What can one say about this story? The triumphant return of Ezquerra to his creation and my first ever Dredd story is a sprawling and brutal epic. I believe it may have coloured my opinion on Judge Dredd ever since, as I saw him in this "at war", not a lawman, but a warrior. He euthanises the radiation-ill, executes collaborators in pits and mercilessly divides the world into those with him and those against him.
I was also new to comics at the time, so the epoch-making moment, which for many defines the difference between Judge Dredd and more conventional superheroes - where Dredd unflinchingly condemns 500,000,000 people to nuclear death in order to achieve victory - seemed to me a logical next step in Dredd's war against his own city's annihilation.
As Garth Ennis wrote in his 2009 tribute to "The Galaxy's Greatest Comic": "In the end, it was a dilemma not unlike those faced by a number of good and bad men in our own history, and if I had to sum it up in one line, I’d say this: what are you prepared to do when there isn’t any easy way out?
And that, I think, is why I’ve never been able to care about Batman, or Wolverine, or Iron Man… or any of them, really. Not because of what characters like that would or wouldn’t do, but because their publishers would never have the courage to have them written into such a situation."
My favourite moment will forever be the excellent, unexpected sacrifice of barely-secondary character Judge Souster, whose final words: "For Freedom! For Justice! For Mega-City One!" ring in my mind to this day. Judge Souster had what it takes, just like Dredd.