(Audiobook) Had read this book before, and the impact now, like then, was overwhelming. While we are coming up on the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz by Soviet forces, there is something to be said for reading/re-reading books about the Holocaust, especially with the rise of antisemitism and other hate crimes. Below is what I felt when I read/listened to this book the 1st time. It still hold true today:
"As of late, when I read a book or listen to an audiobook, I will try to do a brief review of the material on Goodreads, a website dedicated to book readers who can offer their reviews of various books/audiobooks/etc…without the pretense associated with the major newspapers/periodicals. Most tend to be okay to good, with a few that are incredible reads. Yet, every now and then, you come across a book that when you read it or listen to it, it somehow stops you in your tracks, forcing you to consider the implications of those words, and what it means not only for you, but for the world around you.
In the past few days, I managed to come across such a book: The Last Jew of Treblinka. This work is the memoir of a man, Chil Rajchman, and the experiences of his life, at least what he had lived through in his first 31 years when he originally wrote this in 1945. As he recounts his life to that point, the primary focus centers on the period from October 1942 to August 1943, where, as a young Polish Jew, he found himself at the epicenter of one the most horrific places to ever scar the face of the Earth: Treblinka. As a young man with no particular background in writing, Rajchman describes his experiences in a concise, direct prose. It is a rather short work, with most editions topping out at 130-150 pages. Originally, Rajchman wrote his memoir in Yiddish in 1945, which kept its distribution relatively limited. However, in 2009, this work found itself translated into French and German, offering a wider audience. In 2011, it finally appeared in English, with a forward penned by famed Holocaust survivor and author Elie Wiesel. Unfortunately, Rajchman never saw the expanded distribution of his work, having passed away in 2004.
However, while the work remained in obscurity for nearly 65 years, it has made up for lost time. The simple, yet brutal description of life at this relatively unknown camp has made its mark on Holocaust literature. It is comparable to Wiesel’s legendary Night in content and message. Yet, what gives The Last Jew of Treblinka such a place of significance is that it is one of the few eyewitness accounts of what happened at Treblinka.
The Holocaust claimed an estimated 11 million people, with the majority of the deaths distributed over 40,000 concentration camps and ghettos throughout the Third Reich. The make-up and nature of the concentration camps varied based on location and intent. Many of the camps in the western part of the Nazi regime were designed more for slave labor, where the victims were housed to perform some form of work for the Nazi war efforts/economy. In the far eastern reaches of the Nazi regime, many of the camps were but fields with barbed wire and armed guards. Yet, in Poland, there were six camps whose primary raison d’etre was not slave labor or economic gain or mere internment. These camps have become synonymous with the worst of the Holocaust: Chelmno, Belzec, Sobibor, Majdanek, Auschwitz-Birkenau and Treblinka. At these six sites, the Nazis specifically designed the camps with the primary goal for efficient and effective execution and disposal of those humans deemed unworthy to live in the Third Reich (note: Auschwitz-Birkenau and Majdanek did develop extensive slave labor operations, but are lumped into the death camps based on the infrastructure for mass extermination).
While the largest and most well-known was Auschwitz-Birkenau, perhaps the most effective at the mission of mass extermination was Treblinka. Exact figures of total executions at these six camps are not totally known, but even amid these morbid stats (3.5 million of the 11 million killed in the Holocaust), Treblinka stands out. Auschwitz-Birkenau had approx 1.3 million come through its gates, with 1.1 million killed. The other four extermination camps saw death totals estimated within the range of 250,000-600,000 each. As for Treblinka, the death totals range between 750,000 and 920,000, with most of those killed (~99%) within an hour of arrival. After the war, under 80 people are thought to have survived (67 individuals are officially recorded having survived, but there are still individuals being identified as having lived through the hell at that site). The vast majority of those killed at the camp died within a 10 month period (Oct 1942-Aug 1943), at a rate that varied between 15,000-25,000 a day.
It is during this period that Rajchman arrived at Treblinka. Having already lived through hellish conditions at several ghettos throughout Poland, to include the Warsaw ghetto, he had no idea what we was about to face. The book describes the long, cold train ride from Warsaw to Treblinka, and upon arrival, he is caught in a whirlwind of activity, managing to be one of the few individuals selected to work as a Sonderkommando, forced to aid the Nazis in their efforts to maximize the economic efficiency of their extermination. He starts out rounding up the clothes of those who were sent off to the “showers” (euphemism for gas chambers), not knowing for a few days the fates of his fellow passengers, to include his sister. The beatings and cruel treatment start at once, and throughout his time at Treblinka, Rajchman is fortunate to avoid the fate that befell so many at the camp. From cleaning up a face wound to the efforts of a fellow Sonderkommando who was a doctor to prevent blood poisoning, he manages to evade death, usually by the narrowest of margins. Eventually, he finds his sister’s clothing, confirming her death. Shortly afterwards, he volunteers to become a “barber” and despite zero experience or training, he is immediately pressed into that task.
It is as a “barber” that the full impact of the horrors of Treblinka starts to dawn on the young man. His job consists cutting off the hair of all the women who are on their way to the showers as quickly and thoroughly as possible. The general procedure at Treblinka was for the Nazis, after separating the men and women at the train station and having them remove their clothing in designated buildings, to send the men, via a sand-strewn path (“The Path to Heaven” ), to the showers/gas chambers first. The women were held back so that their hair could be cut and collected for future use. As Rajchman cuts their hair, he finds himself hearing the final words of the women, from answering questions about what will happen and will it be quick to hearing the last pronouncements of women, telling him to survive to that he may tell of what was happening, to beat the Nazis and their evil they perpetrated.
From there, Rajchman moves on to other aspects of aiding the processing and disposal of the victims. He becomes a “dentist,” tasked with removing the teeth of the recently dead (gold, silver, false), as well as working body disposal, removing the bodies from the gas chambers after the carbon monoxide completed its task. All the while, Rajchman continues to observe the cruelty and torture that the Nazis inflict on the victims, from forcing nude women and children to stand outside in sub-freezing temperature, before being forced into the gas chambers to observing the guards slap the faces of the Sonderkommando, which resulted in scarring, which in turn, lead to the immediate execution of said victims (facial wounds were not allowed for Sonderkommando).
As his time at the camp continues, he faces increased torment. At first, the Nazis, after gassing their victims, just buried the bodies in a series of pits for mass graves. Additionally, new arrivals who could not walk to the changing rooms/gas chambers, as well as the Sonderkommando who the Nazis deemed no longer able to work, were shot and dumped into those pits. However, in spring 1943, the Nazis, after the discovery of the Katyn massacre site and seeing that their fortunes in the war were shifting after the loss at Stalingrad, decided that it was time to eliminate the evidence of the camps. Thus, the Sonderkommando now had to burn the bodies, dealing with both the recently executed as well as having to exhume the long dead bodies, all for cremation. At the same time, the Nazis forced the Sonderkommando to keep all the facilities clean, keeping up the deception to the victims as well as allowing the Nazis to continue executing massive numbers of inbound victims.
With 1943 progressing, and the Nazis starting to shift more of their efforts to Auschwitz, Rajchman and his fellow prisoners could sense that after they completed the cremation of the previous prisoners, and fewer transports arriving, they would be next to go. Thus, the prisoners, at great risk, coordinated an escape. They had to change their first attempt, but on August 2, 1943, they managed to lead a massive breakout. Rajchman and his fellow inmates flee the camp, and while most did not make it out alive, Rajchman, through good fortune, manages to escape and make his way to the Polish Resistance, where he would spend the rest of the war fighting against the Nazis.
All of this is condensed in a relatively short volume. The language of the writing is not excessively descriptive, but almost matter-of-fact, as Rajchman recounted his experiences. However, in the midst of his language, he provides enough details to offer the read a description of the camp, one that is especially helpful, given that the Nazis effectively destroyed the camp before the Soviet Army liberated it in early 1944. The pain he suffers physically, emotionally and psychologically…all come across in this writing. The work was edited in 1946, but as mentioned earlier, it was not seen by non-Yiddish readers until 2009.
Admittedly, this work is not the end-all/be-all about Treblinka, as he can only speak to what he experienced and knew. However, given the dearth of material about Treblinka, and the lack of first-hand accounts from the prisoners and the camp guards, this work serves as one of the few primary sources. However, the quality and its message go well beyond the pages. As a book, especially about a critical and not well-known aspect of one of the worst events in human history, this qualifies as a must read. Many books, movies, documentaries and other forms of media offer various stories and insights into places such as Auschwitz, and the fact that much of that camp still remained intact upon its liberation in January 1945. Yet, Auschwitz does not have the monopoly on the horrors of the Holocaust, and Treblinka should not be regulated to merely a historical footnote, but needs to be known, understood and serve as the warning of the worst of mankind.
Unfortunately, the lessons that we as the human race should take from Treblinka do not seem to be resonated with us today. Worldwide, there is an increase in the instances of hate speech of all types. For those of the Jewish faith, there is an alarming rise in Anti-Semitism, a form of hate that crosses both ends of the political spectrum. This hatred is not limited to one country or continent, as it is prevalent in America, Europe and the Middle East, locations with significant Jewish populations.
Additionally, there is an even more alarming trend that many people do not know much, if anything about the Holocaust, in spite of the increased efforts of education and greater access to previously undiscovered archives. This past year, surveys in America indicate that nearly 45% of the population could not identify Auschwitz, and just about the same percentage couldn’t even identify one concentration camp or ghetto location. A recent survey from Europe this very week indicates that as many as 33% of the European population knows little to nothing about the Holocaust, which took place on their continents, and with a number of people still alive who still live in Europe who have direct knowledge and experience with the event.
The European surveys are especially disturbing, given recent trends in Central Europe. Anti-Semitism is a major part of the platform for the current Hungarian government, and the rise of the Far Right within other countries, especially in Austria, France and Germany, does not bode well for fighting hate crimes. Additionally, Poland has enacted a series of laws which limit what history can be discussed about the Holocaust, especially if it does anything to paint Poland or the Polish people in a negative light. While many Poles died at the six extermination camps, there were Poles that willingly worked with the Nazis to help implement the Final Solution. Ignorance of history propagates abuse of history, thus the rise of Holocaust deniers, and the ever present specter of a repeat of the horror of places like Treblinka. That is why works like The Last Jew of Treblinka are so important to read and study, so that we can learn the right lessons and work to make sure that those lessons stick, so that future generations do not have to relearn what we learned in the worst possible way."
(1/24/2021) This may become an annual ritual to re-read/listen to this work. This matched up closely with the anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, but Treblinka was perhaps even more effective in its mission of destructive hate. It is not fun to read, but so critical to understand that when you say you “hate” something, you have to have caution, as the manifestation of hate can lead to such horrors as this. The gut punch this book gives the reader never lessens, no matter how many times it is read. As it should be.
(1/20/2023) Another re-listen/re-read. Still as powerful and disturbing. Unfortunately, with the rise of antisemitism across the country and world, works like this are all-too-useful to understand just how far words and simple acts of expression fueled by hate can lead. Should take its place among “Night” for Holocaust literature. It pulls no punches, but where the Holocaust is concerned, you can’t study it/learn about it without the brutal details.