No one in Boston hires mad workhouse girls suspected of murder. So they've packed me off to the mountains of North Carolina to serve a house full of secrets. Here, ghost lights flicker through tall trees. Voices whisper from empty corners. Children walk into the woods and never return. And the master of the house? They say he's man with coal for eyes. A devil in a banker's suit. And ... he'll be home soon.
...............................................
‘A Vow For Breaking,’ is a forbidding, standalone novel steeped in Appalachian lore, inherited curses, and a backwoods mansion brimming with otherworldly terror.
Set in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina, this dark fairy tale follows Sloane McIntyre, a Boston-born workhouse girl and suspected murderess, who is sent away to serve a rich man and his ailing wife. But what begins as a promising new start curdles into something far more sinister. Sloane soon finds herself drawn into a labyrinth of horrors only a demon could survive.
Gothic, eerie, and emotionally sharp, A Vow for Breaking will appeal to readers of Appalachian folk horror, historical gothic fiction, and haunting fables where nothing is as it seems … and almost everything is hungry.
With lyrical menace and atmospheric depth, author L.M. Riviere delivers a chilling story of suspicion, confinement, and the monstrous things we keep locked inside.
L.M. Riviere is the author of the epic fantasy series 'The Innisfail Cycle', the historical fairy tale 'A Dark Most Fair,' and the Appalachian folk horror 'A Vow For Breaking.' She has another folk horror titles due for release in 2026.
She is obsessed with hot coffee, hiking, and refusing to wear 'real pants' in public. She lives in Appalachia.
Short, satisfying, and so much deeper than its page count suggests. This one had me hanging on every word and chewing my nails as the horror and mystery deepened into something filled with terror and rage.
Sloane has been let down by the world at every single turn and she stands against it anyway, with the help of her historical, generational, literal monster. I cannot believe how much I came to love a morally black monster, but here we are. Their dynamic is one of the best things about this and I adored every second of it.
The gothic atmosphere is fantastic. The historical context around Irish hatred of the era is touched on perfectly and is often overlooked. It adds historical and metaphorical weight to Sloane's story and makes the rage underneath it feel completely earned.
The ending was a little too neat for my tastes because I love a little more open endings in my horror, but I'm genuinely splitting hairs here because I had a great time with this one. Dark, fascinating, and I will absolutely be reading more from this author.
Thanks to the author and Booksirens for the complimentary review copy. This review is voluntary and all opinions are my own.
It's a brilliant book – I devoured it (pun intended) – and I particularly loved the black, dark, humour. Sloane reminded me of Shirley Jackson’s Merricat; Sloane too thrives on isolation; coming from a dysfunctional family, she is sent to the Magdalen workhouse, where they are ‘mad as me..'[ red.], where she has a small room in the east wing, ‘with the rest of the nutters.’[red.] Her tulpa helps her, like killing her ‘rotten, murdering, abusive pustule of a father… '[red.]
Following her father’s death, the youngest children are taken in by an uncle and aunt, whilst Sloane is sent off to work as a maid for R.P. Harwood, who lives in North-Caronlina. Once she arrives at the big house, she is taken on as a servant by the lady of the house. She is instructed never to leave her room at night. "Some beasts hunt in these halls at night..." [red.] I stayed up all night reading it and enjoyed every single line – I could have devoured the book! What a wonderful book and what a beautiful tale! It ticked all the boxes for me and I love love stories like these! I found that the 'red door' in Sloane's story draws parallels with my favourite book, Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë, in which Jane undergoes a 'supernatural experience' in 'the red room', where 'a rushing of wings' drives her to hysteria.
Sloane befriends Philomena, the first person who can also see her tulpa. A catharsis unfolds when the Master of the House arrives and Sloane and Philomena have to run for their lives. I thought the ending, in which feminism triumphs over the patriarchal world of power and money, was almost movingly beautiful; Sloane’s is a story of toil and growth – from an abusive childhood to finding a place in society and leaving the past behind.
Stunning, and a moving tale of toil and growth. 5 stars. I would love to read more from this author. Thank you Booksirens for the review copy.
A Vow for Breaking masterfully depicts a historical horror in a haunting and thrilling light. Riviere exposed the ugly realities many women face, while also integrating a gripping folklore element. The voice is so relatable that the reader is almost having a conversation with Sloane.
This book got me hooked from the first page to the last. I read it all in 4 days! I read the whole Harwood house escape sequence in one sitting. Especially considering the length, the plot and characterization were fleshed out beautifully. I was rooting for Sloane the whole way through.
So many books in the overall genres of fantasy, folklore, dark horror, etc. make the main characters as beautiful as possible, even if it doesn’t fit the context. Riviere provided a realistic description of Sloane while also making her likable. Hollywood needs to take notes — your characters don’t need to be drop-dead gorgeous to be worthy of a story.
My favorite scene was the train encounter. The introduction set the stage looking meager and without hope. I teared up when the old woman was so kind to Sloane; it’s a support that all girls in similar situations should have. The themes of hierarchy and injustice balance well with the fantastical elements. Most of all, I appreciated the ending. It wasn’t necessarily a happy one, but it was REAL. It draws attention to what’s true both in history and in today’s world: life is not always fair.
The only “criticism” I have is that I want to know more! I felt Sloane truly cared for Dandy. However, throughout the book he was missing so often that the reader doesn’t have a chance to bond with him. Given, he IS literally a demon, but Sloane’s compassion for him could have been better understood with more Dandy characterization.
Overall, this was a thrilling and intriguing book, and I’m excited to explore the rest of Riviere’s work.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I want to thank Book Sirens and the author for the e-ARC.
A Vow for Breaking follows Sloane, a poor workhouse girl from Boston who is sent to the Blue Ridge Mountains to serve in a wealthy, isolated house after being suspected of murder. What seems like a chance at survival slowly turns into something far more sinister, with strange rules, whispered warnings, and the sense that the house is hiding something hungry.
This was such a stunning, haunting read. I went in for the gothic atmosphere, and it absolutely delivered, but what stayed with me most was how much the story had to say beneath all that darkness.
This is not just a story about a strange house, hungry woods, and things lurking in the shadows. It is also about human suffering, survival, and the horrible choices people are pushed into when the world gives them no safe option. Sloane’s situation carries so much weight because she is not only trying to protect herself, but also to take care of her siblings. That constant pressure follows her everywhere. What does she owe them? What does she owe herself? How much danger can a person accept if the alternative is starvation, abandonment, or worse? I really liked how the story sat with that dilemma instead of making survival feel simple.
Sloane herself was one of my favorite parts. She is sharp, guarded, angry, and exhausted in a way that felt very real. She had to grow teeth because softness alone would not have kept her alive. But she is not cold. That is what made me care about her so much. Even when she is afraid, even when she is suspicious, even when she is making impossible choices, there is still something deeply human in her.
And Dandy? I did not expect to become attached to a terrifying, morally black little menace, but here we are. He is monstrous, yes, but his bond with Sloane added such a strange and fascinating layer to the story. Their dynamic was dark, unsettling, sometimes funny, and honestly one of the things I enjoyed most.
The gothic atmosphere was beautifully done. The house, the rules, the woods, the whispers, the sense that something is always waiting just out of sight, all of it pulled me in completely. I also loved how the book plays with the idea of consumption. Women being used, worked, discarded, hunted, swallowed by systems and by monsters. The metaphor becomes literal in such a chilling way, and that made the horror hit harder.
The heroine in A Vow for Breaking by L.M. Riviere is Sloane McIntyre, a sharp, smart, poor young Irish woman from Boston who has inherited a demon as a constant companion - whether she wants him or not - and thanks to her witch ancestor, he doesn’t have much choice either. Orphaned and with 5 younger siblings to help support, she is on her way from the workhouse to be a maid in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina. As a narrator, Sloane is forthright, funny, and relatable. Even as she tells us about her demon and what he’s done, she questions her own sanity. And she isn’t so sure her story will be relatable to everyone. She tells us not to bother reading if we’ve never been so poor we don’t understand how desperate it can make you because she’s not going to take time to explain it or make excuses about choices she’s made - or things she’s asked or allowed her demon, which she calls Dandy, to do. The chills really start as she travels to Harwood House and hears not only eerie Appalachian lore but several warnings about the house and family, and it may be a good thing she has a supernatural protector, however problematic he may be. A Vow for Breaking was a chilling Appalachian folk horror and a lot of fun to read. You’ll want to set aside a few hours for reading because it’s hard to put down once you start. (I assume…I didn’t even try.) Thanks to the author and Burnt Leaf Press for the advance copy for my unbiased review. Pub. Date: May 1, 2026
I absolutely loved this author's last book, A Dark Most Fair, but after reading this one, L.M. Riviere will be an instant buy for me from now on.
A Vow for Breaking had me hooked from the first page. The reader is foisted into the dark and unfortunate world of Sloane McIntyre, a resilient and determined young woman, plagued not only by circumstance, but a supernatural inheritance she cannot be rid of. At the bleakest moment of her life, she is given the opportunity to work as a lady's maid in the home of a wealthy gentleman in North Carolina--a job simply too good to be true for someone from the Boston slums with little to no experience. It doesn't take long for Sloane to see not only the cracks in the job offer, but the home's foundation, with the looming arrival of its owner, a spectral lady-of-the-house, a suspicious housemaid, ravenous entities lurking in every dark corner, and a list of past maids who had left their employment under mysterious--and perhaps diabolical circumstance.
I was thrilled to receive an ARC copy of A Vow for Breaking. I gobbled this read up. Gorgeous prose. Spot on atmosphere. Enticing plot twists. Strong characters. Lasting imagery. I cannot say enough. If you enjoy dark and haunting historical fiction with a twist of horror, this read is for you. L.M. Riviere just gets better and better.
LM Riviere continues to be such a wonderfully unique writer, who takes swings and goes places without fear. I've read her Innisfail Cycle trilogy and now this, so I can see the breadth of her work. It's beautiful and gory, which is exactly how I like it.
A Vow for Breaking is a great horror debut (I think it's her first horror?) from her. It builds up dread with its mystery so well. Sloane is a fantastic MC with a great ensemble for allies and enemies. I particularly loved her relationship with her demon, Dandy. There's surprising humor in that duo, with a lot of complexity woven into that relationship. The payoff is brutal and satisfying, and what I may expect from her as she knows how to slowly build up to deliver an awesome final act.
It's less that the book has issues, but more of how I feel after reading the Innisfail Cycle books. She writes incredible characters. AVFB has great characters, but there's a level of complexity that was in her other work that I wanted out of it. They are layered and complex, but there's some finer details and nuances that I still longed for.
I received a free ARC by the author in exchange for a free, honest review. My opinions are my own.
The cover hit my spooky, gothic soul before I even read a single word of the premise. But once I did? I was vibrating with excitement. This book has everything I love: a dark fairy tale atmosphere, a historical Appalachian setting, and a resilient woman persevering through hardship.
Everything I hoped this book would be going in, it absolutely delivered. I was pulled into the story from page one, so it became impossible to stick to my 25 pages a day goal. This is a book you devour in one sitting. I ended up reading straight through the night, when the finale hit, just to see how it all ended.
This tale is the epitome of hunger—the idea that the world and the people around you are constantly trying to take, feast, and devour, whether they are literal monsters or not. It's a story about being the hero of your own narrative and defeating the beasts that try to tear you down. Although this isn't a slasher, I still consider Sloane McIntyre my kind of final girl.
Even with the few hiccups I discovered, Riviere's storytelling is so lovely. I'll definitely be looking at more books by her!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Thank you to L. M. Riviere and BookSirens for the ARC — all thoughts are my own. I went into A Vow For Breaking without really knowing what to expect, and I think that made the reading experience even better. This wasn’t the kind of horror story I had in mind going in, but it absolutely delivered in its own way. The pacing worked really well for me — I ended up reading this much faster than anticipated because the structure and buildup kept pulling me in. There’s a strong sense of tension throughout the story, and the twist genuinely caught my attention. One of the highlights for me were the characters. They felt realistic and I appreciated how the book explored personal boundaries and how different they can be from person to person. It also doesn’t shy away from showing what happens when those limits are crossed, which added an extra layer to the story. If I had one critique, it would be the ending. Compared to how strong and engaging the rest of the book was, it felt a bit underwhelming. Overall, though, this was a very enjoyable and gripping read that I would definitely recommend — especially if you’re looking to get more into horror like I am.
A murderous entity that’s passed down through the family? Yes please 💁🏻♀️
The tone of the story is set from chapter one: “This is not a tale for soft, happy children bred for sunshine.”
If you loved the melancholic, dark humour and gothic vibes of A Series of Unfortunate Events as a child, then this is definitely for you.
This had all the ingredients for a book I’m going to become mildly obsessed with. I was hooked from chapter one and “devoured” it 😉
The story follows Sloan, who has faced unfortunate circumstances her entire life, and Derby, a demon bound to her through a generational deal.
Derby was SUCH a vibe. A murderous vibe… but still. Despite being a literal demon, there is something weirdly lovable about him 😂 He reminded me of a pet cat at times and I loved the descriptions of his different forms.
Can we also take a moment to appreciate the cover art?! The creepy vibes are on point.
I thoroughly enjoyed this and will definitely be reading more of LM Riviere’s work.
5/5 stars
Thank you to BookSirens and Burnt Leaf Press for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
A Vow For Breaking might be Riviere's most unsettling tale yet (and my favorite!) and that's saying something. From its cold horror open in the slums of an industrial revolution era Boston, this story centers a cursed young woman and her mysterious and compounding misfortunes as she manages to move from workhouse to manor life to the depths of hell.
Sloane's family curse has left anyone to cross her--and all hope at supporting her starving younger siblings--dead in her wake. When her only prospect takes her deep into the NC wilderness, she finds the demons of her new estate home may be more powerful, more haunting, and more deadly than the one bound to her. Here is a complex dissection of class, history, folklore, and Appalachian tradition, all tightly packaged in a fast-paced horror.
This story has deep roots you can feel, with subtle nods to familiar folk tales recast in a landscape as alive as its monsters. Highly recommended to those who want to be entertained, unsettled, and in the end, haunted by what hides beneath the veneer.
A Vow for Breaking is a stunning short story that transcends the allegory of consumption and turns metaphor into reality. We begin in the not-so-distant past, watching as young women are fed to the insatiable machine of industrialization. Worked and abused until they're empty husks, it's made clear that the next step is either starvation or feeding the more base appetites of man in the form of prostitution. In an attempt to subvert this outcome, Sloane instead ends up facing a monster offering that same fate but in a far more literal sense.
I appreciate that the author didn't shy away from the more lurid details and descriptions, while also not dwelling on the horrors unnecessarily. It helped reinforce the lack of safety our protagonist was already accustomed to, the relative natures of horror and pain, as well as the reality of what survival looks like when life has been a shitshow since day 1.
I also enjoyed that we don't end on a perfect happily ever after, thank you.
Very well written. Descriptive, First POV, found family/relationship. Would not say this book was a slow burn but more of a mid burn with a bang of a mid ending with a very well deserved end. The story is written from the Main characters POV as she tells it, but as she writes her life story without it being in your face that it's a main life event story. The horror concepts within the book are well written and off putting at times. There are some heart wrenching parts that might bring a tear to the eyes, or a gasp. This book was really hard to put down. My only issue was that I wish that there was shorter and a few more chapters so that there are a few more places to take a break and think over what was just read. I really liked the writing style and will be looking into more of this authors books in the future. Thank you to the author and publisher for letting me read this book as an ARC. I really enjoyed the book.
What an exceptional Story! The world building felt truly accurate. The main character, Sloane, has a relatable depth. The setting is in both Boston and the Blue Ridge Mountains. LM Rivire builds everything well. So, you can really feel the place and time without it becoming an unrelatable period peice. The story moves at a good pace and I never found myself drifting. I really really enjoyed the characters! There was just enough trope to keep them familiar and more than enough variation for them to be interesting. I always felt a sense of hope, fear, adventure, discovery, and change. The ending felt appropriate while still carrying all those emotions along to the end.
Full disclosure, I contacted LM.R for a copy when she announced the new book. She asked the publisher to send me a copy. Certainly appreciated.
Full Disclosure: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thank you BookSirens!
I devoured this book in two days (choice of words intentional). It started strong, hooked me immediately and then did not disappoint. I love Dandy, I'm probably not supposed to be so obsessed with an unlikable character but I am. The FMC, is tough but vulnerable, tenacious while scared and very complex, everything a strong FMC needs. Hunting down more books by Riviere.
This was an ARC read and I loved it! The characters were likeable, funny, mysterious, and horrifying. The scenery was both picturesque and haunting, which made it easy to picture everything in my head as I was reading. This is why I love being an ARC reader. Exploring different genres of books in exciting and if you’re looking for an exciting book, definitely get this one!
A Vow for Breaking by LM Riviere is a chilling, gothic folk horror following Sloane McIntyre, a suspected murdereress, as she is sent away to work for a rich man and his sickly wife.
A quick read, I was immediately sucked into the dark and chilling tale of twists, turns and where nothing is as it seems.
Be sure to check the trigger warnings before diving in. Your mental health matters.
A new dark fantasy horror from a master of twisty new fairy tales.
I quite liked this one. It moves along quickly, no extraneous side stories. Just our heroine discovering exactly what kind of horror she’s agreed to in the hopes of supporting her younger siblings.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This was such a cool spooky tale that really ramps up as you read until I could not put it down when I hit the second half. It hit all the right notes for me and there are some scenes that will live in my head for a long time. Definitely recommend.
L.M. Riviere's writing just sucks me right into the story, leaving me with my jaw on the floor. Every time I thought I knew where the story was going, I'd turn the page, and find my theories were wrong. Even though he was a monster, I loved Dandy. He cared for our girl Slone; in his own way.