What do you think?
Rate this book
A Tale Beyond the Sky: Jack and the Beanstalk Retold
Jack Brenwin has one unbreakable when he rises to the top of Westhaven Academy, it will be entirely without magic.
But when a mysterious alchemist offers him the chance to learn the secrets of goblin engineering straight from the source, Jack’s resolve begins to crack—even if getting there will require more magic than most people see in a lifetime. Worse, he must ally himself with Silas, a mage prodigy who embodies everything Jack rich, royal, and magical.
At the top of the beanstalk lies a world of elves, goblins, giants, and fae, where nothing is as Jack was taught. The goblins are not the monsters of childhood tales, and the most dangerous creatures of all wear beautiful faces. When Jack and Silas uncover the true purpose of their mission, Jack must choose between protecting the future he has worked for and risking everything to become the hero he never meant to be.
With Silas’s faith in destiny, the friendship of a golden goose, and the steadfast kindness of a goblin girl, Jack must decide whether ambition matters more than courage.
But when a mysterious alchemist offers him the chance to learn the secrets of goblin engineering straight from the source, Jack’s resolve begins to crack—even if getting there will require more magic than most people see in a lifetime. Worse, he must ally himself with Silas, a mage prodigy who embodies everything Jack rich, royal, and magical.
At the top of the beanstalk lies a world of elves, goblins, giants, and fae, where nothing is as Jack was taught. The goblins are not the monsters of childhood tales, and the most dangerous creatures of all wear beautiful faces. When Jack and Silas uncover the true purpose of their mission, Jack must choose between protecting the future he has worked for and risking everything to become the hero he never meant to be.
With Silas’s faith in destiny, the friendship of a golden goose, and the steadfast kindness of a goblin girl, Jack must decide whether ambition matters more than courage.
249 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 16, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
April 11, 2026
Hello, people!
First of all, let me mention that this book stands alone and belongs to the Fairy Tale of Westhaven Academy series.
It is a retelling of the fairy tale "Jack and the Beanstalk".
The world building is wonderful and the plot has interest and depth.
Furthermore, all the characters are well-written and well-developed. Even the secondary ones have substance and a place in the story.
Finally, the author's writing is easy, pleasant, enjoyable and fast.
Many thanks to the author and BookSirens for the eARC!
This is my honest review!
First of all, let me mention that this book stands alone and belongs to the Fairy Tale of Westhaven Academy series.
It is a retelling of the fairy tale "Jack and the Beanstalk".
The world building is wonderful and the plot has interest and depth.
Furthermore, all the characters are well-written and well-developed. Even the secondary ones have substance and a place in the story.
Finally, the author's writing is easy, pleasant, enjoyable and fast.
Many thanks to the author and BookSirens for the eARC!
This is my honest review!
May 1, 2026
Please take this review with more than a grain of salt. Life got weird and has probably affected my view of this read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A Tale Beyond the Sky is mainly character-driven, and the plot is a little two-dimensional.
Brenwin and Silas go "over the wall" into the world of goblins, orges, and fae to find out why rivaling races are working together. While trying to complete their mission, they uncover more than they ask for and have to find a way out to survive.
Silas and Ruby are my favorite of the group, and are the real heroes of this story. Edric is a very cruel man, and I hope he gets what he deserves.
Brenwin was a little more complex, good and bad. I understand his background plays a huge part in how he views magic and magic users, but the way he treated Silas for 90% of the book didn't sit right with me.
The plot was a bit of a hit-and-miss for me. I like the parallel of Brenwin's past to present events, but it didn't make me feel any sort of way. I liked the epilogue, but some of the elements were not necessary.
If I read this at a different time in my life, I would probably give it a better rating.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A Tale Beyond the Sky is mainly character-driven, and the plot is a little two-dimensional.
Brenwin and Silas go "over the wall" into the world of goblins, orges, and fae to find out why rivaling races are working together. While trying to complete their mission, they uncover more than they ask for and have to find a way out to survive.
Silas and Ruby are my favorite of the group, and are the real heroes of this story. Edric is a very cruel man, and I hope he gets what he deserves.
Brenwin was a little more complex, good and bad. I understand his background plays a huge part in how he views magic and magic users, but the way he treated Silas for 90% of the book didn't sit right with me.
The plot was a bit of a hit-and-miss for me. I like the parallel of Brenwin's past to present events, but it didn't make me feel any sort of way. I liked the epilogue, but some of the elements were not necessary.
If I read this at a different time in my life, I would probably give it a better rating.
April 17, 2026
ARC Review:
I absolutely devoured this book. I couldn’t put it down for a second. Fairytale retellings is one of my favorite types of books out there. As a sucker for Disney and the Grimm Brothers fairytales have always been a huge part of my life. I love seeing them reimagined in new amazing ways. Adelle Summers certainly did that here.
This story was a fantastical read that pulled me in from the first couple of pages. And watching both Jack and Silas grow throughout each chapter was so fun. I really enjoyed getting both of their perspectives because it helped endear the both of them to me well before their opinions of each other started to shift (even if only slightly). Silas was this privileged young man who often was rather ignorant of that privilege. And Jack was cynical and self centered shaped by his past with no real motivation to change. I loved reading each realization and shift in their perspectives. And I adored getting to watch Jack fall in love.
I’d never thought of reading a Jack and beanstalk retelling before this book and I’m so glad that I did. I know you will be too, so definitely give this book a go!
I absolutely devoured this book. I couldn’t put it down for a second. Fairytale retellings is one of my favorite types of books out there. As a sucker for Disney and the Grimm Brothers fairytales have always been a huge part of my life. I love seeing them reimagined in new amazing ways. Adelle Summers certainly did that here.
This story was a fantastical read that pulled me in from the first couple of pages. And watching both Jack and Silas grow throughout each chapter was so fun. I really enjoyed getting both of their perspectives because it helped endear the both of them to me well before their opinions of each other started to shift (even if only slightly). Silas was this privileged young man who often was rather ignorant of that privilege. And Jack was cynical and self centered shaped by his past with no real motivation to change. I loved reading each realization and shift in their perspectives. And I adored getting to watch Jack fall in love.
I’d never thought of reading a Jack and beanstalk retelling before this book and I’m so glad that I did. I know you will be too, so definitely give this book a go!
April 19, 2026
✨ Hi everyone! ✨
I finally got to read this awesome book, and let me tell you, I expected an Into the Woods approach (I love musicals! 🫣). However, it wasn't a typical retelling, but a fresh perspective on Jack's character within a familiar magical world—at least for me and those who read A Dream Enchanted. So, I’ll stop the blabbering and start the review!
The MMC: A Refreshing Anti-Hero
I found it very original for Jack to have an antisocial and cynical attitude at first. We’re so used to confident and social MCs (the kind where everyone becomes their friend or ally), so it was interesting to read about a protagonist with strong intellectual abilities and a bit of an "attitude" toward others (at least at first 🤭). He truly embodies the "underrated MC" trope in fantasy.
Giving him a profession was also a nice touch; it makes him so much easier to relate to. As a former teacher, I loved reading about a character being passionate about something considered "normal" within a fantasy setting.
His anger toward injustice felt very real—likely a result of the bullying and lack of respect he endures. His development is excellently written: starting with his coldness toward Silas and his resentment of Silas's privileges (being both a Prince and a Mage), and then shifting into genuine friendship and camaraderie.
Silas & The Dynamic
I’ve missed Silas! I liked his character in the last book, so I loved seeing him as a lead here, especially as he learns to hone his abilities (both magical and social). I was pleasantly surprised to see a team composed of two introverted characters; it’s an underestimated dynamic that worked perfectly.
The banter was great, Jack being mean to Silas was actually a very funny way to show their connection. Even though it stems from a "forced allies" storyline, the transformation from "hate" to friendship was lovely. I personally enjoy fantasy that focuses more on action than romance!
World-Building & Magic
Having read another ARC from this author, I’m in love with her approach to fantasy. While many books focus on a "grimdark" style, I love how mystical and "light" the perspective feels, even during plot twists.
When I describe the world-building as "Light Academia," I don't mean it lacks complexity. It has a deep structure similar to a fairy tale, like The School for Good and Evil. It was also refreshing to see traditional folk creatures; everyone uses the term "fae" nowadays, so using creatures like goblins felt ironically original! The magic system being intertwined with the social hierarchy also felt very reminiscent of Hogwarts.
Final Thoughts
That’s all I’ll say for now! A huge thank you to the author, and I’m so sorry it took me this long to finish. 😞
To the readers: If you enjoy the dynamic between Elphaba and Glinda (yes, another musical reference!) but with male characters—or if you like the friendship between Kenji and Aaron from Shatter Me (and the rest of the series), then this book is definitely for you!
Almost forgot! I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I finally got to read this awesome book, and let me tell you, I expected an Into the Woods approach (I love musicals! 🫣). However, it wasn't a typical retelling, but a fresh perspective on Jack's character within a familiar magical world—at least for me and those who read A Dream Enchanted. So, I’ll stop the blabbering and start the review!
The MMC: A Refreshing Anti-Hero
I found it very original for Jack to have an antisocial and cynical attitude at first. We’re so used to confident and social MCs (the kind where everyone becomes their friend or ally), so it was interesting to read about a protagonist with strong intellectual abilities and a bit of an "attitude" toward others (at least at first 🤭). He truly embodies the "underrated MC" trope in fantasy.
Giving him a profession was also a nice touch; it makes him so much easier to relate to. As a former teacher, I loved reading about a character being passionate about something considered "normal" within a fantasy setting.
His anger toward injustice felt very real—likely a result of the bullying and lack of respect he endures. His development is excellently written: starting with his coldness toward Silas and his resentment of Silas's privileges (being both a Prince and a Mage), and then shifting into genuine friendship and camaraderie.
Silas & The Dynamic
I’ve missed Silas! I liked his character in the last book, so I loved seeing him as a lead here, especially as he learns to hone his abilities (both magical and social). I was pleasantly surprised to see a team composed of two introverted characters; it’s an underestimated dynamic that worked perfectly.
The banter was great, Jack being mean to Silas was actually a very funny way to show their connection. Even though it stems from a "forced allies" storyline, the transformation from "hate" to friendship was lovely. I personally enjoy fantasy that focuses more on action than romance!
World-Building & Magic
Having read another ARC from this author, I’m in love with her approach to fantasy. While many books focus on a "grimdark" style, I love how mystical and "light" the perspective feels, even during plot twists.
When I describe the world-building as "Light Academia," I don't mean it lacks complexity. It has a deep structure similar to a fairy tale, like The School for Good and Evil. It was also refreshing to see traditional folk creatures; everyone uses the term "fae" nowadays, so using creatures like goblins felt ironically original! The magic system being intertwined with the social hierarchy also felt very reminiscent of Hogwarts.
Final Thoughts
That’s all I’ll say for now! A huge thank you to the author, and I’m so sorry it took me this long to finish. 😞
To the readers: If you enjoy the dynamic between Elphaba and Glinda (yes, another musical reference!) but with male characters—or if you like the friendship between Kenji and Aaron from Shatter Me (and the rest of the series), then this book is definitely for you!
Almost forgot! I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 2, 2026
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Adelle Summers has delivered an incredibly immersive retelling that hits the ground running from the very first page. I was immediately drawn to the protagonist, Jack Brenwin; his characterization is fascinating—a man of logic and mathematics who harbors a hatred for magic that borders on a phobia. Watching his intellectual curiosity and his desire for knowledge battle against his deep-seated fears was one of the most compelling aspects of the story.
The tension throughout the book is palpable. Whether it was the high-stakes infiltration scenes or the complicated, sparky dynamic between Jack and the apprentice, Silas, I found myself completely glued to the pages. I particularly loved the "rogue-like" elements of Jack’s character; despite his academic background, his quick thinking and "slight-of-hand" skills under pressure had me mentally cheering for him during every narrow escape.
What truly elevated this story for me was the beautiful romance that blossomed between Bren and Ruby. Their connection felt earned and deeply sincere, providing a grounded emotional core to the high-stakes adventure. Watching their bond survive the trials of the enclave and the divide between their worlds was incredibly moving—it's the kind of romance that makes you "squeal" with happiness when they finally find their way to one another. I also loved the subtle nods to other classic fairy tale tropes woven into their journey; they felt perfectly placed and made their eventual union feel even more meaningful.
The author successfully balanced high-stakes adventure with genuine heart, and the "Goose" was easily a standout character that stole every scene she was in. This was a beautiful, imaginative story that I truly couldn't put down, wrapping up the emotional arcs in a way that felt both magical and earned while still leaving room for more world exploration.
Adelle Summers has delivered an incredibly immersive retelling that hits the ground running from the very first page. I was immediately drawn to the protagonist, Jack Brenwin; his characterization is fascinating—a man of logic and mathematics who harbors a hatred for magic that borders on a phobia. Watching his intellectual curiosity and his desire for knowledge battle against his deep-seated fears was one of the most compelling aspects of the story.
The tension throughout the book is palpable. Whether it was the high-stakes infiltration scenes or the complicated, sparky dynamic between Jack and the apprentice, Silas, I found myself completely glued to the pages. I particularly loved the "rogue-like" elements of Jack’s character; despite his academic background, his quick thinking and "slight-of-hand" skills under pressure had me mentally cheering for him during every narrow escape.
What truly elevated this story for me was the beautiful romance that blossomed between Bren and Ruby. Their connection felt earned and deeply sincere, providing a grounded emotional core to the high-stakes adventure. Watching their bond survive the trials of the enclave and the divide between their worlds was incredibly moving—it's the kind of romance that makes you "squeal" with happiness when they finally find their way to one another. I also loved the subtle nods to other classic fairy tale tropes woven into their journey; they felt perfectly placed and made their eventual union feel even more meaningful.
The author successfully balanced high-stakes adventure with genuine heart, and the "Goose" was easily a standout character that stole every scene she was in. This was a beautiful, imaginative story that I truly couldn't put down, wrapping up the emotional arcs in a way that felt both magical and earned while still leaving room for more world exploration.
reviewed
August 3, 2026Genre: Fantasy, fairy tale retelling [of Jack and the Beanstalk], adventure
Tropes: Academia
Setting: Magic School, Human⟶Fae world
Writing style: Dual POV, 3rd person, past tense
Character- or plot-driven: Both
Romance: Yes
Clean level: Very clean. 2 mouth kisses minimally described. 1 forehead and 1 cheek kiss without description.
Sensitive aspect: Moderate, low-desecrption violence. One lesson of some sort where a mentor stabs his apprentice with two swords, blood pools from the apprentice’s mouth onto the floor, and he has to use magic to mend torn vessels and bones. Bits of someone’s old flesh stuck in machinery.
The story is very theme-heavy, exploring things like heroism and character as choice not destiny, the power of belonging and lack thereof, the stories groups are told about each other often being incomplete or skewed, and the power of self-belief.
The romance is in the traditional rapid fairy tale style, where the couple spend minimal time together within the story, though the love interest plays more of a role in the plot. What makes it compelling is that it reinforces one of the novel’s central ideas: the way we see ourselves shapes the choices we make, and sometimes it takes someone else seeing our potential before we can begin to see it ourselves. Someone having faith in us, sometimes even before the person really knows us, can inspire us to strive for more than we believed we possibly could be.
____________________________________
I understand the urge to make more low-effort work for Silas, but he simultaneously punished someone completely innocent.
That’s not revenge. Revenge is against the person who wronged you, or at least people directly connected to that person. This is pure projection.
You don’t need direct experience with actual “monsters” to identify them.
Seems rather hypocritical of him. He gladly causes pain, even to a technically lesser degree, to others, presumably all magic users. Because he was treated badly by magic users for not having magic himself, he does the same to those with it simply because they do have it, which somehow makes them guilty of other people’s wrongdoings.
Two people’s feelings about each other can differ.
Favorite Quotations:
• “My room’s across the hall. If someone comes in the night to kill you, make sure you shout. I’m not going to come save you, but I’d like a head start in case they’re after me too.”
• “My father says there’s a bit of a hero in everyone, and helping another find that piece of themselves is the greatest hero work of all.”
• This was pride without arrogance, light unshadowed by doubt. A purpose fulfilled.
• “The answer to that question answers another question you’ve probably been asking yourself, which is why in the world would Edric put his apprentice in the sort of danger he was in beyond the wall?” Brenwin had assumed the answer was that Edric didn’t really like his apprentice all that much, but he raised an eyebrow and played along.
(I received a free copy of this book via Booksirens and am gratefully—voluntarily—leaving a review.)
Tropes: Academia
Setting: Magic School, Human⟶Fae world
Writing style: Dual POV, 3rd person, past tense
Character- or plot-driven: Both
Romance: Yes
Clean level: Very clean. 2 mouth kisses minimally described. 1 forehead and 1 cheek kiss without description.
Sensitive aspect: Moderate, low-desecrption violence. One lesson of some sort where a mentor stabs his apprentice with two swords, blood pools from the apprentice’s mouth onto the floor, and he has to use magic to mend torn vessels and bones. Bits of someone’s old flesh stuck in machinery.
The story is very theme-heavy, exploring things like heroism and character as choice not destiny, the power of belonging and lack thereof, the stories groups are told about each other often being incomplete or skewed, and the power of self-belief.
The romance is in the traditional rapid fairy tale style, where the couple spend minimal time together within the story, though the love interest plays more of a role in the plot. What makes it compelling is that it reinforces one of the novel’s central ideas: the way we see ourselves shapes the choices we make, and sometimes it takes someone else seeing our potential before we can begin to see it ourselves. Someone having faith in us, sometimes even before the person really knows us, can inspire us to strive for more than we believed we possibly could be.
____________________________________
Brenwin couldn’t help himself. Just as the man was past him, Brenwin turned around and tossed the pen he was holding onto the ground so that it landed right where the man was walking, and he stepped right on it. It didn’t trip him much, he didn’t even fall, but it was enough. The top book on the stack came down along with the ink. Brenwin was around the corner out of sight when the sound of shattered glass met his ears. Brenwin could only imagine the mess it was making all over the archmage apprentice’s sparkling clean floors. So much for being almost done. It was a shame Silas would never know who to thank for the inconvenience.
I understand the urge to make more low-effort work for Silas, but he simultaneously punished someone completely innocent.
A bitter corner of his heart whispered for revenge: hurt her, the way others had hurt him. He shoved the thought down.
That’s not revenge. Revenge is against the person who wronged you, or at least people directly connected to that person. This is pure projection.
The royal golden boy had dared to call him, Jack Brenwin, a monster. Just because the mage had slain a dragon and a chimera while still an apprentice didn’t make him an expert on monsters. Brenwin knew monsters. The mage had no idea. The fool.
You don’t need direct experience with actual “monsters” to identify them.
He wondered what kind of excruciating pain she’d endured to become what she was. This was how it always was with magic. His anger burned.
Seems rather hypocritical of him. He gladly causes pain, even to a technically lesser degree, to others, presumably all magic users. Because he was treated badly by magic users for not having magic himself, he does the same to those with it simply because they do have it, which somehow makes them guilty of other people’s wrongdoings.
Brenwin had thought that a friend was someone whose company you enjoyed, and he still found Silas—with all his optimism and magic and royalty—grating.
Two people’s feelings about each other can differ.
Favorite Quotations:
• “My room’s across the hall. If someone comes in the night to kill you, make sure you shout. I’m not going to come save you, but I’d like a head start in case they’re after me too.”
• “My father says there’s a bit of a hero in everyone, and helping another find that piece of themselves is the greatest hero work of all.”
• This was pride without arrogance, light unshadowed by doubt. A purpose fulfilled.
• “The answer to that question answers another question you’ve probably been asking yourself, which is why in the world would Edric put his apprentice in the sort of danger he was in beyond the wall?” Brenwin had assumed the answer was that Edric didn’t really like his apprentice all that much, but he raised an eyebrow and played along.
(I received a free copy of this book via Booksirens and am gratefully—voluntarily—leaving a review.)
August 9, 2026
Mathematician Jack Brenwin's school nemesis is Silas the apprentice archmage. Each has experienced a very different kind of tough life which led them to this graduate-level work, and neither appreciates the other for exactly that reason. When a professor from a different faculty of the school gives Jack the opportunity to live out a dream and make life difficult for Silas, it's worth the chance to take it.
And that's why Jack and Silas go up the giant, short-lived beanstalk into the sky - where the barrier between human and Fae lies - to try to discover why the dangerous Fae and the ingenious goblins have been collaborating on a project. On the other side, they learn first-hand about the danger and chaos of trying to fit in in a foreign land while trying to learn more about fascinating peoples, and avoid likely-death. Brenwin won't leave Silas behind, because he's been guaranteed death should that happen. Silas is trapped, dependent on the one of them who was better-briefed on their mission.
I'm glad I was incentivised to try starting this novel a second time. It began with one of my pet peeves - it's really boring to read about people being bored - but everything gets better from there, and it eventually, once it gets going and gets past the initial character-development torture, delivers a satisfyingly rich and complicated story arc. This retelling of Jack and the Beanstalk offers twists and surprises, from an unexpected and sweet love story to the true nature of the golden goose.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
And that's why Jack and Silas go up the giant, short-lived beanstalk into the sky - where the barrier between human and Fae lies - to try to discover why the dangerous Fae and the ingenious goblins have been collaborating on a project. On the other side, they learn first-hand about the danger and chaos of trying to fit in in a foreign land while trying to learn more about fascinating peoples, and avoid likely-death. Brenwin won't leave Silas behind, because he's been guaranteed death should that happen. Silas is trapped, dependent on the one of them who was better-briefed on their mission.
I'm glad I was incentivised to try starting this novel a second time. It began with one of my pet peeves - it's really boring to read about people being bored - but everything gets better from there, and it eventually, once it gets going and gets past the initial character-development torture, delivers a satisfyingly rich and complicated story arc. This retelling of Jack and the Beanstalk offers twists and surprises, from an unexpected and sweet love story to the true nature of the golden goose.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 16, 2026
I received this ebook as an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book really surprised me, it took me a few chapters to get into it, but once things started going it really took off and grabbed my attention.
A Tale Beyond the Sky by Adelle Summers is a retelling of the story about Jack and the Beanstalk. It was an interesting take on an old classic story. The MMC, Jack Brenwin, is a teaching assistant at the School of Mathematics in the Westhaven Academy. Jack hates magic and avoids it at all cost. Jack is asked to accept a mission from the alchemist, Professor Ravinthal. The professor wants Jack to go across the wall to see what the goblins and fae are doing. Jack has to take Silas, the archmage apprentice with him. Silas is everything Jack hates: magic and higher status. Along with taking Silas they have magic beans that will help them get across the wall to the goblins and then back home. Jack and Silas set out on an adventure that will cahnge their lives and all the while Jack has to deal with more magic than he likes.
This is a wonderful and exciting new outlook on the tale of Jack and the Beanstalk. It will grab you and pull you along on a exciting journey full of adventure, magic, fae, goblins, giants, humans, new friendships and love. A must read if you enjoy any of these! Thanks for the opportunity to read A Tale Beyond the Sky! Can't wait to see whats next!
This book really surprised me, it took me a few chapters to get into it, but once things started going it really took off and grabbed my attention.
A Tale Beyond the Sky by Adelle Summers is a retelling of the story about Jack and the Beanstalk. It was an interesting take on an old classic story. The MMC, Jack Brenwin, is a teaching assistant at the School of Mathematics in the Westhaven Academy. Jack hates magic and avoids it at all cost. Jack is asked to accept a mission from the alchemist, Professor Ravinthal. The professor wants Jack to go across the wall to see what the goblins and fae are doing. Jack has to take Silas, the archmage apprentice with him. Silas is everything Jack hates: magic and higher status. Along with taking Silas they have magic beans that will help them get across the wall to the goblins and then back home. Jack and Silas set out on an adventure that will cahnge their lives and all the while Jack has to deal with more magic than he likes.
This is a wonderful and exciting new outlook on the tale of Jack and the Beanstalk. It will grab you and pull you along on a exciting journey full of adventure, magic, fae, goblins, giants, humans, new friendships and love. A must read if you enjoy any of these! Thanks for the opportunity to read A Tale Beyond the Sky! Can't wait to see whats next!
Review of advance copy
Jack and the Beanstalk was always one of my favourite fairytales growing up, so of course I jumped at the chance to read this retelling early… and I’m so glad I did.
A Tale Beyond the Sky is such a fun, magical world to be immersed in. There’s a mix of magical folk, adventure, and just enough nods to the original story to feel familiar, while still giving you something fresh and exciting. Adelle Summers really did an amazing retelling of this story.
I’m more of a fantasy girl than a romantasy one, so I really liked that the story leans into the fantasy side. The romance is still there and super sweet, but it's more of a backdrop than the main focal point, allowing you to truly be immersed in the adventure.
Bren and Silas have that grumpy/sunshine, can’t-stand-each-other vibe that slowly grows on you, but it's the goblin Ruby and the golden goose that completely stole the show for me. I loved them.
Overall, this was such an easy, enjoyable fantasy read. You’ve got elemental magic, fae, goblins, elves, giants… a bit of tension, a bit of humour, and some really lovely friendships woven in.
It’s the kind of story that pulls you in and keeps you hooked while taking you on an awesome adventure.
Thank you to BookSirens for the advanced reader copy.
A Tale Beyond the Sky is such a fun, magical world to be immersed in. There’s a mix of magical folk, adventure, and just enough nods to the original story to feel familiar, while still giving you something fresh and exciting. Adelle Summers really did an amazing retelling of this story.
I’m more of a fantasy girl than a romantasy one, so I really liked that the story leans into the fantasy side. The romance is still there and super sweet, but it's more of a backdrop than the main focal point, allowing you to truly be immersed in the adventure.
Bren and Silas have that grumpy/sunshine, can’t-stand-each-other vibe that slowly grows on you, but it's the goblin Ruby and the golden goose that completely stole the show for me. I loved them.
Overall, this was such an easy, enjoyable fantasy read. You’ve got elemental magic, fae, goblins, elves, giants… a bit of tension, a bit of humour, and some really lovely friendships woven in.
It’s the kind of story that pulls you in and keeps you hooked while taking you on an awesome adventure.
Thank you to BookSirens for the advanced reader copy.
April 16, 2026
I had to look up the original fairy tale this story is based on, and while some familiar elements are present, everything else is given a fresh and distinctive spin. The core ideas remain intact, but they’re reimagined in a way that feels original and intentional.
The story follows two companions who decidedly do not enjoy each other’s company, yet are sent on a journey together. Along the way, they’re forced to rely on one another’s strengths, build trust, and not only question the beliefs they were raised with, but also step up to protect innocent lives. That’s a lot to cover in a relatively short time, but the execution handles it well.
I especially enjoyed the character development. They never turn into instant friends, but they do grow beyond their initial prejudices and gradually accept one another for who they are, which feels authentic and earned.
The original fairy tale explores themes of risk and reward, bravery, greed, and survival, and all of these elements are neatly woven into the narrative. Add a good dash of entertainment on top, and this becomes another solid and engaging book by the author.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The story follows two companions who decidedly do not enjoy each other’s company, yet are sent on a journey together. Along the way, they’re forced to rely on one another’s strengths, build trust, and not only question the beliefs they were raised with, but also step up to protect innocent lives. That’s a lot to cover in a relatively short time, but the execution handles it well.
I especially enjoyed the character development. They never turn into instant friends, but they do grow beyond their initial prejudices and gradually accept one another for who they are, which feels authentic and earned.
The original fairy tale explores themes of risk and reward, bravery, greed, and survival, and all of these elements are neatly woven into the narrative. Add a good dash of entertainment on top, and this becomes another solid and engaging book by the author.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 17, 2026
A very different retelling of the Jack and the Beanstalk tale!
In Adelle Summers’ version of the tale, Jack is no idiot who traded a cow for magic beans. In this tale, he is a teacher’s assistant given an assignment to steal the beans and go over the wall. For you see, in Adelle Summers’ world, there was a battle between the fae and humans and as a result, there was a great wall built and they separated into magic and non-magic. Jack happens to be human, so has no magic. His mission is to find out what the fae are doing with the wood elves. Of course, he can’t go alone, he will have to take an archmage apprentice with him. This is definitely a very different story than the one I grew up with, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The world building is wonderful and the characters are all very complex, but none more complex than Jack himself. I love the way his past was brought out, just a bit at a time and how very different he is from the archmage apprentice. I adore the goose in this one too! I cannot recommend this story highly enough.
I received an advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
In Adelle Summers’ version of the tale, Jack is no idiot who traded a cow for magic beans. In this tale, he is a teacher’s assistant given an assignment to steal the beans and go over the wall. For you see, in Adelle Summers’ world, there was a battle between the fae and humans and as a result, there was a great wall built and they separated into magic and non-magic. Jack happens to be human, so has no magic. His mission is to find out what the fae are doing with the wood elves. Of course, he can’t go alone, he will have to take an archmage apprentice with him. This is definitely a very different story than the one I grew up with, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The world building is wonderful and the characters are all very complex, but none more complex than Jack himself. I love the way his past was brought out, just a bit at a time and how very different he is from the archmage apprentice. I adore the goose in this one too! I cannot recommend this story highly enough.
I received an advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This was a fun and different take on the classic fairy tale Jack and the Beanstalk. Featuring academia and intrigue, enemies turned forced allies turned friends, some light sweet and clean romance, heroics, character growth, and adventure.
I appreciated that the main characters had a sort of grumpy/sunshine feel to their “friend”ship, because it made their bantering so entertaining. And I especially loved the character Ruby. She was the star of the book in my opinion!
This wasn’t just a fluffy fairytale story, however. There were dark moments, injury and death, fighting, intense scenes, captivity, mentions of experimentation, traumatic events and war.
I think this book would appeal to teen and adult readers who enjoy fairy tale retellings that go a little darker, readers who like imperfect main characters, and readers who like a little bit of no-spice romance sprinkled into their fantasy adventure stories.
I received this ebook as an ARC from the author. The opinions expressed in this review are my own and given willingly.
I appreciated that the main characters had a sort of grumpy/sunshine feel to their “friend”ship, because it made their bantering so entertaining. And I especially loved the character Ruby. She was the star of the book in my opinion!
This wasn’t just a fluffy fairytale story, however. There were dark moments, injury and death, fighting, intense scenes, captivity, mentions of experimentation, traumatic events and war.
I think this book would appeal to teen and adult readers who enjoy fairy tale retellings that go a little darker, readers who like imperfect main characters, and readers who like a little bit of no-spice romance sprinkled into their fantasy adventure stories.
I received this ebook as an ARC from the author. The opinions expressed in this review are my own and given willingly.
April 16, 2026
I received this as an Advance Reader Copy.
4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The classic fairy tale of Jack and the Beanstalk, but altered. We get to see some academia to begin with, and some funny enemies turned forced friends, which is incredibly funny. The romance in this story is just the right amount, with light and cute interactions between the characters.
The way the main characters had a grumpy/sunshine-esque friendship, makes it all the better to enjoy the story. Their banter is entertaining and keeps you wondering what else will they get themselves into. The world is well built and the character arcs were well developed. The love interest is definitely the fave, as she brings a sense of levelheadedness in all the adventure being encountered. This is not your typical fairy tale. You get to embark into some dark adventure and some darker themes, while still appealing to a younger audience. Really good read and recommend if your interests lie in re-told fairy tales that take some fun and interesting detours.
I received this ebook as an ARC from the author.
4/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The classic fairy tale of Jack and the Beanstalk, but altered. We get to see some academia to begin with, and some funny enemies turned forced friends, which is incredibly funny. The romance in this story is just the right amount, with light and cute interactions between the characters.
The way the main characters had a grumpy/sunshine-esque friendship, makes it all the better to enjoy the story. Their banter is entertaining and keeps you wondering what else will they get themselves into. The world is well built and the character arcs were well developed. The love interest is definitely the fave, as she brings a sense of levelheadedness in all the adventure being encountered. This is not your typical fairy tale. You get to embark into some dark adventure and some darker themes, while still appealing to a younger audience. Really good read and recommend if your interests lie in re-told fairy tales that take some fun and interesting detours.
I received this ebook as an ARC from the author.
July 20, 2026
I got this book simplest because it's a retelling of Jack and the beanstalk. I love it!
The plot was smooth and easy to follow. The author took the skeletal framework of the timeless classic and made a totally completely different world. I found myself laughing in some parts, especially the antics of Silas the Archmage Apprentice and the ogre who just hated "his kind." The action scenes was fast-paced, yet not too fast that it was over right away.
Jack Brenwin, our main character, was a bit selfish and self-absorbed in the beginning had a satisfying character arc in the end. Silas, the other main character, was meek and a slight pushover, had a great character arc as well.
At first, when I read near the end, that this was going to be a series, but it turns out to be a standalone. I'm so happy it is. It's a rare find for me to find a standalone fantasy. Can the author expand it? Maybe just the world and just make companion or connected books, but I think it ended cleanly and satisfying.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The plot was smooth and easy to follow. The author took the skeletal framework of the timeless classic and made a totally completely different world. I found myself laughing in some parts, especially the antics of Silas the Archmage Apprentice and the ogre who just hated "his kind." The action scenes was fast-paced, yet not too fast that it was over right away.
Jack Brenwin, our main character, was a bit selfish and self-absorbed in the beginning had a satisfying character arc in the end. Silas, the other main character, was meek and a slight pushover, had a great character arc as well.
At first, when I read near the end, that this was going to be a series, but it turns out to be a standalone. I'm so happy it is. It's a rare find for me to find a standalone fantasy. Can the author expand it? Maybe just the world and just make companion or connected books, but I think it ended cleanly and satisfying.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
4.5 Stars. This was the first fairytale retelling I've ever sat down to read, and it did not disappoint. The story is told from the POV of Jack, a mathematics teaching assistant, and Silas, the archmage's apprentice. Jack has his eyes set on climbing the career ladder and clawing his way to the top. He dislikes magic and is determined to get there without using it. However, he accepts a mission where he must take Silas with him, and this causes all sorts of issues. I really enjoyed getting to know both characters, especially when Jack's obvious dislike of Silas became obvious and they were forced to work together. There's notable defining past events for both men that helps give context to their decisions, and both grow and learn lessons along the way. I really enjoyed the side characters in this too! Ruby was a favorite and I would have liked to have seen more of her. All in all, a great story that keeps the heart of the fairytale, but is also it's own unique story.
May 17, 2026
I love fairytale retellings, so the moment I saw this one, I was immediately interested. And I love when authors take familiar stories and completely make them their own.
In this world, there’s an ongoing battle between fae and humans that resulted in a wall separating the magical and non-magical lands. Jack is human, hates magic, and doesn’t possess any himself, which makes things interesting when he’s sent on a mission with an archmage apprentice… who very much DOES have magic. 👀✨
Ruby was easily one of my favorite characters, and once the story picked up, I really enjoyed this unique spin on Jack and the Beanstalk. It started a little slow for me, but overall it turned into a fun fantasy adventure with magic, tension, and fairytale vibes.
Thank you to BookSirens and Adelle Summers for the advanced reader copy. This is my honest review.
In this world, there’s an ongoing battle between fae and humans that resulted in a wall separating the magical and non-magical lands. Jack is human, hates magic, and doesn’t possess any himself, which makes things interesting when he’s sent on a mission with an archmage apprentice… who very much DOES have magic. 👀✨
Ruby was easily one of my favorite characters, and once the story picked up, I really enjoyed this unique spin on Jack and the Beanstalk. It started a little slow for me, but overall it turned into a fun fantasy adventure with magic, tension, and fairytale vibes.
Thank you to BookSirens and Adelle Summers for the advanced reader copy. This is my honest review.
Review of advance copy
I read this as an ARC.
This was another fun and imaginative read by Adelle Summers!
In Tale Beyond the Sky one of the main characters is one that we have previously seen as the bully of Westhaven Academy, so it's a bit strange at the beginning but as we learn more about him, he becomes more interesting!
I also loved how looks at themes such as: what makes a monster vs what makes a hero, identity and how there are often more than one side to most things.
Although it is the most recent book in a series of books set at Westhaven Academy, it can be read as a standalone. You'll just have a bit more background on some of the characters if you've read previous ones.
I absolutely recommend!
This was another fun and imaginative read by Adelle Summers!
In Tale Beyond the Sky one of the main characters is one that we have previously seen as the bully of Westhaven Academy, so it's a bit strange at the beginning but as we learn more about him, he becomes more interesting!
I also loved how looks at themes such as: what makes a monster vs what makes a hero, identity and how there are often more than one side to most things.
Although it is the most recent book in a series of books set at Westhaven Academy, it can be read as a standalone. You'll just have a bit more background on some of the characters if you've read previous ones.
I absolutely recommend!
Review of advance copy
Slow start, but worth it.
I read this thinking it was a romance for some reason. … it's not so much. Romance is definitely not a central plot, more like a subplot. Which is fine. Just not what I was expecting.
It's a great adventure with a great redemption arc. Although I had trouble with the first two "introductory" chapters being a little slow, once the adventure started, it was fun to read.
Whatever else you do, read the epilogue! I had to stop briefly before it and was dissatisfied with the ending. But the ending was actually excellent if you read the whole thing (duh, me), and I finished very happy.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I read this thinking it was a romance for some reason. … it's not so much. Romance is definitely not a central plot, more like a subplot. Which is fine. Just not what I was expecting.
It's a great adventure with a great redemption arc. Although I had trouble with the first two "introductory" chapters being a little slow, once the adventure started, it was fun to read.
Whatever else you do, read the epilogue! I had to stop briefly before it and was dissatisfied with the ending. But the ending was actually excellent if you read the whole thing (duh, me), and I finished very happy.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A wonderful retelling of Jack and the Beanstalk. The story does have a Jack and a golden goose, that he brings back down the beanstalk, but that is where the similarities in the stories end. Oh, there are giant ogres too.
Jack Brenwin and his friend Silas climb the beanstalk to cross over “the wall.” There they find a magical land full of friendly creatures and fearful enemies. Jack “Bren” and Silas realize why they were sent over the wall (not what they had been told) and an adventure filled with excitement, danger, and even love begins.
A very exciting story that will keep you flipping pages and saying, “I’ll stop after one more chapter.” But you keep saying that and soon are at the end of the book.
Jack Brenwin and his friend Silas climb the beanstalk to cross over “the wall.” There they find a magical land full of friendly creatures and fearful enemies. Jack “Bren” and Silas realize why they were sent over the wall (not what they had been told) and an adventure filled with excitement, danger, and even love begins.
A very exciting story that will keep you flipping pages and saying, “I’ll stop after one more chapter.” But you keep saying that and soon are at the end of the book.
May 7, 2026
I wasn’t sure how to feel at first. I love when a retelling actually does something new, and this one goes all in. The alchemy, the clash between the human and magical worlds, and the focus on two male main characters had me hooked. The section from the bean stealing to the first climb down the vine moved slowly for me, but once Silas fell and fought his way back, the story absolutely took off. The ending was fine, though I was really hoping Ruby would get her goblin happily ever after, but then the epilogue!! I told myself the entire book that Bren couldn’t be the bad guy in this and thankfully I was mostly right. Overall, it felt creative, thoughtful, and genuinely well crafted. I would definitely recommend it to my oldest teen.
Review of advance copy
This story is officially one of my new favorite fairy tale reimaginings with all sorts of character cameos woven into the main story with Jack. Jack happens to be a disgruntled math teacher at Westhaven who gets sent on a mission with an apprentice mage and everything goes awry. Enter elves, goblins,giants,ogres,and fae.
A little kindness goes a long way, especially when someone has felt lost or alone. True kindness can change someone's life. It might even give them the power to be brave.
Unconventional beauty was also important in this story. Beauty is all your special talents and gifts.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
A little kindness goes a long way, especially when someone has felt lost or alone. True kindness can change someone's life. It might even give them the power to be brave.
Unconventional beauty was also important in this story. Beauty is all your special talents and gifts.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 24, 2026
I enjoyed the continuation of the world we got to explore in the Sleeping beuty Retold book, A Dream Enchanted. I like how we get to journey beyond the school and learn more about the war between the fae, the goblins, and the humans! I also really like how Jack Brenwin isn't just a local hero like in the traditional tale--he is an established character in the universe and comes into his own as a member of the community, if a little rough around the edges. I am excited to see where these stories lead and the world they end up building!
Note: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Note: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
May 11, 2026
Reimagined fairy tales can sometimes be a hit or miss, but A Tale Beyond the Sky by Adelle Summers was so good! She gave us clever characters, a beautiful world build, themes of the classic fairytale but told in such a new and different way with depth and emotion. I was completely engrossed in the adventures or maybe misadventures of Silas and Jack. Two strong male main characters and their non-romantic relationship was such a refreshing and unique departure from the norm where most fairytales involve love interests or strong female leads which I really enjoyed. I just couldn’t put this down!
Thank you BookSirens for the advanced ebook!
All of these thoughts and opinions are my own.
Thank you BookSirens for the advanced ebook!
All of these thoughts and opinions are my own.
May 30, 2026
4★ out of 5 ★
I wasn’t ready for how soft this book would hit.
Summers writes like she knows all the quiet things we don’t say out loud. The world feels huge and magical, but the characters feel real; messy, hopeful, tired in that human way. I loved the writing. So many lines I had to stop and re-read.
Dropped one star because the middle slowed down for me, but the ending pulled it all together and left me wrecked in a good way. I closed it and just sat with it for a bit.
If you want a story that feels like looking up at the sky and remembering you’re allowed to hope, read this. 4/5 for me.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I wasn’t ready for how soft this book would hit.
Summers writes like she knows all the quiet things we don’t say out loud. The world feels huge and magical, but the characters feel real; messy, hopeful, tired in that human way. I loved the writing. So many lines I had to stop and re-read.
Dropped one star because the middle slowed down for me, but the ending pulled it all together and left me wrecked in a good way. I closed it and just sat with it for a bit.
If you want a story that feels like looking up at the sky and remembering you’re allowed to hope, read this. 4/5 for me.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 9, 2026
Review of Advanced Reader Copy
I really enjoyed this book! It started slow but picked up in pace and I couldn’t put it down. I appreciated that the focus of the plot wasn’t romance but that there was still some sprinkled in. The book has certain details that are consistent with the original fairytale but not enough to the point where it feels redundant. Overall I recommend this book for a quick read about magic and choosing to do the right thing!
Thank you to BookSirens for the advanced reader copy.
I really enjoyed this book! It started slow but picked up in pace and I couldn’t put it down. I appreciated that the focus of the plot wasn’t romance but that there was still some sprinkled in. The book has certain details that are consistent with the original fairytale but not enough to the point where it feels redundant. Overall I recommend this book for a quick read about magic and choosing to do the right thing!
Thank you to BookSirens for the advanced reader copy.
Review of advance copy received from Author
ARC REVIEW
A bit too slow for me eventhough it does pick up its pace further into the story. The 'frienemies' dynamic and the banters between our two main characters are fun to read. There's not much romance to be talked about. I have to be honest though, this retelling doesn't do much to me. I'm not really feeling for Brenwin or Jack at all. But I do love his moments with Ruby though.
Also, this book makes me realise I really am more interested in Silas since his first appearance in the previous book and now I am so intrigued by his professor too.
A bit too slow for me eventhough it does pick up its pace further into the story. The 'frienemies' dynamic and the banters between our two main characters are fun to read. There's not much romance to be talked about. I have to be honest though, this retelling doesn't do much to me. I'm not really feeling for Brenwin or Jack at all. But I do love his moments with Ruby though.
Also, this book makes me realise I really am more interested in Silas since his first appearance in the previous book and now I am so intrigued by his professor too.
June 23, 2026
It took me a little bit to get into A Tale Beyond the Sky, but once I did I was hooked. I enjoyed reading about their adventure and where it led them. Bren’s relationship with Ruby was so pure with their shared interests. Seeing the characters grow and expand beyond what they were before was thoroughly enjoyable. Definitely something someone would enjoy reading if they like fantasy and adventure with a little bit of magic mixed in. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A Tale Beyond the Sky is a Jack and the Beanstalk retelling. It has aspects of Jack and the Beanstalk like the actual Beanstalk that grows from a magic bean to a place in the sky but that place is a fae realm with fae creatures. I enjoyed the different take on the story. It was a quick read and was a younger reader appropriate story. The dynamic between the two main characters was that of frenemies at times which was funny.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received an ARC of this book and am voluntarily leaving my honest review.
This was an interesting retelling of Jack and the Beanstalk. It was the bare bones of the story with many added characters, creatures, and plot points.
It wasn't bad, but I didn't consider it great either. Maybe it just wasn't my cup of tea? From what I could tell this is a standalone, so the dislike/bad blood between the two MC's felt like it was never explained, which made it feel unnatural.
No language, no spice.
This was an interesting retelling of Jack and the Beanstalk. It was the bare bones of the story with many added characters, creatures, and plot points.
It wasn't bad, but I didn't consider it great either. Maybe it just wasn't my cup of tea? From what I could tell this is a standalone, so the dislike/bad blood between the two MC's felt like it was never explained, which made it feel unnatural.
No language, no spice.
April 16, 2026
This book is part of the Fairy Tales of Westhaven series. This is an enchanting Jack and the Beanstalk retelling. You’re drawn right away into the mystery that the story unravels chapter by chapter. Amazing world building that is detailed and imaginable. Fascinating characters that are interesting and diverse. This is a fast-paced intriguing read! I received an advance review copy, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews