A major revisionist history of the Lewis and Clark For the first time in a generation, This Vast Enterprise offers a fresh and more accurate account of one of the most important episodes in American history, humanizing forgotten figures and shattering long-held myths.
"Original, compelling, and memorable...Fehrman sheds new light on a fabled story, and tells it in a way that puts all of us back in a vanished but resonant world." --Jon Meacham • "Here, at long last, is the Lewis and Clark expedition presented in living technicolor." --Hampton Sides • "Spectacular...Fehrman paints an incredible, vivid, you-are-there portrait." --Garrett M. Graff
"Fehrman's rigorous account sheds light on previously overlooked historical figures and political machinations...drawn from an impressive mountain of research involving dozens of archives, over 100 interviews, and Indigenous oral histories passed down over generations." --The New York Times
In 1806, when Meriwether Lewis and William Clark return from their yearslong journey--having led the Corps of Discovery across eight thousand miles of rapids, mountains, forests, and ravines--they bring an incredible tale starring themselves as courageous explorers, skilled survivalists, underrated scientists, and peaceful ambassadors. While there is truth in those descriptions, there is also distortion.
From one of the most exciting new historians to emerge in the past decade, This Vast Enterprise offers a bold and novel take on the a gripping narrative that draws on lost documents, stunning analysis, and Native perspectives. Craig Fehrman spent five years visiting more than thirty archives, interviewing more than a hundred sources, and collecting oral history passed down over centuries. He came to see that the success of Lewis and Clark depended on much more than just Lewis and Clark. We all know Sacajawea, and some of us know York, the Black man Clark enslaved. But This Vast Enterprise introduces us to John Ordway, a working-class soldier who fought fearsome grizzlies and towed the captains' hulking barge. It introduces us to Wolf Calf, a Blackfoot teenager who watched his friend die in a tense battle with Lewis and his men.
To capture this cast of characters, each chapter in This Vast Enterprise moves to a different person's point of view, describing their desires and contradictions with an unprecedented level of care. One chapter shows Thomas Jefferson operating in an age of bitter partisan unrest--his secret political maneuvers to fund the expedition, revealed here for the first time, are a case study in presidential power. Another chapter shows the strategy and strength of Black Buffalo, completely upending our understanding of Lakota-American diplomacy. York, in his chapters, finds ways to wield power and make choices in an era that didn't allow him much of either. Clark is not a folksy Kentuckian but a student of the Enlightenment. (Fehrman discovered his college notebook; no previous biographer even realized that he went to college.) Lewis is someone willing to sacrifice everything for his country, his mission, and his mentor, Jefferson; in Fehrman's subtle yet heartbreaking analysis, Lewis's legendary strengths are inseparable from his lifelong weaknesses.
In the end, the captains are men who needed help--from Sacajawea, from the Corps, and from each other. Mile after mile, the expedition pushes on through dramatic hailstorms and flash floods, life-threatening frostbite and infections, rattlesnakes and rabid wolves, with the Spanish cavalry in fierce pursuit. Fehrman balances the story's inherent adventure with the humanity of its protagonists. This Vast Enterprise is more than just a work of history--it's a testament to the power of innovative research and emotional storytelling, and a thrilling reminder that even the most familiar moments in history can still surprise us.
Craig Fehrman, a journalist and historian, spent five years writing and researching This Vast Enterprise. His first book, Author in Chief, was described by Thomas Mallon in The Wall Street Journal as “one of the best books on the American presidency to appear in recent years.” Fehrman lives in Indiana with his wife and children.
Thomas Jefferson believed that “somewhere in the continent’s huge and unmapped middle, the Missouri and the Columbia came close to connecting. He wanted a party…to find that connection-to chart the simplest river route from St. Louis to the Pacific.” “The expedition was a lifelong obsession…the mission framed as a commercial one…his real hopes…were science and geography-emphasizing the Enlightenment…”.
“When an imperial nation came across ‘new’ land, it could claim the territory through rituals of discovery…it owned only the right of preemption…Natives retained both the land and the right to sell it…No one brought up the Native view of preemption…Under the Law of Nations…a successful claim to a region’s preemption rights might start with a nation sending out scientific explorers…(establishing) a few trading posts…”.
“This Vast Enterprise”…the Corps of Discovery would travel eight thousand miles to find “the most direct and practicable water communications across this continent, for the purpose of commerce…land was also a motivation…” The start date-May 14, 1804, from Riviere a Dubois (Wood River) near the confluence of the Mississippi and Missouri Rivers. In this thoroughly researched perspective, Historian Craig Fehrman examines the undertaking from the POV of members of the Corps which included York and Sacajawea as well as the expedition as eyewitnessed by Native Americans.
Captain Meriwether Lewis, President Thomas Jefferson’s personal secretary, was chosen to head the Expedition. Army life had given structure to this natural outdoorsman. Jefferson’s library provided an immersive experience enabling Lewis to delve into geography and natural history. On the journey, Lewis would concentrate on the scientific, detouring into the woods to collect plants… catch new species of animals. As per Jefferson’s instructions, he would be required to keep a journal documenting his findings.
Lewis requested that William Clark Co-Captain the Expedition. In response to Lewis’ letter, Clark replied,” My friend, I join you with hand and heart.” Lewis implied that Jefferson would “grant you a captain’s commission.” Clark carried himself like a captain. The commission was not forthcoming. Clark generated much of the Corp’s documentary record-not just journaling but creating a variety of new maps. Each day- Clark recorded a compass heading and a distance, along with latitude and longitude data Lewis collected, in order to create a future master map.
Would the expedition be met with hospitality or hostility? Lewis wanted “stout, healthy, unmarried men, accustomed to the woods and capable of bearing bodily fatigue in a pretty considerable degree…” John Ordway was tasked with the job of running a “boot camp” at Camp DuBois , the goal: shaping a group of soldiers and civilians into a cohesive unit while “keeping thirty or some men from fighting, deserting or drinking themselves to death.” Camp DuBois would be an experiment. In lieu of punishment, a democratic process of consensus and trust would be used. Collective strength would be the key to survival. Ordway was the Corps “de facto” Sergeant. He never received the commission.
York did not agree to join the Corps. As Clark’s slave, he didn’t share their freedom to choose…and was seen as an extension of Clark. York’s worth as a full bodied, important member would be proven time and time again. He felled trees, plowed fields, and built fences. As the party sailed their barges and pirogues, York added his muscle “to sail and row, pole and tow” watching out for sandbars and sawyers. “The more York succeeded, the more (Clark) wanted to humble him.” York did not become a free man until 1820.
Clark needed to grasp an important truth: “On the Missouri, and certainly on whatever came after, the Corps of Discovery was not in charge. Native people set the schedule. Native people held the power. Clark needed them more than they needed him.”
Sacajawea was a member of the Shoshone. The tribe traveled between the mountains and prairie on horseback. When the Hidatsa raided for horses and captives, Sacajawea was taken. French trader and translator Charbonneau won her in a drunken gambling match. As luck would have it, the Corps would take “one French man, his Indian squaw and Charbonneau’s infant son Pahmpi along with them.” Sacajawea and Pahmpi would be symbols of the Corp’s peaceful bearing. Sacajawea made herself indispensable to Lewis and Clark to increase the chances of returning home to the Shoshone. Lewis "smelled and chewed countless plants asking Sacajawea about their Native applications. She showed them how to craft moccasins to protect feet from “prickly pears”. She noticed landmarks, especially the Three Forks, where she was captured five years prior and a patch of red earth-used to make red paint. A joyful encounter ensued with her brother, now Chief Camwahwait. Lewis and Clark would now be able to rent or buy the horses they needed to travel across the Rockies on the last leg of their journey to reach the Pacific Ocean.
Coboway was the most powerful leader of the Clatsop tribe. “He maintained an extensive network of allies, informants and commercial partners. “Adaption and negotiation were Clatsop values.” Meriwether Lewis also “Adapted. He improvised. He persevered.” Coboway saw the Americans as a potential source of not just goods but of profit.” The Clatsops would permit the Corps to build a winter fort within their boundaries.The Clatsop were “extremely fond” of guns while Americans understood the value of Clatsop canoes. A canoe, wrote Lewis, was the “article of the greatest value except a wife, with whom it is equal…If a canoe was worth a wife, why wouldn’t it be worth a few rifles?’
In addition to the extensive footnotes provided, Historian Fehrman presents aquatints drawn by artist Karl Bodmer. Images include photos of Clark’s field notes and a poll that tallied the votes each Corp member, including York, cast to establish the site of their winter quarters after reaching the Pacific. Sacajawea’s opinion was noted as well.
This was a thoroughly enjoyable and informative scholarly read. Highly recommended.
Thank you Alexandra Primiani @Avid Reader Press for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review.
Although I began this book with high expectations, things began to fall by the wayside for me a few chapters into the story. To begin with, it seemed like much of the information in the book had long ago been covered via Ken Burns, as well as previous books concerning the Lewis and Clark Expedition. Worse yet, given the fact that there is a limited amount of written information available on most of the members of group, the author continually relied on guesswork when commenting on their thoughts and feelings. For example, in describing York’s resentment towards Clark or Sacagawea’s sadness about losing her family, the author carefully prefaced such speculations with “maybe” for “perhaps.”
If this book had been slightly tweaked and written as a novel, I think I would have enjoyed it much more. However, as it has been touted as a “historical account” of the Corps of Discovery, the continual conjectures regarding the innermost thoughts of these real life characters made the book difficult to read. Thus, going against the rave reviews for this book…I tossed it in my DNF pile around the halfway point.
This Vast Enterprise by Craig Fehrman elevates narrative nonfiction to a new standard. Fehrman breathes fresh life into the legendary saga of Lewis and Clark’s expedition to the American West through a compelling storytelling device: each chapter is told from a different perspective, ranging from members of the Corps of Discovery to the diverse individuals they encountered along the way. This approach is at its most powerful when Fehrman amplifies voices often sidelined in history, such as York, William Clark’s enslaved body servant, and Sacagawea, the iconic Shoshone translator and some of the leaders of the Native Nations the Corp encountered.
Fehrman also provides an immersive look into the various Native American Nations the Corps encountered, offering nuanced insights into the traditions and cultures of the Blackfoot, Mandan, and Shoshone peoples. Arriving just in time for the 250th anniversary of American Independence , This Vast Enterprise is a refreshing reexamination of the expedition’s role in America’s westward expansion and diplomatic evolution. However, the book truly excels by providing vital context for life in the early 19th century and offering a profound new perspective on the Indigenous Nations that once ruled the American West.
This book should be classified as “historical fiction.” It is abundant with historic facts, the vast majority of which are well established. Yet, the promo touts telling the story from “a new point of view.” So, potential readers should wonder exactly how the established facts are reorganized or supplemented to gain a different vantage point. It turns out that the facts are supplemented by what purports to be the actual thoughts of some of the most critical actors; e.g. the book includes how York feels about being enslaved and Clark’s treatment of him; what Black Bull is thinking prior to and during the nearly disastrous standoff with the Corps; Sacagawea’s considerations about whether to stay with her people or proceed on to the coast with the Corps. Obviously, any previously unpublished thoughts of these key figures could constitute new points of view. However, these are simply the speculations of a third party attributed to them more than 200 years later. When I know a work of “history” is tainted with fiction I lose confidence in everything it says…
Thank you, NetGalley, for granting me a free digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Believe it or not, this is the first book I've read about Lewis and Clark's famous expedition across the frontier. Like the rest of America, I always had a vague notion of what happened via cultural osmosis, but my studies and interests tended to veer away from the American West. With that in mind, I can't attest to how Craig Fehrman's "revisionist" analysis compares to the traditional one, but I did have the opportunity to read this story with fresh eyes. Rather than focus solely on the iconic duo, Fehrman tells each chapter through the perspective of a different key figure on the expedition: soldier John Ordway, Shoshone interpreter Sacajawea, Clarke's enslaved companion, York, numerous Native American leaders, and of course, Lewis and Clark themselves--two exceedingly complicated men who took on the roles of explorers, scientists, physicians, soldiers, and diplomats during the span of their journey.
Fehrman breaks the mold by placing a slightly greater focus on Lewis, the more melancholy and troubled of the two, than Clark, who better fits the bill of a traditional protagonist. Clark was capable of great kindness and cruelty, a duality we see time and again, especially in his interactions with Sacajawea and York. The young Indian woman, who was captured by a warring tribe as a teenager and sold to a French fur trader, and the enslaved man are arguably the two stand-out characters of This Vast Enterprise, although the fact that neither one was literate, and therefore did not leave behind any personal writings, presents an issue. Fehrman writes in the style of a novelist, which makes for an engaging read, and one has to admire the lengths he goes to to try to depict his subjects as complex human beings, but the liberties he takes with deducing what they were thinking and feeling, always expressed so confidently despite scant evidence, can be quite presumptuous. Perhaps York looked upon the Pacific coast and thought of freedom--or perhaps he was tired and wanted to head back to camp. We simply do not know.
By the last third of the book, the multiple POVs start to feel excessive; This Vast Enterprise could have benefitted from being a little tighter, with more consolidation. The story's grand scope is fitting for such a remarkable adventure, however, and Fehrman has written a story that will draw in newcomers and leave them excited to learn more. It certainly left me interested in learning more about this incredible story, and the eclectic men (and woman) who made it happen.
The world needs more books like this one--written from the vantage point, or points, of people who helped make history but who we later generations never hear about. In this case, it's the voices of eight people who were not named Lewis or Clark, but who were important parts of that famous expedition from 1804-1806 to cross the span of what would become the continental United States.
These voices include the sturdy sergeant John Ordway, Clark's enslaved Black "manservant" York, the Lakota leader Black Buffalo, and the Shoshone guide Sacajawea. (Yes, to some degree history has remembered Sacajawea, because she was a young woman, and history loves presumably sexy young women... but she was far more than the "trusty Indian guide" we learned about in school.)
To produce these voices, author Craig Fehrman has done impressive research. Luckily, Lewis and Clark were prodigious journal-keepers. But Fehrman went beyond them--for instance, digging up an 1890 interview with a Native horseman who, as a teenager, had encountered the expedition. His version of the encounter differs significantly from what the two leaders wrote.
As well, Fehrman's vivid writing helped me really feel the physical exertion of that 8,000-mile trek: the cold, the rain, the exhaustion, the panic, the hunger pangs, the sheer strain of dragging canoes up the Rockies and down, or desperately trying to stay afloat in rapids. I honestly can't imagine anyone today surviving a tenth of that trip.
Unfortunately, Fehrman doesn't stick with the facts. He fluffs out his pages (and diminishes his own credibility) with too much speculation on the order of "Sacajawea must have hated saying good-bye." We readers can do that speculation ourselves.
The flip side of that speculation is a problem I constantly find in nonfiction books: TMI of the wrong type--too many repetitive details, as if the author wants to make sure readers appreciate all the research that was done. How many examples of muddy paths or aching portage do we have to read about, to get the point?
By contrast, toward the end the book hints at an important point I wish it had spelled out more: the ramifications of the trek beyond mapping out the unknown territory--most important, Lewis and Clark's fumbling attempts to manipulate Native alliances.
Despite those problems, this is an important book to fill out our understanding of the wide range of people who make history.
Craig Fehrman has done it again! In his new book, This Vast Enterprise, he tells the story of the Lewis and Clark expedition. Fehrman tells a fascinating story about adventure, discovery, foreign policy, man vs. nature, and much more. My knowledge of this expedition before reading this book was limited at best. Fehrman teaches the reader that there were more individuals involved than Lewis, Clark, and Sacajawea. Fehrman does this by writing chapters that alternate between different figures who took part in the expedition or crossed paths with the Corps of Discovery. This book is very well researched, and the level of detail is fascinating. The best parts of this book are when Fehrman really gets down into the minds of each person, so much so that you feel like you know them. He does a great job of this with Sacajawea, York, and Meriwether Lewis.
Craig Fehrman’s This Vast Enterprise offers a fresh, wide-angle look at the Lewis and Clark expedition. It has sometimes been described as revisionist history, but I do not think that term quite fits. Fehrman is not simply tearing down the traditional story. Instead, he broadens the frame, showing that this vast undertaking depended on far more people than the two captains whose names have come to define it.
Rather than centering entirely on Meriwether Lewis and William Clark, Fehrman gives greater attention to the enlisted men of the Corps of Discovery, the Native nations whose lands they entered, Sacagawea, York, and the many others whose knowledge, labor, diplomacy, endurance, and courage made the expedition possible. The result is a more complete and more honest account of one of the most remarkable journeys in American history.
I especially appreciated the Indigenous perspectives throughout the book. The West was not an empty or unexplored wilderness. It was home to Native nations with their own cultures, political alliances, rivalries, trade networks, and long histories. Lewis and Clark were not simply entering the unknown. They were moving through a complicated human landscape that already existed and depended repeatedly on the knowledge and assistance of the people who lived there.
The book also deepened my admiration for Sacagawea. She completed this extraordinary journey while caring for an infant, serving as an interpreter, helping the expedition navigate unfamiliar territory, and signaling peaceful intentions when the Corps encountered Native communities. Her courage is difficult to overstate. Her husband, Toussaint Charbonneau, comes across far less admirably—often selfish, unreliable, and undeserving of the attention history has sometimes given him.
York’s story is equally important and deeply troubling. Enslaved by William Clark, York worked tirelessly and became an indispensable member of the expedition. His strength, hunting ability, labor, and presence contributed enormously to the Corps’ survival and success. Yet he received little credit and was denied the freedom and recognition he deserved. His story exposes one of the great contradictions of the early American republic: a nation celebrating liberty, exploration, and opportunity while denying those very things to a man whose work helped make one of its greatest achievements possible.
Lewis and Clark themselves still deserve enormous admiration. They displayed remarkable courage, creativity, leadership, endurance, and an extraordinary ability to improvise under brutal conditions. President Thomas Jefferson also demonstrated his trademark vision in imagining such a mission. In many ways, I think of the expedition as America’s moon landing—an audacious national undertaking that required imagination, planning, scientific curiosity, teamwork, and tremendous courage.
But there is one essential difference: the land was already inhabited.
That truth gives the expedition a darker and more complicated meaning. Earlier histories often repeated the comforting claim that only one man, Sergeant Charles Floyd, died during the journey. While he was the only member of the Corps to die during the expedition itself, far more than one person ultimately died because of what the expedition represented and helped set in motion. The journey announced that the United States was coming west—not merely to observe and trade, but eventually to claim land, impose authority, and transform the continent.
For Native peoples, the expedition marked the beginning of a reckoning. Disease, broken treaties, military violence, forced removal, environmental destruction, and the loss of homelands followed. The expedition can still be admired as an astonishing human achievement, but the American triumph and the Native catastrophe belong to the same history. Fehrman’s most important contribution may be his insistence that we see both.
The strength of this wider-angle approach is also, at times, its weakness. By expanding the story to include more people and perspectives, Fehrman occasionally loses some of the intimacy, suspense, danger, and wonder of the expedition itself. A wide-angle lens captures more of the landscape, but it can also sacrifice detail and emotional immediacy.
For me, Stephen Ambrose’s Undaunted Courage remains the stronger overall history of the journey. I read it when it first appeared and loved it. It later inspired a National Geographic special that I shared with my students for many years. That book captured the sweep, hardship, scientific excitement, and sheer magic of the expedition in a way that stayed with me.
This Vast Enterprise did not entirely recreate that same feeling, but it did something valuable: it reawakened many of those wonderful emotions and memories. It reminded me why the Lewis and Clark story fascinated me in the first place and why I enjoyed sharing it with generations of students.
I would also have liked more detail about what the expedition discovered, collected, mapped, described, and catalogued. Its scientific work—the plants, animals, geography, maps, observations, and specimens—was among its greatest accomplishments. A fuller treatment of those discoveries would have added even more richness and helped restore some of the sense of exploration that I occasionally missed.
Still, This Vast Enterprise is a valuable and thought-provoking addition to the history of Lewis and Clark. It does not erase their courage or diminish the scale of their achievement. Instead, it reminds us that the journey was never the work of only two heroic men.
It depended on the enlisted members of the Corps, the knowledge and assistance of Native peoples, the courage of a young mother caring for her infant, and the tireless labor of an enslaved man who was denied the rewards granted to others.
This was an excellent addition to my America at 250 reading project. The Lewis and Clark expedition remains one of the most incredible stories of vision, exploration, creativity, and courage in American history. Fehrman simply asks us to admire it with our eyes fully open.
What a truly wonderful book. There is so much great detail, insight and revelation in this expert tracing of The Lewis and Clark Expedition. There is the character and heroism of the leaders and their exploration team is revealed and each individual is a study in courage, patience, hopefulness and strength. Fehrman even takes time to follow up on his own extensive research. His writing style captured my interest throughout and I looked forward to “picking up where I had left off” every evening. One of the best features of this book is the description of each native-American tribe and leader. They are “real” individuals here and indigenous society is revealed in their societies, wars, villages,,reactions to the explorers. Thomas Jefferson is a central figure and his personality and intellect shine thru the entire story. I would recommend this book to everyone seriously interested in American History. The expedition was monumental.Fehrman always tells an exciting story. Thank you NetGalley,author,Craig Fehrman,publisher, Simon and Schuster for the arc ebook of The Vast Enterprise. On Sale April 21,2026
This is one more of those books where I have to wonder if those who offered "blurbs" for its jacket and have praised it elsewhere have actually read it!
The reasons are these:
While it does give voice to many people from whom we have not heard before, it is detailed to a confusing degree, almost impossible for the reader to keep straight "where" the explorers are at any given time, and consistently treats minutiae with the same coverage and length as it does matters of greater importance.
From my point of view, the book could have used a very good editor or two to tighten it up, clarify place- and time-lines, and generally make it inevitable heck of a lot more readable.
How the publishers can describe this book as nonfiction is a total mystery to me. Page after page is filled with pure speculation about historical figures who could neither read nor write and left no record of their thoughts or feelings. The only clues provided for the reader are the many introductory words and phrases the author frequently uses to temporize his suppositions. Words and phrases like "surely," "no doubt," "probably," "almost certainly," "would never have" tip the reader off to purely fictional passages that are there simply to support the author's thinly disguised agenda--which is that all the principals involved in the Lewis and Clark expedition were incorrigible racists who cruelly mistreated all non-whites, especially Negroes, women, and Native Americans. No one is spared. Presidents Washington and Jefferson as well as Lewis and Clark--all are painted with the same broad brush intended to diminish the incredible accomplishments of the expedition.
This book is a classic case of a 21st century writer transporting himself and his 21st century knowledge, morals, and biases back into the past with out regard for the mores, educational standards, or economic conditions prevailing in this country more than 200 years ago.
I'm a big fan of Undaunted Courage. I was excited to read this. I was very disappointed when I began hearing "Perhaps". I feel like there was a lot of opinion on things that may not have actually happened. Especially for non-fiction book. There are good things about this book, but it discredited itself.
Hearing the names Lewis & Clark took me back to the chalkboard-walled rooms of grade school history class. Reading "This Vast Enterprise" put my bare feet into the icy rapids of the Missouri river, where jagged rocks sliced open my skin.
This is my way of saying that Craig Fehrman's "New History" reads like a novel. Rich with colorful descriptions of skies, rivers, and rolling prairies. Saturated with details that appeal to other senses. For example, I felt the sting of mosquito bites and sweat that soaked my shirt as I empathized with the rugged explorers who burned 5,000 calories a day.
And these pages are packed with action. Grizzly bears chasing terrified soldiers, boats tipping into foamy waters with non-swimmers aboard, and a hungry and cold march through the mountains that has a happy ending.
Each chapter in this book is viewed through the eyes of a particular person who played a role in the bigger story. The author calls them the "Cast of Characters." Meriwether Lewis, William Clark, York (a builder, hunter, and body servant of Clark), Thomas Jefferson, Sacajawea, John Ordway (first sergeant), and Black Buffalo (Lakota leader) are some, among many, examples.
Thanks to Fehrman's thoughtful approach, my own eyes have been opened to just how massive this expedition was. And how many lives made it happen and were touched by it. For better, for worse, and for everything in between.
I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in viewing this chapter in America's past through vivid narration.
This Vast Enterprise: A New History of Lewis & Clark by Craig Fehrman Avid Reader Press/Simon & Schuster, April 21, 2026 ★★★★★ (5/5)
I rate books strictly by how much I enjoy reading them, and I very much enjoyed this one. It was one of those books I found difficult to put down. I've always been interested in the story of Lewis and Clark, and in Thomas Jefferson as well, so when I caught Fehrman being interviewed on C-SPAN's Book TV, I went straight to Amazon afterward and ordered my own copy. What I found right away is that it's very insightful, told through the eyes and feelings of many of the characters on the journey, as well as a few of those they encountered along the way. Fehrman doesn't just march through the expedition as a list of dates and river miles.
The chapters I liked best were the ones on Sacajawea and on York, Clark's slave. Sacajawea's reunification with her native tribe, finding her brother and her best childhood friend still there, is told in a way that really brings her emotions to the surface. You feel the weight of that moment with her. York's story is just as affecting, but in a more complicated way. Over the course of the journey he clearly earns the genuine respect of Clark and the rest of the expedition, pulling his weight and more right alongside them. And yet when it's all over, Clark is just as clear that he still "owns" York. Fehrman doesn't soften that contradiction, and the book is better for it.
I highly recommend this book for any history buff. My only real complaint is with the second appendix, which I think Fehrman should have left out entirely. In it he baselessly suggests that Lewis and Clark may have had a sexual relationship, offering nothing to actually back it up. It's unsubstantiated innuendo that adds nothing to an otherwise insightful and well-told history.
One nice surprise came after I posted this: Fehrman himself saw the review and reached out. I asked him straight out whether that appendix, "Sex and the Expedition," and specifically the suggestion that Lewis and Clark may have had a sexual relationship, had come up as a point of debate, either with himself or with other readers. He was generous with his answer. He said most readers who'd mentioned the appendix actually liked it, but that mine wasn't the first complaint he'd heard. He explained that his intent was never to claim Lewis and Clark had a relationship, only to show what was possible in their era. He pointed to an 1805 Navy court-martial, under oath, as evidence that men on an isolated military outfit like a ship (not so different from an isolated expedition) sometimes did have sex with one another, and said flatly, "I do not mean that it was likely or certain; I have no way of knowing that. I only mean it was possible." He told me my take was "a fair take" and that he wouldn't try to talk me out of it, while noting he still thinks the appendix adds something, particularly its points on DNA testing. It didn't change my opinion of the appendix (I'd still have left it out), but it says a lot about Fehrman that he'd take the time to explain himself to a reader, and I appreciated the exchange.
A genuinely insightful, character-driven telling of the expedition. I highly recommend this book for pure knowledge gaining and enjoyment.
Have you read it? And what's the best nonfiction book you've read this year?
If you want to know every detail of why Lewis and Clark took their expedition, and how it went on a daily basis, then this book is for you. Fehrman gives the story a very human element, not just the over arching story but the toll on both Lewis and Clark, their staff, and even Jefferson, who was president.
Fehrman also does an excellent job of showing how precarious the whole venture really was—politically, financially, and personally. He doesn’t treat the expedition as a straight line from St. Louis to the Pacific, but as a series of improvisations, near‑failures, and lucky breaks that could easily have gone another way. The accumulating details of supply problems, personnel conflicts, and diplomatic missteps make the familiar story feel newly suspenseful rather than predetermined.
Very detailed, and a tad repetitive at times, but well researched.
A totally new look at the Louisiana Purchase as well as the Lewis & Clark Expedition. Fascinating research involved newly discovered documents and oral traditions. Seen through the eyes of not only Lewis & Clark, but also members of The Corps of Discovery, a slave brought along by Clark, and numerous Indian/Native Americans with whom they interacted on their journey. And we also learn about the spy, Agent 13, a member of the US Army who was a spy for Mexico. So many new stories and information. Wonderful read!! 4.5****
If you studied about Lewis and Clark in school and think you know their story, you will be amazed at the difference between what you were taught and the complete history in this extraordinary book.
Complete is the word. You learn about the politics of the time, the indigenous people, slavery, medicine and so much more. It never feels like padding or look how much I know; it works together to tell a compelling story.
If you are afraid that the amount of information will take away from the excitement of their journey, you can rest easy. It’s clear about important issues that many of us were never taught, but the audaciousness of their journey is never dull.
Lewis, Clark, Sacajawea, York; they all come to life. I came to a much greater understanding of native America culture, and it made me eager to know more.
You will also never think about grizzly bears the same way after you read this book.
I guess I’ve read too many great books this year, and I’ve already said this once already, but this may be the best book of the year.
This is a perfect example of a history book for the interested non- expert. My take is that of a fascinating topic, flowing narrative, healthy, intelligent, transparent, and well-founded speculation, dozens of opportunities for the reader to make an emotional, empathetic connection to the explorers and native peoples from an important and often misconceived era, an appreciation of the curiosity and technical and scientific rigor Lewis and Clark and their corps followed daily for several years, and brief but well understood political and historical background for the "enterprise". Other five-star components - awesome illustrations, reproduced from the captains journals and other high-quality contemporary accounts, and the "back material", the resources and artifacts that the author relied on to tell this most modern account of the Lewis and Clark Expedition. An absolute treasure. Six stars! (Seven!)
I had to stop reading it after 100+ pages. This is supposed to be a work of non-fiction except the book constantly is saying a person "perhaps," "most likely," and the author's favorite "surely" did something. ("Surely" appears multiple times per page in some sections.) This distracted me so much that I had to put the book down. If the author doesn't have the facts to back something up it shouldn't be in the book. I'm stunned by all the positive reviews. Just awful
An exhaustively researched book that was, in some parts, quite detailed. But the detail is mostly necessary to tell the whole true story about the Corp and its adventures. Highly recommend to any history buff.
Saw him speak at the Texas book festival yesterday, so excited to read this! His background as a journalist first influenced his writing prep in that he interviewed many scholars as well as members of native nations when written accounts were sparse.
“This Vast Enterprise” by Craig Fehrman is an interesting, highly readable account of the Lewis and Clark expedition. I didn’t know much about the expedition, and haven’t read any of the previous books on the topic, so I found this account fascinating and immersive, and I learned a lot about the expedition and the time period. Fehrman incorporated a lot of oral histories and interviews into the narrative, which is presented through the voices of not only Jefferson and the expedition’s leaders, but also from the point of view of the men on the expedition, Clark’s enslaved manservant, Native Americans who encountered the explorers, and even Lewis’ faithful dog, Seaman. Fehrman discusses the military and political context of the expedition as well as its scientific and geographical significance, and he includes thoughtful observations about its successes and failures. Excellent and recommended.
This book is positioned in a nice niche, with more depth that pop history but not as much detail as the academic work on the primary sources. The author seems to have done real scholarship, with a great resource in the form of the expedition journals as well as some apparently new/overlooked Native sources. I certainly got a better understanding of an expedition that is usually just something vaguely referenced within other histories.
Unfortunately, the book is marred by an extremely high level of speculation. The word "perhaps" appears an absurd number of times, and the author is aware of this, reassuring the reader about how careful he is with sources. I believe that enough that I didn't reject the book, but some of the details he offers strike me as dubious. There are many little slippages, leaving you to constantly wonder if something is from the actual sources or just made up by the author to match the audience's expectations.
I feel like the narrative elements go too far with York (Clark's personal slave): the author clearly wants to give this man a voice, but it seems like we don't have the historical records for it, so we're basically forcing a voice on him. The contemporaneous quotes from slaves are reasonable speculation, but York's voice itself has been lost to time. This feels especially hollow because so much of it boils down to, "And York was presumably also there."
I thought things might be better with Sacajawea, but apparently historical information about her is a lot sparser than I thought. So many sections about her have no source; they're just the author filling in what people would like to believe about a Native American woman who, in truth, we do not know.
This comes off negative, and I really do think this direction is a mistake for nonfiction, but I don't want to lose the positives either. The author sprinkles in a ton of primary source quotes and there were multiple times when, instead of just speculation, he brings a quote from contemporaneous voices who at least give us a clearer idea of how things were at that time. He's also capable of setting aside modern judgments to get into the nuances of the individuals, such as Lewis and Clark having various levels of prejudice.
A good popular-oriented take on the expedition. Not a scholarly work, but a good read. The biggest disappointment for me was that that author did not identify locations described in proximity to current-landmarks (near current day Bismarck, ND). That would have made it much easier to keep track of the narrative. I did come away from the book with a greater appreciation for Native American urban culture and for addressing issues like the sex lives of the explorers along the way, the complicated relationships between trappers, traders, Native American politics, British and French reactions, etc.
Though at times an engaging story, I had to force myself to finish it. Living near the Missouri River in the Midwest, I have always had a fascination for Lewis and Clark and their expedition. The author has obviously done a great deal of research, but seems to me there is also a great deal of supposition. Not sure how factual much of the story actually is, although I did find parts of it interesting. I did enjoy learning more about the lives of some of the supporting characters, such as Sacajawea, York, and Ordway, but am left questioning what is fact and what is simply imagined.
The best thing overall about this book is that it is not a Stephen Ambrose-type American exceptionalism version of Lewis and Clark, thought the author does reference both him and another American exceptionalist, Ken Burns. (He is.)
Part of that is to "de-other" not only Sacagawea, but other American Indian leaders the expedition encountered.
And also to "de-other" the one non-White person on the expedition, Clark's enslaved York. (Interestingly, contra common more enlightened practice, Fehrman actually doesn't use that exact word, "enslaved" very much instead of "slave.")
Anyway, this is the book's biggest weakness. A couple of other reviewers have noted that at times, the book, with Fehrman's caveats, is as much historical fiction as it is history.
On York? Early in the book, it's not even historical fiction, it's just fiction, period.
Fehrman makes unsubstantiated, even unsubstantiable, and almost certainly false assumptions about Old York, father of York. Yes, Juba is an African name — north African, coastal African, from the time of Rome. Not at all connected to sub-Saharan Africa. Are we to assume that Old York was literate with another son being named Scipio? That he knew about Rome's battles with Carthage? No, rather, a more reasonable assumption is that John Clark named all five of Old York’s kids. This was actually common. (Two pages later, he admits that the Clarks didn’t teach any of their slaves to read or write, so how could an illiterate descendant of sub-Saharan Africans learn about an Imperial Roman era Numidian, let alone a family of Roman consular generals?) Half-star or more ding for being wrongfully woke, and for blatantly so, and above all for being knowingly so. ("Wrongfully woke" means that there's a non-wrongful version as well, and there is.)
Later chapters about York must be considered fictionalized, where not explicitly based on the journals of Clark or some other literate member of the Corps of Discovery.
Per the endnotes, which are worth reading, I didn’t realize Gerard Baker et al wrote a book claiming Sacagawea was actually Hidatsa. Even without the author’s counterblast, yeah, this seems unlikely. In addition? Since Baker was actually NOT the first American Indian superintendent at Little Bighorn — he doesn’t directly claim this, but, many books, like one I read earlier this year about Rushmore run with it, so he doesn’t go out of his way to swat it down — there should be a grain of salt with his name anyway.
Otherwise, there's not a lot new here. Probably the one thing new to me was the fairly in-depth write-up of Lewis' encounter with the Piikani (PIegan) Blackfoot.
And, other than York, the biggest weakness was the implication that the Oceti Sakowin (Sioux) had been on the Upper Missouri in the Dakotas for a long time when Lewis and Clark got there. Not so, In any real numbers, the western, Lakota, portion had gotten there no more than 50 years earlier. See Wiki.
And, because of York, even though I am keeping it overall at 3 stars, it still gets the "mendaciousness" tag. I will add that I knocked it down 3 times in quarter-star increments from first assembling my notes.
One reason this book works so well is that historian Craig Fehrman presents it like a dramatic novel. The story unfolds from different points of view alternating between the persons traveling on the expedition. It includes the politics behind funding, unvarnished scenes about the challenges of supplying an expedition like this and traveling through rugged territory, the fight for control of territory among the Native populations, and how Native leaders supported and sometimes saved the men on expedition.
The alternating points of view provides varied perspectives and gives a better understanding of the inner lives of the men who supported Lewis & Clark’s mandate, which was essentially to provide President Jefferson with research to fulfill his goal to claim preemptive rights over Native territory. The Louisiana Purchase, which gave the United States preemptive rights over a huge territory west of the Mississippi, emboldened Jefferson to close the gap between that territory and the west coast.
I was most interested in the day-to-day challenges of an expedition like this: provisioning; the methods of travel and navigation including upstream paddling, sailing, or portage; climate and terrain; problems such as predators and internal discord. Enough cannot be said about the importance of teamwork to successfully accomplish a feat of this magnitude. This includs the help of soldiers from working class homes that of the the Natives, particularly Sacajawea. Of course, political leaders played the important role of funding, but their mission has gone down in history to be viewed through a difference lens than it was in the 1800s.
Reading this book in traditional paper versions would have been an even better experience as the maps and illustrations could have been consulted along the way. Unfortunately, eReaders aren’t the best for images.
Many thanks to Avid Reader Press | Avid Reader Press / Simon & Schuster and NeGalley for providing the ARC.
A book ostensibly about the Lewis & Clark Expedition, which says remarkably little about the topic it is meant to be discussing.
This book, at its core, is not actually about the Lewis & Clark Expedition -- it is rather about the people who participated in the Lewis & Clark Expedition. While this is not necessarily a negative, the fact that the author makes the unorthodox stylistic choice to narrate each chapter from a different party member's perspective makes the book seem overly ambitious for what should be, first and foremost, a work of history. I do not think the idea to tell this story through the lens of the individuals it concerns is inherently a bad one, but I do think it could have been executed far better than it was.
The primary issue I have with this book is that it is not particularly good at explaining what occurred during the Lewis & Clark Expedition. It gives many people's personal accounts of specific moments, but despite the fact that I finished this book not even 15 minutes ago, I still have next to no high-level understanding of the event. I understand a great deal about the personality traits and behaviours of many people on the expedition, but this is not why I chose to read this book.
Quite frankly, there were parts of this book which felt like genuine wastes of my time. In particular, the chapters about York (William Clark's personal slave) and Sacagawea (the Indigenous interpreter who accompanied the expedition) felt closer to a work of historical fiction than they did to a genuine historical work. There are paragraphs where every sentence starts with 'maybe', 'possibly', 'perhaps', or some other expression of uncertainty. If every claim made in a chapter is a guess, what is being written is not history -- it's conjecture. I understand that the voices of enslaved African Americans and Indigenous peoples are often overlooked when discussing early US history, but the solution to this is not to bypass the historical method entirely.
Despite my criticisms of this work, Fehrman is genuinely a talented writer, and he seems more than capable of writing about a historical event in a unique, character-driven manner. I simply do not think this subject matter was appropriate for that approach.
I love American history and the expedition of Lewis and Clarke is such a big part of that history. I remember learning about the Westward Expansion in high school, but it didn’t come to life for me til I visited a museum in Kansas, with an exhibit on Lewis and Clarke. Of course in that museum they were portrayed as impeccable heroes “discovering” land (ignoring native history and experience). This book is more nuanced. It does not shy away from mentioning the terrible treatment of native people, slavery, etc.
While interesting, this book is so detailed at times that my eyes started to glaze over a bit. So I had to slow down and read it a few chapters at a time.
My favorite parts were hearing about new experiences people had on the expedition. For example, the white men seeing grizzly bears for the first time or natives seeing a black man for the first time. There is some innocence and wonder in those moments before colonialism and racism wrecked it all.
I also enjoyed the chapters about Sacagawea. You tend to forget how young she was and what all she went through.
All in all an enjoyable book if you’re into the topic.