Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Brewhouse Book Club #1

Fake It Until It's Real

Rate this book
She's afraid she's too much. He's convinced he'll never be enough.

Maplemoor was supposed to be Jess Harper's fresh start, a quiet place to rebuild after a future that never happened. Now she has a book club that feels like family, a coffee shop that knows her order, and a life that finally feels steady again.

What she doesn't have is a date to her best friend's wedding—the one where her ex and his brand-new fiancée will be.

Caleb Ward is the guy everyone counts on when it matters most—reliable, steady, the first one through the door. He did everything right last time, and still ended up the man who got left behind. These days, he's not looking for love. He's not looking for anything.

Which is exactly why saying yes to Jess Harper feels safe. It's just a fake date. One wedding, and then back to real life.

Until it isn't.

One weekend together. One very convincing performance. And suddenly the line between pretending and real is a lot thinner than either of them thought.

The hard part is knowing which side of that line they're on.

292 pages, Kindle Edition

Published April 28, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tina Gallagher

60 books106 followers
As a tween, Tina Gallagher and her best friend would create happily ever afters for their favorite soap opera couples. Eventually, the soap operas lost their appeal, but the writing never did.  

Before living her dream as a full-time author, she worked a spectrum of jobs ranging from baking and cake decorating to marketing and project management.

In between creating memorable characters, traveling, and taking pole dance lessons, Tina enjoys spending time with her handyman husband and two grown children. 

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
41 (45%)
4 stars
33 (36%)
3 stars
14 (15%)
2 stars
2 (2%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
Profile Image for Jessica.
493 reviews269 followers
May 13, 2026
Just finished reading an advanced copy of a book that was just recently released called, Fake It Until It's Real. This was about Jess, after her relationship for over a decade ends she decides to move to the small cozy town of Maplemoor for a new beginning. She was immediately welcomed by the locals and finally felt like she found a place that feels like home to her. But when her best friend's wedding is around the corner and her ex will be there (with his new fiancé), Jess feels like she can't go to the wedding alone because she wants her ex to know she's over him and happy with her life. So her friend suggests her brother as a fake wedding date. Caleb isn't looking for love but he is kind and always shows up for those he cares about. So when his sister asks him to be a fake date for Jess, the new girl in town, he's happy to help. But can Jess and Caleb spend time getting to know each other, then be a fake couple at a wedding, then go back to their regular lives without each other?
This was such a great book! I absolutely flew through it! I loved this small town of Maplemoor, it was so warm and welcoming, full of goodhearted people and the cutest moose mascot! 🫎 I really loved the weekly bookclub meetings at the local coffee shop, how this friend group took Jess right in when she moved to town and made her feel welcome in Maplemoor, and how they cared about her and her happiness. I loved the storyline between Jess and Caleb, fake dating and friends to lovers, it was such a sweet love story! This was such a charming small town with the best characters, and I absolutely can't wait to dive into the next book! 💜📚

Thank you to Tina Gallagher and Cissy Mecca for this ARC of Fake It Until It's Real, in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Shae.
1,057 reviews43 followers
June 10, 2026
Absolutely great read

adventurous, emotional, hopeful, lighthearted, reflective, relaxing
medium-paced

Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I enjoyed this book, fake dating, adventurous dog, and two main characters who absolutely shine.

Jess moved to Maplemoor, a small town, for a change of scenery after her breakup. She was moving on, starting to feel great, when she was told that her ex and his new fiancée would be at a wedding she had to attend.

Caleb agrees to go with Jess as her fake boyfriend for the wedding weekend. However, to make this seem 'real', they start to spend time together and actually fall for each other.

Book club meetings, a friend's brother as a fake boyfriend, a small town that pulls together, and families who enjoy spending time together are some of the things one will encounter in this story. Also, add in Murphy, Caleb's dog, who falls in love with Jess first, and make it clear in his actions. This story was an excellent read. This was my first novel by Tina and Cissy, and I will definitely read the rest of the series.

Reasons I enjoyed this book:
Easy-to-read, Entertaining, Happily Ever After, Page-turner, Romantic, Wonderful characters
Profile Image for Alejandra (Alex) Martin ~ Lexi Likes to Read.
737 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 28, 2026
I am absolutely in love with Jess and Caleb’s story—like, completely gone for it. This isn’t just your typical friends-to-lovers situation… it’s more like semi-strangers → fake dating → friends → finally lovers, and honestly? That layered buildup made everything hit so much harder. Both of them come into this story carrying some emotional baggage from past relationships, so there’s hesitation on both sides. But their chemistry? Effortless. It felt so natural watching them fall into each other’s orbit without even realizing how deeply they were starting to rely on one another.

Oh and that delicious moment of realization—when they both understood just how much the other person had become a constant in their lives? Perfection. And when things did shift into something more official? The awkwardness was so real and so endearing. Instead of being frustrating, it added this layer of authenticity that made their relationship feel even more genuine. I also appreciated the introspection woven throughout—the way they had to learn not only to support each other but to actually speak up about what they wanted and needed. Add in the strong friendships and emotional growth across the board, and I’m fully invested. I cannot wait to see where this series goes next.
Profile Image for Reading by Deb.
1,331 reviews35 followers
May 3, 2026
Jess moved to Maplemoor three months ago to escape her failed relationship and start a new life away from painful memories. Instead, she found a small town that welcomed her with open arms and friendships like she had known them forever.

Every Wednesday night, she met with her new friends at the Brewhouse for their book club, but a book was discussed only on the last day of the month. The rest was socializing and catching up with everyone's week.

Everyone knew she was the Maid of Honor for her best friend's upcoming wedding, and her nervousness in running into her ex, who was also part of the wedding, but she had received a call the night before telling her that he was bringing a plus-one, a fiancée.

Emily looked up with a grin on her face. Their current book trope was about fake dating and she said she knew just who she should invite to be her plus-one at the wedding. Emily's gorgeous six-five brother.

I loved this book! It is very well written and the characters are fully developed and relatable. I love this small town where everyone knows you and steps up to help whenever you need something.

Jess only knew Caleb in passing, so they decided to have a few pre-dates before the wedding to make their dating look believable. Neither expected to have so much in common. You will fall in love with Murphy! Highly recommend!
Profile Image for Amy Reierson.
1,470 reviews18 followers
April 28, 2026
Caleb and Jess, Jess and Caleb. Acquaintances first, then a friend's brother is suddenly doing Jess a favor just because he's a good guy. In the meantime they become friends.
The favor attendIng a wedding with Jess so she doesn't have to face her ex alone. Caleb easily accepts because part of him would want some to help him out if he needed the same.
Now if Caleb was our typical male main character these two would have been fast in love by the end of the wedding. But when a book club is involved in the storytelling how could it end there?
There's so much more. There is incredible family, they are fun, dramatic, supportive and loud and did I mention embarrassing?! The friends, new and a few old are the kind we all hope for. And this small town could only exist in a book. It's dreamy down to the last detail. I can't wait to get started on book two. This review really only touch the tip of this story. I mean someone special a certain character has things figured out from the very beginning, see if you can figure out who it is.
I have voluntarily left this review.
Profile Image for Kelchickbooklover.
2,318 reviews69 followers
April 30, 2026
I was pleasantly surprised with Fake It Until It's Real. The storyline was sweet, had a fun-loving side, and the characters were easily relatable. This is the first book in The Brewhouse Book Club series, as well as the first book by Ms. Gallagher that I have read. Believe me, it will not be the last. Her writing style and storyline had me hooked right from the start.
Jess, a newcomer to Maplemoor, and Caleb, a lifelong resident, are somewhat friends, but when she needs a plus-one for her friend's wedding, he doesn't hesitate to help out. A fake relationship for a wedding just might not stay fake for long. A weekend away, time spent hiking, having dinners and just hanging out has them realizing that there was a spark they could not ignore. In the long run, they were perfect for one another.
From start to finish, I loved the friendships that developed and the fact that family was always there, no matter how much they pushed or interfered. I'm excited to read the next book in the series.
791 reviews6 followers
May 7, 2026
Jess and Caleb both understand heartache after ending long-term relationships, hers being very recent. She moved to Maplemoor to have a fresh start and she has found it - strong small town community, a circle of friends. But attending her best friend’s wedding back in Philadelphia and seeing her ex with his new fiance…. It is too much to handle. Jess is friends with Caleb’s sister Emily, and she suggests Jess take Caleb to the wedding. In getting to know each other more, they realize what was supposed to be fake, could be real. But when Jess may have to move for her job, both of their insecurities coming back to the forefront. Can they move past them together?

I really like the dynamic between these two characters. They were both people you would know and be friends with, and you would want them to be together. Looking forward to book #2 in this series!

I read an Advance Reader Copy of this book.
Profile Image for Vilma .
971 reviews1 follower
May 17, 2026
I love how this fake dating to real romance unfolds so naturally. It never feels forced, mostly because Jess and Caleb start from a place of easy familiarity, acquaintances who’ve shared work interactions, and small conversations. Add in the Maplemoor book club, and you feel how fully Jess has been welcomed into this tight‑knit town after leaving Philly and her ex, Brett.

Caleb is absolutely a golden‑retriever hero, but what makes this story refreshing is that Jess isn’t a grump or a stereotypical Black Cat heroine. She’s simply a woman rebuilding her confidence after life blindsided her, and she’s doing it with quiet strength.

The book club becomes her found family, and when a trip back to Philly for her best friend’s wedding calls for a date, Caleb steps in. He’s the perfect gentleman, kind, steady, and respectful; and once they return home, their connection deepens effortlessly. Friendship shifts into something more, and it feels earned.
Profile Image for Lisa Petty (Book Bangers Blog).
2,490 reviews22 followers
April 30, 2026
Jess Harper needed a fresh start and chose the small town of Maplemoor. Everyone who looks out for their own, she didn't think she would fit in so quickly. But months later, her love for the town continues to grow. She has an amazing set of friends in her book group and a set back home. I love her spunk and her zest for the outdoors. When she finds out her ex will be bringing his new GF to her best friend's wedding, well, that is a whole lot of crazy. But she can do this until she can't. Caleb is the town's HVAC man. He works hard and loves his family. He is a simple man you can't help but love and want to cuddle. When he's asked to go with Jess, he doesn't hesitate. These two will form a friendship that makes you want to be a part of it. But when the wedding is done, can they continue being friends? Or will their hearts want more?
371 reviews10 followers
April 28, 2026
A new series with a nod to book clubs everywhere!

I love small town romance. This one does not disappoint.

Jess need doesn’t want to show up to her best friend’s wedding alone. She knows her recently engaged ex will be there with his fiancée. She is still recovering from the breakup and he’s moved on already.

When Jess talks to her friends at their book club meeting, one of them suggests her brother, Caleb. He agrees to attend the wedding with her. They go on a few get to know each other dates around town before the wedding.

Once the wedding is over they are over right!! You need to read to find out what happens! You won’t be disappointed.

I loved the town mascot an adorable moose.

Proud to be apart of the Brew Crew for this awesome series.
Profile Image for Brittany.
61 reviews1 follower
April 30, 2026
Fake It Until It’s Real was such a delightful small town romance and the first in the Brewhouse Bookclub series. I was pleasantly delighted by this book as it was my first by these two! This book was a quick and easy read. The characters relatability and fun loving nature quickly hooks you!

The story focuses on Jess and Caleb. Jess moved to Maplemoor for a fresh start after a long term romance fizzed out. Caleb has the town roots. Caleb’s sister introduces them when Jess needs a date to her best friends wedding. Caleb is strong and dependable. The man that will be there no questions asked. That fake date turned into the romance they both were waiting for! Follow along as Caleb and Jess fall in love!

Bonus points to Caleb because he’s got the cutest dog who falls head over heels for Jess!
Profile Image for Shari Jahn.
401 reviews11 followers
June 6, 2026
I loved this book. I actually read this book second and book two first. I loved book two so much I wanted to read the first one, too. This series is really good. I really enjoyed the characters and the small town atmosphere. This book is about Jess and Caleb. Jess is going to be the maid of honor for her best friend's wedding but the fact that her ex that she dated for 11 years will also be in the wedding and he will be there with his fiancé. She needs to get through this wedding in one piece. At book club one of the girls offers her brother as a fill in date for her. She does not believe in the fake dating genre but she finds herself right in the middle of a fake dating situation. This was a fun book with great characters. It is well worth the read! I highly recommend it.
Profile Image for Melissa * bookedwithmel.
861 reviews15 followers
April 28, 2026
I am lucky enough to be a part of Tina and Cissy’s Brew Crew for this series.

This series is absolutely right up my alley. A group of women that get together at the local coffee shop regularly for book club and sometimes just bonding. Jess finds a new home in Maplemoor and makes friends with a great group of ladies. Seeing their friendships makes my heart happy. When Jess doesn’t want to go to her friend’s wedding solo because her ex and his new fiancé will be there, Emily volunteers her brother Caleb to accompany her. Caleb has quite the hero complex, and always wants to help someone out that’s in need.

Tina and Cissy have created a small town that makes you want to live there. I can’t wait to read more about Maplemoor and its residents.
575 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 26, 2026
Loved this book with the small town and book club! I have to say I am jealous of this close group of friends from the book club and how they are there for each other. Fell in love with Jess and Caleb. The fact that Jess wasn’t in to the faking dating trope but wound up having it happen to her is the best. From spending the weekend of the wedding together to then missing each other and the time they spent together was beautifully written. I fell in love with both the characters and the setting. This was the first time reading a Tina Gallagher book and am hooked! Love the Brew Crew!
Profile Image for Kristin.
550 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 27, 2026
Jess is coming off a long relationship that didn’t even end in an engagement. She has moved to Maplemoor and is loving her life there. Her best friend is getting married and is also part of the bridal party and has news. So when Jess tells the book club of course the solution is take a fake date. Enter Caleb, one of the brothers of a book club member. Every finds him steady and dependable. And don’t get me started on his adorable dog, Murphy. Jess doesn’t believe in the trope of fake dating to relationship, will it hold true after their weekend together?!,!
228 reviews
May 1, 2026
Fake romance at its best!

Jess is starting over in the small town of Maplemoor, Caleb is a lifelong resident. The ladies of Maplemoor have totally adopted Jess as one of their own. This friend group/found family refers to itself as The Brewhouse House Book Club. Jess needs a date for a wedding that her ex will be at with his new fiancé & Caleb is avoiding his ex, so he volunteers to be her date! Throw in some get together know you time & forced proximity, of course SPARKS FLY! This is book 1 of a 4 book series & I’m so glad to be on The Brew Crew!!
6,424 reviews32 followers
May 1, 2026
Caleb is a golden retriever…

Caleb is a hardworking, good guy with a dog named Murphy. He’s is the good guy who always ends up last, ie without the girl.

Jess is new to town, she moved after her eleven year relationship ended and her ex is already engaged. Hence, her ploy to fake it with Caleb, courtesy of her book club. It’s not a thing, but somehow, all that proximity has Jess seeing Caleb in a whole new light.
Recommend.
93 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 24, 2026
Such a fun start to a new series co-written by two of my favorite authors! Small town + coffee shop + great characters + romance = pure reading enjoyment. The author's descriptions of people and situations make readers feel like we are sitting right beside the characters. I cannot wait to see what next installment brings!
301 reviews1 follower
May 2, 2026
Such a great story!

Jess and Caleb’s story was so much fun to read. I am glad they got past the fake part of their relationship. It was such a warm and fuzzy feeling reading it, and Murphy just made it even better. Who cannot love a pup who loves everyone! Awesome story, can’t wait for the second book.
Profile Image for books_n_ink_217 Elizabeth Welch.
459 reviews27 followers
May 13, 2026
This was a fun slow burn strangers to friends to lovers romance that I thoroughly enjoyed. It’s fun and fresh. She needs a date to a wedding and he steps in…and the relationship starts to blossom from there. There are great friendships depicted in the story that I really had fun reading about! Looking forward to more! Thank you to Indie Pen PR for the gifted ebook!
Profile Image for Shelly.
435 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 23, 2026
Really sweet story. Very solid, showing that love doesn’t always come in like a wrecking ball or streak of lightning. And that the fake romances do sometimes develop. ❤️ Great story!!

I received a free copy of this book from the author. The thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Corrin Cwalinski Wombacker.
3 reviews1 follower
April 29, 2026
Fake It Until It’s Real is Book 1 in The Brewhouse Bookclub Series and if you haven’t read it yet you are missing out. Jess finds a new start in Maplemoor and is loving her new life, job, and bookclub friends. But her old life isn’t too far away and she doesn’t have a date to her friend’s wedding (where of course the horrible ex who broke her heart will be with his new fiancé). Enter the perfect fake-date, Caleb. In order to pull off a fake relationship you have to practice and that practice makes everything very real. Jess is afraid to loose all she’s worked for and Caleb likes his life exactly as he built it. Add in Caleb’s amazing dog, Murphy, who you will want to love as soon as you meet, and you have an adorable fake dating read that you will love from page one! (Oh and the town’s mascot is the Maplemoor Moose) I devoured this book in one day (even reading through dinner to my husband’s amusement) I highly recommend you read it.
Profile Image for Carolyn Meredith.
851 reviews9 followers
May 13, 2026
This is a sweet story with a little steam. Easy to read and a smooth ride from brother of a friend to a couple. Well written with wonderful characters. I am looking forward to reading the rest of the series.
737 reviews
May 20, 2026
This gave me all the cozy feels! All of them i tell you!!

Jess and Caleb were so sweet together. It was impossible not to fall in love with them.

If you dream of being part of a great book club, living in the most adorable town amd having a moose as a mascot then this is the series for you!
47 reviews1 follower
June 11, 2026
Such a lovely, sweet slow dance. Loved the main characters, the friends, and especially the Brewhouse world. The pace of this story is different than I usually read. It's quiet, deliberate, meaningful. Really, really, beautiful. On to book #2!
Profile Image for Nichole Reeves.
98 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
April 27, 2026
Caleb and Jess were a perfect match. Their love was steady and strong. They took a couple wrong turns, but they were able to figure it out in the end. Such a sweet story.
297 reviews2 followers
April 28, 2026
An adorable fake relationship that will have you hooked from the start. Caleb and Jess are absolutely adorable together and their HEA was perfect.
691 reviews4 followers
April 29, 2026
This was such a lovely read. Communication between the characters. Some sexy times but not too much. Just perfect.
Profile Image for Vicki.
145 reviews
June 1, 2026
Unfortunately, I think this one just missed the mark for me. It felt just a little too tied up nicely for what I would have preferred. Based on their dynamic, I would have liked to have seen more of a struggle between the two.

But, I really love the book club aspect. The friend group tying this whole series together is well written and definitely is the type of friend group we all need.

Thank you, Tina Gallagher and Cissy Mecca, for the ARC opportunity. This honest review has been left voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews