The second novel in Rachael Davis-Featherstone’s gripping dark academia duology, examining power, privilege, and the toxic potential of social media.
Rumours, Rivalry, Ruin...
It’s freshers’ week at Oxford University, and Eva is determined not to let the tragic death of her best friend George―or the notoriety she gained solving his murder―define her. Instead, she’s focused on acing her first essay, writing for The Oxford Voice, and maybe even getting to know Malik, her charming new American hallmate. Though try as she might, Eva can’t deny her growing feelings for Xander. Ones that serve as an aching reminder of their shared connection to George every time they start to get close.
But when Oxford’s anonymous student forum, Oxford Slays, is hacked, Eva finds herself at the center of yet another controversy. Eva’s public criticism of Oxford Slays and its negative impact on student well-being means all eyes are on her as the true identities behind the slayer usernames are leaked.
It’s up to Eva to discover who engineered the hack and clear her name. As Eva’s investigations reveal deadly secrets, it isn’t long before Oxford blood is spilled again.
DR RACHAEL DAVIS-FEATHERSTONE is a mixed-race, Black-British, multi-award-nominated author, literary agent, and cofounder of Creative Roots Studio, which helps writers and illustrators build sustainable careers. She grew up in a low-income, single-parent family and studied mathematics at the University of Oxford before receiving a master’s in English literature at the University of Surrey and a PhD in authentic representation in children’s literature at Bath Spa University.
Rachael has published thirty books, ranging from picture books to commercial fiction, and her works have been translated into eleven languages. She has been shortlisted for the Waterstones Children’s Book Prize, longlisted for the Diverse Book Awards and shortlisted for the Inclusive Books for Children Awards. Her debut YA Oxford Blood was The Bookseller’s Book of the Month and a Season Top 10 highlight. Rachael champions diversity in literature and was selected as Rising Star by The Bookseller.
She is a non-executive director for Authors’ Licensing and Collecting Society, a trustee for English PEN, and a Royal Literary Fellow at Mansfield College, Oxford.
I had really enjoyed book one, Oxford Blood, and was wicked excited for book two, but I tempered my expectations when I received the complimentary eARC from Wednesday Books via NetGalley. Why? Because books two in a series can be the hardest, and far too often, they end up being a letdown.
But this? I enjoyed it even more!!
Eva is back with her investigative skills, but this time, I especially loved the exploration of racism. I thought it was handled in such a clever and enjoyable way that also allows the reader to learn. I also loved learning more about the customs at Oxford. While the college featured in the book is fictional, the customs portrayed are 100% reality. This book took me a bit longer to read because I kept looking things up as I went!
You really get a sense of the history and attention to custom that a student gets to experience. I will mention that this may not be what some readers were expecting after book one, but for me? Brava to the author!
This is a slow-burn thriller, so to speak, with several things happening and building throughout the novel. Not only are you caught off guard by certain events, but it’s also surprising how late in the book some of them happen.
Anyway, for me, I loved it! I can’t wait to read it again when the audiobook becomes available because I already know I’m going to want a second read in a different format. Some books are worth experiencing twice, and this is definitely one of them!
This is a sequel to Oxford Blood and occurs a year after events in first book. Eva returns to Oxford for her freshman year, where she reconnects with friends old (Lily, Xander) and new (Ruby, Malik). The issues with racism still continue from the first book. Eva finds herself accused of trying to stop OxS (Oxford Slays, a social media network for the school) through her op ed on cyber bullying. That's is when the book really takes off. Hackers take over OxS and threaten to release names. A student dies. She and her friends are suspects. Eva struggles to figure out who's responsible. There is a slight love triangle (Malik, Eva, Xander), but it is added in a way that does enhance the plot and doesn't feel forced. While this is a sequel, I feel it is not necessary to read the first book, but I would highly recommend it as it was just as good! Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC.
I had high hopes for this 2nd in series YA mystery, envisioning a compelling mystery, cleverly solved - after all, the heroine is an Oxford student. Unfortunately, I feel let down, hence the 3 star rating.
The main character, Eva, is likable, smart, compassionate and loyal, all fine qualities I like in a heroine, however, she’s not much of an amateur detective. I expected a Veronica Mars type investigator, plucky, daring, intelligent and inventive in her strategies to get to the truth, instead, Eva is hesitant and aimless in her approach.
The support characters are drawn as typical college students which, while realistic, are not memorable. The cop father is bland and seems to have little to do with the plot except as a support figure. He’s not even there as a means for Eva to successfully wheedle information out of.
The plot itself meanders. While I enjoyed following along with Eva as she navigated the new world of Freshman week at Oxford, this went on entirely too long. I found myself impatient for a hint at the “secrets” and “mystery” promised to me by the intriguing title and book cover.
Additionally, the author seems determined to continually pound home how racism is prevalent at the school which is completely unrelated to the theme as I understand it from the summary (the dangers of social media and its potential tragic consequences). Even if there was a racism thread running through the story, the author fails to do more than have her characters bring it up at every opportunity. I never read any instances of this affecting the characters. They all seem to enjoy the same events and privileges of the school. No one was mistreated because they were “people of color”. So why include it when it has no bearing on the plot?
In my opinion, as a well-seasoned reader, the really interesting mystery only began mid-way through the book and this is not what I expect as a mystery reader. Add to this that the secrets were vague, and quite frankly a yawn.
In summary, if you're looking for a cracking good mystery, give this a miss. On the other hand, it does offer an immersion into the modern life of young adults and the technology that controls their lives.
I’d like to thank the publisher for providing this book in exchange for an honest review via NetGalley.
One phrase: Oxford drama, anonymous gossip, and another fucking murder 🎓🩸
EVA. BABE. CAN YOU PLEASE HAVE ONE NORMAL SCHOOL YEAR?!
After solving her best friend's murder, Eva is finally starting university at Oxford. She's trying to focus on academics, friendships, and maybe a little romance.
You know. Normal college things.
Except Oxford's anonymous gossip forum gets hacked, students' identities are threatened with exposure, and suddenly Eva is at the center of another scandal.
AND THEN PEOPLE START DYING AGAIN.
At this point, I would transfer. Immediately.
I really enjoyed the premise of this one. The anonymous social media aspect, cyberbullying, privilege, and the way rumors can absolutely destroy someone's life made the mystery feel relevant.
The first half was a little slow for me, though. There was a lot of university drama before the actual mystery started gaining momentum. Once the hacking and secrets took center stage, I was much more invested.
And the romance? I could've taken it or left it. Between Xander and Malik, Eva already had enough emotional complications without adding more relationship drama.
Some of the twists were predictable, but I still enjoyed watching the secrets unravel.
✨ Tropes and vibes:
🎓 Dark academia 🩸 Campus murder mystery 📱 Anonymous gossip forum 🔎 Amateur sleuth FMC 🐍 Secrets and betrayal 👀 Everyone's a suspect 💔 Grief and complicated friendships 👑 Power and privilege 💻 Hacking and cyberbullying 💕 Romantic tension
📚 Read this if you like:
YA murder mysteries, elite university settings, dark academia aesthetics, messy friendships, anonymous gossip, social media scandals, complicated loyalties, and heroines who apparently cannot attend school without stumbling into a homicide investigation.
Was it my favorite mystery? Not quite.
Did the second half have me invested? Absolutely.
Does Eva deserve a semester without someone getting murdered?
Just like the first book, this one comes with a predictable twist. The difference is that, in the first book, I actually guessed the twist correctly but still spent half the time second-guessing myself because some of the clues were misleading enough to keep me suspicious of several characters. But this one is just… straight up predictable.
And I’ve noticed a pattern with how the “mastermind” gets introduced in both books. Someone suddenly appears, is suspiciously friendly, casually drops some very specific lore about themselves, and my brain immediately goes, “Ooooh, I wonder how THAT’S going to come back later.” And then it does, like clockwork.
The first half was also a little too slow for me. I was lowkey bored because the plot felt like it was circling the same drain instead of actually moving forward. But the second half was so much more thrilling, and the hacking elements were genuinely so fun to read.
The romance, though… I don’t know, man. I don’t mind a little romance in my mystery, but this felt a bit unnecessary and forced. I needed more build-up to make it feel less awkward and rushed.
Also, petition to give Eva a major break. She has already been through SO MUCH since the first book, and now she has to deal with yet another threat. She deserves a hot chocolate with extra marshmallows.
Overall, the second half really saved this one for me. Again, someone PLEASE get Eva that hot chocolate. It’s an emergency.
I really enjoyed Oxford Blood so knew I had to pick this one up, and it was so fast paced and easy to read that I read it in one sitting!
Admittedly, I did guess most of the plot twists, but it didn't take away from the book, I really enjoyed the plot points in Oxford Secrets, the hacking was a really unique element to follow and poor Eva just can't catch a break! Solving the murder of her best friend George haunts her as she starts University, but she finds a like-minded individual who is also being terrorised by the gossip on OxS, by anonymous students. It was a really cute Older Sister friendship with Ruby. And suddenly, Eva finds herself in a situation all too similar to the last time she was at Oxford interview week.
I once again really liked the relationship with Xander grow, but Malik was promising until around halfway, where he was rather insufferable but I think that was the point, and proves how much stronger the connection that Xander and Eva have, especially because they stay bonded as they both knew George.
Lily is still the same Lily which you've got to respect to a point, but I think how rude she was in the Tutes was rather uncalled for and she justifies it and all is forgiven, I get it you're competitive but there's no need to be so unsupportive.
This was a very enjoyable thriller and sequel to Oxford Blood. And I will be having a hot chocolate with all the marshmallows for Eva and Ruby!
Thank you to Rachael Davis-Featherstone, the publisher, and NetGalley for providing an advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
Rating: 3.5/5 stars
Oxford Secrets by Rachael Davis-Featherstone is an entertaining YA mystery with an intriguing premise, even if the execution suffers from a few pacing issues. Although this is the second installment in a series, it functions remarkably well as a standalone, making it easy to dive into Eva's new life during her freshman week at Oxford.
Eva is a smart, loyal, and likable protagonist, and the novel does a great job immersing the reader in modern student life and the heavy influence of technology. However, the first half of the book moves at a noticeably slow pace, taking quite a while to get to the core mystery. Eva’s investigative style can feel a bit hesitant and aimless rather than proactive, and a few subplots, particularly the romance, felt slightly forced.
Fortunately, the narrative picks up considerably in the second half. Once the stakes are raised and the clues begin to align, the story becomes much more engaging. Exploring the backstories of the new supporting cast adds welcome depth to the plot, and even when certain twists feel a bit predictable, the momentum is enough to keep you turning pages until the end.
Despite a sluggish start and a few loose ends, it is still a fun, easy read for fans of contemporary student-led mysteries.
✨✨✨ (3.5) Oxford Secrets pulled me in pretty quickly because I really wanted to know what was going to happen next. While I did find some parts very predictable, I still enjoyed the overall story and was curious to see how everything would play out. The first half felt a little slow for me, especially considering this as a pretty fast paced book. However, I really enjoyed the second half and felt like the story picked up and became much more engaging. I also really liked getting to meet the new characters and learning more about their backstories. It was interesting to figure out how their pasts might connect to the bigger plot and what they could potentially bring to the story. The romance, however, felt a little forced at times and didn't completely work for me. I haven't read the first book, so I can't really compare the two or say how this one fits into the series. I was still able to follow along and enjoy the story without having read the first book. Overall, 3.5 stars. It kept me interested, had some fun character development, and definitely had me wanting to find out what would happen next.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an early copy!
Oxford Secrets is the second book in a dark academia duology. The story starts with Eva’s return to Oxford for her first year. She is determined not to let the death of her best friend stop her, or her role in solving his murder define her. Then the anonymous school app OxS (Oxford Slays) gets hacked and all eyes are on Eva since she has openly shared her criticism about the app. Things turn deadly in her attempt to solve who is behind this to clear her name.
I am all for the mystery in this book. The pacing picked up the further in the book I was, and I think that felt right in a way, as it gave me room to get to know the new characters. There was a romance subplot which I liked because it stayed a subplot, but also for me the romance wasn’t very memorable. I also think the continued (from the first book) take on racism, and the influence and dangers of (anonymous) social media, is really important. The latter being the base of the mystery in this book.
Overall I give this book 3,5 stars. There is a lot I liked about this book but didn’t necessarily love. I thought it was an entertaining read and it was one that I couldn’t put down at times.
Thank you to NetGalley & the publisher for this ARC!
I read the first book in a couple sittings so I did have high hopes for this one. Unfortunately, the second book did not do it for me.
It picks up what feels like shortly after book one and poor Eva is back on OxS again for all the wrong reasons. Let the poor girl recover from her bffs death first!! I found this book predictable in the way I wasn’t questioning myself. When I figured it out, I wasn’t going back and forth throughout being like “oh wait, maybe I’m wrong” if that makes sense?
The romance between Eva and Xander didn’t feel natural and I had high hopes for those two. I think it could have been expanded on. I think maybe it was forced considering we ALMOST get an Eva & George romance in the first book (would have absolutely loved that tbh).
I didn’t hate the book but I didn’t love it either. I thought the hacking was pretty cool and felt unique, I haven’t read many books with hacking involved.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The writing improved a lot between the first book and this one, but I found myself liking the characters less and less. There were so many, and none of them felt very fleshed out.
Honestly, it didn't seem like Eva liked anyone around her all that much, so it was hard to like them myself. The lack of emotion is also a bit jarring - Eva is annoyed at how Malik acts after Ruby's death, but her best friend was murdered last year and someone else she's close to is murdered this year, and it feels like there's no grieving, just investigation.
As for the story itself, it was predictable, which isn't necessarily a problem if the plot is interesting, but it took more than fifty percent of the book to actually pick up the pace. That first half really did nothing for the characters or the plot, so I was bored. The love triangle was probably the worst part.
Overall, it was a quick and easy read, but not one I'd really recommend to anyone. The first book could've been left on its own.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
If you enjoyed Oxford Blood, you'll love Oxford Secrets! After her eventful stint over the summer where her best friend, George, was brutally murdered, Eva is back at Oxford. Unfortunately, so is Oxford Slays, the gossip website that she believes to be responsible for destroying the mental health of many of the students. Eva had intended to join the school paper anyway, so why not write an article about it? We get to meet some new characters, including Ruby, the young protege and one of Eva's neighbors, and Malik, a comp sci fresher who lives across the hall from Eva. While trying to get used to school and the ever-changing dynamics of their friend group, Oxford is embroiled in yet another scandal, and Eva is determined to get to the bottom of it. This has all of the drama and suspense of the first with a story that is somehow completely fresh. I couldn't put it down!
This book was a fabulous sequel. Special thank you to Netgalley for the Advanced Reader Copy. This sequel takes place not long after the events of Oxford Blood. The cast of characters is known to us-plus the addition of a few notable faces. OxS and our FLC -Eva Dawkins- is at the centre of the story. After what happened with George last year, she wants to move forward with her life - but OxS, an anonymous digital chat room for Oxford students - has once again become a catalyst of hate, racism, and abuse. Eva Dawkins wants to change it. And apparently so do others who have far more nefarious intentions AND methods.
This is a twisty, dark academia YA novel that I gobbled up in one sitting! Highly recommended if you love the genre.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC!
In this second installment of the Oxford's series, Eva is now officially an Oxford student. She's hoping for a fresh start after her best friend was murdered during interview week and she solved his murder. However, the thought is quickly dashed when her new friend goes missing as well.
I'll be honest, this book isn't bad, but it isn't good either. For all the constant talk about it's Oxford and everyone is sooo smart, everyone acts so dumb. The final reveal is so obvious the whole time, I wanted to scream. Not to mention the fact that Eva is just a bad friend in this book. It's possible this series just isn't for me, but it just does too much and too little at the same time.
I was curious to see where the sequel was going to go, because honestly I wasn't really expecting a second novel.
Eva is still Eva, headstrong and determined as ever to figure everything out but I just feel like.. everything dragged at parts. But nothing is really happening until maybe 40% in?? Like yeah there's a mystery but we don't get to that until we're a decent way through the book which I feel the mystery should've been prevalent at least 10% in. I will say that parts of this book do become predictable especially if you pay close attention to the characters actions, which can kind of take you out of the story. But I still had fun and it was a quick read!
Thank you to Netgalley & St. Martin's Press | Wednesday Books for an e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
Oxford Secrets is a YA novel. Eva is a freshman at Oxford, and she’s trying to move on from her best friend’s murder. I assume that happened in the first book. She makes new friends and gets right into a love triangle. When more crime and mystery surrounds her, she has to figure out what’s going on.
If you’re looking for a Good Girl’s Guide to Murder vibe, this isn’t it. Eva’s dad is a cop, and she has none of his instincts. The love triangle took precedence over the mystery. She acted her age, though her selfishness in putting her dad’s job at risk got old. I wanted for the plot to move along more with less love crap. It was an okay book.
I received this ARC from NetGalley for my honest review.
Thank you, St. Martin's Press, Wednesday Books, for providing the copy of Oxford Secrets by Rachael Davis-Featherstone. I was looking forward to reading this sequel to Oxford Blood, but it took some time to get interested in this story. I loved the new characters, but it felt like there were too many to really get attached to during the course of a single book. Once the story engaged me I couldn’t put it down, and I raced through to learn what was going on. I loved how an anonymous social media platform set the stage for the mystery, and how realistic the posts felt. While this can be read as a standalone, reading Oxford Blood first will give more insight into Eva. 3.75 stars!
Thank you NetGalley for letting me review and read this book
Release date is 1-12-27
This is second book in this series and it was good like the plot was good and it again a very fast paced story to read. I like how the plot in each of the books are different but you still see the main female characters and you see some of the old characters from the book. But then you get to meet new characters also that get involved in the crime fighting too. I figure out who did half way through the book after the event had taken place it kind of sad to me that this character did because I though I was going to like them but then they had to go the crime and made me change my mind about them.
I was looking forward to continuing this series. I enjoyed Oxford Blood in June. Unfortunately, I'm DNFing it early because I wasn't vibing with this book. I'm not sure the premise was for me. I enjoyed the premise of Oxford Blood more. I appreciate the opportunity to read this book early.
Thank you to NetGalley, Rachael Davis-Featherstone, and Wednesday Books for the e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an eARC via NetGalley.
Oxford Secrets is a mild mystery that takes a bit to get started. I almost DNF’d the book but I’m glad that I didn’t. Once you get to the halfway mark, things start to get going. It’s very similar to the first book when it comes to the format. Overall, it’s a 4-star read for me.
It was a great quick read and loved to be back with characters from book one (Oxford Blood). Love the way Eva figures things out and comes to quick conclusions. Hopefully there will be more books to follow. Really enjoyed how easy it was to read both books.
This was such a suspenseful read!! I thought I had it figured all out, which hey, I got most of it right (pats self on back), but then I got thrown for a loop! Loved it so much. Thanks for the ARC NetGalley & Wednesday Books!
While I came to read about sinister happenings around campus (like the cover suggested) this read more like a book about college kids doing college things, none of them being memorable or interesting. I thought about holding on until about the halfway point to give it a fair shot, but there was something about the writing I knew I wasn’t meshing with since chapter one. I don’t want to spend more of my time, risking a reading slump, just to give out a mid 2.5 star in the end.
— thank you to St. Martin's Press | Wednesday Books and Netgalley for providing this eARC in return of an honest review.