Jump to ratings and reviews

Rosecrest Estate #2

A Lady of Merit

Margaret Astley's goal in life has always been to be invisible, but when her older sister runs away, all of London starts to gossip. It's Margaret's job to help bring her family's name back into good standing. But she doesn't have much time. Her parent's finances cannot handle another season in London.

Lord John Merritt, Earl of Faversham, was once a happy boy, but has not been the same since his father's passing. He needs to find a wife, not just to produce a heir, but because he needs someone to bring back his smile.

They both deserve a chance at love, but will blackmailers, overbearing widows, runaway sisters, and unidentified bow street runners get in their way?

304 pages, Kindle Edition

First published August 11, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kiylee Davis

6 books26 followers
No-Spice Author!

Kiylee Davis is an up-and-coming author living in semi-rural Utah. When she’s not reading or writing she can be found playing with her three children, watering her thirty-plus house plants, or sailing on a cruise ship. Kiylee became a writer at a fairly young age. Not only did she write in about four journals every night, but she would write poetry or short stories when she got bored in class. Kiylee began writing her first novel in 2022. After two years of frustration and planning, the story finally came into light. Now, writing goes much smoother. Her shortest novel was researched and written in just 48 days.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
35 (60%)
4 stars
21 (36%)
3 stars
2 (3%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews
Profile Image for Lilly Guirguis.
913 reviews
August 22, 2026
Thank you to Kiylee for this gifted ARC!

Oh, it was amazing!

I love the romance development with John Merritt and Maggie/Margaret.

I loved the sweet, wholesome found family moments
(And no big spoilers, but I love that Lillian, the FMC’s older sister to Maggie, taking accountability for not communicating and responding to the concerned letters (kinda like texting back then) and she’s so sweet and she’s like, I’m sorry, I was not aware of your marriage arrangement and I messed up, but I love being your sister and I’m going to actively improve our relationship as sisters.).
(I always will love the accountability trope!) :)
Also, heads up, there is an unplanned pregnancy trope (with Lillian, not Maggie) and it is handled in a respectful way.

There is also some content considerations- the FMC’s mom and dad, the Lord and Lasy Astleys, are really strict and they rush Maggie to get married (and in some ways, they also… just don’t act like they respect her. They say she’s got to get the marriage done quickly. They say she’s extremely obedient/compliant (which, while it’s kinda nice in moderation, if a person does this, it could be a psychology sign of extreme anxiety, people pleasing tendencies, and fear of going to do anything related to finding their independence if it means that their parents would not approve of. If that applies to you or to someone you know, I’m so sorry. You did not need to have that: you just needed some godly support and some godly, realistic discipline that doesn’t make you feel micromanaged by others.

Profile Image for Adelaide.
28 reviews5 followers
July 25, 2026
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

*the happiest sigh to ever happy sigh* *and another*
I loved this book so much!!!! I need to buy luke and Clara’s book STAT! I will definitely be buying a physical copy of this book as soon as I can get my hands on it!!!
I read this book first and didn’t feel like I was missing anything from the prior book but I just love those characters that I want to read their book! 5⭐️✨

(Note on update: why did I give this book 4.75 stars this is the most 5 star worthy book I’ve read in a while. I don’t even know what I what happened because when I think about the book I thought I had put it as 5 stars🤦‍♀️!)
Profile Image for Fiction with Phoebe.
114 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 9, 2026
Blog Post: https://fictionwithphoebe.com/a-lady-...

3.5 stars

𝘔𝘢𝘳𝘨𝘢𝘳𝘦𝘵 𝘈𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘺 𝘸𝘢𝘴𝘯’𝘵 𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘯 𝘴𝘶𝘱𝘱𝘰𝘴𝘦𝘥 𝘵𝘰 𝘣𝘦 𝘰𝘶𝘵 𝘪𝘯 𝘚𝘰𝘤𝘪𝘦𝘵𝘺 𝘺𝘦𝘵, 𝘭𝘦𝘵 𝘢𝘭𝘰𝘯𝘦 𝘤𝘢𝘵𝘤𝘩 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘦𝘺𝘦 𝘰𝘧 𝘢𝘯 𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘭.

While there is some inspiration from Cinderella, I liked that this story wasn’t a beat for beat retelling. It kept the plot from becoming too predictable.

Margaret continually struggled with self-doubt, which wasn’t surprising given the cutting remarks she’s had to endure and the environment she grew up in.

But with the support of her new husband and in-laws, she slowly became more sure of herself (both as John’s wife and as the Countess of Faversham).

Margaret’s joy and kindness caught John’s attention from the very beginning. A single unguarded moment of laughter. Not her looks or any of the skills society deemed important.

Their own fears and insecurities sometimes prevented them from properly communicating with each other, but they found their way in the end.

I loved all the little ways John tried to show Margaret he cared, from exhilarating horseback rides to new sheet music.

I received an ARC from the author via BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. All opinions expressed are my own.

Favorite Moments
* “My John”
* the portrait hall
* morning ride
* new sheet music
* Epilogue

Content Notes:
some mild innuendo, use of “blast,” mention of Greek gods, use of “devilishly,” mention of curses (none specified), mention of a woman’s curves, mention of an unwed pregnancy (not the FMC), kissing, touching, noticing and awareness
Profile Image for Christy Greenwood.
Author 4 books2 followers
August 11, 2026
Lady Merrit was a surprise for me. It was a great read, but what stood out most was how simple and clear the characters' "issues" were. I read a lot of historical fiction, and they are either inaccurate or just smut lately, but this one was clean, precise, and worth the time invested.

I received this ARC and leaving this review voluntarily
Profile Image for Arleen.
1 review
Read
August 1, 2026
I received an advance reader copy of A Lady of Merit, and having not read the first book in the series, it wasn’t necessary, but now I’m eager to go back and read the first.

I found myself invested in Margaret and John and was eager to see how their stories would unfold. There was a few unexpected twists that kept me engaged, and made it difficult to put down.

One of the things I enjoyed most was the emphasis on faith, family, and redemption. The sibling relationships were especially heartwarming, and I appreciated how the story explored overcoming insecurities, extending grace, and learning to trust God’s plan. The romance developed at a natural pace and was very sweet.
Profile Image for Kristi W - Book Love By Kristi.
519 reviews28 followers
July 27, 2026
“Your laughter is a gift, Maggie. A gift that changed me. I did not realize how badly I needed you. You make me happy, Love. Happier than I have ever been.” “You make me happy, too.”

This marriage of convenience book has lots of family, a mysterious blackmailer, and a sweet romance. There were a few times that I was screaming inside “Just talk to each other!”

Margaret is joyful, caring, and playful. Her battle with self-doubt and feeling like she belongs pulled at my heartstrings. I loved the healing and strength she found because of John. I loved that he always saw her true self, encouraged and created situations where she felt comfortable being her true self. I loved Ellen and Henry! Such sweet kids and their relationship with “Maggie” was delightful. John is patient, gentle, and determined. He was absolutely smitten from his very first glimpse. His determination to know Margaret and make her happy was so sweet. I loved all of the things he did to show her how special she was and how much he loved her. I was so happy for the healing and happiness he found. I loved that his friendship with Luke and Clara is still amazing. His interactions with Ellen and Henry were so fun.

A few more quotes:
🩷 It was not home she longed for, but rather a feeling. A feeling of acceptance, of having someone who cared to hear about her joys and fears. A feeling that meant she mattered, and that she wasn’t so alone. 🩷

“Future Lord Astley, I vow on all that I hold dear, to do everything in my power to protect and love your sister. I promise to keep her happy, healthy, and laughing.”

“All I’s got to say is that man pays ‘ttention, and takes mighty good care of ‘is loved ones, that’s for sure.”

Note: This is book two in the series and can be enjoyed as a standalone. You’ll understand John’s healing and relationship with Luke and Clara more if you read book one first.

This complimentary copy was provided by the author via BookSirens. I was not required to give a positive review, rating and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Thoroughly Clean Indies.
164 reviews
reviewed
August 11, 2026
{291 print pages}

My review of book 1

Genre: Historical
Tropes: Love at first “sight” he falls first
Setting: Regency period (1815): Rosecrest, London
Writing style: Dual POV (except for a third in second half of last sentence), 3rd person, past tense
Tone: Earnest, uncertain at times, emotional
Character- or plot-driven: Both

Romance: Yes
Clean level:
• 1 instance of kissing minimally described over about a paragraph
• 2 mouth kisses minimally described over a paragraph
• 1 mouth kiss barely described
• 1 near-kiss over a paragraph, minimal description
• 1 passing thought of “exchanging kisses”
• 1 instance of him running her hair through his fingers, 1 paragraph
• 1 instance of holding close, rocking back and forth, and kissing top of head
• 1 cheek kiss barely described, 1 without description
• 1 hand kiss lightly described, 2 without description
• 2 head kisses without description
*See caveats below

Sensitive aspects:
• She notices and likes the feel of his muscles working to help her mount a horse
• Quick instance of her trying to ignore chest hairs sticking from his “gaping shirt”

Favorite aspects of the book:
• Themes
• The scenes with Margaret’s little brother Henry and sister Ellen
• How Margaret, her mother, and her youngest siblings become fully a part of the Merritt family
• The growth in Margaret and John’s emotional intelligence

All her life, Margaret has never known pure love and adoration from anyone but her little siblings. Her needs and desires are never considered, and she has spent her whole life being the obedient daughter, doing whatever her parents wanted her to do, fulfilling her “duties” regardless of whether they supported her well-being.

She ironically only finds her freedom when she ends up married to John at the behest of her parents. She finally has a family who values her as her own person, who wants her to be at peace with her life. At first Margaret worries about whether John cares about her in that way, and he worries that she will accept any romantic and emotional advances from him just because she has always done whatever others wanted from her.

This is the first book I’ve read with a theme like this where the characters’ eyes and minds were open to see the patterns in each other’s behavior in regards to themselves. Margaret questions John’s attitude toward her because of some mixed signaling from a specific incident, but when they then spend more time together right after, even without a conversation about it, she is able to see past that uncertainty. She can recognize the unmistakable pleasure he takes in her company and realize that, whatever his side of what happened, he does care about her and enjoy being with her. In the words of the book, “The voice inside might have told her she was unwanted, but being with John had dispelled that voice. After today, she knew John cared for her, and no one, not even herself, could convince her it wasn’t true.” John is eventually able to think calmly and evaluate Margaret’s behavior across different situations and discern the difference between the things she does out of obligation or expectation and the things she genuinely wants to do.

____________________________________

Rosecrest had three dining rooms, a large formal, a small formal, and the family dining room. Today’s party was not nearly big enough for the large room, but was slightly cramped in the smaller one.

So it should have been on the large one. The point isn’t to fill the room but to have enough room.

Why is she telling me about the chicken? Wouldn’t that be a comment for the lady of the … oh … I am the lady of the house. Margaret knew it was true, but she still had a hard time remembering—and believing—it.

That’s irrelevant because she hasn’t actually taken up the position yet. She had no involvement in the preparation for her wedding dinner.

While it made her uncomfortable, there was no denying that John was going above and beyond the mark to see to her personal care, and that was quite flattering.

I don’t see how. He’s her husband.

In English society, that was often the first thing to know about a person and certainly something a wife should know about her husband. “Would you like cream or sugar?” She was grateful it was only the two of them so no one else had to witness what an incompetent woman she was.

Incompetent how? How are you supposed to know when you just barely met him?

Favorite Quotations:
• He thought back to the way she looked atop the pathetic mare, as if she were a diamond seated upon a limp pile of dandelions.
• He wore his black finery, the same he had worn at Clara’s ball, though he looked even more handsome now then he did then. Probably because Margaret knew even better the beauty of his heart.
• “My John,” she said, giving him a playful pat. “Ooh,” he pulled her in closer. “I have been waiting for you to call me that.” “I know.” She laughed. “And honestly, with all the Johns around here, I think it best to be specific. It is a popular name.”


(I received a free review copy of this book via Booksirens and am gratefully—voluntarily—leaving a review.)
548 reviews10 followers
September 19, 2026
Absolutely fabulous!

I loved this second book of the Rosecrest series just as much as the first. It starts with a bang which sends Maggie Astley propelling into the London season in desperate need of a match. Surprisingly, she becomes the object of the Earl of Faversham's desire after hearing her laughter and the two quickly end up married.

The two main characters go on a journey of self-discovery while in a brand new marriage with a practical stranger. My heart absolutely ached for Maggie as she debated whether she was someone of worth after being "trained" by her father to be the perfect wife. Thank goodness for John's goodness! But the sweet earl had his own misgivings and insecurities after the death of his father. I loved how these two grew together throughout the story and also helped solve a couple of sneaky "mysteries" along the way. There is something so special when an author delivers on an imperfect couple. The way they learn to treasure the other, with many, many misunderstandings along the way, made for such an enjoyable read.

I'll be stayed tuned for the rest of the series! I love when an author can keep me hooked and Ms Davis set up the next story to already be an emotional one. I'm there!

I received a copy for consideration without the expectation of a positive review. All thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Judith B King.
Author 5 books6 followers
August 17, 2026
This was a joy to read. I came to it on Kindle Unlimited after reading and enjoying Kiylee Davis first Rosecrest novel A Lord of Valor and was cheering for Margaret from the very first page.

I have struggled with perfectionism for most of my life, so could really identify with someone struggling to believe that they have worth and merit. Yes, sometimes she and the male lead, her husband John, wound me up! Their journey through an arranged marriage (mild spoiler: it turns out the arranging might not have been needed!) would have been much the smoother if they mastered the simple art of talking to each other.

What I particularly loved was that this is a warm, unaffected love story. I enjoy couples who delight in each other and delight in life, and Margaret and John gave me plenty of that. The surrounding cast is lovely, too, and I really appreciate that the author keeps the romance high and the spice absent.

Readers looking for period-authentic, Austen-style prose won't find that here, but I didn't consider that a flaw at all. The writing is accessible, the story has plenty of heart, and I would happily recommend it even to readers who don't normally reach for romance.

I binged the book during a medical appointment, and it lifted my spirits enormously. Sometimes that's exactly what you want from a story.
1,524 reviews19 followers
August 15, 2026
This is the second book in the Rosecrest Estate series. I enjoyed this story of Margaret and John. Their beginning was cute and entertaining. It moved along very quickly but I continued waiting for the tension or drama to begin. There was some obvious tension of a newly married couple but nothing that made you bite your nails until the very end and that was not even completely solved. I did receive an ARC copy so I hope the last threatening letter was addressed in the final version.
In my opinion, if you were looking for a sweet, charming historical romance, that is clean and low drama, this is the perfect book for you. It really is a lovely story and will warm your heart. I am intrigued with the idea of the next book in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
142 reviews
August 25, 2026
This book ⬆️⬆️ was so much fun to read! John Merritt is one amazing guy. He’s charming, funny, and genuinely cares about others. I loved him in A Lord of Valor, the first book in the Rosecrest series, and he was just as amazing in A Lady of Merit. Maggie was a real gem. She tries so hard to please everyone else that it takes her a while to discover her own self-worth. One of my favorite aspects of the book was how quickly John was able to see the real Maggie and fall completely in love with her. That being said, the story still has a slow-burn feel to it.
This story has a strong focus on family. The Merritts will take you in and treat you like family, and Maggie’s siblings were another favorite part of mine. I loved that they played such a big role in the story.
It was also fun to see Clara and Luke from the first book and get more of their story!
1,438 reviews12 followers
September 12, 2026
This is the 2nd book in the series.

The FMC has always been invisible compare to her sister, but when her sister causes a scandal, its up to her to help her family survive it.

The MMC hasnt been the same since his fathers passing, he needs to find himself a wife but not just for an heir, he needs someone to help him be happy again.

I enjoyed reading this book and would recommend reading it.
31 reviews
August 17, 2026
A nice book with a lot of angst with the main couple. They were very innocent and trying to figure out their relationship. Clean, moves slowly but I enjoyed it. I recommend it. Cheering for Margaret and John!
Profile Image for Georgianne.
242 reviews15 followers
August 16, 2026
Oh how I love this series! I cannot wait for Violet's story!
45 reviews
Review of advance copy
July 25, 2026
I loved John and Margaret's story. I thought it was so cute how John pretty much falls in love with her at first sight, and Clara is so excited, she plans a ball for John to meet her right away. I also liked how John may have fallen in love with her at first sight, but was content to go at her pace when he found out how nervous she was. I loved Margaret's little sister too.
I thought it made no sense how Margaret got so angry when John told her he had seen her playing with her sister in her parents' garden and Clara had arranged the ball on purpose so he could meet her. What was she angry about? Margaret admits herself that the garden was easily visible from the road, so it's not as if John was sneaking about where he shouldn't be. He basically tells her that he fell for her right away and that he wanted to meet her so badly, he asked his sister to make it happen. What's to be angry about in that? But she flies off the handle and refuses to talk to him for a while. He is left (very understandably!) confused, and wondering what he did wrong. I was glad that it was not swept under the rug, and Margaret does admit later that she shouldn't have reacted that way and apologizes for it. It always bothers me when the heroine has a meltdown for a stupid reason and never acknowledges it afterward, so I'm glad that didn't happen here.
I hated Lillian. She was so selfish! I didn't mind her running away, though her parents' non-reaction was very strange, and I didn't even mind her not believing John right away when he came to help her. But there was no reason for her to cut Margaret out of her life like she did! Of course she wants her own life, but Margaret wasn't trying to control her! Lillian could have her own life, and still have her sister in it! According to the little sister, this selfishness was not a new development.
As with the previous book in this series, the characters were called by their names rather than their titles, which was a little annoying, but the thing that really dragged down this book for me, though, was the spelling errors. I can handle a few and not really mind, but there were so many! Not obscure or difficult words either; most of them were pretty glaring. Like describing a house, saying it was built with stones of a pinkish 'hew', (!) and that John and Margaret 'peaked' into the nursery! That's only two, but there were so many more, it really pulled me out of the story.
Please, for the love of your readers' sanity, hire a proofreader next time! I might have given this book five stars if it weren't for all the mistakes. I don't remember there being so many in the first book.

I received an ARC of this book, but all opinions are my own.
68 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 27, 2026
This is the second book I’ve read by this author, and I’ve enjoyed both do them. Kiylee has a really great writing style—with interesting stories, engaging characters, and funny banter and memorable situations. It was a great distraction while I was sick, and I read it in two days.

When some hints of “insta-love” showed up, I was bummed. But! The insta-love was more like “insta-attraction/interest” which is understandable and palatable, and it was then used as a jumping block for building an actual relationship based on time together and getting to know each other.

I have few critiques, and they are light. One being the beginning few and last few chapters of the book was written a bit disjointedly and had a rushed feeling. Don’t know how else to describe it. It felt like it needed a little more polishing and fleshing out to make the story to shine even brighter and go a little deeper, and to help the story flow better and make more sense right off the bat. Despite this,I truly did enjoy and highly recommend this story—part of why I share my feelings above as this author is already so fantastic that I can see she has even more potential!

I can’t wait to read the other books by the author, as well as book three in this series!

I was given an ARC for an honest review. Thank you for the opportunity to read this enjoyable book!
Profile Image for Lynda.
422 reviews25 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 23, 2026
Sometimes a second book in a series can be a bit of a disappointment after reading the first. That is not the case with this second book in the Rosecrest Estate series, however; Maggie and John's story has stolen my heart!

I really liked the first book but was unsure how much I might enjoy this take on a marriage of convenience/forced marriage trope, which isn't always my favorite. I am so glad I took a chance and requested a review copy, though, because it is such a wonderful story, well-written and engrossing.

We met John in the first book, and now Margaret is introduced. Her upbringing is very different from John's and she has much to learn about herself and about how a loving family treats its various members. There were a couple of instances where the story could have devolved into cliches but the author put her own spin on events and kept the tropes fresh and unique to this novel.

I recommend this book for fans of Regency romance, those who enjoy unique perspectives on some well-known story elements, and anyone who likes a sweet story with a happy ending. Maybe not a perfect ending in all aspects, but a happy one that is both realistic and uplifting.

I received a review copy from the author but was not required to post a positive review. The opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
Profile Image for Claygirlreads.
18 reviews1 follower
August 13, 2026
A Lady of Merit is like a lovely walk in the park. It felt comfortable, with familiar characters met in book 1, but new things to explore along the way. Seeing Rosecrest from both John's and Margaret's eyes was refreshing and really brought the estate to life. And Violet, oh, I liked her!

He falls first. Whirlwind wedding. Courtship after marriage. Miscommunications ensue. As with book 1, kisses only, very lightly described. No spice. Some lovely hand-flex type moments between John and Margaret though.

I found myself a little tired of Margaret's ping-ponging between loving her new life and doubting herself and squelching who she was. I would have liked her better if she had just embraced the parts of the new life that she loved, because as John determines late in the book, he actually can offer her much of what she longs for. What? Go figure. It's a HEA after all.

I enjoyed seeing familiar characters return from book 1, A Lady of Valor, but there were no spoilers if you read this first. I did feel like Luke and Clara fell a little flat here, compared to how vibrant they were in book 1, possibly because the author wrote this book first.

Solid 2nd book from Davis; I look forward to seeing her grow as an author. And as the epilogue hints at book 3, we won't have to wait too long!

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Liz.
775 reviews28 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 7, 2026
What factor is most important in choosing a spouse? For Lord Merritt, it was a laugh- a beautiful, guileless sound that revealed a truly loving heart. As the match of the season, he could’ve chosen a woman with a huge dowry or a gorgeous face or an extravagant wardrobe. But he wanted to find “a lady of merit” as his father had, and he knew that she would have a loving and unselfish heart. For him, Margaret’s unstudied laughter as she played with her younger siblings revealed just such a heart. It was interesting to see the lengths he went to in order to meet and marry the girl who saw herself as “plain, insignificant Margaret, the girl who felt she could never belong.”

This is a gentle and chaste romance that has the feeling of an arranged marriage, and yet the thrill of a Cinderella story. In the end, it isn’t money or possessions or social standing that makes for true happiness, but honesty and submission to one another’s needs. I am grateful I received an advance reader copy of this gem, and was not required to post a review. The epilogue leaves a nice clue as to the next book in this delightful series!
11 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 11, 2026
Review of advance copy received from author.

I dearly enjoyed this second installment of Rosecrest Estate. The author shows a lot of promise! It was a very easy, cozy read with a touch of drama and miscommunication to keep you invested right through the whole book. I love how John's playfulness ultimately helps Maggie be herself in all aspects of her life, not hiding her personality away in the privacy of her relationship with her siblings, and how loving Maggie helps John open back up after the heartbreak of losing his father. How sweet to know we can be loved even when we don't feel loveable or worthy of love. Something to work on in my opinion would be more authentic conversational language. Also, in one place John tells Maggie that the staff practiced lining up to welcome her to Rosecrest and "deciding who would stand where." They would have stood according to where they rank in service, no deciding needed. I noticed a couple of things like that. But overall a very sweet book. The very last bit of the epilogue made me teary eyed and I will look forward to reading the next installment.

I received this book free from the author/publisher, but this honest review is voluntary.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
1 review
Review of advance copy
July 8, 2026
I am always looking for new authors of sweet, clean regency romances and Kiylee Davis did not disappoint with ‘A Lady of Merritt’!

The story features a hasty marriage followed by a ‘getting to know you’ dynamic. I love when authors show us the perspective of both main characters, which she does beautifully. The point of view flips back and forth a bit more frequently than what I’m used to, but after a few chapters I was so engrossed in the story and chemistry that I didn’t even notice anymore.

I couldn’t put the book down, finishing it in just a few days. The length and pacing was perfect. While some plot lines were predictable (in a comfortable way) there was some surprising twists which made it that much more enjoyable. It was a wonderful sweet, clean regency romance.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. I did purchase her first book, A Lord of Valor, to read prior to reading this which I really enjoyed. Looking forward to the next book in the series!
Profile Image for Courtney Pityer.
1,216 reviews74 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 21, 2026
As someone who greatly enjoyed Kiylee's first book in the Rosecrest Estate series I will say that this second installment was absolutely perfect. It was filled with wit and mystery which managed to keep my attention the whole time I was reading it. You really have to feel for the main heroine Margaret as she is very self conscious about herself and worried about making the wrong move. You also have to admire John for going out of his way to make his new wife as comfortable as possible while dealing with his own issues.

As mentioned Margaret hasn't had much luck with fitting in and of course her parents pressuring her to secure a marriage for her. John of course sweeps in and offers her a promising future at Rosecrest. She is welcomed with open arms and both her and John slowly start to build their relationship. However, there are outside mysteries such as her sister who ran away to get married and John himself who starts recieving anonymous letters. Will they be able to get to the bottom of things before it threatens their relationship?
Profile Image for Kass Rob.
403 reviews19 followers
August 22, 2026
Ok! So I absolutely adore this cutie author, Kiylee Davis! And getting to read A Lady of Merit was extra special! And OH MY GOODNESS, I loved this book! I especially loved knowing that parts of Margaret and John’s story mirrored a little bit of Kiylee’s own love story! It made all those sweet moments feel even more special! Every character was just so lovable, but my heart especially melted watching Margaret, who is so used to taking care of everyone else, finally have someone who wanted to take care of HER!

Margaret and John were absolutely precious together! Their marriage of convenience, growing friendship, and slow build romance gave me ALL the warm fuzzies, and I loved watching Margaret discover that she deserved to be loved, supported, and simply allowed to be herself! Add in the adorable kids, family moments, a little mystery, and plenty of sweetness, and this was such a delightful addition to the Rosecrest Estate series! I can not wait to see what comes next!

Thank you so much to the author for the advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
9 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 29, 2026
This is a sweet regency story. Remembering that it is a story, not real life, then one can fathom that John Merritt is as wonderful as that. Always thinking of his lady and seeing in her what she does not see for herself. Were it only real-life! But isn't that part of what stories are -- delving into the fairytale and taking what we need for the moment. Never a moment to be embarrassed, but totally a great read.

While I was not a BETA reader, I do have to list the egregious reason for not being able, in clear conscience to give this book a 5-star. I pinned three places where the same error occurred. When one puts on clothes, it is called "donning clothing" or "to don" my jacket. The writer, three times in various places in the book, used the word "dawn". Even though I seldom give 5-stars; this was reason enough to not even consider it.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
1 review1 follower
Review of advance copy
July 8, 2026
Kiylee has a great writing style. It flowed together nicely with the first book in the series. While I found the plot to be predictable, the author made each character so likable and relatable that it made me want to read more. The only reason I did not give the book a 5th star was because I felt it could use more historical details of the time and plot development (twists and turns) to keep readers even more engaged.

I enjoyed the perspective of miscommunication in marriage and the humor and also importance of it. The book makes you root for the main couple to overcome the obstacles and see growth because of each other. Overall it is an easy read to jump in and out of for a busy mom’s schedule and a good book.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
14 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 15, 2026
A Lady of Merit is a sweet, heartwarming romance with endearing characters you'll find yourself cheering for from beginning to end.

While I enjoyed the first book in the series, I felt this installment was more fully developed. The first novel left me wanting to know more about the main characters, and at times the romance felt a bit rushed and overly idealized. In contrast, this book does a better job of exploring the characters' backstories, making their relationship feel more authentic and believable.

My only wish is that there had been a little more of a "getting to know you" journey between John and Maggie before their romance progressed. Even so, their story was engaging and satisfying.

If you're looking for a wholesome, enjoyable historical romance with likable characters and a heartfelt love story, A Lady of Merit is definitely worth reading.
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 23, 2026
I read book 1 of this series. I enjoyed book 2 a bit more than book 1. I personally like a mystery element and a bit of drama, which this book had. I would say that while I rejoiced with characters in their happiness I did not fall in love with the characters as I have with other characters in other historical romance novels. What would have brought Margaret and John's story to 5 stars for me would have been a bit more mystery and drama and a mystery that was not so easily solved by the reader before it was revealed to the characters. I also would have liked a bit more length to the story to allow for just a bit more character development. Overall I would recommend this book to the plethora of readers who appreciate lighter reads than I generally choose.

I did not purchase this book and appreciate being given this copy for the purpose of reviewing it in advance.
4 reviews
August 14, 2026
I LOVED this book! Such a beautiful regency story that is loosely based on a fairytale (if you know you know). I thought all of the characters were well written, and the plot was pretty unique even though this is a romance book. I read a couple of reviews here that said that the main heroine is too self-depreciating. I disagree. Yes, the heroine is self-depreciating, but it is perfectly understandable given the environment she grew up in. I didn't find it unrealistic or annoying in the slightest. In fact, one of my favorite aspects of the book was seeing her self-love and confidence increase. If you're on the fence with this book, give it a go! I read it all in one day because I couldn't put it down. I later read it to my husband on a long road trip, and he also loved it even though it is outside of his usual genre. We both laughed and cried multiple times. Highly recommend!
Profile Image for Constance M..
483 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 25, 2026
While this book is in a series, reading the first one is not entirely necessary. Certainly it provides character and setting background, but can be read alone.

I really enjoyed reading this tale. The contract between the two families is so astute, and provides a deeper understanding of reactions and feelings, especially the FMC. She has grown up in a basically loveless home (at least in terms of parents) and was always expected to obey and ensure that appearances and reputation were of foremost importance.

Being introduced into a loving, compassionate environment, she is unsure of her place, and thinks she needs to live up to the standards she imagines they want from her.

How happy she finally becomes to realize that she can be herself and live a joyous life with her new husband.
794 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy
July 27, 2026
I’m so happy to see John come out of his self imposed shell and become the man he was meant to be. How would I respond if the duty of a title and all it entails were thrust upon me?

I love how he’s drawn to Maggie because of her authentic laughter as he passes by. He knows the unfiltered joy is something he needs and he’s determined to go after it.

I don’t alway enjoy instalove stories but this book is so well written that John’s immediate attraction doesn’t feel forced. The characters relate to each other in a way that feels natural.

This is a sweet romance with a storyline that’s a bit different which drew me in and had me invested in the outcome.

I was given a copy courtesy of the author through booksirens and this is my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 51 reviews