What do you think?
Rate this book
Hockey Boys of Loft 3B #2
Rival Season
He's trying to outrun his past...
Penn Matthews is living beyond his wildest dreams. He's made it to the NHL, shares a swanky loft with his teammates, and best of all, he's able to support his little sister. Life is good, and his rocky past is finally behind him.
Until Hazel Palmer shows up at his door.
His downstairs neighbor is as feisty as she is gorgeous, and the type of woman he'd be very interested in—if he hadn't sworn off falling in love years ago. But when Penn finds out Hazel just got her heart broken by his longtime rival, he steps in to help.
...She wants revenge on her cheating ex
Hazel should be writing her dissertation, but it's difficult to focus while dealing with betrayal, a breakup, and the constant distractions from her rowdy upstairs neighbor.
At first, she's convinced the tattooed hockey player in 3B is just another idiot playboy, but when Penn comes to her defense one night, the feuding neighbors realize they share a common enemy—and decide to get payback.
The plan is simple: fake date to make her ex jealous, and get the jerk out of both their lives for good.
But when fake kisses turn into real connection and Penn's past threatens to catch up to him, what started out as sweet revenge soon escalates to risking everything...
Penn Matthews is living beyond his wildest dreams. He's made it to the NHL, shares a swanky loft with his teammates, and best of all, he's able to support his little sister. Life is good, and his rocky past is finally behind him.
Until Hazel Palmer shows up at his door.
His downstairs neighbor is as feisty as she is gorgeous, and the type of woman he'd be very interested in—if he hadn't sworn off falling in love years ago. But when Penn finds out Hazel just got her heart broken by his longtime rival, he steps in to help.
...She wants revenge on her cheating ex
Hazel should be writing her dissertation, but it's difficult to focus while dealing with betrayal, a breakup, and the constant distractions from her rowdy upstairs neighbor.
At first, she's convinced the tattooed hockey player in 3B is just another idiot playboy, but when Penn comes to her defense one night, the feuding neighbors realize they share a common enemy—and decide to get payback.
The plan is simple: fake date to make her ex jealous, and get the jerk out of both their lives for good.
But when fake kisses turn into real connection and Penn's past threatens to catch up to him, what started out as sweet revenge soon escalates to risking everything...
320 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 14, 2026
About the author
Katie Bailey
13 books2,819 followersKatie Bailey is an Amazon top 25 bestselling author of rom coms with relatable characters and tons of chemistry. Her aim with every new love story she writes is to give readers a good laugh, maybe even a bit of a cry, but definitely leave them with a new book boyfriend.
When she’s not busy writing, Katie spends her time chasing twin tornado littles, cursing the cold Canadian winters she endures each year, chugging coffee by the bucketload, and crushing on her husband, who’s the real life inspiration behind all of the fictional men she’s written.
You can connect with Katie on Instagram @authorkatiebailey
When she’s not busy writing, Katie spends her time chasing twin tornado littles, cursing the cold Canadian winters she endures each year, chugging coffee by the bucketload, and crushing on her husband, who’s the real life inspiration behind all of the fictional men she’s written.
You can connect with Katie on Instagram @authorkatiebailey
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 491 reviews
June 23, 2026
⌞ 𝟓 𝒔𝒕𝒂𝒓𝒔. ⌝
This little found family is slowly becoming one of my comfort places. The banter and the connection they all have together is just so wholesome and addicting to read about.
Everything was just about perfect, from the deeply real characters to the plot that couldn't help but suck you in from the very first page. I loved that this book spends just as much time developing the plot and the characters than it does the romance. Both were done so well and were intertwined so perfectly with each other.
⌞ 𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝒑𝒍𝒐𝒕: ⌝
I have to admit, it was the tropes that really sold me on this book. I mean, getting revenge on a cheating ex? Satisfying. Dating said cheating ex's rival? Even better. And I thought it was unique that the authors had Chadwick (the cheating ex) stay in the picture as Hazel's roommate for most of the book. Although it frustrated me (in a good way), it ultimately made the revenge plot so much sweeter.
Speaking of sweeter, this book was just as sweet as it could get. On top of the delicious plot, the romance really captured my heart.
⌞ 𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝒓𝒐𝒎𝒂𝒏𝒄𝒆: ⌝
Their relationship moved seamlessly from hate, to friends, to mutual attraction to the sweetest most wholesome love you could ever ask for. Penn was deeply real and flawed, and he loved Hazel so fully. It was particularly amazing to see him have his happy ending after all the hardship he endured. He deserved the world and she gave it to him. Hazel just needed to be seen and appreciated, and Penn saw her for the person that she truly was and loved her even more deeply because of it. They fit together like puzzle pieces and the way everything came together in the end was so sweet and satisfying.
I know I've probably used the word sweet about a million times already, but it's truly the best word to encapsulate the essence of this book. It's sweet down to its very core and was honestly just a lovely, low stress experience. I didn't need any spice in this book nor did I want it. The close-door nature of the book worked incredibly well for the atmosphere of it.
⌞ 𝑪𝒍𝒐𝒔𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒕𝒉𝒐𝒖𝒈𝒉𝒕𝒔: ⌝
Katie Bailey and Leah Brunner are honestly becoming my favorite romance author duo. I have generally enjoyed both of their separate works in the past, but together, their writing is absolutely addictive. I enjoyed almost every moment of this book and the ending I particularly loved.
This book made me even more excited for Fisher's book, I just know his love story is going to be amazing--I can already tell.
*Katie or Leah, please contact me if you would like an advance reader, I would love a chance to read your guy's next book! Much love! 💕
This little found family is slowly becoming one of my comfort places. The banter and the connection they all have together is just so wholesome and addicting to read about.
Everything was just about perfect, from the deeply real characters to the plot that couldn't help but suck you in from the very first page. I loved that this book spends just as much time developing the plot and the characters than it does the romance. Both were done so well and were intertwined so perfectly with each other.
⌞ 𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝒑𝒍𝒐𝒕: ⌝
I have to admit, it was the tropes that really sold me on this book. I mean, getting revenge on a cheating ex? Satisfying. Dating said cheating ex's rival? Even better. And I thought it was unique that the authors had Chadwick (the cheating ex) stay in the picture as Hazel's roommate for most of the book. Although it frustrated me (in a good way), it ultimately made the revenge plot so much sweeter.
Speaking of sweeter, this book was just as sweet as it could get. On top of the delicious plot, the romance really captured my heart.
⌞ 𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝒓𝒐𝒎𝒂𝒏𝒄𝒆: ⌝
Their relationship moved seamlessly from hate, to friends, to mutual attraction to the sweetest most wholesome love you could ever ask for. Penn was deeply real and flawed, and he loved Hazel so fully. It was particularly amazing to see him have his happy ending after all the hardship he endured. He deserved the world and she gave it to him. Hazel just needed to be seen and appreciated, and Penn saw her for the person that she truly was and loved her even more deeply because of it. They fit together like puzzle pieces and the way everything came together in the end was so sweet and satisfying.
I know I've probably used the word sweet about a million times already, but it's truly the best word to encapsulate the essence of this book. It's sweet down to its very core and was honestly just a lovely, low stress experience. I didn't need any spice in this book nor did I want it. The close-door nature of the book worked incredibly well for the atmosphere of it.
⌞ 𝑪𝒍𝒐𝒔𝒊𝒏𝒈 𝒕𝒉𝒐𝒖𝒈𝒉𝒕𝒔: ⌝
Katie Bailey and Leah Brunner are honestly becoming my favorite romance author duo. I have generally enjoyed both of their separate works in the past, but together, their writing is absolutely addictive. I enjoyed almost every moment of this book and the ending I particularly loved.
This book made me even more excited for Fisher's book, I just know his love story is going to be amazing--I can already tell.
*Katie or Leah, please contact me if you would like an advance reader, I would love a chance to read your guy's next book! Much love! 💕
May 7, 2026
✨ Rating: 4.5⭐️
🫧 Vibes: this isn't pretend for me anymore
🎶 Song: she - zayn
📖 Favourite Quote: "I’ll spend my life loving Hazel in every thought, word, and action. Showing her she’s loved as well as telling her."
📚 Would I recommend? YES
💬 tldr thoughts: another sweet romance by one of my favourite authors duo!
In the package:
📦 fake dating
📦 neighbours to lovers
📦 family drama
📦 tension & angst
Plot: Hazel just found out her boyfriend cheated on her, and now she wants revenge. Her and her upstairs neighbour, Penn, decide to fake date each other. Hazel thought he was another hockey playboy but there's much more to Penn and things start to feel all too real.
Thoughts: I need everyone to pick up this series!! It's so underrated and if you liked the Off Campus books then you will definitely love these books as well. They're sweet, heartfelt and full of emotional depth. I equally loved Penn and Hazel together and as individuals. They both showed up for each other every time and it was so sweet. Penn grew up in the foster system and has time trusting others and thinking he's worthy of love but Hazel makes him realize that he is. I love that the romance is never surface level with these books, the characters all have internal conflicts to work through and they always do it together.
I despised Hazel's parents and how much they belittled her so when Penn stood up to them for her, I was swooning.
Thank you Eleventh Avenue Publishing Inc & LBP LLC and NetGalley for the eARC!
✩⁺₊✩☽⋆ follow me on tiktok and instagram⋆☾✩⁺₊✩
🫧 Vibes: this isn't pretend for me anymore
🎶 Song: she - zayn
📖 Favourite Quote: "I’ll spend my life loving Hazel in every thought, word, and action. Showing her she’s loved as well as telling her."
📚 Would I recommend? YES
💬 tldr thoughts: another sweet romance by one of my favourite authors duo!
In the package:
📦 fake dating
📦 neighbours to lovers
📦 family drama
📦 tension & angst
Plot: Hazel just found out her boyfriend cheated on her, and now she wants revenge. Her and her upstairs neighbour, Penn, decide to fake date each other. Hazel thought he was another hockey playboy but there's much more to Penn and things start to feel all too real.
Thoughts: I need everyone to pick up this series!! It's so underrated and if you liked the Off Campus books then you will definitely love these books as well. They're sweet, heartfelt and full of emotional depth. I equally loved Penn and Hazel together and as individuals. They both showed up for each other every time and it was so sweet. Penn grew up in the foster system and has time trusting others and thinking he's worthy of love but Hazel makes him realize that he is. I love that the romance is never surface level with these books, the characters all have internal conflicts to work through and they always do it together.
I despised Hazel's parents and how much they belittled her so when Penn stood up to them for her, I was swooning.
Thank you Eleventh Avenue Publishing Inc & LBP LLC and NetGalley for the eARC!
✩⁺₊✩☽⋆ follow me on tiktok and instagram⋆☾✩⁺₊✩
May 26, 2026
4 Canada Fest Stars ⭐️
Spicy Level: 0/5 (Closed Door)
I adore Leigh Brunner and Katie Bailey when they tandem write because they honestly write the cutest, wholesome, fluffy, feel-good books that you could ever ask for. I just know that no matter what, I’m going to fall in love with the characters, love their dynamic, love the romance, and finish the book smiling. And I know a lot of people criticise books that are closed-door and not spice-heavy… but honestly? Sometimes you don't want spice... These books are basically a hug on the page, and sometimes that’s exactly what I want.
𝙎𝙮𝙣𝙤𝙥𝙨𝙞𝙨:
This follows Hazel and Penn. Hazel has just found out that her Professional Hockey Player boyfriend has been cheating on her, which really puts a damper on her life because she’s currently house-sitting for his aunt and uncle in an apartment she absolutely loves. The only issue? The upstairs neighbours are a complete menace. And upstairs just so happens to be the Hockey Boys of 3B, including Penn… who also happens to be the biggest rival of Hazel’s ex-boyfriend. Now when Hazel’s ex gets injured and decides the best way to win her back is to basically move himself into her life again and force his grovelling on her, Hazel realises there might be one perfect way to make him back off… fake dating Penn Matthews. Because obviously, fake dating your cheating ex’s biggest rival could NEVER go wrong.
𝙏𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙜𝙝𝙩𝙨 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙁𝙚𝙚𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙜𝙨:
Hazel is your typical nerdy, quiet, overly studious FMC. She likes burying her head in books, cares deeply about doing the right thing, and just wants to finish her doctorate and make something of her life. She’s reserved, a little awkward, and very much gives good girl energy.
And then you have Penn. He's sexy, tattooed, who absolutely knows he’s attractive and could pull basically anyone he wants… but underneath all that Playboy energy is honestly the BIGGEST heart of gold. And I swear this man completely won me over. Because yes, he has the cocky hockey boy exterior, but underneath it he’s sweet, caring, protective, funny, and honestly just a giant golden retriever disguised as a tattooed NHL player. I genuinely think I might love him even more than Noah, and considering how much I adored Noah, that is saying SOMETHING.
As I said in the beginning, the relationship is just sweet. It develops slowly from this irritation/dislike dynamic into genuine friendship, trust, and attraction. And once they actually start getting to know each other, you can see how well they fit together. They really SEE each other, understand what matters to the other person, and connect.
𝙏𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨
▶ Hate to Love
▶ Fake Dating
▶ Neighbours (Forced Proximity)
▶ Ex's Rival
▶ Reverse GrumpyXSunshine
▶ Hockey Romance
▶ College/University Romance
and 𝙈𝙞𝙘𝙧𝙤 𝙏𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨:
▷ Tattooed MMC
▷ "Fuck It"
▷ Chin Lift
▷ Brings her food
▷ Backwards Cap
▷ Grey Sweatpants
▷ One Bed
Overall, this was cute, wholesome, fluffy, comforting, and exactly the type of book that just makes you happy while reading it. If you want a romance that feels like a warm hug with a little hockey thrown in, this is absolutely perfect for that.
Thank you so much to Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey for the gifted copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own
Spicy Level: 0/5 (Closed Door)
I adore Leigh Brunner and Katie Bailey when they tandem write because they honestly write the cutest, wholesome, fluffy, feel-good books that you could ever ask for. I just know that no matter what, I’m going to fall in love with the characters, love their dynamic, love the romance, and finish the book smiling. And I know a lot of people criticise books that are closed-door and not spice-heavy… but honestly? Sometimes you don't want spice... These books are basically a hug on the page, and sometimes that’s exactly what I want.
𝙎𝙮𝙣𝙤𝙥𝙨𝙞𝙨:
This follows Hazel and Penn. Hazel has just found out that her Professional Hockey Player boyfriend has been cheating on her, which really puts a damper on her life because she’s currently house-sitting for his aunt and uncle in an apartment she absolutely loves. The only issue? The upstairs neighbours are a complete menace. And upstairs just so happens to be the Hockey Boys of 3B, including Penn… who also happens to be the biggest rival of Hazel’s ex-boyfriend. Now when Hazel’s ex gets injured and decides the best way to win her back is to basically move himself into her life again and force his grovelling on her, Hazel realises there might be one perfect way to make him back off… fake dating Penn Matthews. Because obviously, fake dating your cheating ex’s biggest rival could NEVER go wrong.
𝙏𝙝𝙤𝙪𝙜𝙝𝙩𝙨 𝙖𝙣𝙙 𝙁𝙚𝙚𝙡𝙞𝙣𝙜𝙨:
Hazel is your typical nerdy, quiet, overly studious FMC. She likes burying her head in books, cares deeply about doing the right thing, and just wants to finish her doctorate and make something of her life. She’s reserved, a little awkward, and very much gives good girl energy.
And then you have Penn. He's sexy, tattooed, who absolutely knows he’s attractive and could pull basically anyone he wants… but underneath all that Playboy energy is honestly the BIGGEST heart of gold. And I swear this man completely won me over. Because yes, he has the cocky hockey boy exterior, but underneath it he’s sweet, caring, protective, funny, and honestly just a giant golden retriever disguised as a tattooed NHL player. I genuinely think I might love him even more than Noah, and considering how much I adored Noah, that is saying SOMETHING.
As I said in the beginning, the relationship is just sweet. It develops slowly from this irritation/dislike dynamic into genuine friendship, trust, and attraction. And once they actually start getting to know each other, you can see how well they fit together. They really SEE each other, understand what matters to the other person, and connect.
𝙏𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨
▶ Hate to Love
▶ Fake Dating
▶ Neighbours (Forced Proximity)
▶ Ex's Rival
▶ Reverse GrumpyXSunshine
▶ Hockey Romance
▶ College/University Romance
and 𝙈𝙞𝙘𝙧𝙤 𝙏𝙧𝙤𝙥𝙚𝙨:
▷ Tattooed MMC
▷ "Fuck It"
▷ Chin Lift
▷ Brings her food
▷ Backwards Cap
▷ Grey Sweatpants
▷ One Bed
Overall, this was cute, wholesome, fluffy, comforting, and exactly the type of book that just makes you happy while reading it. If you want a romance that feels like a warm hug with a little hockey thrown in, this is absolutely perfect for that.
Thank you so much to Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey for the gifted copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own
May 16, 2026
━━━ઇଓㅤ⤸
꒰ 𝐦𝐢𝐧𝐨𝐫 𝐬𝐩𝐨𝐢𝐥𝐞𝐫 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰 ꒱
𝟒-𝟒.𝟐𝟓 ✩
🎧꒱ 'Man I Need' | Olivia Dean
𝒯𝑜 𝒶𝓃𝓎𝑜𝓃𝑒 𝓌𝒽𝑜’𝓈 𝑒𝓋𝑒𝓇 𝒻𝑒𝓁𝓉 𝓊𝓃𝓁𝑜𝓋𝑒𝒶𝒷𝓁𝑒, 𝑜𝓇 𝒽𝒶𝓈 𝒽𝒶𝒹 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝓊𝓇𝑔𝑒 𝓉𝑜 𝒽𝒾𝒹𝑒 𝓌𝒽𝑜 𝓉𝒽𝑒𝓎 𝒶𝓇𝑒 𝒷𝑒𝒸𝒶𝓊𝓈𝑒 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝓇𝑒𝒶𝓁 𝓉𝒽𝑒𝓂 𝒹𝑜𝑒𝓈𝓃’𝓉 𝒻𝑒𝑒𝓁 𝓌𝑜𝓇𝓉𝒽𝓎… 𝒴𝑜𝓊 𝒶𝓇𝑒 𝑒𝓃𝑜𝓊𝑔𝒽, 𝒿𝓊𝓈𝓉 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝓌𝒶𝓎 𝓎𝑜𝓊 𝒶𝓇𝑒.
꒰ 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬: ꒱
To be back in the beautiful world of Loft 3B was like a warm hug after a long, tiring day. I absolutely adored Noah and Ally’s love story and couldn’t wait for the second book–one of the goofy roommates and his downstairs neighbour. And from page one–the dedication already had me in tears; it hit a little too close to home–it did not disappoint.
The found family in this series is one that will make you both grin at the cheesiness and cackle at their hilarious antics, or tear up at how welcoming they are and the little safe haven they’ve created. I was very pleased to read that the cookie-making and reality TV-watching still remained, and even more so when Hazel was accepted into 3B’s family with open arms.
The romance in Rival Season was just as beautiful as the first book. We follow Hazel Palmer who just found out her boyfriend had cheated on her, and Penn Matthews who her ex is his biggest rival from high school. Naturally, they agree on fake dating to get revenge. But, somewhere along the way, their fake feelings turn into something more. I love a good fake dating romance, with all the public shows of affection and tension-filled moments when no one’s around, and this had everything I expected and wanted.
I thought it was hilarious how they were neighbours and started off on the wrong foot–Penn being too loud, always flirting with Hazel despite her clear distaste of him–but then they gradually developed real feelings for each other. It was cute, it was fluffy, but it was also emotional. It’s like they were healing a part of each other. Hazel was giving him love he’d never had when he was younger, supporting and showing up for him, not just the hockey player. And Penn was treating her the way she never was when she was with her cheating boyfriend, making her feel comfortable in her own skin instead of self-conscious.
There was a slight age gap, with Hazel being three years older than Penn, but she mentioned a few times that he was more mature than a lot of guys his age. He's also insanely respectful and thoughtful in every gift and simple gesture–actually listening to what she says and remembering her likes and dislikes. Maturity and gentlemanliness is attractive as hell, especially when you put him up against a guy who used the excuse that he’s ‘an athlete and has a lot of pent-up sexual desire’ when he was confronted about cheating. Speaking of, I wanted to climb through my kindle and absolutely beat the shit out of her ex. My goodness, he was infuriating!
It was so refreshing and heartwarming to read about Hazel's career in social work (finishing her dissertation so she can continue) volunteering to help give foster children what every child should have–warm clothes, a safe environment, love. And even though her family didn't support her whatsoever (her parents were absolute fucking idiots who were so disrespectful towards her and her goals), Penn was there assisting any chance he got, encouraging and reassuring her that what she is doing is incredible and inspiring and impactful (we love a man who backs his woman up).
The only issue I had was the conflict. Now, the conflict was good, but it also lacked/was a tad rushed. In Rookie Season the problems Noah and Ally had to overcome felt a little easy and quick to be resolved. I very much loved the book, but you also want some complications instead of sunshine and rainbows. This book, however, improved a lot. The issues introduced themselves early on; the plot hooked me in from the start. But while the conflict was there, the resolution as well as the characters’ backstory was what lacked. I wanted to know more about Penn’s family and what the specific event that’d been mentioned many times was, instead of a brief summary and a wrap-up that, to me, left the book feeling unfinished in a way. Don’t get me wrong, I love this series and everything about it, but if there’s going to be altercations between characters and a deep and dark backstory, please delve into it throughout the book, not leave it to the last few pages. My advice when reading this is: don’t expect lots of drama; it’s going to be very shallow. These authors had the chance to explore the character more, maybe even expand who's in the book and name a few more of their hockey teammates, but sadly didn’t.
All in all, despite my little negatives–I want to finish my review on a good note–returning to this beautiful hockey series full of found family and pure love has filled me with joy and elation and I can’t wait for the third book where we get to know more about Fisher (another goofy character!) and his love interest (I have no clue who it’s going to be). Penn and Hazel stole my heart, left me teary-eyed and pleased, and I couldn't have asked for a better story about healing and growth.
꒰ 𝐐𝐮𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐬: ꒱
I like hanging out doing these wholesome activities with my little Loft 3B family.
“Every girl needs a good shower cry once in a while.”
“Noah and Ally cook together, I clean up, and Fisher vacuums” He points at my chair. “And your job, Bubbles, is to sit your ass back down and relax for once.”
He smells warm and natural, like a sunny day in the forest.
“Bubbles, if we were really together…there’s no way I wouldn’t kiss you every chance I got.”
“I’ll be out in a second, hold your damn horses.”
“Yeehaw!” Fisher hollers in response.
There’s something about the combination of those intense eyes with that wild curly hair and the freckles dancing across her cheekbones that’s uniquely pretty. She’s the kind of pretty that makes you look then immediately want to look again.
“You don’t have to.”
“I want to.”
“Kiss me again, Penn.”
“I like that you thought of me.”
“I think about you all the time.”
“You’re beautiful, Hazel.”
“I was just thinking the same thing.”
“You were thinking that you’re beautiful?”
“No, you’re beautiful–er, handsome.”
“I’m glad you think so.”
She’s so damned pretty it almost hurts to look at her.
Why am I so unlovable?
“Hey, what’s wrong? What did I say?”
“Nothing!”
“You’re crying. It’s obviously not nothing. Tell me what I did so I can fix it.”
“Talk nerdy to me, Bubbles,” he whispers in a mock-seductive voice that makes me giggle.
I love Hazel. I’m in love with her. And dammit, I’d spend the day in hell if it meant I got to hold her hand.
“Respectfully, ma’am, you can insult me, and you can insult my family. I don’t really care; I can take it. I might even deserve it. But I will not sit here another second while you attack your daughter. I’ve never had more respect for another person than I do for Hazel. She’s incredible, and it’s devastating that you have no idea how amazing she is. You should hang on her every word, you should be damned impressed with everything she does. You should worship the ground this woman walks on, admire how she serves others. Instead, you belittle her, making it sound like she’s wasting her life. I hope someday you pull your heads out of your asses and discover how amazing your daughter is, but until that day comes, I’m out of here.” Penn turns and looks at me, cupping my face in one hand as he gently caresses my cheekbone with his thumb. Then he turns and leaves without another word.
━━━
𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐞𝐝: 15/5/2026
𝐅𝐢𝐧𝐢𝐬𝐡𝐞𝐝: 16/5/2026
-𝓖
꒰ 𝐦𝐢𝐧𝐨𝐫 𝐬𝐩𝐨𝐢𝐥𝐞𝐫 𝐫𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰 ꒱
𝟒-𝟒.𝟐𝟓 ✩
🎧꒱ 'Man I Need' | Olivia Dean
𝒯𝑜 𝒶𝓃𝓎𝑜𝓃𝑒 𝓌𝒽𝑜’𝓈 𝑒𝓋𝑒𝓇 𝒻𝑒𝓁𝓉 𝓊𝓃𝓁𝑜𝓋𝑒𝒶𝒷𝓁𝑒, 𝑜𝓇 𝒽𝒶𝓈 𝒽𝒶𝒹 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝓊𝓇𝑔𝑒 𝓉𝑜 𝒽𝒾𝒹𝑒 𝓌𝒽𝑜 𝓉𝒽𝑒𝓎 𝒶𝓇𝑒 𝒷𝑒𝒸𝒶𝓊𝓈𝑒 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝓇𝑒𝒶𝓁 𝓉𝒽𝑒𝓂 𝒹𝑜𝑒𝓈𝓃’𝓉 𝒻𝑒𝑒𝓁 𝓌𝑜𝓇𝓉𝒽𝓎… 𝒴𝑜𝓊 𝒶𝓇𝑒 𝑒𝓃𝑜𝓊𝑔𝒽, 𝒿𝓊𝓈𝓉 𝓉𝒽𝑒 𝓌𝒶𝓎 𝓎𝑜𝓊 𝒶𝓇𝑒.
꒰ 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬: ꒱
To be back in the beautiful world of Loft 3B was like a warm hug after a long, tiring day. I absolutely adored Noah and Ally’s love story and couldn’t wait for the second book–one of the goofy roommates and his downstairs neighbour. And from page one–the dedication already had me in tears; it hit a little too close to home–it did not disappoint.
The found family in this series is one that will make you both grin at the cheesiness and cackle at their hilarious antics, or tear up at how welcoming they are and the little safe haven they’ve created. I was very pleased to read that the cookie-making and reality TV-watching still remained, and even more so when Hazel was accepted into 3B’s family with open arms.
[ Penn and his roommates make me feel more seen and welcome than I’ve ever felt in a very long time. ]
[ Ally is always wrangling us guys into doing all kinds of roommate activities with her. We have a weekly ritual where we all watch a trashy reality TV show she loves (okay, fine, we’re all hooked), she drags us guys on regular morning runs with her, and we’ve even spent a few nights helping her bake cookies. ]
[ Noah is quiet but hilarious with his dry one-liners. Fisher is the golden retriever of the loft, flirty and fun, but I think there’s more to him deep down. And Penn is a chameleon, soaking in whatever’s going on around him and matching the vibe seamlessly. ]Their friendship is endearing and I love how they all look out for one another like it’s the most natural thing. And for someone like Hazel, who didn’t have many friends or people to look out for her, to find a group like 3B with a cheery girl like Ally who she can hang out and talk girly stuff with and charming but respectful guys like Noah, Penn, and Fisher was the most wholesome and uplifting thing ever. Yes, she is a handful of years older than them and at first felt like an outsider, but they made her feel loved. And in the end, she realised that age is just a number. They are her family. Whether it’s hockey games, trivia nights, or tagging along to art galleries, they’re together–as a group, as friends, and most importantly as family.
The romance in Rival Season was just as beautiful as the first book. We follow Hazel Palmer who just found out her boyfriend had cheated on her, and Penn Matthews who her ex is his biggest rival from high school. Naturally, they agree on fake dating to get revenge. But, somewhere along the way, their fake feelings turn into something more. I love a good fake dating romance, with all the public shows of affection and tension-filled moments when no one’s around, and this had everything I expected and wanted.
I thought it was hilarious how they were neighbours and started off on the wrong foot–Penn being too loud, always flirting with Hazel despite her clear distaste of him–but then they gradually developed real feelings for each other. It was cute, it was fluffy, but it was also emotional. It’s like they were healing a part of each other. Hazel was giving him love he’d never had when he was younger, supporting and showing up for him, not just the hockey player. And Penn was treating her the way she never was when she was with her cheating boyfriend, making her feel comfortable in her own skin instead of self-conscious.
There was a slight age gap, with Hazel being three years older than Penn, but she mentioned a few times that he was more mature than a lot of guys his age. He's also insanely respectful and thoughtful in every gift and simple gesture–actually listening to what she says and remembering her likes and dislikes. Maturity and gentlemanliness is attractive as hell, especially when you put him up against a guy who used the excuse that he’s ‘an athlete and has a lot of pent-up sexual desire’ when he was confronted about cheating. Speaking of, I wanted to climb through my kindle and absolutely beat the shit out of her ex. My goodness, he was infuriating!
It was so refreshing and heartwarming to read about Hazel's career in social work (finishing her dissertation so she can continue) volunteering to help give foster children what every child should have–warm clothes, a safe environment, love. And even though her family didn't support her whatsoever (her parents were absolute fucking idiots who were so disrespectful towards her and her goals), Penn was there assisting any chance he got, encouraging and reassuring her that what she is doing is incredible and inspiring and impactful (we love a man who backs his woman up).
The only issue I had was the conflict. Now, the conflict was good, but it also lacked/was a tad rushed. In Rookie Season the problems Noah and Ally had to overcome felt a little easy and quick to be resolved. I very much loved the book, but you also want some complications instead of sunshine and rainbows. This book, however, improved a lot. The issues introduced themselves early on; the plot hooked me in from the start. But while the conflict was there, the resolution as well as the characters’ backstory was what lacked. I wanted to know more about Penn’s family and what the specific event that’d been mentioned many times was, instead of a brief summary and a wrap-up that, to me, left the book feeling unfinished in a way. Don’t get me wrong, I love this series and everything about it, but if there’s going to be altercations between characters and a deep and dark backstory, please delve into it throughout the book, not leave it to the last few pages. My advice when reading this is: don’t expect lots of drama; it’s going to be very shallow. These authors had the chance to explore the character more, maybe even expand who's in the book and name a few more of their hockey teammates, but sadly didn’t.
All in all, despite my little negatives–I want to finish my review on a good note–returning to this beautiful hockey series full of found family and pure love has filled me with joy and elation and I can’t wait for the third book where we get to know more about Fisher (another goofy character!) and his love interest (I have no clue who it’s going to be). Penn and Hazel stole my heart, left me teary-eyed and pleased, and I couldn't have asked for a better story about healing and growth.
꒰ 𝐐𝐮𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐬: ꒱
I like hanging out doing these wholesome activities with my little Loft 3B family.
“Every girl needs a good shower cry once in a while.”
“Noah and Ally cook together, I clean up, and Fisher vacuums” He points at my chair. “And your job, Bubbles, is to sit your ass back down and relax for once.”
He smells warm and natural, like a sunny day in the forest.
“Bubbles, if we were really together…there’s no way I wouldn’t kiss you every chance I got.”
“I’ll be out in a second, hold your damn horses.”
“Yeehaw!” Fisher hollers in response.
There’s something about the combination of those intense eyes with that wild curly hair and the freckles dancing across her cheekbones that’s uniquely pretty. She’s the kind of pretty that makes you look then immediately want to look again.
“You don’t have to.”
“I want to.”
“Kiss me again, Penn.”
“I like that you thought of me.”
“I think about you all the time.”
“You’re beautiful, Hazel.”
“I was just thinking the same thing.”
“You were thinking that you’re beautiful?”
“No, you’re beautiful–er, handsome.”
“I’m glad you think so.”
She’s so damned pretty it almost hurts to look at her.
Why am I so unlovable?
“Hey, what’s wrong? What did I say?”
“Nothing!”
“You’re crying. It’s obviously not nothing. Tell me what I did so I can fix it.”
“Talk nerdy to me, Bubbles,” he whispers in a mock-seductive voice that makes me giggle.
I love Hazel. I’m in love with her. And dammit, I’d spend the day in hell if it meant I got to hold her hand.
“Respectfully, ma’am, you can insult me, and you can insult my family. I don’t really care; I can take it. I might even deserve it. But I will not sit here another second while you attack your daughter. I’ve never had more respect for another person than I do for Hazel. She’s incredible, and it’s devastating that you have no idea how amazing she is. You should hang on her every word, you should be damned impressed with everything she does. You should worship the ground this woman walks on, admire how she serves others. Instead, you belittle her, making it sound like she’s wasting her life. I hope someday you pull your heads out of your asses and discover how amazing your daughter is, but until that day comes, I’m out of here.” Penn turns and looks at me, cupping my face in one hand as he gently caresses my cheekbone with his thumb. Then he turns and leaves without another word.
━━━
𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐞𝐝: 15/5/2026
𝐅𝐢𝐧𝐢𝐬𝐡𝐞𝐝: 16/5/2026
-𝓖
May 19, 2026
Rival Season by Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey
-Hockey Boys of 3B, Book 2-
3.5/5🌶️
🚪*fade to black
2/3🦋
•My Thoughts•
Overall this was entertaining and a quick and easy read. I enjoyed the storyline and the tropes. However, I struggled with feeling like an old grandma during this - it felt very college without anyone being in college. There were certain scenes that felt really young to me (house party, drinking shots) and even the way the main characters were dealing with their past or families somehow felt young. Young doesn’t feel like the right word but I’m struggling to communicate, maybe two dimensional or obvious? Like the issues weren’t really given a lot of depth and the people we don’t like were so obviously horrible. A few back story items weren’t given a lot of time or development and I wanted more! I realize that this is labeled as New Adult so maybe I need to take my old self to a different genre *but* usually, I’m unbothered. I did continue to enjoy the friend group of 3B and their banter. Penn and Hazel were easy to root for and I loved the way they complimented each other. Fake dating is one of my favorites, too, so this was a fun time. The epilogue had some fun insight into the next book and I’m intrigued by Fisher’s story!
Thank you to the authors and Booked with the Emilys for the early copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
-Hockey Boys of 3B, Book 2-
3.5/5🌶️
🚪*fade to black
2/3🦋
•My Thoughts•
Overall this was entertaining and a quick and easy read. I enjoyed the storyline and the tropes. However, I struggled with feeling like an old grandma during this - it felt very college without anyone being in college. There were certain scenes that felt really young to me (house party, drinking shots) and even the way the main characters were dealing with their past or families somehow felt young. Young doesn’t feel like the right word but I’m struggling to communicate, maybe two dimensional or obvious? Like the issues weren’t really given a lot of depth and the people we don’t like were so obviously horrible. A few back story items weren’t given a lot of time or development and I wanted more! I realize that this is labeled as New Adult so maybe I need to take my old self to a different genre *but* usually, I’m unbothered. I did continue to enjoy the friend group of 3B and their banter. Penn and Hazel were easy to root for and I loved the way they complimented each other. Fake dating is one of my favorites, too, so this was a fun time. The epilogue had some fun insight into the next book and I’m intrigued by Fisher’s story!
Thank you to the authors and Booked with the Emilys for the early copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
April 27, 2026
As a huge fan of the first book in the series, Rookie Season, I knew I was going to love this one. This sports romance series follows a group of hockey players who share a loft and navigate life, professional hockey, love, and friendships. These are the kind of books that don’t need spice to have amazing tension and romance. They can be read as standalone’s but I would recommend reading them in order to fully connect to the group of characters.The loft setting and banter between them all is very “New Girl” coded. A fun time for anyone looking for an underrated sports romance series to obsess over.
Hazel and Penn’s story did not disappoint. They are neighbors whose relationship consists of her coming to his door angrily to complain about the noise constantly. She’s the serious one and he loves to push her buttons every chance he gets. When he sees her arguing with her ex boyfriend who cheated on her, he steps in to help her. What starts out as a fake dating situation quickly evolves into something neither of them expected. I loved the chemistry between these two so much. He calls her “Bubbles” and it’s literally my favorite thing.
-Hockey Romance
-Neighbors To Lovers
-Cinnamon Roll Hero
-Revenge Fake Dating
-”New Girl” Coded Group
-Spice Free Romance
Coming May 14th. Plenty of time to read book one, Rookie Season, before the release!
Hazel and Penn’s story did not disappoint. They are neighbors whose relationship consists of her coming to his door angrily to complain about the noise constantly. She’s the serious one and he loves to push her buttons every chance he gets. When he sees her arguing with her ex boyfriend who cheated on her, he steps in to help her. What starts out as a fake dating situation quickly evolves into something neither of them expected. I loved the chemistry between these two so much. He calls her “Bubbles” and it’s literally my favorite thing.
-Hockey Romance
-Neighbors To Lovers
-Cinnamon Roll Hero
-Revenge Fake Dating
-”New Girl” Coded Group
-Spice Free Romance
Coming May 14th. Plenty of time to read book one, Rookie Season, before the release!
May 25, 2026
3.75⭐️
This book was fun and silly and yes, a little cringey but I had a good time reading. FINALLY a romance book where the characters were mature and there was no miscommunication.
This book was fun and silly and yes, a little cringey but I had a good time reading. FINALLY a romance book where the characters were mature and there was no miscommunication.
April 16, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
- Book 2 of the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B
- FTB New Adult Romcom
- Complicated family relationships/past
- Faking dating
- Found family
- Hockey player MMC
- PhD student FMC
- She’s older
✨ a few of my favorite things:
- Sweet Penn and his protectiveness
- Penn & Cassie have the sweetest relationship
- Ally & Hazel becoming friends
- the red dress 😏
- “Some rules were meant to be broken”
- THE TENSION
- The nicknames
- How he takes care of her
- Their thoughtfulness for one another
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Ahhh!! I was just as obsessed with book 2 as I was with book 1! I was again so entertained by the hockey boys of loft 3B. Maybe even more! I really loved how Penn and Hazel’s relationship developed. Penn was so good at comforting her and putting her at least. I adored the way the gravitated towards one another and teased each other. Their flirting was so fun and holy crap do these two have so much chemistry!! Leah and Katie KNOW how to write chemistry!!! All the little touches!!! I couldn’t get enough of them.
I appreciated the depth of character and how both MCs weren’t perfect. Rather they both had to work through some insecurities and internal conflicts. Also I so appreciated that Hazel made the move 😉 *no spoilers* but I LOVE the honesty. I appreciated how Penn recognized sleeping around and partying are not fulfilling. I liked him showing her in actions and words that he wasn’t in it for the physical even though they were attracted to one another.
This is a fade to black romcom with mild language, passionate/descriptive making out, strong innuendo, and a quick non-descriptive fade to black in the epilogue. The characters do party, drink, and talk about sex. The authors have a content warning in the beginning of the book.
**Thank you so much to Leah, Katie, and Booked With The Emilys for letting me read this gifted ARC. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**
Song:
Grave by Avery Anna
Mr. Predictable by Avery Anna
Slim pickins by Sabrina Carpenter
Pancakes for Dinner by Lizzy McAlpine
Glad you exist by Dan + Shay
Dress by Taylor Swift **
Wow by Sabrina Carpenter & Zara Larson
Nonsense by Sabrina Carpenter
- Book 2 of the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B
- FTB New Adult Romcom
- Complicated family relationships/past
- Faking dating
- Found family
- Hockey player MMC
- PhD student FMC
- She’s older
✨ a few of my favorite things:
- Sweet Penn and his protectiveness
- Penn & Cassie have the sweetest relationship
- Ally & Hazel becoming friends
- the red dress 😏
- “Some rules were meant to be broken”
- THE TENSION
- The nicknames
- How he takes care of her
- Their thoughtfulness for one another
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Ahhh!! I was just as obsessed with book 2 as I was with book 1! I was again so entertained by the hockey boys of loft 3B. Maybe even more! I really loved how Penn and Hazel’s relationship developed. Penn was so good at comforting her and putting her at least. I adored the way the gravitated towards one another and teased each other. Their flirting was so fun and holy crap do these two have so much chemistry!! Leah and Katie KNOW how to write chemistry!!! All the little touches!!! I couldn’t get enough of them.
I appreciated the depth of character and how both MCs weren’t perfect. Rather they both had to work through some insecurities and internal conflicts. Also I so appreciated that Hazel made the move 😉 *no spoilers* but I LOVE the honesty. I appreciated how Penn recognized sleeping around and partying are not fulfilling. I liked him showing her in actions and words that he wasn’t in it for the physical even though they were attracted to one another.
This is a fade to black romcom with mild language, passionate/descriptive making out, strong innuendo, and a quick non-descriptive fade to black in the epilogue. The characters do party, drink, and talk about sex. The authors have a content warning in the beginning of the book.
**Thank you so much to Leah, Katie, and Booked With The Emilys for letting me read this gifted ARC. No positive review was required. All thoughts are my own.**
Song:
Grave by Avery Anna
Mr. Predictable by Avery Anna
Slim pickins by Sabrina Carpenter
Pancakes for Dinner by Lizzy McAlpine
Glad you exist by Dan + Shay
Dress by Taylor Swift **
Wow by Sabrina Carpenter & Zara Larson
Nonsense by Sabrina Carpenter
May 26, 2026
One thing for sure…two things for certain. Katie Bailey and Leah Brunner will get this girl out of a slump!
I DEVOURED this book! I was sad when I had to go to sleep and still had a little bit left. (Being an adult who can’t stay up all night anymore kinda stinks)
But I A! DORED! Penn & Hazel. They were THE MOST adorable couple ever - and the fake dating trope was literally perfection for this story! I LOVED THE RIVALRY THEME & and the REVENGE RULES!!
Katie & Leah are both FANTASTIC at writing such real feeling characters! Their thoughts & feelings are so tangible, and honestly just so relatable.
This book pulled on my heart strings, it made me giggle, it made me swoon, it made me fan myself a few times (these girls can write some chemistry- and some kisses *whew*), it made me want to slap some people, and hug some people.
It just was…so fabulous!
I’m DYING for Fisher’s story now! (Especially after that epilogue 😏🤔)
5/5 stars
{this book is closed door - but with heavier innuendo & language!}
*I received this book from the authors**All options are my own*
I DEVOURED this book! I was sad when I had to go to sleep and still had a little bit left. (Being an adult who can’t stay up all night anymore kinda stinks)
But I A! DORED! Penn & Hazel. They were THE MOST adorable couple ever - and the fake dating trope was literally perfection for this story! I LOVED THE RIVALRY THEME & and the REVENGE RULES!!
Katie & Leah are both FANTASTIC at writing such real feeling characters! Their thoughts & feelings are so tangible, and honestly just so relatable.
This book pulled on my heart strings, it made me giggle, it made me swoon, it made me fan myself a few times (these girls can write some chemistry- and some kisses *whew*), it made me want to slap some people, and hug some people.
It just was…so fabulous!
I’m DYING for Fisher’s story now! (Especially after that epilogue 😏🤔)
5/5 stars
{this book is closed door - but with heavier innuendo & language!}
*I received this book from the authors**All options are my own*
May 27, 2026
Rival Season by Katie Bailey and Leah Brunner
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:fade to black
Age rating:15+
This had me invested from the very first page. I absolutely ADORE Penn and Hazel. They’re just so so so precious and truly see each other for who they are and I WANT THAT. Someone get me a hockey player please. The romance was perfect. The found family was perfect. The banter, tension, just EVERYTHING was perfect. Such a fun time. I laughed so much and couldn’t stop smiling. And the end?! AMAZING! I need book three in my hands as soon as possible. Definitely recommend!
Rating:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:fade to black
Age rating:15+
This had me invested from the very first page. I absolutely ADORE Penn and Hazel. They’re just so so so precious and truly see each other for who they are and I WANT THAT. Someone get me a hockey player please. The romance was perfect. The found family was perfect. The banter, tension, just EVERYTHING was perfect. Such a fun time. I laughed so much and couldn’t stop smiling. And the end?! AMAZING! I need book three in my hands as soon as possible. Definitely recommend!
June 24, 2026
Definitely a 4.75 this book is SOOOOOO good!!!!!! Idk how this series isn’t more popular. I am sooo so sooo excited for the third book to come out in August! Guys! I swear please read these. They are the best hockey romances of all time!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Content: There is language that is comparable to book 1 such as sh*t, a$s, a$shole, da*n or h*ll , and d*ck throughout the book. While f-bombs were not used, using puck was the substitute. (40 times) Now, realistically these are hockey players so it makes only sense for the novel. This book had parts was a tad bit attraction driven for my taste but nothing in this book is gross or derogatory. The protective nature of Penn was so wonderful and I love that this was also more than a romance. It talked about self worth, foster care and had aspects of found family. Every situation is this book was well thought out and the ending made me tear up. This book is 100% closed door and never crossed any lines even in the make-out scenes . The make-out scene was detailed for my taste and there is also one scene that fit a partying lifestyle the authors are portraying and it was tastefully done. This was your classic fake dating story in the world of hockey and the writing was bingebable. I also like how the story unfolded and there was so much clear communication. Also can we talk about a studious PHD queen? Do I wish we seen more chemistry between them, yea but they were also fighting to get rid of the ex. I think the FMC fell more in love or you can see her fall in love Penn beyond attraction compared to Penn, just saying. ALSO the fade to black happens very vaguely between a married couple in the last two pages of the book. This was a quick, cute, NA hockey romance .
All in All, if you love Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey and were are okay with book 1, this book is fun. I would only recommend this if you read book 1 and liked it.
I wasn’t bothered by the content because I knew what I was getting into and I applaud Leah and Katie for address that this does not go into the clean and wholesome category because of the inneudo and language.
was the one bed necessary? no , it would have been better if it wasnt there.
Hazels ex was a dirtbag hahah maybe too much
All in All, if you love Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey and were are okay with book 1, this book is fun. I would only recommend this if you read book 1 and liked it.
I wasn’t bothered by the content because I knew what I was getting into and I applaud Leah and Katie for address that this does not go into the clean and wholesome category because of the inneudo and language.
was the one bed necessary? no , it would have been better if it wasnt there.
Hazels ex was a dirtbag hahah maybe too much
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 26, 2026
This is an ARC Review of Rival Season by Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey. Rival Season is scheduled for release on May 14, 2026.
Thanks to Booked with the Emilys, Leah Bruner, and Katie Bailey for the gifted copy of this book. It is always a privilege to be an ARC reader.
A few months ago, I wondered what all the hype with hockey romances was. Don’t get me wrong, I love a good romance novel. I just wasn’t sure why hockey specifically had become such a popular theme in romance stories.
Since then, I have read a few hockey romances including Rival Season. Rival Season is a great example of why these books are so loved these days. It includes classic tropes such as fake dating, good girl/reformed bad boy, and neighbors.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was sweet, funny, and quick-paced. The secondary characters were just as likable as the main characters. There’s nothing I would change except for maybe some of the names, but that’s 100% a me problem.
Thanks to Booked with the Emilys, Leah Bruner, and Katie Bailey for the gifted copy of this book. It is always a privilege to be an ARC reader.
A few months ago, I wondered what all the hype with hockey romances was. Don’t get me wrong, I love a good romance novel. I just wasn’t sure why hockey specifically had become such a popular theme in romance stories.
Since then, I have read a few hockey romances including Rival Season. Rival Season is a great example of why these books are so loved these days. It includes classic tropes such as fake dating, good girl/reformed bad boy, and neighbors.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was sweet, funny, and quick-paced. The secondary characters were just as likable as the main characters. There’s nothing I would change except for maybe some of the names, but that’s 100% a me problem.
May 18, 2026
3.5🌟
Me han parecido monísimos siguiendo la línea del primero, peeeeeeeeeeeero por cómo se nos había presentado su dinámica en el libro anterior me esperaba que hubiese más banter de "enemies" y no todo tan rápido en cuanto a que se hiciesen amigos y demás.
Me han parecido monísimos siguiendo la línea del primero, peeeeeeeeeeeero por cómo se nos había presentado su dinámica en el libro anterior me esperaba que hubiese más banter de "enemies" y no todo tan rápido en cuanto a que se hiciesen amigos y demás.
May 29, 2026
Thank you, Partner, @bookedwiththeemilys @leah.brunner.writes & @authorkatiebailey for the #gifted copy of "Rival Season" [Pub Date: Out Now]
Fake dating is the trope theme for me this year & Rival Season is the top-tier "lets pretend to date" story. Quite honestly dating to get revenge on a cheating ex + a dirty dog of a rival is a win-win in my book. Fake kisses never read so sweet.
I am always a sucker for a man who does the small things to win over his love interest. I knew I was down bad for this book when Penn sent Hazel a pair of noise canceling head phones the first few chapters. The sweetness & swoon only keeps getting better as you read. *eeeep*
Don't even get me started on the D R A M A in this. I wanted to jump into the book & get my fisticuffs out.
The fake dating arrangement + the tattooed hockey player doing the sweetest things for his "Bubbles" are what made my heart swell for this story.
If you're suffering from an Off-Campus hangover, I highly recommend Leah & Katie's hockey books to itch your hockey romance scratch.
🏒 The nerdiest & most intelligent fmc (you'll probably want to grow up to be her one day)
💜 The MOST ADORABLE fur friend (IFYKYK)
🇨🇦 You'll want to wipe drool off your face after you meet the tattooed Penn
🏒 The fake dating arrangement is chefs kiss & the revenge is so sweet
💜 You'll probably want to punch a few characters in the throat & the drama is so worth it
🇨🇦 You're going to want to eat a truck load of routine & try out Maple drink recipes after reading this
🏒 Being on a trivia team is the only form of fun you're gonna want on a week night.
💜 Last & most important you're going to be mad that August isn't tomorrow because you're gonna itch for Fishers book...
Fake dating is the trope theme for me this year & Rival Season is the top-tier "lets pretend to date" story. Quite honestly dating to get revenge on a cheating ex + a dirty dog of a rival is a win-win in my book. Fake kisses never read so sweet.
I am always a sucker for a man who does the small things to win over his love interest. I knew I was down bad for this book when Penn sent Hazel a pair of noise canceling head phones the first few chapters. The sweetness & swoon only keeps getting better as you read. *eeeep*
Don't even get me started on the D R A M A in this. I wanted to jump into the book & get my fisticuffs out.
The fake dating arrangement + the tattooed hockey player doing the sweetest things for his "Bubbles" are what made my heart swell for this story.
If you're suffering from an Off-Campus hangover, I highly recommend Leah & Katie's hockey books to itch your hockey romance scratch.
🏒 The nerdiest & most intelligent fmc (you'll probably want to grow up to be her one day)
💜 The MOST ADORABLE fur friend (IFYKYK)
🇨🇦 You'll want to wipe drool off your face after you meet the tattooed Penn
🏒 The fake dating arrangement is chefs kiss & the revenge is so sweet
💜 You'll probably want to punch a few characters in the throat & the drama is so worth it
🇨🇦 You're going to want to eat a truck load of routine & try out Maple drink recipes after reading this
🏒 Being on a trivia team is the only form of fun you're gonna want on a week night.
💜 Last & most important you're going to be mad that August isn't tomorrow because you're gonna itch for Fishers book...
May 23, 2026
5 ⭐️
This book was SO GOOD! I read it in one sitting! I loved the last one, Rookie Season, so I was super excited when I heard the authors were writing a sequel. They did not disappoint at all. I loved the family dynamic of 3B again, and I loved how they included Hazel and made her feel loved. Honestly, I wish I lived in loft 3B too. The characters are so fun and they support each other so well. As always, I loved Ally’s character, and her and Hazel’s friendship was so wholesome and genuine. Penn was my favorite character( besides Ally) in Rookie Season, so I was so excited to read his book. The hype was so worth it, and it is one of my new favorites. Hazel is a great main character and so is Penn. I loved how foster care tied into Hazel’s job and Penn’s background. Also the Epilouge? So good! I was almost crying happy tears!! I can’t wait for Fishy’s book!! 🐠🏒⛸️
This book was SO GOOD! I read it in one sitting! I loved the last one, Rookie Season, so I was super excited when I heard the authors were writing a sequel. They did not disappoint at all. I loved the family dynamic of 3B again, and I loved how they included Hazel and made her feel loved. Honestly, I wish I lived in loft 3B too. The characters are so fun and they support each other so well. As always, I loved Ally’s character, and her and Hazel’s friendship was so wholesome and genuine. Penn was my favorite character( besides Ally) in Rookie Season, so I was so excited to read his book. The hype was so worth it, and it is one of my new favorites. Hazel is a great main character and so is Penn. I loved how foster care tied into Hazel’s job and Penn’s background. Also the Epilouge? So good! I was almost crying happy tears!! I can’t wait for Fishy’s book!! 🐠🏒⛸️
May 19, 2026
This book. This has been one of my most anticipated books for this year. Add in the next book in this series to that list as well.
I came across Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey about a year and a half ago. I have made my way through ALL of Katie’s backlist and have 2 books left with Leah’s. So combine the two for a book series and I was all in.
These two write this story flawlessly. It’s smooth, fun, entertaining, and full of emotion and angst. You easily get wrapped up in the story and I can vouch for the fact that putting it down to do life wasn’t easy.
I adored Penn’s bad boy exterior with the caring and loving interior. He’s sweet and loves hard for those in his close circle. He has a rough past and with that comes some insecurity and adds to the man he’s become. I respect him so much.
Then Hazel. She’s fire, especially around Penn. She has her own insecurities brought on by the need to be perfect and yet never measuring up for the ones she wants acceptance from the most.
I love their interactions at the beginning. The explosion of chemistry. The fake dating. The hate you to love you. It’s just so good.
So yes. I sing this book’s praises. And if you didn’t like it. Then that’s your prerogative. But I won’t stop, can’t stop.
Also the way they leave the ending. I need Fisher’s story NOW. Guess I will just have to wait. Fine.
[Again go into this book knowing it’s fade to black, there’s language, and it’s new adult romance. So this isn’t written for youth or teens. There’s banter and innuendos.]
I came across Leah Brunner and Katie Bailey about a year and a half ago. I have made my way through ALL of Katie’s backlist and have 2 books left with Leah’s. So combine the two for a book series and I was all in.
These two write this story flawlessly. It’s smooth, fun, entertaining, and full of emotion and angst. You easily get wrapped up in the story and I can vouch for the fact that putting it down to do life wasn’t easy.
I adored Penn’s bad boy exterior with the caring and loving interior. He’s sweet and loves hard for those in his close circle. He has a rough past and with that comes some insecurity and adds to the man he’s become. I respect him so much.
Then Hazel. She’s fire, especially around Penn. She has her own insecurities brought on by the need to be perfect and yet never measuring up for the ones she wants acceptance from the most.
I love their interactions at the beginning. The explosion of chemistry. The fake dating. The hate you to love you. It’s just so good.
So yes. I sing this book’s praises. And if you didn’t like it. Then that’s your prerogative. But I won’t stop, can’t stop.
Also the way they leave the ending. I need Fisher’s story NOW. Guess I will just have to wait. Fine.
[Again go into this book knowing it’s fade to black, there’s language, and it’s new adult romance. So this isn’t written for youth or teens. There’s banter and innuendos.]
June 6, 2026
4.75⭐️!!
This was the PERFECT palette cleanser I needed - I was blushing, giggling, and literally kicking my feet throughout this book!!🤭🦋 I read it in 24 hours, it was just so binge-able!! Hazel and Penn were so heartwarming and easy to root for; I mean who doesn’t love fake dating?😍 also I flippin hated Chadwick and their families 😒 it was hard not to scream at the pages throughout the whole book because he was the WORST🙅♀️
*rating dipped just a little for some crude humor/innuendo, lots of language. At least from my memory, this book has less of that than the first book!
This was the PERFECT palette cleanser I needed - I was blushing, giggling, and literally kicking my feet throughout this book!!🤭🦋 I read it in 24 hours, it was just so binge-able!! Hazel and Penn were so heartwarming and easy to root for; I mean who doesn’t love fake dating?😍 also I flippin hated Chadwick and their families 😒 it was hard not to scream at the pages throughout the whole book because he was the WORST🙅♀️
*rating dipped just a little for some crude humor/innuendo, lots of language. At least from my memory, this book has less of that than the first book!
May 24, 2026
I am loving this series so much!!!! I absolutely love a book with fake dating and ate it up in this book. I love the found family with Penn and his roommates and the romance in this was just perfect! It was so sweet seeing both of the characters realize they deserve someone who deeply understands and loves them 🥲 I am so excited for the next book!!!
June 10, 2026
4 ★
Sweet, wholesome, fluffy, comforting, and so much more. I really really liked this one! So excited for book 3 in August!
Sweet, wholesome, fluffy, comforting, and so much more. I really really liked this one! So excited for book 3 in August!
May 13, 2026
Thank you, Partner, @bookedwiththeemilys @leah.brunner.writes @authorkatiebailey for my gifted ARC.
This is book two of the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B series, and I loved it! Penn and Hazel were everything with their fake-dating romance. They navigate some complicated family dynamics, a toxic ex-boyfriend, and their growing feelings for each other. Honestly, it's been a while since I read a book this fast. Now I want to re-read it and listen to the audiobook!
Read this book if you enjoy:
-Hockey Romance
-Fake Dating
-Tattooed MMC
-Neighbors
-Revenge
-Good girl heroine
-Firstborn daughter
-Cinnamon roll hero
-Reformed bad boy
This is book two of the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B series, and I loved it! Penn and Hazel were everything with their fake-dating romance. They navigate some complicated family dynamics, a toxic ex-boyfriend, and their growing feelings for each other. Honestly, it's been a while since I read a book this fast. Now I want to re-read it and listen to the audiobook!
Read this book if you enjoy:
-Hockey Romance
-Fake Dating
-Tattooed MMC
-Neighbors
-Revenge
-Good girl heroine
-Firstborn daughter
-Cinnamon roll hero
-Reformed bad boy
June 16, 2026
The way I am obsessed with Hazel and Penn! I literally can not get enough of them.
Hazel is immediately one of my top favorite FMCs. She is goal-oriented, studious and focused. However, her focus does take a hit when a particular hockey player can't stop pushing her buttons and Hazel pushes his right back. I loved watching her grow into herself, and become more confident in what she wants and actually act on it.
Penn, oh Penn. I love this character so much. He may seem flirty and not serious, but he is hiding a big hurt and just wants to be accepted. I love that he found his group with the rest of the 3B roommates, Noah, Ally, and Fisher. Their moments together are simply the best. I also loved Penns initiative, he was a force when he wanted something or if someone he loved was hurt.
Hazel and Penn's relationship started out as a revenge fake dating. With Hazel’s ex being the A-Hole that he is, their payback was satisfying. But what started as a revenge plot, turned real, very quickly. Their chemistry and attraction was off the charts hot. Their dates, opening up to one another, and Penn and his team helping her with volunteering, was just perfect. I seriously loved all their moments together.
I completely recommend this book and honestly this whole series! With book three coming out this summer, you have more then enough time to read them. Thank me later 😉
🔥 Heat level: Heavy make-outs, fade-to-black in epilogue
🫢 Language: Frenquent mild language, no F-words
Hazel is immediately one of my top favorite FMCs. She is goal-oriented, studious and focused. However, her focus does take a hit when a particular hockey player can't stop pushing her buttons and Hazel pushes his right back. I loved watching her grow into herself, and become more confident in what she wants and actually act on it.
Penn, oh Penn. I love this character so much. He may seem flirty and not serious, but he is hiding a big hurt and just wants to be accepted. I love that he found his group with the rest of the 3B roommates, Noah, Ally, and Fisher. Their moments together are simply the best. I also loved Penns initiative, he was a force when he wanted something or if someone he loved was hurt.
Hazel and Penn's relationship started out as a revenge fake dating. With Hazel’s ex being the A-Hole that he is, their payback was satisfying. But what started as a revenge plot, turned real, very quickly. Their chemistry and attraction was off the charts hot. Their dates, opening up to one another, and Penn and his team helping her with volunteering, was just perfect. I seriously loved all their moments together.
I completely recommend this book and honestly this whole series! With book three coming out this summer, you have more then enough time to read them. Thank me later 😉
🔥 Heat level: Heavy make-outs, fade-to-black in epilogue
🫢 Language: Frenquent mild language, no F-words
June 4, 2026
3.5 stars
Plot- I liked the premise of their fake dating relationship. It was actually plausible, which I appreciated!
The way their relationship transitioned from suspicious strangers to friends to more was smooth and realistic.
Characters- I liked both main characters. I liked how they trusted each other at the end when it could easily have been a Big Misunderstanding.
I liked the found family elements.
I didn’t feel completely immersed. I wish I felt more connected to the characters.
Romance- Good chemistry. I had a big smile on my face often. They were very cute. I loved how devoted he was, and what a gentleman he was. He cared for her and treated her like she was all important.
Writing- This was the greatest weakness in the book, I think.
I feel like the book had untapped potential. Their family issues could have had way more depth than they had. But the writing was overly simplistic and exaggerated.
For example, in the real world the cheating boyfriend would have acted contrite and made flowery promises to the FMC even if he wasn’t truly committed to those promises. He would have spoken to her with more finesse. He would have attempted to make her doubt herself or attempted to receive forgiveness and a second chance. It would have felt more REAL that way. Instead, he basically said “You have no right to be mad about me sleeping with other women. It’s what’s expected with an athlete like me. Besides, there were no feelings involved. You’re lucky to be with me. Just get over it.” It was so OTT and absurd, it just felt a little silly. All his behavior after that convo was just too silly.
Same with her caricature of a mother. Just silly, when there could have been real angst.
Nuanced writing is much better! It’s no fun when villains are 110% horrible. It’s too easy to hate them. They aren’t real people anymore, when they are blatantly despicable. Give them some humanity, some mixed messaging, some redeemable qualities. Make them a little gray, as most humans are. It was just too black and white. I wanted more! I wanted true angst instead of easy decisions.
Content-
Language- not that I can remember
Spice- Some descriptive making out, plenty of references to sleeping with people/hookups, some innuendo. Fade to black in the epilogue. I wouldn’t share this with my 14-yr old but it was fine for an adult. I’d consider it steamy clean.
Triggers/Violence- unloving family
Substance abuse- no, but tons and tons of social drinking. There were lots and lots of references to alcohol of various kinds. I would say there was alcohol in most scenes.
Spiritual/religious- no
Cover- love it!
POV- dual perspective, first person
Cliffhanger- no
Will I Continue?- yes, I’ll read the next in series when it comes out
Format- audiobook via Audible
Narration- good!
Plot- I liked the premise of their fake dating relationship. It was actually plausible, which I appreciated!
The way their relationship transitioned from suspicious strangers to friends to more was smooth and realistic.
Characters- I liked both main characters. I liked how they trusted each other at the end when it could easily have been a Big Misunderstanding.
I liked the found family elements.
I didn’t feel completely immersed. I wish I felt more connected to the characters.
Romance- Good chemistry. I had a big smile on my face often. They were very cute. I loved how devoted he was, and what a gentleman he was. He cared for her and treated her like she was all important.
Writing- This was the greatest weakness in the book, I think.
I feel like the book had untapped potential. Their family issues could have had way more depth than they had. But the writing was overly simplistic and exaggerated.
For example, in the real world the cheating boyfriend would have acted contrite and made flowery promises to the FMC even if he wasn’t truly committed to those promises. He would have spoken to her with more finesse. He would have attempted to make her doubt herself or attempted to receive forgiveness and a second chance. It would have felt more REAL that way. Instead, he basically said “You have no right to be mad about me sleeping with other women. It’s what’s expected with an athlete like me. Besides, there were no feelings involved. You’re lucky to be with me. Just get over it.” It was so OTT and absurd, it just felt a little silly. All his behavior after that convo was just too silly.
Same with her caricature of a mother. Just silly, when there could have been real angst.
Nuanced writing is much better! It’s no fun when villains are 110% horrible. It’s too easy to hate them. They aren’t real people anymore, when they are blatantly despicable. Give them some humanity, some mixed messaging, some redeemable qualities. Make them a little gray, as most humans are. It was just too black and white. I wanted more! I wanted true angst instead of easy decisions.
Content-
Language- not that I can remember
Spice- Some descriptive making out, plenty of references to sleeping with people/hookups, some innuendo. Fade to black in the epilogue. I wouldn’t share this with my 14-yr old but it was fine for an adult. I’d consider it steamy clean.
Triggers/Violence- unloving family
Substance abuse- no, but tons and tons of social drinking. There were lots and lots of references to alcohol of various kinds. I would say there was alcohol in most scenes.
Spiritual/religious- no
Cover- love it!
POV- dual perspective, first person
Cliffhanger- no
Will I Continue?- yes, I’ll read the next in series when it comes out
Format- audiobook via Audible
Narration- good!
April 25, 2026
“Penn Matthews—as superfluous as he might seem—is an intimidating man. An intimidating and admittedly good-looking, man who I know my ex-boyfriend can’t stand. Suddenly, an idea pops into my head, and for the first time in days, I feel like I know exactly what I need to do.”
Rival Season is the super cute story of Penn and Hazel aka Playboy and Bubbles! While these two start out as rivals, the need to get rid of an ex-boyfriend quickly extinguishes the hate in order for some fake dating to happen! It doesn’t take long for the sparks to fly and the fake dating to become not-so-fake.
I freaking LOVED Penn and Hazel! Penn may have been a big, tough, tattooed hockey player, but his soft spot for Hazel and the way he loved, cared for, and protected her had my heart melting into a puddle! Hazel was cute and spunky and deserved someone amazing like Penn after daring Chadwick—who was the worst!
I loved Penn’s friends/roommates! It was fun to see Fisher, Ally ,and Noah again and see how quickly they drew Hazel in and made her feel loved. I loved the chemistry between Hazel and Penn and their fun flirting and banter. I loved how he stood up for her to her parents. And I loved how Hazel loved Penn for the man he had become and didn’t judge him for his past mistakes or his family. They were soooo cute together!
Favorite quotes:
Penn glances down at my lips. “Bubbles, if we were really together… there’s no way I wouldn’t kiss you every chance I got.”
“I don’t know how you walk around carrying an ego that large. Surely the weight of it is crippling.” I flex my arms so my biceps strain under the thin fabric of my long-sleeved shirt. “Muscles, Bubbles. They come in handy for carrying heavy things.”
“Hazel Palmer is turning out to be the gift that keeps on giving—a surprise under every layer I peel back. And as I watch her retreating form as she makes her way up the steps of the beautiful limestone building, I can’t help but think about how eager I am to unwrap the next layer.”
Rival Season is the super cute story of Penn and Hazel aka Playboy and Bubbles! While these two start out as rivals, the need to get rid of an ex-boyfriend quickly extinguishes the hate in order for some fake dating to happen! It doesn’t take long for the sparks to fly and the fake dating to become not-so-fake.
I freaking LOVED Penn and Hazel! Penn may have been a big, tough, tattooed hockey player, but his soft spot for Hazel and the way he loved, cared for, and protected her had my heart melting into a puddle! Hazel was cute and spunky and deserved someone amazing like Penn after daring Chadwick—who was the worst!
I loved Penn’s friends/roommates! It was fun to see Fisher, Ally ,and Noah again and see how quickly they drew Hazel in and made her feel loved. I loved the chemistry between Hazel and Penn and their fun flirting and banter. I loved how he stood up for her to her parents. And I loved how Hazel loved Penn for the man he had become and didn’t judge him for his past mistakes or his family. They were soooo cute together!
Favorite quotes:
Penn glances down at my lips. “Bubbles, if we were really together… there’s no way I wouldn’t kiss you every chance I got.”
“I don’t know how you walk around carrying an ego that large. Surely the weight of it is crippling.” I flex my arms so my biceps strain under the thin fabric of my long-sleeved shirt. “Muscles, Bubbles. They come in handy for carrying heavy things.”
“Hazel Palmer is turning out to be the gift that keeps on giving—a surprise under every layer I peel back. And as I watch her retreating form as she makes her way up the steps of the beautiful limestone building, I can’t help but think about how eager I am to unwrap the next layer.”
May 23, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Fade to Black
Rival Season is the 2nd book in the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B series and it was even better than the first, so I had to give it 5 stars. This delivered everything I want in a fake dating romance.
Penn and Hazel started off on the wrong foot as neighbors when Hazel went off on him for his loud music. She has also jumped to the wrong conclusions about Penn being a player. Hazel is staying in the apartment below Penn, which belongs to one of her boyfriend's family members. She breaks up with her boyfriend when she learns he cheated on her. Unfortunately, her ex moves into her place for 6 weeks after he got injured in a game against his rival, Penn, and she can't get rid of him. Penn hates her boyfriend, so he offers to fake date her to try and push her ex into leaving.
I loved how Penn proved Hazel wrong with her assumptions about him because he is such an amazing man. He is a few years younger than her, but he is very mature due to his difficult childhood with his horrible father. Hazel starts to fall for him the more he opens up to her, and she realizes she may want things to be real between them and isn't afraid to let him know.
I loved these two together and I truly felt their chemistry. It honestly didn't even need the spice. What I really appreciated was how this couple communicated through everything. There were a couple of times I was expecting the typical 3rd act breakup, but it never happened because the talked it out. It was so refreshing.
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW
🎤Dual narration by Tim Paige & Andi Arndt
Tim Paige and Andi Arndt did a great job narrating this sweet romance. Tim Paige brought Penn's easygoing and sunshine personality to life perfectly. Andi Arndt delivered fantastic banter and emotions.
Thank you to Must Love Audio for providing the ALC.
Fade to Black
Rival Season is the 2nd book in the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B series and it was even better than the first, so I had to give it 5 stars. This delivered everything I want in a fake dating romance.
Penn and Hazel started off on the wrong foot as neighbors when Hazel went off on him for his loud music. She has also jumped to the wrong conclusions about Penn being a player. Hazel is staying in the apartment below Penn, which belongs to one of her boyfriend's family members. She breaks up with her boyfriend when she learns he cheated on her. Unfortunately, her ex moves into her place for 6 weeks after he got injured in a game against his rival, Penn, and she can't get rid of him. Penn hates her boyfriend, so he offers to fake date her to try and push her ex into leaving.
I loved how Penn proved Hazel wrong with her assumptions about him because he is such an amazing man. He is a few years younger than her, but he is very mature due to his difficult childhood with his horrible father. Hazel starts to fall for him the more he opens up to her, and she realizes she may want things to be real between them and isn't afraid to let him know.
I loved these two together and I truly felt their chemistry. It honestly didn't even need the spice. What I really appreciated was how this couple communicated through everything. There were a couple of times I was expecting the typical 3rd act breakup, but it never happened because the talked it out. It was so refreshing.
AUDIOBOOK REVIEW
🎤Dual narration by Tim Paige & Andi Arndt
Tim Paige and Andi Arndt did a great job narrating this sweet romance. Tim Paige brought Penn's easygoing and sunshine personality to life perfectly. Andi Arndt delivered fantastic banter and emotions.
Thank you to Must Love Audio for providing the ALC.
May 4, 2026
Rival Season by Katie Bailey & Leah Brunner 🎧
Dual narration by Andi Arndt & Tim Paige
I was so ready to be back with the Loft 3B crew, and this one delivered exactly what I wanted. After loving Rookie Season, this felt like coming home to the roommates, the chaos, and the kind of story that just makes you smile the whole way through.
Hazel and Penn start off as neighbors with very different vibes. She’s structured, focused, and not exactly thrilled about his presence. He’s the one who nudges, teases, and absolutely refuses to let her stay in her perfectly curated bubble - and he nicknames her Bubbles. When her cheating ex enters the picture, Penn steps in and the fake dating setup takes off from there… and the banter is so good. Playful, constant, and full of that easy chemistry that makes their connection feel natural from the start.
🩵 neighbors to lovers
🏒 dislike to lovers (on her side)
🩵 revenge fake dating
🏒 cinnamon roll / golden retriever MMC
🩵 “New Girl” coded loft dynamic
🏒 closed door romance
This is closed door, and it never feels like anything is missing. The emotional connection, the buildup, the small moments between them… it all carries the story in such a satisfying way. Penn is the kind of MMC who shows up without hesitation, steady, supportive, and quietly all in. The way he brings Hazel out of her shell and lets her just be herself is everything.
🎧 Andi Arndt captures Hazel’s personality so well. You can feel how controlled and put-together she is at the start, and then hear that shift as she softens and opens up.
🎧 Tim Paige absolutely nails Penn. Warm, playful, and full of heart. He leans into that golden retriever energy in the best way, bringing humor and sincerity into every scene.
This one is just a genuinely fun, feel good listen. Great characters, great dynamic, and a story that leaves you smiling by the end.
Thank you to Katie Bailey, Leah Brunner, Must Love Audio, NetGalley, and 11th Ave Publishing for the ALC and ARC
Dual narration by Andi Arndt & Tim Paige
I was so ready to be back with the Loft 3B crew, and this one delivered exactly what I wanted. After loving Rookie Season, this felt like coming home to the roommates, the chaos, and the kind of story that just makes you smile the whole way through.
Hazel and Penn start off as neighbors with very different vibes. She’s structured, focused, and not exactly thrilled about his presence. He’s the one who nudges, teases, and absolutely refuses to let her stay in her perfectly curated bubble - and he nicknames her Bubbles. When her cheating ex enters the picture, Penn steps in and the fake dating setup takes off from there… and the banter is so good. Playful, constant, and full of that easy chemistry that makes their connection feel natural from the start.
🩵 neighbors to lovers
🏒 dislike to lovers (on her side)
🩵 revenge fake dating
🏒 cinnamon roll / golden retriever MMC
🩵 “New Girl” coded loft dynamic
🏒 closed door romance
This is closed door, and it never feels like anything is missing. The emotional connection, the buildup, the small moments between them… it all carries the story in such a satisfying way. Penn is the kind of MMC who shows up without hesitation, steady, supportive, and quietly all in. The way he brings Hazel out of her shell and lets her just be herself is everything.
🎧 Andi Arndt captures Hazel’s personality so well. You can feel how controlled and put-together she is at the start, and then hear that shift as she softens and opens up.
🎧 Tim Paige absolutely nails Penn. Warm, playful, and full of heart. He leans into that golden retriever energy in the best way, bringing humor and sincerity into every scene.
This one is just a genuinely fun, feel good listen. Great characters, great dynamic, and a story that leaves you smiling by the end.
Thank you to Katie Bailey, Leah Brunner, Must Love Audio, NetGalley, and 11th Ave Publishing for the ALC and ARC
May 22, 2026
Tropes:
fake dating
neighbors to lovers
reformed playboy
Dual POV
Katie and Leah did it again- giving me those New Girl vibes with book 2 of the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B! This time around we get Penn as our MMC. He kinda gave me Schmidt vibes in the beginning- being cocky and all - but then quickly realized he was more of a Schmidt from the last two seasons who's sweet and incredibly in love with CeCe.... except for Penn it's Hazel :D Speaking of Hazel, she gave me Jess vibes... okay weird right, Jess and Schmidt? But stay with me here and read it!
I love a good fake dating trope and Rival Season definitely hit the nail on the head. I love how Hazel was annoyed with Penn in the beginning but due to a series of events, they quickly team up together. Their chemistry was adorable and I enjoyed how fast that Penn falls for Hazel. Also, what I liked a lot about Rival Season was the trust between Hazel and Penn. There's a situation at the end that would normally be super dramatic between our couple but I LOVE how Katie and Leah flipped that "typical" storyline and turned it into one of trust instead. That was beautiful and we need more of that! Also, that epilogue has me SO excited for Fisher's story! I can't wait.
fake dating
neighbors to lovers
reformed playboy
Dual POV
Katie and Leah did it again- giving me those New Girl vibes with book 2 of the Hockey Boys of Loft 3B! This time around we get Penn as our MMC. He kinda gave me Schmidt vibes in the beginning- being cocky and all - but then quickly realized he was more of a Schmidt from the last two seasons who's sweet and incredibly in love with CeCe.... except for Penn it's Hazel :D Speaking of Hazel, she gave me Jess vibes... okay weird right, Jess and Schmidt? But stay with me here and read it!
I love a good fake dating trope and Rival Season definitely hit the nail on the head. I love how Hazel was annoyed with Penn in the beginning but due to a series of events, they quickly team up together. Their chemistry was adorable and I enjoyed how fast that Penn falls for Hazel. Also, what I liked a lot about Rival Season was the trust between Hazel and Penn. There's a situation at the end that would normally be super dramatic between our couple but I LOVE how Katie and Leah flipped that "typical" storyline and turned it into one of trust instead. That was beautiful and we need more of that! Also, that epilogue has me SO excited for Fisher's story! I can't wait.
May 22, 2026
“Bubbles, if we were really together…there’s no way I wouldn’t kiss you every chance I got.”
The Hockey Boys of Loft 3B have my whole, entire heart! When initial enemies, Noah and Hazel (aka Bubbles), come up with a fake dating plan that is utterly swoon-worthy, a whole bundle of electrical chemistry is released, and I couldn’t get enough of the tension, banter, and romance.
Hazel’s sass is the perfect complement to Noah’s dry wit and protective energy. These two have a dynamic that leaps off the pages and at the same time, fully drew me inside the book. I loved the teammates and cameos, but I especially enjoyed getting to know these two characters more thoroughly.
The playfulness is heated and the lines between fake and real are very blurry, but that only adds to the delicious suspense of their attraction. My desire to devour this book was unquenchable and now I’m beyond eager for Book 3.
These characters have my heart and soul!
⚠️moderate language and innuendo; closed door/fade-to-black
*I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.*
The Hockey Boys of Loft 3B have my whole, entire heart! When initial enemies, Noah and Hazel (aka Bubbles), come up with a fake dating plan that is utterly swoon-worthy, a whole bundle of electrical chemistry is released, and I couldn’t get enough of the tension, banter, and romance.
Hazel’s sass is the perfect complement to Noah’s dry wit and protective energy. These two have a dynamic that leaps off the pages and at the same time, fully drew me inside the book. I loved the teammates and cameos, but I especially enjoyed getting to know these two characters more thoroughly.
The playfulness is heated and the lines between fake and real are very blurry, but that only adds to the delicious suspense of their attraction. My desire to devour this book was unquenchable and now I’m beyond eager for Book 3.
These characters have my heart and soul!
⚠️moderate language and innuendo; closed door/fade-to-black
*I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.*
June 1, 2026
If Katie Bailey or Leah Brunner writes it, I'm absolutely reading it. So when these amazing ladies team up, it's a no brainer for me. This newest installment of the Bailey/Brunner collab is just as golden as the first. To be honest, as much as I love Ally and Noah, I think I love Penn and Hazel even more. The chemistry, humor, banter, and swoon is top tier and I just love this world Katie and Leah have created. I'm so sad there's only one more book and I'm already hoping Katie and Leah write another series together sometime in the future.
If you love closed door romance that still has steamy moments, this is 100% your series. Get a copy of Rival Season asap!
❤️Hockey
❤️Fake dating
❤️Nicknames - "Bubbles" and "Playboy"
❤️Tattoos
❤️More Ally, Noah, and Fisher
❤️Cassie
❤️Bertie
❤️Found family
❤️Fluffy
❤️One bed
❤️Trivia night
❤️Foster rep
❤️Friendship between Ally and Hazel
❤️Penn's birthday party
❤️That kiss during the party 🥵
❤️Thrifting
❤️Hazel's jacket
❤️The mosaic steps and picnic
❤️Epilogue
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
🚪
If you love closed door romance that still has steamy moments, this is 100% your series. Get a copy of Rival Season asap!
❤️Hockey
❤️Fake dating
❤️Nicknames - "Bubbles" and "Playboy"
❤️Tattoos
❤️More Ally, Noah, and Fisher
❤️Cassie
❤️Bertie
❤️Found family
❤️Fluffy
❤️One bed
❤️Trivia night
❤️Foster rep
❤️Friendship between Ally and Hazel
❤️Penn's birthday party
❤️That kiss during the party 🥵
❤️Thrifting
❤️Hazel's jacket
❤️The mosaic steps and picnic
❤️Epilogue
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
🚪
June 4, 2026
3⭐ entertaining but messy
This was a fast, bingeable sports romance with plenty of tension, banter, and chaotic neighbor energy.
The “rivals next door” setup works really well, and the living situation adds a nice layer of forced proximity that keeps the story moving.
The plot sometimes feels a bit overcrowded. There’s a lot going on (family drama, relationship complications, team dynamics, and personal struggle) which makes certain emotional beats feel rushed instead of fully developed. Some conflicts also resolve a bit too conveniently for my taste.
I HATEEDDD Chadwick and Hazel’s parents. Chadwick especially was insufferable every time he showed up (entitled, self-absorbed, and completely lacking accountability) which made every scene with him instantly frustrating. Hazel’s parents weren’t much better either. Their attitude toward her felt dismissive and unfair.
Overall, it’s a solid guilty-pleasure read with great banter and chemistry, but not quite as tight or emotionally impactful as it could have been.
This was a fast, bingeable sports romance with plenty of tension, banter, and chaotic neighbor energy.
The “rivals next door” setup works really well, and the living situation adds a nice layer of forced proximity that keeps the story moving.
The plot sometimes feels a bit overcrowded. There’s a lot going on (family drama, relationship complications, team dynamics, and personal struggle) which makes certain emotional beats feel rushed instead of fully developed. Some conflicts also resolve a bit too conveniently for my taste.
I HATEEDDD Chadwick and Hazel’s parents. Chadwick especially was insufferable every time he showed up (entitled, self-absorbed, and completely lacking accountability) which made every scene with him instantly frustrating. Hazel’s parents weren’t much better either. Their attitude toward her felt dismissive and unfair.
Overall, it’s a solid guilty-pleasure read with great banter and chemistry, but not quite as tight or emotionally impactful as it could have been.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 491 reviews