Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle was such a childhood favorite — my third grade teacher read it aloud to an enraptured class — that when I found this three-volume treasury on a discount book table as a teenager, I begged my mother to buy it.
Now the same three-volume treasury is in my keeping, and I had the joy of introducing my own children to Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle over the past couple of months. Of particular delight was how enthusiastically my 8yo responded to the book; he doesn't typically show as much interest in the books we read as his younger siblings do, but he couldn't get enough of Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle. (He has repeatedly voiced disappointment that I refuse to turn around and reread the entire book immediately.)
Mingled with the delight of sharing the book, I also had the fun of returning to something beloved from childhood better able to understand why it was so captivating. The premise of the book is exceptionally clever and permits the author to write a didactic book that is anything but tedious and moralistic. At one and the same time, the stories are both subversive and affirming of virtue: we relish the spectacle of children's bad behavior, which is told humorously and realistically, and then, in some cases, the cure ramps up that bad behavior for even greater comic effect before resolving it. The young audience of these books are prompted to root for the right even as they are amused (perhaps morbidly fascinated) by the wrong.
What I appreciate most about the philosophy behind Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle's cures is that they are much more than a bandaid for bad behavior. Each and every cure teaches the afflicted child to crave virtue, not merely because it leads to appropriate actions, but because it has been shown to be so desirable. Hence the cure for bad table manners involves an extremely polite pig who exhibits the attractions of etiquette; the cure for heedless breaking is a magic powder that causes one to move slowly and gracefully, "like a queen" (a pleasing sensation); the cure for children who don't want to go to bed is to find out how miserable they become without sleep. The mechanism of cures varies — which is what makes the collection fun to read — but all the cures involve a change of mind before change of action.
Another delight of returning to the books: the world of Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle is charming in an old-fashioned way that I didn't perceive as a child. It's a world where mothers phone friends to discuss their problems, kids rollerskate and play neighborhood games and attend movies on the weekend, adults play cards, fathers turn on radios or read newspapers and take their children to the drugstore for ice cream sodas. In the domestic realm, there is a lot of cooking and baking (after-school snacks to make your mouth water!), ironing, mending, sewing, gardening. Children are always popping over to Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle's house; they often walk to school and each other's houses. On the one hand, these things are not very removed from our world; but the more I thought about it, I had to admit these aren't typical accessories to modern life, and the aura of antiquity gives the book a very cozy domestic feeling.
One note on rating: this volume contains the first, second, and fourth Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle installment, but for some reason their ordering is 1, 4, 2 (perhaps because the second volume sounds a note of finality). I found the middle book (published ten years after the first two) much less captivating than the earlier two, and even its morality somewhat troubling (is "leadership" the opposite of "bullying"? is enterprise a proper remedy for daydreaming...and should daydreaming be suppressed entirely?). Were I rating the first, and perhaps the second, volume alone, I'd give it 5 stars; the fourth would get 2 or 3.