Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

A Girl from Ohio

Rate this book
From the author of Their Shadows Deep comes a powerful story of first love and second chances, deadly secrets and life-changing truths, closed chapters and open doors.

Bestselling author and esteemed Ohio University Professor Emmet Maze is at the height of his career—and a world away from his troubled New Jersey youth. But when a young woman enters his office with a desperate plea, it changes his life forever.

Jenn Newlin is the spitting image of her mother, Kaya, a face Emmet could never forget. As college students in the ’70s, he and Kaya were inseparable, falling in love and supporting each other’s dreams in a post-Vietnam America. But after three years together, the budding journalist and brilliant math student abruptly parted ways. And Kaya married another man.

Now, that man is missing, and Kaya and Jenn beg Emmet to help find him. But as Emmet digs into his disappearance, he uncovers a dangerous web of murder, fraud, and organized crime. And while he’s swept up in a rush of familiar emotions, he makes an even more shocking discovery—and faces a true test of his soul.

334 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 27, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Peter Golden

25 books146 followers
Peter Golden is an award-winning journalist, historian, and novelist who has written nine books and interviewed Presidents Nixon, Ford, Reagan, and Bush (41); Secretaries of State Kissinger, Haig, Shultz, and Eagleburger; Israeli Prime Ministers Rabin, Peres, and Shamir; and Soviet President Gorbachev. His first novel, Comeback Love, was praised by the novelist and reviewer Caroline Leavitt as an “extraordinary debut.” Wherever There Is Light, his second novel, was featured in New York Magazine’s Fall Preview issue, widely reviewed, and selected by the New Jersey Star-Ledger as one of the best books of 2016. His third novel, Nothing Is Forgotten, which explores the connection between the Holocaust and the Cold War, was published on April 10, 2018. New York Times bestselling author Lisa Wingate praised the novel as "the sort of book you won’t soon forget…Cold War Europe, lingering Nazi secrets, and the tragic history faced by millions of families not only bring this tale to life but will keep you turning the pages.”

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
46 (42%)
4 stars
44 (40%)
3 stars
15 (13%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
3 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews
2,938 reviews32k followers
October 22, 2026
Emmet is a bestselling author and professor at Ohio University, a life very different from his childhood. A woman named Jenn enters his office, and he thinks she looks just like a woman, Kaya, he knew as a college student in the 70s. The two were in a serious relationship, but something happens that tore them apart. Kaya married someone else, and now that person is missing.

Both Jenn and Kaya are asking Emmet to help find him, using his resources. The more he digs, the more danger he uncovers.

A Girl from Ohio is a well-written historical mystery. I was invested i these characters and on the edge of my seat with how it would all resolve.

I received a gifted copy.

Many of my reviews can also be found on my blog: www.jennifertarheelreader.com and instagram: www.instagram.com/tarheelreader
Profile Image for Colleen Kellas.
50 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 11, 2026
5 Stars. This is an Arc I recieved from Netgalley In exchange of my complete and Honest Opinion.

In A Girl From Ohio By Peter Golden follows Emmet. a journalist in his 50s gets a letter from his ex-girlfriend asking for help finding her husband that she left him for. He couldn't say no to the love of his life so of course he couldn't say no.

Every word written in this book was a brush stroke of a masterpiece that is book. This was amazing I loved every second of book. I quote bits and Pieces and shared it to my friends. One of which reminds me of the MC. I will say though if you werent told that they were humans you'd think they were bunnies.

I read this from Sep 6 2026- Sep 11 2026 Release Date is Oct 27 2026

Song: Stop The Wedding By Ashe
Profile Image for Christine.
684 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 20, 2026
Thank you Brilliance Publishing and NetGalley for the ALC in exchange for my honest review. Paul Heitsch was a great narrator for this novel.

Danggggg! This book was filled with twists and turns that I simply did not see coming! Yet, it still worked with the story without becoming too outlandish.

I also enjoyed that at the beginning of the book, Kaya and Emmet’s history with each other was the starting point and not a flashback. Overall, this was an entertaining read with mystery, suspense, and even romance!
Profile Image for Melissa (Nissa_the.bookworm).
1,310 reviews103 followers
November 5, 2026
𝐑𝐄𝐀𝐃 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐒 𝐈𝐅 𝐘𝐎𝐔
🔍 consider yourself an armchair detective
👀 are a fan of dual timelines
💕 enjoy a bit of romance in your mysteries
💭 have ever wondered “what if”

• 𝐖𝐇𝐀𝐓 𝐈𝐓’𝐒 𝐀𝐁𝐎𝐔𝐓

Bestselling author and esteemed Ohio University Professor Emmet Maze is at the height of his career—and a world away from his troubled New Jersey youth. But when a young woman enters his office with a desperate plea, it changes his life forever.

Jenn Newlin is the spitting image of her mother, Kaya, a face Emmet could never forget. As college students in the ’70s, he and Kaya were inseparable, falling in love and supporting each other’s dreams in a post-Vietnam America. But after three years together, the budding journalist and brilliant math student abruptly parted ways. And Kaya married another man.

Now, that man is missing, and Kaya and Jenn beg Emmet to help find him. But as Emmet digs into his disappearance, he uncovers a dangerous web of murder, fraud, and organized crime. And while he’s swept up in a rush of familiar emotions, he makes an even more shocking discovery—and faces a true test of his soul.

• 𝐌𝐘 𝐓𝐇𝐎𝐔𝐆𝐇𝐓𝐒

This was such a great mystery, spanning across 30+ years! As someone who also lost an important person, I felt that I could really relate to Emmet’s character when it came to Kaya. I enjoyed the first part of the story, getting to know who he and Kaya were, especially together, but the mystery is what kept me most entertained! I wasn’t entirely sure where this story would go, and in the end, I was left highly satisfied by the way it all played out. I enjoyed how the author plays with the question of “what if” and “how much do we really owe to people from our past?” I felt that Emmet was a stand up character for agreeing to help, even though he didn’t care much for the missing person.
Profile Image for Sue - Recos and Reads.
404 reviews47 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 24, 2026
Bestselling author and Ohio University professor Emmet Maze is riding high having left his troubled past behind, until Jenn Newlin arrives seeking help to find her missing stepfather. Her striking resemblance to Kaya, Emmet’s first love from the 1970s, brings back old memories.

As Emmet investigates the disappearance, he uncovers a dangerous mix of murder, fraud and organised crime. But the deeper he digs, the more shocking the revelations become, making him face old memories and some tough choices.

The novel brings together a long-lost romance, secrets from the past and a mystery that takes a dangerous turn. With 1970s America as its setting, it demonstrates how the changing times influence the characters and the decisions they made and the ways those choices impact later life.
Profile Image for Chelsie.
1,660 reviews
November 11, 2026
Emmet has never really gotten over or forgotten his first real love. It was a whirlwind romance of three years until she decided her ex was the marrying type and walked out the door to never look back. Emmet has made a name for himself chasing stories that are intriguing as well as mysterious.

When decades later Kaya's daughter asks for him to help find her father, Kaya's husband who has gone missing he can't turn her down. He has found others who were missing, how hard can it be to find the golden boy football star from their high school that stole his love? As Emmet and Kaya search for Reese, history unfolds and we find out the reason Kaya left, the life they have both lived since, the secrets they’ve held, and what has brought them to this point in life with how Reese and Kaya got into the mess they are in.

I really enjoyed all the different characters that brought this together and the historical story of their past, their families pasts and that you never really forget your first love. Thank you to the author and publisher for the complementary novel and to Suzy Approved Book Tours for the tour invite. This review is of my own opinion and accord.
Profile Image for Debbie Rozier.
1,527 reviews96 followers
November 4, 2026
I enjoyed the fact that the book begins with a missing person but then we go back in time to 1978 to find out more about the main character’s, Emmet, relationship with a woman he has never been able to get over.

The book also has an element of a thriller as we go back to 2012 to try to figure out what happened to the missing man. That part is quite fast moving.

Finally, this book is steeped in family drama. Emmet’s lost love, Kaya, is the person with the missing husband. Kaya also has tons of baggage with her family business and her husband.
Profile Image for Sohana Nasrin.
140 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 19, 2026
A bitter sweet love story wrapped in a historical mystery. As a journalism professor, I'm immediately drawn to a novel featuring a journalist-turned-professor whose past comes knocking on his office door! I love the premise of a decades-old romance colliding with a present-day mystery. Set against the backdrop of post-Vietnam America, the story explores lost love, second chances, buried secrets, and the complicated choices that shape our lives. The combination of historical fiction, emotional storytelling, and a dangerous investigation makes this particularly intriguing to me. I'm especially interested in how the novel connects personal history with the larger social changes of the 1970s.
Profile Image for Lauren Hanstine.
47 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 27, 2026
Coming from a person who went to OU, then taught in the area for 5 years after, I LOVED this book.

Mr. Golden did such a great job including local restaurants and streets and hospitals even! It was fantastic and I loved getting to be back in Athens, even if I wasn’t really there.

The plot of the story was also great, and I was immediately engrossed! Lots of little twists and turns to keep me reading!

Thank you so much to NetGalley for the advanced copy to read and review!!!
Profile Image for Annie.
5,035 reviews93 followers
November 14, 2026
Originally posted on my blog Nonstop Reader.

A Girl from Ohio is a star-crossed bittersweet love story wrapped around a cold-case by Peter Golden. Released 27th Oct 2026 by Amazon on their Lake Union imprint, it's 381 pages and is available in hardcover, paperback, audio, and ebook formats. It's worth noting that the ebook format has a handy interactive table of contents as well as interactive links throughout. For Kindle+ subscribers, this book is currently included in the K+ subscription library to borrow and read for free.

Well written and engaging as well as bittersweet, the author explores lost chances, lost love, youth (and the arrogance and often bewildering emotions that come with it), and how choices indelibly mark our lives. The main character is an intelligent professor of journalism who is drawn into an investigation when "the one that got away", his long-ago love comes back into his life tangentially. The story is told through a dual-timeline third person perspective.

He's tenacious, resourceful, moral, and compassionate, and as the story unfolds and he uncovers more of the bigger picture from decades ago and its impact on the current time, the story does become quite convoluted, so readers should be prepared to bring a healthy suspension of disbelief. A lot of the character motivations are questionable, and the denouement and resolution were surprising.

Clearly the author is intimately familiar with the setting, and for readers familiar with the area (Northern Ohio, including OU and surrounding areas) it will add depth and interest. Content warnings for domestic violence, financial coercion, controlling behavior, financial crime and murder.

The unabridged audiobook has a run time of 9 hours 34 minutes and is capably read by Paul Heitsch. He has a well modulated, neutral, professionally trained voice for the read and does a good job delineating the small cast of characters. Some of his female character voices are a bit breathy/whispery, but not egregiously so. Sound and production quality are high throughout the read.

Three and a half stars. It woulld be a good choice for public or home library acquisition, or possibly as a book club selection or buddy read.

Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher for review purposes.
Profile Image for Donna Krutsinger - Mockingbird Musings.
172 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 21, 2026
Peter Golden's new novel, A Girl from Ohio, is a love story, a story about second chances, and a mystery that will keep you guessing. For good measure, let's throw in some historical fiction flashing back to the 1970s post-Vietnam era on college campuses.

The protagonist, Emmet, has become a best selling author and a highly regarded college professor at Ohio University. This is a far cry from when he was a reporter, scurrying from story to story on the same campus he attended decades ago. Once in a great while, he may think back to Kaya, his college sweetheart of 3 years, but most of the time he's thinking about his next novel. He and Kaya parted their senior year at Ohio U, a choice that bewildered him but was decided by Kaya. Since then, their lives have gone in extremely different directions.

That is why Emmet is taken aback one day when a younger-looking Kaya walks into his college office pleading for his assistance. It turns out that the Kaya doppelgänger is her grown daughter, Jenn, and she's there to beg for Emmet's assistance in finding Reese, who is not only Jenn's father and Kaya's husband, but, at one time, Emmet's nemesis. Jenn has seen all of Emmet's best sellers, which revolve around finding missing persons, on her mother's bookshelves. She's also noticed that the the first two books even contained dedications to her mother.

The investigation into Reese's disappearance proves to be a rocky road that opens many past wounds and leads the reader to multiple shocking surprises.

A Girl From Ohio mixes many genres—some historical fiction, some romance, some thriller, and a lot of mystery. My favorite character actually turned out to be a secondary one—Lily. Lily is a retired policewoman and Emmet's now next door neighbor. She was married to Isaac, Emmet's old college roommate, who recently succumbed to cancer. She is feisty, kind and wise, and an invaluable part to Emmet's current life.

Look for A Girl From Ohio which will hit shelves Oct. 27, 2026. It's a good mix of family secrets, mystery, and intrigue that will keep your interest. Thank you, NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing, for an opportunity to review this ARC.





196 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 18, 2026
Peter Golden’s “A Girl From Ohio,” which a preliminary look at had me thinking was going to be a look back at the tumultuous post-Vietnam times of my young adulthood (and it was to some extent, with a particular turn on Kent State), ended up being more for me a look at the disappointment that later life can prove for a onetime star high school athlete – in this case, Reese, the husband of the titular character, Kaya.
Not that a reader could be expected to feel much sympathy for Reese, with how he vents his frustrations on Kaya, including physically abusing her, though he also has been enough of a father that his daughter by the marriage, Jenn, comes looking for help with his disappearance from the novel’s protagonist, Emmet, whom Jenn knows her mother was “together with” while in college.
Something more than that they were, in fact, to where marriage had even looked to be in the cards, until she suddenly and inexplicably broke off the relationship and went on to marry Reese.
It’s something Emmet has never understood or gotten over, though he has been able to get on with his life enough to marry another woman and become an author of several nonfiction books, including one where he was able to find a runaway – a feat of detective work which has Jenn thinking he could help solve the mystery of her father’s disappearance, the unraveling of which constitutes much of the second half of the novel, with the usual implausibilities and unlikely turns of events which make for why I don’t usually care for mysteries.
Still, if you’re more a mystery fan than I, Golden’s novel is a compelling read, even if I would have liked it to have been more a revisiting of the time of Vietnam which proved so traumatic for me and so many others, including the novel’s Kaya, whose brother was a casualty of the war.








Profile Image for Jazisunray Skillern.
378 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 26, 2026
A Girl from Ohio masterfully blends suspense, nostalgia, and emotional depth. As a bestselling author and esteemed Ohio University professor, Emmet Maze draws readers into the life of a man who seems to have left his troubled past behind, only to be thrust back into its shadows by a desperate plea for help. The arrival of Jenn Newlin, a young woman bearing an uncanny resemblance to Emmet's first love, Kaya, sets off a chain of events that is as gripping as it is poignant.

Peter Golden skillfully weaves together past and present, allowing us to experience the intensity of young love in the turbulent 1970s alongside the high-stakes intrigue of a modern-day investigation. The characters are richly drawn, with Emmet's internal struggle and the complex relationship between Jenn, Kaya, and her missing husband adding layers of complexity to the narrative. The plot unfolds with expertly timed twists, leading the reader through a labyrinth of murder, fraud, and organized crime that keeps the pages turning late into the night.

What truly sets this novel apart is its heart. Beneath the suspense and danger lies a profound meditation on love, regret, and the choices that shape our lives. Emmet's journey is as much about solving a mystery as it is about confronting his own past and discovering what truly matters.

Golden delivers a compelling, unforgettable story that will resonate with readers long after the final page. Highly recommended for anyone who loves literary thrillers with emotional resonance.

Thank you, Peter Golden, Brilliance Audio, and NetGalley for the ARC.
208 reviews1 follower
November 2, 2026
*A Girl from Ohio* brings together the emotional pull of first love and second chances with the suspense of a mystery built around disappearance, crime, and long-buried secrets. Emmet Maze appears to have left his troubled youth behind, becoming a successful author and respected professor. But when Jenn Newlin arrives seeking his help, the resemblance to her mother, Kaya, brings back memories of a relationship that shaped his younger years. Their story from the 1970s adds a meaningful emotional layer to the present-day mystery.

The disappearance of Kaya's husband gives the story an increasingly dangerous direction. What begins as a request for help becomes an investigation that exposes murder, fraud, and organized crime. As Emmet follows the clues, he must confront not only the unresolved emotions connected to Kaya but also revelations that challenge his understanding of the people and events around him. The contrast between his past and present creates an engaging foundation for exploring love, loyalty, truth, and the consequences of choices made long ago.

At 334 pages, *A Girl from Ohio* should appeal to readers who enjoy mysteries with strong character development, complicated relationships, historical context, and unexpected revelations. Its blend of romantic history and criminal suspense offers something for readers who appreciate more than a straightforward investigation. The story's central questions about second chances, family connections, and the lasting influence of the past give it an emotional dimension that complements its suspenseful plot.
638 reviews
November 18, 2026
A Girl from Ohio offers an engaging combination of romance, mystery, and suspense, built around a past relationship that unexpectedly resurfaces decades later. At the center is Emmet Maze, a successful author and professor whose established life takes an unexpected turn when Jenn Newlin arrives seeking his help. Her resemblance to Kaya, the woman Emmet once loved, immediately creates an emotional connection between his past and the mystery unfolding in the present.

One of the story's strongest elements is the history between Emmet and Kaya. Their college romance in post-Vietnam America, shaped by shared ambitions and affection, gives the present-day events emotional weight. Their abrupt separation and Kaya's subsequent marriage leave unanswered questions that make Jenn's arrival especially significant.

The suspense deepens when Emmet becomes involved in the disappearance of Kaya's husband. What begins as a personal request develops into an investigation involving murder, fraud, and organized crime. This shift gives the narrative a gripping dimension, while Emmet's unexpected discoveries and moral test suggest that the consequences of uncovering the truth may be just as significant as finding the missing man.

Overall, A Girl from Ohio promises a compelling reading experience for fans of mystery and fiction that combine emotional relationships with dangerous secrets. Peter Golden brings together first love, unresolved history, and criminal intrigue in a premise that encourages readers to keep turning the pages to discover how the past and present ultimately connect.
Profile Image for Miranda Beystehner.
84 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 23, 2026
This is my first time reading a book by Peter Golden, and I absolutely adored it! Having grown up in Ohio, I was initially drawn to the title, but I really fell in love with the story during Part II, which takes place on the Ohio University campus in the 1970s. We get to meet Emmet and Kaya as they make their way through college and eventually find their way to each other. Kaya is dating her high school sweetheart, the quarterback, while Emmet is trying to find his place in the world of journalism. This part of the story was written so beautifully, and it was incredibly easy to picture it all unfolding.

As the story jumps to more recent times, we’re faced with a mystery that goes far beyond a missing person. Things get a little deep and complicated, but I was avidly following along, trying to figure out what had really happened. As I got closer to the end, I started piecing things together, but that in no way took away from my enjoyment of the story.

All the pieces of this story fit together so nicely, and I was really impressed with Golden’s storytelling. I can’t wait to pick up another one of his books! I would recommend this to anyone who enjoys a little nostalgia, stories set during college days, and a mystery that keeps you guessing.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Lake Union Publishing for providing me with an advance reader copy!
Profile Image for Andrew Langert.
Author 1 book17 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 10, 2026
I received an ARC of this novel through NetGalley.

The girl from Ohio in this story is Kaya. She is a bright, beautiful college student in love with a fine young man named Emmet, who aspires to be a professor and author. Kaya can get any man she wants and the star QB from the football team sets his sights on her. Not only is he a star football player, he also has lots of money. Kaya is faced with the decision. Love or money. She truly loves Emmet, not the football player, but money would solve a lot of immediate problems for her family. What should she choose?

That is the first portion of the book, which is the best part of the book. The story then vaults ahead 30 or so years later and the reader sees the consequences of Kaya’s decision. Her problems are quite serious and her life and the lives of her husband and daughters are at risk.

The characters in this book are excellent, some likable, some not. The college setting for the first part of the book is well-portrayed. The latter part of the book, where the characters are scrambling around to get out of trouble, is less interesting. When all is said and done, the reader’s hope is that everyone eventually gets what they deserve.
Profile Image for Kate - anaris.books.
49 reviews
October 24, 2026
I received A Girl from Ohio from NetGalley.

Kaya and Emmet were college sweethearts: a budding journalist and a brilliant math student who unexpectedly broke up after three years together. Kaya later marries her high school boyfriend, and more than thirty years pass before her daughter contacts Emmet for help when her father disappears. As Emmet investigates, he uncovers a dangerous web of murder, fraud, and organized crime.

The mystery was captivating, and I enjoyed following Emmet as he searched for answers. His role as a middle-aged professor and writer traveling through Europe to unravel a mystery gave me strong Robert Langdon vibes.

My main issue was the characterization. The inner monologues, especially Kaya’s, did not feel very convincing or emotionally layered to me. Her point of view on her sex life and sexuality felt more like an outside interpretation than an authentic female perspective. Several supporting characters also lacked depth, while Emmet was the one character who felt developed.

The audiobook narration did not work as well for me. It felt too monotone.

Overall, this is an intriguing international mystery with a compelling investigation, but the characterization and narration kept me from fully connecting with it.
Profile Image for Linda Zagon.
1,834 reviews235 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 19, 2026
Peter Golden, the Author “A Girl From Ohio” has written an intriguing, intense, and powerful thriller. The Genres for this well-written book are : Historical Fiction, Mystery, Suspense, Thriller, and Romance. The Author vividly describes the various time periods, the locations and scenery, and the dark and dramatic characters. Emmet Maze is a Professor, Author, Journalist, and excels in finding missing people or details. In the current time, the daughter of his former girlfriend from the early 1970’s, comes to Emmet for help in finding her father, and her mother’s husband who has disappeared. Emmet and Kaya were an item for three years, just after the Vietnam War ended. Kaya just ended their relationship and married a former boyfriend. Emmet still feels there is unfinshed business between them.

It seems, Reese, Kaya’s husband owes money to the government, crime syndicates, and many toxic people. These people play dangerous games. There are secrets, betrayals, espionage, dander, threats, kidnapping and murder, I highly recommend this intense criminal thriller.

Profile Image for Dea Farrell.
1,044 reviews8 followers
November 6, 2026
What happens when the past you left behind years ago comes knocking at your door, only to drag you into a dangerous web you didn't see coming? In college, Emmett and Kaya fell in love and had a perfect romance for three years, until one day Kaya abruptly ended it. Years later, Kaya's adult daughter seeks Emmett's help because her father, Kaya's husband, has gone missing. Emmett agrees to help because he never stopped caring for Kaya and hopes to see her again. I thought the first part of the book that took place in the 70s was a whirlwind, but I was wrong; the entire second half of the book was just as, if not more, incredible. This was a twisty thriller filled with secrets, romance, mystery, and suspense. I loved this book so much, from the romance to the thriller aspects. It was historical fiction mixed with the present day, and it kept me hooked. The characters were very well developed and their stories were intriguing. If you like an emotional read that will also keep you on the edge of your seat, this is the perfect book for you.
Profile Image for Jamie.
5 reviews
October 28, 2026
I really enjoyed A Girl from Ohio! The story was engaging, and I especially loved how it moved between different timelines, jumping between the past and present. I thought this added depth to the story and kept me interested throughout.

My only criticism is specifically with the audiobook production, not the novel itself. There were a handful of moments where certain sentences or phrases sounded noticeably different from the surrounding narration, almost as if they had been recorded separately and inserted afterward. The voice sounded similar, but something about the tone or audio quality was slightly off, making those moments feel unnatural and disrupting the flow. It didn't happen often, but it was noticeable enough to pull me out of the story.

Aside from those minor audio inconsistencies, I thought the book itself was excellent! My four-star rating reflects the audiobook experience rather than the quality of the writing or story.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advance audiobook copy in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Book Bench.
849 reviews2 followers
October 28, 2026
Emmet Maze and Kaya fell in love as college students in the seventies, broke up, and built separate lives. Decades later, Kaya's daughter Jenn shows up at Emmet's office asking him to help find her missing father. The author alternates between the college years in post-Vietnam America and the present-day search, and the early romance is strong enough that I cared more about the people than the mystery itself.
The middle gets a bit crowded once the organized crime thread kicks in, and Emmet puts a few pieces together faster than seemed realistic. But the central question stayed interesting to me: what do we owe the people from the parts of our lives we thought were over? (It made me remember a similar situation in my own life where my answer was: nothing, if it means jeopardizing the good life I have now.)
The ending handles the second-chances idea well without overdoing it. Good for readers who like a mystery with a romance at its center.
Profile Image for Susan Ballard (subakkabookstuff).
2,995 reviews106 followers
November 13, 2026

This was a great surprise, with vivid details of the Ohio setting. It's not only full of drama and relationship issues, but it’s also a twisty mystery with fraud, organized crime, and a missing person.

I enjoyed Emmet’s character; he’s an author and a professor, and he never expected his ex-girlfriend Kaya’s daughters to come to him for help in finding their missing father.

Emmet’s amateur investigation is dangerous and intriguing, and another mystery fuels his motivation. Emmet and Kaya’s relationship plays a large part, with a timeline back in the 1970s that lets us see their beginnings. My heart went out to him as I felt he was giving so much, and Kaya had kept so much from him.

🎧 Thank you @brilliancepublishing for the gifted audiobook.
Paul Heitsch’s narration brought the story to life, especially Emmet!


Thank you @suzyapprovedbooktours and @petergoldenwriter for this gifted book.







Profile Image for Heather Button.
2,102 reviews19 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 15, 2026
I requested this audiobook from @netgalley because like the title, I am a girl from Ohio. 🤣

Ohio University professor and writer Emmet is contacted by a girl who looks shockingly like his college love Kaya and asked to help her and her mom (Kaya) find her missing dad. The request opens up a floodgate of memories for Emmet and he's forced to relive their terrible parting, and that Kaya married another man. He moved on with his life and married as well, but she was always the unknown. And now, the two are reunited and working together to find out just what Kaya's husband has been up to.

This was really good. It kept my attention and the story moved along nicely. The narration was done from Emmet's point of view, and was heartbreaking at times. I really enjoyed the references to my home state and the different places there.

⭐⭐⭐⭐
998 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 16, 2026
Not the most popular opinion, but I felt like this book dragged on in places. In other places, it moved quickly and I really enjoyed it. The characters were fine, their interactions felt legit, I thought the story line was interesting. But through parts of the book it just felt like very little was actually happening. I enjoyed the historical parts and references to the Vietnam War era - I thought that was well done and fascinating. I liked that the book switched between two timelines, making it easier to understand who the characters are and why. I think that the book just needed a little more oomph and drama woven throughout the pages - pieces of it really worked and others just felt slow and kind of forced. If you are looking for a book that has history, second chance romance, and some mystery and intrigue, give this one a try. Thank you netgalley for my advanced reader copy.
Profile Image for Kayla Thorn.
88 reviews
October 31, 2026
Summary:
Best-selling author Emmett is approached by a young woman who asks him to look for her father. This woman is the daughter of his college sweetheart Kaya. The more Emmett digs into this mystery the more complicated things become.

Read if you like
-historical mystery
-romance interwoven into a mystery
-first love, second chances

My thoughts:
Unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me. I thought that Paul Heitsch was a great narrator. The mystery part, while somewhat predictable in my opinion, was interesting and it picked up in the second half of the book so I did enjoy the second half more. Unfortunately, I really did not care for Kaya or the love story between her and Emmett and since it made up a large portion of the book it was hard for me to get past. Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for the advanced audio copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Profile Image for Emily Grimm.
107 reviews
November 4, 2026
Holy cow! Originally, I requested this book purely because, well... I'm also a girl from Ohio! And I'm SO glad I did because this story had me feeling ALL the emotions.

I loved the tender, safe kind of love between Emmet and Kaya, as well as the special bond between Emily and Emmet. There was so much heart woven into this story.

Suspenseful, dramatic (in all the best ways), emotional, and a beautiful love story all rolled into one. I was completely invested!

And Peter, THANK YOU for all the Ohio details that made this book even more special! The mentions of Kroger, Jackie O's, Ohio towns, local newspapers, and all those familiar Ohio references made me smile. It was such a beautiful and authentic capture of Ohio, and I absolutely loved seeing my home state represented throughout the story.

This Ohio girl is officially a fan, and I cannot wait to read more of Peter Golden's books!
322 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 20, 2026
Having relatives who live in Ohio where this story takes place intrigued me. Beginning in the later years of The Vietnam War , the readers meets college students who are navigating those tumultous times. Emmet, a published author and professor, is approached by the daughter of his first love from his college undergraduate years. She is trying to locate her father who has disappeared. But as he helps her, he reconnects with people in his past (including Kyra, his exgirlfriend who is married to the missing man). In his search, murders occur, secret fraud accounts are found and he encounters some nasty people with ties to organized crime. A thriller of a book, I am anxious to read more books from this author.
Profile Image for Heather~ Nature.books.and.coffee.
1,314 reviews297 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 3, 2026
This was such a great mystery. I was immediately pulled in by the author's writing. Emmett, a published author and a college professor, gets an unexpected visit from Jenn, who is the daughter of his ex-girlfriend, Kaya, whom he dated in the 70’s as college students. Jenn is asking for his help with trying to find her father, Reese. I really enjoyed the writing and plot. There's mystery, and suspense to pull you in. And the unraveling of secrets comes to light, and some really good surprises too. This is quite a compelling and fast paced read. If you enjoy Thrillers, then I definitely think you should check this out.

Thank you to the author, publisher, netgalley, and Suzy approved book tours for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Stephanie Vantell.
54 reviews
October 27, 2026
The story follows Emmit Maze, an esteemed author and professor at Ohio University. One day, he is approached by the daughter of his former girlfriend, Kaya, who asks for his help in finding her missing father.

Told through alternating timelines, the story explores Kaya and Emmit’s lives from college and beyond. It’s filled with well-developed, likable characters and is a tale of secrets and forgiveness, second chances, and the search for truth.

Born and raised in Ohio, I thoroughly enjoyed the nostalgia this story brought back for me. I had the pleasure of listening to the audiobook, narrated by Paul Heitsch.

Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for the ARC!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 47 reviews