Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Girl with the Wrong Name

Rate this book
Ever since “The Night In Question” left her with a hideous scar and no memory of what happened, Theo Lane has been hiding. An aspiring filmmaker, she uses a hidden button cam to keep the world at bay. She spends the entire summer in a Manhattan café, secretly documenting random “subjects.”

Once school starts, Theo finds her best friend has morphed into a flirtatious, short-skirt-clad stranger. Everyone ignores the scar. As if that will make it go away. The café remains her lunchtime refuge.

Her most interesting subject is the Lost Boy, a stranger who comes in every day at the same time. When she finally gets up the courage to talk to him she discovers why: the Lost Boy, Andy, is waiting for someone who said she’d meet him there…four days ago. Intoxicated by Andy’s love for this mystery girl, Theo agrees to help him find her, and her unhealthy obsession pulls her into a perilous, mind-bending journey. But is it really Andy’s world she’s investigating? Or is it her own?

259 pages, Hardcover

First published November 3, 2015

28 people are currently reading
1679 people want to read

About the author

Barnabas Miller

9 books24 followers
Barnabas Miller has written many books for children and young adults. He also composes and produces music for film and network television. He lives in New York City with his wife, Heidi; their cat, Ted; and their dog, Zooey.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
208 (29%)
4 stars
230 (32%)
3 stars
188 (26%)
2 stars
60 (8%)
1 star
20 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 143 reviews
Profile Image for The Candid Cover (Olivia & Lori).
1,267 reviews1,609 followers
March 10, 2021
Full Review on The Candid Cover

Readers looking for a thrill ride of a book should absolutely put The Girl with the Wrong Name on their radars. It is an intense psychological thriller that has an aspiring filmmaker as its protagonist. Also, the plot is so unpredictable, it leaves the reader in a constant state of wonder.

Barnabas Miller has created an amazing whirlwind of book that is full of suspense! Lately, I have been really into this genre, which is probably why I enjoyed this book so much. It honestly has it all, a mysterious scar, a night in question, a creepy sanctuary, everything that makes an interesting thriller. This is the kind of book that will blow the reader’s mind!

Theo, in The Girl with the Wrong Name, is such an enjoyable main character. She is brave and curious, and goes with her instincts. Theo’s name is also really interesting, since it has an interesting backstory. One of my favourite things about her is how she wants to be a filmmaker. I always love books with film/TV components, so this book was quite entertaining for me.

The plot of The Girl with the Wrong Name is so unpredictable. This is the kind of book with a powerful and shocking ending that the reader won’t even see coming (think We Were Liars). However, I did feel like there were some loose ends in the book, and I have so many questions after reading it. This was sort of disappointing, because I grew pretty attached to the characters, and want to know more about what happens to them. Other than that, the plot is so fast-paced and thrilling, making this book impossible to put down.

The Girl with the Wrong Name is a thriller with a curious main character and a twisty plot. It is a book that readers will find unputdownable, as it is so fast-paced. Fans of We’ll Never Be Apart by Emiko Jean should definitely read this book, as there are many similar components that will leave readers breathless.
Profile Image for Paula M.
586 reviews624 followers
December 18, 2015
Very weak opening and disappointing ending. No, it did not helped my book slump at all. Full review to follow!
Profile Image for Tonyalee.
783 reviews136 followers
December 3, 2015
See this review and more on my blog, Lilybloombooks

Take an unreliable narrator. Mix it with an unpredictable plot, mystery, suspense and what do you get? The Girl with the Wrong Name.

Psychological thrillers have been one of my favorite genres for some time now and this one was one of THE BEST that I have read. I am usually pretty good (around 85%) at figuring out what is going on/whodunnit/what is real type of THINGS and I could not figure this book out to save my life. And I can't even talk about ALL THE THINGS because even one small inkling could tip you off and ruin the whole experience.

Theo is one of those contradictory characters that I love so much. She is strong; yet vulnerable. Snarky; yet sweet. She has this strong passion for film making and even though it's not something that I would typically enjoy, seeing things in her eyes makes everything POP. She's just so real.

There are a few things in the end that I wanted answers to that I just didn't get. Is that the point? Probably. It doesn't take away from my enjoyment because the whole NOT KNOWING left me wondering for days (okay, weeks) after finishing what happens from here!?

Vague I know - but you must head into this one with blinders on. It's thrilling, unpredictable, a little dark but with a whole lotta greatness. I highly recommend The Girl with the Wrong Name.

I received this book for free from The Publisher in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Profile Image for Trisha.
5,877 reviews229 followers
June 14, 2016
What a high, pulse-pounding story this was. I knew there would be twists and turns, but I assumed all the wrong things and this story completely wow'd me.

I didn't anticipate the end or even that final twist but I loved it - every minute. So glad I grabbed this pretty cover and gave the story a try. I loved it
Profile Image for PinkAmy loves books, cats and naps .
2,711 reviews253 followers
November 7, 2015
Grade: B-

Seventeen-year-old budding documentarian Theo Lane secretly films strangers and obsesses over NYT wedding announcements. She can't remember how she got the scar on her face 2 1/2 months a free The Night In Question. She meets Lost Boy Andy Reese, who's searching for Sarah, a chance encounter with whom he's fallen in love.

Confused yet? THE GIRL WITH THE WRONG NAME had me wondering what the heck was happening and the reliability of narrator Theo. We aren't privy to why she's in therapy, but know she's taking an antidepressant, but I immediately wondered if her problems ran deeper that PTSD and depression and into the realm of psychopathy. Theo had a great, sarcastic, unique voice that drew me in from page one. Even when I didn't like how she treated her friends and parents, I loved her character. I had a hard time seeing why Theo's best friends liked her, she was thoughtless and often unkind. While Theo was fleshed out, the secondary players seemed to exist only to support Theo.

The plot had me guessing and wondering and the resolution took a fill third of the story to explain. Barnabas Miller included so many details in the wrap up that destroyed any credibility that THE GIRL WITH NO NAME could be anything other than a story created in Miller's mind. I was glad that the book had a definite ending, even though it lacked authenticity.

THEMES: mental health, mystery, family, friendship,

A lukewarm recommendation for THE GIRL WITH NO NAME.
Profile Image for Shannon.
Author 5 books280 followers
March 28, 2017
2.5/5

So I can't really decide what I think of this book. It was all too muddy and confusing. Although the book did certainly keep me guessing in its second half (as you could see from my various status updates along the way), and it was full of things I didn't expect, I wouldn't say it was particularly a SHOCK VALUE type of book. It absolutely was unexpected and had elements I've not seen before, but it still had a lot of those fall-back tropes (), not to mention that sheer amount of coincidence that had to occur in order for everything to come together the way it had. I'm awarding points for creativity and the mental gymnastics required of the author to piece together such a complicated plot, but at the root of it all, my reaction to this story was just lukewarm.
Profile Image for Sara.
1,202 reviews62 followers
July 27, 2019
Wow, what a page turner! The story gets weirder and weirder with each chapter. Who is Sarah? Who is Andy? What is with that scar on Theo's face?

This is the story of Theo, who's avoiding high school because she was in some sort of accident that disfigured her face. She meets Andy from Texas in a coffee shop and he's searching for a girl named Sarah he met a few days ago who disappeared.

The problem is who IS Andy exactly? Things start to get totally bizarre as they start looking for Sarah.

The only downside I felt about this book is the ending. A little TOO bizarre, IMO.
Profile Image for Vicki.
2,699 reviews111 followers
March 20, 2016
I love psychological thrillers and this book didn't disappoint me. Theo is the main character, a female, who meets Andy while she is secretly filming him. He happens to be waiting for Sarah, who is his would be soul mate, if he can find her. So Theo takes up arms with him and they go on a search to find Sarah.

Sarah is this mysterious girl that Andy just can't get his mind off and she becomes practically a part of Theo's every thought, too. The two of them go on some pretty scary adventures to find this perfect girl for Andy.

The thing about this book that I really loved is that it was not predictable. I did have some guesses as to what happened to Sarah but I was never spot on. I had some ideas about Andy and other characters as well, but I was off there too.

I have so much I want to say but am afraid I'll spoil it for others who read this, so I'll leave it at that.

Recommendation: If you like psychological thrillers, read this one!
Profile Image for Jenelle.
923 reviews35 followers
January 14, 2017
Daaaaaang!!

When this started off exactly like some Julia Roberts wedding movie, I NEVER would have guessed how psychologically twisty the story would get.

Like, literally, imagine a twist tie that has been twisted not one or two or even three times like a normal story or a loaf of bread. No, this twist tie has been twisted and turned and flipped and knotted right down to the very end of its little wire tips and then you realize, wait, that isn't a twist tie at all-- it's a freaking necktie in an Eldredge Knot!

Because yes, you've been tricked, you fool! You thought you had it figured out back in the early stages, but jokes on you, because that wasn't the big secret that explained the whole story, that was just one measly piece of the puzzle, and a red herring at that!

Sooo sneaky.

I loved it.
Profile Image for Haley Isabella  BellaTheBibliophile.
23 reviews13 followers
November 22, 2017
This book really amazed me. I received this book as a Christmas gift last year and the blurb seemed pretty interesting but I didn't feel the urge to pick this book up (I have a huge collection of books I still need to get around to) but I'm glad I finally did. This book was full of plot twists and I do mean full. Every time I got used to one plot twist, another one quickly took over. For a little while I was pretty confused on where this story was heading but everything started to make sense/fall together around the end of the story. When I read the blurb I assumed this would be a cute sappy love story but it turned out to be a physiological thriller. It was just what I needed to get back into reading, what started out as a book I felt no real urge to read turned into a book I didn't want to put down.
Profile Image for Shelley.
5,592 reviews489 followers
November 5, 2015
**I received this book for free from (Publisher) via (Edelweiss ) in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.**

*Genre* Juvenile Fiction /Thriller /Suspense
*Rating* 3.5

*My Thoughts*

17-year old Theodore (Thee/Theo) Lane doesn't remember the so called "Night in Question." She believes something awful happened to her but doesn't remember what. Every time she looks in the mirror, she claims she has a 4 inch scar on her face. One could say right from the top, that Theo repressed the memory of what happened to protect herself.

*FULL REVIEW POSTED @ GIZMOS REVIEWS 11/05/2015*

http://gizmosreviews.blogspot.com/201...

Published: November 3rd 2015 by Soho Teen
Profile Image for Erin .
1,612 reviews1,520 followers
January 23, 2016
The Girl with the wrong name is dark & twist filled. Some of the twist you think you've figured out only to be hit with a different twist. I thought I would like this book but instead I love it. The year is still young but this book is my favorite book I've read so far.
Profile Image for Sierra.
41 reviews16 followers
May 9, 2016
Disappointing. Confusing. Much language.
I would not recommend this book, and I probably won't be reading anything else by this author. :P
Profile Image for Kelsey van Dillen.
736 reviews39 followers
July 14, 2015
Ik dacht dat dit een verhaal zou zijn over een lelijk eendje wat een jongen helpt zijn liefde te vinden. Alleen dat hij dan uiteindelijk toch verliefd op het eendje wordt omdat hij haar ware karakter leert kennen. Boy, ben ik even voor de gek gehouden. Ik heb niet te kans gekregen om tussendoor aan de recensie te schrijven omdat ik verder MOEST lezen. Er gaan zoveel gedachten door mijn hoofd. Ik val van de ene verbazing in de andere. Het is zo niet wat ik had verwacht, maar het is zo geniaal. En ik had NOOIT gedacht dat ik dit zo goed zou vinden.
Prepare for the biggest plottwist EVERRRRRR. En een mooi einde.
Dit boek is mijn serendipity.

Profile Image for Kyleigh.
108 reviews20 followers
March 7, 2018
I really enjoyed this book!

I love Theo and her personality and her obsession with the wedding announcements in the newspaper. I love Max and Lou and I just really enjoyed this book.

It was fun trying to figure out who Sarah was and the relationship of everyone in the story. I did not see the ending coming and it was a surprise to me that the story went in that direction. But I think it was great anyway. I actually really like how everything came together in the end. All the pieces were put into place and everything made sense.
Profile Image for Nattie.
1,118 reviews24 followers
January 28, 2016
This one started off not to my liking when Theo declared that she looks like a serial killer because of a 4" long scar on her cheek. I found that very insulting to people with scars, and it was stupid. Most serial killers don't look any certain way.

The format of the book was unique, but I couldn't connect with it. I got tired of Theo talking to herself.
Profile Image for Mahlia.
75 reviews
August 10, 2016
OMG, this book was amazing! It totally hooked you and kept you excited about the next page. I couldn't put this one down!! This is a must-read!
Profile Image for Laila.
245 reviews
May 31, 2023
was not expecting this book to give as much as it did!!!
i have to say tho it’s good in a bad way. as in it’s entertaining and stupid and fun and shocking but not good but not bad. take off that thinking cap and it’ll be a fun time!

i was thinking it’d be a sappy little romance with a little “mystery” but i was wrongggg

you think you know what’s going on but it just keeps going and kept on shocking me
very unexpected.

i hateeeeed that everything happened in september 2003 tho. like that’s wayyy too close. everything tragic happened september 3, 2003…

it’s very unbelievable for a 5 year old to be able to remember everything that theo did. but wooooowwww.

spoilers:

theo was hallucinating everything!??? she had an older sister?? Andy wasn’t real but wasn’t real?? the video tape where we find out her sisters bf/ husband was actually insane?? emma killing andy in the end!!!!

THE REAL ANDY??!???!
YUCKKKK

theo was 5 when her sister, cyrano, died. cyrano died at 18 the day she got married to andy.

I CAN NOT BELIEVE THAT HE REALLY MARRIED CYRANO AND THEN THE NIGHT OF THEIR WEDDING HE MAKES A WHOLE THING FOR THEM TO DO THE DO WITH FLOWERS AND CANDLES ALL ROMANTIC. WHILE THEYRE DOING THE DO HE GOES CRAZY BC HE THINKS CYRA ISNT “PURE” SO HE BEATS HER UP JN THE REFUGEE THEY MADE TOGETHER FOR WOMEN ESCAPING DOMESTIC ABUSE!!! AND WHEN 5 YEAR OLD THEO WALKS IN, TO STOP THEM THEN THE ROOM CATCHES ON FIRE AND HE GRABS THE WEDDING RUNG OFF HIS BEATEN WIVES FINGER AND RUNS OUT SLAMMING THE DOOR LEAVING HIS WIFE AND A 5 YEAR OLD IN A BURNING BUKDINNG?!!?!!!?
i genuinely gasped.

THATS HIW HE DIES TOO BC HE MARRIES EMMA, HIS AND CYRANO FORMER BEST FRUEND, AND WHEN HE THINKS SHES NOT “PURE” HE TRUES TO DO THE SAME TO HER BUT EMMA DEFENDS HERSELF
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Maria Judnick.
267 reviews1 follower
January 16, 2016
While it was well-written and plotted, I just think I'm not the ideal audience member. This book is a thriller, yes, but the way the plot comes together seemed implausible to me....but I think this story is one genuinely written for teens.

*semi-spoilers ahead*

------------------------
Things that bothered me:
--Theo's mom as a character seems a little incredible. Why she decided to conceal that info is beyond me.
--How did Theo's very important tape survive that fire? How did her family not know there were two budding filmmakers in the house? Wouldn't those tapes have been found much earlier?
--How had the real Andy, if he was so insane, manage to not have another episode in the last twelve years? How had Emma not figured it out in all their years of dating?
--How had no one noticed that Theo was acting so erratically?
-- Could that song be enough to trigger such a strong reaction?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Michele Lanfant.
17 reviews
Read
January 11, 2017
This book was an interesting book with some unique aspects. On page 258, Max and Theo(a girl) exchange a conversation. "What's so funny?"... "Just Lou and her whole 'married' thing. She's freakin' hilarious." "I know." I roll my eyes. "Like that will ever happen." Max and Theo secretly like each other but they aren't going up to say that they like each other. Lou thinks that they are perfect for each other. When Theo says "Like that will ever happen," she is doubting the future. It isn't great to doubt because the things you want to happen, won't happen. I liked this book and I would recommend it.
Profile Image for Greg.
869 reviews
July 27, 2019
Great story. Lots of fun, humor, weirdness, at least at first, then, oh oh, not so much fun, then, holy shit, scary. Wondering what's going on, what's going to happen, never quite sure till the very end. Twists and truths and more twists and more truths.

Finished it in two days. Couldn't put it down.

Great main character. Lots of heart, lots of pain, lots of confusion, trying to figure things out.

And nice writing style, good, easy flow. Thank you so much for that.

And, yes, interesting from the very first page. Thank you so much for that also. So rare.
Profile Image for Jamal Whittick.
55 reviews
November 24, 2015
I absolutely hated this book the characters and their bad choices but I guess I liked it enough to finish it and the ending was very anti climactic. Not a good debut book.
Profile Image for Taylormade1203.
5 reviews
December 24, 2015
This book floored me. I cannot believe everything that happened! Honestly one of the best books I have read in a really long time! I would recommend this to anyone!
Profile Image for Hilary Martin.
202 reviews31 followers
January 20, 2016
It got better about halfway through but I skimmed through most of it.
Profile Image for Amy.
196 reviews2 followers
July 14, 2016
Wow. Intense read. Not a predictable story at all. I was unsure as to where the story was heading until the last 20 pages.
Profile Image for fawn.
43 reviews
August 9, 2018
The synopsis doesn't even begin to serve justice to this book. It has great twists AND explains everything. There's some sexual harassment in it, so trigger warning for that.
Profile Image for Christina.
42 reviews1 follower
February 14, 2021
Actual Rating: 3.5

I really didn't see the twist coming and I was actually surprised. It was a good read, but the ending was a little boring for me. I didn't understand what was happening at first, but I eventually caught on.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 143 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.