Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

To All the Earls I've Loved Before: A BRAND NEW sizzling second chance Regency romance from Emma Orchard for 2026

Rate this book
The BRAND NEW addictive, spicy and scandalous Regency romance from Emma Orchard. An unmissable second chance romance if you love Bridgerton, Eloisa James and Sophie Irwin! 🌶️💕'If you're girding your loins for Bridgerton, you may want to indulge in this Regency romp' THE TIMES ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Bianca Constantine has no intention of surrendering her freedom to marriage. Newly wealthy and determined to make her name as an artist, she plans to avoid the dangers of Society altogether – until a chance encounter with a charming young lord draws her back into London’s glittering world.

Commissioned to paint the boy’s portrait, Bianca expects nothing more scandalous than long afternoons in an elegant townhouse. Instead, she comes face to face with the one man she hoped never to see again.

The summer Bianca spent in Venice with Xan Challender was filled with passion, freedom, and lies. She never told him she was an heiress. He never revealed that he was set to inherit an earldom.

Now Xan has returned to England to claim his title, and neither has forgotten the betrayal that tore them apart – or the desire that still burns between them.

What happened in Venice should stay in Venice - but some secrets are just too explosive to stay hidden...

Praise for Emma

'An exciting new talent' - KATIE FFORDE

'Hot stuff. I loved it!' - FERN BRITTON

'Absolutely glorious' - SOPHIE IRWIN

'A delicious Regency romp' - ALAN TITCHMARSH

'Sensual and exciting' - HEIDI SWAIN

'Heyer with spice!' - LIZ FENWICK

'Witty, heartfelt, deeply emotionally authentic and incredibly sexy' - KATY MORAN

'Sexy, seductive and swoon worthy' - SARAH BENNETT

'Witty, spicy, seductive' - HANNAH DOLBY

'Perfect for fans of Bridgerton' - DARCIE BOLEYN

'Fans of Heyer and Bridgerton rejoice!' - CHARLOTTE BUTTERFIELD

'The bonking was hot' – KJ CHARLES

'A delicious slice of escapism' - LAURA WOOD

'Heart-thumping romance' - JENNI KEER

305 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 30, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Emma Orchard

14 books113 followers
Emma Orchard was born in Salford. She studied English Literature at the Universities of Edinburgh and York, before working behind the scenes in publishing and television for many years. Her first job was at Mills & Boon, where she met her husband in a classic enemies-to-lovers romance. She now lives in North London.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
31 (32%)
4 stars
44 (46%)
3 stars
17 (18%)
2 stars
1 (1%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews
Profile Image for Jody Lee.
1,034 reviews59 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 12, 2026
Oooh this was juicy! Told in dual timeline, but I didn't mind at all, because it was totally necessary to the story, and also perfectly structured. She cut back and forth when exactly when she needed to each time. We are three years post-How to Not Marry a Lord, and the youngest sister Bianca is back in England after a extended trip abroad, mainly Italy, where she studied and produced her art. She's staying with a sister in London and painting in the shared park when she meets little Adrian, son of an Earl living on the same square. One thing leads to another and she is commissioned to paint Adrian's picture, one day the earl walks in and IT'S HER LOVER FROM VENICE Xan. Who she basically left with a "thanks for the fun" note. And whom she told she was a widow, not a society heiress.

One thing I particularly loved about this book is that all the hard feelings and conflict are her fault, which she freely admits, "because of all the lies she'd spun him, and above all the manner in which she'd left him." We get details told in very effective use of flashback, including at one point seeing a scene from two different POVs once more information has been revealed. He's trying to make sense of everything, lashing out and miserable. Because here's the thing, these two were OBSESSED with each other. Like sizzling chemistry, and ignoring all other obligations. There's a scene very early on where he's confessing his attraction (in a way that seems out of character but we'll allow it) and he essentially is like, don't you dare do anything provocative, everything you do turns me on, and she's like, you mean {eats cream-filled pastry and licks lips]? It's so great.

Anyway, that mutual obsession is still there. And they are remarkably communicative, still each super attracted to the other and freely talking about it. She explains her lie (it was an established persona so she could travel solo, her old governess came up with the idea). Later, again, perfectly placed, she talks about what was on her mind when she pulled a runner, and he actually listens and agrees that it was her only option.

Because of course, sometimes love isn't enough. A woman has to take it on trust that her husband will let her keep at her work, and follow her muse. Especially Bianca, who has independence and a supportive family and her own fortune, and never intended to marry. I respected Orchard for not taking the easy solution when Bianca essentially is offered everything she could want.

Let's talk about the real MVP of the book Lady Deborah, whose motto is basically "But reflect for a moment and you will see that I am right." She's just out here masterminding stuff and calling it like she sees it and sticking her nose in everywhere. "It was either the operation of malign fate, or his aunt's deliberate doing. Admittedly, it was quite often difficult to tell one from the other." We love a bossy old lady who dgaf.

I texted a friend who I knew also had this arc at 62% and reported that I was terrified Orchard would not be able to land this plane because it was such a strong first half. I'm happy to report she completely did. Even with the resolution of the HEA, which initially felt unbalanced to me, I realized Orchard alludes to plans and compromise and comforting reassurances between our MCs making it work beautifully. What a pleasure to read such a well crafted and emotional work.

Thank you to Boldwood and Netgalley for the arc.
Profile Image for _boundbytales.
233 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 29, 2026
╰► 3.5/5 ⭐️(rounding down)

To All the Earl's I've Loved Before:

Thank you to NetGalley and Bookwood Books for offering me an Advanced Reader Copy of To All the Earls I've Loved Before in exchange for an honest review.

From the very first page, we are thrown into Bianca Constantine's world of art, desire, passion, and independence. Bianca is a woman who refuses to fit neatly into the expectations placed upon women of her time. While society might expect her to settle down, find a suitable husband, and follow the path that has been laid out for her, Bianca has other ambitions. She wants to expand her artistic abilities, learn from some of the greatest artists in the world, and pursue a life that is of her own making.

So when she meets a stranger while traveling alone, she never expects for her life to change.

This was my first introduction to Emma Orchard's work, and I was pleasantly surprised. I found myself enjoying her writing. There is something very immersive about her prose, particularly in the regency language that made it into every scene. I enjoyed reading the moments from the past and seeing how the connection played out between Zan and Bianca. I enjoyed the odd friendship with Lady Deborah, and who could forget little Lord Dawbney who stole my heart from the first moment we met him.

While I enjoyed the second-chance romance, the banter, the characters, and the world-building, I did feel as though something was missing. My biggest issue was the pacing. The chapters are quite short, which can work incredibly well in a romance because it keeps the story moving and makes the book easy to read. However, in this case, I occasionally felt as though the story moved forward before certain moments had the opportunity to fully develop. There was room to expand on the side characters, room to expand scenes with more dialogue and flesh the characters out a bit more.

The story wasn't bad, I just wanted more details, more emotions behind each scene.

From what I understand, this is a later book in a bigger series. Perhaps if I had read the previous stories, I might have felt like I knew the side characters a bit more. However, not having read the previous books was not an issue in terms of following along with this story. I would definitely be interested in reading more of Emma Orchard's work in the future. For my first introduction to her writing, To All the Earl's I've Loved Before was an enjoyable historical romance with a strong-willed heroine, a second-chance love story, plenty of banter, and some memorable supporting characters.

My rating system:
⭐️: Not my vibe at all.
⭐️⭐️: I finished it, but I didn't have a good time.
⭐️⭐️⭐️: Yeah, that was fun. I enjoyed myself. I probably won't reread it, but it was fun.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️: I loved it and want to read more from this author.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️: Perfect, amazing, everything I love in a novel!
Profile Image for VickydpBooks.
1,344 reviews25 followers
October 25, 2026
I am going to be honest this one I wasn’t overly keen on reading because it gave me Bridgeton vibes!

If you love Bridgerton, Eloisa James and Sophie Irwin, this sounds like an absolute must-read! 🌶️💕

A fiercely independent heroine, a charming lord with secrets of his own, and a passionate summer romance that comes back to haunt them years later? Yes, please! 😍

Bianca Constantine is determined to live life on her own terms, pursuing her dream of becoming an artist rather than settling into the expectations of Society. But when a commission brings her face-to-face with Xan Challender, the man who broke her heart in Venice, things get deliciously complicated.

Neither of them was entirely honest during their summer together, and now that they’re back in London, old betrayals and unresolved feelings are impossible to ignore. Add in plenty of Regency glamour, simmering tension, scandalous secrets and a second-chance romance, and I’m already hooked!

I love the sound of a heroine who refuses to be confined by Society’s rules, especially when there’s a swoon-worthy lord and unfinished business involved. Give me the ballroom drama, the stolen glances and all that delicious romantic tension! 💋🔥

Definitely one for fans of witty Regency romance, strong heroines and steamy second chances! 💕📚
Profile Image for Maja.
671 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 25, 2026
Thanks a lot to Boldwood Books for providing this ARC!

First, I am thankful that this book worked as a standalone, because this was actually my first read by Emma Orchard. But, it might not be my last, because I did enjoy To All the Earls I've Loved Before a whole lot!

The dual POV and dual timelines only made the experience better and both Biana and Xan grew on me while reading - especially Bianca, our artist, who wants to be independent and travel the world, which is, as we know, frowned upon when it comes to women in the Regency Era. And on top of that, she had a short affair with a man.... oh what a scandal!

The story was fun, it was spicy, heartwarming and romantic. Can totally recommend!
Profile Image for Bene_reads_books.
573 reviews73 followers
October 31, 2026
I review a digital advance copy provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
What happened in Venice should stay in Venice.
Well, as a Venice lover myself, I'm happy that Bianca and Xan's story didn't stay in Venice.
It's a Regency romance with a twist : because Bianca is an artist, because Bianca is a free spirit, because Bianca is a liar.
Dual timelines are not easy to manage and the author does it well, the story's structure is flawless. Xan and Bianca are endearing and their chemistry is palpable. Lady Deborah is a fantastic secondary character.
I really enjoyed myself reading this book.
Profile Image for Jilly.
434 reviews2 followers
October 16, 2026
I enjoyed this book. It's been a while since I've read books based around proper English social norms in the 1800s. It was still romantic trope, but it offered some differences from the usual chick lit.
I did feel like it had some side story info that could have been deleted as it was unnecessary to the plot. It almost felt like it was a second book in a series, or the author was leaving an opening to have future books about some of Bianca's sisters. It made the book longer than it needed to be.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Dieuwke.
Author 1 book13 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 14, 2026
To All the Earls I've loved Before is another enjoyable read by Emma Orchard whose "A most unsuitable Suitor" and "How to NOT marry a Lord" I love with a passion.
Talking of passion: Bianca, the youngest of the Constantine sisters has a few. None as burning as the passion she feels for Xan Challender whom she meets in his own house, whilst she is painting his son, little Lord Dawnbey, not two years later, he now an Earl, and she no longer under an assumed name.

We need both time lines as gradually it is revealed what has transpired between them and why. The early longing and passion and the laying eyes on each other again are amongst the best parts. (the cafe in Venice scene is fabulous) The range of emotions both characters go through are well fleshed out.

I can't say anything about the plot, but will admit there's no shortage of cunning women and I read it on one lovely autumnal Sunday, having a blast.
Why three stars and not the solid four of the other two mentioned here in the first sentence? For me the ending was too constructed and too prolongued/drawn out.

Still, absolutely recommend reading it
Out October 30th

I received an ARC from NetGalley/Boldwood in return for my honest opinion
Profile Image for Meg Pearson.
807 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 13, 2026
To All the Earls I’ve Loved Before by Emma Orchard was an absolutely delightful Regency romp! If you love Bridgerton-style romance, scandalous secrets, independent heroines, and second chances at love, this one deserves a spot on your TBR. 💕

Bianca Constantine is a heroine after my own heart. She’s an artist, an heiress, and a woman determined to live life on her own terms in a world that would much rather see her settled into a respectable marriage. I loved her passion for her art and her refusal to give up her independence simply because society expects her to. There’s something refreshing about a historical romance that acknowledges that finding love and finding yourself don't always have to be mutually exclusive.

While travelling in Venice, Bianca enjoys a passionate affair with a man she never expects to see again. Fast-forward to London, where she’s commissioned to paint the portrait of a young earl’s son, only to discover that the earl is none other than her former lover, Xan! Cue the unresolved feelings, awkward encounters, delicious romantic tension, and secrets that refuse to stay buried. 😂

I particularly enjoyed the dual timeline, which gradually reveals what happened between Bianca and Xan in Venice and adds so much context to their reunion. Their chemistry is undeniable, but this is about more than rekindling an old flame. It’s about trust, forgiveness, and figuring out whether love can work when two people have very different ideas about what their futures should look like.

I also adored the supporting cast, especially Lady Deborah, who absolutely steals her scenes with her sharp observations and wonderfully meddlesome ways. The family dynamics and sisterly relationships add warmth and humour, while the Regency setting provides the perfect backdrop for all the romantic complications.

My one reservation was that the pacing felt a little drawn out in the latter part of the book. I occasionally wanted the story to move along a little faster, particularly as Bianca wrestled with her feelings and the future she wanted. Nevertheless, the central romance and the exploration of female independence kept me invested.

While the characters sometimes express ideas and enjoy freedoms that feel more modern than the historical period, I approached this as a romantic fantasy rather than a strictly authentic depiction of Regency society—and thoroughly enjoyed it on those terms!

Overall, this was a charming, romantic, and entertaining read with a spirited heroine, plenty of chemistry, and a lovely reminder that a happily-ever-after shouldn't require a woman to abandon the life she wants for herself.

If you love Bridgerton, second-chance romances, and historical heroines who dare to write their own rules, give this one a try!

Thank you to NetGalley, Boldwood Books, and Emma Orchard for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
442 reviews3 followers
November 15, 2026
I've read most, if not all, of Emma Orchard's books so far. So, my question to myself is how I didn't realise until now that several of the previous books involved the Constantine sisters? I will admit I immediately connected with the previous installment for the sisters but now that I have made this discovery, it's all falling into place for me.

Bianca Constantine is one of the three sister who inherited a home and fortune from a distant aunt. This puts her in a good position to do as she pleases without needing a husband to keep her safe and sound. She has taken a sojourn of sorts into Italy with her chaperone and she spends her time painting and exploring. But eventually they part ways for their own adventures and she finds herself in Venice. She is happily painting as she wishes and has used a partially false name and identity for her own protection. She is known to be a young widow and this is the situation when she meets Xan, who really is a widower and has a young child back at home. There's an intense relationship that develops between these two and then Bianca leaves quite suddenly. When we next see her, she's staying with her sister in London, and painting outside much of the time. It's here she meets the young boy, Adrian, and they develop a friendship very quickly. It's not long before revelations are made and there's some reckoning to be made by both Bianca and Xan for previous offenses.

The story shifts back and forth between Venice time and London time so that we don't get the full picture until quite late in the story. It's obvious where things are going but the fun is seeing what sort of path it takes to get there. I was really pleased with this story, especially once I had my realisation of the connection between this and several other books. I like the way this story was handled and it had a feminist bent without it being too rigid about it. Both Bianca and Xan have experiences that shape them and how they move about the world. Much of Xan's experience involves growing up with a father and brother who weren't the best of people, but also with a marriage that had its own stories. Bianca's experience is more based on the mores of the day for women but finding a way to add some independence at the same time. I think it worked out nicely and never felt like too out of balance to me.

While I don't think it's necessary to have read the earlier books, they do provide a bit of background that might fill in some blanks. I don't find there's too much repetition, though, from the previous tales, like sometimes happens in series of books.

Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for the free advanced copy. I've provided my feedback under no obligation.
Profile Image for Lisa Castore.
73 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 20, 2026
For readers who love the gossip, longing, and spice of historical romances like Bridgerton & Pride and Prejudice.

Bianca and Xan’s lives are never the same after their paths cross in this regency romance. Bianca is fiercely independent, Xan has a chip on his shoulder, and their connection is electric. The story follows their romance with dual POV’s and dual timelines around the 1810’s across Europe.

* Mid size FMC
* MC’s in their 20’s
* Second chance
* LGBTQ rep
* Light spice

There’s clear commentary on both classism and sexism during this time, and a liberating depiction of defying these limits.

I don’t want to give so much away, but the conflict upon her return to London feels adjacent to miscommunication and is therefore frustrating to me. That being said, the yearning is primal and visceral through out and successfully drives the plot. However, the long awaited spice at the end of the book was brief and underwhelming.

Both characters are revealed to be flawed in their own ways. I usually appreciate this, but at one point in the beginning of the book Xan’s threat to “take” a woman without her consent crossed a line - it made him highly unlikable and dampened the thick romantic tension that was there. I did however appreciate how realistically his shame was depicted as shaped by his father and brother. I also love a slightly awkward and reclusive MMC (think The Sunken Archives duology by Sylvia Cathrall) and Xan did not disappoint. However, his sudden shift in character at the end of the book seemed TOO out of character, stifling the natural progression and releasing the tension too early.

As for Bianca, I don’t fully understand her difficulty in making her decision, the resolution seemed obvious and inevitable, but perhaps frequent readers of historical romance would disagree. It was also difficult to keep track of all of her stares. It would have been just as affective to have two (rather than 5) without sacrificing the plot.

The writing style is dense and felt too labored specifically in the beginning when establishing backstory. The story seemed to slow a bit too much at certain points, especially in the middle amidst each characters internal ramblings, as well as the last 20 pages. The dialogue featured run on sentences/monologues that, at times, felt fabulously reminiscent of Shonda Rhimes, while at other times felt confusing and unnatural.

Thank you to Boldwood Books and Emma Orchard for the free advanced copy.
Profile Image for Paloma.
843 reviews10 followers
November 2, 2026
What is an independent young rich woman, with the desire to paint and travel the world, to do when society doesn't allow her to be by herself without a chaperone? Well she makes up a story about being a young widow living modestly who enjoys painting. That is what our main protagonist Bianca Constantine, passing as Signora Bianca Rossi, did while she traveled through Venice. Soon she stumbles into Xan Challender, a very handsome English man who becomes completely obsessed with her and thus begins a small but intense affair with Signora Rossi. while she visited Venice. But the love affair is short lived as Bianca realizes that she has so much to loose from this situationship and she must return home to her sisters.
Upon returning home, Bianca meets Lord Dawbey while she is painting. He is a young boy who becomes smitten with Bianca and her painting. It is a novelty to see a female artist and specially one who doesn't care what polite company has to say about her. Soon Bianca is called in by Lady Deborah Townshend who is the young Lord's great aunt, and who wants his portrait done so when his father Lord Fairmont returns, it can be a gift and surprise. But the surprise is between Signora Rossi and Xan when they discover they are Bianca and Lord Fairmont and that they had a steamy but meaningful affair and then Bianca ghosted Xan and he did not take it well.

I devoured this beautiful gem. It was so smooth, wonderfully written and very enjoyable. Reading about Signora Rossi and Xan in the past, how they met and how deep their rendezvous was, helped to see how and why Lord Fairmont was so hurt and angry at her. Meeting in the present was shocking but very entertaining. He definitely didn't take the ghosting well but you can tell he still feels a lot for Bianca. I also enjoyed reading a bit more about her sisters and their little secrets. They are good sisters and supported Bianca in all her decisions. Oh and let's not forget Lady Wellbeloved, who I feel she ended up helping Bianca and Fairmont get closer together faster than hurting them with her gossip. Another great work by the great Emma Orchard.
Thank you Netgalley and Boldwood Books for this eARC. All opinions are entirely my own.
486 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 29, 2026
Get set for real treat from Emma Orchard as we return to the somewhat extraordinary world of the Constantine family, in To All The Earl’s I’ve Loved Before, as we join Bianca in Vienna in 1817, thoroughly enjoying her life as a painter and Widow, a guise created to allow her to move freely about the Town as a single woman.
Xan Challender has come to Vienna to see the sights. He is a widower still mourning his wife, their relationship one that was fraught with issues and his young son, left in England with a beloved Aunt. He is somewhat overwhelmed by the immense beauty that is Vienna. A chance meeting between the two leads to a short-lived affair of the heart, which while deeply passionate, is cut short by Bianca.
The next time the two meet is in London at the home of the now Lord Fairmount as she has been commissioned to paint the portrait of his son Adrian. Master Adrian is a delightful child and the two build a friendship valued on both sides.
A day like any other day turned out to be anything but as Xan, now Lord Fairmount, upon the death of his dissolute brother, and Bianca meet unexpectedly in his townhouse, shocking them both, bringing back memories that still have the power to hurt deeply.
The old saying comes true, as what a tangled web they both did weave in Vienna, which is now forcing them both to not only face themselves, but sort through the mess they have made of their romance.
As the days pass, they dance around each other, until young Adrian becomes seriously unwell, calling for his friend Bianca. Being in daily proximity is a small torture, but also makes the benighted lovers realise that they may be, could be, are almost surely in love. But what to do about it is the real question. She wants her freedom to paint, and he simply wants to marry her!
Join in the chaos that ensues as you turn the pages of To All The Earl’s I’ve Loved Before and enjoy every moment of this most enjoyable Regency Romp.


Profile Image for Connie.
2,665 reviews62 followers
October 30, 2026
Bianca Constatine is a young woman who has received a large inheritance from a relative which has allowed her to spend some time in Italy painting the beautiful sights. Now, she has returned to London to stay with one of her many sisters. Bianca doesn’t want to marry. With her own money she does not need a husband to care for her. She wants nothing more than to travel and paint.

Out painting one day, she is approached by a young boy who introduces himself as Lord Dawbney, son of Earl Fairmount, a widower. They enjoy a chat and then his great-aunt staying with them invites her to tea and requests that she paint Lord Dawbney. She is happy to do so and as he is a very intelligent little boy, they spend time enjoying one another’s company. One day, his father comes to where they are painting and when he and Bianca see one another, they freeze.

Alexander (Xander) Challender once met Bianca in Italy and evidently had an affair with her which both of them vehemently denied. Now, Xander realizes that she lied to him using another name which angers him and he wants nothing to do with her. However, neither one of them can deny their passion for one another.

As they try to avoid one another, society puts them together and they protest that there is any attraction. Can they finally relent and be together or will they just not suit?

This is a rather different romance story where the heroine vehemently wants to have her cake and eat it too. But sometimes life will not let us deny what we truly want. That is what we see here. I liked the book and enjoy the author’s books. I can’t help but say that I wished Bianca had been easier to convince to give into her desires.

Copy provided by NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Profile Image for Winnifred D..
1,074 reviews39 followers
November 7, 2026
Tropes: enemies to lovers; MFC with a fake persona; stuffy MMC
Steam level: 2-3
Part of a series; fine on its own.

2.5 head-scratching stars squeaked up. This HR was not what I'd hoped for. The writing style is solid but the storyline could have easily been edited to novella length. The flash backs introduce engaging secondary characters without developing the MC's well enough. Too much telling, too much ruminating, too much unearned angst. Instead of true chemistry there's insta-lust. The mains talk at each other when they're not overthinking.

MMC Xan is quite oblivious and immature, often overreacting, and despite the plot machinations I somehow hoped MFC Bianca would not end up with him. He does finally have a rather abrupt arc around the 80% mark, and there are sweet exchanges between Bianca and his son (hence the 3 stars) but most of the scenes between the MC's left me feeling annoyed or indifferent. I failed to see how marrying Xan would benefit Bianca, other than the fact that she would be mother to his son.

I have to mention that this book doesn't really qualify as erotica, as the spice is not graphic and just takes place near the beginning and end of the book. Otherwise, the MC's have the occasional sexy thought. Puzzlingly, there is no final open door consummation scene.

I enjoyed an earlier book by this author but, honestly, this one disappointed me.

This is my honest, voluntary review of an advanced reader copy of this book. Thanks to the author, publisher, and Net Galley.
33 reviews1 follower
September 29, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the ARC opportunity in exchange for an honest review.

2.5ish stars. I really wanted to love this one. The premise is fun—a second-chance Regency romance that brings Bianca and Xan back together after their summer in Venice—and whenever the story returned to their Venice interactions, I was completely on board. Their chemistry and the push-and-pull between them were delightful, and those Venice scenes were easily my favorite parts of the book.

Unfortunately, I struggled with the London timeline. There was a lot of narration and explanation without enough action or character interaction to keep the story moving for me. At times, it felt like I was being told about what was happening rather than getting to experience it alongside the characters.

I also found the number of names and titles used for the same characters tedious. Moving between nicknames, first names, surnames, and society titles made it harder than necessary to keep track of some of the supporting characters and the surrounding world-building. I found myself having to stop and remind myself who was who more often than I would have liked.

Overall, there were definitely elements I enjoyed, particularly Bianca and Xan’s Venice scenes and their unresolved feelings for each other, but the London portion made for a more uneven reading experience. For me, this landed around 2.5 stars.
Profile Image for Roux Coe.
25 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 22, 2026
Firstly, thank you to Emma Orchard and Boldwood Books for sending me an ARC of To All the Earls I’ve Loved Before. After reading and really enjoying my ARC of How to Not Marry a Lord, I was so excited to be chosen to review the next spicy, regency romance from Emma.

The story weaves together two different timelines, letting us watch the history between our main couple, Bianca and Xan, slowly unravel alongside the present drama. Those flashbacks dropped just enough tantalising clues to keep me hooked, building the tension step-by-step until everything finally comes to a head.

This book builds beautifully on Bianca’s character arc, giving our heroine so much more depth as she attempts to forge her own path and make her own decisions in a world where she is expected to conform to strict rules. We are also offered a fascinating peek into her high-society family’s intricate (and often delightfully messy!) dynamics.

The evocative prose captures the period's charm while keeping the narrative lively, seamlessly weaving together swoon-worthy romance, deliciously spicy, toe-curling moments and perfectly timed comedy.

Discovering Emma’s work has been such a joyful, comforting escape. Her stories are a breath of fresh air, and I couldn't recommend them more to anyone craving a beautifully romantic, swoon-worthy Regency read to sweep them away while waiting for the next season of Bridgerton!
1,570 reviews
October 31, 2026
Bianca Constantine has no intention of giving up her freedom or becoming someone's wife. Newly wealthy and determined to establish herself as an artist, she is happy to stay away from Society until a commission to paint a young lord's portrait brings her back into London. Unfortunately, it also brings her face-to-face with Xan Challender, the man she fell for during a passionate summer in Venice. Neither had been completely honest about their circumstances, and now that Xan has returned to England as an earl, the hurt and attraction between them are still very much alive.
I liked Bianca's independence and her determination to pursue a life of her own rather than simply settling into the expected role of an aristocratic wife. Her artistic ambitions also gave her character something a little different, and I enjoyed the contrast between her desire for freedom and the expectations surrounding her.
The second-chance aspect worked well, particularly with the history between Bianca and Xan. Their time together in Venice gave their relationship an emotional foundation, although I sometimes found the misunderstandings and secrets between them a little frustrating. There was good chemistry between them, but I would have liked a little more development of their relationship and some of the emotional conflict. An enjoyable read!
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own. 
Profile Image for Carolina CHC.
395 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 15, 2026
I sometimes forget about Emma Orchard's stories, caught up in discovering new author, and in life itself, but then, an ARC of hers comes along, and it's the perfect reminder of just how much I enjoy her writing.

This is the story of the youngest Constantine sister, Bianca: an independent artist who, beyond her talent, is deeply devoted to her craft. Being an heiress in her own right makes many things easier for her, so when she meets an English stranger while traveling alone, she never imagines just how much her life will change a year later.

Alexander, Xan, is trying to survive his own grief when he decides to take time off to travel the continent. In Venice, he meets an enigmatic woman who changes the way he sees life, love, and passion for the rest of his life. That fate would later rearrange a meeting with the woman he never forgot is something he never expected. But discovering that she isn't quite who he remembers feels like a betrayal he can hardly forgive.

This story is charming, even if it isn't quite the typical regency fiction you might expect. It has that same inclusive, modern spin Bridgerton brought to the genre. I enjoyed it thoroughly, just as I have the other books in Bianca's sisters' series. 4.5 / 5 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for this ARC. This is my voluntary and honest review.
202 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 13, 2026
Dearest Reader, should you tire of a season with the ton, amidst its doldrum affairs and smog covered streets, spilling with gossip and ever churning scandal, cast your eyes to Italy, loves, there lies a story....
Emma Orchard returns us to the Constantine sisters - the littlest, Bianca, an artist who wished to travel unchaperoned through a pilgrimage of Europe, seeking inspiration to paint, creates a persona of a recently widowed Italian (thank her roots), to escape the scrutiny a heiress and debutante would receive. Xan, a by the book, if you please, middle brother, and recent widower, with a child, finds himself entranced and infatuated with Signora Rossi, as they explore and savor their new fledgling lust (the pastry scene reminding me of Bridgerton's Simon moment in reverse)...
They part ways suddenly, until they meet again with Bianca as the artist booked to paint Xan's son.... what ensues is gossip most salacious, a slew of meddling sisters and aunts and two people who will wilfully misunderstand why they can't seem to fall out of love!
I loved this romp through the Venetian gondolas and revisited Viola and Sabrina, and Bianca was a force of nature, unique, unbridled and very very lucky!
My curtsies to Boldwood Books and Netgalley and my renewed allegiance to Emma Orchard and her growing collections!
#octoberReads #RegencyRomance #SummerIntrigueXLondonReality
60 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 19, 2026
When Miss Bianca Constantine arrived in Venice, it was her love of art that took her there, under an assumed name - Signora Rossi a widow, though she had little experience of men, let alone marriage. Her inheritance had provided the means to travel in comfort and having left her companions in Rome, she was enjoying her freedom. A chance encounter with a handsome, Englishman, Xan Challender, was not something she had expected, but when he stood there, blocking the view that she was painting, she really had no option but to speak. And so began their passionate relationship, both expecting that what happened in Venice, would stay in Venice. But fate had other ideas and through a series of chance encounters, the two are thrown together once again in London, in an attempt to save Bianca's reputation from the scandalous rumours put about by Lady Wellbeloved, who Xan had called on in Venice, when making enquiries about Signora Rossi. I loved the interaction between Bianca and Xan, both the passion and the fury, as each of them struggle to come to terms with their feelings and get to know another better. The landscapes of Venice are lavishly portrayed and provide very welcome escapism as we enter another British Winter. A very worth 5 stars!
31 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 5, 2026
My biggest qualm with To All the Earls I Loved Before is the title! I love a Regency-era romance, and the romance in this book was LOVELY, but our FMC truly only had this one romance.
Bianca and Xan explore such a beautiful and rare relationship set in a time when female sexuality and choice were ultimately taboo or practically nonexistent. Bianca travelling and developing as an individual, rather than simply existing within the confines of her romantic relationship, was such a refreshing take. I also loved that it was dual POV—I think without it, we would have missed so much of Xan’s development and how both of them gradually ended up falling in love.
The time jumps felt a bit stilted at some points, and there were moments where I wanted a little more time with the characters before moving forward. But overall, this was a lush, romantic story between two people who felt almost like equals in a time when that was simply not the norm. Their relationship felt tender, intentional, and genuinely romantic.
A lovely historical romance with characters who were allowed to grow both together and independently.
294 reviews3 followers
October 30, 2026
Bianca Constantine has no interest in marriage or society life, she wants to be an artist and knows that a husband is unlikely to support her in her ambition. She travels to Venice and reinvents herself as Bianca Rossi, a widow, and spends her time studying and painting. A chance meeting with Xan Challender, an Englishman travelling abroad for his health, results in a tumultuous affair. Knowing that the affair won’t lead anywhere and nor does she want it to, Bianca leaves Venice and heads back to London without telling Xan. Once back home, she’s commissioned to paint the portrait of a young boy only to find that he’s Xan’s son and that Xan is now an Earl.

Their stories are told from both of their points of view and, using flashbacks, we learn more about Xan’s family life and Bianca’s burning ambition for her art. Both Bianca and Xan examine themselves and their actions and accept they’ve both been at fault, but will it bring them closer together or drive them further apart?

Another thoroughly enjoyable Regency romance from Emma Orchard.

Thanks to Net Galley and Boldwood Books for an ARC for my honest review.
Profile Image for Mary Gosse.
106 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 30, 2026
This was a good book! I’ve previously read other books in this series, but really they could all stand alone (necessary back-stories of side characters were all well explained).

Bianca and Xan first met in Venice, and I enjoyed learning about their shared past via flashback chapters, and how their experiences shaped their current feelings and decisions. In Venice, we find out that Bianca and Xan both lusted after each other and could barely keep their hands to themselves. Their feelings were reawakened after running into each other back in London, although they had to keep their hands in check while in public, as they weren’t supposed to have known each other well before then. The story spent quite a bit of time on the physical side of their relationship, which I thought turned (too) quickly into love. I would have liked a bit more time spent on developing the emotional and non-physical side of their relationship. However, the characters were well written and the storytelling was smooth and interesting.

Overall, I did enjoy this book and would recommend it. Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the free advanced copy - this is my honest and voluntary review.
Profile Image for Steph Reads.
161 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 4, 2026
Following on from How to Not Marry a Lord, Emma Orchard returns with another instalment in the Constantine Sisters series, and overall, I found myself enjoying the flow of this book significantly more than the it's predecessor.

The standout feature of this story is easily the dual timeline narrative. Unfolding the past alongside the present gave incredible depth to the story without weighing down the beginning with heavy backstory exposition. It created a beautiful, natural momentum for a compelling second-chance romance. I also really appreciated how the novel framed their history—it explicitly acknowledges that their initial connection was born of intense physical attraction and obsession rather than instant, deep love. This realistic distinction made the emotional slow burn feel far more earned.

That said, the final third required a bit of patience. While the push-and-pull dynamic between Zan and Bianca kept me invested, Bianca’s character growth felt a little drawn out towards the end. Between her internal back-and-forth and what felt like a collection of proposals—though the very first was undeniably forced by propriety—I found myself getting slightly frustrated by how many trips and conversations it took for her to realise what was already blatantly obvious to the reader (and every other character in the book)!

There is a heavy amount of internal dialogue throughout the book. While I didn't mind the reflection, I felt Zan underwent much more meaningful self-realisation than Bianca did. As for the romance, expect plenty of delicious, lingering tension and build-up, though the spicy scenes themselves lean mild on the heat scale.

Ultimately, despite wanting Bianca’s internal breakthrough to arrive a little faster, this was a charming, well-structured second-chance historical romance that builds wonderfully on the series. 3.8 ⭐

Quick Highlights & Tropes
💠Tropes & Elements: Second Chance Romance • Holiday Romance (Venice) • Forced Proximity • Dual Timeline • Regency Romance • Slow Burn Tension
💠Pacing: Excellent dual-timeline structure; slightly drawn-out third act
💠Spice Level: Mild (High build-up and tension, but low explicit heat)
💠Character Focus: Great growth from the MMC (Zan); slow-burn self-reflection from the FMC (Bianca)

Thank you to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
5 reviews14 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 16, 2026
ARC review.
3.5/5 rounded up

I read this in a couple evenings and didn’t get a chance to pick a quote. So here is a Taylor Swift lyric I think sums up the heroine Bianca pretty well:

You don't have to save me but would you run away with me? (Call It What You Want. Taylor Swift., 2017)


This story focuses on Bianca Constantine, the youngest sister in her family, and a widower with a young son. They unexpectedly meet again after a brief affair in Italy.

Pros:
- the chemistry between FMC and MMC
- feminist characters
- the heroine’s outspoken personality and her hobbies/work that she refuses to give up for society
- unorthodox family structures are represented
- slow burn

Cons
- the second half dragged out so some tension between FMC and MMC was lost

This was my first Emma Orchard novel, and I really enjoyed it. It was an easy low-stakes novel to read in the evening, and I want to read more about the Constantine sisters in the future.
194 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 26, 2026
3 stars – To All the Earls I’ve Loved Before by Emma Orchard. This is book 8 in the series. I love the Constantine family and their stories. This one focused on Bianca and it is a good premise, but I had a hard time staying with it. The book progressed very slowly and was more in the characters’ thoughts rather than their actions. FMC Bianca Constantine meets MMC Xan Challender. They have an affair in Venice. Eventually both are in England at the same time and, unfortunately, run into each other. Bianca would have been quite happy never seeing Xan again, but life doesn’t work the way Bianca wants. Good premise, just a little light on the interaction and dialogue for me. I love the author’s work and this has been a wonderful series overall.

A huge thank you to NetGalley and the author and Boldwood Books for allowing me to read an ARC. All thoughts and opinions expressed here are my own.
Profile Image for Ridzi.
66 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 28, 2026
3.5 rounded to 4. I keep going back to Emma Orchard in hopes of reviving the magic of the Second Lady Silverwood. Alas, like most of the ones that have followed, this one doesn't quite get there.

In all honesty it's been misclassified as an "erotica" which is all honesty it's nowhere close to. Most scenes fades away with a couple that jump between details and abstraction. The story is refreshing for a regency, where the MMC is genuinely questioning what she gets from marriage. The right question to ask for an heiress with relative freedom and ambitions.

The delivery, specially the child character Elliot could have done with more page time. One of the things that was missing was why they connected so deeply in the past beyond just the sex? To this there was no clear answer which leaves the story poorer.

Overall a decent afternoon read.
574 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 3, 2026
Once again an absorbing, readable romance following the fortunes of the six Constantine sisters. In the latest novel, We find Bianca, the youngest, in Venice attempting to pursue an independent lifestyle and build a career as an artist. She assumes a false identity to preserve her reputation so that she can return to London as a respectable heiress while having a bit of fun in Venice. She meets Xan and has a passionate affair hopefully commitment free. Unfortunately they meet up again unexpectedly in London and have to deal with a potential scandal when a notorious gossip from Venice sees Bianca while she is portrait painting, the novel explores the difficulties a woman faces when she desires independence rather than marriage and how she needs to be highly talented to succeed in a man’s world. .
Profile Image for Sarah.
743 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 12, 2026
I enjoyed this one - it’s a continuation of the Constantine sisters’ stories with the youngest Bianca taking the stage. There’s a hidden identity foreign romance plot with the MCs unexpectedly meeting again in London with lots of hurt feelings, miscommunication, sexual tension and uncertainty about what they want from the future. I thought the first half of the book was very tight with excellent dialogue between the two, very visceral sexual repression. Where it fell apart a bit for me was the transition to forgiveness and love which felt a bit unearned, especially after the intensity of the first half. I also felt like the build up to the steam was better than the actual steam?

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC
296 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
To All The Earls I've Loved Before is the last book I believe about Bianca, the youngest Constantine sister. Bianca went on a tour of Europe and ended up in Venice chaperoned. She met Xan and then nearly a year later she finds she is painting a portrait of his son. Bianca had left Xan with very little explanation in Venice and they are trying to figure out how to be civil. There is angst, a bit of fake dating, and eccentric female family members.

This was a cute story and I loved revisiting the Constantine women and how they have all ended up. Pacing in general was good, but was not a fan of the pacing at the end. I highly recommend this if you are a regency romance fan and I would read the series in order. Thank you Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the ARC!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Displaying 1 - 30 of 50 reviews