Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Batter Up!

Rate this book
What happens when a summer fling leads to catching feelings?

After years of supporting her ex-husband’s dream of being a pro ball player, Jane Morris has returned home to the small city of Red Rock, Alberta to fulfill hers, running her bakery Batter Up!. To make it a success, she’s working to land a multi-year contract with the Fliers, the local Triple A ball club. Finding her old friend Carter playing for the team is an unexpected bonus.

Carter Cook wants to win a World Championship. After a car accident left him badly injured, he fought his way back and signed a minor league contract that landed him in Red Rock. All he wants is to prove he can still play at the highest level, and return to the big leagues.

After an encounter with her ex, Jane invites Carter to move in with her — platonically, of course. But their chemistry can’t be denied, and before long being roommates turns into friends with benefits. They both know it can’t be anything more. Jane’s life is in Red Rock, and Carter will be gone as soon as the big club calls.

As the season goes on, Carter and Jane start to wonder if their relationship could be more. For them to make it work, one of them would have to give up their dream, forcing them to ask:

Is chasing your dream worth giving up a chance at love?

318 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 15, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kristy Mallory

7 books14 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
19 (35%)
4 stars
30 (56%)
3 stars
2 (3%)
2 stars
2 (3%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
Profile Image for Maria.
95 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 6, 2026
After a messy, scandal-filled divorce and a move, Jane is fully focused on making her dream a reality: Batter Up!, her bakery. Meanwhile, Carter, a professional baseball player, is finally back on the field after two years of rehab following an accident, and he’s determined to keep a promise. Jane and Carter first met when Carter was a rookie, and now, years later, their paths cross again.

I absolutely adored Jane’s relationship with her daughter and son. They’re such a sweet, lovable family, and I loved seeing their dynamic throughout the book.
And Carter? Such a green flag! He’s thoughtful, considerate, and genuinely selfless. And his relationship with Ethan was one of the things I loved the most, it felt like a real father-son relationship.
Even though the age gap is pretty big, I really loved Jane and Carter together. Their relationship feels so healthy, especially because they actually communicate with each other, and their relationship never felt unnecessarily messy just for the sake of drama. And that ending? They deserved that so much!

Batter Up! is definitely worth reading and worth rereading! It’s one of those books you pick up and suddenly realize you’ve been reading for hours because you’re so invested in the story. The writing is easy and engaging, and the whole book just pulls you in. I really enjoyed it!
Profile Image for Leanne.
23 reviews1 follower
August 20, 2026
This baseball romance sold me right from the dedication to the 2025 Blue Jays 💙

Carter is determined to make it back to the big leagues after a devastating accident. Jane is eager to thrive in life and her bakery after divorce (and of course her ex’s name is Chad). When Carter suddenly comes barreling back into Jane’s life, there is instant chemistry. The story follows their relationship as they navigate their evolving feelings while each following their own dream.

I actually loved the real baseball in this and the author clearly knows her stuff. The storyline wasn’t far-fetched and characters felt genuine in their motivations, dialogue, and growth. I’m not usually a fan of the age-gap romance, but this was sweet (and a little spicy 🌶️). There was more to it than just the romance! If you love a heartwarming small town, friends to lovers, sports romance, give this one a try!

A big thank you to the author for the opportunity to read the ARC!
Profile Image for Trinity Gerke.
116 reviews1 follower
September 22, 2026
✨4.5
This book was so cute!! I loved the relationship between Jane and Carter. It felt so real and the yearning had me feeling all the emotions. I loved that they knew each other before and it was like a loose “second chance” even though they weren’t romantic the first time they knew each other. I loved the dynamic between Jane and her kids and the vast emotions they had for their father. As someone with mixed emotions for a parent, this resonated with me. I also liked to see the workings of the minor league baseball system. Even if all the details weren’t accurate to real life (which they didn’t need to be for the story to work), it made me feel like I was on the team with Carter and could see how it all works. I can’t wait to see where this series goes and I will for sure be reading the rest of them!
Profile Image for Ginger Forsyth.
8 reviews1 follower
August 24, 2026
I feel super fortunate to have been chosen as an ARC reader for Batter Up! It's always a good time when you can slow down, take in a small town romance with big city vibes. Without spoiling the sweet storyline, I would highly recommend the story of Jane & Carter. From what I have read in the ARC readers group, Kristy is working on the continuation of the story, and I can't wait to jump back in. Will be looking forward to the follow up.
Profile Image for Kayla.
97 reviews5 followers
September 3, 2026
This is my first book by Kristy Mallory and I’m SO glad I got picked to ARC read. It was so good😭 it was the perfect mix of small town romance, SPICE and investment in a baseball team. I love that Jane & Carter communicated like adults about their career goals instead of hiding their dreams from one another. And Jane being so strong to stand up to Chad? As a divorced woman how that played out was so perfect for me. Finally that ending?! I love a happy ending all tied up in a bow💜
Profile Image for The Girl Behind the Books.
18 reviews2 followers
September 15, 2026
Disclosure: I received an Advance Reader Copy (ARC) in exchange for an honest review, and all opinions expressed are entirely my own.

Some people get a second chance at love.

Some get a second chance at their dreams.

And apparently, if you're Jane Morris and Carter Cook, life decides you've suffered enough and gives you both at the same time.

Batter Up! is the kind of sports romance that reminds me why I will willingly read the same tropes a hundred times over and still lose my mind when they're done right. Friends to roommates? Yes. Friends with benefits? Absolutely. A baseball player who had no business making me this emotionally invested in his happiness? Unfortunately for me, also yes.

But somewhere between the bakery, the baseball field, two people trying to rebuild very different lives, and my increasingly concerning hatred for a fictional man named Chad, this stopped feeling like just another sports romance.

Because Batter Up! isn't really about finding someone to complete your life.

It's about rebuilding a life you're proud of, and finding someone who doesn't ask you to give it up in order to love them.

And that is exactly why I loved Jane so much.

Jane isn't introduced to us as someone waiting for a man to come along and fix everything. She's already doing the fixing herself. She's a mother, a divorcee, a business owner, and a woman trying to figure out what her life looks like when it finally belongs to her again. Her bakery isn't simply a cute setting conveniently thrown into a romance novel; it's part of the independence she's fought to create.

I particularly loved that motherhood never erased Jane the woman.

She's allowed to adore her children while still wanting things for herself. A career. Independence. Sex. Companionship. Love. A future that isn't entirely defined by being someone's mother or someone's ex-wife. And I think there's something incredibly refreshing about watching a female character realize that wanting those things doesn't make her selfish.

Especially when you consider what, and by what, I mean who, she's moving on from.

Chad.

Oh, Chad.

I don't think a fictional ex-husband has irritated me this much in a while.

But as much as I wanted to reach through my Kindle and personally tell that man to leave Jane alone, his presence serves a purpose. Because the more we understand Jane's past and the relationship she's coming from, the easier it becomes to appreciate everything Carter does differently.

And Carter Cook...

Sir.

There are MMCs you like while you're reading, and then there are MMCs who make you question why your standards for fictional men continue to become increasingly unreasonable.

Carter is firmly in the second category.

What made me fall for him wasn't one enormous romantic gesture. It was the accumulation of everything else. His presence. His patience. The familiarity already existing between him and Jane. The way their relationship gradually shifts without suddenly making them feel like completely different people.

Their chemistry doesn't appear out of nowhere just because the book needs its protagonists to fall in love. There's history underneath it. There's friendship. There's trust. And then there's attraction sitting there making the whole "friends with benefits" idea increasingly hilarious because, respectfully, who did these two think they were fooling?

Certainly not me.

That's probably one of my favorite things about Batter Up!: every stage of their relationship feels earned.

Friends becoming roommates could have simply been a convenient excuse for forced proximity. Instead, it gives them space to rediscover one another. Roommates becoming friends with benefits could have felt like a shortcut to spice. Instead, it becomes another step in an intimacy that was already developing. And when feelings inevitably enter the equation, I wasn't sitting there wondering when exactly these two had fallen in love.

I had watched it happen.

Little by little.

And that makes all the difference.

The baseball storyline deserves its flowers too, because this is actually a sports romance where the sport matters.

Carter's career isn't a uniform the author gives him because baseball players are hot, although, Kristy, I appreciate the contribution to the genre. Baseball represents something Carter has lost and desperately wants back. His return to the field, his time with the Red Rock Fliers, and his hope of making it back to the majors give him an identity and a goal completely separate from Jane.

Which is important because Jane has one too.

She has her children. Her bakery. Her home. The life she's fought to rebuild.

Carter has baseball. His comeback. The possibility of returning to the majors.

And suddenly the question isn't whether these two love each other.

It's whether love can fit into two lives that are already moving toward very different futures.
That's the kind of romantic conflict I can get behind.

Not a random misunderstanding thrown into the last 15% because apparently happiness is illegal before an epilogue. Not two adults refusing to communicate for reasons known only to the plot.

An actual conflict.

Because neither dream matters less simply because they've fallen in love.

Jane shouldn't have to abandon the stability and independence she's worked so hard to create. Carter shouldn't have to stop fighting for the career he's spent his life pursuing. And I loved that the book allowed both things to matter at the same time.

Maybe that's why the romance worked so well for me.

Neither character exists solely for the other.

They have children to care for, businesses to grow, careers to reclaim, baggage to unpack, exes I would personally like launched into the sun...

They have lives.

And then they choose to make room for each other inside them.

There's something so much more romantic about that than two characters sacrificing everything they are in the name of love.

And beyond Jane and Carter themselves, I think Kristy Mallory created exactly what I want from the beginning of a sports-romance series: a world I actually want to come back to. The Red Rock Fliers don't feel like background decoration around one couple's story. By the end, I wasn't only attached to Jane and Carter; I was already curious about what, and more importantly who, might come next.

Which is both exciting and deeply inconvenient for my TBR.

So yes, I came for the baseball romance.

I stayed for a woman rebuilding her life after divorce, a man fighting for another shot at his dream, a relationship that understood chemistry doesn't need to be rushed to be addictive, and two people discovering that a second chance doesn't necessarily mean going back to the life you had before.
Sometimes it means building something completely different.

And sometimes, apparently, it involves baseball, baked goods, forced proximity, questionable friends-with-benefits decisions, and one man named Chad testing every ounce of patience I possess.

⭐ 5/5

No notes on the rating.

Jane Morris, you deserve the world.

Carter Cook, you have officially raised the bar.

Chad...

I have nothing nice to say, so in the spirit of personal growth, I will simply move on.

Thank you so much to Kristy Mallory for trusting me with an ARC of Batter Up! Getting the opportunity to read and review a book before it enters the world will never stop feeling special to me, and I'm incredibly grateful to have been a small part of this one's journey.

Batter Up! reminded me that second chances aren't always about getting back what you lost.

Sometimes they're about realizing that what comes next can be even better.
Profile Image for Inês Ramos.
34 reviews
September 18, 2026
This is my first book about a baseball romance series. Initially, I expected the trade mechanisms to be complex and complicated, but Mallory explained them clearly enough for a non-fan. It is also dual POV so you can see what Jane and Carter are feeling in different scenes which helped learn more about both of them.

The depictions of the town, the house, the bakery, and especially the characters were never so special, allowing them to grow into something new and special.
Being a plus sized girly, it was refreshing to see that Jane gets to feel comfortable and confident in her body (which should be the normal but unfortunately it isn’t) and that made me feel even more into the storytelling and the characters lives.

Jane, The Superwoman of the Family
She is such a sweetheart! Jane loves to bake and watch baseball. Her family has been part of the baseball league since before she was born.
She is a small business owner that makes amazing treats, cakes and other confectionery products but with a twist, with baseball references.

Since her divorce with Chad, everything she has worked for has been succeeding and I truly felt like I was there, feeling what she was feeling.
She finds love again and it is something truly wonderful to see. “Carter’s praise wrapped around me like a hug. Even so, his words were almost impersonal. Safe.”
Jane, in my opinion, is the most beautiful, amazing person in this book and it truly shows as you read!

Chad, The Ex-husband
Chad is the ex-husband that has always put himself first. He preferred to spend time with others than with his family. He was in a major league for baseball so they kept moving and Jane couldn’t do anything else besides taking care of her kids, cook and clean.
He only truly cared about others if it helped him in any way possible. In the end, he was left alone, with his greed and his bad character…

Chad is the type of guy that becomes truly angry when he doesn’t get what he wants and he is truly the type of character that you’ll hate to know…
Cancel and move Chad! No one wants you here…

Carter, The Baseball Comeback
Carter was around 10 years younger than Jane and Chad. She met him when Chad took Carter under his wing. He moved in and she cooked and helped Carter with anything he would need.

He is such a kind soul, who wants to help and support others, independently of what others say.
He went to Red Rock to try to go back to the major league in Vancouver. He started playing again in The Fliers and he was always happy to teach the younger generation. Everyone in Red Rock loves him and truly wishes him a lot of success!

This is the type of guy you should fall in love with but are too scared to admit it. And I love every second we get of his pov!

Brooke and Ethan, The Amazing Kids
They are Jane’s amazing kids! Brooke is a college school and she is a caring, kind and loving young woman.
Ethan is a teenager baseball player that loves helping his mum and to play. He is caring, kind, friendly and fun!
They are the absolutely best kids that Jane could’ve ever asked for and it was so sweet sweet seeing their relationship.

Final Thoughts
I loved this book! I just can’t wait for the second of the series! I think the characters and storyline were well-thought about and everything just fits together.
If you love a romance book about baseball, baseball players and teams, love, age gaps, secret relationship with small town vibes then this book is for you!
I can’t recommend it enough!
Profile Image for Rachel B.Ocean.
38 reviews
September 15, 2026
A Heartwarming Friends-to-Lovers Sports Romance!
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐/ 5
🌶️🌶️.5 / 5

Batter Up! was such a sweet and heartfelt sports romance. I absolutely loved getting to know Jane and Carter! I’m a sucker for friends-to-lovers and some good forced proximity, so the combination of old friends, roommates, a little friends-with-benefits, and baseball had me hooked pretty quickly.

Jane was definitely one of my favorite parts of this book. She’s rebuilding her life after a difficult divorce and making her bakery a success, so all the power to her. I really loved that her story was about so much more than finding a new relationship. She’s a mother, a business owner, and a woman putting herself first.

And then there’s Carter fighting his way back to professional baseball and trying to earn another shot at the majors. I loved how supportive and thoughtful he was with Jane, especially when it came to respecting her boundaries and understanding that she had her own dreams and responsibilities. His relationship with Jane’s kids was also such a highlight for me. Carter and Ethan were just so perfect from the get-go. There was something so sweet about seeing him become part of their lives while still having his own goals and ambitions.

The romance between Jane and Carter, though, was something special. Their chemistry was immediate, but I really appreciated that their relationship didn’t feel rushed. They already had a history and friendship, so watching that slowly turn into something more felt natural. What started as a "this is temporary" situation obviously became much harder to keep casual, and I was rooting for them the whole time.

I also really appreciated the genuine and near-immediate communication between them. Jane knew that Carter was working toward getting back to the majors, and Carter knew how important her bakery and her life in Red Rock were to her. Their biggest obstacle wasn’t whether they loved each other—it was figuring out how to make room for each other without either person having to give up the life they had worked so hard to build.

The baseball aspect was another huge win for me. The sport mattered to the story rather than simply being a backdrop, which I love. Carter’s comeback, his relationship with his teammates, and his goal of returning to the majors all gave his character a purpose.

And can we talk about Chad? Because WOW. I understood very quickly why we don't like Jane’s ex. And Brooke, my girl standing her ground against him!

I also really enjoyed the small-town atmosphere and the supporting cast. I’m invested in some of the other Red Rock Fliers and definitely curious about where this series is going next. I will happily follow them into another book!

Overall, Batter Up! was a fun, emotional, and swoony romance. I, of course, loved the friends-to-lovers setup and forced proximity, but the way both characters were allowed to have dreams outside of their relationship made it that much more real and relatable. It was a great reminder that finding love doesn’t mean giving up the life you’ve worked to create, it means finding someone who wants to build a future alongside you. (Cheesy, I know!)

Thank you so much to Kristy Mallory for the gifted e-ARC!
Profile Image for Renee.
22 reviews
September 18, 2026
Batter Up

This review may contain spoilers.

Thank you to Kristy Mallory for the opportunity to read an advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review via NetGalley.

I went into this book not knowing much about the author, attracted by the cover and the promise of reading a sports romance part of a wider series, these are my favourite. I didn’t know anything about baseball and I was pleasantly surprised to read a sports romance that has actual sports in it! I had a good time with this plot-first double underdog, handsome men attempt a career redemption arc and root for a woman to succeed in business and love you should check out this book.

Jane is a woman after my own heart, we are similar in age and have a love for baked goods. I enjoyed reading about her successful bakery and her relationship with her kids as she moves on from a marriage that fell apart as a result of cheating. There was a jump scare with this ex but I won’t spoil the plot only to say, I was very mad at first to see him but the narrative deals with him in a way that means at the end all is forgiven from this reader.

Carter is a man who has layers, he is not simply the very rich male love interest but someone whose body is on the line as well as his heart. He is easy to love and reader will root for him to make the right decision for himself and of course, for love.

TLDR: things I liked
Professional Baseball player making a bid to return to the big leagues
Likable main characters
Female small business owner
Toxic ex - he really is despicable
Off page cheating, not main characters
Forced proximity with a twist and times 2
Age gap - uno reverso she is older
Women in her 40’s
Man in his 30’s
Slower burn
Romance
Second chance
Realistic sports injuries after a career at the top
No plot armour, the main characters could well fail at business, and their sporting comeback


Things I found difficult:
Baseball references! But this will be a big bonus for others
Above mentioned toxic ex, he was dangerous and awful
Profile Image for Roxs Reads.
869 reviews1 follower
October 3, 2026
The author said, “Baseball Romance,” and I said, “Sign Me Up!” Especially since this book was releasing at the end of the 2026 post-season push for the MLB. After reading the dedication, I felt an instant connection with the author and had a good feeling about reading Batter Up. This is my first book by author Kristy Mallory, and I thank her for the advance reader copy.

The story follows Carter Cook as he struggles to return to the major leagues after a devastating injury. I found this part of the story very realistic, and I easily related to Carter and envisioned him as a member of my beloved Blue Jays. The author clearly knows her way around baseball, which made the story feel authentic.

Carter’s journey back into baseball is intertwined with his budding relationship with Jane Templeton—his “friend’s” ex-wife. There’s an age gap to contend with, a messy divorce from his now-jealous and homeless ex-husband, teenage children, Jane’s growing bakery, and all the drama life can throw their way. I found the story authentic. Adults looking for love the second time around have responsibilities to put ahead of themselves. They rarely get to focus on their own relationship, and author Kristy Mallory made sure that was a prominent part of their story. But it also highlights how Jane and Carter care for each other, do special things for each other, and are the rock each needs to make life a little easier.

Jane and Carter get an amazing, well-deserved ending. I was sad to see it all end, but felt happy for them as if they had become my new friends. If you’re a fan of sports romance, especially baseball, then you should definitely pick up a copy of Batter Up.
Profile Image for Marci Crawford.
432 reviews9 followers
September 16, 2026
There’s sports ROMANCE, and then there’s SPORTS romance, and this book definitely fits into the second category. There is A LOT of sports talk.

If you’re someone who loves baseball, you’ll probably love this book. Clearly the author loves baseball, I’m just not sure if the amount of baseball comes from the author’s love of the game, the characters themselves, maybe a combination of both, 🤣 or if it’s laying the groundwork for the series, but as someone who doesn’t watch or follow baseball in general (though I do understand the game saving teens who play), there was a bit more baseball than I expected.

Despite that, there is more to the story than baseball. It’s a later-in-life, reverse age-gap romance where Jane is finding herself and learning to put herself first for once after a horrible marriage and very public divorce. Her children are growing up while still learning to cope with the abandonment issues that came from all of that.

Then there’s Carter, who is coming to terms with his limitations as a player while recovering from a life- and career-changing injury.

And then there’s Chad… well… that’s all I have to say about him. 😂

There are a lot of other characters to keep track of, which I’m sure will play bigger roles as the main characters in future books in the series.

Overall, I thought this was well written and thoughtfully put together. It’s the first book I’ve read from this author, and I wouldn’t mind going back and reading something different from her.

If you love baseball and enjoy a detailed story with a little spice sprinkled in, this could be a great read for you!

Thank you to the author for this advanced copy.

Profile Image for Sarah (TheLibrarysKeeper).
673 reviews14 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 11, 2026
A big thank you to Kristy for sending my first ever baseball romance my way! As a Blue Jays fan this was so much fun.

I loved Jane's character and how much personal growth she went through to get where she is now for herself and her kids. All the hard work she out into business has made her wildly successful and happy. From the personal side her work in therapy has allowed her to stand up for herself and fight for what she wants. I am 100% here for a FMC who knows what she wants and goes for it rather than waiting for it to drop into her lap.

So the premise of the novel is Jane has started her own bakery, adorably called Batter Up. She's working to secure a deal with the local baseball field selling her baked goods there as baseball is a huge part of her life. She is divorced from a pro baseball player and has two kids. One of which plays ball as well. In the midst of securing this deal, she runs into Carter. Who used to live with her and her ex husband back when he was a rookie.

Carter is working his way back to to the big league after a serious injury and a divorce. My only complaint with the novel comes from Carter. For most of the book it seems like he's a Ken doll whose job is baseball. He started coming around toward the end of the novel, but he just felt a little hollow before that point.

The spice was not the reason I read this book. I was here for the plot and the spice was just extra. I really appreciate when a romance novel can have plot thats well done over spice heavy books with unclear plot.
Profile Image for Sarai Mulvey.
271 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 20, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I absolutely devoured Batter Up! This was such a sweet, heartwarming sports romance, and I loved Jane and Carter together.

Jane is a recently divorced baker rebuilding her life when she reconnects with Carter, an old friend of her ex-husband who is playing AAA baseball while fighting for another chance in the majors after a devastating accident. Their chemistry was fantastic, but I especially loved how their relationship developed beyond the romance. Carter’s relationship with Jane’s kids was so sweet, and I loved how supportive and respectful he was of Jane and her boundaries.

This had so many romance elements I enjoy—friends to lovers, forced proximity, baseball, a plus-size FMC, and an age gap that really worked for me even though that trope isn't usually a favorite. I also loved the themes of second chances and realizing that it’s okay for your dreams to change. Both Jane and Carter were figuring out what they wanted their futures to look like, and their character growth made the story even more satisfying.

The baseball and baking details were also so well done. You can tell Kristy Mallory knows both, and I loved getting to know the other players along the way. The dramatic, movie-worthy ending was the perfect finishing touch.

A fun, emotional, and swoony start to the Red Rock Fliers series. I’m already looking forward to the next book—and hoping we get more of Raine!
Profile Image for Amy Kaplan.
52 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 18, 2026
I absolutely devoured this book. It's been so long since I stayed up late to finish a book, it was that good.

Batter up! By Kristy Mallory is the story of Jane, a plus size baker who is recently divorced and finally getting her life back in order. She reunites with an old friend of her ex-husbands, Carter, who is in town playing for the AAA team with hopes of being called back up to the majors after a devastating car accident nearly saw him paralyzed.

This book has all the tropes I love in a good romance - Age difference, forced proximity, sports theme, plus size main character whose body isn't important, and friends to lovers. The chemistry was undeniable (and mouth watering) and the book was written in a way that showed immense knowledge and attention to detail. It was clear the author knows baseball, and baking! The terminology and the sports knowledge was impressive.

I loved the dramatic movie-style ending and could absolutely see this made into a movie for Netflex of Amazon Prime. I also appreciated that the author introduced other players on the team organically as this appears to be the first book in a soon-to-be-series. I'll absolutely be looking out for stories about Raine especially. I think that character has a lot of potential.
Profile Image for Christine Blood.
300 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 10, 2026
An absolute home run of a sports romance!
Carter is determined to make it back to the big leagues after a devastating accident. Jane is focused on rebuilding her life and thriving with her bakery post-divorce (and of course her ex’s name is Chad). When Carter suddenly comes barreling back into Jane’s life, their chemistry is instant and electric.
What truly made this book stand out was how authentic and grounded the entire story felt. The author clearly knows baseball inside and out, crafting a sports storyline that felt completely realistic rather than far-fetched. Carter and Jane felt like genuine people, with natural dialogue, believable motivations, and distinct personal journeys as they chased their individual dreams while supporting one another. Even though I’m not typically drawn to the age-gap trope, their dynamic completely won me over—it was wonderfully sweet, deeply supportive, and delivered just the right amount of heat to keep things exciting.

If you love heartwarming small-town vibes, friends-to-lovers, and authentic sports romance, definitely add this to your TBR!

Thank you to the author for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Michele.
330 reviews
September 15, 2026
Carter is back in town with a AAA team trying to move his way back into the majors after a devastating car accident. Jane is the ex -wife of the family he stayed with when he was just getting into the league and now she lives in the same town as his new team. When a situation arises with her ex-husband, Carter steps in to help her and her family out. There is attraction right off the bat, but with the age gap and her relationship to the team, it could cause issues. But are they enough to stay away from each other?

This was a decent book. It had a good story with some family drama in it, but it showed how much Jane had grown in Carter’s eyes. With her ex, she was a pushover, but now she is a strong, independent woman running a business and being a single mother to her older children. Carter is a good guy and wants to do the right thing, but his career is everything to him. So that causes some conflict as well. There is a lot of baseball in it, which I enjoyed. There is also a lot of spice. Making up for some dry spells in their lives. 4/5⭐️5/5🌶️

I received an advanced copy of this book.
51 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 7, 2026
Jane Has Opened Up Her Own Dream Bakery Batter Up! in Her Hometown After A Messy Divorce And Reconnects With Carter, Who She First Met 10 Years Ago As A Rookie, When He Joins The Red Rock Fliers Baseball Team. I Adored This Story To Bits And Loved Jane And Carter. I Enjoyed That The Story Featured An Older Plus Size FMC But That Story Didn't Make A Big Deal Of The Age Gap (Jane Is 46 & Carter Is 34) And Has A Lot Of Body Positivity. I Enjoyed Carter's Relationship With Jane's 17 Year Old Son Ethan And How Carter Helped Him Home His Baseball Skills. All The Mentions Of Jane's Baked Goods Especially The Player Themed Cookies Were Fabulous And Made Me Hungry. The Writing Style Is Very Easy To Read And Fast-Paced And Very Bingable. The Story Had Just The Right Amount Of Spice Interwoven With The Sweet Romance. I Can't Wait To Read The Next Book In The Red Rock Fliers Series, I'm Looking Forward To The Other Players Stories, Especially Raine's.

Thank You To NetGalley And The Publisher For The ARC.
15 reviews
September 23, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I absolutely loved Batter Up! by Kristy Mallory—if you love sports romance with incredible heat and a swoon-worthy age gap, this is a total home run!

Why this book was fantastic:

The Tropes: Younger baseball player x older baker heroine, age gap (10+ years), small-town vibe, and temporary/expiration-date romance tension. The Spice: The chemistry between Jane and Carter was off-the-charts hot! The spice in this book was so, so good and kept the pages turning.
The Plot: Jane is focused on expanding her bakery after a tough divorce and definitely isn't looking for love. Enter Carter—a minor league baseball player a decade younger who is only in town temporarily. Watching them fall hard despite knowing his time in Red Rock is limited made their connection so sweet and high-stakes.

It’s packed with actual baseball action, amazing heat, and a romance that will leave you smiling.

Easily a 5-star read for me! Thank you to Harbourview Publishing and NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Cheyenne Klapperich.
4 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 27, 2026
ARC Review
This was my first Kristy Mallory book and I can’t wait for the next! (I see it’s Red Rock Fliers #1… 👀)

I loved Jane and Carter’s individual stories— but I loved the way the two intertwined even more! Carter was so supportive to Jane, whether it was in the bakery or defending her from Chad, he was a constant positive light.

Chad was a major snooze (duh his name is Chad) and wholly frustrated me (Seriously Chad, grow up) but his character involvement was important for the plot.

Seeing Jane reaching her dreams with the bakery was so so special. And with her kids, friends, and man by her side?! LOVE.

I love a good sports romance even if I’m not a sporty gal— but some of the lingo was over my head so I definitely called on my husband for his knowledge lol

Small town, age gap, friends to lovers, sports romance— a perfect combination. I look forward to seeing how the rest of the series (🤞🏻🤞🏻🤞🏻) plays out.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Tasha.
2,436 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 14, 2026
Batter Up! by Kristy Mallory is a fun, heartwarming start to the Red Rock Fliers series. I really enjoyed the combination of romance, baseball, and characters who felt genuine and relatable. The story had a great balance of sweet romantic moments, emotional depth, and lighter scenes that kept me turning the pages. I especially liked watching the characters grow and navigate their relationships while taking chances on new beginnings. The baseball setting added an energetic and entertaining backdrop without taking away from the romance. Mallory did a wonderful job creating characters you can root for, and by the end, I was already curious about the other people introduced throughout the story. It’s an easy, enjoyable read with plenty of heart. Overall, Batter Up! was a fun first book in the series, and I’m looking forward to seeing what comes next!

I received an ARC copy from NetGalley. Thank you for giving me the chance to read this novel and share my honest review of the novel
Profile Image for Eirena Ewert.
110 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 9, 2026
ARC Review

Cute story regarding two divorcees reconnecting. He gets signed with a triple-A team that’s based in her hometown, while she moved back to her hometown and started a bakery following her divorce from a nasty man. Said nasty man keeps popping up and is a problem often. Current ball player moves in with bakery owner/single mom to avoid nasty man from living in her spare bedroom. Of course they start to fall for each other, but how can they continue on when he might be called up and she wants to continue her bakery dream?

This book felt slow to me and I even considered DNF’ing at about 78% because it seemed like they had stuff mostly resolved, which wasn’t true so I was glad that I kept going. There was just a lot of extra fluff that didn’t seem necessary to the story and kept it slow for me.
Profile Image for Fernanda Serna.
54 reviews
September 9, 2026
ARC Review 📖✨

So happy I was picked to ARC read this book! This is my first Kristy Mallory book, and I’ll definitely be reading her other books!

Batter Up! was an amazing book. The way it balances the story, the spice, and the context it gives you is just perfect!!

I have to be honest, I don’t know a thing about baseball, but other than some abbreviations that were used, you don’t need to know anything about the sport to understand the story!

What to expect: A love story involving two mature adults, a self-love lesson, a story of resilience, and an awesome way of intertwining everything!

The ending was happily unexpected (but kinda predictable? lol), and I wish it hadn’t felt so rushed!

I can’t wait for the next book in the series, and I hope we get to see a glimpse of what Jane and Carter’s future looks like!!
Profile Image for Cheryl.
2,552 reviews71 followers
September 21, 2026
Spicy baseball romance

All Jane Morris is looking for is a way to keep her bakery business healthy and maybe expand it. She's definitely not looking for romance. And even if she was looking for romance after a disastrous divorce, it wouldn't be with Carter Cook who is over ten years younger than her and only in Red Rock, Alberta temporarily playing minor league baseball until he's called to the major leagues.

But it's funny how the heart works. Both Jane and Carter fall hard for each other knowing that the relationship probably isn't going anywhere. But it's funny how things work out for the best.

This was an excellent romance. You need to like baseball, though. Full of baseball and spicy content.

I received this Digital Review Copy from Harbourview Publishing through NetGalley. Thank you.
Profile Image for Karen R.
55 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 23, 2026
(ARC provided in exchange for an honest review)

​
​Batter Up! by Kristy Mallory was such a charming read! As a huge minor league baseball fan, I absolutely loved all the detailed nuances of minor league baseball woven into the story.

Carter’s journey as he works his way back to the major leagues after a devastating accident was written with so much heart and determination—you can't help but root for him every step of the way.

​On the other side of the dynamic, watching Jane bring her dreams to life with her bakery was just as wonderful to follow. The balance between sports grit and sweet, hard-earned dreams made this book stick out. A fantastic romance with dual ambition and great character growth!
Profile Image for Holley Cuppia.
159 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 25, 2026
This was a fabulous first read for me by Kristy Mallory! Carter and Jane were definitely a sweet couple! There were so many things going in this story. Jane is a plus sized woman who’s had to rebuild her life after a divorce from her pro-ball-playing husband. She returns home and builds the life she wants. Along comes Carter, who she knew previously when he was more of a child, in her eyes. Carter is not a child anymore! Jane has more serious things to take care of with no time for a dalliance with someone so much younger than she. But Carter is not a child anymore! There’s so much to lose if a relationship was found out. But so much to gain.

This story has the age gap, plus-sized heroine, and a guy who knows what a woman needs, regardless of her age.
Profile Image for Hannah Myers.
232 reviews2 followers
September 12, 2026
A fun easy read! I love baseball & love when books are based around it. My favorite thing ab the alternative povs was that each chapter picked up INSTANTLY after the last from the other person’s pov, nooo time skip lol I really think Julio Hernandez was the unsung hero, what a guy. Loved Emily & Jane’s other friends too. I do feel like we could’ve tied up the end a little more w Ethan’s thoughts ab Carter coming home, etc but overall, I thought it was a really sweet luv story with some fun spice haha so excited for this to be released so you all can read it! I received an ARC from Kristy Mallory; thank you for the opportunity to be an early reader!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Michelle.
18 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy
August 25, 2026
ARC READER - I was given this book as an ARC in exchange for a review.

I did not know exactly what I was getting into when I signed up to be an ARC Reader. I know a little bit about baseball, but not too much. I think the thing that I liked most is how immersed into the story I got. I loved how Jane and Carter got their happy endings after everything that happened to them - even if it was in completely different ways!. I also loved how relatable Jane was. But also the spice - amazing.


So if you like baseball, spice, second chances, and happy ending - give this a read!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Becky Whitney Manuzzi .
369 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 15, 2026
Thank you Kristy Mallory for the chance to read this as an ARC. This review is honest and voluntary.

This was a cute baseball romance to read with (mostly) likable characters. I loved that the FMC was independent and was pitting herself before any man, it was refreshing to read in a romance. My only gripe was how the smut was written. It was too detailed for my liking, but if you wanna know every single detail, this book is for you!

I defs think this is the perfect fall read as baseball season wraps up!
Profile Image for Emily.
161 reviews7 followers
September 21, 2026
Thoroughly enjoyed this- especially with Jane being middle-aged- its nice to read a story where the characters are closer to my age than fresh out of school! The past friendship helped pave the way for their future- and while there was an age gap, it didnt feel like too much emphasis was put on that. I'm a sucker for sports romance- and while baseball is not my typical sport I read (as I don't follow it in general mich passed being aware how my local MLB team is doing)- it didnt lessen my enjoyment even when reading about the sport (very central to the story!)
Profile Image for Leah Nelson.
86 reviews
September 30, 2026
Jane a single mother, with 2 kids, who just went through a nasty, high profile divorce. When her ex husband shows up and all but demands she let him move back in after losing his job, Jane panics and says that she found a tenant already. Carter has just moved back to town to join their baseball team and shortly after, gets dragged into this. He's a good sport, plays along with it and even moves in. He's an upstanding guy. He's sweet, thoughtful and the complete opposite of her ex husband. Thank you to Kristy for the advanced copy of this book, I loved it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews