Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

That Asian Girl Is a Problem: Confessions of a Recovering Good Girl

Not yet published
Expected 27 Apr 27
Rate this book
In a world that tells women of colour they are either too much or not enough, Rachel Phan asks: What if being a “problem” is actually the point?

That Asian Girl Is a Problem is a bold, witty, and uncompromising collection about what it means to live as a racialized woman in spaces that were never built for you. Drawing from her own experiences, Phan dives into the contradictions of being the “problem” woman in the workplace, in family, in faith, in marriage and even in her own body. With sharp humour and unflinching honesty, she exposes the absurdity of a society that demands gratitude, silence and smallness from women of colour—and explores what happens when they finally refuse.

From a court transcript satirizing how racialized women are “tried” for being too much at work, to a tongue-in-cheek ‘recipe’ for the perfect Asian female body, to searing reflections on filial piety, interracial marriage, fatphobia, queerness and impostor syndrome, That Asian Girl Is a Problem blends memoir, cultural critique and playful experimentation to expose the pressures racialized women face—and the thrill of living on your own terms.

Part social commentary, part coming-of-age, part rebellion, this book transforms every insult and “flaw” into an act of resilience and defiance. For anyone who’s ever been called difficult, too much, or simply a problem, Rachel Phan offers both recognition and a rallying cry: being a problem might be the most honest and freeing way to live.

224 pages, Paperback

Expected publication April 27, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Rachel Phan

3 books73 followers
Rachel Phan is a bestselling Chinese Canadian author. A graduate of Toronto Metropolitan University’s Master of Journalism program, she and her work have been featured on CBC, The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, Toronto Star, Chatelaine, and Maclean’s. Her instant national bestselling book, Restaurant Kid: A Memoir of Family and Belonging, was longlisted for Canada Reads in 2026 and named one of CBC Books’ Best Books of 2025.

Follow her on Instagram: @rachelmphan

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
10 (66%)
4 stars
3 (20%)
3 stars
1 (6%)
2 stars
1 (6%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews
Profile Image for Liann Zhang.
Author 3 books926 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 5, 2026
My official blurb for this lovely collection of essays:
"Every part as compelling, honest, and relatable as her debut memoir, Rachel Phan returns with a bold collection of essays that highlights the contradictory nature of existing as an Asian girl in modern society. That Asian Girl is a Problem achieves the herculean feat of addressing a wide-range of topics through essays that are innovative, witty, and incredibly breezy to read. It’s a book that everyone will see themselves in, whether they’re a problematic Asian girl or not."
Profile Image for Vic.
226 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy
October 9, 2026
Rachel Phan wrote a book that spoke to how I often feel in white spaces and even within my own community. Almost everything she said sounded like things lots of Asian women feel, but shouldn't say out loud because we're supposed to be obedient, passive, and always the ones to shove aside our own thoughts and feelings to please everybody else.
Her writing was genius, particularly the pages in between chapters that had a bingo card and checklists.They were very tongue-in-cheek, highlighting all the ways us Asian girls and women can be perceived as problematic. Similarly, there was a parody of Rachel being on trial for some "offenses" she committed in a work setting. It couldn't have been more relatable! I appreciated her sense of humour for such an upsetting topic.
Some points Rachel made in the last chapter were quite bold, verging on controversial. I didn't necessarily agree with everything she said about the publishing industry, but I understood what she was getting at and why she felt the way she did.
Rachel, if you ever read this review, I thought you were too harsh on yourself regarding your first book!
444 reviews5 followers
November 16, 2026
I really related to a lot of the feelings Rachel writes about in this book, namely the tough emotions she feels towards her parents. I cried at one point, reading about how her parents' relationship improved after Rachel's first book was published.
At certain times, I was challenging myself because I'd reacted a bit dismissively towards the things Rachel writes about: frustrations with being Asian in the workplace, or relationships with men. "Why aren't you taking more agency, are you SURE it's stereotypes that are preventing your promotion or is it your perceived lack of impact, which would be more of a gender than race issue?" but that's probably my internalized racism speaking (which is very hard to get rid of!!)

I found the checklists throughout the book very heavy-handed, could just be me though.
Profile Image for Jennifer Moffatt.
Author 13 books125 followers
Review of advance copy
October 24, 2026
A big fan of Rachel Phan's first book, Restaurant Kid, I was eager to read That Asian Girl is a Problem (with a shoutout to my local bookstore who emailed me that I could pick up my preordered copy early!) and I'm happy to say that Phan exceeded my expectations. I think I liked this second memoir even more. Honest, funny, heartbreaking, unflinching, eye-opening... The section on body image was especially poignant for me, and the ending had me in tears (the good emotional kind). I am grateful Rachel has continued to share her stories with us and am saddened by the realities of the racism she endured growing up and as an adult. All Canadians should read her work and I hope it inspires us all to do better and lift up marginalized voices. I look forward to reading every book Rachel Phan writes.
1 review
November 7, 2026
Picked this up at the Word on the Street book market in Toronto!

As an Asian Canadian that grew up in Markham, I didn’t feel like I could relate to a lot of the experiences Rachel described, but I can appreciate her honesty and openness in sharing them. I think the first bit fell flat for me as it was a series of ideas that I’ve heard about/talked about at length before and I was hoping to hear a different perspective or way of talking about them, but it felt very familiar, so I was tiptoeing into DNF territory.

Halfway through this book, I went on a trip to China for 3 weeks.

Picking this back up after the trip was like picking up an entirely different book. My trip highlighted all of the things that were described in the book and I saw some of the effects of a complicated body image, relationship with sexuality, and work performance as a woman in real time. I think this is what ultimately motivated me to keep reading and eventually finish this book. It’s unapoligetically open, familiar, and comforting to hear another person’s experience.
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews