Among the many things that are used to describe "The Diary of A Nobody", there are two which are most frequently cited. One is the term, "accidental masterpiece", meaning that the Grossmith brothers, both gifted comedians of the era, never intended that their comic novel, disguised as a diary of a nobody, or rather of one of the most memorable narrators and protagonists of comedic fiction, should be as good and influential as it is. The second thing is that many, including me, think it to be hilarious in the best sense while there are also many other readers, as evidenced by many unimpressed 3-star reviews here on Goodreads itself, who believe that the book is hardly the comedic masterpiece it is made out to be.
On reading the actual novel itself, one realises just how misleading these two descriptions can be. "The Diary Of A Nobody" is a brilliant novel, a superb specimen of Grossmith' self-conscious comedic style that would later inspire a whole generation of comedic troupes in the subsequent century - Monty Python's sketches of suburban England, with Terry Jones as the gullible housewife and Graham Chapman playing the middle-class husband, come most to the mind - and even on its own, is a wistful and nostalgic ode to an older, more genial but not necessarily innocent way of life before materialism and capitalism reached on the throes of the British Isles across the Atlantic. And while it might not be chock full of side-splitting gags or one-liners, the hilarity and the warm humour is derived from its humdrum protagonist and his hapless attempts to make some sense of his boisterous and moody friends, his dealings with servants and shopkeepers, his wayward and flippant son and the fast-changing ways of the world around him.
Charles Pooter starts recording the daily experiences, observations and events of his humdrum life from a certain April in an unnamed year and the diary, despite his intentions about half-way to finish it on a whim of temporary disillusionment, goes on for the next fifteen months, though, again, entries for a few months are missing due to a hilarious misadventure which I won't reveal to you right now. Pooter and his wife Carrie have just moved in, at the beginning of their diary, into a new suburban house which they have taken on rent and right from the initial pages, the Grossmiths get us acquainted with not only this mild-mannered couple, sometimes quarreling but always more or less in happy and even loving agreement with each other, but also Pooter's old friends, Gowing who is, in the narrator's words, always "coming" and Cummings who is always "going". There is a most eclectic cast of characters who step in and out of their lives and the pages of Pooter's diary - unpredictable shopkeepers, new acquaintances who turn out to be more unwelcome than ever, a kind and affable boss of many years, an uncouth and rude young colleague, some more friends and relatives and, most memorably, the son Lupin himself, always in or out of some trouble or misadventure.
Pooter's interactions with Lupin are what lifts the novel out of its endlessly amusing tenor - a thing to which I will turn now. In its own simple, warmly funny but profound way, the novel reveals a definite point of divergence between the old and the new, between the contented and the ambitious, between the genial and the reckless. Lupin's frivolity is a rude contrast to old Pooter's anxious concern that he should not offend anybody else, which he ends up doing unwittingly much to his detriment and our bemused enjoyment. At heart, what makes Pooter such an endearing character and chronicler of these events and incidents and even his innermost thoughts and reflections, even as they might seem insignificant to a more skeptical reader, is the plain, unadorned honesty and sincerity with which he records them in his diary. His only object in life is to get by without much fuss, with his wife, whom he loves and adores, despite the occasional disagreements, and with his old friends, whom he cannot get rid of, despite their not-so-innocent form of mischief and humour, largely directed on him, as it should be. And thus in this simple yearning for contentment, Pooter makes us root for him, he makes us hope that he gets his happy ending, whatever it may be, at the end of this diary, if not really at the end of his own life, which he cannot control yet.
It is thus this tender core of humanistic warmth and empathy that defines "The Diary Of A Nobody" and distinguishes it from most other comedic works. Unlike others, the Grossmiths do not revel in Pooter's simplicity and limited imagination; yes, they do tease it and poke some gentle fun at it when his earnestness gets the better of him; we laugh at Pooter's incapacity to make sense of the world and its strange, even startling ways around him but we laugh even more raucously at the very people around him - they are the butt of our jokes and laughter and in the end, we find ourselves siding with this almost elderly man because his despair and confusion are as real and believable as his flaws and inadequacies. Yes, "The Diary of A Nobody" is hilarious, much more than it gets credit for, but it is also heartwarming in the most unexpected ways too.
Reading it as I find myself on the throes of the thirties, I was reminded time and again of just how much Pooter's story, told so skilfully by the writers with a style so conversational and unaffected that never do we doubt its realism, resonates with us all. I see my father, now a dignified gent in his sixties, still working, still keeping his mind and body alert and agile as ever (God bless him) and I find in him something of a reflection of Pooter himself, hoping against hope, still endowed with old-fashioned virtues of honesty and duty. In Pooter himself, I find a sad reminder for us all of a time when it was considered to be noble and honourable to do one's duty, to be loyal, to be even contented with less. Surely, these are things that we cannot abide by anymore; it is beyond us. But the greatest quality of "The Diary Of A Nobody" beyond its humour will always be its heartwarming quality of innocence, resilience and simple happiness, all of which have been lost forever as a relic of the past.