Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Critic

Rate this book
Pittsburgh, 1995. When a notorious theater critic is poisoned through the U.S. mail, the FBI comes for the woman he took the column from — a PR account executive moonlighting as a theater journalist, whose history of psychiatric treatment makes her the perfect suspect.

Jessica Greer didn't do it. But she knows enough about ricin to sound like she did.

To clear her name, she'll have to outmaneuver the federal agent building a case against her, the newsroom that just dubbed her "The Mail Murderess," and a Pittsburgh arts world full of people with better motives than hers. The deeper she digs, the guiltier she looks.

For readers who loved God of the Woods, The Other Black Girl, and The Frozen Rivers.

346 pages, Kindle Edition

Published June 18, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

L.L. Kirchner

16 books61 followers
L.L. Kirchner writes psychological thrillers and historical crime fiction about complicated women who find themselves up against powerful people—and decide to fight back.

Her Steel City Suspense series follows Jessica Greer through the scandals, secrets, and shifting loyalties of 1990s Pittsburgh. Her Queenpin Chronicles trilogy—Florida Girls, Vegas Girls, and Havana Girls—features another collection of women who refuse to play by the rules.

Kirchner is an award-winning screenwriter, Pushcart-nominated writer, and journalist whose work has appeared in The Washington Post, Salon, and The Rumpus. She once worked simultaneously as a religion editor, dating columnist, and bridal editor, while holding down a PR job. This may explain a few things about her fiction.

She’s also the author of two memoirs about her life and work in Asia, and a former Home Shopping Network host.

She currently lives in Florida with her husband and their fur boy, Pepper.

Find her at LLKirchner.com.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
15 (30%)
4 stars
9 (18%)
3 stars
21 (42%)
2 stars
4 (8%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews
Profile Image for Leonie.
302 reviews
May 10, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4 stars)

This was such an interesting and captivating read, that kept me on my toes!!
I loved the story from start to finish, particularly the reader didn’t know who the real murderer was and how it wasn’t clear till the story wanted the reader to know from the way the story was told. I especially adored how we got to see multiple pov‘s (Jessica, Lydia, Dina, the witness statements and more) as well as the way the story was generally told through unreliable narrators and always incorporated ways to make one question their own perception. Besides that, I also liked the complexity of every main character and how, LGBTQIA+ characters were included as well.
The story overall shines through it’s atmosphere though. Right from the beginning, one is thrown into this mess of a situation and, as I mentioned, always questions the motives and the motivations of the characters even if they might seem innocent.
A little downside is that some things did feel somewhat out of the blue for me and even a day after finishing, I’m still questioning whether or not, I just misread an important clue (haha).
Overall though, it was a really good read and I think people who enjoy mysterious novels with complex characters and a captivating plot as well as a great atmosphere should totally read it!!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a free copy of the book in exchange for an honest and voluntarily given review.
Profile Image for Miranda Summerset.
1,006 reviews8 followers
August 9, 2026
5/5 STARS! WOW, talk about an unexpected surprise! This book was SOOOO good! Told from multiple povs, it’s fast & exciting and makes you so tense at times. It’s an almost murder mystery, which I really thought was interesting. Loved all of the characters and definitely wasn’t expecting how it ended. So fantastic! Can’t wait to read more from this author.
Profile Image for Tam Merry.
34 reviews3 followers
May 14, 2026

Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me this Advance Reader Copy in exchange for an honest review.

Jessica is our main character and also the main suspect. Her work colleague Ted, who just so happens to have taken Jessica’s job, ends up in critical condition in the ICU after eating a poisoned brownie that was mailed to him. Set in the 90s, the whole setup definitely gives off Unabomber-era vibes, and I loved all the nostalgic office details, like the reference to the Rolodex - remember them !?

Jessica was easily my favourite character because she does absolutely nothing to make herself look innocent. She’s awkward, she keeps showing up at the worst possible moments, and she even starts questioning whether she could have committed the crime herself. She’s a mysterious hot mess, but somehow you can’t help but like her. Especially as she becomes determined to figure out, if she didn’t do it… who did?

I’m still searching for an author who really nails a police investigation, and as someone who was very invested in the recent mushroom trials, this premise immediately caught my attention.

I really enjoyed the 90s nostalgia, the messy characters, and being led down a deceptive path before the twist finally arrived.
Profile Image for Amanda Sassy-pants.
319 reviews13 followers
August 2, 2026
Jessica Greer is a journalist with a job at a PR firm, and she moonlights as a theatre critic writing for an alternative news weekly. She’s just been replaced by another critic, and on the day she learns she’s out of a job, her replacement is poisoned. With motive and opportunity, Jessica quickly becomes the prime suspect—but everyone around her is acting suspiciously.

Jessica has a gap in her memory from the night before the poisoning and an empty brownie box in her bin that she can’t explain. Dina knows the truth about a decades-old secret, while the victim’s ex has returned to town and is secretly involved with someone close to the investigation.

This was a fast-paced mystery with sharply written characters, plenty of twists, and a compelling plot. I enjoyed the story and the writing very much and am looking forward to reading more by this author. I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Tara Lush.
Author 29 books646 followers
July 14, 2026
The Critic took me back to the 1990s!

L.L. Kirchner drops us into the wacky and gritty world of Pittsburgh’s alt-weekly scene in 1995. Theater critic Jessica Greer has just lost her column to a rival — and then becomes the FBI’s prime suspect when that rival is poisoned with ricin in the newsroom.

Let’s just say that Jessica makes for a terrible suspect. She’s weird, whip smart and doesn’t quite fit in. I adored her and rooted for her.

Her voice is snarky — but never cynical the way a modern-day version of this character might curdle into. She’s a true blast from the ‘90s: sharp enough to see the machinery closing in around her, human enough to keep wisecracking.

The book is written in multiple points of view, and while those were fun, I was Team Jessica all the way.

Jessica is a complex character. Her anxiety, intrusive thoughts, the phobias — the bridges especially — landed with accuracy. I speak as someone who’s lived with both, and I’ve rarely seen it rendered this honestly. Jessica’s mental health is layered, messy, and treated with real respect, but never a gimmick, never a punchline. That balance is so hard to strike, and Kirchner nails it.

And then there’s the theme that made me both nostalgic and sad me up as a former journalist: the way the media treats female suspects. The sensationalism in this book — a woman transformed overnight from writer to “the Mail Murderess,” her private pain splashed across the evening news — brought a lot of my career roaring back.

When one of the journalists says, near the end, “that’s going to be huge,” the whole story clicks into place. That single line is the key. It’s the machine admitting what it’s really after. It gutted me, because it’s true then and it’s true now.

The Critic is fascinating and funny, serious and suspenseful, and underneath the mystery it’s got something real to say. I couldn’t put it down and can’t wait for what comes out of Kirchner’s mind next!
Profile Image for Rhonda Woloshun.
20 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
June 2, 2026
*Book Review: The Critic by
@Ilkirchnerauthor
The scene: Pittsburgh, 1995
The story: "A notorious theater critic collapses. A broke PR hack with a sharp mouth and a fractured memory becomes the prime suspect. The press calls her The Mail Murderess. And this 90s psychological thriller is a high-drama newsroom page turner you cannot miss!"
The Critic hooked me immediately as a
Pittsburgh girl
myself, the nods to Steel City landmarks made this relatable and painted such an aesthetic backdrop for this drama. (You'll find tons of yinzer-coded language too!)
If you want a smart, can't-put-down character-driven mystery…..where even if you think you have this one solved... you're actually only beginning to uncover the truth ...because this is one whodunnit that's well earned...this is for you!
I devoured this in a day and a half. I HAD to know what happened. Absolutely 5 stars - add this one to your TBR immediately

Tropes
Mental Health/illness
Strong FMC(s)
+ Multi-POV
Family/generational dynamics + investigation realism
“Red herrings"
Profile Image for Dawn .
34 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 5, 2026
I took this book on a trip with me to NYC this week and finished it in two days. What a fun ride!!! If you are looking for a perfect travel or beach read and enjoy a fun and zany crime thriller, this one is for you.

I like the main character, but honestly love her mom, Jeannine. She brings the humor and the love for her daughter. I also loved that this was set in the 90s - so fun to reminisce about the early days of cell phones - and that it's set in Pittsburgh. I recently traveled there for the first time and it's always exciting when you have actually seen the setting the book takes place in.

I personally enjoy a mystery that doesn't make me need therapy afterward, so I deeply appreciated the author's take and style. Looking forward to the next one in the series, and not so secretly hoping for more of our FBI duo.
Profile Image for Nicole Fincher.
107 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 12, 2026
Get ready to head to the 'Burgh circa 1995! This twisty psychological crime novel will have you guessing and second guessing yourself to the end! Follow the main suspect, Jessica, while she is trying to prove her innocence all while questioning whether she is actually innocent or not, talk about an unreliable narrator!!
The three POVs plus the witness statements give us so much information, yet still keeps you guessing.
Come for the suspense, stay for the setting! Set in Pittsburgh, the city itself is a special part of the story. See how many iconic references you can find, not just about the city, but from the 90s too. This was a thrilling blast from the past that I couldn't read fast enough!
Profile Image for Susan Stover.
147 reviews9 followers
August 16, 2026
The Critic was such an interesting read! I really enjoyed the 90s Pittsburgh setting because it gave the whole story a different feel, especially without all the technology we have today.

Jessica is definitely not your typical main character. She's messy, sarcastic, complicated, and there were plenty of moments where I questioned her right along with everything else happening in the story. I actually liked that she wasn't perfect because it made her feel more real.

The mystery kept me curious without being overly complicated, and I loved the mix of darker moments with a little humor thrown in. There were several times I thought I had things figured out, only to start questioning myself all over again.

This was a fun, twisty mystery that kept me turning the pages.
842 reviews15 followers
September 22, 2026
Pittsburgh 1995: Jessica, is a PR account executive moonlighting as a theater journalist. She has just been told that she is being replaced by a competitor theatre critic that has a grudge against her. On the same day, her replacement is rushed to the hospital poisoned by a letter that came in the mail. Jessica is considered the only person of interest with a motive by the FBI. She also has a past history of mental illness. Little effort is put into searching for any other suspects. She begins her own investigation as the publicity and opinions all point to her. There comes a point where she wonders if she may be guilty.

This novel is told with 3 POV and easy to read. The ending brought out secrets from the past.

Thank you Voracious Readers Only and Book Funnel
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 27, 2026
The Critic by L.L. Kirchner was an outstanding read — sharp, clever, and impossible to put down. The story immediately hooked me, but what really stood out were the characters, pacing, and intelligence of the writing.

Kirchner delivers a book that feels sophisticated without ever becoming slow or pretentious. The characters are vivid, the tension keeps building, and the story unfolds in a way that constantly kept me engaged. One of the best thrillers I’ve read in a long time.

I highly recommend this book!
Profile Image for Vivian.
772 reviews32 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 17, 2026
If you like reading a story that will have you guessing and second guessing yourself, where the characters tell you only part of the story and there are so many twists and turns that you get dizzy by them, this is the story for you!
The city of Pittsburgh in the 90's is as much as a character as the ones in the story, so come to this journey with an open mind and be prepared to hear from three different point of view about the plot of the story and try to unravel the mystery and get to the right conclusion, you will not be disappointed.
4 reviews
July 8, 2026
I'll start by saying The Critic isn't my typical type of read, yet I couldn't put the book down. Looking forward to reading more from L.L. Kirchner. I enjoyed the pacing, particularly cycling through the various POVs.

The Critic grabbed my attention from the first chapter and held it to the end. There are twists and turns that kept me guessing. Every spare moment was spent getting to the next chapter. This lead to an incredibly late night… I had to know the ending.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I left this review voluntarily
17.8k reviews206 followers
Review of advance copy
June 15, 2026
A death will lead to her being accused of a murder she did not do. You will be pulled into a fast paced mystery as you see where it will all go. Life is going to get complicated and interesting journey to find the truth of the crime
I received an advance copy from hidden gems and a great murder mystery
4 reviews
June 25, 2026
It sure looks like she poisoned her replacement after she loses her job as theater critic at a Pittsburgh newspaper. But even Jessica can’t be sure if she did. As she faces her past trauma, Jessica must figure out a way to accept her past before she is arrested for murder. Kept me guessing and didn’t want to put it down!
Profile Image for Michelle.
51 reviews
July 22, 2026
The Critic is an exciting and twisty mystery that will have you guessing until the end. I loved the 90s setting and the nostalgia trip I went on while reading this book. I also appreciate the portrayal of mental illness as not being cutesy nor the end of your life, and I found Jessica to be very relatable. It's a fun, thrilling read that I definitely recommend!
66 reviews
November 2, 2026
This was by no means a bad book and I’m sure a lot of other people will love it. I feel like I figured out the culprit really early on as their behaviour was pretty obviously a give away in my opinion. I liked finding out the backstory and reason behind it but overall I found the book hard to get into and just an okay read for me. I think I would have liked it more if I was more surprised.
Profile Image for Hailey.
2 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 5, 2026
The Critic was a complex and beautifully written read that, as others have said, kept me on my toes! L.L. nails the 90s nostalgia and pulls you in from the very beginning.

I can’t wait to see what she does with the next books in the Steel City Mysteries.
Profile Image for Bailey.
20 reviews
August 19, 2026
I picked this up in Florida - great cover and premise and was a local author. The book would have benefited from heavy story editing. The story was rushed and confusing, the character arcs lacked structure, and it was almost a DNF.
Profile Image for Erin.
237 reviews
August 20, 2026
I was excited to read a book set in Pittsburgh, but this was so muddled in the first chapters that I couldn't go on. I was confused as to who was who and there wasn't enough to make me care to go further.
Profile Image for Cindy Bloomfield.
36 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
June 9, 2026
Good story. Being accused of a murder you did not commit is hard work. All the things you must do to be found innocent.
40 reviews2 followers
September 28, 2026
I I found the first few chapters a bit confusing with the characters. Overall a good book enjoyed the other half.
5 reviews1 follower
July 17, 2026
The Critic — Loved It!

Loved this latest offering by LL Kirchner. As a native Pittsburgh native, I enjoyed the references to landmarks and the references to the world of independent journalism. The mystery was quirky, unsettling, and in the end, so satisfying.
Profile Image for Amy Rupp.
50 reviews11 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
May 11, 2026
The Critic by LL Kirchner is a character-driven psychological suspense novel that delivers on its intriguing premise — a poisoned brownie, a workplace conspiracy, and a cast of unreliable narrators across multiple POVs. The story unfolds partly through police interviews and witness statements, giving it a procedural layer that works really well alongside the workplace mystery.

The character development is one of the book's strongest elements. You become genuinely invested in these characters even as you're constantly questioning their reliability — and juggling multiple unreliable narrators is no small feat. The conspiracy-driven plot kept me engaged and guessing throughout.

A few plot points and character decisions didn't fully come together for me, and some details felt like they might be leading somewhere that ultimately didn't connect. But as the first book in a new series, there's plenty of runway for those threads to develop.

If you enjoy twisty, character-focused psychological suspense with a strong procedural element, this is worth adding to your TBR. I'll be watching for book two.

Note: Goodreads does have 1/2 stars but I rated this 3.5 stars.

Thank you to the author for early access to this title.
Profile Image for The Bookish Mama.
35 reviews
May 9, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

The Critic had an interesting premise that immediately caught my attention, particularly the combination of investigative journalism, trauma-related memory gaps, and a bioterrorism storyline involving the mail. The central mystery kept me curious throughout, and there were a few twists that genuinely surprised me.

I also appreciated the LGBTQ representation woven into the story, and I thought the overall concept had a lot of potential. The writing itself was often engaging and readable, especially during the stronger suspense-driven moments.

That said, this book could benefit from another round of editing before publication. I noticed a number of typos throughout, as well as repeated sentences and descriptions appearing in multiple places, which occasionally pulled me out of the story and affected the pacing.

I also struggled to connect with many of the characters, as I found most of them difficult to fully invest in emotionally. In addition, there were a few plot points and character decisions that didn’t completely come together for me, which made parts of the mystery feel somewhat uneven.

Overall, while this one didn’t fully work for me personally, I think readers who enjoy psychological mysteries involving unreliable narrators, journalism, and conspiracy-driven plots may still find elements to enjoy, especially the unique premise and unexpected twists.
681 reviews9 followers
June 26, 2026
The Critic is a compelling psychological suspense novel that delivers an intriguing blend of mystery, tension, and atmospheric storytelling.

L.L. Kirchner crafts a suspenseful narrative filled with compelling characters, psychological depth, and the promise of unexpected twists that keep readers engaged.

Overall, it's an excellent choice for fans of psychological suspense, mystery, and character-driven thrillers with a strong sense of atmosphere.
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews