I always find it difficult to “review” or analyze the story of a person’s life. It always takes a lot of courage and confidence to share a story, which is so personal. So, it feels odd. It feels more like critiquing a life, instead of the literary skills of an author. That’s why I find it unfathomable when some readers verbally eviscerate books of this nature.
That being said, I mostly enjoyed “Getting Real.” At first, I will be blatantly clear and candid, I did not enjoy it. I bought it, started it, and stopped it. Three months later, I returned to it…
I originally found some portions of the narrative to be overly self-aggrandizing. Specifically, I thought she might have overemphasized and overplayed her violin talents. But I do acknowledge she was probably a stellar player, she put in a lot of work, and it was a big part of her life. But I don’t like some of her lines that she uses for description…as an example, I didn’t like the section where she described “being burdened by her talents.” A lot of children across America do not have the ability to ever see an instrument —not just because of “talent,” but because of a lack of financial support or emotional encouragement. I would never consider a “talent” a “burden.” It was a luxury and a blessing that she was raised in an environment, where she was provided with this opportunity. She could’ve just as easily been born in a totally different environment, and her life would’ve been insanely different. Carlson seems to be cognizant of this fact and she expresses it at various points, but some of her lines do not align with the notion. In other words, she may not have been meaning to sound pretentious; and given the chance to interact with my review, she would likely even agree with me about instruments being a blessing / luxury. But nonetheless, I still think it’s important to point out.
My mouth also dropped—literally dropped—whenever I read the section, where she claimed she wanted to be “fat” as a child to avoid being too perfect. I don’t buy this. To be crude and colloquial, I call bull shit.
In spite of these critiques, I found her story more powerful whenever she started talking about the Miss America competition. I like her focus on diligence and perseverance, and I absolutely adored hearing about her children. I also enjoyed her description of her value system; it felt genuine and I appreciated that. Finally, I LOVE her emphasis on failure —the way that failures can lead us to success, if handled effectively.
I read another review that heavily criticized Gretchen’s attitude and called her out for being a “perfectionist” and leading a “boring life.” I couldn’t disagree more. I come from an entirely different background from this woman, but I really identified with her description of perfectionism. To an outsider who may not think this way, it might seem haughty and arrogant. But I would argue, being someone who has spent time feeling and oftentimes struggling with similar emotions, it genuinely is a type of drive that you’re almost born with —one that can be impossible to shake. It can really define who you are, and help you accomplish goals. It can also be painful and difficult at times. Her life wasn’t boring, and I imagine a hateful, bitter person would cast a judgement of this nature. She really did accomplish a lot, and did so many fascinating things that I’ll never get to personally experience. I liked hearing about those.
Overall, I found her story to be inspiring and I am thankful she shared it. If I could offer suggestions though, I would recommend more thought be placed into the phraseology of certain lines.