer because Silas unnecessarily caused her some problems. I liked how she explained to Rowan about his friends worries over the games and the pressure on them. She also realises his parents have no idea who he is or what he wants to do with his life.

What will happen when Amanda is single again, will he want to stay with Summer. Can he stand up to his parents and make his own decisions for his future. What reaction will Silas have when he finds out they’re really together. What will his friends and Amanda think when they find out the truth of what he’s been up to. Will both the teams make it to the state championships. I loved his grovelling at the end and his grand gesture to win her back. Then the hilarious twist in the epilogue. An enjoyable romance with a good amount of soccer action and fun characters.
Profile Image for Kay Daniels (Kay Daniels Romance).
2,315 reviews78 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 17, 2026
The Frost Lake High series is fun to read and Faking For Now was another fun addition to this series. I love the nostalgia each book generates for me, as far as stepping back to my own youth, along with revisiting the characters I've already come to know.

Being young is tough in a way where you don't always know what's happening tomorrow, but you also have a lot of big feelings about everything and every option that could come along. I felt that with both Rowan and Summer all throughout their journey of this story. Everything is bigger when you are young and these Frost Lake High books are a reminder of just how big all those feelings were when I was their age. For example, how important decisions were and how big life seemed at every moment of every day, or how overwhelming the smallest thing could be. Not to mention experiencing everything for the very first time; first kisses, holding hands, or wearing your boyfriends number to his sporting event. 🥰 ....sweet sigh...I love the nostalgia of it all.

Rowan Blakenship is super laid back and has watched his best friends find love within the past year. Rowan isn't necessarily looking for love, but there is a girl, Amanda that he has hooked up with on and off again from time to time. He likes to keep things super casual, so Amanda works with that plan. As the new school year starts, he's hoping they start up again, but that casual plan doesn't quite go his way, but when a new transfer, Summer Lindsey, needs help fitting in Rowan might have a solution to both of their problems. It's so sweet how he didn't see everything in front of his face, but that's teenage emotions I believe.

This is Summer's senior year and due to boundary changes she's had to transfer to a new school and a new soccer team for her final year. It's hard to make friends when everyone has known everyone forever, but even harder was to fit in on a new soccer team, when she was their literal rival the year before. Summer doesn't really care about making friends, but she does need every advantage to get the best scholarships to attend college next year and soccer is her way in. Summer doesn't know how to make the girls work with her, when they don't trust her, it's frustrating and hard and I felt for this young woman. One of the few people in school, Rowan, or otherwise known as  Mr. Popular, befriends her. He literally does like everybody and doesn't know why he shouldn't, but when he also notices that his crush notices he offers up a plan of fake dating so the girls on the team will warm up to her and in turn might pull the eye of his crush his way. 

It all works, except they forget how fake it all is. Falling for the laid-back easy guy is...well easy. And Rowan was drawn to Summer from the moment he first saw her. Everyone around them saw how great they were together long before they could admit it themselves. Faking was the easy part, since falling happened right along side of it. The hard part was actually admitting it wasn't fake to begin with.

I loved revisiting with the Frost Lake High characters; Vaughn, Lacey, Claire, Austin and even Eli and Eddie. 😍 The friendship circle is strong and Rowan seems to be the very heart of it. For a guy who didn’t always see it within his own home, he's very sweet with his friends. How he likes to approach his romantic relationships started to make sense as to why he played them so casual when you find out more about his home life. 🥺 I was so happy that Summer came into his world and vice versa.

Thank you to Netgalley, Sourcebooks, and Bloom Books for the advance review copy and all opinions are my own.
147 reviews
July 31, 2026
3.5 stars. While I found this to be a satisfying conclusion to the Frost Lake High series (at least, I think it’s the final book based on the epilogue and the acknowledgements), it didn’t shine for me the way the previous book did. That being said, I still stayed up late to finish it.

Due to the redrawing of district lines, Summer Lindsey had to transfer to her rival high school, Frost Lake, for her senior year. To make matters worse, her new soccer team not only doesn’t welcome her, but they are also openly suspicious of her intentions for joining the team. Meanwhile, Rowan Blakenship, the party-loving and easygoing member of the boys’ team, has problems of his own. He thought he would get back together with his ex, Amanda, at the end of the summer, but she doesn’t seem interested. Plus, his parents are pushing for a college plan that he doesn’t like at all. He decides to propose a fake dating relationship to Summer to improve both of their situations: Summer will gain clout on her team and get an insider connection to the head of admissions at the local university, and Rowan will make Amanda jealous. But, the lines between what’s real and what’s fake quickly begin to blur.

Summer has quite a compelling storyline and not one that I have read a lot. Seeing how she navigated her complex situation kept me going throughout the book. I also enjoyed Amanda as the villain. On the other hand, Rowan had more of a familiar story, and his side of things was more predictable. Each chapter mostly alternates between Rowan’s and Summer’s points of view, and sometimes, it was hard to tell/remember whose chapter it was, which was confusing and a weakness of the overall writing.

One element that was inconsistent with the previous book was how teen partying was described. In Playing with Forever, there was a lot more drinking, whereas in this book, there was some drinking, but nonalcoholic options were always mentioned, and it seemed like it was mostly other people, not the soccer players, who were drunk (with one major exception). This book centers on the same group of friends, so I found this inconsistency odd. Similarly, there was a much more explicit intimacy scene in this book, so I feel like despite less partying being described, this book might be geared to a slightly older audience.

However, my main issue with the book was the premise for the fake relationship. It didn’t have a strong backbone and was entirely predictable, even with some enemies-to-lovers mixed in. I don’t think my students would be as critical, but I had higher hopes for it due to enjoying the previous book so much and liking Summer as a character. Still, this was a breezy summer read and I am looking forward to going back to the first book to complete the trilogy!

Thank you to SOURCEBOOKS/Bloom Books for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Pine Reads Review.
787 reviews34 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 21, 2026
“Trust me. There is nothing going on between me and Rowan Blakenship.”

When forced to transfer to her rival school, Frost Lake High, Summer Lindsey now must navigate her new soccer team, new school, oh… and new relationship? Enter Rowan Blakenship, the carefree and funny guy on the men’s soccer team who takes immediate interest in Summer because of her talent and last name. She is, coincidentally, the sister of his enemy. But when Summer struggles with being shunned by her new teammates, and Rowan is desperately trying to win back his ex, Amanda, they form a plan: to fake date until Rowan wins Amanda back and Summer becomes a true member of her new team. But, of course, the line between real and fake gets blurrier as time goes on. Are they truly only faking it, or has it always been real?

To start off, I liked the concept of this book—fake dating will always get me; however, this story and these characters did not seem to make sense. Rowan was kind of rude throughout the story, yelling at his friends, discouraging them, etc. He was not the type of person you could rely on. He was almost too carefree in my opinion. I did not feel like there was any character development happening with Rowan. Plus, he was flirting with Amanda (Summer’s teammate) while he was with Summer, and I just never thought he was taking the “relationship” seriously. I did like Summer; she was spirited and determined, but again I saw issues with the way she was written. There was a point where she was apologizing to her brother for something he did to her, and that rubbed me the wrong way. It did not feel like a great example for teenage girls to be reading and/or learning from. The girls on her soccer team were rude and shunned her for an almost unrealistic reason, which was not something I could get behind. In terms of their relationship, I wasn’t ever really convinced that they liked each other, and when they did finally admit their feelings, it felt rushed and not truly fleshed out. That being said, I loved the friendship dynamics between Summer and her friends from Oakley; they were uplifting and supportive of Summer, and that was refreshing to read in between bits of drama. Summer’s determination and strength throughout the story kept me going.

Faking for Now releases August 24th, 2026.

Pine Reads Review would like to thank NetGalley and Bloom Books for sending us an ARC in exchange for an honest review. Any quotes are taken from an advanced copy and may be subject to change before final publication.

Follow us on Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, and Facebook @pinereadsreview, and check out our website at www.pinereadsreview.com for reviews, author interviews, blogs, podcast episodes, and more!
Profile Image for Rocío.
119 reviews
September 2, 2026
The first part was fine, funny even. Summer was pleasant to read; however Rowan was not what I expected, that was not the Rowan I read in the previous books. Sure, he was the same nice guy, the lonely, but... I don't know, I don't feel he was the same easy going friendly guy who talked to Austin while everyone else was avoiding him.
Anyway, first part was fine, and then Silas happened.

Mayor spoilers ahead

I don't know, I feel cheated.
Profile Image for Lindsey Adams.
1,554 reviews31 followers
August 27, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️️⭐️/ ️🌶️🌶️

I have never wanted to go back to high school, in real life. Returning to high schools in the book world, another story. Returning to Frost Lake High, any chance I get! Book 3 is here in this young adult series by Rebecca Jenshak. Faking for Now has a high school senior having to change schools at the beginning of the year. What starts out as a plan to just get through the final year of school, turns into so much more than our MCs planned for.

Summer is excited for her senior year, until the district lines are redrawn and she ends up having to attend her rival high school. From the very beginning things go terribly wrong. She loves playing soccer, but the new school is questioning her intentions of playing for them. This is not what she had in mind before she left for college. When a classmate approaches her with a fake dating arrangement, she doesn’t have anything to lose. Resilient, passionate, and committed are all traits of Summer’s and she brings them to everything she does. Including the fake relationship that begins to feel not so fake.

Rowan thought his senior year was going to go differently too. He would get back with his ex, play soccer, and then live life. Yet, his ex has no interest in getting back together with him, his parents have college all mapped out for him, and he has no interest in college. While he can’t necessarily change his parent’s minds, he is sure he can make Amanda (his ex) jealous if she thinks he has also moved on. Summer seems like she could use the help, being the new girl and all, so he asks her to fake date him. Summer challenges him, doesn’t bow down to his golden boy reputation, yet still stands by him even when she has nothing to gain.

Having loved Rebecca for sometime, I have fully enjoyed reading her young adult series. This series as a whole has been fun, energetic, and a bit nostalgic. There is no amount of money you could offer me to go back to high school, but Rebecca’s writing reminds me of the good times I had. Being an athlete myself, I can easily connect with the grind our characters go through to play the sport they love. I don’t know if Rebecca has more books planned for this series, but if she does, I am looking forward to them. If not, this series ends on a high note. I will always recommend Rebecca’s books too!

As always, review any author notes before reading.

What to Expect:
⚽YA Romance
🩷Soccer Romance
⚽Fake Dating
🩷Enemies to Lovers
⚽Brother’s Rival
🩷Sporty FMC
⚽Golden Boy MMC
🩷New Girl at School
Profile Image for Brittney.
1,478 reviews40 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 28, 2026
Faking for Now • Rebecca Jenshak
Frost Lake High #3

One phrase: fake dating the soccer golden boy ⚽💕

I am beyond obsessed with Frost Lake High and the world Rebecca Jenshak created.

Faking for Now was such a fun, sweet, swoony addition to the series, and Rowan absolutely deserved his own story. He became such an easy favorite side character in the first two books, but seeing him fully shine here? Loved it.

Summer is starting her senior year at a rival school after a sudden boundary change completely flips her plans. New school. New teammates. New everything. All she wants is to survive the year and keep playing the game she loves.

Rowan has his own version of pressure. Everyone thinks they know exactly who he is and what his future should look like, but he is starting to realize his dreams might not match the plan everyone else has for him.

Then comes the fake dating arrangement.

Rowan helps Summer fit in with her new team, and Summer helps make his ex jealous. Simple. Fake. No feelings.

Obviously, that goes perfectly.

I loved how naturally Summer and Rowan’s relationship developed. She first catches his attention with her confidence and talent on the soccer field, and from there their connection grows from friendship to fake dating to something that feels so real and right.

Their dynamic was sweet, easy, and full of that young love warmth that makes sports romance so fun to read.

And the friend group?

Perfection.

Getting more of Claire, Austin, Lacey, and Vaughn made me want to reread the first two books immediately. This series has such a cozy, addictive little world, and I am absolutely hoping we get even more stories set here.

✨ Tropes and vibes:
⚽ soccer romance
💕 fake dating
🏫 rival school transfer
🥹 young love
🫶 friendship first
🔥 golden boy MMC
🌟 confident FMC
💔 make the ex jealous
👟 teammates and competition
📣 senior year chaos
💞 feelings become real
✨ perfect friend group

📚 Read this if you like:
New adult romance, young love, soccer players, fake dating, strong friend groups, rival school drama, and sweet sports romances where pretending turns into something real.

This was swoony, fun, sweet, and another reason I never want to leave Frost Lake High.

#FakingForNow #RebeccaJenshak #SportsRomance #FakeDating #BookReview @Bloom
Profile Image for Shelby.
148 reviews6 followers
August 10, 2026
Faking for Now is a YA sport romance following Summer and Rowan as they navigate a fake relationship due to Summer moving to a new school her senior year and Rowan trying to navigate his situationship that ended without closure.

Summer never planned on starting a new school her senior year of high school, but due to new boundaries being draw, there is nothing her parents can do. With starting a new school, she now has to start over with the school soccer team. The team that absolutely hates her because of her brother reputation and her being on the rival team just a few months ago. Summer understands their hesitation to trust the new girl, but truly all she wants to do is play soccer again and get a scholarship to collage. Summer never thought she’d find herself teaming up with Rowan, the soccer flirt, but he will be her best bet with getting in with the team. He is truly liked by everyone and with him in her corner there is no way people can continue to ignore her. Getting into this relationship Summer and Rowan both knew it was for a limited time and there is no way they can every make it real, but feelings have a way of showing themselves when you least expect them. Too bad flirty, people pleasing Rowan won’t ever say his true intentions with the fear of letting himself and the people around him down. So, Summer needs to keep her eye on the prize and not let him change her mind on getting her dream life.

Rowan doesn’t know when his last relationship ended, if you can call it that, but it did. He doesn’t necessarily want a relationship because it comes with someone trusting you to do what’s best in the relationship and when you have parents that have already decided your future for you, you tend to not want to ruffle any feathers or make other people disappointed in you. So it’s easier just to not say anything and not disappoint anyone. However, Rowan has learned it’s probably not going to get you anywhere, it’s definitely not going to get you the girl. When Rowan and Summer started their fake relationship, he thought it was just to make his ex jealous, but Rowan had his eye on Summer the entire time he just didn’t want to face the rejection. Rowan is the last thing Summer needs, she has a plan and Rowan’s plan is to not follow the plan his parents set out for him. So, for now Rowan is here to help Summer and try not to fall in love even more with the person that understands him and knows him more than anyone else has in the past. Easier said than done.

Rebecca truly knows how to give it all to us. What a sweet, butterfly inducing, story continuation in the Frost Lake High series. Summer and Rowan have been my favorite so far, definitely has to do with the tension building with that fake relationship they tried to fake.
Profile Image for Amy.
1,616 reviews36 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
August 23, 2026
“He makes everything better and brighter somehow.”

Faking For Now is the third installment in the Frost Lake High series, and it’s every bit as delightful as I hoped it would be. Rowan and Summer’s fake dating scheme is pure YA gold—equal parts chaotic, charming, and unexpectedly tender—and watching their “enemies” (well… mostly on Summer’s part) dynamic shift into something real was such a joy. Even as someone who doesn’t gravitate toward YA all the time, this series continues to be an absolute treat.

Summer’s senior year gets upended when a boundary change forces her to switch schools, dropping her straight into a soccer team full of girls she used to compete against. They don’t trust her, she’s struggling to find her footing, and the pressure is relentless. Rowan, meanwhile, is hoping to win back his sort of ex—who just happens to be the captain of the girls’ team—and suddenly a fake relationship seems like the perfect solution for both of them. Make the ex jealous, help Summer get accepted, and pretend it’s all strictly strategic. Easy… until it isn’t.

Summer and Rowan are opposites in the best, most complementary way. Summer is laser focused, driven, and determined to chase the future she’s worked so hard for. Rowan is easygoing, conflict averse, and still figuring out what he wants from life. Watching their friendship develop—slowly, quietly, and with all those little moments where they start nudging each other toward growth—was one of my favorite parts of the book. Rowan’s arc especially stands out; Summer becomes the catalyst he didn’t know he needed, pushing him to stop drifting and start choosing the life he wants.

Their banter is snarky and flirty, their chemistry is effortless, and together they feel like a breath of fresh air. Rowan and Summer balance each other in all the right ways, and watching them shift from reluctant allies to something genuinely meaningful was such a satisfying journey.

This series has been such a fun, heartfelt ride, and Faking For Now brings everything full circle with a charming final couple who are a pure delight.
Profile Image for Ashley  Jenkins.
164 reviews
August 29, 2026
Ah, I’m so sad to finish this adorable high school series, but what a way to go out. This may just be my favorite, and that had some high bars to meet. This series may have been about high school kids, but Rebecca does such a great job at making it feel mature and real, bringing you back to those core memories and some of the best days of our lives. This book was no exception to the other two. It captured my attention, and my heart, and I didn’t want to stop reading. It was light hearted, low spice, so cute, and easy to lose yourself in. It’s definitely binge-worthy, and completely wholesome. I found myself constantly smiling, and had that cozy feeling when I finished. One that just warmed your heart.

Rowan and Summer were so adorable! They are both soccer players, but complete opposites. Rowan being the happy go lucky, life of the party, can make anyone smile, and has his future planned out by his parents. Whereas Summer is a little more guarded and reserved, maybe a little sassy, and is having to work to pave her way. She comes from a rival school, and is now forced to spend her senior year trying to not be the new girl and play soccer for so she can earn a scholarship. Along the way, Rowan befriends her and the two of them make an arrangement — fake date to help him win back an ex, and for her to make friends and get that scholarship. But fake blurs to real and these two finally caved in, stealing my heart along the way. You can help but smile and be their biggest supporters because they’re both so genuine and fun. They learn about each other and find ways to be each other’s biggest supporter. They have flirty banter that made me smirk, and have that cute high school love that just makes you smile.

This is book three in the series, but can be read as a stand alone. Be prepared to reminisce and think back to those glory days. Definitely a palate cleanser book, one that will leave you feeling content and cozy.

Thank you to Bloom Books for the opportunity to ARC read this book! I have loved this series!
Profile Image for Ria Alexander.
2,809 reviews53 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 24, 2026
Fabulous sweet & fun read

Frost Lake High is one of my favourite series from Rebecca Jenshak, and FAKING FOR NOW, book #3, has reinforced that. A fake dating, enemies to lovers, brother's rival, he falls first, soccer romance which was a sweet, fun and entertaining read.

Summer Lindsey's final year at high school has started disastrously. Not only did she have to switch to a rival school and their girl's soccer team, she has to endure the team hating her. They think she is a spy for her former school and don't trust her. Rowan Blakenship plays for the boys soccer team and he's under pressure too. His father wants him to join the family business, while he wants to follow his dream of going to college and continue playing soccer. He also wants to win back his ex, who is the captain of the girl's team.

Rowan realises Summer is having trouble fitting in and comes up with a plan to help them both ... a fake relationship. I loved watching their tentative friendship grow and evolve. It grew naturally through their wonderful banter, shared moments, their undeniable chemistry, and their genuine like for each other. They're good for each other, providing support and encouragement when they were needed. I loved that summer was able to show Rowan that he needed to confront his parents about what he wanted.

I really loved this story, it's a fabulous YA romance with not much spice included. I enjoyed all the characters, even the mean girls ... because what's a teen romance without some mean girl attitude? While it can be read as a stond alone, Frost Lake High is such a great series you'll want to read them all.

Read and Reviewed for Reading Is Our Satisfaction

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐5 STARS
Profile Image for Heather Miller.
1,615 reviews53 followers
September 8, 2026
Book Tropes: YA High School Romance, Sports Romance (Soccer), Fake dating, Rivals to lovers, Third book in series

Rowan, Frost Lake's charming soccer star. He is a senior and loves soccer, isn't sure what he wants to do in the future - college / no college. His parents own a few car dealerships, and other businesses. They are on the wealthy country club life, living a fantastic life, his parents are always traveling. Rowan doesn't have to 'try' at soccer it's just very natural to him.

Summer is a new transfer student to Frost Lake. She's been across town at the rival high school. Due to a district re-structing new law she is now going to Frost Lake. She loves playing soccer and loved her life at her previous high school. Now at Frost Lake she isn't sure how she will fit in with the new team / new school.

Summer and Rowan start talking and like hanging out with each other. Rowan's ex, Amanda is dating the quarterback of the football team. However, Amanda was really just trying to make Rowan jealous, not realizing he was still interested in her. All Rowans friends are grateful that he's moved on to Summer and not interested any more in Amanda. But, he was still into Amanda when he and Summer made a 'fake dating' deal.

Somewhere along the fake dating Rowan and Summer start to fall for each other. Summer isn't sure when the lines blurred/crossed. Rowan likes that the lines crossed. He is more himself around Summer than he was with Amanda.

Will 'fake' dating hurt their friendship? Will being with Rowan hurt Summer's chances of getting into her dream college? Will her brother forgive her for being with Rowan?

I did receive a free ARC Copy of this book. I am freely leaving a honest book review.
Profile Image for casey.
555 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 1, 2026
4 ⭐️

thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the arc.

⋆˙⟡ tropes ⟡˙⋆
🎒 fake dating
⚽️ brother’s rival
👟 enemies to lovers
🥅 golden boy
📚 new girl at school

⋆˙⟡ thoughts ⟡˙⋆
this was a cute read. i’ve lately found a new found love for soccer (thank you world cup) and the soccer element was fun because i haven’t read a lot of soccer romances.

as i mentioned in my previous reviews for the other books in the series, it does follow high school students… however there’s so much more: issues with parents, having a crush, finding yourself and your dreams, etc., it’s almost nostalgic of being a teenager. do i miss high school myself? nope 🙂‍↔️ lol but it’s always fun to escape and enjoy a low spice, easy going, read!

summer and rowan are cute together. i enjoyed seeing them develop a friendship in their fake dating scheme (aka actually falling for one another) hehe. i was rooting for summer the entire time to have a good senior year and find friends/a support system <3 i also was rooting for rowan to stand up to his parents, and pursue what he wants, not what they want.

⋆˙⟡ synopsis ⟡˙⋆
summer is forced to transfer to frost lake high her senior year, the rival school she's spent years competing against.
rowan, the school’s charming soccer star’s future is already mapped out by his parents, complete with college admissions events and expectations he's never questioned… until now. when their paths collide, a fake dating arrangement seems like the perfect solution. he will help her fit in with her new team, and in return, she'll help make his ex-girlfriend jealous. how long until lines are blurred?
Profile Image for Melanie (mells_view).
1,979 reviews397 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 19, 2026
I kind of can’t get enough of her. I don’t think I’ve ever felt this way.

We love a down bad book boyfriend who doesn’t really realize how down bad he truly is. Enter Rowan Blankenship, the good time guy who doesn’t take anything too seriously. Rowan, meet Summer, your soccer rivals little sister who is being forced to switch schools her senior year. Sigh. It’s almost like this story writes itself with this epic tropes. Oh wait, I forgot one, Rowan is missing his ex, who dislikes Summer because while she is her new teammate, she is ALSO from a rival soccer team. Obviously, Summer and Rowan take all that info and decide to fake date to get Amanda’s attention.

Honestly, I’ve loved this Frost Lake series. All of them have been sweet and have given me so much of those teen sitcom/movie vibes. From the dialogue, to the tropes, to the teen angst, to the sweet love stories, it all just feels perfectly nostalgic to my high school years and all the shows I loved back then. Faking for Now is no exception. Rowan and Summer are dealing with so much in and out of school during their senior years. Relationships with their parents, with their friendships, communication, figuring out their futures, and through it all they find something in each other that they did not expect. They genuinely start out as reluctant friends, but when they decide to fake date it all comes a little too naturally to them.

I loved this story as an adult, and while I definitely think all parents should check out content prior to letting their teens read, I would have loved this book as a romance loving teenager.

*AVAILABLE AUGUST 25TH*
**arc
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews