What do you think?
Rate this book
Unintended Cultivator #9
Unintended Cultivator: Volume Nine
In the Jianghu, there is only the illusion of peace…Sen has returned from the capital and reluctantly begun the work of building a sect. Yet the endless politics, rivalries, and logistical burdens of leadership weigh heavily on a man who once answered to no one. Every day pulls him deeper into a life he never truly wanted.
Only the looming war with the spirit beasts keeps him from abandoning it all.
Yet, not even distance can allow someone as famous as Judgment’s Gale to go undisturbed for long. Emissaries from sects begin to intrude on his small corner of the world. Some come with benign intentions, while others come to put the former wandering cultivator in his place.
Once, Sen could simply walk away. Now he has a sect to protect and a daughter whose safety he will defend at any cost. Sen may find that war of a different kind is unavoidable…
Only the looming war with the spirit beasts keeps him from abandoning it all.
Yet, not even distance can allow someone as famous as Judgment’s Gale to go undisturbed for long. Emissaries from sects begin to intrude on his small corner of the world. Some come with benign intentions, while others come to put the former wandering cultivator in his place.
Once, Sen could simply walk away. Now he has a sect to protect and a daughter whose safety he will defend at any cost. Sen may find that war of a different kind is unavoidable…
425 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 14, 2026
About the author
Eric Dontigney
30 books212 followersRaised in Western New York, Eric Dontigney has lived in New Mexico, Florida, Wisconsin, Virginia, Pennsylvania and Tennessee. He currently resides near Dayton, OH. He is a fan of photo-realism paintings, coffee and well-made food. He has a Bachelor's degree in Philosophy.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews
July 16, 2026
Too wordy.
Too wordy. Too much self reflection. Hardly any action. Just talk talk talk talk endlessly. This has to be the worst in the series. Time jumps and more time jumps. Plus. Plus! He is still NOT a nascent soul cultavator!
Too wordy. Too much self reflection. Hardly any action. Just talk talk talk talk endlessly. This has to be the worst in the series. Time jumps and more time jumps. Plus. Plus! He is still NOT a nascent soul cultavator!
July 15, 2026
This was kind of a weird one for me. Most stories, the protagonist struggles against an antagonist or two, barely survives, but comes out stronger.
That's not really what happened here. There was never a point where it seemed Sen would be defeated, no time when he's cornered and desperate, no crucible by which to refine himself.
Furthermore, the title has the word "cultivator" right in it, and there isn't an single line of actual cultivation in this book.
What it does have an overabundance of is unnecessary narration. Sometimes two entire pages of narration between two lines of dialogue in the middle of a conversation. I had to flip back to remind myself of what they were even talking about. A lot of rambling and moaning going on.
I'm not sure where the five star reviews are coming from. It felt like the author didn't really know where the book was going to end up and just sort of pantsed it to the end. Frankly a little frustrating.
That's not really what happened here. There was never a point where it seemed Sen would be defeated, no time when he's cornered and desperate, no crucible by which to refine himself.
Furthermore, the title has the word "cultivator" right in it, and there isn't an single line of actual cultivation in this book.
What it does have an overabundance of is unnecessary narration. Sometimes two entire pages of narration between two lines of dialogue in the middle of a conversation. I had to flip back to remind myself of what they were even talking about. A lot of rambling and moaning going on.
I'm not sure where the five star reviews are coming from. It felt like the author didn't really know where the book was going to end up and just sort of pantsed it to the end. Frankly a little frustrating.
July 17, 2026
Newest Fav Series, but it’s in a Slump
It’s happened with the past couple, and as with this those this book in the series has the same issue. The dialogue and actual events of the book would only fill a handful of pages. The majority of the book is extremely bloated with Sens thoughts monologue in a constantly repeated nature. While the writing style of the series has always been a heavy hand on the MCs internal dialogue, lately it’s become almost the entirety of the book. Advancement has haulted, even the appearance of clues or the search thereof. Actual story events have haulted, just one per book now that represents 25% of the book with the rest being bloated internal dialogue- often repeated maxims. I hope this series returns to its roots in the next book
It’s happened with the past couple, and as with this those this book in the series has the same issue. The dialogue and actual events of the book would only fill a handful of pages. The majority of the book is extremely bloated with Sens thoughts monologue in a constantly repeated nature. While the writing style of the series has always been a heavy hand on the MCs internal dialogue, lately it’s become almost the entirety of the book. Advancement has haulted, even the appearance of clues or the search thereof. Actual story events have haulted, just one per book now that represents 25% of the book with the rest being bloated internal dialogue- often repeated maxims. I hope this series returns to its roots in the next book
July 18, 2026
The pace at which this series is advancing diminishes with each book released. It's still fun to watch an OP MC do OP things, but I could do with a little less hand-wringing. After all, Sen must be in his seventies by now. Surely his moral framework is well established and tested. At this point, his self-doubt comes off as moral theatrics rather than honest hesitation.
July 23, 2026
Unintended Cultivator: Volume Nine by Eric Dontigney marks a pivotal transition in the expansive progression fantasy saga, shifting the narrative focus from solitary wandering to the complex, heavy burdens of sect leadership. After the intense political maneuverings and chaotic events in the capital during the previous installment, the protagonist, Lu Sen, returns to the Jianghu hoping for a semblance of peace. However, he quickly discovers that peace in the martial world is nothing more than a fragile illusion. Sen is forced to reluctantly begin the monumental task of building his own sect from the ground up, a decision driven by necessity rather than ambition. For a man who has spent most of his life answering to absolutely no one, this new reality is a jarring and deeply uncomfortable adjustment.
The narrative dives deep into the logistical and political nightmares of establishing a new power in a world ruled by ancient traditions. Sen finds himself bogged down by endless rivalries, administrative burdens, and the suffocating weight of leadership. Every single day seems to pull him further away from the freedom of the open road and deeper into a rigid life he never truly wanted. The story does an excellent job of highlighting this internal conflict, showcasing the frustration of a supremely powerful warrior suddenly forced to deal with the mundane details of managing a growing faction. The only thing keeping Sen from abandoning the exhausting project and fleeing back into the untamed wilds is the terrifying, looming threat of an all-out war with the spirit beasts—a catastrophic event that requires a fortified front to survive.
Despite his desire to remain isolated in his small corner of the world, Sen’s fearsome reputation makes anonymity impossible. Known throughout the martial world by the intimidating moniker "Judgment's Gale," his fame acts as a double-edged sword. While it instills fear, it also acts as a beacon for the ambitious and the arrogant. Emissaries from various established sects begin to encroach on his territory. Some delegations arrive with benign intentions, seeking alliances or attempting to gauge the strength of this rising power. Others, however, are far more hostile. Offended by the idea that a former wandering cultivator dares to elevate himself to the status of a sect leader, they come specifically to put Sen in his place.
In the past, Sen’s reaction to such blatant disrespect would have been swift, brutal, and definitive. Raised by a trio of infinitely powerful, ancient cultivators who taught him supreme martial skills but offered little in the way of social grace, Sen’s default solution to conflict has often been extreme violence. However, Volume Nine challenges him to evolve past those tendencies. He can no longer simply draw his blade, slaughter his arrogant enemies, and wander away. Retaliation now has widespread consequences. He is tethered to a physical location and responsible for the lives of his disciples. Every action he takes reflects on his newfound sect, forcing him to engage in the political posturing and diplomatic maneuvering he has despised since his days as a destitute street urchin.
The emotional core of this volume revolves heavily around Sen’s adopted mortal daughter, Aia. She is the primary anchor keeping his humanity intact and the driving force behind his determination to build a safe haven. The world of cultivators is notoriously dismissive and cruel toward mortals, treating them as little more than expendable dirt. Sen’s fierce love for Aia highlights his underlying compassion and stands in stark contrast to the cold nature of his peers. He is acutely aware that if he were to walk away from his responsibilities, Aia would be left vulnerable to the vindictive enemies he has made over the years. His protective instincts push him to compromise his own freedom, emphasizing the profound sacrifices that come with parenthood.
As the story progresses, Dontigney masterfully explores the moral ambiguity of Sen’s journey. The protagonist struggles with intense self-reflection, agonizing over the fact that in his quest to protect his loved ones, he is slowly adopting the ruthless tactics of the arrogant sect members he grew up hating. He is forced to make heavy compromises, weighing the cost of his soul against the safety of his people. The hypocrisy of his actions weighs on his conscience, providing a rich, character-driven narrative that elevates the book beyond standard progression fantasy tropes.
Ultimately, Unintended Cultivator: Volume Nine sets the stage for a massive paradigm shift in the series. While Sen desperately tries to manage the internal politics of his nascent sect and the external pressures of visiting dignitaries, the shadow of the spirit beast war grows darker. The book builds a slow-burning tension, making it clear that Sen cannot avoid the coming conflicts through martial prowess alone. He must step up, embrace the mantle of a true leader, and prepare for an unavoidable war of a different kind.
The narrative dives deep into the logistical and political nightmares of establishing a new power in a world ruled by ancient traditions. Sen finds himself bogged down by endless rivalries, administrative burdens, and the suffocating weight of leadership. Every single day seems to pull him further away from the freedom of the open road and deeper into a rigid life he never truly wanted. The story does an excellent job of highlighting this internal conflict, showcasing the frustration of a supremely powerful warrior suddenly forced to deal with the mundane details of managing a growing faction. The only thing keeping Sen from abandoning the exhausting project and fleeing back into the untamed wilds is the terrifying, looming threat of an all-out war with the spirit beasts—a catastrophic event that requires a fortified front to survive.
Despite his desire to remain isolated in his small corner of the world, Sen’s fearsome reputation makes anonymity impossible. Known throughout the martial world by the intimidating moniker "Judgment's Gale," his fame acts as a double-edged sword. While it instills fear, it also acts as a beacon for the ambitious and the arrogant. Emissaries from various established sects begin to encroach on his territory. Some delegations arrive with benign intentions, seeking alliances or attempting to gauge the strength of this rising power. Others, however, are far more hostile. Offended by the idea that a former wandering cultivator dares to elevate himself to the status of a sect leader, they come specifically to put Sen in his place.
In the past, Sen’s reaction to such blatant disrespect would have been swift, brutal, and definitive. Raised by a trio of infinitely powerful, ancient cultivators who taught him supreme martial skills but offered little in the way of social grace, Sen’s default solution to conflict has often been extreme violence. However, Volume Nine challenges him to evolve past those tendencies. He can no longer simply draw his blade, slaughter his arrogant enemies, and wander away. Retaliation now has widespread consequences. He is tethered to a physical location and responsible for the lives of his disciples. Every action he takes reflects on his newfound sect, forcing him to engage in the political posturing and diplomatic maneuvering he has despised since his days as a destitute street urchin.
The emotional core of this volume revolves heavily around Sen’s adopted mortal daughter, Aia. She is the primary anchor keeping his humanity intact and the driving force behind his determination to build a safe haven. The world of cultivators is notoriously dismissive and cruel toward mortals, treating them as little more than expendable dirt. Sen’s fierce love for Aia highlights his underlying compassion and stands in stark contrast to the cold nature of his peers. He is acutely aware that if he were to walk away from his responsibilities, Aia would be left vulnerable to the vindictive enemies he has made over the years. His protective instincts push him to compromise his own freedom, emphasizing the profound sacrifices that come with parenthood.
As the story progresses, Dontigney masterfully explores the moral ambiguity of Sen’s journey. The protagonist struggles with intense self-reflection, agonizing over the fact that in his quest to protect his loved ones, he is slowly adopting the ruthless tactics of the arrogant sect members he grew up hating. He is forced to make heavy compromises, weighing the cost of his soul against the safety of his people. The hypocrisy of his actions weighs on his conscience, providing a rich, character-driven narrative that elevates the book beyond standard progression fantasy tropes.
Ultimately, Unintended Cultivator: Volume Nine sets the stage for a massive paradigm shift in the series. While Sen desperately tries to manage the internal politics of his nascent sect and the external pressures of visiting dignitaries, the shadow of the spirit beast war grows darker. The book builds a slow-burning tension, making it clear that Sen cannot avoid the coming conflicts through martial prowess alone. He must step up, embrace the mantle of a true leader, and prepare for an unavoidable war of a different kind.
July 21, 2026
Even with this being one of the weaker outings for this series, this was still a tremendously fun read. It is more than likely that any issues I had with it will be erased when the next book is out and this book becomes part of a binge of the entire series, where the beginnings and endings of each story blur into each other.
That being said, there are issues with this book, starting with the fact that this novel felt a little like filler. There's not much forward progression here. It's more of a novel in a holding pattern, giving Sen (and likely the author) a bit of time to get comfortable with just where he is in the story and to make peace with a few outstanding internal character conflicts in Sen himself. After the breakneck pace and massive change of the last book, I think this series needed this book to try and settle itself out again, and remind itself of what story is being told.
A consequence of this is that there was a bit too much navel-gazing for my tastes. We spend a lot of time in Sen's hed as he tries to figure out for himself just who he is a person, how he feels about the actions he has taken on his journey so far, and what he wants to do going forward. I would love to see this play out more organically through the story rather than through exposition, but it wasn't so jarring as to really put me off.
On the plus side, there is plenty of chance to see an OP main character live up to the potential he has been working towards for so long. Sen has finally reached the stage where he doesn't just feel like an advanced student who is still facing challenges that are beyond his level. Here he gets a chance to show just how close to the peak of cultivation he is already, and just how few threats he needs to be worried about. Some people may find this lack of physical conflict off-putting, but honestly I find it cathartic to finally get some chance to revel in the rewards of what this series has been leading towards for so long.
Overall, it's not the strongest outing in the series, but it's far from a major issue. It was enjoyable enough for what it was, and as previously mentioned, many issues fade away when this book becomes just another entry in the much larger story.
That being said, there are issues with this book, starting with the fact that this novel felt a little like filler. There's not much forward progression here. It's more of a novel in a holding pattern, giving Sen (and likely the author) a bit of time to get comfortable with just where he is in the story and to make peace with a few outstanding internal character conflicts in Sen himself. After the breakneck pace and massive change of the last book, I think this series needed this book to try and settle itself out again, and remind itself of what story is being told.
A consequence of this is that there was a bit too much navel-gazing for my tastes. We spend a lot of time in Sen's hed as he tries to figure out for himself just who he is a person, how he feels about the actions he has taken on his journey so far, and what he wants to do going forward. I would love to see this play out more organically through the story rather than through exposition, but it wasn't so jarring as to really put me off.
On the plus side, there is plenty of chance to see an OP main character live up to the potential he has been working towards for so long. Sen has finally reached the stage where he doesn't just feel like an advanced student who is still facing challenges that are beyond his level. Here he gets a chance to show just how close to the peak of cultivation he is already, and just how few threats he needs to be worried about. Some people may find this lack of physical conflict off-putting, but honestly I find it cathartic to finally get some chance to revel in the rewards of what this series has been leading towards for so long.
Overall, it's not the strongest outing in the series, but it's far from a major issue. It was enjoyable enough for what it was, and as previously mentioned, many issues fade away when this book becomes just another entry in the much larger story.
July 18, 2026
This is one of those rare times when I wish half-star ratings were available. Three stars feels too harsh given how much I enjoy this series as a whole, but four feels too generous for a book that compares so poorly with most of the others.
What works is that I still enjoy this world, so I’m always happy to revisit it. Ai is charming, the dynamic within Sen’s adoptive family remains great, and I like the premise of Sen building his academy and sect.
What doesn’t work is that so little of consequence happens. I don’t mind slice-of-life, but it still needs to be interesting. Most of this feels like fairly pointless filler intended to get us to the spirit beast war.
Even that might have worked for me, though, were it not for the much larger problem: the near-constant philosophizing about killing people. It has been going on for nine books now, and the “woe is me, why does everyone keep making me murder them?” routine has thoroughly run its course. It is especially grating here, when Sen’s anguish concerns committing mass murder on a truly monumental scale, based on the thinnest of pretexts and carried out in perhaps the most heinous and indiscriminate way possible.
The author displays an almost colossal disconnect from reality. At one point, while preparing for his act of mass murder, Sen accidentally kills two people ahead of schedule. He then feels guilty about framing their deaths as the result of a lovers’ quarrel because he doesn’t want to damage their reputations.
I mean, wtf? You are about to murder everyone they know, and your moral hang-up is that their friends might think poorly of them for the final day of their lives?
The entire thing feels weirdly sociopathic.
Then again, I felt almost as strongly about how bad book four was, and the series redeemed itself completely in the books that followed. Here’s hoping the spirit beast war requires less clarification of the author’s views on the victimhood of murderhobos and allows the series to return to form.
What works is that I still enjoy this world, so I’m always happy to revisit it. Ai is charming, the dynamic within Sen’s adoptive family remains great, and I like the premise of Sen building his academy and sect.
What doesn’t work is that so little of consequence happens. I don’t mind slice-of-life, but it still needs to be interesting. Most of this feels like fairly pointless filler intended to get us to the spirit beast war.
Even that might have worked for me, though, were it not for the much larger problem: the near-constant philosophizing about killing people. It has been going on for nine books now, and the “woe is me, why does everyone keep making me murder them?” routine has thoroughly run its course. It is especially grating here, when Sen’s anguish concerns committing mass murder on a truly monumental scale, based on the thinnest of pretexts and carried out in perhaps the most heinous and indiscriminate way possible.
The author displays an almost colossal disconnect from reality. At one point, while preparing for his act of mass murder, Sen accidentally kills two people ahead of schedule. He then feels guilty about framing their deaths as the result of a lovers’ quarrel because he doesn’t want to damage their reputations.
I mean, wtf? You are about to murder everyone they know, and your moral hang-up is that their friends might think poorly of them for the final day of their lives?
The entire thing feels weirdly sociopathic.
Then again, I felt almost as strongly about how bad book four was, and the series redeemed itself completely in the books that followed. Here’s hoping the spirit beast war requires less clarification of the author’s views on the victimhood of murderhobos and allows the series to return to form.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I never tire of reading this amazing cultivation series, and this, book 9, kept me reading through the night. Sen is becoming ever more involved in his sect, even though he still insists it be called an academy, as he hates sects. These usually thrive on violence and hunting for power. One of the rules Sen set down for any cultivators visiting his sect is that the mortals in his town are to be respected, so when a group of cultivators from the Twisted Blade sect arrive and start causing havoc in town his ire is unleashed and they are all killed. Sen knows that this will cause a retaliation from the rest of the sect who might have even used the idiots to have a reason to attack Sen's Deep Wilds sect. So Sen decides he won't wait for this to happen, but to take the war to them. Sen now has his people to look out for, grandmother Lu, Falling Leaf, and Glimmer of Night, but most of all his beloved daughter Ai, and he intends to make sure no harm comes to his family and friends. This book is brutal in that Sen takes on the mantle of Judgement's Gale once again, as he obliterates a whole sect overnight. He takes no pleasure in doing this, as he knows that he will have to pay for his crimes in his next life, but what needs to be done has to be done. Apart from this a war which was even worse than a sect war was threatening them, and this was a threat coming from the spirit beasts and their King who was out to attack humanity, be this mortals and cultivators alike. I love that Sen has grown such a kind heart, and no matter how little he thinks of himself, I think he is a very responsible and kind cultivator, and I love the way he interacts with mortals especially his daughter Ai. I look forward to book 10 which I am sure will be another epic read.
July 23, 2026
This is the ninth book in the Unintended Cultivator series. I have been enjoying this series even though for the last few books I’ve been waiting for them to be written. (Life is so much better when they’re already all out when you discover them.) I’ve really enjoyed this series. The early growth was pretty fast and one of the things that these longer cultivation series have against them is that there’s this big rush to super powerful and then the story balance just isn’t there anymore because you need world altering danger for every challenge. Dontigney has found that balance fairly well. The growth continues, but so do the challenges.
In this book Sen has come back from the Capital, where most of Book 8 was set. He’s finally decided that his academy can be a sect and starts making some real decisions around that. One of the repercussions of this is that other sects are noticing and getting challenges. There’s a lot of introspection in this book as we go through this and I really enjoyed Sen working through this.
The big ending for this book takes my opinion of Dontigney up about three notches in terms of authorship. I’ve definitely enjoyed him as an author, his characters, his stories, the action and interactions but with this entry his scenes and introspection managed to take myself to a new level of emotional connection to the story. Or maybe to the character. I was left thoughtful, a little bit down but also a bit happy. It’s not super common that a book will give me the feels and often this is caused by being overdramatic (or traumatic) to the point of feeling manipulated. But this time the emotions came on their own, subtly, I wasn’t even sure I was feeling exactly what the author wanted. This was refreshing. This takes some serious capability in your craft. Really enjoyed that about this book.
Obviously I’m not going to stop a series after the ninth entry but I really enjoyed this book, in whole new ways, if you will. I’m definitely here for the long haul.
In this book Sen has come back from the Capital, where most of Book 8 was set. He’s finally decided that his academy can be a sect and starts making some real decisions around that. One of the repercussions of this is that other sects are noticing and getting challenges. There’s a lot of introspection in this book as we go through this and I really enjoyed Sen working through this.
The big ending for this book takes my opinion of Dontigney up about three notches in terms of authorship. I’ve definitely enjoyed him as an author, his characters, his stories, the action and interactions but with this entry his scenes and introspection managed to take myself to a new level of emotional connection to the story. Or maybe to the character. I was left thoughtful, a little bit down but also a bit happy. It’s not super common that a book will give me the feels and often this is caused by being overdramatic (or traumatic) to the point of feeling manipulated. But this time the emotions came on their own, subtly, I wasn’t even sure I was feeling exactly what the author wanted. This was refreshing. This takes some serious capability in your craft. Really enjoyed that about this book.
Obviously I’m not going to stop a series after the ninth entry but I really enjoyed this book, in whole new ways, if you will. I’m definitely here for the long haul.
July 21, 2026
Disappointed. Way too much "musings" from different characters that was more of a rehash than moved the story forward. The books main event, I was led to believe, was a potential world ending war to take place but turned out to be a carrot that got lost somehow. With not much really happening for the first 60% of the book I was loosing hope for it. There was a stretch of chapters that prepped for what turned out to be the big event in the book that did little to keep me interested. The results were expected and I enjoy the how it played out. This installment was not like the previous books. I enjoyed them and looked forward to this one. On the whole - I was disappointed. Sorry, I don't usually give such a low rating but I was compelled to do so.
July 14, 2026
EPIC
In many other stories the events in this would be a few chapters. A stop in a story arch.
This was sincerely writing about choosing to destroy a Sect, with all the consideration, feeling, depth, and humanity intact. It is thoughtful, emotional, and overdue.
It does not preach; there is neither glory nor condemnation. It does not ask you to agree or disagree.
Thanks Eric. It feels like you read these stories and liked them yet felt something was missing, then found it in you to try to do it better. You are doing it.
Much appreciation.
In many other stories the events in this would be a few chapters. A stop in a story arch.
This was sincerely writing about choosing to destroy a Sect, with all the consideration, feeling, depth, and humanity intact. It is thoughtful, emotional, and overdue.
It does not preach; there is neither glory nor condemnation. It does not ask you to agree or disagree.
Thanks Eric. It feels like you read these stories and liked them yet felt something was missing, then found it in you to try to do it better. You are doing it.
Much appreciation.
July 15, 2026
inevitable
At a certain point, as series grow longer and the MC stronger, the story slows. Even when he’s not dragging half a dozen wives and an entire army around, the MC’s power and reach make his choices more impactful. And so he spends longer considering his actions than when he was barely staggering from disaster to opportunity to enlightenment.
This dragged a bit for me, as the MC *re*-considered every decision at least twice.
But I still enjoyed it, and will buy volume 10 when it becomes available.
At a certain point, as series grow longer and the MC stronger, the story slows. Even when he’s not dragging half a dozen wives and an entire army around, the MC’s power and reach make his choices more impactful. And so he spends longer considering his actions than when he was barely staggering from disaster to opportunity to enlightenment.
This dragged a bit for me, as the MC *re*-considered every decision at least twice.
But I still enjoyed it, and will buy volume 10 when it becomes available.
July 16, 2026
A little disappointing
Not enough action for 400+ pages. A lot of boring introspection... Enough that I skipped pages and didn't miss their content. Honestly, Eric is a fantastic writer and I've enjoyed the first several books. There are two important plots in this story and only one came to fruition. Book 8 was starting to slow also, but this is worse. If the trend continues, book 11 won't be worth reading. I guess we will see how number 10 goes. Book 9 probably rates 3 stars, but the overall series is good enough to warrant the extra star.
Not enough action for 400+ pages. A lot of boring introspection... Enough that I skipped pages and didn't miss their content. Honestly, Eric is a fantastic writer and I've enjoyed the first several books. There are two important plots in this story and only one came to fruition. Book 8 was starting to slow also, but this is worse. If the trend continues, book 11 won't be worth reading. I guess we will see how number 10 goes. Book 9 probably rates 3 stars, but the overall series is good enough to warrant the extra star.
July 23, 2026
Existential crisis
This entire book was basically Sen having an existential crisis and self reflection, again. When this series started, Sen represented the best that a cultivator could be; however, throughout the series he has become everything he despised about cultivators. He then deludes himself to justify his actions or wanton slaughter and destruction.
I suppose one thing this series does get across, we are all products of the world we live in. The best of intentions do not survive contact with the real world, and it’s ugly.
This entire book was basically Sen having an existential crisis and self reflection, again. When this series started, Sen represented the best that a cultivator could be; however, throughout the series he has become everything he despised about cultivators. He then deludes himself to justify his actions or wanton slaughter and destruction.
I suppose one thing this series does get across, we are all products of the world we live in. The best of intentions do not survive contact with the real world, and it’s ugly.
July 24, 2026
Getting a little tired and long in the tooth
I really like this series initially. It was a fun read even with the little mistakes attributed to a Indie author. Now... not so much. The books now read more like A.I. generated filler and that is what is killing me. Way too much mental chatter filler that is duplicated throughout the book. I eventually just fast forward until they quit the meandering silent monolog. I will have to drop the series if this continues onward into the next series of books. A.I. has become a crutch that destroys creativity and good writing.
I really like this series initially. It was a fun read even with the little mistakes attributed to a Indie author. Now... not so much. The books now read more like A.I. generated filler and that is what is killing me. Way too much mental chatter filler that is duplicated throughout the book. I eventually just fast forward until they quit the meandering silent monolog. I will have to drop the series if this continues onward into the next series of books. A.I. has become a crutch that destroys creativity and good writing.
August 7, 2026
An endless slog
To quote the main character "Feeling guilty over something I couldn’t avoid is pointless."
Using that metric, 80% of this book was pointless. The story was awful. The author gave the main character no options except overwhelming destruction, but made him question it for the majority of the book. I will not continue with this series. It seems strange to stop reading a series where you've invested 9 books-worth of time in, but I never want to revisit this world again.
To quote the main character "Feeling guilty over something I couldn’t avoid is pointless."
Using that metric, 80% of this book was pointless. The story was awful. The author gave the main character no options except overwhelming destruction, but made him question it for the majority of the book. I will not continue with this series. It seems strange to stop reading a series where you've invested 9 books-worth of time in, but I never want to revisit this world again.
July 15, 2026
I really enjoy this series...
And the 'bloopers' were hysterical!! (Hello DH!) However, this book was a bit existential emo. I get it, Sen was pushed to the limit. And if you have the power, you should always ask yourself if you're doing something for the right reason. But if someone or something threatened my family that way and I had the power to end them, they would no longer be a problem.
And the 'bloopers' were hysterical!! (Hello DH!) However, this book was a bit existential emo. I get it, Sen was pushed to the limit. And if you have the power, you should always ask yourself if you're doing something for the right reason. But if someone or something threatened my family that way and I had the power to end them, they would no longer be a problem.
July 14, 2026
Title: Sects and Violence
Content Ratings: Language – PG13; Violence – R; Other – MA
There's not a lot to say at book 9 other than that this still remains one of my favorite series. This one gets a little more violent in unsettling ways as the realities of being Judgment's Gale and starting the not-a-sect manifest. As usual, hard to put down and left me ready for more.
Content Ratings: Language – PG13; Violence – R; Other – MA
There's not a lot to say at book 9 other than that this still remains one of my favorite series. This one gets a little more violent in unsettling ways as the realities of being Judgment's Gale and starting the not-a-sect manifest. As usual, hard to put down and left me ready for more.
July 15, 2026
great book, great addition to the series
Got the book the day it dropped and read it the same day. The author had a gift for writing dialog and it’s great to see the MC grow as a person. All in all, this book is a fun, well crafted addition to the series. Unfortunately now I have to wait until November to read the next one!
Got the book the day it dropped and read it the same day. The author had a gift for writing dialog and it’s great to see the MC grow as a person. All in all, this book is a fun, well crafted addition to the series. Unfortunately now I have to wait until November to read the next one!
July 31, 2026
Unintended Cultivator, Volume 9 of the Unintended Cultivator series, is an ebook I borrowed through Kindle Unlimited (KU). Wow, we got Sen and a whole lot of vengeance on ths side. Don't mess with family or those under Sen's protection. This is a great series--worth waiting for each book to be released.
July 15, 2026
Great read
Love this series. I can honestly say that there is nothing I dislike about this series. Which if you've read any of my other posts, you will know how unusual that statement is.😁
Love this series. I can honestly say that there is nothing I dislike about this series. Which if you've read any of my other posts, you will know how unusual that statement is.😁
July 16, 2026
Awesome Stuff
This book was mostly about our guy advancing to the highest level of body cultivation and the stupid sects that keep challenging him. Of course one sect goes too far, and he has to destroy them. Great Read
This book was mostly about our guy advancing to the highest level of body cultivation and the stupid sects that keep challenging him. Of course one sect goes too far, and he has to destroy them. Great Read
July 18, 2026
Way too much internal debate
Pages and pages and pages and pages and pages and pages and pages of internal debate. I started skipping 3 or 4 pages when the debate started and it worked out fine to just read the response and continue the story.
Pages and pages and pages and pages and pages and pages and pages of internal debate. I started skipping 3 or 4 pages when the debate started and it worked out fine to just read the response and continue the story.
July 21, 2026
I've showered praise on this series for so accurately expressing human feelings and morals and this book does not fall short. Really excited for the next book. I'm wondering if the next book will be the last giving it an even ten. But maybe not I guess we'll see.
July 24, 2026
Good book
What to say love the bloopers ,they had me rolling. It was a amazing book like the whole series so far and a amazing author. I look forward to reading the next book in the series 😀
What to say love the bloopers ,they had me rolling. It was a amazing book like the whole series so far and a amazing author. I look forward to reading the next book in the series 😀
July 26, 2026
Superfluous
The biggest change from the last book is the building of the mc’s rep, one full book for an event that had next to no stakes and is littered with the mc’s puddle deep analysis of the situation and solutions to the problem.
The biggest change from the last book is the building of the mc’s rep, one full book for an event that had next to no stakes and is littered with the mc’s puddle deep analysis of the situation and solutions to the problem.
July 26, 2026
Good, but a lot of repeated inner monologuing
Some moments of brilliance, but this book, more than the previous ones had Sen inner monologuing about the same things, over and over and over again.
Stop stalling out the plot, or advance the monologue through dialogue instead.
Some moments of brilliance, but this book, more than the previous ones had Sen inner monologuing about the same things, over and over and over again.
Stop stalling out the plot, or advance the monologue through dialogue instead.
July 26, 2026
Another fun book
Another fun book in the series that kind of surprised me with Sen not being completely OP. Some good action and it sets the series up for what should be a crazy next book
Another fun book in the series that kind of surprised me with Sen not being completely OP. Some good action and it sets the series up for what should be a crazy next book
August 3, 2026
The major criticisms I have with these books, is the author over writes everything and the constant introspection becomes really tedious. Unfortunately this book is probably the worse so far and at least two hundred pages were really superfluous to the main story.
July 14, 2026
Fanfreakingtastic!
What an amazing book! I absolutely loved this book and such wonderful characters! I can not wait for the next book to come out!
What an amazing book! I absolutely loved this book and such wonderful characters! I can not wait for the next book to come out!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews