What do you think?
Rate this book
Sanctuary Lake Retreat #1
Off the Trail
Off the field, off the grid, and accidentally falling in love…
I’m a professional baseball player—or I was, until I was forced into early retirement. I’m still getting used to the idea of my team heading to the playoffs without me when I total my Lambo—an accident, I swear—and my agent ships me off to a private lakeside retreat in the wilds of Maine to get my head on straight. No phone. No internet. Just trees, stars, and too much time to think about how baseball’s been my whole life since my dad first tossed me a ball.
The only thing keeping me grounded is Blaze, the retreat’s activities director. He’s way too easy to talk to and up for anything. Hiking, fishing, stargazing—somehow we end up doing everything together. And when one of our “activities” turns into an unintentionally date-like candlelit dinner, I realize that maybe dating Blaze is what I’ve wanted all along.
But when I get an unexpected offer from my old team, I have to make a choice. Should I go back to the life I used to know, or is off the trail with Blaze exactly where I’m supposed to be?
Take a trip to Sanctuary Lake, where you can fall off the grid and fall in love. Off The Trail is an accidental dating, low-angst steamy m/m romance with a sexual awakening and cozy lakeside feels.
I’m a professional baseball player—or I was, until I was forced into early retirement. I’m still getting used to the idea of my team heading to the playoffs without me when I total my Lambo—an accident, I swear—and my agent ships me off to a private lakeside retreat in the wilds of Maine to get my head on straight. No phone. No internet. Just trees, stars, and too much time to think about how baseball’s been my whole life since my dad first tossed me a ball.
The only thing keeping me grounded is Blaze, the retreat’s activities director. He’s way too easy to talk to and up for anything. Hiking, fishing, stargazing—somehow we end up doing everything together. And when one of our “activities” turns into an unintentionally date-like candlelit dinner, I realize that maybe dating Blaze is what I’ve wanted all along.
But when I get an unexpected offer from my old team, I have to make a choice. Should I go back to the life I used to know, or is off the trail with Blaze exactly where I’m supposed to be?
Take a trip to Sanctuary Lake, where you can fall off the grid and fall in love. Off The Trail is an accidental dating, low-angst steamy m/m romance with a sexual awakening and cozy lakeside feels.
260 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 16, 2026
About the author
Elle Waters
17 books39 followersFueled by chocolate and canned wine, Elle Waters writes smutty small town romance with guaranteed happy endings. She lives with her family in Connecticut. Sign up for her newsletter to hear about her next release!
Elle loves to hear from readers at elle@ellewatersauthor.com.
Elle loves to hear from readers at elle@ellewatersauthor.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 102 reviews
Review of advance copy
🧢⚾️ This is a book I will, without a doubt, be reading over and over again. 🐶🥾
No AI ✅
Well-written, cozy, low-angst.
The book makes healing and falling in love sound, feel easy.
It certainly was for Blaze and Shawn.
The ease of the sexual awakening in this (from an ex-baseball player, as well) is beautiful, in that, there are 0 issues whatsoever besides a bit of what I would think would be very normal at a very normal time in the story, as well.
I enjoyed how much time the two men spent together on page, even before things progressed between them.
Both MCs (and all the side-characters) were EXTREMELY likable.
Every time I think I like one more, I think of a reason I like the other.
Really though, they’re perfect for each other.
The sexual chemistry between the two is palpable, and while the spice is minimal it’s still surprisingly hottt.
I will say - the way some of it’s written, it seems like they literally only ever last like less than a minute when sleeping with each other. I know they didn’t, but it made me giggle.
Still, Blaze when he loses control, Shawn and a probable oral fixation… I was left wanting more of thatttt.
The only real conflict of the story stems from miscommunication or the lack thereof, even when it could have been really really heavy with what our characters have gone or are going through. It was genuinely *chefs kiss* 🤌
I didn’t need, nor want anything else.
There are a couple of heavy scenes, Shawn meets Blaze at Sanctuary Lake Retreat in Laketon, Maine. He’s sent (forced) there by his agent after a car accident(?).
He’s hopeless when he gets there, not much lower he could have felt (about himself). It only comes out a couple times, the rest is genuinely him healing. Shawn finds himself, his purpose, and his home at the retreat and in Blaze.
As someone who has related scarily well to the first part, this had my favorite kind of happy ending.
And it's why this story gets a full five stars from me.
Memorable Quote
Not the quote you would expect me to choose from a love story, but this is one that means a lot to me.
I'll for sure be reading the next book, I'm looking forward to it already.
I'm also interested in reading some of Elle's other work, as I enjoyed her writing, and to be honest, well-written goes a really long way with me.
Thank you to Amazon's GRR for this free ARC. Rating and review are voluntary - opinions given are always my own.
No AI ✅
Well-written, cozy, low-angst.
The book makes healing and falling in love sound, feel easy.
It certainly was for Blaze and Shawn.
The ease of the sexual awakening in this (from an ex-baseball player, as well) is beautiful, in that, there are 0 issues whatsoever besides a bit of what I would think would be very normal at a very normal time in the story, as well.
I enjoyed how much time the two men spent together on page, even before things progressed between them.
Both MCs (and all the side-characters) were EXTREMELY likable.
Every time I think I like one more, I think of a reason I like the other.
Really though, they’re perfect for each other.
The sexual chemistry between the two is palpable, and while the spice is minimal it’s still surprisingly hottt.
I will say - the way some of it’s written, it seems like they literally only ever last like less than a minute when sleeping with each other. I know they didn’t, but it made me giggle.
Still, Blaze when he loses control, Shawn and a probable oral fixation… I was left wanting more of thatttt.
The only real conflict of the story stems from miscommunication or the lack thereof, even when it could have been really really heavy with what our characters have gone or are going through. It was genuinely *chefs kiss* 🤌
I didn’t need, nor want anything else.
There are a couple of heavy scenes, Shawn meets Blaze at Sanctuary Lake Retreat in Laketon, Maine. He’s sent (forced) there by his agent after a car accident(?).
He’s hopeless when he gets there, not much lower he could have felt (about himself). It only comes out a couple times, the rest is genuinely him healing. Shawn finds himself, his purpose, and his home at the retreat and in Blaze.
As someone who has related scarily well to the first part, this had my favorite kind of happy ending.
And it's why this story gets a full five stars from me.
Memorable Quote
“Eventually, I turn away from the darkness.
No. That’s not what I want.
I still don’t know what I want, but I guess I’m choosing to try to find out.” - p. 69
Not the quote you would expect me to choose from a love story, but this is one that means a lot to me.
I'll for sure be reading the next book, I'm looking forward to it already.
I'm also interested in reading some of Elle's other work, as I enjoyed her writing, and to be honest, well-written goes a really long way with me.
Thank you to Amazon's GRR for this free ARC. Rating and review are voluntary - opinions given are always my own.
Review of advance copy
A lovely gentle romance, including bi-awakening, between a newly released former baseball star and a retreat handyman/activity leader, set on an isolated retreat in beautiful forested Maine. Includes a sweetheart of a dog. 🥹
Shawn is mad, sad, depressed, frustrated…he’s been let go of his pro baseball team due to his elbow injury/surgery not being fully successful. His agent (nice lady!) has sent him to remote Maine on an internet-free retreat to regroup, rest, and settle in with himself and his new situation.
Blaze works at the retreat, leading group and individual activities such as fishing, hiking, kayaking. He lives down the road with his sister in his own home (that does have internet), and has never gotten involved with a guest. He’s a fan of baseball…
The two have great friendly chemistry as guest and personnel, and I loved seeing Shawn’s awareness of Blaze grow from Huh to ooooh…a-ha. It is gradual enough to be believable and quick enough not to drag on, and they’re fast attracted to hanging out with each other. Blaze has no expectations of a straight millionaire pro athlete having any interest; Shawn hasn’t ever been aware of a man. But as they spend time together, Shawn’s natural awareness starts to turn to sexual awareness, and their communication and respect for each other made it so enjoyable to read turn into Something.
Shawn’s path toward finding something to do with the rest of his life happens to mesh well with Blaze’s lifestyle and goals, and if it’s a little easy for them to work out? Well, I was very in the mood for a lovely lower-angst read. There’s tension from Blaze’s sad past clashing with Shawn’s outside world coming for him toward the end, but no annoying separation due to miscommunication or anyone being ridiculous.
Enjoyable!
HEA, two worlds collide, former baseball pro and outdoorsman, bi-awakening, isolated retreat, small town feel, strong secondary characters. No OM action or drama at all. First times with a man. Safe for me. Recommended.
My thanks to Gay Romance Reviews for the ARC; this is my free and impartial opinion.
Shawn is mad, sad, depressed, frustrated…he’s been let go of his pro baseball team due to his elbow injury/surgery not being fully successful. His agent (nice lady!) has sent him to remote Maine on an internet-free retreat to regroup, rest, and settle in with himself and his new situation.
Blaze works at the retreat, leading group and individual activities such as fishing, hiking, kayaking. He lives down the road with his sister in his own home (that does have internet), and has never gotten involved with a guest. He’s a fan of baseball…
The two have great friendly chemistry as guest and personnel, and I loved seeing Shawn’s awareness of Blaze grow from Huh to ooooh…a-ha. It is gradual enough to be believable and quick enough not to drag on, and they’re fast attracted to hanging out with each other. Blaze has no expectations of a straight millionaire pro athlete having any interest; Shawn hasn’t ever been aware of a man. But as they spend time together, Shawn’s natural awareness starts to turn to sexual awareness, and their communication and respect for each other made it so enjoyable to read turn into Something.
Shawn’s path toward finding something to do with the rest of his life happens to mesh well with Blaze’s lifestyle and goals, and if it’s a little easy for them to work out? Well, I was very in the mood for a lovely lower-angst read. There’s tension from Blaze’s sad past clashing with Shawn’s outside world coming for him toward the end, but no annoying separation due to miscommunication or anyone being ridiculous.
Enjoyable!
HEA, two worlds collide, former baseball pro and outdoorsman, bi-awakening, isolated retreat, small town feel, strong secondary characters. No OM action or drama at all. First times with a man. Safe for me. Recommended.
My thanks to Gay Romance Reviews for the ARC; this is my free and impartial opinion.
September 26, 2026
3.5⭐
I've seen a lot of people gushing about this book and wanted to join in. Well, I knew it's probably not going to be a 5 star read for me since I prefer speculative fiction, pure contemporary romance is usually a bit of a snooze. And I was right. This was exactly what was promised, a nice romance, but the "hook" was missing. This doesn't mean it's a bad book at all, I enjoyed it in a mellow way, and it even had some nice 4-star moments. Just not quite enough to push the rating further.
I don't mind a painless bi-awakening but it felt a bit weird it was an instant attraction kind of thing. Shawn felt like he hadn't been much interested in people sexually or romantically, so a slower realisation would have worked better here. This is a very minor thing though, otherwise I enjoyed the low-angst discovery, and it was perfectly fine and even nice that the book wasn't another well of homophobia.
I can't help but be a little bit bitter about the possibility of just stopping your regular life and enjoying nice slow days in nature not giving a shit. Wouldn't mind a little break from the rat race. The resort did seem to offer better prices for people who weren't that well-off but still there was this sense of upper middle-class fuckery, and I guess Shawn was probably filthy rich anyway. But this was another very minor thing, this book is the kind of fluff that one can't really be mad that it doesn't take a bigger stance on fighting social injustice. 😅
It's cute and sweet, and mellow as I mentioned. These guys became friends, liked each other, and were considerate. I had a nice night with it, but probably won't reread. Might grab the sequel though.
I've seen a lot of people gushing about this book and wanted to join in. Well, I knew it's probably not going to be a 5 star read for me since I prefer speculative fiction, pure contemporary romance is usually a bit of a snooze. And I was right. This was exactly what was promised, a nice romance, but the "hook" was missing. This doesn't mean it's a bad book at all, I enjoyed it in a mellow way, and it even had some nice 4-star moments. Just not quite enough to push the rating further.
I don't mind a painless bi-awakening but it felt a bit weird it was an instant attraction kind of thing. Shawn felt like he hadn't been much interested in people sexually or romantically, so a slower realisation would have worked better here. This is a very minor thing though, otherwise I enjoyed the low-angst discovery, and it was perfectly fine and even nice that the book wasn't another well of homophobia.
I can't help but be a little bit bitter about the possibility of just stopping your regular life and enjoying nice slow days in nature not giving a shit. Wouldn't mind a little break from the rat race. The resort did seem to offer better prices for people who weren't that well-off but still there was this sense of upper middle-class fuckery, and I guess Shawn was probably filthy rich anyway. But this was another very minor thing, this book is the kind of fluff that one can't really be mad that it doesn't take a bigger stance on fighting social injustice. 😅
It's cute and sweet, and mellow as I mentioned. These guys became friends, liked each other, and were considerate. I had a nice night with it, but probably won't reread. Might grab the sequel though.
September 17, 2026
This book was popcorn. Nothing wrong with popcorn, it's exactly what I wanted to eat in the moment, but it is popcorn. The book had chances to add depth, particularly around Shawn's processing of his car accident, and Blaze's catastrophizing over a little weekend trip, and more or less opted not to. And again, nothing wrong with that, just how the author wanted the book.
So the story is that Shawn, a newly retired baseball player whose retirement was somewhat less than planned or voluntary, is sent by his agent to a forest retreat away from the evils of the world, internet included, to rest and recuperate. While there, he meets Blaze, the outdoor coordinator slash future homeowner once it's done being built. Shawn has never been into dudes before but he sees no issue with starting now, and they begin a flirtation that leads to a romance that leads to all the typical questions of how can this last when Shawn eventually has to go back to his life. But does he???
But yeah, it was a perfectly fine and cute book, nothing dazzled me, nothing disappointed me, nothing surprised me, it was just a good time and a chill way to spend a few hours. I certainly wouldn't recommend it as your next big literary obsession, but if you're looking for a solid palate cleanser between more challenging premises or stories, you could do a lot worse than this one. I look forward to the second, I end up needing lighthearted goo as a palate cleanser a fair amount.
Thank you to GRR for an eARC of this title, this is my honest review.
So the story is that Shawn, a newly retired baseball player whose retirement was somewhat less than planned or voluntary, is sent by his agent to a forest retreat away from the evils of the world, internet included, to rest and recuperate. While there, he meets Blaze, the outdoor coordinator slash future homeowner once it's done being built. Shawn has never been into dudes before but he sees no issue with starting now, and they begin a flirtation that leads to a romance that leads to all the typical questions of how can this last when Shawn eventually has to go back to his life. But does he???
But yeah, it was a perfectly fine and cute book, nothing dazzled me, nothing disappointed me, nothing surprised me, it was just a good time and a chill way to spend a few hours. I certainly wouldn't recommend it as your next big literary obsession, but if you're looking for a solid palate cleanser between more challenging premises or stories, you could do a lot worse than this one. I look forward to the second, I end up needing lighthearted goo as a palate cleanser a fair amount.
Thank you to GRR for an eARC of this title, this is my honest review.
September 17, 2026
I loved this book, from the character to the setting to the gentle plot.
A pro baseball player loses his career after Tommy John surgery, and cracks up his Lamborghini in response. His agent sends him to a resort in the Maine woods to get his head together, and there he meets Blaze, a man who had to take responsibility for his young sister after their parents' death. Both of them have emotional stuff to get through.
The setting at Sanctuary Lake is just wonderful. A no-internet luxury escape with gourmet food, luxe accomodations, and any kind of play equipment you'd want.
This is a slow burn romance with a pair of characters who haven't had time or space to love before. Very emotional.
A pro baseball player loses his career after Tommy John surgery, and cracks up his Lamborghini in response. His agent sends him to a resort in the Maine woods to get his head together, and there he meets Blaze, a man who had to take responsibility for his young sister after their parents' death. Both of them have emotional stuff to get through.
The setting at Sanctuary Lake is just wonderful. A no-internet luxury escape with gourmet food, luxe accomodations, and any kind of play equipment you'd want.
This is a slow burn romance with a pair of characters who haven't had time or space to love before. Very emotional.
September 19, 2026
Off the Trail by Elle Waters is book 1 in the new Sanctuary Lake Retreat series. This was a sweet low- angst romance between Shawn, former professional baseball player, and Blaze, activity director at the retreat that Shawn gets sent to. Blaze has been so busy taking care of others that his personal life has been ignored. Shawn has no idea what to do with his life now that his career is over.
I loved these two together. You could feel the love between them. The secondary characters were also interesting and I’m looking forward to Nolan’s story. I wish there had been a little more to the last conflict as Blaze was a little out of line. Very enjoyable story though.
I received an ARC from the author and GRR for my honest review.
I loved these two together. You could feel the love between them. The secondary characters were also interesting and I’m looking forward to Nolan’s story. I wish there had been a little more to the last conflict as Blaze was a little out of line. Very enjoyable story though.
I received an ARC from the author and GRR for my honest review.
September 16, 2026
Thank you Gay Romance Reviews for the advanced copy. I think this one is more like 3.5 stars? But overall I enjoyed the storyline.
Shawn has been recently cut from his major league baseball team and is sent to a retreat in the woods after getting into a bad car accident. He kind of lost himself and is working on figuring out who he is without baseball in his life. Blaze is the activities director of the retreat, and he and Shawn grow a friendship that quickly becomes more.
I think part of my issue is that I don’t love insta love. I wish I did because I feel like I’m a romantic at heart, but it also feels like these two jumped into something serious pretty quick, with Shawn never having dated or been attracted to a man before. While I appreciated that he was not questioning too much, it felt like he was immediately on board and ready to do anything for Blaze.
Meanwhile, Blaze was really insecure. Like, to the point where it did frustrate me a little. Shawn gave zero indications that he wasn’t serious, called when he said he would, and he showed up over and over again. Blaze’s issues seemed really out of pocket, and his sister dating her boss and everyone just being okay with it also stressed me out. I also thought some of the family issues were not fleshed out. For example, Shawn’s dad didn’t want to speak with him after getting cut from the team and when you find out why, it’s infuriating. This is an adult man!! Argh.
That being said, I did enjoy the sweetly romantic moments. I loved the body positivity especially when it comes to body hair as people can be really cruel. I love that Shawn praised Blaze’s body as perfect for him. It was incredibly sexy. I also really liked how brave Shawn was to go after what he wanted and to be honest about his feelings. I also liked our supporting characters at the retreat, and I think Nolan’s book would be fun cause he’s a great character.
Overall, this is a low angst, small town ish romance with insta love and some frustration, but it was a quick read and I’m not mad I read it. 😅
Shawn has been recently cut from his major league baseball team and is sent to a retreat in the woods after getting into a bad car accident. He kind of lost himself and is working on figuring out who he is without baseball in his life. Blaze is the activities director of the retreat, and he and Shawn grow a friendship that quickly becomes more.
I think part of my issue is that I don’t love insta love. I wish I did because I feel like I’m a romantic at heart, but it also feels like these two jumped into something serious pretty quick, with Shawn never having dated or been attracted to a man before. While I appreciated that he was not questioning too much, it felt like he was immediately on board and ready to do anything for Blaze.
Meanwhile, Blaze was really insecure. Like, to the point where it did frustrate me a little. Shawn gave zero indications that he wasn’t serious, called when he said he would, and he showed up over and over again. Blaze’s issues seemed really out of pocket, and his sister dating her boss and everyone just being okay with it also stressed me out. I also thought some of the family issues were not fleshed out. For example, Shawn’s dad didn’t want to speak with him after getting cut from the team and when you find out why, it’s infuriating. This is an adult man!! Argh.
That being said, I did enjoy the sweetly romantic moments. I loved the body positivity especially when it comes to body hair as people can be really cruel. I love that Shawn praised Blaze’s body as perfect for him. It was incredibly sexy. I also really liked how brave Shawn was to go after what he wanted and to be honest about his feelings. I also liked our supporting characters at the retreat, and I think Nolan’s book would be fun cause he’s a great character.
Overall, this is a low angst, small town ish romance with insta love and some frustration, but it was a quick read and I’m not mad I read it. 😅
September 26, 2026
This was a really sweet, gentle romance with a bi awakening, a beautiful Maine setting and, of course, an adorable dog. 🥹
Shawn is a former baseball star who has just been cut from his team after his elbow surgery doesn’t go as planned. He’s sent to a remote retreat to figure out what comes next when baseball is no longer his whole life. There he meets Blaze, the activities director, and their friendship quickly turns into something more.
I’ll admit, insta-love isn’t always my thing, and these two jumped into something serious pretty quickly, especially with Shawn never having been attracted to a man before. I appreciated how comfortable Shawn was with his feelings, but the speed took a little getting used to.
Blaze also frustrated me at times with how insecure he was. Shawn consistently showed that he was serious, so some of Blaze’s doubts felt unnecessary. There were also a few family issues I wish had been explored more.
That said, I really enjoyed the sweet moments between them. I loved Shawn’s confidence in going after what he wanted and the body positivity, especially around body hair. The way Shawn made Blaze feel completely wanted exactly as he was was incredibly sweet.
I also liked the retreat setting and supporting characters, especially Nolan, who I’d definitely like to see get his own story.
Overall, a quick, low-angst romance with plenty of sweetness, a beautiful setting and an adorable dog. Not perfect for me, but I still had a good time with it.
Shawn is a former baseball star who has just been cut from his team after his elbow surgery doesn’t go as planned. He’s sent to a remote retreat to figure out what comes next when baseball is no longer his whole life. There he meets Blaze, the activities director, and their friendship quickly turns into something more.
I’ll admit, insta-love isn’t always my thing, and these two jumped into something serious pretty quickly, especially with Shawn never having been attracted to a man before. I appreciated how comfortable Shawn was with his feelings, but the speed took a little getting used to.
Blaze also frustrated me at times with how insecure he was. Shawn consistently showed that he was serious, so some of Blaze’s doubts felt unnecessary. There were also a few family issues I wish had been explored more.
That said, I really enjoyed the sweet moments between them. I loved Shawn’s confidence in going after what he wanted and the body positivity, especially around body hair. The way Shawn made Blaze feel completely wanted exactly as he was was incredibly sweet.
I also liked the retreat setting and supporting characters, especially Nolan, who I’d definitely like to see get his own story.
Overall, a quick, low-angst romance with plenty of sweetness, a beautiful setting and an adorable dog. Not perfect for me, but I still had a good time with it.
September 24, 2026
3.5/5 STARS! Cute & fun mm romance. Minimal conflict. Steamy but not too over the top. Really good & lighthearted romance. Fall vibes. Loved the setting.
Read
November 9, 2026Cute, cozy, low-stakes romance. Pretty quick connection but a few key scenes gave some depth to the relationship.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
After being injured, having surgery and cut from his baseball team, Shawn Camden crashes his car. His agent tells him to lay low for a while and suggests a retreat in a remote part of Maine. One of the locals who works there, Blaze, catches his eye and he isn’t sure why that is since he’s never been with a man before. At the age of 35, Shawn finds himself in a life crisis and also starts to question his sexuality. Blaze has lived in the small town his whole life and has never gotten involved with a guest before. As the two spend more time together, they both find themselves unable to deny the pull they feel toward one another. But with Shawn only expected to stay in town for a limited time and Blaze dealing with issues from his past, the two have to make some choices if they want a future together. This book paints a vivid image of a quant, small town in Autumn. It brought to mind the Gilmore Girls’ town (you know, if they actually had gay people in Stars Hallow.) I read a lot of MM books and can’t quite think of another with the same kind of cutesy, small town feel. It had the right amount of sarcasm and spice (this is more of a slow burn). I look forward to Nolan’s book next! I received an ARC copy of this book and am leaving a review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Advanced Copy Review:
I don't know if there are better words to describe this one than serene and cozy. It was like a sports romance without all of the stress because it's in the unique setting of a post-career. The plot hit all of the notes that I wanted and anticipated. I don't think I left this one with any unanswered questions. All of the characters were quite likeable, so I didn't leave the book with irritation towards any character.
My biggest criticism with Off the Trail is that the side characters felt more like footnotes than important pieces to the story. Throughout, a character would re-emerge for a chapter or 2 then dissapear completely for who knows how long. I think this pattern left me wanting more from Brooke specifically. It made sense that she was sparse in the early part of the book because it fit her storyline. I would've like to see her dynamic with Shawn develop a bit more. There are some other specific characters that I felt could've used extra writing: Marika (quite likeable and like a mom to Blaze), Rocky (a big secret that really didn't prove to be consequential past his main appearance), and Misty (literally on the cover).
There were a couple moments where there were unexpected time jumps from chapter to chapter (specifically going down the mountain was skipped and there was a one week time skip). It through me off when reading through because I thought there would be more plot development in the times skipped.
That said, the core elements of the book are quite enjoyable. I was invested in the characters and plot. There were some lines that hurt in the best way, and I love that in a book. While I would've liked more fullness to the plot, it was great overall. I'd call it a good reading experience when I wanted more at the end (but not in a way that I'm angry).
I don't know if there are better words to describe this one than serene and cozy. It was like a sports romance without all of the stress because it's in the unique setting of a post-career. The plot hit all of the notes that I wanted and anticipated. I don't think I left this one with any unanswered questions. All of the characters were quite likeable, so I didn't leave the book with irritation towards any character.
My biggest criticism with Off the Trail is that the side characters felt more like footnotes than important pieces to the story. Throughout, a character would re-emerge for a chapter or 2 then dissapear completely for who knows how long. I think this pattern left me wanting more from Brooke specifically. It made sense that she was sparse in the early part of the book because it fit her storyline. I would've like to see her dynamic with Shawn develop a bit more. There are some other specific characters that I felt could've used extra writing: Marika (quite likeable and like a mom to Blaze), Rocky (a big secret that really didn't prove to be consequential past his main appearance), and Misty (literally on the cover).
There were a couple moments where there were unexpected time jumps from chapter to chapter (specifically going down the mountain was skipped and there was a one week time skip). It through me off when reading through because I thought there would be more plot development in the times skipped.
That said, the core elements of the book are quite enjoyable. I was invested in the characters and plot. There were some lines that hurt in the best way, and I love that in a book. While I would've liked more fullness to the plot, it was great overall. I'd call it a good reading experience when I wanted more at the end (but not in a way that I'm angry).
July 18, 2026
Thank you to Victory Editing NetGalley Co-Op for the ARC!
I ended up reading this book in a day and still gave it three stars. It was very short and very quick, and honestly I kinda just wanted to be over with it at certain times. That’s not to say there weren’t things to enjoy – one of the characters has a sister, and their relationship was compelling. The problem for me was that there were some issues with internal logic and the writing felt a little flat and repetitive at times.
As an example, we have Shawn, a recently fired/let go previously-pro MLB player. While recovering from an accident, his former agent suggests he go to this retreat in Maine for two weeks to clear his head, so he does. It’s mentioned that his therapist thinks it’s a good idea, except later when he gets his phone again (the resort has no reception), the therapist is texting wondering why he missed their session. And then it’s suddenly been well over two weeks and he isn’t asked to renew his stay until at least a month in.
The character voices were also the same. It’s dual pov, but you can only tell because of the different activities they engage in; their voices were the same.
And the other guy is named Blaze. Which is tough.
I know that’s a lot of issues, but I still did give it three stars – I enjoyed it, and I read it in a day where I also worked my entire, normal office job. It was an easy, light read, but it just fell flat unfortunately.
Note: This book is listed as 320 pages but I simply don’t think that that’s true – I think it’s closer to 220. It could be format and reader settings, but usually my ebooks have a higher page count than ‘official’ because I use custom fonts and a large font size.
I ended up reading this book in a day and still gave it three stars. It was very short and very quick, and honestly I kinda just wanted to be over with it at certain times. That’s not to say there weren’t things to enjoy – one of the characters has a sister, and their relationship was compelling. The problem for me was that there were some issues with internal logic and the writing felt a little flat and repetitive at times.
As an example, we have Shawn, a recently fired/let go previously-pro MLB player. While recovering from an accident, his former agent suggests he go to this retreat in Maine for two weeks to clear his head, so he does. It’s mentioned that his therapist thinks it’s a good idea, except later when he gets his phone again (the resort has no reception), the therapist is texting wondering why he missed their session. And then it’s suddenly been well over two weeks and he isn’t asked to renew his stay until at least a month in.
The character voices were also the same. It’s dual pov, but you can only tell because of the different activities they engage in; their voices were the same.
And the other guy is named Blaze. Which is tough.
I know that’s a lot of issues, but I still did give it three stars – I enjoyed it, and I read it in a day where I also worked my entire, normal office job. It was an easy, light read, but it just fell flat unfortunately.
Note: This book is listed as 320 pages but I simply don’t think that that’s true – I think it’s closer to 220. It could be format and reader settings, but usually my ebooks have a higher page count than ‘official’ because I use custom fonts and a large font size.
Review of advance copy received from Author
A pro baseball player cut from the team; a Maine outdoorsman who reads people and a magical retreat
Shawn experiences profound disappointment when he is removed from the professional baseball team to which he has dedicated his life. However, the new ownership did not regard him as a valuable asset to the team. Heartbroken by the decision and an unexplained accident with his highly expensive vehicle, Shawn reluctantly consents to participate in a retreat designed to assist individuals in discovering their next steps.
During the retreat, Shawn is drawn to Blaze, the burly activities director and lifelong supporter of the team Shawn once played for. Blaze perceives Shawn's need for companionship, relaxation, and guidance in planning his future. Having arranged activities ranging from badminton to deep woods hikes, Blaze is a native of the area who lost his parents in a plane crash and assumed guardianship of his sister during his teenage years.
Shawn recognizes this nurturing aspect in Blaze and offers assistance with some of the tasks, as he has little to do during his days due to the lack of internet access, with his only means of communication being a landline in his cabin. He laments his inability to support his former team but is increasingly fond of Blaze's company. Both men identify as heterosexual, yet they later admit to developing feelings for each other early in their acquaintance.
Elle Waters demonstrates excellent worldbuilding skills. Readers become familiar with the cabins nestled among the trees surrounding Sanctuary Lake and observe guests receiving gourmet meals prepared by a talented chef, as well as having their activities arranged for them.
In the distinctive style of Elle Waters, these men openly express their desire to deepen their understanding of each other. This includes Shawn, whose father has ceased communication with him following his removal from the team, as he meets and gets to know others working at the retreat, including the operator of a nearby woodworking school and local restaurant personnel.
This is an engaging, easy-to-read love story enriched with vivid descriptions that evoke a full-color portrait of a fall day in Maine, set against a backdrop of clear night skies filled with stars—perfect for two men to fall in love and make a lifelong pledge to each other.
Shawn experiences profound disappointment when he is removed from the professional baseball team to which he has dedicated his life. However, the new ownership did not regard him as a valuable asset to the team. Heartbroken by the decision and an unexplained accident with his highly expensive vehicle, Shawn reluctantly consents to participate in a retreat designed to assist individuals in discovering their next steps.
During the retreat, Shawn is drawn to Blaze, the burly activities director and lifelong supporter of the team Shawn once played for. Blaze perceives Shawn's need for companionship, relaxation, and guidance in planning his future. Having arranged activities ranging from badminton to deep woods hikes, Blaze is a native of the area who lost his parents in a plane crash and assumed guardianship of his sister during his teenage years.
Shawn recognizes this nurturing aspect in Blaze and offers assistance with some of the tasks, as he has little to do during his days due to the lack of internet access, with his only means of communication being a landline in his cabin. He laments his inability to support his former team but is increasingly fond of Blaze's company. Both men identify as heterosexual, yet they later admit to developing feelings for each other early in their acquaintance.
Elle Waters demonstrates excellent worldbuilding skills. Readers become familiar with the cabins nestled among the trees surrounding Sanctuary Lake and observe guests receiving gourmet meals prepared by a talented chef, as well as having their activities arranged for them.
In the distinctive style of Elle Waters, these men openly express their desire to deepen their understanding of each other. This includes Shawn, whose father has ceased communication with him following his removal from the team, as he meets and gets to know others working at the retreat, including the operator of a nearby woodworking school and local restaurant personnel.
This is an engaging, easy-to-read love story enriched with vivid descriptions that evoke a full-color portrait of a fall day in Maine, set against a backdrop of clear night skies filled with stars—perfect for two men to fall in love and make a lifelong pledge to each other.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
ARC Review
So sweet, I feel like I walked away from reading this with a million cavities.
This book is the epitome of cozy read; like the ideal setting to read this is while it's raining, cuddled up on the couch with a drink of your choice. This book was my introduction to Elle Waters' works and it was good one. The storytelling pulls you into this world like a warm hug. I appreciated how even though you're introduced to a decently large cast of characters, they are not all thrown at you at once. Every character felt like they had a purpose in the story, and were all genuinely likable.
The relationship between Shawn and Blaze was believable and easy to root for, they felt like real people. The romance progression was also nice — not too slow but not too fast either.
This book does have the miscommunication trope at the core of it's climax/conflict, but it doesn't drag on too long to become annoying. Though it is still something to be mindful about it's a trope you dislike. Additionally, there really isn't any other conflict so there are times where it felt like there wasn't anything else really happening in the book. Which did make the story drag a bit in some parts.
However, I absolutely think it's worth checking out, especially if you're in need of a palate cleanser between heavier books or are just generally a big fan of low angst / fluffy reads. I will definitely be keeping an eye out for Nolan's story next.
While all thoughts and opinions include in this review are my own, I want to give a big thank you to NetGalley and Lemon Tree books for the complimentary copy!
So sweet, I feel like I walked away from reading this with a million cavities.
This book is the epitome of cozy read; like the ideal setting to read this is while it's raining, cuddled up on the couch with a drink of your choice. This book was my introduction to Elle Waters' works and it was good one. The storytelling pulls you into this world like a warm hug. I appreciated how even though you're introduced to a decently large cast of characters, they are not all thrown at you at once. Every character felt like they had a purpose in the story, and were all genuinely likable.
The relationship between Shawn and Blaze was believable and easy to root for, they felt like real people. The romance progression was also nice — not too slow but not too fast either.
This book does have the miscommunication trope at the core of it's climax/conflict, but it doesn't drag on too long to become annoying. Though it is still something to be mindful about it's a trope you dislike. Additionally, there really isn't any other conflict so there are times where it felt like there wasn't anything else really happening in the book. Which did make the story drag a bit in some parts.
However, I absolutely think it's worth checking out, especially if you're in need of a palate cleanser between heavier books or are just generally a big fan of low angst / fluffy reads. I will definitely be keeping an eye out for Nolan's story next.
While all thoughts and opinions include in this review are my own, I want to give a big thank you to NetGalley and Lemon Tree books for the complimentary copy!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
After a car accident, Shawn Camden, a former professional baseball player, is sent to a private lakeside retreat in Maine by his agent in order to decompress. Ever since he was cut from the Hartford Laurels baseball team a few months ago, Shawn has been depressed, wondering how he’ll move forward, and the car accident certainly didn’t help. It’s at the retreat that he meets Blaze Hardy, the activities director. Instantly, there’s an attraction between them, and soon, Shawn begins to see a new future for himself, one with Blaze in it.
Overall this was a sweet romance. But it was almost too sweet. There was no tension or angst and so I felt very bored throughout. It didn’t really feel like the characters had much personality either. And I was so looking forward to the fall vibes but it still felt too summery! The tension that happens later in the book felt very over the top to me. I get that Blaze had a lot of trauma and so Shawn leaving (BRIEFLY) to support his old baseball team probably felt like a big deal, but even Shawn says “I was gone for four days” after Blaze tells him he was ready to cut him off. FOUR DAYS!!!! And he said he was coming back! Because the rest of the story was so angst-free, this type of tension didn’t feel warranted or believable that far into the book. And Shawn’s car accident didn’t feel necessary. I kept forgetting about it lol and it was barely mentioned at all until the end.
What I did like: I liked how clear this was written and I especially liked how thoughtful the smut scenes were. Waters did an excellent job with that and demonstrating consent and safe sex. I also liked some of the side characters, like Nolan and Marika. In fact, Nolan will be the mc for the next book and because I liked his character so much, I would like to read it. It could be that maybe this first book just wasn’t for me, but I understand and appreciate how much others enjoyed it 🩷
Thank you to the author and Netgalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Overall this was a sweet romance. But it was almost too sweet. There was no tension or angst and so I felt very bored throughout. It didn’t really feel like the characters had much personality either. And I was so looking forward to the fall vibes but it still felt too summery! The tension that happens later in the book felt very over the top to me. I get that Blaze had a lot of trauma and so Shawn leaving (BRIEFLY) to support his old baseball team probably felt like a big deal, but even Shawn says “I was gone for four days” after Blaze tells him he was ready to cut him off. FOUR DAYS!!!! And he said he was coming back! Because the rest of the story was so angst-free, this type of tension didn’t feel warranted or believable that far into the book. And Shawn’s car accident didn’t feel necessary. I kept forgetting about it lol and it was barely mentioned at all until the end.
What I did like: I liked how clear this was written and I especially liked how thoughtful the smut scenes were. Waters did an excellent job with that and demonstrating consent and safe sex. I also liked some of the side characters, like Nolan and Marika. In fact, Nolan will be the mc for the next book and because I liked his character so much, I would like to read it. It could be that maybe this first book just wasn’t for me, but I understand and appreciate how much others enjoyed it 🩷
Thank you to the author and Netgalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
September 14, 2026
This was such a cozy, feel-good romance. ❤️
I really enjoyed Off the Trail. I loved the idea of a professional baseball player suddenly being forced to step away from the only life he’s ever known and ending up at a secluded retreat in Maine—with no phone, no internet, and plenty of time to figure out what he actually wants.
Shawn was easy to root for. Losing baseball, especially under circumstances he didn't choose, really knocked him off balance, and I liked watching him slowly start to realize that his life could be about more than just the game.
And then there’s Blaze. 😊 I loved the way these two connected. Their relationship felt relaxed and natural, with all the hiking, fishing, stargazing, and other activities giving them plenty of opportunities to spend time together and get to know each other. The whole lakeside retreat setting was probably my favorite part of the book—it gave the story such a peaceful, cozy atmosphere.
I also really enjoyed the sexual-awakening aspect. Watching Shawn discover this side of himself while falling for Blaze added another layer to their relationship, and I liked that the romance wasn't weighed down by tons of angst or unnecessary drama.
I would have loved to see more of Shawn's relationship with some of the other people at the retreat.
Sometimes you just want a book that makes you feel good while you're reading it, and Off the Trail definitely delivered that for me. 💕
I received this free ARC, and this is my honest review.
I really enjoyed Off the Trail. I loved the idea of a professional baseball player suddenly being forced to step away from the only life he’s ever known and ending up at a secluded retreat in Maine—with no phone, no internet, and plenty of time to figure out what he actually wants.
Shawn was easy to root for. Losing baseball, especially under circumstances he didn't choose, really knocked him off balance, and I liked watching him slowly start to realize that his life could be about more than just the game.
And then there’s Blaze. 😊 I loved the way these two connected. Their relationship felt relaxed and natural, with all the hiking, fishing, stargazing, and other activities giving them plenty of opportunities to spend time together and get to know each other. The whole lakeside retreat setting was probably my favorite part of the book—it gave the story such a peaceful, cozy atmosphere.
I also really enjoyed the sexual-awakening aspect. Watching Shawn discover this side of himself while falling for Blaze added another layer to their relationship, and I liked that the romance wasn't weighed down by tons of angst or unnecessary drama.
I would have loved to see more of Shawn's relationship with some of the other people at the retreat.
Sometimes you just want a book that makes you feel good while you're reading it, and Off the Trail definitely delivered that for me. 💕
I received this free ARC, and this is my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Off the Trail is about Shawn, a recently ex-professional baseball player who, after getting into a car accident, is forced to go on a wilderness retreat to clear his mind. There he finds Blaze, the activities director, whom he can’t stop thinking about.
There are multiple things that I appreciate about this novel. First is how nonchalant Shawn was about his attraction to Blaze. He accepted that he found men attractive rather easily. I also like how both men were very masculine; they enjoyed fishing, hiking, and building things. They are both seemingly ‘straight passing,’ which led to the strange dance they had to do to see if the other was also into them, which was really fun to read! This dynamic is pretty rare to read in MM romance (at least in the ones I’ve read), so it was incredibly refreshing!
Overall, the book is very low angst and cozy. This is a perfect book to read when you’re looking for something easy and fun to read. I do think that the two MCs moved a bit fast towards the end, but hey, I’m looking for entertainment in my romance novels, not realism. I will also say I am super excited for Nolan’s book and look forward to reading it.
Thank you, NetGalley and the author, for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Tags/Warnings
.
.
.
Tropes: Queer awakening, Low angst, Accidental dating
Triggers: Past parental death
Third act break-up: No
OM/OW: None
There are multiple things that I appreciate about this novel. First is how nonchalant Shawn was about his attraction to Blaze. He accepted that he found men attractive rather easily. I also like how both men were very masculine; they enjoyed fishing, hiking, and building things. They are both seemingly ‘straight passing,’ which led to the strange dance they had to do to see if the other was also into them, which was really fun to read! This dynamic is pretty rare to read in MM romance (at least in the ones I’ve read), so it was incredibly refreshing!
Overall, the book is very low angst and cozy. This is a perfect book to read when you’re looking for something easy and fun to read. I do think that the two MCs moved a bit fast towards the end, but hey, I’m looking for entertainment in my romance novels, not realism. I will also say I am super excited for Nolan’s book and look forward to reading it.
Thank you, NetGalley and the author, for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Tags/Warnings
.
.
.
Tropes: Queer awakening, Low angst, Accidental dating
Triggers: Past parental death
Third act break-up: No
OM/OW: None
Review of advance copy received from Author
“Why me?”
“Oh, that’s easy. You’re you.”
Shawn woke up from an accident, and with him being retired from pro baseball, he was encouraged to take a vacation in a retreat house where he met Blaze who worked there. They started to spend more time together to the point of dating, but Shawn's needed to go back to the city.
I finished this in a few hours!
This is your typical romance where you know you gonna have a happy ending. This is just cozy, low angst, with little to no drama book. It's basically a Hallmark movie in book form.
Love our characters but they didn't have much depth to them. They were basically just stating things, not really showing us much. I did like them enough that I am not bothered by it.
The queer awakening was just brushed off. I kinda wished we explore more of that or at least Shawn talked about it with someone instead of just going with the flow. I mean, I am not queer or anything but I would love to have that representation in this book.
“I like the idea of muddling through as long as I have someone to muddle through with.”
“Let’s muddle, then.”
Their relationship was really straight-forward. They went from spending time together to being friends to exploring things physically. I don't have much to say because it's just really predictable.
If you like some fun mindless read where you know you gonna get a happy ending, then this book is for you. This book is what I needed as a palate cleanser.
“Oh, that’s easy. You’re you.”
Shawn woke up from an accident, and with him being retired from pro baseball, he was encouraged to take a vacation in a retreat house where he met Blaze who worked there. They started to spend more time together to the point of dating, but Shawn's needed to go back to the city.
I finished this in a few hours!
This is your typical romance where you know you gonna have a happy ending. This is just cozy, low angst, with little to no drama book. It's basically a Hallmark movie in book form.
Love our characters but they didn't have much depth to them. They were basically just stating things, not really showing us much. I did like them enough that I am not bothered by it.
The queer awakening was just brushed off. I kinda wished we explore more of that or at least Shawn talked about it with someone instead of just going with the flow. I mean, I am not queer or anything but I would love to have that representation in this book.
“I like the idea of muddling through as long as I have someone to muddle through with.”
“Let’s muddle, then.”
Their relationship was really straight-forward. They went from spending time together to being friends to exploring things physically. I don't have much to say because it's just really predictable.
If you like some fun mindless read where you know you gonna get a happy ending, then this book is for you. This book is what I needed as a palate cleanser.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
You know when you take a warm shower after being out in the cold, that the vibe of this book.
The mountain resort and lakeside setting were so vividly described that they instantly reminded me of where my family vacations every year. I wanted to pack a bag, rent a cabin, and stay there for a week. The small-town charm was everything.
The accidental dating trope? Chef's kiss. Blaze and Shawn's relationship developed so naturally that I never felt like they were rushing toward a happily ever after. They were curious about each other, supportive, and their chemistry just worked. The resort staff absolutely stole my heart too. The banter between Blaze and Nolan made the whole place feel like a family, and as a pet parent, I have to give a special shoutout to Misty, who was the very best girl.
As a baseball girly, I also really appreciated how the sport was incorporated into the story. It felt authentic and added another layer to Shawn's journey without ever overshadowing the romance.
This book is cozy, heartfelt, and quietly healing. It made me smile from beginning to end, and by the time I finished, I wasn't ready to leave these characters or this little mountain town.
Thank you to NetGalley, Lemon Tree Books, and Elle Waters for providing me with an ebook ARC in exchange for an honest review.
The mountain resort and lakeside setting were so vividly described that they instantly reminded me of where my family vacations every year. I wanted to pack a bag, rent a cabin, and stay there for a week. The small-town charm was everything.
The accidental dating trope? Chef's kiss. Blaze and Shawn's relationship developed so naturally that I never felt like they were rushing toward a happily ever after. They were curious about each other, supportive, and their chemistry just worked. The resort staff absolutely stole my heart too. The banter between Blaze and Nolan made the whole place feel like a family, and as a pet parent, I have to give a special shoutout to Misty, who was the very best girl.
As a baseball girly, I also really appreciated how the sport was incorporated into the story. It felt authentic and added another layer to Shawn's journey without ever overshadowing the romance.
This book is cozy, heartfelt, and quietly healing. It made me smile from beginning to end, and by the time I finished, I wasn't ready to leave these characters or this little mountain town.
Thank you to NetGalley, Lemon Tree Books, and Elle Waters for providing me with an ebook ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This is an incredibly well written slow burn with a fantastic plot. This book gives cozy vibes x100. I wanted nothing more than to read it curled up under a cozy blanket beside a roaring fire. Unfortunately, it’s summer, so I had to settle for pretending I was enjoying that cozy feeling instead 🤣
It was also really refreshing to see a solid/thicker MMC with body hair. It’s not often that I see my type of guy represented in these books, and I absolutely loved that.
Elle did a fantastic job of creating the atmosphere and building a world that I already can’t wait to explore more of. I’m so excited to see where this series goes.
I’m assuming Nolan and Josh’s story is next, and I cannot wait! I absolutely fell in love with the little glimpses of Nolan we got in this book, and I’m so excited to see him find his happily ever after 😍
My only complaint was the way Blaze acted toward the end, but I appreciate that it wasn’t a third act breakup and was more just a moment of stupidity. I can handle that 🤣
Overall, this was a wonderful read, and I cannot wait to jump back into Sanctuary Lake when the next book releases!
Thank you so much to the @ellewatersbooks, the publisher and @netgalley for the privilege to read this ARC!
Title - Off The Trail
Author - Elle Waters
Star rating - ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Spicy Rating - 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Overall - Autistic Allie Approved✅
It was also really refreshing to see a solid/thicker MMC with body hair. It’s not often that I see my type of guy represented in these books, and I absolutely loved that.
Elle did a fantastic job of creating the atmosphere and building a world that I already can’t wait to explore more of. I’m so excited to see where this series goes.
I’m assuming Nolan and Josh’s story is next, and I cannot wait! I absolutely fell in love with the little glimpses of Nolan we got in this book, and I’m so excited to see him find his happily ever after 😍
My only complaint was the way Blaze acted toward the end, but I appreciate that it wasn’t a third act breakup and was more just a moment of stupidity. I can handle that 🤣
Overall, this was a wonderful read, and I cannot wait to jump back into Sanctuary Lake when the next book releases!
Thank you so much to the @ellewatersbooks, the publisher and @netgalley for the privilege to read this ARC!
Title - Off The Trail
Author - Elle Waters
Star rating - ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
Spicy Rating - 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Overall - Autistic Allie Approved✅
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I really loved that this is such a sweet, cozy read and is the perfect book for the fall. I love an MM romance, and this one felt so raw and real, which I think is rare to find. Shawn and Blaze's relationship developed so naturally, and I loved that it was a quiet, down to earth love story instead of something with a bunch of drama.
Blaze was such a sweetheart and a genuinely good guy, and I loved how close he was with his sister, Brooke. Shawn's journey after his baseball career unexpectedly ended was emotional, and I really enjoyed how he was there to figure out who he was while spending time at Sanctuary Lake. His awakening felt genuine, and the slow burn between him and Blaze was adorable. They truly were exactly what the other needed, even if neither of them expected it.
I also loved that this was a shorter romance that never felt rushed. It had everything it needed to tell a complete, satisfying story even though it wasn't as long as a traditional 300+ page romance, but also longer than a novella. It still left me wanting more from this world and I already can't wait for Nolan's book next!
Thank you to NetGalley, Elle Waters, and Lemon Tree Books for the eARC of this book.
Blaze was such a sweetheart and a genuinely good guy, and I loved how close he was with his sister, Brooke. Shawn's journey after his baseball career unexpectedly ended was emotional, and I really enjoyed how he was there to figure out who he was while spending time at Sanctuary Lake. His awakening felt genuine, and the slow burn between him and Blaze was adorable. They truly were exactly what the other needed, even if neither of them expected it.
I also loved that this was a shorter romance that never felt rushed. It had everything it needed to tell a complete, satisfying story even though it wasn't as long as a traditional 300+ page romance, but also longer than a novella. It still left me wanting more from this world and I already can't wait for Nolan's book next!
Thank you to NetGalley, Elle Waters, and Lemon Tree Books for the eARC of this book.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
So grateful I got to read this early thanks to an ARC from Lemon Tree Books and NetGalley.
Off the Trail by Elle Waters is a sweet, cozy, little MM romance following former pro baseball player Shawn and Maine local Blaze as they gently fall for each other at a rural retreat center. Shawn is in crisis and sent to find himself in rural Maine; Blaze is the outdoor coordinator at Sanctuary Lake, a place designed for healing and recovering from life's tragedies.
The story is simple, gentle, cozy, and tender with a little spice sprinkled in (the closing spicy scene was the hottest for me).
The support characters have promise, though none of them have enough time to become fully fleshed out. The story really centers on the location itself and Blaze and Shawn's budding romance.
I do love that the story is between two large, muscular, masculine men loving each other and learning each other's bodies. It's also very low on homophobia, which is refreshing and contributes to the ease you feel as you follow Blaze and Shawn.
Angst is rather low and what's there is resolved pretty quickly, so it's perfect for readers who want to cuddle up with a book that will go easy on their heart.
Off the Trail by Elle Waters is a sweet, cozy, little MM romance following former pro baseball player Shawn and Maine local Blaze as they gently fall for each other at a rural retreat center. Shawn is in crisis and sent to find himself in rural Maine; Blaze is the outdoor coordinator at Sanctuary Lake, a place designed for healing and recovering from life's tragedies.
The story is simple, gentle, cozy, and tender with a little spice sprinkled in (the closing spicy scene was the hottest for me).
The support characters have promise, though none of them have enough time to become fully fleshed out. The story really centers on the location itself and Blaze and Shawn's budding romance.
I do love that the story is between two large, muscular, masculine men loving each other and learning each other's bodies. It's also very low on homophobia, which is refreshing and contributes to the ease you feel as you follow Blaze and Shawn.
Angst is rather low and what's there is resolved pretty quickly, so it's perfect for readers who want to cuddle up with a book that will go easy on their heart.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.75☆
I enjoyed this read! At first, I was scared I wasn't going to, because I was having a hard time caring about the protagonists, which made me scared that I wasn't going to be able to root for them as a couple. But eventually, as the characters grow into themselves and have their relationship develop, I started to genuinely like them.
This book was very cozy and comforting to read, and there are no stressors or conflicts, which makes me super giddy, as someone who gets quite anxious over conflicts in books. The vibes here are impeccable! Really cozy stuff.
Also a small detail I appreciated about this book was the sibling relationship it explored.
Blaze and Shawn's dynamic is so cute, I was giggling while reading about them (even giggling my way through the awkward dialogues). They communicate really well and that's always a good thing for me (...I may or may not study psychology).
Plus, it was surprisingly funny. I found myself, multiple times, laughing while reading this book, which is always a bonus for me.
A little thing that annoyed me was how self-deprecating Shawn is (specially at the beginning). Eventually it gets a little less annoying lol.
Thank you NetGalley and the Publisher for this eARC! This was my honest and unbiased opinion.
I enjoyed this read! At first, I was scared I wasn't going to, because I was having a hard time caring about the protagonists, which made me scared that I wasn't going to be able to root for them as a couple. But eventually, as the characters grow into themselves and have their relationship develop, I started to genuinely like them.
This book was very cozy and comforting to read, and there are no stressors or conflicts, which makes me super giddy, as someone who gets quite anxious over conflicts in books. The vibes here are impeccable! Really cozy stuff.
Also a small detail I appreciated about this book was the sibling relationship it explored.
Blaze and Shawn's dynamic is so cute, I was giggling while reading about them (even giggling my way through the awkward dialogues). They communicate really well and that's always a good thing for me (...I may or may not study psychology).
Plus, it was surprisingly funny. I found myself, multiple times, laughing while reading this book, which is always a bonus for me.
A little thing that annoyed me was how self-deprecating Shawn is (specially at the beginning). Eventually it gets a little less annoying lol.
Thank you NetGalley and the Publisher for this eARC! This was my honest and unbiased opinion.
September 21, 2026
“Off the Trail” by Elle Waters is the first book in the ‘Sanctuary Lake Retreat’ series and features reluctantly retired professional baseball player Shawn who meets retreat employee Blaze while coping with one of the lowest points in his life. The serenity of his surroundings and the attractive man who helps him enjoy them make Shawn reevaluate his priorities and force him to face a future he never anticipated.
This contemporary adult gay romance is a lovely introduction to a new series. Both of the main characters are charismatic and personable, and the “gay for you” aspect is introduced in a believable fashion. I enjoyed the small-town vibe and the way everyone works together to enhance the peaceful atmosphere of the well-named environment, and several of the secondary characters will undoubtedly get their time in the spotlight during subsequent stories. This seems like a wonderful place to visit or live in, and although I felt sad for some of the revelations that Blaze has to deal with, it was great to see him find a person who gives back to him just as he has done for others. I look forward to reading more stories in this setting.
A copy of this title was provided for review
This contemporary adult gay romance is a lovely introduction to a new series. Both of the main characters are charismatic and personable, and the “gay for you” aspect is introduced in a believable fashion. I enjoyed the small-town vibe and the way everyone works together to enhance the peaceful atmosphere of the well-named environment, and several of the secondary characters will undoubtedly get their time in the spotlight during subsequent stories. This seems like a wonderful place to visit or live in, and although I felt sad for some of the revelations that Blaze has to deal with, it was great to see him find a person who gives back to him just as he has done for others. I look forward to reading more stories in this setting.
A copy of this title was provided for review
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Extremely low-angst romance, where rural Maine is the real MVP :)
Shawn, dealing poorly with his early retirement from professional baseball, wraps his car around a lamp post and is sent by his agent to a private lakeside retreat with, horrors, no wi-fi, to sort himself out. Whereupon he starts noticing the attractiveness of the male retreat activities director, and adds to his lengthy pile of Things To Think About, "reconsidering his presumed heterosexuality." (In a low angst way!)
Blaze took on the upbringing of his younger sister after his parents died, and they now share a house though he's determined to build her her own. He loves his job at the retreat, small town life, and the only fly in the ointment is a singular lack of gay men he's mutually attracted to. Enter Shawn.
I'd recommend this to anyone looking for a very fluffy (but also spicy) autumn vibes read. The plot is straightforward, but well-written, and sometimes that's exactly what I want to read: no high drama, just life working out for people.
Rating: 15/20
This review is based upon a complimentary advance review copy provided by the publisher.
Shawn, dealing poorly with his early retirement from professional baseball, wraps his car around a lamp post and is sent by his agent to a private lakeside retreat with, horrors, no wi-fi, to sort himself out. Whereupon he starts noticing the attractiveness of the male retreat activities director, and adds to his lengthy pile of Things To Think About, "reconsidering his presumed heterosexuality." (In a low angst way!)
Blaze took on the upbringing of his younger sister after his parents died, and they now share a house though he's determined to build her her own. He loves his job at the retreat, small town life, and the only fly in the ointment is a singular lack of gay men he's mutually attracted to. Enter Shawn.
I'd recommend this to anyone looking for a very fluffy (but also spicy) autumn vibes read. The plot is straightforward, but well-written, and sometimes that's exactly what I want to read: no high drama, just life working out for people.
Rating: 15/20
This review is based upon a complimentary advance review copy provided by the publisher.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This is a perfect cozy fall read. Grab your blanket and sit outside in you hammock for this MxM romance that takes place in the woods of Maine during fall. Off The Trail by Elle Waters is a great writer and I will be reading some more of Elle's work for sure this year! This book is perfect for those looking for both cozy romance and a little steamy times. This is a very easy read for those looking to finish a book this year and cozy up with the fall vibes.
Blaze is the perfect representation of gay Mainer living in the woods working for a resort and really makes you want to find a resort of your own. I love how much this character obviously cares for others and grows through the book to care about himself more and learn to change and grow. Shawn is a former professional baseball player looking to learn how to live off the field. He ends up in a car crash where his agent decides to send him to a nature retreat where there is no service and very few people. Join Shawn as he discovers his sexuality may not be what he thought, life can be good with no phone and how to live off the trail.
Thank you to Victory Editing NetGalley, and Elle Waters for the ARC!
Blaze is the perfect representation of gay Mainer living in the woods working for a resort and really makes you want to find a resort of your own. I love how much this character obviously cares for others and grows through the book to care about himself more and learn to change and grow. Shawn is a former professional baseball player looking to learn how to live off the field. He ends up in a car crash where his agent decides to send him to a nature retreat where there is no service and very few people. Join Shawn as he discovers his sexuality may not be what he thought, life can be good with no phone and how to live off the trail.
Thank you to Victory Editing NetGalley, and Elle Waters for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Review of an advance copy from NetGalley. No incentive was provided in exchange for my honest opinion.
Injured professional athlete figuring out their life after losing their career is a fairly well trodden premise within the genre. This story doesn't veer far from the path. Blaze and Shawn's relationship is cosy, fairly low angst with moderate spice. It doesn't ask too much of the reader, and gives a bit more in return. So a favourable deal.
Shawn discovering what life looks like after baseball, and Blaze figuring his way out of a somewhat self-imposed isolation are dealt with in a gentle way that never really leaves you in doubt of the HEA.
The side characters are a little underdeveloped for my taste, I would have liked a few more pages on each of them. There definitely feels like some setup work was being done for subsequent books; Josh and Nolan, possibly Luis, spring to mind.
I do wish the narrative voicing was a little more distinct. There were times when I had to double-check whose perspective I was following because the voicing was so similar.
Overall, a comfortable read, 3.5*
Injured professional athlete figuring out their life after losing their career is a fairly well trodden premise within the genre. This story doesn't veer far from the path. Blaze and Shawn's relationship is cosy, fairly low angst with moderate spice. It doesn't ask too much of the reader, and gives a bit more in return. So a favourable deal.
Shawn discovering what life looks like after baseball, and Blaze figuring his way out of a somewhat self-imposed isolation are dealt with in a gentle way that never really leaves you in doubt of the HEA.
The side characters are a little underdeveloped for my taste, I would have liked a few more pages on each of them. There definitely feels like some setup work was being done for subsequent books; Josh and Nolan, possibly Luis, spring to mind.
I do wish the narrative voicing was a little more distinct. There were times when I had to double-check whose perspective I was following because the voicing was so similar.
Overall, a comfortable read, 3.5*
Review of advance copy received from Author
Advance Copy Review:
I absolutely loved the coziness of this book!
This is the perfect book to read in front of a fireplace with some warm coffee on a winter day. Perfect to snuggle with.
Story takes place in a small town. When a professional baseball player is forced into an early retirement and is sent to a lakeside retreat to find himself again, after a horrible car accidents... following his realization that his career as a professional athlete is over.
There, is where he meets the retreat's activities director and for the first time ever, finds himself attracted to a man...
I'll let you read the book so you can immerse yourself in this story as they both figure things out in every way.... especially intimately.
I love a self discovery... slow angst... lingering love story.
One of my favorite quotes was when they were looking at the clear sky full of stars :
"I read a book once where they called it Cosmic Insignificance theory. Being out here reminds you that nothing you do really matters in the big scheme of the Universe."
There's more on that paragraph, but I won't spoil it! 🤭
I give this a 4.5 ⭐️
And 2.5 🌶 level.
Hope you enjoy it!
I absolutely loved the coziness of this book!
This is the perfect book to read in front of a fireplace with some warm coffee on a winter day. Perfect to snuggle with.
Story takes place in a small town. When a professional baseball player is forced into an early retirement and is sent to a lakeside retreat to find himself again, after a horrible car accidents... following his realization that his career as a professional athlete is over.
There, is where he meets the retreat's activities director and for the first time ever, finds himself attracted to a man...
I'll let you read the book so you can immerse yourself in this story as they both figure things out in every way.... especially intimately.
I love a self discovery... slow angst... lingering love story.
One of my favorite quotes was when they were looking at the clear sky full of stars :
"I read a book once where they called it Cosmic Insignificance theory. Being out here reminds you that nothing you do really matters in the big scheme of the Universe."
There's more on that paragraph, but I won't spoil it! 🤭
I give this a 4.5 ⭐️
And 2.5 🌶 level.
Hope you enjoy it!
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
Cozy is the perfect word to describe this book - it made me wish I read it while under a blanket on the couch! Shawn and Blaze’s relationship was all kinds of sweet and I read it in a day, which never happens anymore.
Shawn is a retired pro baseball player who isn’t ready for retirement, acts out and gets sent to Sanctuary Lake to do some soul searching. One of the first people he meets when he arrives is Blaze, the retreat’s outdoor activities director. Then, once they meet, they’re in each other’s orbit, spending time together as friends and then more. It felt like a natural progression with some of the awkwardness I’ve come to expect from awakening stories. But Shawn and Blaze were incredibly sweet together, genuinely enjoyed each other’s company and knew just what to say to help each other consider new possibilities.
The “black moment” (if you could even call it that) was a little strange and felt like it was happening for the sake of it happening, not really to progress the story - I think it could have progressed some other way without pulling them apart. I also felt like there were too many side characters who didn’t really add much to the story, but were just pesky enough that it felt like they needed stories of their own - it was a little confusing and took me out of the main storyline a few times.
Overall, I really enjoyed this and I’ll be on the lookout for the next book in the series to come out!
Shawn is a retired pro baseball player who isn’t ready for retirement, acts out and gets sent to Sanctuary Lake to do some soul searching. One of the first people he meets when he arrives is Blaze, the retreat’s outdoor activities director. Then, once they meet, they’re in each other’s orbit, spending time together as friends and then more. It felt like a natural progression with some of the awkwardness I’ve come to expect from awakening stories. But Shawn and Blaze were incredibly sweet together, genuinely enjoyed each other’s company and knew just what to say to help each other consider new possibilities.
The “black moment” (if you could even call it that) was a little strange and felt like it was happening for the sake of it happening, not really to progress the story - I think it could have progressed some other way without pulling them apart. I also felt like there were too many side characters who didn’t really add much to the story, but were just pesky enough that it felt like they needed stories of their own - it was a little confusing and took me out of the main storyline a few times.
Overall, I really enjoyed this and I’ll be on the lookout for the next book in the series to come out!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 102 reviews