In the days of the British Empire, things were taken that probably shouldn’t have been. So how come they’re still in museums, galleries and some much stranger places? There are eight million objects in the British Museum alone. A number of them were stolen in wildly dodgy ways – a very big number. A chance encounter with one of them (a mechanical tiger/music box that mauls a soldier when you turn a handle) prompted journalist Marc Fennell to ‘What is that? And how the hell did it get here?’ The answer was so gloriously weird that it sent Fennell on a globetrotting adventure, investigating the most audacious criminal enterprise in history – the British Empire. With wit, empathy and unflinching honesty, Stuff the British Stole reveals the true stories behind remarkable objects in the world’s most celebrated museums. These artifacts tell the stories of power, resistance and survival that have shaped our modern world. Travelling from the pyramids of Egypt to the beaches where Captain Cook first landed, from Tuscan marble quarries to Kenyan torture chambers, Fennell uncovers the uncomfortable truths hidden behind the plaques. The human stories museums would rather we didn’t talk about. Part travelogue, part true crime, part reckoning with history, this is a book about how the hell we got here.
The stories were interesting but as someone who binged the show last week I was disappointed half the book was stories that weren’t new to me.
There’s definitely a formula to this concept and in the show I feel the visuals help keep things feeling fresh, but here I did find everything felt very samey. Each chapter sets up the object, explains its history/provenance and then finishes with a musing about empire and whether we can consider the object stolen. And when some lines are verbatim the same as in the show and there’s not much added I found myself skimming the ones I was familiar with. Some of the humour also didn’t really work for me.
The chapter on the Gweagal shield was the standout for me, though, it felt like it was told with a bit more care and thought than the others and made an interesting point about the mythology attached to objects and the different meanings we attribute depending on what it was that was taken.
I’d recommend this for people who haven’t encountered any of this series before and think it could act as a nice intro to the concept. Those already familiar might find it a bit repetitive like I did.
I love pretty much everything Marc Fennell does and this is no exception. However, if you've listened to the podcast and watched the TV show, there isn't much new here.
The book comprises an introduction (set in Egypt) and conclusion (discussing Chagos) plus ten chapters: Tipu's Tiger, Looty (the Pekingese dog), Parthenon Marbles, Horus (mummified boy), Shellal Mosaic, Chalice Tree, Gweagal Shield, The Great Rubber Heist, Operation Legacy (Mau Mau), and Strange Fowle (the Dodo). The topics of these ten chapters have all been covered on the podcast or TV show (or both, in the case of the marbles).
I listened to the audiobook via the library, and I'm glad I did. If you're not based in Australia, though, and haven't been able to experience the podcast and TV show, I do highly recommend this book.
I listened to this on audiobook format. Read by the author. Given the subject matter, this could have been a very dry book but the author interjected humour into it, when appropriate. But that’s not to say he by passed gravity. He, in fact, did well to approach the topic with sensitivity, thoughtfulness and respect. Being Greek, I did find the marbles chapter hard to listen to, but that was not a reflection of the authors handling of it. Infact, I admired his skill and thoughtfulness. My one criticism of the book is the last chapter about the dodo. It felt like the saddest chapter and to end the book on that note felt like … well, the biggest downer of all.
unfortunately I got the critically analysis media form of neurodivergence and not the good at maths kind (sorry dad 🤪)
Marc is a great writer, and some lines really sing but I did find several chapters to not be particularly engaging or interesting stories which impacted on overall enjoyment - there were minor little stylistic quirks like calling the professors Prof so and so which also took me out of the writing.
The show is absolutely brilliant - this one just wasn’t quite totally my cup of tea ( 🍵 🇬🇧) which is more than fine
That is a good line Mark and I'm glad you finally got to say it even though you weren't allowed near Diego Garcia Island (an island I knew nothing about until now). I know of Mark Fennell from the days of his tech and movie news on Triple J but then I got old and am deep within my parenting years, so I missed that he had a podcast and TV show all about Stuff the British stole. I'll have to search that out because I’m sure the kids will like it too.
The book was of course amazing. I'm a history lover through and through and don't get me started how they don't really teach history in public primary school in Australia. I surprisingly had a great history upbringing in my schooling in Chicago for the first half of my life. So obviously I was drawn to this book at the library.
It covers things you might already be aware of like the robbery of the Greek antiquities that were later brought to the British museum and the decades of debate as to whether they should be returned.
The book moves from familiar controversies to lesser-known stories about the Mount Keefe Chalice to a history of rubber trees, Opium War, the Oxford dodo, the atrocities in Kenya, the Belgian Congo and Diego Garcia island.
For anyone who loves history or to better understand the stories hidden behind museum plaques, this is a compelling and thought-provoking read.
I listened to this as an Audiobook and it made for a really enjoyable read/listen. It’s narrated by the Author, so we get to hear the book as he wants it read. 📚
This book had the potential to be very boring and dry, it was anything but! Super witty and captivating aswell, I found myself listening to it any chance I got. 🗿 I really enjoyed it and if you like Historical Artefacts or have ever wondered how a specific item ended up in a museum, then this book is for you! (highly recommended the audiobook)📜
Fennell is, as ever, an engaging storyteller, tracing 10 stories of how British colonisation has impacted the people, places and objects of the world.
If you've listened to the podcast or watched the TV show of the same name, there's nothing new here. However, if you're new to Fennell's work or prefer books, then this is a great place to start.
Fantastic book, informative yet entertaining:) Enjoyed the sensitivity that Marc Fennell approaches topics, especially Indigenous objects that were stolen. Not a fan of the British government and authorities before reading the book my loathing for them has increased.
After being so disappointed with the angle that Angertainment by Ed Coper chose to take to analyse a situation, I was suspicious about how this book would go. Despite this, I went for it anyway and actually ended up really enjoying it! The author struck a good balance between modern opinions and those of the time particular items / situations were taken / occurring. I liked it!
Very informative and fruity (enjoyable) in language. Its astounding that in this day and age , the British are still unrepentant and unwilling to return plundered items.