What do you think?
Rate this book
One of Them Is Lying
They all have secrets and no one can leave.
When Stella lands a job working at Titheridge Farm, she’s thrilled. She’s aware of what kind of man Alan Titheridge is – he’s been embroiled in scandals for months - but it’s now her job to try to clear his name.
Stella plans a weekend at the farm for the family and invites five VIP guests, in a bid to win them over. But as everyone arrives for their country break, a storm is brewing.
Forty-eight hours later, someone is dead.
Trapped by the weather and all with secrets of their own, one of the partygoers is lying and one isn’t who they say they are. Now they must work out who they can trust, before it’s too late…
When Stella lands a job working at Titheridge Farm, she’s thrilled. She’s aware of what kind of man Alan Titheridge is – he’s been embroiled in scandals for months - but it’s now her job to try to clear his name.
Stella plans a weekend at the farm for the family and invites five VIP guests, in a bid to win them over. But as everyone arrives for their country break, a storm is brewing.
Forty-eight hours later, someone is dead.
Trapped by the weather and all with secrets of their own, one of the partygoers is lying and one isn’t who they say they are. Now they must work out who they can trust, before it’s too late…
288 pages, Paperback
First published May 10, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews
May 8, 2026
I was excited to dive into this one thanks to a complimentary copy from Boldwood Books via NetGalley, especially since I’ve enjoyed a previous book from this author and tend to gravitate toward thrillers from this publisher. Unfortunately, this one just didn’t land for me.
The story is broken into five sections, which I actually like from a structural standpoint, but the first half felt like very little was happening. It ended up being a real slog to push through. I’m absolutely on board for setup and a slow burn, but this didn’t feel like that so much as it did stalled pacing without enough momentum to keep me engaged.
By the time the action finally picked up, I was already pretty disengaged, which made it difficult to fully connect with what was unfolding. I did manage to enjoy a decent stretch later on, but overall it was hard to fully recover from that slow start. Unfortunately, the plot also felt predictable at times, a bit convoluted, and occasionally unclear in its direction.
So this ended up being a miss for me, but as always, reading is subjective.
The story is broken into five sections, which I actually like from a structural standpoint, but the first half felt like very little was happening. It ended up being a real slog to push through. I’m absolutely on board for setup and a slow burn, but this didn’t feel like that so much as it did stalled pacing without enough momentum to keep me engaged.
By the time the action finally picked up, I was already pretty disengaged, which made it difficult to fully connect with what was unfolding. I did manage to enjoy a decent stretch later on, but overall it was hard to fully recover from that slow start. Unfortunately, the plot also felt predictable at times, a bit convoluted, and occasionally unclear in its direction.
So this ended up being a miss for me, but as always, reading is subjective.
May 11, 2026
Y’all, CL Swatman had me side-eyeing EVERYONE. 🌩️🔪
A storm-trapped farmhouse, scandal, secrets, suspicious guests, and then… someone dies. The tension in this book was thicker than Mississippi humidity. 😅 Every conversation felt loaded, and nobody seemed trustworthy.
Stella was a strong lead trying to hold chaos together while everything quietly unraveled around her. Swatman’s writing is sharp, fast-paced, and packed with that delicious “something is VERY wrong here” energy.
Parts didn’t completely knock me out, but this was still a twisty, addictive thriller that kept me flipping pages faster than 👀.
Thanks to Boldwood Books for providing this review copy via #NetGalley for my honest, voluntary review. #OneOfThemIsLying #CLSwatman #NewRelease #BoldwoodBooks
A storm-trapped farmhouse, scandal, secrets, suspicious guests, and then… someone dies. The tension in this book was thicker than Mississippi humidity. 😅 Every conversation felt loaded, and nobody seemed trustworthy.
Stella was a strong lead trying to hold chaos together while everything quietly unraveled around her. Swatman’s writing is sharp, fast-paced, and packed with that delicious “something is VERY wrong here” energy.
Parts didn’t completely knock me out, but this was still a twisty, addictive thriller that kept me flipping pages faster than 👀.
Thanks to Boldwood Books for providing this review copy via #NetGalley for my honest, voluntary review. #OneOfThemIsLying #CLSwatman #NewRelease #BoldwoodBooks
June 10, 2026
**review to come**
May 16, 2026
3,5 stars
It took me quite a while to finish this book because I’ve been sick or rather, I still am.
Overall, the book was very well written, and I absolutely loved the author’s writing style. However, the story itself felt a little underwhelming to me. It had so much potential, but I kept wanting more from it.
Especially towards the end, I would’ve loved to see more of what happened afterward, since the ending felt a bit too abrupt for my taste. I also wish there had been more about Renee and Abigail. In the end, I did enjoy the book and I truly think it had a lot of potential, I just wanted the story to give a little more.
It took me quite a while to finish this book because I’ve been sick or rather, I still am.
Overall, the book was very well written, and I absolutely loved the author’s writing style. However, the story itself felt a little underwhelming to me. It had so much potential, but I kept wanting more from it.
Especially towards the end, I would’ve loved to see more of what happened afterward, since the ending felt a bit too abrupt for my taste. I also wish there had been more about Renee and Abigail. In the end, I did enjoy the book and I truly think it had a lot of potential, I just wanted the story to give a little more.
April 19, 2026
One Of Them Is Lying by CL Swatman, Stella has been hired by Alan Titheridge to boost his popularity. it’s been in the news that he’s allowed poaching on his land and that he cheated on his longtime wife Rhonda. Stella comes up with a great idea to have a big bang get together with five VIP guest and something that is also going to help a charity and gets the OK from Alan. The only thing is Alan doesn’t know Stella has a whole different ulterior motive for embellishing her CV and getting the job. It seems this isn’t the first she’s met the family and no matter how nice he seems she knows him differently. what Stella knows is by far the lesser of two evils because what she finds out is even more explosive. on the VIP weekend his daughters Renee and Romilly will also be there when the road gets cut off and a thunderstorm is happening it will be nothing compared to the hurricane inside the house and not everyone will live through it. I really really like this book the only thing that made me pause was when a five-year-old was talking about how she hated her daddy and I knew that it is natural for children to love their parents even if they’re abusive they want their parents Love so even though I knew this part was wrong it didn’t overshadowed the book so that I didn’t enjoy it I absolutely did it was well put together I like Stella I like the guy who worked in the the farm building or whatever it was I think his name was Tom I wish I was better at writing stuff like that down this was a great book they do have a trigger warning of incest so there’s that but if you could stomach that the rest is really a great read. #NetGalley, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview,
May 31, 2026
2.75⭐️
This read more like Women’s Fiction rather than a Mystery/Thriller. A slow start, the writing giving away a twist early on, and the pace picking up only after 45% of the book was done 🫠
Characters being written to make the worst possible choice only so another character experiences even more trauma is…really frustrating to read. If I say more it will spoil a portion of the book but…why drive into woods when the person RAN into the woods? All you needed was a flashlight…*sigh* 😮💨
Personally, s**ual assault does not make a story more compelling or thrilling for me. Sometimes it seems like authors put that in their books as a shocking twist but I hate it honestly - it doesn’t add anything to the read imo and it is a prominent piece of discussion in this book.
If characters being shocked and traumatized into silence as they watch their lives and the lives of others crumble as they themselves admit to cowardice doesn’t sound like an enjoyable read, this book probably isn’t for you.
TW: r*pe, p*dophilia, some language
This read more like Women’s Fiction rather than a Mystery/Thriller. A slow start, the writing giving away a twist early on, and the pace picking up only after 45% of the book was done 🫠
Characters being written to make the worst possible choice only so another character experiences even more trauma is…really frustrating to read. If I say more it will spoil a portion of the book but…why drive into woods when the person RAN into the woods? All you needed was a flashlight…*sigh* 😮💨
Personally, s**ual assault does not make a story more compelling or thrilling for me. Sometimes it seems like authors put that in their books as a shocking twist but I hate it honestly - it doesn’t add anything to the read imo and it is a prominent piece of discussion in this book.
If characters being shocked and traumatized into silence as they watch their lives and the lives of others crumble as they themselves admit to cowardice doesn’t sound like an enjoyable read, this book probably isn’t for you.
TW: r*pe, p*dophilia, some language
May 11, 2026
This was the first book I’ve read from C.L. Swatman and definitely won’t be my last. I absolutely loved the Agatha Christie vibes I was getting from this book with the isolated weekend gathering and long list of suspects. The plot smoothly shifted into a domestic psychological thriller as the mystery unraveled with each twist. One of Them is Lying is an unputdownable page-turner and an easy five star read for me.
May 10, 2026
Revenge makes one do strange things!!! I went into this book knowing absolutely nothing about it. It was a slow burn from the beginning but it picked up speed and never stopped till the end. Many many twists at the end and this left me a little confused. Much thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this early release. It’s out tomorrow!
Trigger warning: rape multiple times towards the end
Trigger warning: rape multiple times towards the end
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 21, 2026
An excellent mystery full of plot twists,turns and surprises. I recommend this book to anyone who enjoys reading unusual mysteries.
May 14, 2026
Before diving in, I do think this book could really benefit from trigger warnings. It contains discussions of sexual abuse and child sexual abuse, and this is definitely not a light, popcorn-style thriller.
That said, I still really enjoyed this one overall. The setup gave me strong Agatha Christie vibes — an isolated farmhouse, a storm trapping everyone inside, a long list of suspicious guests, and secrets everywhere you turn. Once the tension really kicked in, I was completely hooked trying to figure out who could actually be trusted. At one point or another, I genuinely suspected everyone.
I will admit the first quarter of the book felt a little slow for me. While the character introductions and setup were necessary, it took some time before the story really grabbed me. But once the twists started coming, the pacing picked up significantly and became much more addictive. I especially loved the claustrophobic atmosphere and the constant sense that something was deeply wrong beneath the surface.
The characters themselves weren’t always likable, but they were compelling, layered, and messy in a way that worked really well for this type of thriller. Stella was an especially interesting lead, and I liked slowly uncovering what was really going on at Titheridge Farm.
My only real disappointment was the ending. I liked the direction the author chose, but it felt a bit abrupt compared to the intensity of the chapters leading up to it. I would have loved a little more time spent fleshing everything out after the final reveals.
Overall though, this was a dark, twisty, atmospheric thriller that kept me guessing and delivered plenty of tension and suspicion along the way. If you enjoy isolated-setting mysteries, morally messy characters, and slow-burn psychological suspense, this is definitely worth picking up.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
That said, I still really enjoyed this one overall. The setup gave me strong Agatha Christie vibes — an isolated farmhouse, a storm trapping everyone inside, a long list of suspicious guests, and secrets everywhere you turn. Once the tension really kicked in, I was completely hooked trying to figure out who could actually be trusted. At one point or another, I genuinely suspected everyone.
I will admit the first quarter of the book felt a little slow for me. While the character introductions and setup were necessary, it took some time before the story really grabbed me. But once the twists started coming, the pacing picked up significantly and became much more addictive. I especially loved the claustrophobic atmosphere and the constant sense that something was deeply wrong beneath the surface.
The characters themselves weren’t always likable, but they were compelling, layered, and messy in a way that worked really well for this type of thriller. Stella was an especially interesting lead, and I liked slowly uncovering what was really going on at Titheridge Farm.
My only real disappointment was the ending. I liked the direction the author chose, but it felt a bit abrupt compared to the intensity of the chapters leading up to it. I would have loved a little more time spent fleshing everything out after the final reveals.
Overall though, this was a dark, twisty, atmospheric thriller that kept me guessing and delivered plenty of tension and suspicion along the way. If you enjoy isolated-setting mysteries, morally messy characters, and slow-burn psychological suspense, this is definitely worth picking up.
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
May 24, 2026
★★½☆☆
I am always entirely on board for a locked-in mystery, but unfortunately, this one didn't manage to deliver on its promise. When Stella lands a job at Titheridge Farm, she is absolutely thrilled. She is well aware of the scandals surrounding her new boss, Alan Titheridge, but it is her responsibility to try and clear his name. In a bid to win over five VIP guests, she plans a weekend break for them at the farm, but a massive storm quickly traps everyone inside. Forty-eight hours later, someone is dead, and with the weather keeping them stuck together, they realize that someone is lying about who they really are.
The story is broken into five distinct sections, which worked well from a structural standpoint, but the first half felt like a massive slog to push through. I enjoy setup and a slow burn, but this didn't feel like a true slow burn so much as it did stalled pacing without enough momentum to keep me engaged. Absolutely nothing happens until you are about eighty percent of the way through the book, which is when the text finally offers something remotely interesting. I kept hoping the pace would pick up, but instead, I found myself checking the percentage remaining on my Kindle just to see how much farther I had to go to get to the point.
The plot ultimately strained credulity, and the final reveal felt incredibly rushed and not fleshed out enough, which was frustrating given how drawn out the first half was. There were far too many characters introduced, particularly the VIP guests, who felt entirely unnecessary, lacked depth, and were hard to follow. Because the cast was so bloated, several storylines were left completely unfinished, including the actual ending for the overarching mystery. It was a strong premise, but between the inconsistent character behaviour and a very meh ending, it just didn't land for me.
Thank you to the author, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley for the ARC.
I am always entirely on board for a locked-in mystery, but unfortunately, this one didn't manage to deliver on its promise. When Stella lands a job at Titheridge Farm, she is absolutely thrilled. She is well aware of the scandals surrounding her new boss, Alan Titheridge, but it is her responsibility to try and clear his name. In a bid to win over five VIP guests, she plans a weekend break for them at the farm, but a massive storm quickly traps everyone inside. Forty-eight hours later, someone is dead, and with the weather keeping them stuck together, they realize that someone is lying about who they really are.
The story is broken into five distinct sections, which worked well from a structural standpoint, but the first half felt like a massive slog to push through. I enjoy setup and a slow burn, but this didn't feel like a true slow burn so much as it did stalled pacing without enough momentum to keep me engaged. Absolutely nothing happens until you are about eighty percent of the way through the book, which is when the text finally offers something remotely interesting. I kept hoping the pace would pick up, but instead, I found myself checking the percentage remaining on my Kindle just to see how much farther I had to go to get to the point.
The plot ultimately strained credulity, and the final reveal felt incredibly rushed and not fleshed out enough, which was frustrating given how drawn out the first half was. There were far too many characters introduced, particularly the VIP guests, who felt entirely unnecessary, lacked depth, and were hard to follow. Because the cast was so bloated, several storylines were left completely unfinished, including the actual ending for the overarching mystery. It was a strong premise, but between the inconsistent character behaviour and a very meh ending, it just didn't land for me.
Thank you to the author, Boldwood Books, and NetGalley for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The first thing that needs to be said about this novel is that it is not a casual read. There are scenes of graphic sexual violence, some of them involving a child. I'm not sure if the publisher will be including a warning, and I wanted to make sure I did that before I write this review.
A young woman named Stella shows up at Titheridge Farm, a fake resume and list of references in hand. She is being interviewed to help Alan Titheridge with his rather messy public persona. He's quite wealthy and runs a retreat of sorts at the farm where guests come to enjoy the countryside. There is skeet shooting, axe throwing—even a spa on the premises—but he's been embroiled in so much bad press as of late that no one is spending money to come and stay on his property. He has a thing for the ladies, which would be fine if he wasn't married to a lovely woman named Rhonda, and has become a favorite target for photographers and journalists alike.
Once Stella is hired, she sets up a weekend of activities and invites several VIP guests in hopes of putting Alan's image in a more positive light. A huge storm blows in and cuts the electricity. Later, it's learned that a large tree has been felled cutting off access to and from the property. Thank goodness there's plenty of food and drink. Unfortunately, things get worse when someone is murdered. There are difficult relationships between most of the people trapped inside the Titheridge home. There are different journalists working for rival news agencies, estranged family members … and is Stella who she claims to be?
As dark as some of this narrative is—and some of it is truly dark—I have to say that I found this book to be incredibly engaging. It was not exactly what I expected, but that isn't a complaint. The plot was interesting and Swatman delivered a fantastic twist.
A young woman named Stella shows up at Titheridge Farm, a fake resume and list of references in hand. She is being interviewed to help Alan Titheridge with his rather messy public persona. He's quite wealthy and runs a retreat of sorts at the farm where guests come to enjoy the countryside. There is skeet shooting, axe throwing—even a spa on the premises—but he's been embroiled in so much bad press as of late that no one is spending money to come and stay on his property. He has a thing for the ladies, which would be fine if he wasn't married to a lovely woman named Rhonda, and has become a favorite target for photographers and journalists alike.
Once Stella is hired, she sets up a weekend of activities and invites several VIP guests in hopes of putting Alan's image in a more positive light. A huge storm blows in and cuts the electricity. Later, it's learned that a large tree has been felled cutting off access to and from the property. Thank goodness there's plenty of food and drink. Unfortunately, things get worse when someone is murdered. There are difficult relationships between most of the people trapped inside the Titheridge home. There are different journalists working for rival news agencies, estranged family members … and is Stella who she claims to be?
As dark as some of this narrative is—and some of it is truly dark—I have to say that I found this book to be incredibly engaging. It was not exactly what I expected, but that isn't a complaint. The plot was interesting and Swatman delivered a fantastic twist.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A Crucial Trigger Warning is Required:
Readers must be advised that this book contains extremely graphic and disturbing content. The subject matter includes explicit depictions and discussion of sexual violence, specifically rape and child molestation. Those who are sensitive to these topics or who have personal trauma related to them should exercise extreme caution before proceeding. This is not a casual read, and the publisher should ensure this warning is prominently displayed.
Initial Shock and Storyline Assessment:
Frankly, I was taken aback by the depth and darkness of the narrative. I went into this expecting a different kind of story entirely. However, once I adjusted to the challenging themes, I found the core storyline to be compelling and, in a dark way, deeply engaging. While the subject matter is undeniably difficult, the author crafted a plot that held my attention from the first page to the last. The pace was excellent; it was a quick, engrossing read that didn't linger unnecessarily on the horrific details but handled them with a necessary gravity.
Recommendation:
I can only recommend this title with a strong, unambiguous caveat. If you are certain you do not have any triggers related to the subjects of rape, child abuse, or other forms of sexual violence, the storyline itself is well-executed and warrants attention. It is a powerful, albeit disturbing, piece of work. For all other readers, please prioritize your mental health and well-being; this book may simply not be for you.
A Note of Gratitude:
My sincere thanks to #NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this Advanced Reader Copy (ARC).
Readers must be advised that this book contains extremely graphic and disturbing content. The subject matter includes explicit depictions and discussion of sexual violence, specifically rape and child molestation. Those who are sensitive to these topics or who have personal trauma related to them should exercise extreme caution before proceeding. This is not a casual read, and the publisher should ensure this warning is prominently displayed.
Initial Shock and Storyline Assessment:
Frankly, I was taken aback by the depth and darkness of the narrative. I went into this expecting a different kind of story entirely. However, once I adjusted to the challenging themes, I found the core storyline to be compelling and, in a dark way, deeply engaging. While the subject matter is undeniably difficult, the author crafted a plot that held my attention from the first page to the last. The pace was excellent; it was a quick, engrossing read that didn't linger unnecessarily on the horrific details but handled them with a necessary gravity.
Recommendation:
I can only recommend this title with a strong, unambiguous caveat. If you are certain you do not have any triggers related to the subjects of rape, child abuse, or other forms of sexual violence, the storyline itself is well-executed and warrants attention. It is a powerful, albeit disturbing, piece of work. For all other readers, please prioritize your mental health and well-being; this book may simply not be for you.
A Note of Gratitude:
My sincere thanks to #NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this Advanced Reader Copy (ARC).
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
One of Them Is Lying by C.L. Swatman is a compelling and emotionally layered thriller that blends mystery with deeply personal stakes.
From the outset, the story pulls you in with a strong sense of intrigue—there’s an immediate question of truth versus deception that keeps you hooked. Swatman builds tension effectively, creating an atmosphere where doubt lingers over every interaction and nothing feels entirely certain.
What sets this book apart is its emotional core. Beneath the mystery, there’s a powerful exploration of relationships, trust, and the consequences of secrets. The characters feel real and flawed, and their motivations unfold in a way that adds depth to the story. I found myself especially drawn to how the narrative balances suspense with introspection.
The pacing is steady, with a gradual build that allows both the plot and the emotional elements to develop. While it’s not a nonstop thriller, the tension simmers throughout, leading to a series of reveals that are both engaging and, at times, surprising.
There were a few moments where the story felt slightly predictable, but the strength of the writing and the emotional investment in the characters made up for it. Swatman’s style is accessible and immersive, making it easy to get lost in the story.
Overall, One of Them Is Lying is an engaging and thoughtful thriller that offers more than just twists—it delivers a meaningful look at trust, truth, and the impact of the choices we make. It’s a great pick for readers who enjoy character-driven suspense with emotional depth.
From the outset, the story pulls you in with a strong sense of intrigue—there’s an immediate question of truth versus deception that keeps you hooked. Swatman builds tension effectively, creating an atmosphere where doubt lingers over every interaction and nothing feels entirely certain.
What sets this book apart is its emotional core. Beneath the mystery, there’s a powerful exploration of relationships, trust, and the consequences of secrets. The characters feel real and flawed, and their motivations unfold in a way that adds depth to the story. I found myself especially drawn to how the narrative balances suspense with introspection.
The pacing is steady, with a gradual build that allows both the plot and the emotional elements to develop. While it’s not a nonstop thriller, the tension simmers throughout, leading to a series of reveals that are both engaging and, at times, surprising.
There were a few moments where the story felt slightly predictable, but the strength of the writing and the emotional investment in the characters made up for it. Swatman’s style is accessible and immersive, making it easy to get lost in the story.
Overall, One of Them Is Lying is an engaging and thoughtful thriller that offers more than just twists—it delivers a meaningful look at trust, truth, and the impact of the choices we make. It’s a great pick for readers who enjoy character-driven suspense with emotional depth.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
One of Them Is Lying is one of those thrillers that creeps up on you, tightening its hold page by page until you realise you’ve read half the book without looking up. From the moment Stella arrives at Titheridge Farm, there’s a quiet sense of unease, as though the house itself is bracing for what’s coming.
The setup is irresistible: a disgraced public figure hoping for redemption, a carefully selected group of guests with their own hidden motives, and a storm rolling in that cuts them off from the world just as tensions begin to rise. The author captures that deliciously claustrophobic feeling of being trapped with people you’re not sure you should trust, and it gives the whole story a low, steady hum of dread.
What really works here is the slow reveal of secrets. Nothing is handed over too quickly; instead, the truth seeps out in small, unsettling moments that shift your understanding of each character. Everyone is hiding something, and the book plays with that uncertainty beautifully. By the time the inevitable death occurs, it feels like the natural breaking point of all the pressure simmering beneath the surface.
Atmospheric, pacey, and full of those subtle twists that make you second‑guess every assumption, One of Them Is Lying is a perfect pick for readers who love a storm‑lashed setting, a cast full of secrets, and that irresistible “just one more chapter” pull.
With thanks to CL Swatman, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
The setup is irresistible: a disgraced public figure hoping for redemption, a carefully selected group of guests with their own hidden motives, and a storm rolling in that cuts them off from the world just as tensions begin to rise. The author captures that deliciously claustrophobic feeling of being trapped with people you’re not sure you should trust, and it gives the whole story a low, steady hum of dread.
What really works here is the slow reveal of secrets. Nothing is handed over too quickly; instead, the truth seeps out in small, unsettling moments that shift your understanding of each character. Everyone is hiding something, and the book plays with that uncertainty beautifully. By the time the inevitable death occurs, it feels like the natural breaking point of all the pressure simmering beneath the surface.
Atmospheric, pacey, and full of those subtle twists that make you second‑guess every assumption, One of Them Is Lying is a perfect pick for readers who love a storm‑lashed setting, a cast full of secrets, and that irresistible “just one more chapter” pull.
With thanks to CL Swatman, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
May 11, 2026
🩵🕯️One of Them is Lying ARC Review 🕯️🩵
Thank you so much to CL Swatman and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read and review this book!
One of Them is Lying is a standalone psychological thriller. Alan Titheridge has been surrounded by scandal for months, and it’s now Stella’s job to clear his name. But after planning a weekend getaway for some influential VIPs in hopes of getting some good PR, conflicts arise between the guests. Can they find the truth before it’s too late??
This was an interesting read. Stella was doing her best to improve the reputation of a man that didn’t necessarily deserve it. I enjoyed the world building and the isolation of the farm/retreat getaway. I did find that i struggled with liking a lot of these characters due to their difficult personalities, but I also feel like this was an intentional choice by the author. I feel like I was expecting a who-done-it murder mystery, but this book provided something else entirely. I didn’t dislike it, it was just unexpected
Overall this was a three star read for me. I enjoyed the story overall and the world building. This book absolutely has some potential triggers, so please check if you’re sensitive. As this was not a romance book, no rating will be given for spice
If you’re a fan of thrillers with engaging world building, decades-long mystery, and long awaited vengeance, then absolutely pick this up.
Thank you so much to CL Swatman and Boldwood Books for the opportunity to read and review this book!
One of Them is Lying is a standalone psychological thriller. Alan Titheridge has been surrounded by scandal for months, and it’s now Stella’s job to clear his name. But after planning a weekend getaway for some influential VIPs in hopes of getting some good PR, conflicts arise between the guests. Can they find the truth before it’s too late??
This was an interesting read. Stella was doing her best to improve the reputation of a man that didn’t necessarily deserve it. I enjoyed the world building and the isolation of the farm/retreat getaway. I did find that i struggled with liking a lot of these characters due to their difficult personalities, but I also feel like this was an intentional choice by the author. I feel like I was expecting a who-done-it murder mystery, but this book provided something else entirely. I didn’t dislike it, it was just unexpected
Overall this was a three star read for me. I enjoyed the story overall and the world building. This book absolutely has some potential triggers, so please check if you’re sensitive. As this was not a romance book, no rating will be given for spice
If you’re a fan of thrillers with engaging world building, decades-long mystery, and long awaited vengeance, then absolutely pick this up.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The synopsis made me think that this was a whodunit in the vein of Dame Agatha: a group of strangers, an isolated location and murder most foul. This is not it. There is crime and punishment, but the killing itself only happens almost at the end. Still, I was not disappointed because the writing is so compelling. Stella is doing her best to restore the reputation of a middle-aged man that has gotten away with way too much. She moves to his farm, which is now a resort that offers a curated rural experience to wealthy city folk, and invites influential people to make them forget a recent scandal. There, she spends time with Alan’s family and staff, trying to determine who has been sabotaging him. The novel is split into several parts, some told in third person and others as first-person narrative. As the blurb states, one of the characters is not who they say, hiding a big secret. At first, I thought that the author was cheating and contradicting herself but, after careful consideration, she is just using a clever trick to hide what was really going on. That, along with good writing that makes the farm and surrounding woods come to life, made for entertaining reading. I enjoyed it.
I chose to read this book and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, NetGalley/Boldwood Books.
I chose to read this book and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, NetGalley/Boldwood Books.
May 19, 2026
One of Them is Lying is a well-written psychological thriller that follows Stella as she plans a VIP weekend at the Titheridge Farm, Alan Titheridge has been embroiled in scandals over the past several months, and Stella is hoping this elite and luxury weekend will go a long way in improving his reputation. However, things do not go according to plan. From the start, it's clear that the guests are all hiding dark secrets and many have their own agendas for the weekend. When a nasty storm rolls in and traps the guests at the farm, things go from bad to worse, especially when a dead body is discovered.
To begin with, I really did think this book was well-written, and I appreciated how the story was told through varying POVs and timelines. I definitely wanted to finish the book and discover the whys and the who-dun-its. With that said, there were way too many characters. The "extra" characters (mainly those invited as the VIP guests) were unnecessary and hard to follow. None of them were developed, and they were all quite boring. With that many characters, there were quite a few storylines that felt unfinished, including the ending for the overarching mystery. Outside of the guests, all of the family members were extremely unlikable. I feel like this book had potential but just wasn't quite there.
To begin with, I really did think this book was well-written, and I appreciated how the story was told through varying POVs and timelines. I definitely wanted to finish the book and discover the whys and the who-dun-its. With that said, there were way too many characters. The "extra" characters (mainly those invited as the VIP guests) were unnecessary and hard to follow. None of them were developed, and they were all quite boring. With that many characters, there were quite a few storylines that felt unfinished, including the ending for the overarching mystery. Outside of the guests, all of the family members were extremely unlikable. I feel like this book had potential but just wasn't quite there.
June 13, 2026
I spent this entire book side eyeing EVERY SINGLE PERSON. 👀
🌩️ Isolated farmhouse
🌧️ Storm trapping everyone inside
🤫 Secrets everywhere
🔪 A dead body
😳 Absolutely nobody I trusted
One of Them Is Lying starts with Stella landing what seems like the perfect job....helping repair the reputation of scandal ridden businessman Alan Titheridge. To win over some important guests, she organizes a VIP weekend at Titheridge Farm. Sounds simple enough...Until a storm cuts everyone off from the outside world.
Then someone ends up dead. And suddenly every person trapped inside that house becomes a suspect.
😮💨 BABE.
The atmosphere in this book was THICK. The isolated farm setting gave me classic locked room mystery vibes. Every conversation felt suspicious. Every character seemed to be hiding something. And the more secrets that came out, the more I questioned literally everyone.
Stella was determined, clever, and trying to navigate a situation that kept getting messier by the minute but even she wasn't telling us everything...👀
If you love:
🔪 Storm trapped mysteries
🏡 Isolated country estates
🤫 Family secrets
👀 Untrustworthy characters
🌧️ Atmospheric suspense
💀 Everyone is a suspect vibes
...then add this one to your TBR.
Just make sure to check trigger warnings first because this story tackles some very dark subject matter.
🌩️ Isolated farmhouse
🌧️ Storm trapping everyone inside
🤫 Secrets everywhere
🔪 A dead body
😳 Absolutely nobody I trusted
One of Them Is Lying starts with Stella landing what seems like the perfect job....helping repair the reputation of scandal ridden businessman Alan Titheridge. To win over some important guests, she organizes a VIP weekend at Titheridge Farm. Sounds simple enough...Until a storm cuts everyone off from the outside world.
Then someone ends up dead. And suddenly every person trapped inside that house becomes a suspect.
😮💨 BABE.
The atmosphere in this book was THICK. The isolated farm setting gave me classic locked room mystery vibes. Every conversation felt suspicious. Every character seemed to be hiding something. And the more secrets that came out, the more I questioned literally everyone.
Stella was determined, clever, and trying to navigate a situation that kept getting messier by the minute but even she wasn't telling us everything...👀
If you love:
🔪 Storm trapped mysteries
🏡 Isolated country estates
🤫 Family secrets
👀 Untrustworthy characters
🌧️ Atmospheric suspense
💀 Everyone is a suspect vibes
...then add this one to your TBR.
Just make sure to check trigger warnings first because this story tackles some very dark subject matter.
May 21, 2026
3.5/5 ratings
First off, I'd recommend checking the trigger warnings as there are quite a few. The author has done an amazing job with the plot, particularly with how she started with that slow mystery-building phase. The book is divided into five parts, and from a plot perspective, that structure makes complete sense.
The plot had so much potential, and the story kept me wanting more from it. I expected a little bit more overall. If you're someone who enjoys mind-blowing thrillers or a really gripping, fast-paced book, then this one might not be for you. But if you're looking for a wonderful book with a more natural, subtle kind of thrilling vibe, then this could work well for you.
The writing style is quite good. However, I felt the plot has significantly more potential than what was ultimately delivered. Because of that, I did feel disengaged at a few points while reading. That said, I really enjoyed it overall. You would enjoy reading it. The buildup creates these big expectations, and when the payoff comes, it doesn't quite match that anticipation. The pacing could have been better as well. But overall, solid writing and good buildup, just wish the plot had delivered more on its promise.
First off, I'd recommend checking the trigger warnings as there are quite a few. The author has done an amazing job with the plot, particularly with how she started with that slow mystery-building phase. The book is divided into five parts, and from a plot perspective, that structure makes complete sense.
The plot had so much potential, and the story kept me wanting more from it. I expected a little bit more overall. If you're someone who enjoys mind-blowing thrillers or a really gripping, fast-paced book, then this one might not be for you. But if you're looking for a wonderful book with a more natural, subtle kind of thrilling vibe, then this could work well for you.
The writing style is quite good. However, I felt the plot has significantly more potential than what was ultimately delivered. Because of that, I did feel disengaged at a few points while reading. That said, I really enjoyed it overall. You would enjoy reading it. The buildup creates these big expectations, and when the payoff comes, it doesn't quite match that anticipation. The pacing could have been better as well. But overall, solid writing and good buildup, just wish the plot had delivered more on its promise.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Well, I sure wasn’t expecting that! From the title, blurb, and definitely the cover, I expected “One of Them is Lying” to be a “twisty, unputdownable” mystery with a side of coziness to it. Maybe a sly, dark sense of humor. Nope. This book is dark, dark, dark, dark.
This book should come with a warning. I’m being serious. This novel deals with rape, sexual abuse, and incest. It seriously needs a trigger warning for the second half of the book. There is nothing that even hints at the heaviness in the blurb or marketing. As I was reading this, I kept feeling sorry for anyone that would be reading the book that had suffered through any of these unimaginable horrors and being ambushed by the subject while trying to enjoy this novel.
That being said, this is a really good book. It is well written. The characters are interesting. It’s just a good job by the author all the way around. It’s just heavy, though.
So, should you read this book? Definitely, as long as you are aware of the subject matters you are going to run into when you do.
I received this ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an unbiased review.
This book should come with a warning. I’m being serious. This novel deals with rape, sexual abuse, and incest. It seriously needs a trigger warning for the second half of the book. There is nothing that even hints at the heaviness in the blurb or marketing. As I was reading this, I kept feeling sorry for anyone that would be reading the book that had suffered through any of these unimaginable horrors and being ambushed by the subject while trying to enjoy this novel.
That being said, this is a really good book. It is well written. The characters are interesting. It’s just a good job by the author all the way around. It’s just heavy, though.
So, should you read this book? Definitely, as long as you are aware of the subject matters you are going to run into when you do.
I received this ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an unbiased review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This was a really intriguing, slow-burn thriller that pulled me in quite quickly. From the start, you know everyone is hiding something, and the story slowly peels back each character’s secrets bit by bit, which kept me constantly guessing about who could be trusted.
There are quite a few unlikeable characters in this book, but in a way that works really well for the story - the kind where you’re suspicious of everyone and keep changing your mind about who you think is lying. I love books that make you play detective while you’re reading, and this definitely had that feel.
The setting also adds to the atmosphere, an isolated farm, bad weather, a group of people who don’t fully trust each other. it has that classic locked-room mystery vibe where tension slowly builds as the truth starts to come out.
The twist at the end was a really good one. The kind that makes you rethink certain characters and moments from earlier in the book, which I always think is the sign of a well-planned thriller. Overall, a really enjoyable, character-driven mystery with lots of secrets, tension and a satisfying twist at the end.
There are quite a few unlikeable characters in this book, but in a way that works really well for the story - the kind where you’re suspicious of everyone and keep changing your mind about who you think is lying. I love books that make you play detective while you’re reading, and this definitely had that feel.
The setting also adds to the atmosphere, an isolated farm, bad weather, a group of people who don’t fully trust each other. it has that classic locked-room mystery vibe where tension slowly builds as the truth starts to come out.
The twist at the end was a really good one. The kind that makes you rethink certain characters and moments from earlier in the book, which I always think is the sign of a well-planned thriller. Overall, a really enjoyable, character-driven mystery with lots of secrets, tension and a satisfying twist at the end.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This book should come with a trigger warning, but it doesn’t. It deals with rape, sexual abuse, and incest, and goes to some very dark places, especially in the second half.
If you’re okay with that, this is a seriously gripping read.
The story drops you into a remote farm where a group of guests are invited for a tense weekend meant to fix a damaged reputation. A storm cuts everyone off, secrets start surfacing, and before long, someone ends up dead. From that point on, it becomes a full-on guessing game.
What stood out most to me was how untrustworthy everyone felt. No one is entirely likeable, and that actually works in the book’s favour because you’re constantly reassessing who might be lying. It really leans into that classic closed-circle mystery feel, but with a much darker edge.
The plot is tight, the pacing keeps building, and the twists land well. It’s also very much a revenge story, and it handles that in a clever way without making things predictable.
This isn’t an easy or comforting read, but it is a compelling one. Just make sure you know what you’re getting into before you start.
If you’re okay with that, this is a seriously gripping read.
The story drops you into a remote farm where a group of guests are invited for a tense weekend meant to fix a damaged reputation. A storm cuts everyone off, secrets start surfacing, and before long, someone ends up dead. From that point on, it becomes a full-on guessing game.
What stood out most to me was how untrustworthy everyone felt. No one is entirely likeable, and that actually works in the book’s favour because you’re constantly reassessing who might be lying. It really leans into that classic closed-circle mystery feel, but with a much darker edge.
The plot is tight, the pacing keeps building, and the twists land well. It’s also very much a revenge story, and it handles that in a clever way without making things predictable.
This isn’t an easy or comforting read, but it is a compelling one. Just make sure you know what you’re getting into before you start.
May 13, 2026
First things first, there needs to be a trigger warning with this book. There is talk of sexual abuse and child sexual abuse. It's not a light, fluffy popcorn thriller.
That being said, I did enjoy the book! I wish the first 25% or so would have moved a little quicker. I felt like it was a bit hard to get in to. I know we needed to get introduced to the characters but the beginning just didn't have that instant, reel you in kind of feeling. It did certainly pick up though and you started to really wonder just what is going on and who you should be suspicious of. In my mind, everyone was guilty at one point or another! I like the way the author decided to end it but I wish the ending would have been fleshed out a little more. It felt a somewhat abrupt and a bit of a let down coming off of the previous few chapters. Overall though, definitely worth a read and I look forward to seeing what else this author has in store!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
That being said, I did enjoy the book! I wish the first 25% or so would have moved a little quicker. I felt like it was a bit hard to get in to. I know we needed to get introduced to the characters but the beginning just didn't have that instant, reel you in kind of feeling. It did certainly pick up though and you started to really wonder just what is going on and who you should be suspicious of. In my mind, everyone was guilty at one point or another! I like the way the author decided to end it but I wish the ending would have been fleshed out a little more. It felt a somewhat abrupt and a bit of a let down coming off of the previous few chapters. Overall though, definitely worth a read and I look forward to seeing what else this author has in store!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy. All opinions expressed are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Claustrophobic Suspense At Its Best! Looking for a thriller that traps you in a web of secrets and never lets go? Titheridge Farm is the perfect, chilling setting for a story where no one, not even the protagonist is exactly who they seem.
When Stella is hired to salvage philanthropist Alan’s reputation at Titheridge Farm, she enters a hornets' nest of bizarre family dynamics and suspicious staff.
However, the true intrigue lies with Stella herself; small clues early on hint at a hidden agenda, and I loved how her own ulterior motives were peeled back layer by layer as the story progressed.
The slow-burn pacing is superb, allowing secrets and lies to unravel gradually toward a revelation so dark it takes your breath away. With relatable characters and a storm-lashed, multi-layered climax, this is a must-read for fans of claustrophobic, bone-chilling domestic suspense.
My thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC. This is my own opinion.
When Stella is hired to salvage philanthropist Alan’s reputation at Titheridge Farm, she enters a hornets' nest of bizarre family dynamics and suspicious staff.
However, the true intrigue lies with Stella herself; small clues early on hint at a hidden agenda, and I loved how her own ulterior motives were peeled back layer by layer as the story progressed.
The slow-burn pacing is superb, allowing secrets and lies to unravel gradually toward a revelation so dark it takes your breath away. With relatable characters and a storm-lashed, multi-layered climax, this is a must-read for fans of claustrophobic, bone-chilling domestic suspense.
My thanks to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC. This is my own opinion.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.5*
What a wild ride! The remote farmhouse setting—cut off by a storm with no phone signal—creates the perfect backdrop for a classic whodunit! A colourful cast of characters gathers for the weekend, and the tension builds beautifully as secrets start to surface. The twists in the final stretch were great, and the ending lands was great and satisfying. The author’s writing style ties it all together effortlessly—it’s the icing on the cake!
A content note for readers: the story includes references to a rape scene, cancer diagnosis and death, and child sexual assault. These elements emerge around (and after) the halfway point, shifting the tone into much darker territory.
Overall, this is a gripping blend of thriller, suspense, and murder mystery—one that would translate brilliantly to the screen!
My thanks to #netgalley, the author and publishers #boldwoodbooks for the opportunity to read and review this fantastic book, my honest review is given voluntarily.
What a wild ride! The remote farmhouse setting—cut off by a storm with no phone signal—creates the perfect backdrop for a classic whodunit! A colourful cast of characters gathers for the weekend, and the tension builds beautifully as secrets start to surface. The twists in the final stretch were great, and the ending lands was great and satisfying. The author’s writing style ties it all together effortlessly—it’s the icing on the cake!
A content note for readers: the story includes references to a rape scene, cancer diagnosis and death, and child sexual assault. These elements emerge around (and after) the halfway point, shifting the tone into much darker territory.
Overall, this is a gripping blend of thriller, suspense, and murder mystery—one that would translate brilliantly to the screen!
My thanks to #netgalley, the author and publishers #boldwoodbooks for the opportunity to read and review this fantastic book, my honest review is given voluntarily.
April 10, 2026
Trigger warnings for incest, child abuse and rape.
This story is basically broken up into three segments. 1) Tells of Stella getting a job at Titheridge Farm where her job is to help improve the reputation of Alan Titheridge who has been plagued by bad press. There is a hint that her CV may have been embellished. (2) Abigail’s story of her childhood, her mother’s death and her quest for revenge. And, lastly (3) Renee’s tale.
Stella plans a weekend to highlight all that the farm has to offer as a corporate retreat and help repair Alan’s reputation with 5 VIP guests. Unfortunately, a storm forces the plans to change. There is no cell service and a tree blocks the road. Trapped!
This story is about family dynamics, hiding your true self, a predatory man who ruins lives and fighting back.
Thanks you NetGalley for the advance reader’s copy. This review is left voluntarily.
This story is basically broken up into three segments. 1) Tells of Stella getting a job at Titheridge Farm where her job is to help improve the reputation of Alan Titheridge who has been plagued by bad press. There is a hint that her CV may have been embellished. (2) Abigail’s story of her childhood, her mother’s death and her quest for revenge. And, lastly (3) Renee’s tale.
Stella plans a weekend to highlight all that the farm has to offer as a corporate retreat and help repair Alan’s reputation with 5 VIP guests. Unfortunately, a storm forces the plans to change. There is no cell service and a tree blocks the road. Trapped!
This story is about family dynamics, hiding your true self, a predatory man who ruins lives and fighting back.
Thanks you NetGalley for the advance reader’s copy. This review is left voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
C.L. Swatman’s latest, One of Them Is Lying, is a true slow-burn thriller that caught me completely off guard. Between the title, the enchanting cover, and the blurb, I was expecting a clever, twisty mystery,I was not expecting it to get this DARK!
The story explores complex family dynamics through a mix of third person and first-person perspectives. While the characters are interesting and the multi-part structure keeps you reading, the second half ventures into very heavy territory.
A note for sensitive readers: This book definitely needs a trigger warning. It deals graphically with rape, sexual abuse, and incest. It’s a compelling read if you can handle the intensity, but be prepared for a much grittier journey than the cover suggests.
Thank you, NetGalley, for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
The story explores complex family dynamics through a mix of third person and first-person perspectives. While the characters are interesting and the multi-part structure keeps you reading, the second half ventures into very heavy territory.
A note for sensitive readers: This book definitely needs a trigger warning. It deals graphically with rape, sexual abuse, and incest. It’s a compelling read if you can handle the intensity, but be prepared for a much grittier journey than the cover suggests.
Thank you, NetGalley, for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
This one had an intriguing premise and I was curious to see how everything would come together. The story spends a lot of time building out the main character and her past, but it started to feel repetitive rather than adding new layers.
The pacing was the biggest issue for me. It takes most of the book to get to the central mystery, and when it finally does, everything moves very quickly. The final reveal and resolution felt rushed compared to how much time was spent on the setup.
One of the most critical perspectives in the story needed more depth. Given how heavy that backstory is, it felt like it was introduced and resolved too quickly to have the impact it should have.
Overall, an interesting concept that didn’t fully land for me.
This one had an intriguing premise and I was curious to see how everything would come together. The story spends a lot of time building out the main character and her past, but it started to feel repetitive rather than adding new layers.
The pacing was the biggest issue for me. It takes most of the book to get to the central mystery, and when it finally does, everything moves very quickly. The final reveal and resolution felt rushed compared to how much time was spent on the setup.
One of the most critical perspectives in the story needed more depth. Given how heavy that backstory is, it felt like it was introduced and resolved too quickly to have the impact it should have.
Overall, an interesting concept that didn’t fully land for me.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Wellll....during what turned out to be the first portion of the book (it's broken into five parts), I was fairly bored. Fortunately, things flipped after that, secrets were revealed, backstories were delved into, and it all became more interesting.
Stella comes to Titheridge Farms in hopes of securing a PR position, claiming she can fix the public perception of Alan Titheridge (who lately has been receiving some bad press). Here, she meets Tom, a I guess handyman who lives on the property, and the rest of the Titheridge family. All is not what it seems with just about everyone involved, and those twists were enough to hold my interest, at least moderately.
There are mentions, and not casual mentions, of sexual assault that are pretty disturbing, so that's something to keep in mind here.
Thank you to NetGalley for my ARC.
Stella comes to Titheridge Farms in hopes of securing a PR position, claiming she can fix the public perception of Alan Titheridge (who lately has been receiving some bad press). Here, she meets Tom, a I guess handyman who lives on the property, and the rest of the Titheridge family. All is not what it seems with just about everyone involved, and those twists were enough to hold my interest, at least moderately.
There are mentions, and not casual mentions, of sexual assault that are pretty disturbing, so that's something to keep in mind here.
Thank you to NetGalley for my ARC.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews