From the bestselling author of Hillbilly Elegy—an intimate account of why Vice President JD Vance strayed from the Christianity of his youth and what led him back to faith.
Communion is a spiritual exploration of what it means to be a Christian in all the seasons of life JD Vance has experienced—as a child, a young man, a husband, a father, and a leader.
Picking up in some ways where Hillbilly Elegy left off, Communion recounts how Vance's pursuit of material privileges ultimately led him into a secular wilderness.
Communion reveals how Vance regained his faith and discusses his conversion to Catholicism, how his faith guides his work in public life, and how it shapes his thoughts about the future.
James David Vance (born James Donald Bowman) is an American politician, lawyer, veteran, and a New York Times bestselling author, who served as the junior United States senator from Ohio from 2023 to 2025. A member of the Republican Party, he currently serves as the Vice-President of the United States of America.
After graduating from high school in his hometown of Middletown, Ohio, Vance served from 2003 to 2007 as a combat correspondent, with six months in Iraq. He then attended Ohio State University, graduating in 2009. He graduated from Yale Law School in 2013. His 2016 bestselling memoir Hillbilly Elegy got significant press attention during the 2016 election and became a feature film in 2020. It describes his upbringing in the Rust Belt, poverty, drug addiction, and Appalachian culture.
Vance defeated Democratic nominee Tim Ryan in the 2022 United States Senate election in Ohio. Initially opposed to Donald Trump's candidacy in the 2016 election, Vance has since become a strong Trump supporter. On July 15, 2024, Trump nominated Vance as his running mate at the Republican National Convention. He was the first US Marine veteran to be nominated for vice president.
As a Catholic this book upset me. Vance writes like a lapsed catholic, while claiming to believe as a convert, and the book reads as if he is looking to Catholic theology to justify the deeply anti-Catholic actions of the administration he is a part of. He is borrowing the trappings of his new faith to give his own choices spiritual credibility. His apparent goal of self-justification in the eyes of God naturally leads him to feel righteous about criticizing the Pope, and to mocking, in this book, the deeply held beliefs of those Catholics who actually practice their faith, and who try to live by their faith. Marian devotions are beyond the pale for him and yet praying to Mary is so central to Catholicism, and such a source of solace and faith for Catholics, that Vance's meant-to-be-lighthearted ridicule lands very strangely. He also mocks transubstantiation, which is the central mystery of Catholicism, and the sacramental rite that is at the core of the Mass. Of course it’s impossible to believe in. That’s where faith lives, in the impossibility of believing in what God asks us to believe in. The converts I know are far more devoted to the mysteries of my faith than those born into Catholicism. Vance’s faith journey lands in the opposite direction, where he’s writing like a jaded Catholic. His argument feels strange, and false, and as if it might be as temporary a conversion as his anti-Trump stance in his prior book.
At its core, this cowardly book is an apologia for Christian nationalism, and a deeply dishonest one at that. I found something morbidly fascinating in the sum of influences laid bare in its pages (CS Lewis, Pope Leo XIII, René Girard, Peter Thiel). Despite all: boring and conventional.
I made it fifty pages into this when I realized that even if the Pope himself was reading the bible to him while Jesus Christ washed his feet JD Vance still wouldn’t understand what is going on at church. This book was a PR stunt.
Excellent and well-written book. I'd encourage anyone to read this, regardless of your political stripe. I once had a librarian look at me disdainfully when I checked out Hillbilly Elegy - she said she wouldn't even touch it. I thought that a shame, because she's missing out on a very good book and perspective.
I'm so impressed with his willingness to expose so much of his personal feelings at this time of his life. In a world of hate, he is opening himself up to so much possible hate talk directed at himself. But on the other hand he is sowing love. This is an excellent read no matter your beliefs of God and religion.
When J.D. Vance’s formidable grandmother died, his connection to Christianity went with it. Although he’d been raised going to church with her on occasion, the faith had never become internalized; as he deployed to Iraq, he was moving further and further away from the memory of it. Communion is the story of how a young man came to believe again, and a reflection on how Christianity’s eternal truths have inspired him as a father, husband, and public servant.
Although I’ve been sold on this book as a memoir of his coming to the Catholic church – an improbable decision given his origins in Protestant hill country – that is not strictly the case. The first half follows his faith’s decline and fall, but I noticed ambiguity. Even in the desert, he was reading Chronicles of Narnia and wishing Jesus was more like Aslan – and when he’s in college and identifying as an atheist, he still notices contempt for Christians as if he’s still connected to the faith. While pursuing the cursus Mammonae – law school, clerking for a judge, lucrative practice – Vance began having a crisis of meaning. What was all this for? His coworkers were seemingly married to their jobs, with no time left for their children or the simple enjoyment of life. He realized, with a Girard-esque start, that he was simply modeling the desires and ambitions of those around him, just as if he were in high school again. Around this time, he fell in love with a woman, Usha, who seemed destined for a great career in the law – but she had little interest in getting and spending and laying waste to all her powers. She wanted an interesting job, but she wanted a meaningful life – children to love, a husband to experience adventures with – not to be a girlboss. Her perspective, and his realization that he needed to be a worthier partner, put Vance on a quest for meaning. The more he read, the more interesting he found the wisdom of the Church – particularly its social doctrine, which places the human person and not GDP at the center of social, economic, and political thinking. After a quiet evening reflecting in a cathedral while his son slept, he made the choice to swim the Tiber.
Communion is an intimate work; conversion stories cannot help be. Part of the story is his learning to accept grace, to realize that as haunted as he may be by his past of violent, dysfunctional relatives, it needn’t – won’t – define him. It dovetails neatly with Christianity’s message of grace and redemption, of escaping sin’s power. The second half of the book is more of a reflection on Christianity’s place in the West, both historically and now, and he muses on ways that the Christian appreciation of the person can inform politics. This is not your granddaddy’s ‘moral majority’: while no doubt agreeing that much of what is tolerated in society is destructive, like pornography, Vance focuses his thinking on other issues, particularly labor and the family. Given how central becoming a husband and father was to Vance changing his life, making him assess the why of things, he unsurprisingly agrees with the social doctrine (and others, like Wendell Berry) that the economy exists for human needs, not the other way around. Corporations should not be allowed to keep wages miserly by relying on illegal migrant labor, nor should apps that allow for the complete commodification of labor – calling in workers only when The Algorithm suggests they’ll deliver the most bang for the buck – be tolerated. Human beings are persons made imago Dei, not cogs to be manipulated or resources to be managed. We know what happens when those resources are wasted or those cogs are worn down in materialist societies: they are disposed of.
I devoured this book, staying up until the early hours of the next day and then gnawing on it all day the next. Those of you who are familiar with what I tend to read and write about are probably not surprised – trying to figure out what the flourishing life is, and how to guide people towards it, has been my passion for twenty years now. I think it’s rare, though, for someone who have this itch, this bug, this desire to break out of going with the flow, and asking – what’s it all for? I think it’s especially rare for politicians, because as honorable as some of their intentions might be, it’s a field of human endeavour that attracts those who crave power, authority, influence, etc. Seneca aside, I don’t think the pursuit of gold and the pursuit of wisdom overlap overmuch. But Vance proves in this book to be an author deeply versed in Augustinian thought, and that’s not just this layman’s notion: Bishop Robert Barron, who presumably knows a thing about patristics, said as much in his own review. One thing Vance criticizes throughout the text is that economics increasingly displaces morality as our default language to evaluate matters of concern to the republic – and his rejection of that in his earnest defense of humanity against the machine, is a throughline. Unfortunately, I think this book will be judged by many simply because of Vance’s role in the Trump administration, which is doubly sad because Vance and progressives who are oriented toward family needs could have a conversation. The political parties are changing, in both good and unhinged ways, and those who genuinely care more about the body politic rather than an ideology, need to find one another instead of trolling for twitter cred. Vance, like Sasse before him, and Ralph Nader too, is raising questions that can and should be considered by everyone.
As a single crazy cat lady...I loved this book. So good to read about a man finding Christ, yearning to learn, and really listen to his heart and after being an atheist, to be more a knowledgeable Catholic. This book weaves present day geo-political goings on, with the religious/non religious aspects which can affect life. JD is so curious and such an open person, nice to see. All Glory to God.
Please don’t listen to the 1 star reviews. They didn’t even read the book. I found his story honest and humble… a little rough around the edges, but that’s ok- part of the whole package of J.D. Vance I suppose. It gave me a better understanding of the V. P.
I know, I know... it's a book written by a politician. And we all know politicians are liars and sellouts. But I liked Hillbilly Elegy (notably written before Vance got into politics) and I think Vance is a fascinating person who also embodies this wider phenomenon of "recovering nihilists" discovering Catholicism, so I wanted to check this out.
============
The Good:
- Vance's description of how people lose their faith (social inertia, striver culture, poor theology) is insightful and relevant to many fallen away Christians especially those from the Bible Belt (like me). I do think *some* of his reasoning about "why Catholicism" is helpful for agnostics or nominal Christians just starting to look into the Church. Particularly his extended quote of the parable of The Stranger--of course this is not his own thought, but it's edifying and shows (I think) Vance genuinely has wrestled with hard questions and does believe (even if only in some Pascaline sense). The quotes from Augustine are good but pretty limited in scope--more about dealing with Creationism than anything super psychologically deep.
- The passages about his wife clearly show he loves that woman; this is pretty much the only thing we can know for sure about Vance's true convictions. Passages about Usha are some of the only ones where the writing actually comes alive and you get a sense that Vance the Man is speaking (and not Vance the Politician)
- Some (not all) of his defenses for the administration's policies are well-explained. I also think he makes good points about prioritizing human life over GDP and economic growth--but this is ironic considering his administration has impugned the dignity of (illegal) immigrants in its messaging (even if detentions and deportation are just by law). He offers no defense for this obvious disconnect and actually barely mentions Trump at all (and maybe this is a good thing--Trump, like a black hole, has a tendency to swallow entire constellations of thought whole)
============
The Bad:
- Only 1/2 of the book is really about Vance's conversion, and 95% of that was already published in an article he wrote for The Lamp back in 2020. Nothing that new despite marketing the book as his "conversion story".
- Much of the book deals with apologetics for policy which don't concern the primary audience of this book (conservatives who already support him) and will never convince anyone else... so why is it here? There are some ways he tries to tie Catholic social teachings to policy but they're too superficial to impact the intended audience (devout Catholics) imo
- The book is disorganized and unfocused in its presentation, and Vance's style, like his IRL speaking, is clear, concise, and icy cold (not very endearing). One does not come away from this book an impression of warmth, or even sincerity (shocker lol)
============
The Ugly:
- During the description of Vance's final conversion to the Catholic Church, he brings up the topic of clergy abuse. A relevant and reasonable obstacle for conversion, but his handling of the issue seems designed more to subtly attack the bishops than offer insight into his own conversion. Why do I say this? On page 165-166, he quotes a statement from the 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report which explicitly mentions the anal rape of children by clergy. Why is this here? Vance describes him and Usha being super fired up to protect their kids after this report released, questioning his desire to convert, and then suddenly... it's resolved after one conversation with his Dominican priest friend? Forgive me for wanting more information on his change of heart. Unlike almost all the other material on his conversion, these concerns about abuse were NOT in his 2020 Lamp article. So it was added *for this book*. Given this addition--and his sparse accounting of overcoming such an enormous hurdle to conversion--followed only two chapters later by a 5 page defense of Trump's immigration policy against the USCCB (not even a bad defense, but you see the imbalance) it's natural to question why this abuse quote was included. I personally suspect there are many, many wicked bishops in Hell, but all this struck me as a ploy for Vance to remind the public that the bishops (deservedly) have little credibility--*but only insofar as to neuter the attacks on his own policies*, not to actually grapple with how to personally develop trust in God who allows abuse (something that would have been far more edifying but is barely touched upon)
- The little blurb at the end about Charlie Kirk definitely being pro-Israel was bizarre and completely out of left field. It read like a subtweet. I'm no Candace Owens cultist, but if Vance was trying to dissuade suspicion about Kirk's death... the lady doth protest too much methinks
- Finally... my biggest gripe with this book is the same gripe I had after reading Vance's 2020 article for The Lamp, except I was willing to give 2020 Vance (not even a year into his conversion) the benefit of the doubt, because all conversions have mixed motives... but 6 years later and this guy is still singing the same tune, except now he's the (second) most powerful Catholic in the world. So I'll be direct, the gripe is this: it seems Vance has not really encountered Jesus in any personal sense. Vance appears to understand Catholicism as merely a venerable institution or system for "virtue" and "civilization". All throughout this book, Vance talks about how "Catholicism" helps him be a more virtuous father, cured him of striver culture (dubious, but okay lol), protects the rights of workers, etc. He talks about Rene Girard and memetic desire and how we project our faults onto innocent victims, but Christianity reverses this, etc. And this is all good and true.
But to quote Flannery O'Connor (talking about the Eucharist): "If it's just a symbol, then to Hell with it!" Like CS Lewis and Nietzsche before him said, if Christianity is not true, then not only is it NOT "useful" or "virtuous", it's farcical, complete bullshit, even wicked! What other "institution" asks one to love not only their neighbor, but their *enemy*? To "not love the world and the things of the world"? To identify with weakness and sin and dependency, and not strength or glory or success? Take Girard's scapegoat theory. Why is it "good" that we care about the misfit at all? Why *not* scapegoat them, crush them? Why not pursue power and prosperity and pleasure? This is Dionysus vs the Crucified, and it's really at the heart of why Christianity is either true or totally evil. Unfortunately Vance floats far above the roiling surface of this debate.
Contra Vance, the Church is not a system whose function is building civilizations or making us really virtuous successful people. In fact, the more virtuous and successful at "being Christian" we think we are, the worse we are doing at it! Someone might ask, if the Church isn't a system or venerable institution, then what is it? It is this: the Church is the body of Christ, and she was established by Christ (not by poets or philosophers or earthly kings) and her function is to *help people encounter God by the proclamation of the Gospel*, that is, repentance and mercy, Christ crucified and resurrected... everything else--her visibility, her authority, her sacraments, her many incredible teachings, serves this one purpose--to assist the grace of God (and it is grace, not the Church) in transforming our hearts. If this shaft of light has graced a corner of Vance's heart, this book does not tell.
=============
Overall I wouldn't recommend this book to anyone except Catholics who follow politics and are trying to understand just what kind of Catholic JD Vance is. But this book only really tells you what kind of Catholic he *probably is not*: a deeply converted one. But someday he may be. And so may I. Pray for him. Pray for me.
I admire him as a person especially after reading his Hillbilly Elegy. His perspective finding God again and what he believes was vulnerable and eye opening for me. He made some points that were really interesting. “I acknowledged that yes, everyone would believe if they saw a real life miracle. But the Christian argument is a bit more complicated: No matter what we see we are all templated by doubt. The Peter whom had pulled out of the sea is the same Peter we denied Christ three times shortly before His Crucifixion.”
I have really come to appreciate and admire JD over his time as Vice President, and I am so impressed and awed at his vulnerability in writing this book. I don't know how many modern-day politicians would have enough guts to write and publish a book about their personal journey and relationship with Christianity. I am a devout Christian, though not Catholic as JD is, and I resonated with much of this book. I appreciated the background he provided, and how many of his reasons for becoming an athiest later became the push he needed to embrace Christianity. His ideas are very thought-provoking and will resonate with any Christian, regardless of your denomination.
A powerful story of finding meaning, through marriage, fatherhood, and eventually God, and how he believes each of those elements can create a better society. Originally started as a sequel to Hillbilly Elegy, the Vice President writes of a deeply personally spiritual journey. The mixing of cultural and economic insights written with appreciable candor continues the same style that made his debut memoir such a hit.
When read with political lens, Vance makes it clear that he would be a much different leader than both Trump, and the Republican leaders of the past. A clear disdain for wealthy business leaders, and disappointment in the culture that creates the modern high-paid, high working hours employees. “I eventually realized that elite professional life demands a disconnection from much of what makes us human.” He frequently bemoans the focus on GDP over family life and the unmeasured toll that has taken on society. He considers the benefits of paid family leave and policies against Big Tech as ways the GOP should evolve, even if they run counter to traditional small government conservative ideas. He even hints at a yearning for a more European quality of life, with beautiful architecture and a Japanese society focused on safety and orderliness, over traditional American ideas of maximum independence.
“God made us to work, yes. But to work to sustain our lives and to create beautiful and amazing things. An economy geared toward creation and dignity may very well produce more real prosperity than one geared toward finance and accumulation. This would undoubtedly be a more Christian economy”
Vance, while espousing support for religious liberty, believes strongly that America is a Christian nation and points repeatedly to the downfalls in Europe as it has departed from Christianity. Criticizing the decline of formal religion, he decries the modern movements that have replaced religion for some “at some point, Covid protocols began to feel like their own secular religion…The lack of grace and zealous enforcement of social rules rivaled any religious tyranny I’d ever encountered.” This combined with his repeated critiques of a culture that values work over family, and how the very mundane work of family; changing diapers, making food, caring for the elderly, makes us more human and Christian, even if economically we, individually and our national GDP, are worse off
Communion is a call to Christ, but also a call to parenthood, where Vance himself seems to have found most of his purpose and insights from. It’s a call to repentance, for the world, but refreshingly to see from a modern leader, to himself as well.
This is a very good book. I have already read at least one review by a Catholic site I respect, saying that this book “falls short.” Well, to me, it didn’t. I wasn’t going into this looking for a comprehensive theological treatise. JD has only been Catholic for 7 years; prior to that, he was an atheist for over a decade, after a very mixed-theology evangelical upbringing. All I wanted was to learn what brought JD to the Catholic Faith (which I also adhere to) and I received ample answers to that question, quite cogently stated.
It's hard to know what all to say in a review of this book, which is probably why I've procrastinated on writing it. There's a lot to say.
This book is purportedly an account of JD Vance's return to Christianity and Catholicism after realizing the emptiness of his atheism and worldly pursuits. It reads more like a man who wants to establish himself as a particular kind of candidate before the 2028 presidential election.
It seems to me like Vance hasn't really converted to Christianity but only to the institution and cultural aesthetic of the Catholic church. I have at least two reasons for thinking this. First, there's very little discussion or mention of Christ in the entire book and much of what is said has the thinness of a couple dogmatic pronouncements, the sort of thing one might profess in the Nicene creed. This is strange since Christ is the central figure of the Christian faith, and if all that is said is the kind of thing memorized from a creed or catechism, then there's no indication that a person has much interest in Christ himself. There's no indication that Vance has wrestled with Christ's life, death, or resurrection in any kind of meaningful way.
Second, because Vance hasn't wrestled with Christ in a meaningful way, he finds himself frequently confused when popes and bishops criticize the way Trump's administration treats immigrants and refugees. Both in this book and various podcasts he's expressed how frustrating it is to be told that migrants have dignity too. He thinks he knows this but fails to see what this actually requires of him. Either he is unable to recognize the dehumanizing rhetoric and treatment of migrants under Trump's administration or he fails to find it offensive or he simply finds it politically disadvantageous to distance himself from it. Any of these is a huge problem for anyone who names the name of Christ. The moral clarity he otherwise seems to possess becomes immediately confused when, say, children are being used as bait for capturing parents, detention facilities serve food with maggots, lies are being spread about immigrants, or human beings (many who are fellow Christians) are being chased down in the streets or in their homes. If Vance had encountered the love and compassion of Christ in a meaningful way, then he might begin to grasp the nature of the criticism coming from his spiritual leaders.
Aside from this, I appreciated that he was able to talk about real issues facing modern society, particularly economic inequality, social atomization, technological disruption, and a loss of shared meaning. My sense is that if I had encountered this book without the context of Vance's actual track record then I would have at least found him a respectable interlocutor. One of Vance's constant refrains is that "You shall know them by their fruits." I can't help but agree. Actions reveal the true meaning of a person's words and thus I suspect that there's an emptiness to a lot of what Vance says.
An assorted list of other notable things: 1) He clearly needs therapy to deal with his trauma. 2) His close relationship with Peter Theil is disconcerting. 3) He has nostalgia for mythic times of former racial unity. 4) He identifies with the post-liberal right and what exactly this means for him is hard to discern. 5) He expresses appreciation for Catholic social/economic teaching. More genuine commitment to this would be good for America. 6) It's not clear to me that he left behind his ambitious nature. After all, he completely changed his view on Trump to become VP.
Bizarre and meandering. Felt manipulative, undeveloped, and at times forced. Failed to focus on the topic. Expected a lot more out of such a highly educated author. Y'all can feel free to skip this one.
“In a spirit of humility, I ask that you pin the shortcomings of this book on the man who wrote it, not the faith that inspired it.” J. D. Vance
In this memoir, J. D. Vance shares how he reconciled the trauma of his past with who he was becoming as an adult, life partner, family man & leader. He rejected using his past as an excuse, chose not to languish in victimhood, but tapped into his own personal agency to learn a new way of life. Chief among his influences was/is his wife, Usha. Of her he writes, “She [Usha] was the tornado in the Wizard of Oz. Before her, I existed in black and white. Now, the full color of the world revealed itself.”
Through his years in the military & at college, Vance realized that crude superficial goals like credentials, careers, & money would never form the basis of a truly good life. As he searched for meaning, he read Christian writers (C. S. Lewis, G. K. Chesterton, etc.), talked to priests & thought deeply. Eventually, he returned to the church and allowed God’s grace to help him deal with his past trauma, personal guilt & need for forgiveness. Since then, he has sought for his Christian faith to permeate all aspects of his life--especially parenting--and including public service.
Two Bible passages hold special meaning for him:
II Corinthians 4:7-10: “But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us. We are hard pressed on every side, but not crushed; perplexed, but not in despair; persecuted, but not abandoned; struck down, but not destroyed. We always carry around in our body the death of Jesus, so that the life of Jesus may also be revealed in our body.”
Philippians 4:8: “Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable—if anything is excellent or praiseworthy—think about such things.”
He ends the book ruminating on why God allows tragedies—like his own father’s death from cancer in 2023 and his friend Charlie Kirk’s assassination in 2025—and how God uses them. Vance remains convinced that an all-powerful God loves us & that the Christian church will endure.
I’m convinced people have been paid to give this book low stars. This was a down to earth, easy to read, deeply human book. He’s honest about his beliefs and how they have changed over time and how they are ever evolving but that his sole focus is to be a good man, father, and husband. I mean maybe people don’t like it because he’s so honest but I found it extremely refreshing and I felt connected to his story because it so similiarly mimicked our faith journey in a lot of ways. I’m close in age to him so maybe it’s easier to relate for that reason, but I found the book refreshingly honest with a little politics thrown in.
I really enjoyed listening to this! JD is curious and vulnerable and insightful.
“Because life is good. Our human story will oscillate between tragedy and comedy while God's love and creation will inspire, confuse, and, at times, anger us. But through all that, I'm certain God's church will endure because Jesus Christ and His truth's endure. And we will all get our chance to make our mark on His church before we enjoy the rewards of heaven and communion with Him. Amen.”
He’s humble, he’s honest, and he’s always learning and growing. He’s spot on that our country needs to first focus more on helping families cultivate virtuous children, not the GDP (it will work itself out if we focus on the former). All the 1-star reviews didn’t read the book. And I truly believe Jesus DID heal his grandfather now that he’s in the presence of God.
As we enter the glide path to the 2028 Presidential election, a great divide among today’s Effective Right is differing views of JD Vance. One group, my group, views Vance as the most plausible candidate to raise and carry the banner of those on the Right who actually want to exercise power. They view him as correct-thinking, adequately right-wing, willing to learn, as well as young, dynamic, and not a slave to the decades-long stranglehold of our gerontocratic gynocracy. The other group views Vance as a weak, dishonest trimmer, a cutout for Peter Thiel or other supposedly dark forces, a way to decoy the energies of the Right, or all three. Vance’s new book gives us occasion to examine this crucial argument—although, as we’ll discuss, maybe none of it matters.
To be sure, Communion is not a political manifesto. It is dissimilar to most books written by, or ghostwritten for, politicians in the run-up to campaigns, which are almost always dumb pablum. (As far as I can tell, Vance wrote this book entirely by himself.) Rather, it is a spiritual memoir. In some ways it is a sequel to Vance’s 2016 life memoir Hillbilly Elegy, which brought him to national attention, in large part due to Rod Dreher. True, that is the only useful thing Dreher has ever accomplished, but it was not nothing, and Vance remains loyal to Dreher, even if Dreher has recently betrayed him in his simpering and cowardly quest to hobble the Effective Right.
For those unaware, the brief version of Vance’s life is that he was born very poor in Ohio, north of Cincinnati, to a soon largely-vanished father and a drug-addicted mother. After high school, he joined the Marines, an honorable method of entering the cursus honorum for intelligent young White men whose background otherwise today shuts them out of ways to rise in modern America. He left the Marines in 2007, graduated in 2009 from Ohio State, and then attended Yale Law School, graduating in 2013, there finding his now wife, Usha. Like me, he abandoned a nascent career in corporate law, turning instead to private equity, starting at Thiel’s Mithril Capital in 2016, and also involved himself in politics—initially on the advocacy side, and then being elected to the Senate, representing Ohio, in 2022.
The frame of this book is the how and why of Vance’s conversion to Roman Catholicism, in 2019. He was raised a Protestant, part Baptist, part Pentecostal, part nondenominational, under the significant influence of his grandmother, “Mamaw,” who (along with his grandfather, who died in 1997) raised him. His grandmother’s faith, in the manner of many low-church Protestants, was strong but idiosyncratic, heavily driven by the hardships of a difficult life, focused not on doctrine or churchgoing but on principles by which to live one’s life. It was formation by example, not by theology, and as often happens to young men when they enter circumstances entirely different from their childhood, as soon as he left home he began to question what he had absorbed.
Vance repeatedly self-identifies and self-criticizes himself in these pages as a striver, one with “the arrogant desire to rise above others.” In his youth, he was very much aware of the social debility imposed on him by his roots, and the natural impulse of a man who wishes to rise above his initial station is to reject the paths and ways which characterized his low position. Much of this, in Vance’s case, was a desire to free himself of any tie to the addiction, financial ruin, and shiftlessness he often encountered among his family and wider social groupings. But when making such a change, all matters are necessarily reexamined, including a man’s religion. When Vance joined the Marines, he still self-identified as a “conservative Christian,” but had begun to see that common Protestant obsessions of the time, especially the Rapture (and its cultural manifestations, such as the Left Behind series), as well as largely abstract political controversies with a religious overlay which ignored the actual problems facing those around him, did not answer adequately to either spiritual questions or the needs of his people. The churches he attended certainly gave generously to the poor, but were too often “divorced from the day-to-day concerns of the faithful.”
And so he lost his faith. “Losing my faith wasn’t, consequently, a primarily intellectual act. It was the equivalent of divorce. I was severing myself from my roots as I understood them—from my family, the grandmother I’d just lost, the values I’d been taught.” He does not, wisely, claim to fully understand why; those who claim loss of faith is merely an intellectual development, usually cast as an achievement and improvement, do not understand the process. It is a gradual happening in the vast majority of cases, revolving, as Vance says, around the erosion of trust, exacerbated by “the inertia of modern life.” Faith becomes irrelevant, and so disappears. (This has never really happened to me, even if I became less observant for a time. As Psalm 14 says, “The fool hath said in his heart, there is no God.” Which shows, once again, that ideas we think of as modern were well understood in Bronze Age Israel.)
Still, he kept reading Christian literature while in Iraq, notably C. S. Lewis, always a good choice. But by 2006, he was calling himself an atheist. He wasn’t convinced to do this by the then-fashionable New Atheists, now thankfully vanished from the public consciousness. Instead, he felt, in essence, that Christ just didn’t deliver. Unsurprisingly, he was then pulled toward the ideas of Ayn Rand, another common occurrence among right-wing young men, though he never went full Randian. “I didn’t care about God’s will. I cared about my own. I cared about winning, never having to worry about money again, and having the type of job that commanded respect.”
In due course, he drifted toward law, for the same reason many others (including, again, me) do—not for any love for the law, or even knowing much about its practice, but for money, (incorrectly) perceived security, and social prestige (though as he identifies, that prestige comes from the modern phenomenon of workism, the focus on grueling work as the source of identity, a historically bizarre belief). Thus, he chose Yale, the most selective law school, and among the most prestigious two or three in the country (though I doubt very much that today, in 2026, any young White man seen to be in any way right-aligned could be accepted to Yale). He seems to have enjoyed Yale, even if he questioned its emphases and biases, especially the stupid idea that women have a harder road in law school and law, when in reality in law and every other area of America life, high and low, women for decades have been served everything on a silver platter, at the expense of far more competent men, and to the huge detriment of society at large.
In a book by an active politician more than a few punches are necessarily pulled, so one can never be entirely sure what Vance thinks. But it certainly appears to resonate with the more aggressive sections of today’s Right. For example, as with Yale but not limited to that instance, Vance repeatedly guardedly refers to the gross abuse of men in modern American society, but never quite comes out and addresses it, or what should be done about it. He does not, in other words, endorse sex role realism, but he may very well believe in it. He also seems to have an interesting psychology; we will get to his opinions on death, but for example, he is “permanently terrified that things will unravel,” meaning he anticipates (and necessarily develops plans to deal with) disaster. I have a lot of sympathy for that approach to life, and again, it is a quintessentially male trait, the desire to protect, and therefore denigrated today.
Vance’s return to faith began with the realization that different, and frankly more sophisticated, versions of Christianity existed compared to those he had known in his youth. He discovered that doubt and debate were features of most Christian belief, not something Christians were commanded to avoid by bathing in a sea of bromides. He encountered a passage from Saint Augustine (whom he took as his patron saint when he was baptized), where Augustine notes that “different interpretations are sometimes possible without prejudice to the faith we have received.” Put more simply, he realized that the faith of his childhood was simplistic, and that a more considered faith could be both richer and answer the questions he had thought Christianity failed to answer.
In particular, he saw that neither science nor technology necessarily conflicted with Christian belief. He came into contact with Thiel, who (similarly to Alexander Karp) complains that technology has been and is being used to stultify us and satisfy base desires, rather than lift mankind to new heights. Through Thiel, he encountered René Girard, and understood that his own core desires were mimetic—not necessarily wrong, or bad, but ill-thought out, and rigidly bracketed, along with all his thoughts, by what was regarded as desirable and permissible by his Yale peers.
He did not then rush to the nearest church and throw himself weeping on the altar. But the “door was open.” By his third year of law school he was engaged to his classmate, Usha. He clerked for a federal judge (he did not obtain a supremely-prestigious Supreme Court clerkship, but Usha did). He examined Christianity more closely, diving into the Book of Job and Lewis’s The Problem of Pain, refracting his difficult childhood and the travails of his relatives and companions of that time through a more sophisticated lens than the old low-church standby, “it’s all God’s plan and He works in mysterious ways.” At the same time, his life was launching fast—he married in 2014, and was, despite being troubled by his past, happy enough.
He and his wife for the first few years worked law-related jobs, and in 2016 Hillbilly Elegy launched Vance to public notice. At this point he opposed Donald Trump, and “even at the time I couldn’t help but notice that my criticisms made me a ‘safe conservative.’ . . . Trump criticism functioned as social immunity. And this immunity was quite lucrative—it guaranteed that I could make excuses for my fellow hillbillies or even empathize with them, so long as I did not commit the unforgivable sin of suggesting that they be given political power through their chosen candidate.”
Vance’s first child, a son (of now four children) was born in 2017. He continued his slow fall toward the gravitational well of Christianity, finding merit in the set prayers of Catholicism, and in the social thought of Rerum Novarum and its message of subsidiarity, unsurprising given his background and how his people have been raped by the globalists and private equity titans. But it was still just a “flirtation,” even if every few weeks he and Usha (who was and remains Hindu) would take their son to church. He read; he talked to influential priests. He realized that the problems with which he had identified Christianity and Catholicism were “problems ultimately caused by the shortcomings of human beings,” and that the Church has much of great depth and nuance to say on that matter. True, a not-infrequent criticism of Roman Catholicism is that it is instrumental and excessively rational. Vance adverts to this, but did not find it an insurmountable stumbling block. And, ultimately, he was baptized in 2019. In short, his reason was that “I needed to do more than read the occasional book of theology or reflect on my own shortcomings.” Instead, “I needed grace.” And it is, after all, always and everywhere grace which leads to salvation.
The last quarter of the book is more political. In Vance’s telling, his political evolution in a Trumpian, more populist, direction, meaning giving ear to the trampled White middle and lower classes of America, proceeded in a not-dissimilar manner. Certainly his background suggested a populist bent, but we should not forget he had spent nearly two decades trying to leave his background behind, and being praised only when he said safe, allowed things which never criticized, much less threatened, our ruling elites. Vance’s turn came when he realized that “the fruits of the so-called rules-based international order, especially since the mid-1990s, were rotten.” He saw that all the political elites across the West were an insulated group of clowns forbidden to think or speak outside of narrow views, “secular global liberalism,” which were approved for them. Ultimately, in 2024, as a senator, at the Munich Security Conference, in a speech that attracted huge attention, he in essence attacked the entire postwar Western system, in part through the prism of our insane and stupid response to Russia’s entirely justified actions in Ukraine.
Of particular interest to me, Vance savages the cult of GDP, along with the undeserved respect accorded to the views and persons of professional economists, practitioners of the “dismal science,” who used to be of borderline relevance in political discussions but are now exalted as oracles. He endorses Oren Cass’s The Once and Future Worker, and notes the destruction that results from how the lower classes, who occupy mostly service jobs, have to serve consumerism at the expense of family. He notes the catastrophe of below-replacement fertility in the West, and that a society without children lacks dynamism. On these matters, he might as well be Charles Haywood, if Charles Haywood was more careful to make his opinions palatable to the ignorant.
And finally, Vance closes with talk of death. One death is the death of the West, “civilizational death.” He fears that he, and our generation, will allow what our ancestors built to fall into permanent disrepair, that is, destruction. (Very bravely, those great ancestors, in a short list, include Christopher Columbus, Robert E. Lee, and Stonewall Jackson.) He notes a Orthodox standard prayer about the dead, that God grant the deceased “memory eternal”—not in the minds of men, but within His divinity. Fear of such death, for Vance, therefore, somewhat distorting the Orthodox use, is “a sense of despair over the prospect of leaving things worse off than we found them—a death, not of an individual, but of the civilization that gave an individual’s life meaning. Memory eternal is the antidote to all of this. . . . It ensures that the communion we seek in life runs not only among those living today but also across the generations that came before us and those yet to come.”
The other death is his own death, on which he dwells quite a bit. For a Christian, to be sure, this is an expected, even required, frequent topic of thought. On a personal level, he says that he fears death very little, both inherently in his personality and due to his Christian faith. (Given the inevitable increasing violence of the Left, this is a very important trait for any man of the Effective Right.) He turns introspective, discussing Simon Peter, crucified as was his Lord, saying “The very thing I fear is that thing that Simon Peter . . . experienced: death without triumph. Death knowing that your friends will be worse off, at least in the short term. Death without any certainty that your earthly labors will bear fruit. And in this fear, my own vanity convicts me.” Still, he draws hope, ending the book with a visit to Rome and a return to spiritual rumination. “Here in Rome it was obvious. Caesar was dead. Christ still lived.”
It is all very interesting, and something any man or woman struggling with faith would do well to read. But let us lower ourselves to discuss the politics of 2026, and 2028. With the well-deserved, if maybe unfortunate, nationwide defeat of the Republican Party a few weeks ago, a great deal seems to ride on the 2028 Presidential election, even more than was riding before. After all, this election will determine if the Republican Party, already a very flawed, almost worthless, vessel, will return to the despicable ways of Mitt Romney, John McCain, and George W. Bush, or will take the next steps onward from Trump to actually represent the interests of those who elected Trump. Vance is the obvious frontrunner to succeed Trump. Therefore, we will review common objections to Vance, and thus to his candidacy, one by one, and address each in turn. And then, we will talk about whether any of this has any substance. Or is it whistling past the graveyard, and the correct approach to the American future is rather the question in the title of John Mellencamp’s fourth album—“Nothin’ Matters and What If It Did?”
The first common attack on Vance, and I think the one with the most substance, is that he lacks the personality which is absolutely necessary for the next President, if America is to have any hope to survive and flourish. The man who becomes President in 2029 must realize, as the saying goes, what time it is. The forces of the Left, gathering power for nearly a century in America, have received their first setback ever in America, in the form, grossly imperfect as it has been, of Trump. This will inevitably compound the violence and chaos the Left attempts to impose in their quest for utopia, to reach the final destination of total emancipation and total egalitarianism. And history teaches us that because the Left, with its core belief in an arrow of history pointing to ever greater Left power, can never accept any rollback of its power, it must be utterly crushed, without mercy. The next President must recognize and accept this necessity.
While Vance has given more than one indication, in speeches and elsewhere, that he would approach the role of President with hard-edged, realistic thinking, this book itself suggests he likely does not inherently possess the harsh personality, totally devoid not only of the hyperfeminization of our society, but of any feminine empathy whatsoever, required in the next President. This is perhaps no surprise; the Left never shows any pity or mercy, while the Right is always, until very late in the day, constrained by conscience and by the desire for normalcy and peace. The unfortunate result, however, is that the American Right (and even more the pseudo-Right of odious men such as William F. Buckley) has for decades whined like a little bitch about the endless aggressions and advances of the Left, while never performing any aspect of the absolutely necessary tit-for-tat response required by first-grade game theory. One has only to look at what was done to the Left—that is, nothing—after the Left murder of Charlie Kirk to see an excellent example, whereas if an equivalent figure on the Left had been murdered, to this day every news outlet would talk every day about the murder and Right responsibility, many people would have been imprisoned under charges of “conspiracy” and “stochastic terrorism,” and the Left would have made every attempt to use the murder as an excuse to violently crush the entire Right for years. That is to say, most of the Right has always consistently engaged in pre-emptive surrender while advancing the goals of the Left, sometimes out of an utterly wrong belief that engagement is possible with the Left, but more often because they are afraid or because bowing to the Left has been the easy path to comfort and riches.
Nonetheless, I suspect two things. As I say . . . [Review completes as first comment.]
I read several reviews of this book before reading it myself, both here on Goodreads and in newspapers and magazines. As you would expect, many were shaped by opinions of J.D. Vance's politics. If, however, you are genuinely curious, as I was, I would encourage you to read Communion for yourself. I found it to be less a political manifesto than a thoughtful narrative of a sincere spiritual journey.
Vance takes the reader through his years in the Marine Corps, at Ohio State, and at Harvard Law School, during which he gradually lost his faith. At Harvard he met Usha, and the two fell in love. As he began thinking about the kind of husband and father he wanted to become, he found himself drawn back toward Christianity. Usha, though not herself a Christian, played an important role in that return. Recognizing that church made him a better man, she encouraged his search and even attended services with him.
Christianity recognizes the brokenness of human beings. Vance writes that he was particularly struck by the Catholic sacrament of confession as a way of confronting his sin and accepting personal moral responsibility. "I screwed up. I'm sorry. I will do x (perform penance or make restitution) in an attempt to become a better person."
One of the most interesting sections for me describes Vance's reading of Pope Leo XIII's encyclical, Rerum Novarum. Vance is openly critical of measuring prosperity primarily through consumer spending or GDP, and of employers who fail to pay fair wages or require employees to work holidays. I believe these criticisms arise from personal experience—he recounts trying to gather his extended family for Thanksgiving while relatives working in retail were unable to attend. The overwhelming impression I came away with is that Vance sincerely desires strong, stable families more than economic growth at any cost.
I found the writing in Communion to be intelligent, articulate, and deeply self-reflective. When Vance writes, "What felt comfortable at this point was to intellectualize faith. So I read a lot of books," I immediately related. I've read many of the same authors he mentions and quotes. In both his experience and my own, books become more than a source of information; they become a means of formation, shaping character as well as intellect. They remind us of humanity's brokenness while refusing to let our brokenness excuse our failures toward one another.
Some themes I noticed: • Grace operates on God's timetable. • Faith and reason belong together, with tradition and personal experience playing important roles. • Strong families matter more than consumption. • Intellectual humility is essential because no one can master every field of knowledge.
This memoir resists easy ideological labels, drawing on Catholic social teaching in ways that challenge assumptions on both the political right and the political left. Whether or not one agrees with Vance's politics, his account of conversion struck me as thoughtful, intellectually honest, and genuinely heartfelt.