A hilarious, glittering, pop-noir thriller about a rising musician and her new BFF, the secretly psychotic popstar who brought her on tour
Gretchen McMurphy was playing bingo halls and dive bars until a fitness influencer used her breakup anthem to help followers get a better booty, and now she’s landed her dream gig—opening for iconic pop star Fae Deeds.
Suddenly Gretchen has things she’s not used to having: a sizeable income, screaming fans, bottled water preferences, and a friend who understands the pressures of the music industry, the daily battle of being a woman in the public eye, and what it feels like to have every man you’ve ever loved hurt you.
Fae really gets it. Fae knows. Fae has developed her own tools for dealing with these issues—and it’s not good coping skills or proper meditation. It’s much, much sharper than that. And pretty soon Gretchen must decide what (and who) she’s willing to sacrifice for fame.
Razor-sharp and riotously funny, The First Cut is the Deepest by Mindy McGinnis is a deliciously unhinged thrill ride down the music industry’s darkest alleys.
Mindy McGinnis is an Edgar Award-winning novelist who writes across multiple genres, including post-apocalyptic, historical, thriller, contemporary, mystery, and fantasy.
While her settings may change, you can always count on Mindy’s books to deliver grit, truth, and an unflinching look at humanity and the world around us.
What do you mean one of my fave (and IMO underrated to the general public) YA authors of thrillers/feminist rage suspense has an adult debut coming out and nobody told me?!!?
Truly though The Female of the Species is a must-read while you wait for this one if i had to just pick one.
Why is this book so funny, witty, and full of twists and turns? The First Cut is the Deepest by Mindy McGinnis is everything all rolled into one. It is simultaneously dark and hilarious. I enjoyed the quirky characters and fast paced story telling.
Gretchen is a rough around the edges, up-and-coming musician that is discovered and finds herself opening for the one and only Fae Deeds, a pop princess icon of the ages. Fae understands everything Gretchen is going through: pressures of the industry, the struggles of being a woman in the public eye, and what it is like for a man to hurt you.
This novel is a reader’s backstage pass to a raucous musical, murderous ride. I loved it. The relationship between Gretchen and Fae, while outrageous, feels so realistic at the same time. In the fore front is female friendship, empowerment, with a side of revenge. But don’t get it twisted, this is not the type of friendship anyone wants!
And the ending… oh my goodness, a real gasp escaped me. I didn’t see it coming and that made me love it even more. I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough.
The best part of this entire book was when I deleted it. I’m curious if the author is always like this or if this was just a special occasion.
Everything went hard on SHOCK just for the sake of shock factor. It’s overly vulgar and raunchy without any good reason behind it.
We get garbage right out of the gate, within the first 2% Gretchen had already talked about her breasts and/or ass like six times. First time she meets Fae she’s sharing “eyeball bacteria” First time she meets her new manager she’s talking about not getting laid in months and her dildo being ate by a monster.
It’s been a quite a while since I’ve found a FMC this damn insufferable. At one point she prides herself on how loud and inappropriate she is. She belches, she casually makes anal jokes. She’s ✨ unapologetically herself ✨ Everything was so out of pocket, it just dripped with how snappy, quirky and “cool girl” she thought she was. She had one facet to her personality and that doesn’t make for a very interesting or likable main character.
Nothing happens for the first 25% of the book except Gretchen running her mouth. Once the plot kicked in it made her *slightly* more tolerable because there were other things going on beyond Gretchen doing Gretchen stuff.
Fae was slightly less irritating. She had her “hobby” and we see Fae on a few occasions tell massive lies to the public just for attention or to spite someone. She had a little more dimension to her. I think she would have been a more interesting character to be in the mind of even if her stupidity about keeping her mouth shut knew no bounds.
Gretchen’s mom was written so weirdly. We see her doing/talking about things that are things one would think of someone elderly might do or easily fall for and then we get told her mom is 42. Excuse me… Millennials are not out there using their SSNs as a username or giving strangers remote access to their phones and thus getting scammed. She didn’t know what “lol” meant and has to get an explanation on emojis… Author managed to create a 42 year old Boomer.
I suffered through all of this ridiculousness to get an ending even MORE ridiculous.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for this advance copy. Opinions are my own.
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC of The First Cut Is the Deepest. This book is an absolute fever dream. Gretchen is a struggling singer-songwriter who catches her big break when one of her songs goes viral in a workout influencer's video. Suddenly she's opening for Fae Deeds: the biggest pop star in America, a glittering, beloved icon who may or may not be an actual fae creature. She's also a prolific serial killer. What follows is Gretchen being dragged—often against her better judgment—into a world of celebrity excess, obscene wealth, manufactured perfection, and post-concert murder sprees. The prose is hysterically funny. If dark humor is your thing, this book feels like the emotional support Xanax you crush into your morning coffee just to survive another day in late-stage capitalism. Mindy McGinnis somehow makes you adore every character involved in this trainwreck—including Fae, who absolutely should not be as lovable as she is. You know this story is heading somewhere gruesome, but you can't look away. A few highlights: "No, it's just that all my best thoughts come out of my vagina." "You drank soap, stole my contact, talked about your vagina, burped at me, and made it abundantly clear you've checked out my boyfriend more than once... You're perfect. I love you." "I've got twenty thousand new followers, a couple hundred texts and DMs, plus a blood alcohol level that might be reaching double digits." And somehow it only gets more unhinged from there. This book had me snort-laughing, jump-scared, seething with righteous fury while cheering for female rage, and equipped me with more comebacks than pornhub. It's chaotic, hilarious, vicious, and weirdly heartfelt. Read it.
4 1/2 easy to read, funny, little raunchy not for the straitlaced, faint of heart as the main character is hell on wheels with a thoughts like a sailor at sea. This is dark as well as funny as it gives a backstage view of rising fame and psychotic tendencies. Gretchen McMurphy is pulled from obscurity when an influencer uses one of her songs, and now she’s landed her dream gig—opening for iconic pop star Fae Deeds, who has been in the spotlight since she was a child. She is used to everything given to her, seems to know the monetary value of nothing-will just throw money at it, and has quite a dark side if you cross her. At the same time, Gretchen now has things she has never fathomed such as screaming fans, hot bassist, disposable income, and personal assistant that can get anything she wants --some of those wants are entertaining, code words the assistant will know what she up to --backstage antics Gretchen is like Lorelai of Gilmore Girls--always with some sort snarky retort. I found them entertaining, the explanations about her past love life and family drama added to this twisted tale. Gretchen's off color remarks contrast with Fae's unicorns and rainbow attitude. The bond the two create in the most interesting way (no spoilers) is also entertaining. While Fae has her rainbow attitude, don't cross her. For example, perhaps her ex-boyfriend really didn't cheat on her but rather became the butt of a smear campaign engineered by Fae. And the end, great twist Thank you to NetGalley, Penguin Random House, and the author Mindy McGinnis, for the opportunity to read and devour this book in advance.
Received a copy on NetGalley in exchange for an honest review ✨
3.5 rounded up bc why not
This book was like if Daria was R-rated, I could see fans of Rachel Harrison liking this as well. I found it fun overall, it was an easy read, and I liked the touch of the interview inserts at the start of the chapters.
My issues were that the dialogue early on felt forced/trying too hard to convince us Gretchen is “not like other girls”, to the point of cringe; it lessens in the latter half of the book and is a lot more enjoyable. I DID like the ending, but I personally don’t care for the type of twist this book had.
This was a dark, fun read. I was super into it, until I wasn’t though. But I think that’s just a personal thing for me because I hate implausible convenience for the sake of plot. And the dialogue got a bit cringe near the end. Overall, it was ok! And the end was pretty gnarly in a good way. Thanks to NetGalley for this ARC!
This is absolutely bananas and also absolutely delightful. I enjoyed nearly every minute, and the minutes I did not enjoy were when it was obvious that this was pushed very quickly and they decided to be sloppy with editing in order to speed things up. The biggest problem is Gretchen's mom is characterized by her bumbling and silliness, which would be fine, except the biggest joke about her is that classic "my Boomer ass parents think LOL means 'lots of love,'" which would work except that the book takes place NOW and Gretchen EXPLICITLY says "My mom is 42." That's a Millennial! That is my peer! We do not think LOL means "lots of love," we make fun of older people thinking that and the Zoomers make fun of us for using it at all! COME ON. Also, just lots of sloppy things like "bourgeoise" instead of "bourgeoisie," claiming there's a Ritz Carlton in Tucson which is only true if you are talking about the greater Tucson metro area (it's in Dove Mountain, which is a helluva schlep from Tucson Tucson and would be an absolutely terrible place to stay if you were playing a show in Tucson, and also a Taylor Swift-sized artist wouldn't do both Tucson and Phoenix on a tour even though we Tucsonans would all love that so we don't have to drive two hours in a straight line each direction just to go to a goddamn concert) and not Tucson proper, and other typos and simple errors that may seem inconsequential but in totality add up to laziness in the drafting and editorial process.
I did think the Big Twist was blunt and a touch too quick yet also the right way to end things, but the way it was executed is also in line with other books of this ilk, so I can't really take too much issue with it, though I do think it calls into question some earlier moments that no longer hold up when you are given new information. I also wish I had gotten a final bit of followup and closure with , because that whole thing felt uncomfortably unfinished.
Overall, however, like I said, completely bananas and completely fun and nearly exactly what I was promised. Would I have liked a little more awareness of race and not just class, to really hone in on the Taylor Swift parallels? Sure, but I also wouldn't want a white woman attempting to handle that because I have yet to come across a white lady novelist who is capable of both good novel writing AND actual good racial analysis, so better left lightly mentioned, I guess.
I really enjoyed the premise of this book! A Taylor Swift-esque pop star who also happens to be a serial killer? Sign me up.
The story follows Gretchen McMurphy, an up-and-coming musician who gets the opportunity to open for superstar Fae Deeds. Fae takes Gretchen under her wing, but Gretchen eventually discovers that her new mentor has a rather murderous secret.
I thought the beginning was entertaining and had a lot of momentum. Unfortunately, somewhere along the way, the story started to lose me. The concept was fun, and I liked the idea of a beloved pop star secretly taking justice into her own hands, but I found myself becoming less invested as the story progressed. There were some interesting twists, but they didn't quite have the impact I was hoping for.
I did like both Gretchen and Fae as characters, although neither particularly stood out to me. They were entertaining enough to follow, but I never felt especially attached to either of them, which probably contributed to my waning interest as the story went on.
Overall, this was a decent read with an entertaining premise that I wish had held my attention a little better. It took me a few weeks to finish, which I think says something about how my interest fluctuated throughout. Not a bad book by any means, just one that didn't quite live up to its initial potential for me.
3.5 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
First, I want to say that this is marketed as a thriller, or even horror, but I honestly don't think it fits either category. I'd say it's more general fiction, bordering on YA.
I enjoyed it for the most part! At the beginning, I loved the author's writing style, and I really liked Gretchen. However, as the story progressed, Gretchen started becoming a little grating. Her inner monologue and her dialogue couldn't seem to go a single sentence without some sort of smart-ass remark, and she eventually started coming across as a bit of a pick-me. Thankfully, that seemed to calm down toward the end.
The story itself was exciting and entertaining at first, but it also started to lose momentum as it went along, becoming a little boring toward the end.
While I didn't dislike the ending, I also didn't feel entirely satisfied with it. Without giving away any spoilers, I was left with a few unanswered questions, and some things didn't quite make sense to me.
Overall, it was still an entertaining read, and it's a 3/5 for me!
A lot hornier than I like my pop culture/serial killer horror, but hard to put down, and the depraved passions are after all part of what makes it horrifying. I don’t exactly like Gretchen, but she’s smart and funny and ultimately more charismatic than her mentor. If there’s no explicit meeting at the crossroads with Old Scratch, there’s a chilling suggestion that souls are bought and sold all the time for lesser and lesser stakes. What kind of Faustian bargain did [name redacted lest her faithful descend] make?
reading this was like pulling teeth. the writing style is so obnoxious i had to force myself to get through it. gretchen's narrations made me want to pull my hair out. what a waste of time
**. THIS IS AN ADVANCED READING COPY FROM NETGALLEY: PUBLICLY set to be RELEASED ON JANUARY 12, 2027- RUN to your closest bookstore!!! This is the one book of 2027 you absolutely NEED TO READ.
This was a real fast paced, shocking and wildly fun read, that is of course if you have a strong interest in thriller and suspense genre although this was also about a young girl named Gretchen who posted herself singing while playing the guitar and a well known exercise coach and influencer who had thousands of followers on her site, chose to use one of Gretchen’s original songs to do her glute and butt workout. This video managed to thrust Gretchen’s otherwise unknown song into a massive hit in social media stratosphere. Then it was noticed by an outrageously popular and influential singer who’s own following was in the millions and she was in need of an opening act as her previous act was pregnant and no longer able to travel or keep up with the grueling schedule required of her. As luck would have the unbelievably crazy famous and the very best pop singer of all time, Fae Deeds winner of a handful of Emmys has contacted Gretchen, she wants her and meets up with her to see if she’ll open for her for the rest of concert. To have this opportunity, playing in front of an audience of 50k plus per night is like a fever dream. In fact, Gretchen doubts she’d ever dreamt that big before. It’s an out of body experience and one she will meet with the confidence and professionalism of someone who’s been around for years. It’s impressive and profoundly inspiring particularly considering the weighty external factors that she’s expected to not only endure but to participate in. They meet and get along so well it feels like fate has been waiting for this exact moment to reveal this once in a lifetime opportunity that most can only fantasize about. With no time to prep and barely any time process, Fae and her enormous entourage slip Gretchen into Faes car and essentially her world as they speed off to the venue she will be performing in mere hours. While Fae and her crew all head into her dressing rooms, Gretchen finds herself alone on the 2nd floor and what is reminiscent of what she imagines an old bomb shelter would look like. With panic bubbling up, her mind is reeling. She has no clothes, her manager never showed, she doesn’t know where her guitar is and she is on verge of a full blown panic attack. Gasping for air, hyperventilating she is realizing she has never sung before 55k ppl before. She’s only been to dive bars with drunk people and small venues she’s pretty sure no one was even listening to her. Just as Gretchen’s on verge of passing out from lack of oxygen and reality setting in, Marty, Fae’s manager walks in and takes charge as she imagines real managers do, unlike her manager who’s deigned to even show. Marty informs her that he is now her manager, he will connect her with a publicist and to answer the question she’s asked aloud(though she could’ve sworn she was only repeatedly asking silently jn her mind) that her guitar is on its way. He assures her the makeup artists are all en route, as well as her clothing designers and her other people he had titles for but her shock has temporarily paused her brain and its retention. Before she can regroup, she has 3 people poking at her front, a woman holding an arm full of different bras that begin at her wrist and end at her shoulder, two other people whipping out crazy concoctions of clothing at her, all while her face and hair are being assaulted by arms, hands and a bevy of products she’s never seen let alone used in her life. Never has she been so overwhelmed, overstimulated and overjoyed. Yet, this is not how she’s envisioned herself, this just isn’t HER. She takes a look at her plastered made up face and hair that looks obscene and loses herself. She tells them all to get the hell out. She asks Janelle, the bra lady to please stay and hires her on the spot as her assistant. They begin again, this time, the makeup is minimal and while the clothing designer tried to get her into this sexy situation, she refused holding strong to her flannel and old jeans. The only new thing she has on is one of the bras Janelle offered her. She’s the bra whisperer and with a 36DD she needs one. As they are walking towards the stage for Gretchen to perform they get into the elevator where she proceeds to say she’s going to throw up and does. Then is handed a mint by Janelle and she is soon being introduced to the audience. She starts out playing her guitar and bc the lights are so bright she can only see the first few rows but she can feel the bodies pulsating and cheering and it goes right through her. On her last song someone throws something up onto the stage, she sees it hurling high speed out of the corner of her eye and from so much practice in catching her alcoholic Dads empty’s she grabs it with one hand and cracks it open. She slugs it in one go and then smashes the can on her forehead and continues singing about anger and bitterness specifically towards men. The audience went absolutely WILD- first when she caught it then when she finished it and the entire stadium was in chaos and mayhem when she crashed it on her head and decided last minute to BELCH into the microphone and tell the man who threw the full beer at her he needs to be kinder to women and should be ashamed for throwing at her. She got a standing ovation she was on cloud nine and couldn’t believe every dream she dreamt as a kid had just come true. After Fae was finished her set, she demanded that Gretchen join her in her room. They bond over alcohol, drunkenness and shared secrets. Fae is quite possessive and isn’t content unless all attention is on her and is unable to congratulate or compliment her or anyone else. The whole time there women have been touring, Faes serious famous tennis player has been missing, Strangley she doesn’t seem to be a girlfriend in mourning or under duress. In fact she is so tickled with the way the concert is going since Gretchen had joined it’s given Gretchen pause about who exactly is Fae Deeds. When Gretchen’s ex starts to blackmail her with a sex tape she is so distracted terrified and doesn’t have the excessive amount he seems to think she does, For weeks, Gretchen remains introverted and so worried. Her bass player had even attempted to chat her up and if she’s honest he’s so hot and she adores his perspective on life it is so positive and secure. Though his childhood was stable with both parents while Gretchen spent time caring for a drunk mother, never knowing who her dad was and being neglected and withheld love affection and social life as she couldn’t ever bring friends to their trailer where her mom hoarded and had several cats. It stunk like cat pee and litter box, Her dad had been far away working as a miner in Russia and had not come back to visit them at all and always made an excuse as to why he couldn’t get back home, When Fae sees the text message blackmailing Gretchen, she tells her to absolutely NOT pay him any money but tell him to meet her in the costume trailer that night once her set is over. She will need to stand up for herself and tell him that she’s giving him nothing and she doesn’t care if he sells the tape. He begins to get aggressive and Gretchen stabs him in the ribs and then with a feral yell Fae comes out from behind the costume racks and slices him up with an ax. Fae proves again and again in each city town and place they play in she is a serial killer and makes Gretchen go with her. She justifies that she only kills wastes of space and men who hurt women or her. Gretchen, having sociopathic tendencies doesn’t seem as wrecked and broken apart had she not had a disconnect within her. An unexpected, ruthlessly cruel and uncalled for twist comes from Fae in attempt to toss Gretchen out of her life, the limelight and permanently get rid of her and the person she’s fallen in love with. To Gretchen’s surprise her least expected alibi and ally is someone who has shown no love lost for her previously but there she is enduring Gretchen will rise above the sinister take down Fae has orchestrated and she will be beside her as it transpires. I was shocked- truly shell shocked at the way this ended. Yet, I freaking loved it!! THANK YOU TO #NetGalley for this #ARC #Advanced Reading Copy by author #MindyMcGinnis and to her generous publishing company #PenguinRandomHouse I am so grateful for this wonderful opportunity to have had the privilege to read this book prior to its public release and encourage everyone to get to their closest local book store for its launch on January 12, 2027 because this book is PHENOMENAL!! I cannot wait to buy the book to add to my own private collection and read it again. Riveting and so many plot twists as well as pure SHOCKERS!! Made my head spin with the duets these two main characters got into on and off the stage. This was a real fast paced short and fun read, that is of course if you have a strong interest in thriller and suspense genre although this was also about a young girl named Gretchen who posted herself singing while playing the guitar and a well known exercise coach and influencer who had thousands of followers on her site, chose to use one of Gretchen’s original songs to do her glute and butt workout. This video managed to thrust Gretchen’s otherwise unknown song into a massive hit in social media stratosphere. Then it was noticed by an outrageously popular and influential singer who’s own following was in the millions and she was in need of an opening act as her previous act was pregnant and no longer able to travel or keep up with the grueling schedule required of her. As luck would have the unbelievably crazy famous and the very best pop singer of all time, Fae Deeds winner of a handful of Emmys has contacted Gretchen, she wants her and meets up with her to see if she’ll open for her for the rest of concert. To have this opportunity, playing in front of an audience of 50k plus per night is like a fever dream. In fact, Gretchen doubts she’d ever dreamt that big before. It’s an out of body experience and one she will meet with the confidence and professionalism of someone who’s been around for years. It’s impressive and profoundly inspiring particularly considering the weighty external factors that she’s expected to not only endure but to participate in. They meet and get along so well it feels like fate has been waiting for this exact moment to reveal this once in a lifetime opportunity that most can only fantasize about. With no time to prep and barely any time process, Fae and her enormous entourage slip Gretchen into Faes car and essentially her world as they speed off to the venue she will be performing in mere hours. While Fae and her crew all head into her dressing rooms, Gretchen finds herself alone on the 2nd floor and what is reminiscent of what she imagines an old bomb shelter would look like. With panic bubbling up, her mind is reeling. She has no clothes, her manager never showed, she doesn’t know where her guitar is and she is on verge of a full blown panic attack. Gasping for air, hyperventilating she is realizing she has never sung before 55k ppl before. She’s only been to dive bars with drunk people and small venues she’s pretty sure no one was even listening to her. Just as Gretchen’s on verge of passing out from lack of oxygen and reality setting in, Marty, Fae’s manager walks in and takes charge as she imagines real managers do, unlike her manager who’s deigned to even show. Marty informs her that he is now her manager, he will connect her with a publicist and to answer the question she’s asked aloud(though she could’ve sworn she was only repeatedly asking silently jn her mind) that her guitar is on its way. He assures her the makeup artists are all en route, as well as her clothing designers and her other people he had titles for but her shock has temporarily paused her brain and its retention. Before she can regroup, she has 3 people poking at her front, a woman holding an arm full of different bras that begin at her wrist and end at her shoulder, two other people whipping out crazy concoctions of clothing at her, all while her face and hair are being assaulted by arms, hands and a bevy of products she’s never seen let alone used in her life. Never has she been so overwhelmed, overstimulated and overjoyed. Yet, this is not how she’s envisioned herself, this just isn’t HER. She takes a look at her plastered made up face and hair that looks obscene and loses herself. She tells them all to get the hell out. She asks Janelle, the bra lady to please stay and hires her on the spot as her assistant. They begin again, this time, the makeup is minimal and while the clothing designer tried to get her into this sexy situation, she refused holding string to her flannel and old jeans. The only new thing she has on is one of the bras Janelle offered her. She’s the bra whisperer and with a 36DD she needs one. As they are walking towards the stage for Gretchen to perform they get into the elevator where she proceeds to say she’s going to throw up and does. Then is handed a mint by Janelle and she is soon being introduced to the audience. She starts out playing her guitar and bc the lights are so bright she can only see the first few rows but she can feel the bodies pulsating and cheering and it goes right through her. On her last song someone throws something up onto the stage, she sees it hurling high speed out of the corner of her eye and from so much practice in catching her alcoholic Dads empty’s she grabs it with one hand and cracks it open. She slugs it in one go and then smashes the can on her forehead and continues singing about anger and bitterness specifically towards men. The audience went absolutely WILD- first when she caught it then when she finished it and the entire stadium was in chaos and mayhem when she crashed it on her head and decided last minute to BELCH into the microphone and tell the man who threw the full beer at her he needs to be kinder to women and should be ashamed for throwing at her. She got a standing ovation she was on cloud nine and couldn’t believe every dream she dreamt as a kid had just come true. After Fae was finished her set, she demanded that Gretchen join her in her room. They bond over alcohol, drunkenness and shared secrets. Fae is quite possessive and isn’t content unless all attention is on her and is unable to congratulate or compliment her or anyone else. The whole time there women have been touring, Faes serious famous tennis player has been missing, Strangley she doesn’t seem to be a girlfriend in mourning or under duress. In fact she is so tickled with the way the concert is going since Gretchen had joined it’s given Gretchen pause about who exactly is Fae Deeds. When Gretchen’s ex starts to blackmail her with a sex tape she is so distracted terrified and doesn’t have the excessive amount he seems to think she does, For weeks, Gretchen remains introverted and so worried. Her bass player had even attempted to chat her up and if she’s honest he’s so hot and she adores his perspective on life it is so positive and secure. Though his childhood was stable with both parents while Gretchen spent time caring for a drunk mother, never knowing who her dad was and being neglected and withheld love affection and social life as she couldn’t ever bring friends to their trailer where her mom hoarded and had several cats. It stunk like cat pee and litter box, Her dad had been far away working as a miner in Russia and had not come back to visit them at all and always made an excuse as to why he couldn’t get back home, When Fae sees the text message blackmailing Gretchen, she tells her to absolutely NOT pay him any money but tell him to meet her in the costume trailer that night once her set is over. She will need to stand up for herself and tell him that she’s giving him nothing and she doesn’t care if he sells the tape. He begins to get aggressive and Gretchen stabs him in the ribs and then with a feral yell Fae comes out from behind the costume racks and slices him up with an ax. Fae proves again and again in each city town and place they play in she is a serial killer and makes Gretchen go with her. She justifies that she only kills wastes of space and men who hurt women or her. Gretchen, having sociopathic tendencies doesn’t seem as wrecked and broken apart had she not had a disconnect within her. An unexpected, ruthlessly cruel and uncalled for twist comes from Fae in attempt to toss Gretchen out of her life, the limelight and permanently get rid of her and the person she’s fallen in love with. To Gretchen’s surprise her least expected alibi and ally is someone who has shown no love lost for her previously but there she is enduring Gretchen will rise above the sinister take down Fae has orchestrated and she will be beside her as it transpires. I was shocked- truly shell shocked at the way this ended. Yet, I freaking loved it!! Thank you to #NetGalley, to the phenomenal #MindyMcGinnis, the generous publisher, #Penguin Random House who approved this #Advanced Reading Copy #ARC for me to review and give my honest feedback of.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
This book follows Gretchen, a young rising pop star who gets the opportunity of a lifetime when she is offered the position to open for Fae Deeds (the biggest pop star in the world) on Fae’s tour.
This pains me to say, but I really, really, really did not like this book, and I unfortunately do not have any positive things to say about it.
To start, the writing was remarkably hard to follow. There would be paragraphs where Gretchen would go off on a tangent about something and I literally would not understand what she was saying. Characters often responded to another in disjointed ways, almost like there were two separate conversations going on. It was jarring and hard to follow.
The characters… argh!!! Gretchen was truly unbearable. She was painted as being a confident, quirky, in-your-face gal who was still charming, but I actually hated every minute of reading about her. It felt like the writing was trying too hard to make her sound quirky with every single sentence. Every word she spoke to another person had to be some sort of zippy comeback and it was infuriating. It was giving redditor who thinks they are a lot more clever than they are. Fae was a little better in my opinion, as she had kind of a light and silly air about her. But she was also just not super well fleshed out. I suppose that’s the best way to put it- all of the characters felt like caricatures, with one trait brought to the forefront and nothing going on behind the scenes.
This book also did something I don’t really enjoy which is that the plot twist at the end WAS surprising, but only because it relied on withholding a huge amount of information from the reader that we should have been privy to. I won’t go into too much detail here for fear of spoilers but if you read it I think you’ll know what I mean.
I do believe this book is supposed to be satirical. However, good satire normally has like… a point. This didn’t really seem to have that. It poked fun at the music industry but didn’t seem to have anything real to say about it, and I was disappointed by that.
Overall, I just did not like the experience of reading this book. The writing and narration was grating, the characters were one-note, the plot dragged, and the plot twist ending came out of nowhere. Disappointed to give this 1 star but I really don’t feel it had any redeeming qualities for me.
**A Wickedly Entertaining Descent into Fame, Friendship, and Dangerous Obsession**
Mindy McGinnis's *The First Cut Is the Deepest* promises a deliciously dark and unconventional thriller that takes readers into the glamorous yet unsettling world of the music industry. Blending pop culture, sharp humor, psychological suspense, and a distinctly twisted sense of danger, the story explores what can happen when the dream of fame comes with an unexpected and potentially deadly price.
At the center is Gretchen McMurphy, a musician whose career takes an extraordinary turn after her breakup anthem gains attention online. Going from performing in bingo halls and dive bars to opening for celebrated pop star Fae Deeds gives Gretchen access to a world she once could only imagine. The sudden success brings financial comfort, enthusiastic fans, and the excitement of being recognized, but perhaps its biggest surprise is the friendship she develops with Fae.
Their connection initially seems built on shared experiences. Fae understands the pressures of public attention, the challenges women face in the entertainment industry, and the emotional scars left by difficult relationships. Yet the description hints that her methods of coping are anything but conventional. Beneath the glittering pop-star image lies something considerably more disturbing.
This contrast between glamorous celebrity culture and psychological darkness gives the premise much of its appeal. Fae's increasingly unsettling behavior creates an intriguing tension, while Gretchen's position as an ambitious newcomer raises an uncomfortable question: how much is someone willing to sacrifice to achieve lasting fame?
The book's combination of pop-noir atmosphere, razor-sharp humor, and thriller elements makes it stand out from more conventional stories about musical ambition. Its exploration of female friendship, celebrity pressures, revenge, and obsession offers plenty of room for both suspense and dark comedy.
Overall, *The First Cut Is the Deepest* looks set to deliver an entertaining, unpredictable ride for readers who enjoy twisted psychological thrillers with a satirical edge. Its unusual premise and larger-than-life characters make it an intriguing addition to contemporary thriller fiction.
Three and a half stars, rounded up. This is a wild romp – the kind of book where words like “realistic” and “believable” are kind of beside the point. The point is outrageous excess, and author Mindy McGinnis delivers in spades.
Does she try too hard sometimes? Maybe. Or maybe that’s her lead character, Gretchen McMurphy, a scrappy singer who never does anything small. She’s recently been thrust into the limelight thanks to a viral “Better Booty” video by a fitness influencer who used one of Gretchen’s tunes to show off her butt-toning exercise moves. Gretchen’s moment of fame gets the attention of pop music megastar Fae Deeds, who taps Gretchen to be her opening act. Gretchen goes for the gusto by, among other things, downing an entire can of beer onstage, belching, and calling the rowdy fan who threw the beer can … well, an obscene name that I actually had to look up.
Subtlety is not Gretchen’s strong suit – she freely admits that she has no filter, and the more self-conscious she gets on the inside, the raunchier her quips get on the outside. But her uber-famous new mentor – think Taylor Swift-level fame, mashed up with the Disney star of your choice – is hiding an unexpected wild side behind her wholesome-seeming baby blues.
I’ll let you experience the rest for yourself, except to say this book made me laugh out loud many times, and yes, it’s a page-turner. I did question why Gretchen went SO all-in as she supports some of Fae’s escapades (you’ll see), and I don’t think the ending entirely holds water. But did I mention that believability isn’t really the point here?
If you’re okay with some edgy language, sex and violence in the name of laughs – and it IS funny – I think you’ll have as much fun with this one as I did.
NOTE: Thank you to Pengun Random House for providing an advance copy of this book via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Completely over the top, and I mean that as a compliment. This is a wild, chaotic ride, and I had a lot of fun with it.
I liked the main character almost immediately. She’s funny, messy, and says exactly the wrong thing at exactly the wrong time, which was entertaining at first. By about the midpoint, though, the constant inappropriate comments started to wear on me a little. There were moments when I wanted her to just stop, please.
I don't want to give away anything about the story. The book also almost lost me in the middle, largely because the narrator began to feel unreliable in a way I’m not sure was intentional. Some of what she was telling us had become so outrageous that I started questioning not just the situation, but whether I could believe her version of any of it. Given how heightened the entire story is, that may work perfectly for some readers, but it briefly pulled me out of the book.
Still, this is the kind of story where subtlety would defeat the purpose. It goes big, stays big, and ends pretty much the way a book like this has to end. Even though I could see where things were heading, I found the ending satisfying.
For reasons I cannot fully explain, I pictured Selena Gomez as Fae from almost the moment she appeared. I would absolutely watch an adaptation of this - either as a movie or, even better, an unhinged limited series.
It was fast, funny, outrageous, and genuinely fun to read.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley, G.P. Putnam's Sons, and Mindy McGinnis for an eARC in exchange for an honest review!
I'll be totally honest, for the first 45%-odd percent of this, I was ready to DNF. The quippy, irreverent dialogue didn't work for me, and I was so frustrated and annoyed with how Gretchen was reacting to the crazy situations she finds herself thrust into in this novel. But, in a kind of magical way, once I got past the 50% mark it all started clicking into place for me and becoming so, so fun.
The last half of this book is completely wild. Whatever you're expecting to happen, it's different. It caught me off gaurd in the best way and I really enjoyed it!! The constant jokes and references started becoming a lot more in-depth too, and it sorta felt like I was solving a puzzle alongside the characters.
The only suspicion I had that never came to fruition was that Aubrey Stone would be more important that immediately obvious. I was a little shocked that Gretchen was still taking shots at her at the very end, despite them, for all intents and purposes, having the same outlook about Fae. I was sure Aubrey would be part of the plot that unfolds in the second half, and I was wrong.
This was such a fun, crazy ride, even though it does start off a little rocky for my tastes. The ending is so satisfying, crazy, and unexpected that I'm glad I stuck it through. The premise of a pop-star serial killer is just so rich for exploration! I definitely recommend it for anyone who thinks that premise sounds interesting.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
THIS BOOK Y'ALL!!! I threw this book twice. Not out of anger. Out of shock. Pure and utter shock at the twists that Mindy took. What a fucking ride.
This was Mindy's Adult debut but I've read a fair few of her YA books over the years. I've also been lucky enough to see her talk in person at book signings multiple times. This book was so Mindy. It was just like sitting down and her telling you a story and I loved that about it!
I'm selling this to people as: Imagine if Taylor Swift were a serial killer and instead of her fans decoding lyrics to figure out which ex they're about, people are using lyrics to connect her to unsolved crimes.
Our MC Gretchen was an absolute hoot! She is the messiest person I've ever read but she was so much fun! She had me cackling more times than I can count. Reading from her POV was an absolute trip from beginning to end.
And Fae? She's our TSwift(ish) character who Gretchen describes as a "manic pixie-murder-girl" and nothing could be closer to the truth. She is exactly that. And while she is possibly bat-shit crazy, that's also what makes her so fun to read.
This novel is a bit absurd at times but if you're in for a dark, humorous, girl power time, I highly recommend!
Loved this beginning - “Being famous is kind of like losing your virginity - dreaming about it is way more fun than then the actual thing.” I knew I’d be going somewhere in this book. This is a “poo-noir” thriller and it’s funny and clever.
Gretchen McMurphy is a struggling singer-songwriter who sings in dive bars when her breakup then is used by a fitness influencer. The next thing Gretchen knows pop star Fae Deeds spots this and invites her to be her opener. Then Gretchen’s ex, Boyd, figuring she’s got money tries to extort her. Fae has an idea of how to nip that in the bud and it’s a shocker! I’m ending the summary here because I don’t want to spoil anyone’s read. It’s a good one. As Gretchen goes down a rabbit hole accompanying Fae she may have changed her mind on her opening thought: she says at the end: “Life is good; being famous is better.” Read on to find out why?
Beware there’s spice here but there’s also a crazy plot that keeps you reading. It’s a tight walk of hi-jinx and heart with chills and wicked femininity. Lots of fun though as the author explores the world of fane and privilege. Fae is seriously crazy! All is explained at the end. A good one.
My thanks to NetGalley and G. P. Putnam’s Sons for granting me access to this ARC.
Thank you to NetGalley, Penguin Random House, and the author Mindy McGinnis, for the opportunity to read and devour this book in advance.
Gretchen McMurphy becomes famous completely by accident when a fitness influencer uses one of her songs, turning her into a sensation over night and grabbing the attention of superstar Fae Deeds. Suddenly, Gretchen is catapulted into stardom when Fae makes Gretchen her opening act on tour. Gretchen stays down-to-earth amidst the lifestyle changes including turning Janelle, a bra woman (literally shows up with bras for Fae and Gretchen to wear), into her personal assistant. But Gretchen also deals with men letting her down, intense scrutiny by fans and the music industry, and overwhelming criticisms about her every move. But Fae's got her back offering support and understand, especially when she shares her dark side with Gretchen.
I found myself laughing out loud repeatedly, rooting for Gretchen along the way, and gasping out loud at the shocking twist of an ending.
So excited that I had the opportunity to read the first adult novel by Mindy McGinnis and look forward to many more!
The First Cut is The Deepest By Mindy McGinnis was gifted to me By Putnam Books through the NetGalley catalog in exchange for my honest review and honestly it was Magnificent!!!
I want to make Gretchen McMurphy my new BFF just to listen to her talk and to have conversations with her in hopes that she might rub off on me and I could be a fraction of the kind of funny that she is!! The HUMOR is the BEST!!
It is an excellent story too with a bad ass twist! I mean what can you ask for when justice prevails and Fae, the B*#@h gets whats coming to her yet you still appreciate her villainous role and the justice shes serving even if she is batSh@*t crazy!! Gretchen's hysterical dialog elevates every conversation she has through out the entire book making me want to read it again!
This book was pure enjoyment from start to finish! I just feel bad that people will have to wait until 2027 to get their hands on it! Although it's worth the wait too!! 🥳🤩🥰 So excellent and some of the best delivered humor I have ever read!! BRAVO!
Is the first cut the deepest? For Gretchen McMurphy, her first song cut the deepest squats and made her famous. When a fitness influencer used her song to create an exercise video, the pop star it girl, Fae Deeds took notice and asked her to open her shows. It all seems to be falling into place for Gretchen when her ex-boyfriend appears with demands of money or else a sex video will be released. Does this bother Fae Deeds, sweet singing girl of the pop world? Why no, why would it? It only gives her the opportunity to cut even deeper and maybe do the deed!
Be forewarned! If it is important for you to love the main character, Gretchen McMurphy is not that character. She is lewd, crude, and raunchy. For her, sex is not fulfilling unless it ends in a UTI. If you enjoy attending school board meetings to protest books, this book is not one for you to pick up. It contains a lot of sexual content. But if you like being surprised and don't mind a little death and blood, The First Cut is the Deepest by Mindy McGinnis is for you!
Oh my gosh, when I say this was unhinged ans hilarious…
This was such an insane read. You have two unhinged main characters with near opposite personalities (think Gretchen Wilson and Taylor Swift but dial up the personas by ten). Hilarious, sometimes crude, and always u predictable banter and verbal quips. And a final twist I was truly blindsided by (though maybe in saying this you’ll at least be expecting one which I wasn’t… naïve, I know).
And while their friendship was so unpredictable it bordered on unbelievable, I actually loved it. I wanted Gretchen and Fae to be besties, for Fae to help Gretchen to succeed and for Gretchen to give Fae a real friendship not fake media headlines.
Pick this up if you want some outrageous fun coupled with a butterfly wing-loving serial killer full of girls supporting girls…until they really don’t.
Thank you to Mandy McGinnis, Putnam, and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
Where do I even start?! This was hilariously unhinged in the best way possible! I was drawn in immediately by the quirky characters, and stayed for the witty, dark humor. We follow Gretchen’s newfound fame after one of her songs is used in a popular influencer’s video. They become fast friends and Gretchen is immediately roped into the chaotic and absolutely feral world of Fae Deeds. She quickly finds out that the pop star life isn’t just about the money and the fans, there’s a much darker side as well. And Fae is going to drag her along for all of it. This is such a modern and messy take on your typical serial killer storyline and I absolutely devoured it! The twists just kept coming, and the ending was not what I was expecting!
Thank you so much Mindy McGinnis and NetGalley for my gifted arc in exchange for my honest review!
Honestly, I’m not sure how I feel about this book. The main character(s) were both so wildly annoying to me that I was almost reading it out of spite to finish it. Gretchen was not a character I wanted to read about or learn more about. She was abrasive and rude, and honestly sometimes gross. Fae was the opposite in the way that she lived in her own fantasy world with no understanding of a normal life. I was dead set on disliking Gretchen… until the last few chapters. I really didn’t think there would be a redemption arc for her in my eyes, but the ending really made me reconsider, which is why I can’t decide about this book. I’d love to hear others opinions on this story.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
First of all: thank you netgalley for the opportunity to read this eARC! Second: Gretchen McMurphy! Oh. My. God. The beginning of this book was a bit slow and I was starting to think it wasn't for me...I am SO GLAD that I kept reading! After finding out Fae Deeds has a deep dark secret that she sucks Gretchen into, the twists keep coming! The friendship between Fae (who has her head in the clouds and believes she is the best thing since sliced bread) and Gretchen (who is who she is and refuses to apologize for any of her weird or gross tendencies) is wild and unexpected. And the ending of this book?! I NEVER saw it coming! Do yourself a favor and READ THIS BOOK when it is published!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This was a fun turn-off-your-brain read, from the over-the-top caricatures of characters to the that-doesn't-make-quite-sense-but-that's-funny plot points. A struggling artist goes viral due to her song being used in a glute workout video is handpicked by THE ultra uber pop star to open for her US tour. Despite being opposites, the two become fast friends, especially once our mega pop star turns out to have a terrible secret. This book is trashy, confusing, crass, but it is hard to deny how charming it is.
Thank you to NetGalley and Putnam Books for allowing me access to this book in exchange for an honest review.
I really loved the idea of this book: a pop star-focused thriller. That just sounded so fun and I love what I call a girlie-pop thriller. (I think everyone else calls it a bubblegum thriller.)
But I didn't get invested in these characters, they needed a lot more characterization and personality. I just felt like I was thrown in, like I was expected to automatically care about these characters without being showing a reason to do so.
This still had its fun moments though.
Thanks to NetGalley for the e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!