What do you think?
Rate this book
The Spellbound History Quartet #2
Witch Dance
Not yet published
Expected 9 Mar 27In the summer of 1518, the citizens of Strasbourg are dancing themselves to death.
Brilliant medical student Evelina del Valle arrives determined to stop the plague before the quarantined city collapses… while keeping a terrible and fatal secret: she’s a witch. But she’s left her coven, her sister, and that life behind her for good. All she wants now is a career in healing.
But Strasbourg’s sickness defies everything she knows about medicine. Every experiment of hers fails in uncovering how and why the plague is spreading. The afflicted cannot stop dancing, and the local physicians insist they must “dance it out,” even as bodies fall and no natural cause can be found.
Then Alaric Keller crosses her path―secretive, dangerous, and bound to the shadowed Black Forest beyond the city walls, where rumors whisper of hidden fae courts, gemstone magic, and bargains struck in the dark. His mother was the plague’s first victim, and he is desperate to save her. He needs Evelina’s help, but the way he looks at her suggests he already knows the secret she keeps―and he threatens to use it against her.
As suspicion tightens and the death toll climbs, Evelina is forced to choose what she’s willing to sacrifice: the life she’s built, the identity she’s hidden, or the man who may not only hold the key to the truth and her heart, but also her ruin.
Because Evelina fears this is no ordinary plague.
And she knows that once the dance begins, it does not stop.
Brilliant medical student Evelina del Valle arrives determined to stop the plague before the quarantined city collapses… while keeping a terrible and fatal secret: she’s a witch. But she’s left her coven, her sister, and that life behind her for good. All she wants now is a career in healing.
But Strasbourg’s sickness defies everything she knows about medicine. Every experiment of hers fails in uncovering how and why the plague is spreading. The afflicted cannot stop dancing, and the local physicians insist they must “dance it out,” even as bodies fall and no natural cause can be found.
Then Alaric Keller crosses her path―secretive, dangerous, and bound to the shadowed Black Forest beyond the city walls, where rumors whisper of hidden fae courts, gemstone magic, and bargains struck in the dark. His mother was the plague’s first victim, and he is desperate to save her. He needs Evelina’s help, but the way he looks at her suggests he already knows the secret she keeps―and he threatens to use it against her.
As suspicion tightens and the death toll climbs, Evelina is forced to choose what she’s willing to sacrifice: the life she’s built, the identity she’s hidden, or the man who may not only hold the key to the truth and her heart, but also her ruin.
Because Evelina fears this is no ordinary plague.
And she knows that once the dance begins, it does not stop.
416 pages, Hardcover
Expected publication March 9, 2027
About the author
Isabel Ibañez
17 books5,708 followersIsabel Ibañez is a USA Today, Indie, Sunday Times, and #1 New York Times bestseller and the author of the Secrets of the Nile duology, Together We Burn, Written in Starlight, and Woven in Moonlight, which is listed among Time Magazine’s 100 Best Fantasy Books Of All Time and was a finalist for the William C. Morris award. She is the proud daughter of Bolivian immigrants and has a profound appreciation for history, traveling, and writing stories where her characters are often running for their lives. She currently lives in the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina with her family, their adorable golden doodle, and an overwhelming amount of of books.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews
Read
July 28, 2026Hiii! With the pub date of WITCH DANCE fast approaching, and the season of promo happening in full swing, I thought I’d do a PSA covering some frequently asked questions about WITCH DANCE.
1. What is the Spellbound Histories Quartet? They are four interconnected standalone romantic fantasies set during the Renaissance. Each book has a different set of characters that follows a witch trying to survive this particular era when men dominated every sphere, particularly in arts and innovation and sciences. The books can be read out of order, though the magic system is the same in each one, and builds with each subsequent story. There is one character who is in all four books, and his backstory also builds in the same way: one book at a time, until his own story takes center stage.
2. So, I don’t need to read Graceless Heart before Witch Dance? Nope! You’ll miss some Easter eggs and the introduction to the Courier but that’s it!
3. How do I get an ARC of WITCH DANCE? A few ways! You can email my publisher at hello@stmartinspress.com and ask for one, sign up for the Goodreads giveaways happening on this site, or follow me on IG (@IsabelIbanezBooks) where I’ll be giving away an ARC each month leading to the pub date starting in September!
4. How can I preorder a signed copy of WITCH DANCE? Through Good Folk Bookshop (@GoodFolkBookshop). I’ll also be running a preorder campaign through them. More details coming closer to the pub date will be shared on my IG or in my newsletter! You can sign up by visiting my website: Isabelibanez.com
5. Is WITCH DANCE a romantasy? No. I love romantasy, and to me, that means the romance is front and center and the driving force of the plot. WITCH DANCE, and the other quartet books, all feature a love story, but it’s definitely the B plot. The engine of the book runs on a larger story/plot and the romance is a big part of it, but it’s not, say, the steering wheel.
A quick word about the ARCs and e-galleys: the printed ARCs are an earlier version of WITCH DANCE than the e-galleys on Netgalley/Edelwiess. WITCH DANCE went through a long editing process; developmental and copyedits, first and second pass pages and proofreading. Because printing happens overseas, ARCs get printed much earlier and the version heading out into the world is of the copyedited manuscript. Meaning, it’s gone through developmental edits and a copy editor has read it and I personally made even more edits (done by hand and with a red pen on a version I printed at home). Even so, and to my utter chagrin, if you read the printed ARC you will catch mistakes. Like, say, the mortifying instance when I misspelled laughter. Can’t wait for you all to find that one. ;) Expect word echoes, missing words, and other fun minor inconsistencies and grammatical errors in the printed ARC.
The e-galley should be the second pass version of the book. Between copyedits and second pass, I made about 700 changes to the manuscript. That sounds like a lot but it’s nothing major — both versions of the book tell the same story but the second pass is a more polished version. Less mistakes, more tweaks in the writing, a smattering of added dialogue and nuance, a smidge more banter and emotion, and thankfully, laughter is now spelled correctly. But funnily enough, as I’m reading it again for the tenth time all the way through, I found yet another misspelled word and one whole line repeated twice on the same page (I wanted to move the line down further and the original one at the top didn’t get deleted). 😆 After copyedits, I also challenged myself to cut wherever I could, too.
Between each round of edits, weeks go by and every time I come back to the manuscript, it’s with fresh eyes. I catch things I didn’t see clearly when I was in the weeds. Adding certain lines of dialogue that help drive the nuance of a conversation home. Beats of emotion I missed in the first, second, third round of edits. As a recovering perfectionist, I would love for all early readers to enjoy the most polished version, but it’s just not possible with printing schedules. But I admit there’s something sweet and precious about the printed ARCs of WITCH DANCE—it’s a snapshot of the journey of a story making its way onto a bookshelf, mistakes and all.
Whew! I think that’s everything. With that, I’m once again having my husband block me from this site. 😆 As always, you can find me on IG (and nowhere else, other than my website, and a Facebook page that is linked to my IG). There is an “Isabel Ibańez” claiming to be me on TikTok but they are lying to you. Feel free to tell them so if this impersonator reaches out!
Ok, now I’m really done, ha.
Love,
Isabel
1. What is the Spellbound Histories Quartet? They are four interconnected standalone romantic fantasies set during the Renaissance. Each book has a different set of characters that follows a witch trying to survive this particular era when men dominated every sphere, particularly in arts and innovation and sciences. The books can be read out of order, though the magic system is the same in each one, and builds with each subsequent story. There is one character who is in all four books, and his backstory also builds in the same way: one book at a time, until his own story takes center stage.
2. So, I don’t need to read Graceless Heart before Witch Dance? Nope! You’ll miss some Easter eggs and the introduction to the Courier but that’s it!
3. How do I get an ARC of WITCH DANCE? A few ways! You can email my publisher at hello@stmartinspress.com and ask for one, sign up for the Goodreads giveaways happening on this site, or follow me on IG (@IsabelIbanezBooks) where I’ll be giving away an ARC each month leading to the pub date starting in September!
4. How can I preorder a signed copy of WITCH DANCE? Through Good Folk Bookshop (@GoodFolkBookshop). I’ll also be running a preorder campaign through them. More details coming closer to the pub date will be shared on my IG or in my newsletter! You can sign up by visiting my website: Isabelibanez.com
5. Is WITCH DANCE a romantasy? No. I love romantasy, and to me, that means the romance is front and center and the driving force of the plot. WITCH DANCE, and the other quartet books, all feature a love story, but it’s definitely the B plot. The engine of the book runs on a larger story/plot and the romance is a big part of it, but it’s not, say, the steering wheel.
A quick word about the ARCs and e-galleys: the printed ARCs are an earlier version of WITCH DANCE than the e-galleys on Netgalley/Edelwiess. WITCH DANCE went through a long editing process; developmental and copyedits, first and second pass pages and proofreading. Because printing happens overseas, ARCs get printed much earlier and the version heading out into the world is of the copyedited manuscript. Meaning, it’s gone through developmental edits and a copy editor has read it and I personally made even more edits (done by hand and with a red pen on a version I printed at home). Even so, and to my utter chagrin, if you read the printed ARC you will catch mistakes. Like, say, the mortifying instance when I misspelled laughter. Can’t wait for you all to find that one. ;) Expect word echoes, missing words, and other fun minor inconsistencies and grammatical errors in the printed ARC.
The e-galley should be the second pass version of the book. Between copyedits and second pass, I made about 700 changes to the manuscript. That sounds like a lot but it’s nothing major — both versions of the book tell the same story but the second pass is a more polished version. Less mistakes, more tweaks in the writing, a smattering of added dialogue and nuance, a smidge more banter and emotion, and thankfully, laughter is now spelled correctly. But funnily enough, as I’m reading it again for the tenth time all the way through, I found yet another misspelled word and one whole line repeated twice on the same page (I wanted to move the line down further and the original one at the top didn’t get deleted). 😆 After copyedits, I also challenged myself to cut wherever I could, too.
Between each round of edits, weeks go by and every time I come back to the manuscript, it’s with fresh eyes. I catch things I didn’t see clearly when I was in the weeds. Adding certain lines of dialogue that help drive the nuance of a conversation home. Beats of emotion I missed in the first, second, third round of edits. As a recovering perfectionist, I would love for all early readers to enjoy the most polished version, but it’s just not possible with printing schedules. But I admit there’s something sweet and precious about the printed ARCs of WITCH DANCE—it’s a snapshot of the journey of a story making its way onto a bookshelf, mistakes and all.
Whew! I think that’s everything. With that, I’m once again having my husband block me from this site. 😆 As always, you can find me on IG (and nowhere else, other than my website, and a Facebook page that is linked to my IG). There is an “Isabel Ibańez” claiming to be me on TikTok but they are lying to you. Feel free to tell them so if this impersonator reaches out!
Ok, now I’m really done, ha.
Love,
Isabel
Want to Read
September 21, 2026excited to read the second book in ibañez's spellbound history quartet - and this one revolves around the plague... where are all my readers who were obsessed with researching the black plague when they were in grade school?!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
When I saw graceless heart was a part of a series I was excited and a bit wary, since I couldn't see how that story was going to continue, and it doesn't really. Witch Dance is part of a series of books that can be read as a standalone because they share a world but not much more than that.
To me witch dance is less historical and more fantastical, which is great, it's my preferred fantasy setting/story type.
We follow Evelina, a witch in hiding training to become a physician, when she is called to a small village to treat a disease. For unknown reasons people in this town are dancing until they die, and the people in charge have called for help from the university. The son of the first victim, Alaric, is half fae and has run away from faerie after being told by his father that he would have to marry a witch. A witch that looks exactly like Evelina.
I loved Isabel Ibañez writing in the last book and I'm very satisfied that it continued to be great in this book. The plot moves fast, there's always something happening and the characters are very captivating. Alaric has a dog and I love him so much, I'm always down for characters that have pets that they love more than life itself.
I'm very excited for the series to continue. And also very pleased that the books will be standalones because my memory is not great and this way I can enjoy them fully.
Thank you Netgalley and Saturday Books for the ARC.
To me witch dance is less historical and more fantastical, which is great, it's my preferred fantasy setting/story type.
We follow Evelina, a witch in hiding training to become a physician, when she is called to a small village to treat a disease. For unknown reasons people in this town are dancing until they die, and the people in charge have called for help from the university. The son of the first victim, Alaric, is half fae and has run away from faerie after being told by his father that he would have to marry a witch. A witch that looks exactly like Evelina.
I loved Isabel Ibañez writing in the last book and I'm very satisfied that it continued to be great in this book. The plot moves fast, there's always something happening and the characters are very captivating. Alaric has a dog and I love him so much, I'm always down for characters that have pets that they love more than life itself.
I'm very excited for the series to continue. And also very pleased that the books will be standalones because my memory is not great and this way I can enjoy them fully.
Thank you Netgalley and Saturday Books for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Oh God, where do I start with this book... it was a hot mess that didn't deliver what it promised. I saw it in the catalogue, and even though I wasn't interested since I'd read another book by this author and absolutely despised it, I decided to give this a try in hopes of seeing her improve her work. I remember her debut book being hopelessly shallow, with a piss-poor research on history and translating it poorly into the story, and a main character who is absolutely useless, has no agency of her own, and relies on a man to get things done. Unfortunately, many of those aspects are still apparent in this book.
This book went from being about a plague, a witch wanting to be a doctor and facing misogyny and wanting to break through it, to suddenly focusing on fae and curses and magic. Even if we ignore that and focus on how the main character is a witch and has been said many, many times in the book how they face prosecution at the hands of self-righteous men, those aspects aren't explored when it comes to relevance to Evelina's story except to serve in the final battle against the fae king. That isn't what I went into this book for.
Let me also say that Evelina and Alaric are the most useless main characters I've ever read because they're not doing anything except pushing the plot forward passively. Nothing they do for almost the entirety of the book is substantial, and it makes the stakes for the story below zero... It's so frustrating having to see Alaric being the oil that keeps the plot going forward passively while all he does is being emo in Strasbourg, go with Evelina but didn't do anything while she retrieves what he needed to get, and THEN get all lovey-dovey with Evelina after half the book being so suspicious and undermining Evelina any chance he gets, and the cherry on top being him going back to Fae while everyone else around him does all the work. Meanwhile, Evelina decided that all her hard work to become independent and break free from patriarchal demands got flushed down the drain the second Alaric wants her back, and all she wants now is to run away with him and paints Sabina as the villain, all because she crafted a curse that the Fae king ordered her to make, and everything that she does was so the witches can keep living. It's honestly so tiring seeing how demonized she is when all she wants is for her people to not keep being the victims of genocide. This story is supposed to be about fighting for what the character wants, and apparently Evelina wanted that dick so bad at the end that nothing else matters.
The apparent theme of a book that promises a story that is centered around women, witches, and gaining agency felt tainted by the dominance of men controlling the narrative and not delivering the absolution for women that they needed. I concur that the author is not for me. Even as a historical fantasy, this was not something that would satisfy people who gravitate towards that genre because of how poorly done it is.
This book went from being about a plague, a witch wanting to be a doctor and facing misogyny and wanting to break through it, to suddenly focusing on fae and curses and magic. Even if we ignore that and focus on how the main character is a witch and has been said many, many times in the book how they face prosecution at the hands of self-righteous men, those aspects aren't explored when it comes to relevance to Evelina's story except to serve in the final battle against the fae king. That isn't what I went into this book for.
Let me also say that Evelina and Alaric are the most useless main characters I've ever read because they're not doing anything except pushing the plot forward passively. Nothing they do for almost the entirety of the book is substantial, and it makes the stakes for the story below zero... It's so frustrating having to see Alaric being the oil that keeps the plot going forward passively while all he does is being emo in Strasbourg, go with Evelina but didn't do anything while she retrieves what he needed to get, and THEN get all lovey-dovey with Evelina after half the book being so suspicious and undermining Evelina any chance he gets, and the cherry on top being him going back to Fae while everyone else around him does all the work. Meanwhile, Evelina decided that all her hard work to become independent and break free from patriarchal demands got flushed down the drain the second Alaric wants her back, and all she wants now is to run away with him and paints Sabina as the villain, all because she crafted a curse that the Fae king ordered her to make, and everything that she does was so the witches can keep living. It's honestly so tiring seeing how demonized she is when all she wants is for her people to not keep being the victims of genocide. This story is supposed to be about fighting for what the character wants, and apparently Evelina wanted that dick so bad at the end that nothing else matters.
The apparent theme of a book that promises a story that is centered around women, witches, and gaining agency felt tainted by the dominance of men controlling the narrative and not delivering the absolution for women that they needed. I concur that the author is not for me. Even as a historical fantasy, this was not something that would satisfy people who gravitate towards that genre because of how poorly done it is.
October 17, 2026
A historical retelling of the dancing plague with a unique world building that encompasses medical research. If you like witches, faes, vampires, and female empowerment, this book is for you!
Thanks so much to St Martin’s Press | Saturday Books and NetGalley for this advance reader copy of Witch Dance by Isabel Ibáñez, to be published on March 9th, 2027.
Thanks so much to St Martin’s Press | Saturday Books and NetGalley for this advance reader copy of Witch Dance by Isabel Ibáñez, to be published on March 9th, 2027.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thanks to St. Martin's Press and Netgalley for providing a free copy of witch dance in an exchange for an honest review.
This was so good?? How come I haven't read any of Isabel Ibañez's books before.
I have not read Graceless Heart (I need to) so this took a while to get into, but once I was hooked, I could not put it down. Now I need the courier's story too because he was such a compelling character and we don't even know his name yet or the woman he is searching so desperately for 😭😭
I really liked the magic system especially the concept of the gemstones (my favorite was the echostone because what do you mean I can walk around having a built-in translator in my brain that is so cool).
Speaking of languages this book features chapter numbers in Spanish which made me want to actually learn the numbers beyond diez (gotta lock in on Spanish for real).
Eveline is a determined medical student who would do anything to prove herself in the Universidad despite two very annoying colleagues (looking at you, Alvaro and Silvestre). So, when a chance is given to her in Strasbourg to find a cure for the dancing sickness, she immediately jumps on it.
I find the plague disturbing and could not believe it when I read the author's note and discovered that it in fact took place in the 1500s? I almost thought it was a myth and went down an internet rabbit hole to try to understand how such a thing happened in history😭 This was well-researched in terms of how the author handled it.
I was rooting for Alaric and Eveline but wished they stayed a littleee bit more in the slow-burn development phase because the tension was delicious. Alaric is not the typical broody fae prince who lacks in personality but has his own struggles of striving to free himself of his father's hold for a full decade. Also his love for Thorn and Thorn immediately warming up to Evelina? I have a huge soft spot for characters who consider their pets best friends😭.
My only qualm is that the timing of the second open-door scene was off-putting since someone had just died😭 It took me out for a minute. But despite that there are only two open door scenes which are skippable for non-spice readers.
Overall, a fantastic, atmospheric read! 4.5/5 stars
This was so good?? How come I haven't read any of Isabel Ibañez's books before.
I have not read Graceless Heart (I need to) so this took a while to get into, but once I was hooked, I could not put it down. Now I need the courier's story too because he was such a compelling character and we don't even know his name yet or the woman he is searching so desperately for 😭😭
I really liked the magic system especially the concept of the gemstones (my favorite was the echostone because what do you mean I can walk around having a built-in translator in my brain that is so cool).
Speaking of languages this book features chapter numbers in Spanish which made me want to actually learn the numbers beyond diez (gotta lock in on Spanish for real).
Eveline is a determined medical student who would do anything to prove herself in the Universidad despite two very annoying colleagues (looking at you, Alvaro and Silvestre). So, when a chance is given to her in Strasbourg to find a cure for the dancing sickness, she immediately jumps on it.
I find the plague disturbing and could not believe it when I read the author's note and discovered that it in fact took place in the 1500s? I almost thought it was a myth and went down an internet rabbit hole to try to understand how such a thing happened in history😭 This was well-researched in terms of how the author handled it.
I was rooting for Alaric and Eveline but wished they stayed a littleee bit more in the slow-burn development phase because the tension was delicious. Alaric is not the typical broody fae prince who lacks in personality but has his own struggles of striving to free himself of his father's hold for a full decade. Also his love for Thorn and Thorn immediately warming up to Evelina? I have a huge soft spot for characters who consider their pets best friends😭.
My only qualm is that the timing of the second open-door scene was off-putting since someone had just died😭 It took me out for a minute. But despite that there are only two open door scenes which are skippable for non-spice readers.
Overall, a fantastic, atmospheric read! 4.5/5 stars
Want to Read
May 4, 2026COVER REVEALLLLLL ~~~~
I need this now. I can't WAIT!!!🥹💚
I need this now. I can't WAIT!!!🥹💚
October 11, 2026
This is the second book in Isabel Ibañez’s interconnected standalone series, and I think I liked it even better than the first one (Graceless Heart)! As someone who knew of the Strasbourg dancing plague before reading this, I thought it was so interesting to hear her fantasy take on this very strange historical phenomenon. I loved the writing and the description and how I really felt like I was in medieval Germany. As always in Isabel’s books, the FMC, Evelina, is fiery and stubborn and determined, and I LOVED the MMC, Alaric. He was so strong and protective and noble, and they had such a great grumpy x sunshine dynamic. I enjoyed exploring both a historical European town as well as the fae world and seeing one particular familiar character from Graceless Heart. I thought this story ended well with a few open endings that make me excited for the last 2 books in the series.
Content Notes: Open door scenes in chapters 30 and 34, as well as a semi descriptive fade to black scene in chapter 50. Some strong language and use of the Lord’s name in vain. Trigger warning for misogyny, death of parent, abusive parent, some violence, injuries, and killing. Characters in this book are witches who cast spells. The FMC is a witch who has left her coven but still occasionally uses magic.
Thank you to Saturday Books and NetGalley for sending me a digital ARC of this book! All thoughts and opinions above are my own.
Content Notes: Open door scenes in chapters 30 and 34, as well as a semi descriptive fade to black scene in chapter 50. Some strong language and use of the Lord’s name in vain. Trigger warning for misogyny, death of parent, abusive parent, some violence, injuries, and killing. Characters in this book are witches who cast spells. The FMC is a witch who has left her coven but still occasionally uses magic.
Thank you to Saturday Books and NetGalley for sending me a digital ARC of this book! All thoughts and opinions above are my own.
November 8, 2026
What can I say expect Isabel has done it once again.
If it wasn’t for work and life being so busy I would’ve finished this book much faster.
My favorite thing about any of the books Isabel has written is how much history she will include.
I also loved getting more of courtier’s lore and why he does what he does. I’m excited to get his full story one day
Keeping my review short and sweet to avoid spoilers for anyone who wants to go in knowing very little!
Thank you to NetGalley for the arc!
If it wasn’t for work and life being so busy I would’ve finished this book much faster.
My favorite thing about any of the books Isabel has written is how much history she will include.
I also loved getting more of courtier’s lore and why he does what he does. I’m excited to get his full story one day
Keeping my review short and sweet to avoid spoilers for anyone who wants to go in knowing very little!
Thank you to NetGalley for the arc!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I wasn't that drawn to the first installment of the interconnected standalones (Graceless Heart), but throw in witches, a plague, and historical medical aspects? You’ve got me there, Isabel Ibañez. You really did.
First and foremost, gemstones being the magic system? You have my heart. If it were one thing I loved, it would be that. The echostone was a great concept. Basically, being a built-in translator, I would love that for any language. Let’s be honest. Ibañez used traditional witch and fae elements, which I loved. The Fae are mischievous, cunning, and tricky. I was reminded of Holly Black’s representation of Faefolk in Folk of the Air, which I adored. Let’s not forget the novel medicine and blending magic with it. Who doesn’t love a good ol plague infecting the population? It was unique in its own way and definitely not a standard infectious disease that would be solved in an instant. I also enjoyed all the foreshadowing with the Courier the most. Each time he was on the pages, I needed to know more.
I do think the romance was a bit rushed for my tastes, and Evelina’s sister’s arc was too quick for me so that's where my stars get deducted, overall this was a good introduction for Ibañez’s work and I hope she has more in store for me!
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the eARC
First and foremost, gemstones being the magic system? You have my heart. If it were one thing I loved, it would be that. The echostone was a great concept. Basically, being a built-in translator, I would love that for any language. Let’s be honest. Ibañez used traditional witch and fae elements, which I loved. The Fae are mischievous, cunning, and tricky. I was reminded of Holly Black’s representation of Faefolk in Folk of the Air, which I adored. Let’s not forget the novel medicine and blending magic with it. Who doesn’t love a good ol plague infecting the population? It was unique in its own way and definitely not a standard infectious disease that would be solved in an instant. I also enjoyed all the foreshadowing with the Courier the most. Each time he was on the pages, I needed to know more.
I do think the romance was a bit rushed for my tastes, and Evelina’s sister’s arc was too quick for me so that's where my stars get deducted, overall this was a good introduction for Ibañez’s work and I hope she has more in store for me!
Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the eARC
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you to the publisher for gifting me a copy of the next book of the connected Spellbound History Quartet. Each book is set in the same historical fantasy world but can be read as a standalone.
Witch Dance is at its most powerful and emotional when it focuses on the interactions of twin sisters Evelina and Sabina. I appreciated the world and the magic system and the twists and turns that system brought along with it. But the relationship between the sisters and the challenges and heartbreak they are able to cause each other is what honestly kept me reading. It is a great story within a historical fantasy setting that explores what can happen when sisters that love one another find themselves on opposing sides of what they believe the next steps should be of a rebellion.
Witch Dance is at its most powerful and emotional when it focuses on the interactions of twin sisters Evelina and Sabina. I appreciated the world and the magic system and the twists and turns that system brought along with it. But the relationship between the sisters and the challenges and heartbreak they are able to cause each other is what honestly kept me reading. It is a great story within a historical fantasy setting that explores what can happen when sisters that love one another find themselves on opposing sides of what they believe the next steps should be of a rebellion.
September 21, 2026
Thank you St. Martin’s Press for the ARC.
I’m already such a fan of Isabel Ibañez’ writing, and Witch Dance did not disappoint.
Isabel has a tremendous ability to transport you to the time and place the stories take place, something I really loved about her Secrets of the Nile duology, and something she has perfected in Witch Dance. I had to stop at various moments just to take in the scene. I also appreciate the historical inspiration - I was shocked to learn this was inspired by a real dancing plague.
While this can be read as a standalone, I enjoyed the continuity of the magic system from her prior novel, Graceless Heart, plus the developing story of one of the supporting characters that makes an appearance in both (I have a feeling their story will have a bigger role in the rest of the installments of this quartet).
The story was action packed, the romance was enjoyable and did not detract from the story, the tension was delicious, and it features complex characters who aren’t all they appear.
I’m already such a fan of Isabel Ibañez’ writing, and Witch Dance did not disappoint.
Isabel has a tremendous ability to transport you to the time and place the stories take place, something I really loved about her Secrets of the Nile duology, and something she has perfected in Witch Dance. I had to stop at various moments just to take in the scene. I also appreciate the historical inspiration - I was shocked to learn this was inspired by a real dancing plague.
While this can be read as a standalone, I enjoyed the continuity of the magic system from her prior novel, Graceless Heart, plus the developing story of one of the supporting characters that makes an appearance in both (I have a feeling their story will have a bigger role in the rest of the installments of this quartet).
The story was action packed, the romance was enjoyable and did not detract from the story, the tension was delicious, and it features complex characters who aren’t all they appear.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This was good! I read the first book in the Spellbound Histories Quartet last year and really enjoyed it so I was so excited to see that there were going to be more books in the same world. I love how unique Isabel Ibañez books are. This book was eerie and magical with a little mix of romance.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and Net Galley for this advanced copy.
Thank you to the author, publisher, and Net Galley for this advanced copy.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
But for a book titled Witch Dance, it was woefully absent of witches.
Review will be posted closer to the release day!
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press/Saturday Books for the e-ARC!
· · ─ ·✶· ─ · ·
Started: October 11, 2026
Finished: October 15, 2026
September 29, 2026
Having always been interested in history, my curiosity was piqued by the book’s description: “In the summer of 1518, the citizens of Strasbourg are dancing themselves to death”.
The story first introduces us to Evelina’s point of view, a witch studying medicine in Spain, and then to Alaric’s, a lovable character who will do anything to save his mother, who is suffering from the dancing madness in Strasbourg.
I found this story to be well-written, blending history with fantasy. I didn’t find the story particularly predictable, while at the same time, it wasn’t overly complex or filled with too many twists and turns.
It’s a fairly easy read, and it’s easy to immerse yourself in this world and let yourself get carried away by the story.
The only downside I found was that some descriptions or dialogues are in other languages (Spanish and German in the English edition), which can make the reader feel somewhat disconnected from the story while reading these passages if they don’t speak those languages. However, I don’t think this prevents the reader from understanding the story as a whole.
I wasn’t familiar with this author before, but I’m glad I discovered her! Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!
The story first introduces us to Evelina’s point of view, a witch studying medicine in Spain, and then to Alaric’s, a lovable character who will do anything to save his mother, who is suffering from the dancing madness in Strasbourg.
I found this story to be well-written, blending history with fantasy. I didn’t find the story particularly predictable, while at the same time, it wasn’t overly complex or filled with too many twists and turns.
It’s a fairly easy read, and it’s easy to immerse yourself in this world and let yourself get carried away by the story.
The only downside I found was that some descriptions or dialogues are in other languages (Spanish and German in the English edition), which can make the reader feel somewhat disconnected from the story while reading these passages if they don’t speak those languages. However, I don’t think this prevents the reader from understanding the story as a whole.
I wasn’t familiar with this author before, but I’m glad I discovered her! Thank you NetGalley for the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and publisher for the ARC.
Not my typical genre but so glad I picked this up!
The dancing plague of 1518 was real?! It really happened. How bizarre and fascinating.
this take on it was super cool. I loved the MCs, the atmosphere, the COZINESS.
I happened to be reading it on a stormy day with a fire going and I was literally in heaven
I can’t wait to go back and read more from the author.
PS. Please do not give a book a mediocre / bad review because you don’t like what you signed up for. If a book advertises witches and romance and then gives you witches and romance, it did its job.
Not my typical genre but so glad I picked this up!
The dancing plague of 1518 was real?! It really happened. How bizarre and fascinating.
this take on it was super cool. I loved the MCs, the atmosphere, the COZINESS.
I happened to be reading it on a stormy day with a fire going and I was literally in heaven
I can’t wait to go back and read more from the author.
PS. Please do not give a book a mediocre / bad review because you don’t like what you signed up for. If a book advertises witches and romance and then gives you witches and romance, it did its job.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I genuinely did not expect Witch Dance to get under my skin the way it did. There is something so strange and atmospheric about this book that I felt completely pulled into it from the beginning. The historical setting, the unsettling dancing plague, the magic, and the mix of witches, fae, and other supernatural elements all come together in a way that feels incredibly fresh. It has this eerie quality that never quite goes away, even during the quieter moments, and I loved that. Isabel Ibañez's writing is also so immersive that I could practically see the streets, hear the music, and feel the tension hanging over everything. This is the kind of fantasy where the setting becomes part of the experience rather than simply existing in the background.
Evelina was such a wonderful FMC to follow. I loved that she is intelligent and compassionate without being written as some flawless heroine who always knows exactly what to do. Her struggle between being a physician and being a witch gave her character so much depth, especially because she is constantly trying to prove that she belongs in a world that doesn't necessarily want to take her seriously. Alaric was just as compelling in a completely different way. He carries so much anger, grief, and fear from everything he's experienced, and watching his walls slowly come down was one of my favorite parts of the book. These two could not have been more different when they first met, which made their reluctant partnership so much fun to watch develop.
And the tension between them? Absolutely delicious. Their romance never felt like it was taking over the actual story, which I appreciated because the mystery surrounding the plague was fascinating enough to keep me invested on its own. Instead, their relationship grows naturally alongside everything else, with plenty of suspicion, frustration, longing, and those little moments where you can tell they're starting to care about each other long before either of them wants to admit it. I especially loved how their personal histories affected the way they interacted. Neither of them could simply forget everything they'd been taught or everything they'd survived, so watching that trust develop felt earned rather than rushed. The multiple POVs worked beautifully too, and every perspective added something instead of feeling like an interruption.
By the time I finished, I was just sitting there thinking about how much I had enjoyed the entire experience. There are books you like because the plot is good, and then there are books that create a specific feeling that stays with you after you close them. Witch Dance was absolutely the latter for me. It was eerie, romantic, beautifully written, occasionally heartbreaking, and wonderfully imaginative, with a story that kept giving me reasons to turn the page. I went into this expecting a historical fantasy with a romantic subplot, and I came away completely absorbed in its world and characters. This is easily one of those books I will be recommending whenever someone asks for a fantasy that feels different from everything else on the shelf.
Evelina was such a wonderful FMC to follow. I loved that she is intelligent and compassionate without being written as some flawless heroine who always knows exactly what to do. Her struggle between being a physician and being a witch gave her character so much depth, especially because she is constantly trying to prove that she belongs in a world that doesn't necessarily want to take her seriously. Alaric was just as compelling in a completely different way. He carries so much anger, grief, and fear from everything he's experienced, and watching his walls slowly come down was one of my favorite parts of the book. These two could not have been more different when they first met, which made their reluctant partnership so much fun to watch develop.
And the tension between them? Absolutely delicious. Their romance never felt like it was taking over the actual story, which I appreciated because the mystery surrounding the plague was fascinating enough to keep me invested on its own. Instead, their relationship grows naturally alongside everything else, with plenty of suspicion, frustration, longing, and those little moments where you can tell they're starting to care about each other long before either of them wants to admit it. I especially loved how their personal histories affected the way they interacted. Neither of them could simply forget everything they'd been taught or everything they'd survived, so watching that trust develop felt earned rather than rushed. The multiple POVs worked beautifully too, and every perspective added something instead of feeling like an interruption.
By the time I finished, I was just sitting there thinking about how much I had enjoyed the entire experience. There are books you like because the plot is good, and then there are books that create a specific feeling that stays with you after you close them. Witch Dance was absolutely the latter for me. It was eerie, romantic, beautifully written, occasionally heartbreaking, and wonderfully imaginative, with a story that kept giving me reasons to turn the page. I went into this expecting a historical fantasy with a romantic subplot, and I came away completely absorbed in its world and characters. This is easily one of those books I will be recommending whenever someone asks for a fantasy that feels different from everything else on the shelf.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This is one of the most utterly unique & imaginative books I have ever read, and trust me I read an obscene amount. If I could give 20 stars I would. I loved it so thoroughly, I will NEVER forget this book. AND it has fae, witches, vampires in an atmospheric dual world setting... I cannot stress enough that this is a must read standalone that I know without a doubt will be a hit in 2027. I was so teary with how thankful I was to read it at the end, truly gripping.
The magic system was easy to understand yet distinctive (loved how original the gemstones were!!) & the plot was fast paced (no fluff). The whole plot premise captivated me from the beginning- it was so suspenseful but also had this eerie layer to it that had my attention from the first chapter. We get several POVs which seamlessly pulled all the strings of the story together.
I was blown away by the worlds we were placed into. It shows how immensely talented the author is write about a city lesser known to most and make you fall in love and want to visit it yourself. I know she mentioned in a social media post she went on a research trip to this place (Strasbourg) she completely captured that magic that made you really feel there. So much so that I did my own independent research and would love to visit next year. Through her immersive writing I felt like I was right on the cobbled streets hearing the bard music, or in a lair with a giant raven grasping me (if you know, you know). Also this is a niche thing I always notice with authors but her ability to write spacial immediacy was stunning.
The FMC & MMC really shined in this book. They were both so incredibly complex with trauma , grief, + emotional depth. My heart broke for Evelina with all she had endured ..."tired of always just trying to survive" ... but despite her past she still has so much empathy and kindness in her heart, and that's a truly strong FMC in my opinion. Alaric had his own gut wrenching situations with his mother (no spoilers), and I loved watching him eventually open up to Evelina despite his deep hatred for witches. They had a few... hm... rare bonding experiences, one of which did make me laugh lol.
This pair was the epitome of reluctant allies done perfectly with so much suspense woven with TENSION, yearning (dialed up to maximum - my goodness) ... and when it snaps, it SNAPS!! Their love story was wholly beautiful and distinctly their own, it was truly beautiful to watch it grow and take root to a soul deep level.
This book is a one-of-a-kind adult fantasy romance masterpiece. There are so many twists and turns with an ending you'll never see coming. You'll cry, you'll smile, and you'll be completely captivated through it all.
Get ready to be on the edge of your seat the entire while Isabel's writing transports you to whole new worlds that are unforgettable. From the bottom of my heart I want to thank Isabel Ibañez for bringing this book to life, I feel so incredibly grateful that I had the opportunity to read it. I am actually a bit teary with how incredibly thankful I am. Thank you also to St.Martin's Press / Saturday Books & NetGalley!
The magic system was easy to understand yet distinctive (loved how original the gemstones were!!) & the plot was fast paced (no fluff). The whole plot premise captivated me from the beginning- it was so suspenseful but also had this eerie layer to it that had my attention from the first chapter. We get several POVs which seamlessly pulled all the strings of the story together.
I was blown away by the worlds we were placed into. It shows how immensely talented the author is write about a city lesser known to most and make you fall in love and want to visit it yourself. I know she mentioned in a social media post she went on a research trip to this place (Strasbourg) she completely captured that magic that made you really feel there. So much so that I did my own independent research and would love to visit next year. Through her immersive writing I felt like I was right on the cobbled streets hearing the bard music, or in a lair with a giant raven grasping me (if you know, you know). Also this is a niche thing I always notice with authors but her ability to write spacial immediacy was stunning.
The FMC & MMC really shined in this book. They were both so incredibly complex with trauma , grief, + emotional depth. My heart broke for Evelina with all she had endured ..."tired of always just trying to survive" ... but despite her past she still has so much empathy and kindness in her heart, and that's a truly strong FMC in my opinion. Alaric had his own gut wrenching situations with his mother (no spoilers), and I loved watching him eventually open up to Evelina despite his deep hatred for witches. They had a few... hm... rare bonding experiences, one of which did make me laugh lol.
This pair was the epitome of reluctant allies done perfectly with so much suspense woven with TENSION, yearning (dialed up to maximum - my goodness) ... and when it snaps, it SNAPS!! Their love story was wholly beautiful and distinctly their own, it was truly beautiful to watch it grow and take root to a soul deep level.
This book is a one-of-a-kind adult fantasy romance masterpiece. There are so many twists and turns with an ending you'll never see coming. You'll cry, you'll smile, and you'll be completely captivated through it all.
Get ready to be on the edge of your seat the entire while Isabel's writing transports you to whole new worlds that are unforgettable. From the bottom of my heart I want to thank Isabel Ibañez for bringing this book to life, I feel so incredibly grateful that I had the opportunity to read it. I am actually a bit teary with how incredibly thankful I am. Thank you also to St.Martin's Press / Saturday Books & NetGalley!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Evelina del Valle is studying to be a physician and hiding that she’s a witch. She's been chosen for a field assignment to help cure a mysterious dancing plague.
Alaric Keller was kidnapped as a child and brought to his father in Faerie. The experience has taught him to despise the wickedness of witches and the fae. He manages to escape, returning to his human mother right before she catches the plague.
The two must work together to solve the mystery of the deadly illness. It's an investigation that brings them closer together. But with every passing day, they're running out of time to save the infected.
✨Adult Fiction
🧪Historical Romantasy
💀Witch x Halfling Fae Prince
✨The Dancing Plague of 1518
🧪Enemies to Lovers
💀Reluctant Allies
✨Women in STEM
🧪Open Door
'Witch Dance' is the captivating second novel in 'The Spellbound History Quartet.' It's a historical romantasy that draws inspiration from the Dancing Plague of 1518. This story is told in third person limited, multi-POV.
The first book in this series didn't spend much time on the magical worldbuilding. So, it was exciting that this one explores the witches, vampyres, and the fae. The different creatures, combined with the plague, worked to create several layers of high-stakes conflicts. It's much darker than the previous book, with a quarantined town, a disturbing sickness, and wheelbarrows full of the dead.
Evelina is strong, independent, capable, and focused. She's an intelligent student, who's been working hard to prove herself. Even though she feels guilty for abandoning her coven, she knows that it's the only way to seize control over her destiny.
Alaric is honourable, intense, loyal, and determined not to be corrupted by power. His biggest fear is being trapped in his father's clutches once again. I found him frustrating at times, but I also understood his perspective.
The romance is a slow burn that's equal parts tension, longing, and softness. To start, Evelina and Alaric need to work through the misunderstanding that's keeping them apart. They both have huge hearts, which is what inevitably brings them together.
Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Saturday Books for providing an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
Alaric Keller was kidnapped as a child and brought to his father in Faerie. The experience has taught him to despise the wickedness of witches and the fae. He manages to escape, returning to his human mother right before she catches the plague.
The two must work together to solve the mystery of the deadly illness. It's an investigation that brings them closer together. But with every passing day, they're running out of time to save the infected.
✨Adult Fiction
🧪Historical Romantasy
💀Witch x Halfling Fae Prince
✨The Dancing Plague of 1518
🧪Enemies to Lovers
💀Reluctant Allies
✨Women in STEM
🧪Open Door
'Witch Dance' is the captivating second novel in 'The Spellbound History Quartet.' It's a historical romantasy that draws inspiration from the Dancing Plague of 1518. This story is told in third person limited, multi-POV.
The first book in this series didn't spend much time on the magical worldbuilding. So, it was exciting that this one explores the witches, vampyres, and the fae. The different creatures, combined with the plague, worked to create several layers of high-stakes conflicts. It's much darker than the previous book, with a quarantined town, a disturbing sickness, and wheelbarrows full of the dead.
Evelina is strong, independent, capable, and focused. She's an intelligent student, who's been working hard to prove herself. Even though she feels guilty for abandoning her coven, she knows that it's the only way to seize control over her destiny.
Alaric is honourable, intense, loyal, and determined not to be corrupted by power. His biggest fear is being trapped in his father's clutches once again. I found him frustrating at times, but I also understood his perspective.
The romance is a slow burn that's equal parts tension, longing, and softness. To start, Evelina and Alaric need to work through the misunderstanding that's keeping them apart. They both have huge hearts, which is what inevitably brings them together.
Thank you NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Saturday Books for providing an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
September 24, 2026
Thanks NetGalley for the ARC—
I am so happy I found this while looking at available arcs- THIS WAS SOO GOOD!
I really enjoyed the realism (which I didn’t even realize how much realism there was until reading the author note).
This was such a beautiful story with so many wonderful layers. If it seems like I’m gushing over this book it’s because I am. Evelina was such a well thought out character, her struggle to be taken seriously as a doctor “even though she’s a woman” is just as poignant to the time period the book is set in while still being a relatable feeling today. Her struggle to find balance within herself as a healer and a witch was tough to bear witness to but it was also a beautiful story arc. Evelina’s willingness to enter a city on lockdown from a mysterious plague is heroic because so few would do it. As her shitty companions would prove. She doesn’t see herself as a hero at any point in the story though and that just makes her even more relatable. She believes in her abilities enough to need to help these people.
Alaric was also a really beautifully written character. He spends 18 years in Faerie against his will and finally escapes back to the mortal world to find his mother. Shortly after they are united she falls victim to a mysterious dancing plague. By the time we come to the town there are dozens of citizens infected and dead but Alaric’s mother (the first victim) is still alive solely because he wears himself down to care for her. He forces her to rest by tying her down and force feeding her food & water. The emotional drainage of having to physically fight her to give her body this rest is evident and it just adds another layer of empathy for him.
Alaric clocks Evelina as a witch immediately and despite his wariness towards her they end up an unlikely team to try and save the townspeople. The eventual romance between them truly is background noise but this is no way a negative. Their relationship is interwoven into the story but the romantic aspects are not make or break for the story.
Honestly this was just such a great read for any fan of fantasy with romantic undertones. I was reminded of Crimson Moth and Cruel Prince in the best ways.
I am so happy I found this while looking at available arcs- THIS WAS SOO GOOD!
I really enjoyed the realism (which I didn’t even realize how much realism there was until reading the author note).
This was such a beautiful story with so many wonderful layers. If it seems like I’m gushing over this book it’s because I am. Evelina was such a well thought out character, her struggle to be taken seriously as a doctor “even though she’s a woman” is just as poignant to the time period the book is set in while still being a relatable feeling today. Her struggle to find balance within herself as a healer and a witch was tough to bear witness to but it was also a beautiful story arc. Evelina’s willingness to enter a city on lockdown from a mysterious plague is heroic because so few would do it. As her shitty companions would prove. She doesn’t see herself as a hero at any point in the story though and that just makes her even more relatable. She believes in her abilities enough to need to help these people.
Alaric was also a really beautifully written character. He spends 18 years in Faerie against his will and finally escapes back to the mortal world to find his mother. Shortly after they are united she falls victim to a mysterious dancing plague. By the time we come to the town there are dozens of citizens infected and dead but Alaric’s mother (the first victim) is still alive solely because he wears himself down to care for her. He forces her to rest by tying her down and force feeding her food & water. The emotional drainage of having to physically fight her to give her body this rest is evident and it just adds another layer of empathy for him.
Alaric clocks Evelina as a witch immediately and despite his wariness towards her they end up an unlikely team to try and save the townspeople. The eventual romance between them truly is background noise but this is no way a negative. Their relationship is interwoven into the story but the romantic aspects are not make or break for the story.
Honestly this was just such a great read for any fan of fantasy with romantic undertones. I was reminded of Crimson Moth and Cruel Prince in the best ways.
October 29, 2026
There is something irresistible about historical fiction that blurs the line between reality and the supernatural, and Witch Dance captured my attention almost immediately.
Isabel Ibañez has such a beautiful way of bringing a story to life. Her writing is vivid, atmospheric, and wonderfully immersive, creating a world that feels both haunting and enchanting. I was particularly drawn to the eerie undertones, the fascinating historical elements, and the imaginative touches of magic that made the entire experience feel refreshingly original.
The characters were equally compelling, with personalities and motivations that kept me invested. I loved the subtle intrigue, the uncertainty surrounding certain intentions, and the chemistry that simmered beneath every interaction. There was just enough danger and mystery to keep me eagerly turning pages.
Although I haven't read the previous book set in this world, I never felt lost or unable to appreciate the narrative. Quite the opposite, actually. I became so intrigued by the setting and its lore that I'm now genuinely interested in going back and exploring more of it.
What I enjoyed most was how effortlessly the author balanced historical detail with fantastical storytelling. The unsettling atmosphere never overshadowed the emotional moments, and the imaginative premise offered something wonderfully different from my usual reads.
Overall, Witch Dance was a captivating, cleverly crafted adventure that delivered a lovely combination of suspense, romance, and dark enchantment. An absorbing experience from beginning to end, and one that reminded me why I love discovering stories that dare to be a little strange.
Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to revel in this world.
Isabel Ibañez has such a beautiful way of bringing a story to life. Her writing is vivid, atmospheric, and wonderfully immersive, creating a world that feels both haunting and enchanting. I was particularly drawn to the eerie undertones, the fascinating historical elements, and the imaginative touches of magic that made the entire experience feel refreshingly original.
The characters were equally compelling, with personalities and motivations that kept me invested. I loved the subtle intrigue, the uncertainty surrounding certain intentions, and the chemistry that simmered beneath every interaction. There was just enough danger and mystery to keep me eagerly turning pages.
Although I haven't read the previous book set in this world, I never felt lost or unable to appreciate the narrative. Quite the opposite, actually. I became so intrigued by the setting and its lore that I'm now genuinely interested in going back and exploring more of it.
What I enjoyed most was how effortlessly the author balanced historical detail with fantastical storytelling. The unsettling atmosphere never overshadowed the emotional moments, and the imaginative premise offered something wonderfully different from my usual reads.
Overall, Witch Dance was a captivating, cleverly crafted adventure that delivered a lovely combination of suspense, romance, and dark enchantment. An absorbing experience from beginning to end, and one that reminded me why I love discovering stories that dare to be a little strange.
Thank you to NetGalley for the opportunity to revel in this world.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC!
Witch Dance was an improvement over Graceless Heart for me, and I overall really enjoyed it.
The book mainly follows Evelina, an undercover witch and healer studying at la universidad de Salamanca to be a doctor. A terrible plague breaks out in Strasbourg, and she, along with a professor and two fellow students, is sent there to try to find a cure. She quickly realizes everything is not as it seems with this plague.
This was a really fun time, good vibes book. I'm in a witchy mood right now and it scratched that itch perfectly. I didn't remember much about Graceless Heart, but I didn't feel I was missing anything not remembering.
I felt like the writing and world building were both significantly better in this versus Graceless Heart. I felt like the magic system wasn't well fleshed out in that one, but it is much more fleshed out in this book. I really understood how it works now and it just made it so much easier to fall into this world and into the story. Still not a literary masterpiece, but since it was a big improvement from the previous one that really helped up my enjoyment and rating.
I really enjoyed the characters in this one. I thought they were all well fleshed out and had fantastic arcs from beginning to end of this book. I was incredibly invested in them and in them getting the ending they deserved. The romance was pretty well done as well, and I enjoyed that.
While this still isn't perfect, the fact that it was quite a big improvement from Graceless Heart really helped me enjoy this a lot. I would definitely recommend this for fall, and think a lot of people could enjoy this!
Witch Dance was an improvement over Graceless Heart for me, and I overall really enjoyed it.
The book mainly follows Evelina, an undercover witch and healer studying at la universidad de Salamanca to be a doctor. A terrible plague breaks out in Strasbourg, and she, along with a professor and two fellow students, is sent there to try to find a cure. She quickly realizes everything is not as it seems with this plague.
This was a really fun time, good vibes book. I'm in a witchy mood right now and it scratched that itch perfectly. I didn't remember much about Graceless Heart, but I didn't feel I was missing anything not remembering.
I felt like the writing and world building were both significantly better in this versus Graceless Heart. I felt like the magic system wasn't well fleshed out in that one, but it is much more fleshed out in this book. I really understood how it works now and it just made it so much easier to fall into this world and into the story. Still not a literary masterpiece, but since it was a big improvement from the previous one that really helped up my enjoyment and rating.
I really enjoyed the characters in this one. I thought they were all well fleshed out and had fantastic arcs from beginning to end of this book. I was incredibly invested in them and in them getting the ending they deserved. The romance was pretty well done as well, and I enjoyed that.
While this still isn't perfect, the fact that it was quite a big improvement from Graceless Heart really helped me enjoy this a lot. I would definitely recommend this for fall, and think a lot of people could enjoy this!
November 12, 2026
ARC provided by NetGalley, the review is my own.
I enjoyed this standalone historical fiction with a paranormal twist very much. With nearly everything being a series these days, finding a true standalone is a real treat.
This book follows Evelina, twin to Sabine, who is the only female medical student of the time, (and also a witch) in Salamanca. A mysterious plague overtakes Strasbourg, and Evelina, 2 fellow students, and her professor journey there to figure out the cause of the plague and attempt to stop it. The plague turns out not to be a deadly disease, but instead a type of mass hysteria that results in uncontrolled and unstoppable dancing (based on an actual true historical event in Strasbourg.) In Strasbourg, she meets Alaric, who is the escaped prince of a Fae realm who has gone back to the human world to be with his mother (who has fallen victim to the curse.)
As Evelina and Alaric work to find the cause and cure the townsfolk, it becomes apparent that the outbreak is magical in nature. A battle for the town, as well as the Fae realm ensues.
Throughout the book we meet several other interesting characters, including a mysterious male known only as The Courier- I’m really hoping his story is the next one told.
I enjoyed this very much- I always love to see actual history represented with a twist.
This book releases in early 2027, and I definitely recommend it.
I enjoyed this standalone historical fiction with a paranormal twist very much. With nearly everything being a series these days, finding a true standalone is a real treat.
This book follows Evelina, twin to Sabine, who is the only female medical student of the time, (and also a witch) in Salamanca. A mysterious plague overtakes Strasbourg, and Evelina, 2 fellow students, and her professor journey there to figure out the cause of the plague and attempt to stop it. The plague turns out not to be a deadly disease, but instead a type of mass hysteria that results in uncontrolled and unstoppable dancing (based on an actual true historical event in Strasbourg.) In Strasbourg, she meets Alaric, who is the escaped prince of a Fae realm who has gone back to the human world to be with his mother (who has fallen victim to the curse.)
As Evelina and Alaric work to find the cause and cure the townsfolk, it becomes apparent that the outbreak is magical in nature. A battle for the town, as well as the Fae realm ensues.
Throughout the book we meet several other interesting characters, including a mysterious male known only as The Courier- I’m really hoping his story is the next one told.
I enjoyed this very much- I always love to see actual history represented with a twist.
This book releases in early 2027, and I definitely recommend it.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Shoutout to NetGalley for the ARC!
There were so many things about this book that intrigued me. I love that this interconnected series takes place in Europe during the Renaissance and the concept of a dancing plague was eerie and interesting. However, it felt like the author was trying to do too much and yet nothing at all for most of the story. I came into this book expecting a lot of magic, witches, and fae, and yet got barely any of that compared to other books that market the same content. The pacing of this book was also a huge obstacle for me. Portions of the story felt unnecessarily drawn out, and the plot was very predictable. It also felt like the main characters were so focused on each other that they weren't able to see the glaringly obvious causes to the plague.
It's possible it was a "right book, wrong time" sort of scenario for me with Witch Dance, especially because many other early reviews are quite positive. I was definitely second-guessing myself when I started to see how much other people have enjoyed this book, but I also don't always agree with the masses on popular fantasy novels. All that being said, this might not have been the book for me, but it definitely could be for someone else!
This author certainly does a great job crafting creative concepts, so I hope the next book I pick up by her is a better fit for me. Isabel is also good friends with some of my favorite authors, so I know she's got strong writers in her corner who are likely in the trenches with her providing feedback and strengthening her as a writer.
There were so many things about this book that intrigued me. I love that this interconnected series takes place in Europe during the Renaissance and the concept of a dancing plague was eerie and interesting. However, it felt like the author was trying to do too much and yet nothing at all for most of the story. I came into this book expecting a lot of magic, witches, and fae, and yet got barely any of that compared to other books that market the same content. The pacing of this book was also a huge obstacle for me. Portions of the story felt unnecessarily drawn out, and the plot was very predictable. It also felt like the main characters were so focused on each other that they weren't able to see the glaringly obvious causes to the plague.
It's possible it was a "right book, wrong time" sort of scenario for me with Witch Dance, especially because many other early reviews are quite positive. I was definitely second-guessing myself when I started to see how much other people have enjoyed this book, but I also don't always agree with the masses on popular fantasy novels. All that being said, this might not have been the book for me, but it definitely could be for someone else!
This author certainly does a great job crafting creative concepts, so I hope the next book I pick up by her is a better fit for me. Isabel is also good friends with some of my favorite authors, so I know she's got strong writers in her corner who are likely in the trenches with her providing feedback and strengthening her as a writer.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
thank you to netgalley and st. martin's press for the ARC.
i didn't know i needed this book until i read it!! the setting. the atmosphere. the plague! as we have established in other reviews, i do not do well with body horror, so when the plague was first introduced w/ i felt my stomach drop. it was so unsettling, i couldn't put the book down. i literally read 90% of it in one sitting.
i really enjoyed the plot and it felt like it had real stakes, which i always appreciate. i LOVE historical fantasy, and i felt like isabel added in a lot of fantastical elements (vampyres, witches, fae) while still keeping the story grounded. evelina and alaric were great characters with a lot of depth to them that really leant itself to building their relationship while also establishing them as fleshed out characters that you want to root for.
the reason this is 4 stars and not 5 for me is the "slow burn" didn't feel super slow. it was around 40% into the book where they admitted they had feelings for each other, and my sweet spot is around 60%. i also felt like felt in poor taste. it was kind of giving ACOWAR having sex while everyone was fighting outside lol
i've only read isabel's YA, but i'm really invested in this series now! gotta go back and read graceless heart!!
i didn't know i needed this book until i read it!! the setting. the atmosphere. the plague! as we have established in other reviews, i do not do well with body horror, so when the plague was first introduced w/ i felt my stomach drop. it was so unsettling, i couldn't put the book down. i literally read 90% of it in one sitting.
i really enjoyed the plot and it felt like it had real stakes, which i always appreciate. i LOVE historical fantasy, and i felt like isabel added in a lot of fantastical elements (vampyres, witches, fae) while still keeping the story grounded. evelina and alaric were great characters with a lot of depth to them that really leant itself to building their relationship while also establishing them as fleshed out characters that you want to root for.
the reason this is 4 stars and not 5 for me is the "slow burn" didn't feel super slow. it was around 40% into the book where they admitted they had feelings for each other, and my sweet spot is around 60%. i also felt like felt in poor taste. it was kind of giving ACOWAR having sex while everyone was fighting outside lol
i've only read isabel's YA, but i'm really invested in this series now! gotta go back and read graceless heart!!
November 10, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley, St Martins Press & Saturday Books for this ARC!
Witch Dance is a romantic, lush, atmospheric book which is exactly what I’ve come to expect from Isabel Ibañez and why she’s an auto-read/buy author for me.
I love how Ibañez centers women as the heroes of all her stories, and how they are determined, compassionate and sure of their desires. I liked Graceless Heart but I loved Witch Dance. The pacing was excellent (until the last 10%), the romance/enemies-to-lovers was believable and had me bought in immediately, and the conflict was multilayered.
The plot is interesting because of the mystery brewing and the crossover between worlds; there are also quite a few red herrings that keep the reader distracted until the big reveal(s). I also really appreciated the commentary on the persecution of women, witchcraft, and healers during this time period. And because I’m a softy, the love story got me: I thought the way Alaric and Evelina grew together and how their love was tended to and kindled over time was beautiful. Also I think it’s so clever how Ibañez is weaving together this quartet into a universe using a special character from Graceless Heart.
Witch Dance is a romantic, lush, atmospheric book which is exactly what I’ve come to expect from Isabel Ibañez and why she’s an auto-read/buy author for me.
I love how Ibañez centers women as the heroes of all her stories, and how they are determined, compassionate and sure of their desires. I liked Graceless Heart but I loved Witch Dance. The pacing was excellent (until the last 10%), the romance/enemies-to-lovers was believable and had me bought in immediately, and the conflict was multilayered.
The plot is interesting because of the mystery brewing and the crossover between worlds; there are also quite a few red herrings that keep the reader distracted until the big reveal(s). I also really appreciated the commentary on the persecution of women, witchcraft, and healers during this time period. And because I’m a softy, the love story got me: I thought the way Alaric and Evelina grew together and how their love was tended to and kindled over time was beautiful. Also I think it’s so clever how Ibañez is weaving together this quartet into a universe using a special character from Graceless Heart.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Advance Read copy provided by Netgalley.
This book is so great! I love witch books so this drew me in immediately. I could tell right away I was going to love this book. The author captivated me with the characters and her writing. I wasn't aware that the dancing in Strasbourg really happened until the Author's note! I like to believe that magic is real and this is more historical fiction than we realize.
I felt Alaric's anguish of being trapped in Fae lands and that he wanted to escape to get back to his Mom. His devastation, love and growth during the book felt so real. Evelina was such a strong and fearless female character during this time period, not to mention that she was hiding she was a witch.
The book had a lot of side plots, quests and adventures other than trying to cure the dance plague. I liked these surprises in the book and not knowing what to expect.
I highly recommend this book to other readers. It's a love story, a drama, war and fantasy, with a twist of strong love of family and adventure awaiting all of you who choose to take this adventure!
Thank you St. Martin's Press and Netgalley for showing me to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This book is so great! I love witch books so this drew me in immediately. I could tell right away I was going to love this book. The author captivated me with the characters and her writing. I wasn't aware that the dancing in Strasbourg really happened until the Author's note! I like to believe that magic is real and this is more historical fiction than we realize.
I felt Alaric's anguish of being trapped in Fae lands and that he wanted to escape to get back to his Mom. His devastation, love and growth during the book felt so real. Evelina was such a strong and fearless female character during this time period, not to mention that she was hiding she was a witch.
The book had a lot of side plots, quests and adventures other than trying to cure the dance plague. I liked these surprises in the book and not knowing what to expect.
I highly recommend this book to other readers. It's a love story, a drama, war and fantasy, with a twist of strong love of family and adventure awaiting all of you who choose to take this adventure!
Thank you St. Martin's Press and Netgalley for showing me to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 6, 2026
ARC review releasing 3/9/2027:
If you remotely enjoyed Graceless Heart you will love this. Highly recommend for fans of witches, plagues, cool magic systems, and of course “I hate you but why can’t I stop thinking about you” vibes.
Evelina + Alaric = obsessed.
The world/lore expanded on *just right* and still has me wanting more!! (Two words: The Courier👀)
The enemies to lovers / yearning vibes were so good.
I loved Graceless Heart and wasn’t sure it could be topped but it might just! When I had heard there were going to be MORE books after Graceless Heart I was excited, and when I heard this one was going to be based on the dancing plague?? I couldn’t wait!!
Thanks NetGalley/publisher for the eARC!
If you remotely enjoyed Graceless Heart you will love this. Highly recommend for fans of witches, plagues, cool magic systems, and of course “I hate you but why can’t I stop thinking about you” vibes.
Evelina + Alaric = obsessed.
The world/lore expanded on *just right* and still has me wanting more!! (Two words: The Courier👀)
The enemies to lovers / yearning vibes were so good.
I loved Graceless Heart and wasn’t sure it could be topped but it might just! When I had heard there were going to be MORE books after Graceless Heart I was excited, and when I heard this one was going to be based on the dancing plague?? I couldn’t wait!!
Thanks NetGalley/publisher for the eARC!
November 14, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and St Martin’s Press/Saturday Books for sending me a free eARC in exchange for an honest review.
I really enjoyed this book! I felt it was the right mix of fantasy and historical fiction, and even though it’s part of a quartet, you can read it separately. I haven’t read the first book in this series but since they’re self-contained stories, I never once felt lost.
I was a little worried about how the ending would come out but thankfully everything ended happily. I think the only reason I’d give this 4 stars instead of 5 is because there were times when I’d put the story down, and wouldn’t feel the need to want to pick it up again immediately. Like I was fine if I didn’t touch it for a day or two.
But it was still good and I definitely want to read more by this author!
I really enjoyed this book! I felt it was the right mix of fantasy and historical fiction, and even though it’s part of a quartet, you can read it separately. I haven’t read the first book in this series but since they’re self-contained stories, I never once felt lost.
I was a little worried about how the ending would come out but thankfully everything ended happily. I think the only reason I’d give this 4 stars instead of 5 is because there were times when I’d put the story down, and wouldn’t feel the need to want to pick it up again immediately. Like I was fine if I didn’t touch it for a day or two.
But it was still good and I definitely want to read more by this author!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Witch Dance by Isabel Ibañez has an intriguing blend of historical mystery, witchcraft, and romance. The dancing plague makes for an eerie backdrop, and there’s plenty in the premise to draw readers in. While there were elements I enjoyed, I didn’t connect with the story as deeply as I’d hoped. Overall, this was a middle-of-the-road read for me, but readers who enjoy atmospheric historical fantasy may find more to love.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 131 reviews