What if the line between irritation and attraction is thinner than the wall between you?
After another brutal night in the ER, Dr. Theodora Brennan wants one thing: sleep. What she gets is a new neighbor, Catherine Matthews, a former concert pianist with a rigid routine and music that bleeds through the walls at two in the morning.
What begins as a wary standoff becomes something neither of them expects. Catherine has spent years perfecting the distance between herself and the rest of the world. Theo has spent years running toward everyone else's emergencies to avoid her own. In the quiet hours between their apartments, when defenses slip, something shifts.
In the Lonely Hours is an emotionally intimate slow burn about two women who have spent years avoiding the very thing they are now being offered. Wry, tender, and quietly charged, it explores control and vulnerability, the wounds we carry in private, and the unexpected ways people find each other in the dark.
For readers who love character-driven romance, slow-burn enemies-to-friends-to-lovers tension, and second chances that ache before they heal.
I was maybe twenty percent into this book when I was struck with how beautiful Alexanda’s writing is. I don’t think that’s ever happened to me. Just a pointed mental note to myself on the writing, so that’s a major compliment to the author. I’m not much of a note taker when I read a book, but I had to call out this most swooniest moment where one FMC compares the other to a beautiful piece of classical music:
"It starts controlled. Careful. But underneath it's restless, emotional, breathtaking. There's a pulse running through the whole thing that refuses to quit, no matter how tired it gets." She paused. "It's beautiful because it keeps moving even when it hurts to." She looked at Theo. "That's you, Theodora."
In the Lonely Hours’s magic all begins with the delicious meet-cute. The first FMC, Theo’s, 2 am knock (pounding) on the second FMC, Catherine’s, door and then the absolute unraveling of these two wonderful characters as soon as the door is opened and they see each other. The reader knows, just KNOWS these two are going to fall in love and it is going to be wonderful, starting with the first antagonistic Post-it note message which the reader can immediately tell is code for crackling attraction.
I’ve read some other romances recently, where the love declaration doesn’t feel earned, if that makes sense. In this book, it is. Very. Or put another way, along with some critical independent character growth, Theo and Catherine put in the hard work to make their relationship work, so when you get to the ‘I love you’s,’ it hits with all the feels.
I see now why this book is getting so many positive reviews. The story is the perfect mix of longing for purpose and for love.
Dr. Theo Brennan is a resident in a fast paced emergency room, close to being burnt out but holding on so she can continue on the track laid out by her brilliant surgeon parents. Living only a few doors down from Theo is a world class pianist, Catherine Matthews, who insists on practicing in the wee hours of the night. Their clashes are delightfully diabolical with plenty of sharp banter and a heated undertow. But both characters are hiding from personal struggles that make it difficult for them to trust which makes for a tentative but achingly sweet courting.
I enjoyed this book in so many ways because it diverges from being a spicy, humorous romance, which in itself is wonderful, and morphs into a tender story about two people each finding their truth and then being able to accept love. The support characters are strong and help to drive the story rather than just being background. I also want to mention that music plays a big part in their story. As I was reading the book, I kept marveling at how the author has Theo and Catherine communicate in alternate ways to express their growing intimacy, with gestures, innocuous gifts, and shared songs. I just flat out loved this story.
I recommend for fans of sharp-witted characters, age gap (10 years), high heat chemistry, angst, and love stories that make you gasp with happiness.
I loved Theo and Catherine’s relationship from minute one. Them communicating non stop, from post it, to text, to calls and more. The banter is A class. Seeing their relationhip growing in a crescendo was simply a delight. It was both funny and so tender at the same time. Theo and Catherine are so complementary, and Theo is the perfect representation of patience and thoughtfulness Catherine needed. I don’t think they take that much time to cross the line, yet, this book is a slow burn, with the perfect amount of « gosh when will these fools get together ». Catherine was the one holding back the relationship most of the time but I really understood her being not reasonable, but not being able to fight it. I felt like I was in Mary’s shoes, the lovely neighbor who provided the perfect dose of meddling. Both characters felt layered, with Theo struggling to grow outside parental expectations and Catherine still needing to recover. I love when authors take time to make relationships and characters grow. That’s why I really liked their necessary time apart; it made me savor their reunion so much more because it felt earned. If I had one minor gripe, it would be that I wanted to know more about Catherine's condition and how it impacted her daily life. I simply devoured this book.
“In the Lonely Hours” WAS SUCH AN EMOTIONAL STORY OH MY!!!
Right from the start I was hooked on the storyline. I initially loved the synopsis and this enemies to friends to lovers trope. So when I started reading and got to this point of the book, I already knew that this was gonna be a good book. And what can I say? It IS a great book!! I adored both of our main characters Theodora and Catherine so much and I also loved how the main characters were written, especially Mary (god bless her!) and Harry. Besides that, I also really loved how the story was written and the general writing story and prose. Moreover (and since I mentioned the characters already), I really liked how Elle Alexandra portrayed their struggles and how complex and at one point complicated Theo’s and Catherine’s relationship was. I loved seeing how they got from the initial “you annoy me” vibe to the “I like spending time with you” and then to the point where more happens. But I also loved seeing the struggles that arose during the middle of the story and in my opinion, it made the whole experience feel much more meaningful and real in a way. Like I actually could’ve imagined this scenario playing out in real life at some point. Furthermore, I wanna add that the steamy scenes are incredibly written. I think I’ve bookmarked these pages so often because I was in love with the descriptions used and the way the act itself was portrayed soo beautifully!! Nevertheless, I did feel like some parts of the story were dragged sometimes or that the ups and downs were somewhat predictable. Still, in my humble opinion, this is a great book, with great character developments and amazing themes!! This is a book which I would totally recommend to everyone who loves a good enemies to lovers story that includes so much more emotional depth than one might think at first glance.
Ps: the epilogue is sooo sweet!! I’m never gonna get over that actually hihi.
This book had it all! Lots of emotion, deep characters, banter, longing, music, and plenty of love. I was totally hooked from the first chapter to the last.
I loved the very first encounter between Theo, the doctor, and Catherine, the pianist. The little notes they exchanged were hilarious and very entertaining. The connection between the two was so electrifying and full of emotion.
The two main characters were also so well-developed, with rich backstories, and by the end of the book, I felt as if they were my friends because I knew them so well. The supporting characters were also very likable and entertaining.
A great book filled with intense sapphic longing. I could hardly put the book down—I was that captivated by it. Read this book! You won’t regret it.
When two women collide and the notes [both on paper and in key] come together in such an exquisite way you feel thoroughly complete. That’s what happens between Theodora [Theo] and Catherine. When ordinary is extraordinary and a Wednesday evening brings “the perfect moment…in the accumulated significance of all the ordinary ones” (pg. 394). It is in the space of ordinary where the author pulls emotions from both characters that touch the reader deeply.
The story is in the post-it exchanges. The careful composure and relentless need to preserve an image that existed only in the past, Catharine, a former concert pianist plays at ungodly hours. An attempt to return while still hiding – the piano sits untouched. Enter Dr. Theodora Brennan, an ER physician trapped in a life where she has no agency. A desire to break free but lacks the courage. Neighbors. A late-night knock-on apartment door 14D. A post-it banter battle and accidently, a space where stolen moments between these two bring them together and keep them from running away.
So much anguish in the prose written about Catharine. How she makes herself smaller because being truly seen feels too vulnerable. Alexanda takes you on a journey where Catharine moves from hiding. Denying. Crying. How much has been lost to fear. Unworthy. Less than whole. And, eventually, slowly, painfully, she gives herself permission to be seen. The piano is touched. A key is pressed. The sound is beautiful. But the in between is filled with struggle and as the reader you will feel that struggle. (pg.232). The deliberate severing of what mattered most. Better to have killed vulnerability – to take it back - then to feel the pain of loss.
But then there’s Theodora [Theo], the woman who manages to take Catharine apart.
“It was just a piece of paper” No Theo, it was everything…
I enjoyed that this book is extremely low angst/drama. There's no inflated dramatic misunderstandings or nonsense, just adults who are slowly forming a friendship and then a romantic relationship while struggling with their own trauma and problems quietly.
There are a few things that I feel are telling us rather than showing and we fast forward through the real moments of connection over time but generally, this is charming, engaging, and makes me want to root for these characters to end up together because they are genuinely good together. A solid first book for me from this author!
Leave it to the women who love women to flirt through post it notes. And they do it quite successfully too! If you love the slow burn doctor/musician stumbling through life romance this one is so well done I didn't want to put it down, but I didn't want it to end. My love for both MCs Theo and Catherine, is one I didn't expect but thoroughly enjoy. I recommend this one and give it 5+Bösendorfer stars
An uptight musician neighbour Catherine disturbs a sleep deprived ER doc Theo with her piano playing. Such a simple concept for a plot.
Often it can take time to truly 'like' both MCs but here I had no problem. The author immediately sets you up with enough background and two compelling, complex characters in Theo and Catherine. So you quickly care and are invested in whats going to happen with them.
Great emotional descriptive writing. It's the kinda book you feel yourself smiling, sighing and tearing up to as you read along. Its such a special book I almost wanna keep it a secret.
And why do my fav books often have a Catherine or a Kate?
Anyway many plaudits to the author Elle Alexanda look forward to future books.
I really loved this book! its up on my favourites/must-reread it shelf already. Enjoy
Im shocked! This audiobook definitely took away some of the emotion I felt reading the novel originally! Craden is my #1 go to narrator but this one didnt do it for me.
The audiobook is finally out! Can it make the experience even better??
A few repetitive terms and a lull in the story here and there, but truth be damned, this book was excellent. 4.5 🌟 rounded up as absolutely loved the banter and tension from the mains. Lots of chemistry and quite romantic. Bravo.
Story 4.5 🌟 Spice 2 🌟 Characters 4.5 🌟
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Obsessed. I was hooked from the very beginning and there was no prying this book from my hands—not a chance in hell. In The Lonely Hours exceeded my expectations tenfold and absolutely blew me away.
Catherine and Theo were fleshed-out characters that had chemistry, tension, and witty banter since the hard knock on the door at two a.m. Meet-cutes are my absolute favorite and this one sealed the deal for me. It took me no time at all to love them as individuals before ever becoming a couple. The pace from enemies-to-friends-to-lovers was realistic and progressed smoothly. The storyline was engaging, addictive, and I was invested in not only Catherine and Theo but also the side characters. One of my favorite things about the book was that the author took the actual time to build their friendship before they became lovers.
Despite their differences and age gap, the two just made sense together, and I rooted for them. Catherine was all about routine, maintaining control, and held her cards close to the vest. Theo was witty, impossible not to love, and wore her heart on her sleeve. I deeply empathized with them and the battles they quietly fought. It broke my heart to see them struggle, but their healing and growth was so rewarding.
I couldn’t possibly love this more than I already do. There were a blend of moments where I laughed out loud, moments where I couldn’t keep a smile off my face, and moments so achingly tender that I had to clutch my chest. Overall, it was an emotional ride with enough comedic relief that kept the mood from becoming too heavy. In The Lonely Hours will stay with me, and I’ll gladly keep it forever. I unequivocally fell head over heels in love and I highly recommend this as a must-read.
God. This book ripped my heart out of my chest and then gently put it back inside. The sticky notes, holy crap. I melted as they went on. My wife had to remind me that we used to leave sticky notes for each other early in our relationship. Perhaps thats why I loved this part of the plot so much. I like to listen to books while I read along and I usually turn the narration speed to about 1.4/1.5. I purposely listened to this book at 1.1 because I wanted to savor it and didn’t want it to end. I just finished this book tonight and I’m immediately going to start it again.
I absolutely LOVED the way these two met. Their initial interactions were funny, witty, and just enough banter to have me cheesing.
The timeline? Perfect. It didn’t feel rushed, nor did it feel dragged out. When I was about 50% in I was really worried because I just couldn’t put together how there was still half the book left. It really was pulled back together and didn’t feel like there were needless extra pages.
Theo was my absolute favorite. I loved the way she presented herself and how she stood up for what she really wanted. She was easy to love throughout the whole story.
I wanted to smack Catherine a few times, because for the older character she sure had some stuff to work through. She made her redemption though, and I love her for it.
The writing style wasn’t my favorite though. The shorter, exaggerated sentences always make things feel more cheesy. It also reminds me of AI, which I may be a bit paranoid, but a few people have vocalized this book could possibly have had the assistance with AI (something I do not agree with).
This is why it resulted in a 3.5. Although I loved their story and the originality of their meet up, the writing style and AI vibes lower it for me.
I loved the sample and had to buy the book. So many great lines and I loved the organic way the relationship developed in this good length book. The only thing I didn't quite love was the first physically intimate scene. I added physically deliberately there because so many of the scenes are true intimacy. That is why I think I found the conversation during the physical scene jarring in a way nothing else in this book has been. There is a section after this when a plot point comes to the fore and things for the couple change. There is a change in tone of the book. The levity disappears, the emotion does not. This is the rain. I am looking forward to the rainbow. Oh my! The first third is light, amusing and unfurling. The second is emotional and sad and beautifully written and the third? Emotional and perfect. This book is a nutritional delight. I enjoy snacks that have no nutritional value but tasty at the time...... A lot of what I have read has been the latter. This, this however is a fulfilling feast. It has none of the intimacy bingo so prevalent today that isn't actually intimate..... Yet the intimacy is off the charts. This is possibly slow burn but not a low burn. It has left a deep impression on me. The rainbow was well worth what went before. Rounded down because you can’t go higher than 5!
Well, @ellealexanda_author you absolutely did not mess around with In The Lonely Hours!
What starts as two people annoying each other through posted notes quickly turns into texts, late-night calls, and a friendship that slowly becomes impossible to ignore. And honestly? Watching that connection build felt so real and so beautiful.
Beneath all the banter and tension is a deeply emotional story about feeling unseen by the people who were supposed to know you best. One struggling with the pressure of expectations, the other carrying the weight of being made to feel weak because of health struggles.
The healing in this story is soft, patient, and full of compassion. And compassion really is such a beautiful thing. 📸📚
1. Rewarding this 5 stars is making me rethink every other 5 star I gave out this year.
2. I need to state that I do not cry when reading books, and this book got me there.
3. I started this at about 11:45pm thinking I'd get a few chapters in and then go to sleep. I had to stop myself at about 70% of the way through when I saw 4:15am. I was then able to finish it the next night after agonizing all day that I didn't have time to read more until post-dinner.
What an absolutely phenomenal book. I adored the characters, and have to give kudos to the neighbors too. Sometimes the supporting cast are filler, but I didn't get that from this book. The banter between Theo and Catherine especially was just honest to God fun. Nothing felt forced or cheesy, it was just written gold.
This book had so much heart and I'm so grateful I read it.
I’ve been in a bit of a romance book slump lately and this was just perfect for me. I found myself staying up later than normal because I was so into Catherine and Theodora. Their enemies to friends to lovers to forever was a delight to read. I will say I was a bit hesitant to read this because I did not enjoy the other offering from this author. I’m so glad I listened to my friend, Andrea, @looseleftlesbian, and read this. It was the most enjoyable book I’ve read this summer. The writing flowed, there were very few of the UK-isms that I run into when UK authors write about American characters and cities. The character growth was amazing and the vulnerability that each character showed was delicious.
It’s 4:50 AM, so I’ll go to bed now, but I swear on my life I’ll come back soon to rave about this book. So fucking good.
Actual review, 4th of september, 2026:
It took me a little while to come write this review because life got hectic but I had sworn on my life so I didn't have much choice.
No, but seriously, this book was really good! I had been reading a couple of male-male romances because my horny gay friend loves them and recommended them to me but DEAR GOD, there's so much sex in them lmao. And nothing against a lot of sex in books, but two men? Not personally interested, as a lesbian. If those books had less penetration and more emotion, I would've loved them. But no, sadly they're mostly erotica in a pretty romance bow.
This book could not be more opposite even if it tried, and in the best way possible. The spine, the skeleton of this book, is the emotions as I think romances should. Lesbians just do it better because women just do it better (in my extremely biased opinion).
Anyway, so the book:
We meet Dr. Theo[dora] Brennan and renowned pianist Catherine Matthews. They are neighbors in the same building, and one night when Theo's trying to sleep, Catherine gets busy playing the piano. Theo's outraged by the hour and goes to confront the public nuisance, just to meet the not-so-lovely-in-the-moment (and 10 years older) Catherine.
They start exchanging post it notes with loose threats about making more noise and stopping said noise by all means necessary and it's really cute. They of course start flirting but mainly becoming friends.
It was honestly so cute to see how they were growing closer. I think the author took her job seriously and showed, not told, us how much they were getting familiar. This part of the book takes months, and it'd be so fucking boring to see them interact every single time. We don't have time for that! So we see the EVIDENCE of their interactions. Catherine being the one turning the lights on Theo's apartment as if it's her own when they both enter, for example, is one of those details that stayed with me for some reason. I'm not complaining. We see many examples of this, how they are kinda sharing both apartments.
Their friendship is nice and wholesome. I loved it. When we get to the relationship... it gets MESSY fast and actually I also loved it so much for a completely different reason.
Both characters have their own demons, right? But Theo's are much more manageable than Catherine's so in a way you can tell it's mostly Catherine's story (since it's her arc what drives the plot and what poses conflict).
With that preamble, let's talk about the characters. Dear babies, I love them:
Dr. Theo is amazing, she's totally my type and I'm lowkey very into her. She's doing her residency in Emergency Medicine and is a very good doctor who comes from a family of doctors. Her parents want her to pursue the same path her mother took in cardiology, but she's not so sure she wants that. She has a heart of gold. Her arc is mainly discovering what she wants out of life and pursuing her actual path. Nice.
Catherine is... well. I mean, I'm also lowkey into her but in a totally different way. I think that instead of being attracted to her, I just love her more deeply, and that's thanks to her arc. She is an exceptional classical pianist, but also was incredibly famous and her career was taking off in a mainstreamer way a year before the start of the book. But in the middle of a performance, she has a medical incident that derails her career. I think the details are mostly treated in a bit of a mysterious way so I'll use a spoiler tag, but honestly I don't think knowing this ruins the experience whatsoever (I knew EVERYTHING because I wanted to know what kind of disability rep we were getting and I enjoyed it maybe even more, so make of that what you will). Anyway, spoiler: . More than what happened to her medically (the thing + the subsequent diagnosis), she's mortified because she was vulnerable and feels such shame that has stopped her career. She's also scared of it happening again and all of it has just become a huge trauma in all aspects of her life, seeding fear and shame in practically everything. So her arc is overcoming that fear and opening up and all that good stuff, but of course it's not that easy and her arc is much, much more complicated than Theo's.
Theo's arc is supported by Catherine, right? Like, Catherine helps her realize she wants to do what she loves, yada yada, supports her when confronting her parents... All the good stuff. But Catherine's arc kinda is the relationship. Being with Theo (as friends, at first) has helped her tremendously, but when they get a tad more serious things go to shit because of Catherine's trauma.
I loved how the conflict yanked my heart because I got it, I really did. I understood fully why they couldn't be together, it wasn't just some bullshit the author made up for the plot's convenience (to be very honest it's such a low bar lmfao, but it's true!). I don't like when we need to create a conflict out of thin air because there needs to be one, but in here, as painful as it was, it was absolutely necessary.
Look, I wanna talk more in depth about this book, with spoilers, so I will. If you don't wanna know, I'll tell you when to stop. But in conclusion for my non-spoiler peeps: the characters were great, the arcs were exquisite, the angst and the pain agonizing in the best way. It's a book that has emotional depth and a beautiful depiction of healing not thanks to a love that works like magic but supported and motivated by love. I really recommend it.
In case you wanna know, it DOES have sex, but it's minimal. And again, not that I'm the smut police or anything but I think that's appropriate in this case. The superficial, the sexual part wasn't the most important thing, so we gave the important stuff more time. That's great.
And, also in case you wanna know, here are a few of the things represented in this book (really a non-exhaustive list): Theo's a lesbian, Catherine isn't explicitly stated iirc but she's bisexual; age gap relationship; we have rep of dysfunctional families, other gay characters, drugs, addiction, death and grief, trauma, disability (), homelessness.
If you don't want spoilers, BEGONE! From this point on, I'm not gonna care for my words at all.
Now that's only us cool kids, let me say: Catherine fucking broke me in the best way.
I have nothing but sympathy and love for her, but my god was she frustrating! I found her compelling and complex and fun to read, but when she started with the whole "sorry, i can't even look you in the eyes after you saw me in the hospital" was ROUGH.
If you're reading the spoiler section because you're a cool kid but didn't read the book, let me fill you in: after they get together, Catherine has a seizure and ends up in Theo's ER. Theo, worried out of her mind, cares for her (note that she didn't know about Catherine having epilepsy). But when Catherine wakes up, she... breaks up with her. She's humiliated because how dare she have a medical crisis out of her control, huh. We all know (Catherine even knows) it's not rational, but she can't help it. She's mortified and feels like she looks inferior to Theo so she can't stand being with her. Ouch.
Again, I get it. She was always a person very much in control and it's hard to let go of certain things. But it broke my heart for many reasons. I wanted her to be okay, i wanted her to be loved, I wanted Theo to be loved. So sad, but
The reconciliation was so good, omg. I think it could've been better, because it is Catherine who tells us that she needs to earn Theo's forgiveness, but at no point in Theo's POV did I ever think she hadn't forgiven her or something. Maybe I'm misrepresenting the situation and more than forgiveness Catherine was seeking to gain Theo's trust. It doesn't matter, I think my point stands: I would've preferred to see more clearly why they couldn't just kiss and make up through Theo's POV. But Theo was so ready to jump on that lmao, which I mean, completely understandable, I would've FOLDED at the first sign of interest. Anyway.
Even though it could've been better, it was great still. Seeing all of Catherine's work on herself, going to therapy and all, was great. Again, in this story love isn't something that cures you and makes every trauma go away. No, it's more like a constant hum in the back of your head and heart that accompanies and motivates you while you work on yourself, which is exactly how it is in real life. Love isn't a magical cure-all, but it can motivate us to be better and help us through the transformation. Seeing it depicted here was lovely. Felt very real.
Unrelated to anything but also I want to add that I kinda loved how Theo just mentions how she dated someone for the briefest of times after they broke up. I loved it because 1) i'm sorry but i kinda enjoyed the little sting Catherine felt (*evil laugh*) and 2) i love the idea that Theo wanted to forget yet she really couldn't because they're mean to be each other's person. Lovely, really. [Bonus reason: when Theo said that she needed someone to choose her, to want her after the rejection... damn. Broke me. I've been Theo, it's not fun.]
Which takes me to Theo's arc. I think it was so wholesome, even if a tad abrupt. Not her deciding she wanted to pursue a different way of practicing medicine, but her taking all the steps felt a tiniest bit quick. I won't dock any points because of that, tho, because I don't know if it could've been done any differently —I think that wasn't the point of the story so we just glazed over it.
Theo finding a new kind of joy in the world was the best. After seeing her struggle with Harry and being in the ER, it was so welcomed to see her happy at her job.
The piano concert at the fundraiser was awesome, too. I was listening to classical music while reading it, 10/10 highly recommend! This book reminded me of my love for classical music in general, so it was extra special. I was the kind of kid who would actually listen to my classical CDs (they were my dad's but i kinda stole them lmao) instead of other artists. Then I grew up and kinda forgot about it? But I'm BACK, baby!
Special shout-out to Mary, the nosiest, most meddling neighbor we all need.
I know the spoiler section is all over the place. Honestly, I'm just HAPPY! Liked this so much. And yes, I did fall in love with Theo. I will not be calling her her full name because that's her wife's thing, but I mean... What an attractive and sweet woman. I need a Theo in my life.
That's it, I did rave about the book! Thanks for reading ❤️
Absolutely fell in love with this book- it had me laughing and crying and falling in love at the same time! All I can say is please take this review seriously and get this book! Absolutely fantastic!
Incredible! I could not put this book down. Not only because it was fantastic but also because I was physically sick during all of the conflict. The writing made me feel so unbelievably connected to each of these characters that I felt every moment of their pain and grief so comprehensively. This book was truly a journey. I miss Theo and Catherine, ugh, I would read an endless amount of books about them. I want more!
Witty and angsty 😊 In the Lonely Hours started hilariously with the post-it note war between neighbours, Theodora and Catherine. Who then became friends and more before things fell apart and they are left to pick up the pieces….slowly over time with help from wonderful supporting characters.
Where do I even start? I guess by saying ‘In the Lonely Hours’ is hands down the best book I’ve read all year.
Elle Alexandas writing is honestly addicting. Every paragraph, every piece of dialogue feels like it has earned its place in the book. And for me that is a tell-tale sign that an author genuinely knows how to not only tell a story, but how to write it.
Catherine and Theo are characters who stay with you. For me, Theo’s emotional journey was something I related deeply to. And Catherine’s journey, on the contrary—which may sound stupid—felt like something I was owed. And their journey together? Maybe a little bit of hope.
Needless to say, this book has come to mean something personal to me. And if anyone ever tells me that romance books are lacking depth, I’m going to hit them so hard over the head with the physical copy I’ve just ordered of this book.
I don’t even know if there are words to depict how much I adored this book. It had everything I wanted and more. I loved the themes, the motifs , the sticky notes, banter, chemistry, found family, EVERYTHING.
I enjoyed learning more about classical music as well. Both MCs were so loveable. They were both complex, strong and independent. Not only do you fall in love with them, you find yourself falling in love with the side characters as well. Coming from a social work background, the issues that Theo would see at work were so relatable. The systems we have in place are broken. It’s stitch them and ditch them. I think the author did a phenomenal job at portraying this and also showing the complexities of it. I think the contrast between Theo and her parents with how they handle patients and the stress was a genius way to depict aspects of this too!
The author does an amazing job at fleshing them out, especially Harry and Mary! They both were such pivotal and important parts of Catherine and Theodora’s story.
I loved the reoccurring theme of music and sticky notes. Everything was tied up nicely and the epilogue was more than I imagined. I really would love a short story or novella of Catherine and Theodora just to see where they are after the things they discussed (spoilers). This is going into my favorites and will definitely be a physical copy I’ll need to buy and reread!
I really enjoyed the banter in it and the heartfelt moments. The sticky notes war got me laughing out loud, while the backstories of Theo and Catherine made me want to hug them tight.
Sorta hurt-comfort age gap with a self controlled pianist and a deeply optimistic and "I wear my heart on a sleeve" young ER doctor.
Loved also the secondary characters. Bless Mary lol.
Only one note about this:
"Catherine's fingers froze on the ivory" Since my native language is not English, I am wondering if this really means "ivory", which luckily started being removed from piano keys from the 50s and in the 80s was officially banned, because of the killing of elephants and other animals for it. Nowadays, you can't even sell just like that an ancient piano with ivory keys. It would feel a bit out of character for Catherine to own such piano. But maybe the author meant the color... or the ivory touch. My electric piano has ivory touch keys, for example.
Anyway, 4.5 stars. Love me some classical music. Claire de Lune 🥹 Still, loved that Catherine played also Einaudi!
its been almost a year since i read a 5 stars book.
i had really high expectation for this one when i saw multiple of people i follow in goodreads giving it high score and talking good about it.
it did not disappoint at all.
this a beatiful story where the yearning leaves with your chest tight and waiting for it all to drop.
i'm a bit stunned, every page, every moment was necessary and it never lost my interest. I read for three hours one day and it gave me back the satisfaction of encountering a book that get a hold of your emotions.
i could try and talk about the characters and their dynamic but i think someone elses out there must have explained better.
However, it was a wondeful experience to read Theo and Catherine fell in love.
Since the first sticky note and the petty exchanges to learning to decipher music notes or the sound of a pair of shoes, the author perfectly manage to show how to different world and personalities can tangle around each other so tight that the imprint of the other person will never leave.
Fine for the first half but pulled and I started to skip read and felt I was missing nothing, which was sad. Ok, lucky to have 4*s but the opening dialogues made it worth it.
I was very excited for this novel, and it is unfortunate to say that I had mixed feelings upon reading it. It was good, but also felt like something was missing? As though the parts that I took issue with were regarding things that were not actually on the page. Maybe it’s a me issue; I would not discourage anyone from reading this, and I know several people who enjoyed it more than I did.
The Good: -There were many wonderful scenes in this novel that I enjoyed a lot. There were some excellent choices made and details I adored. The sticky-notes? Pure gold. I wish there had been considerably more! -I liked how this novel addressed some more serious topics alongside the whimsy of the central plot. I thought the handling of a certain medical condition was well done. -I liked the protagonists together, when they were together. I love a supportive partner, or the dynamic when someone can read you so well that its annoying. -I loved Harry.
Complaint-Town: -My main issue is that I felt like there was far too much that took place off-page that we didn’t see, and it was some of the good stuff! Through the entire first half I was confused about the nature/status of their relationship; it seemed like off-page they had a ton of conversations that we didn’t know about. Interactions we didn’t see, gifts given that we didn’t know about, etc. One minute I was thinking that they have only exchanged a few sticky-notes but then its referenced that they have had sufficient conversations that they know each others work schedules. Things like that; I would have loved to experience the relationship grow, moreso than be informed that it had happened. -The elements outside of their direct relationship felt under-developed (though they contributed a lot to the novel!). Simon existed and was a subplot, but it didn’t really seem to matter much or go anywhere. Similar to Theo’s parents; I loved the subplot but then it seemed to get essentially abandoned, and they were very two-dimensional at the best of times. -Bunch of little things…. Are you writing in British English or American English? Do hospitals work that way? Why is there no soundproofing or rules against 2am concerts? -I had a hard time getting engaged in the story, and never felt that “pull” to read it. Idk why, probably what’s written above.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.