Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Then Until Forever

Rate this book
Avery Bennett hasn’t thought of Jax Anderson in four years. At least, that’s what she tells herself. She’s moved on from her high school boyfriend after he broke up with her before leaving for college. She’s built her own business from the ground up; she’s even tried dating again, though her relationship with her now-ex crashed and burned even harder than her first. She’s happy with her new life. She’s content. But she wasn’t expecting the flare of confusing emotions that came swirling back when she found out her high school sweetheart was back in town. And back to stay.

Jax made a mistake. He lost the love of his life when he broke up with Avery four years ago. He told himself they could still be friends; that he would work up the bravery to call her once everything calmed down because he couldn’t handle losing her forever. But he hadn’t done it. Now, he’s determined to get her back. He knows he can’t have Avery in all the ways he wants, but he’ll settle for just being her friend, if she doesn’t hate him too much after how he left her.

253 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 6, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Mase Evans

7 books40 followers
Mase Evans is a fantasy and romance author who enjoys a story that immerses readers in new worlds full of fun characters, adventure, and swoon worthy love stories. She primarily writes fantasy romance books geared toward YA an NA audiences.

She grew up in Houston, Texas with her younger siblings and began writing at the age of 10, finishing her first full length novel when she was 14. She continues to live in Texas with her husband and her four fur babies.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
36 (16%)
4 stars
123 (54%)
3 stars
55 (24%)
2 stars
8 (3%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 194 reviews
Profile Image for Sim-fully Ever After.
1,017 reviews96 followers
October 15, 2026
4🌟 | 0🌶️

Fall romances are even better when there's a little second-chance romance mixed in.

Avery and Jax had me rooting for them from the start, and their childhood friends-to-lovers history made their connection feel so genuine. I loved how they slowly found their way back to each other rather than rushing into old feelings.

Avery was easy to connect with, especially because she had her own life and goals outside of her relationship. Jax was equally endearing, and watching him find little ways to stay close to her had me smiling. Their chemistry, lingering feelings, and sweet moments made the slow burn well worth it.

Maple Brook was another highlight, with its cozy autumn atmosphere and lovely small-town charm. The fun friend group and Sir Fluffington added even more personality to the story.

This was such a comforting romance, and I finished feeling happy to have spent time in this little world.

~~~~

A sincere thank you to Mase Evans and Beyond The Books PR for the ARC! 🥰📚

I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
Profile Image for Robin ❤️.
535 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 23, 2026
Maple Brook
Book 1
First time reading anything by Mase Evan’s and let me tell you it won’t be the last.

The perfect fall vibes with the perfect fall town.
Mase has a way of pulling you in with her cozy writing.

Maple Brook is literally the perfect little town. I’m obsessed and would move there in a heartbeat.

Jax and Avery have this undeniable connection and chemistry. You can’t help but to root for them both together and separately.
I felt giddy right along with Avery. Her feelings for Jax were rooted so deep. I got butterflies with her too 😭 absolutely adorable.❤️

Childhood friends to lovers always gets me and this one definitely did. The emotion was sooo on point.
Huge thanks to Mase Evans for this arc.
Releases October 6th 🍂🍁🍃


Profile Image for RosieRitesReviews.
200 reviews10 followers
October 10, 2026
Then Until Forever (Maple Brook, Book 1) by @ gives ALL the cozy fall vibes packed with second chances, friends to lovers, forced proximity, and two people who are discovering that time apart doesn't always mean moving on.

My Thoughts:
This was such a cute second chance read! I loved Avery's character, she had her own struggles, her own goals and just seemed content living her life despite having her heart broken again and again. Jax complimented her character perfectly. I really enjoyed how the second-chance between these two did not feel instant or forced. Rather, it felt like two people slowly finding their way back to where they should've been all along.

Thank you so much to R&R Book Tours and Mase Evans for sending me a copy of this book! All opinions are voluntary and entirely my own.
Profile Image for BookishVibesClub.
361 reviews150 followers
October 8, 2026
🧡 second chance romance
🧡 yearning
🧡

Language: Used often (F, GD)
Profile Image for Megan Shamy.
1,364 reviews40 followers
October 7, 2026
Avery and Jax were high school sweethearts until Jax broke her heart and left for college. Four years later, he’s back in town and suddenly all those feelings Avery swore she was over are very much still there. I really loved the history between these two. You could feel that Jax never truly got over Avery, and watching him try to work his way back into her life, even if it meant settling for friendship was so sweet. I will say the story was a little slow for me in some parts, and there were definitely moments when I wanted Avery and Jax to just talk to each other, but overall this was such a cute and comforting read.

Trope: Second Chance Romance
High School Sweethearts
Small Town
Friends to Lovers
Forced proximity
Its always been you
Slow Burn
Fall Vibes
Profile Image for Heather Scantlin.
15 reviews
September 18, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐

Until Forever by Maze Evans was such a cute, refreshing read! I really appreciated how realistic and genuinely flawed the characters felt. They weren’t perfect, and their choices and emotions felt believable, which made it easy to become invested in them.

The storyline moves pretty quickly, so this was an easy book to fly through. There’s zero spice, but it honestly didn’t need it—the sweet interactions, chemistry, and little moments between the characters carried the romance really well.

Overall, this was a light, feel-good read that I really enjoyed. And if there’s a sequel, I absolutely need it because I’m already invested in seeing where Liam and Rachel’s story goes!
Profile Image for Courtney Rueda.
62 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 3, 2026
Thank you for this arc!!
This book was such a cute, cozy, heart warming, perfectly crafted for fall, read. I absolutely adored this second chance romance for these two high school sweethearts. I thought this book was very relatable and the characters felt very real to me, like they would truly be friends of mine (who you just want to smack and say '"get back together already, dang it!").
At times it did feel a little repetitive which is why 1am giving it 4 stars. But overall this book is such a good cute read!
Profile Image for HighLadyofSpice.
390 reviews12 followers
October 1, 2026
4.5 stars. This was such a light, easy read. I very much enjoyed Avery and Jax the entire way through. Very slow burn, but the tension and buildup was well done. The key factors to make me love a romance. Not overly big on second chance romance but this one sealed the deal for me and I can’t wait to read more of this series and by this author.

Thank you to Mase Evans for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review
Profile Image for Jen &#x1f5a4;.
245 reviews5 followers
November 11, 2026
4 ⭐️

Such a cozy little romance! 🤎📚 Small-town charm, second-chance love, and a best-friends-to-lovers storyline? Yes, please! 🥰

I loved the feel of this one! The small-town vibes gave me all the Gilmore Girls feels, and I’m always a sucker for a story about finding your way back to love and giving it another chance. 🏡☕️💕

So happy I had the opportunity to check out a local author! Always love supporting talent close to home! 🖤

Profile Image for Caitlin.
1,473 reviews18 followers
Review of advance copy
September 25, 2026
This was such a cute, cozy, feel good romance set in my favorite time of the year!

An easily bingeable book with amazing chemistry and characters that you can't help but love and root for.

Standalone: Yes
Tropes/Vibes:
- fall
- second chance
- always been you
- slow burn

Profile Image for Melissa.
281 reviews4 followers
October 6, 2026
This is my very first book by Mase Evans, and let me tell you—it will not be my last! Maple Brook is officially the ultimate cozy fall town, and I am ready to pack my bags and move there immediately.

Then Until Forever was such a fun, refreshing read. Avery spent four years convincing herself she was completely over Jax, the guy who shattered her heart at eighteen. She was fine! Moving on! Mind-ing her business! That is, until Jax had the sheer audacity to move back to town, into her exact apartment complex, and right into her social circle. Cue the delicious, excruciatingly slow-burn agony. And when Avery needs a date for her brother’s wedding? Naturally, asking the ex who broke her heart seems like the most logical decision. You already know the chaotic second-chance goodness that follows!

What really made this story hit for me was how delightfully real and flawed the characters felt. They weren't picture-perfect; they made actual human choices and had believable emotions that made it so easy to root for them. Plus, the friend group was elite—constantly roasting each other to pieces, but riding for each other when it mattered most.

And look, I love Avery and Jax, but Sir Fluffington the cat easily stole the entire show. True main character energy.

If you want a cozy fall romance that perfectly balances laugh-out-loud humor with characters who feel like people you’d hang out with in real life. I can't wait to dive into the next book!

Thank you to Mase Evans and Beyond the Books for the ARC! It's like you just got me and knew I needed this book ASAP!
Profile Image for Emmy Wong.
729 reviews27 followers
September 28, 2026
This is the perfect classic fall romance for lovers of The Notebook and other sad but heartwarming stories. I was truly immersed in this from start to finish, it had loveable characters, a rather predictable but fun plot, it was very well paced and the chemistry is sizzling on every page. The funniest thing or you could also say the saddest thing about this book is that Jax is honest with his feelings and knows he’s been hopelessly in love with Avery for years, but won’t go after he romantically again because he’s scared of hurting her. While Avery is in completely denial that she loves him and claims she’s over him, even though hes the reason she doesn’t like fall anymore…and when you find out why, it’s incredibly heartbreaking. Jax moved back after 4 years and just wants to be close to the love of his life even if she just wants to be friends and yes he made a stupid mistake but he’s so determined and adorable that I can’t help but love him. Avery is such a realistic character as well and her conflicting feelings showed that and is one my favourite things about her. Sometimes when the fmc is just ready to go all in again, I’m kind of suspicious but Avery takes her time to recognise her love again and when she’s sure, she does not hold back, even if it means her heart getting broken. This book had me so emotional and I was cheering them on the entire time. I loved both Avery and Jax and definitely recommend this. I give it a 4.5/5
Profile Image for Dominique Books&Hooks.
65 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 29, 2026
Thank you to Mase Evans and Beyond the Books PR for the eARC.

Maple Brook Book 1
First time reading anything by Mase Evan’s and let it won’t be the last.

Maple Brook, a perfect fall town, exudes the quintessential fall vibes. I would move there in a heartbeat. Mase’s writing has a captivating way of drawing you into her cozy world.
The storyline progresses swiftly, making it an enjoyable and quick read. While there’s no explicit romance, the book effectively conveys the romance through the characters’ sweet interactions, chemistry, and subtle moments.

Avery and Jax, who had a tumultuous relationship years ago, found themselves drawn back together despite their past heartbreak. Their love, though deeply rooted, remained a constant, even as they struggled to convince themselves of their feelings.
I thoroughly enjoyed their backstory and the natural way the story unfolded. What I particularly appreciated was the absence of any villainous intentions. There was no animosity directed towards any character for their past mistakes at the age of 18. It was refreshing to witness the author’s realistic portrayal of the novel and its characters through their actions.

READ IF YOU LOVE:
~Cozy fall vibes
~ Second Chance
~ Friends to Lovers
~ Slow Burn
~ He Falls First
~ A cat named Sir Fluffington
~ "It's always been you"
Profile Image for yue.
236 reviews4 followers
Read
October 2, 2026
I had the privilege of reading this book in advanced thanks to Mase Evans and Beyond the Books PR. I am very happy whenever novels are set in my favorite season so normally I am very happy when I received this book.

The story and the plot itself is good. The writing was also okay too but when I started reading, I find it very hard to fully engage with the story itself. It's a me thing not necessarily the book or the author's problem. The pacing was a bit on a slow side for me which really contributed to why it was hard to me to finish this book. The story has some good points too. Our story was about Jax and Avery who were ex-lovers and now find themselves again in the same circle. The build up to their reconciliation was a bit slow but what I particularly loved about it was the characters in it, both main and the side characters around them.

I would leave my rating blank for the reason that I think the story didn't just land well to me because of my own preference and it would be unfair to the author if I rate it 3 just because of a "me" problem. Still, I am very grateful for Mase Evans and to Beyond the books PR for the opportunity. I would return to this review again to give the book another read and Ill update this review
Profile Image for Jenn.
207 reviews23 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 4, 2026
This was my first book by Mase Evans, and I really enjoyed the cozy fall atmosphere and small-town setting.

One of my favorite parts was the group of friends. I loved how they were constantly making fun of each other but were also incredibly supportive when it mattered. It made the town and relationships feel warm and lived-in.

The second-chance romance between Avery and Jax was definitely a slow burn, and I mean very, very slow. Avery needing a date to her brother’s wedding and turning to the ex who broke her heart four years earlier was such a fun setup, and I enjoyed watching the two of them slowly find their way back to each other.

My biggest issue was that I kept expecting a bigger explanation for why Jax broke up with Avery and left four years ago. It felt like the story was building toward some kind of reveal or deeper reason, and when that never really came, I was left wanting a little more closure.

Still, I really liked the friendships, the fall vibes, the town, and the overall feel of the story. And Sir Fluffington the cat was easily one of my favorite characters.

Thank you to Beyond the Books PR and Mase Evans for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Sonja Charters.
3,450 reviews155 followers
October 6, 2026
Aw! This front cover had me sold before I even opened the book if I'm honest.
If this doesn't give you autumn tbr vibes, nothing does!
And, it looked like the cutest seasonal romance ever, so I couldn't wait to dive into this one.

This is the first book in the Maple Brook series and also my first read by this author.

Now, I do read a lot of romance reads like this and although this was a fairly predictable storyline, I still found it an immersive read because I really liked and connected with the characters.

Avery and Jax had been everything, until they split up when he left her to go to college.
Now back in town, he with ideas to repair the damage done and rekindle at least a friendship, she however, can't understand the depth of the feelings that have flooded back.

Both Avery and Jax were well developed characters, each with their own flaws that made them and their relationship feel realistic.
I loved how this progressed through the book, but I was a little shocked to see that there was absolutely no spice through this read.

I find that so many books (at least that I read) do include the spice, that I found this really refreshing and also really pleased to see that this still worked really well without it.
The relationship still felt like it worked without this included.

The writing had me hooked and rooting for Avery and Jax and it was really easy to get carried away with this.
I loved the small town and all the autumn vibes.
Definitely a series I'd love to come back to.
Profile Image for Yelitz Ramos .
61 reviews3 followers
October 16, 2026
Avery Bennett is happy with her new life. She built her new business and moved on from her high school boyfriend, or at least that’s what she thought.
Jax Anderson made a mistake by losing the love of his life four years ago. He broke up with Avery and thought that they could still be friends, but he never tried to call her after that. Now, Jax is back and determined to win Avery back.

I love Fall season, and this book gave me the exact vibe. Maple Brook is the perfect little town. I imagined it while I was reading, and I can see myself living in it. The characters were realistic and engaging, making the story interesting and believable. As humans, we make mistakes in love, but what counts is accepting those mistakes, fixing them, and fighting for that love. It is a fast paced, easy read. I finished it in two days, because I couldn’t put it down. I enjoyed the chemistry and the sweet moments between Avery and Jax. The cozy environment and the humor between the characters made the story comforting to read. This book gave me that pumpkin spice feeling I needed, and I can’t wait for the next book.

Thank you Beyond the Books PR and the author for the ARC!
Profile Image for Cheyanne Lee .
77 reviews2 followers
September 25, 2026
This was a sweet second chance romance, with no spice.

Avery and Jax were high school sweethearts who had been best friends for most of their childhoods, Jax breaks up with Avery several months before going off to college as he doesn’t feel they could make long distance work and Avery would not move with him, he hoped that they would be able to remain friends, this isn’t what happens.

Jax moves away to college and comes back to their hometown four years later and they try to be friends again, but will they ever be ‘just friends?’

Whilst they’re friendship is very cute and wholesome, I just didn’t connect on a deep level with their story it felt a bit to predictable and I felt irritated that it took 95% of the book for them to both realise they’re feelings for each other had never gone away, they’re was also a lack of romance in this book for me personally and that’s why I’ve rated it 3 stars.

*disclaimer: as this is a 3 star review I will not post my review anywhere else as that is unfair to the author considering the book has not yet released.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Stephanie Farmer.
216 reviews5 followers
October 16, 2026
This one was FALL in a book. From the coffee shop to the cute town to the fun seasonal drinks- you truly got the fall vibe from this one, and I LOVED that. Avery is incredibly relatable. We all have a one that got away, but she didn’t let that stop her and she continued to pursue her dreams even when her world was falling apart. I really loved her character. Jax—-Jax 😒 silly boys making silly decisions that change women’s lives forever. I loved the “it was always you” but the miscommunication trope is always so frustrating to me. 😬 This is just a me thing though, and I recognize that other people don’t mind it. I also really enjoyed the side characters and the friend group that knew they were meant to be helping them along the way. Overall this was fun, cozy, and full of swear words 😆
Thank you to Beyond the Books for the eARC 🫶🏼
Profile Image for Amanda Schumacher.
410 reviews13 followers
September 29, 2026
This was such a good book! We have small town, second chance, fake dating, and exes to lovers. I love this so much.. I am a sucker for second chance romances... this book really hit me in the heart. They dated in high school and he broke up with her when they were 18 and in the middle of their senior year thinking it would be easier when he went to college. long distance was just something he didn't really wanna do. he disappeared out of her life for 4 years before showing up at the coffee shop she works at and starts a conversation about wanting to be friends again after so much time. Things escalate from there... they're both blind to the fact that they both feel the same way about the other... this is a must read
Profile Image for Jennifer W.
366 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 4, 2026
Thank you for this arc!! I had such a cozy read ✨

I’d say this is a 3.5 ⭐️

I had a bit of a hard time getting into the story but it always gave cute and cozy fall vibes! 🍂 I also thought the story felt a bit ”slim”? Like there wasn’t much happening around Avery and Jax. Like their jobs were mentioned, and she did work a little, but was he ever there? And our cute kitty? He could have been more incorporated 🥹

Anyway, around 60% I really started to enjoy the story and the emotional parts of it. Avery and Jax were so cute and he really YEARNS for her! He is down so so bad and you can really tell! They were adorable and I was like: come on you guys! It’s crystal clear you both love each other! 🫶🏼

I am also curious about Rachel and Liam… will there be another book perhaps? I think I would like seeing their story 🤭
Profile Image for Ciara Biggs.
50 reviews21 followers
October 16, 2026
This is a cozy fall read. I liked the storyline , second chance romances are always a vibe for me. I did like both MC’s I just felt like there could have been more communication between them. I like spicy books so this was different for me as there wasn’t really any spice - but I did assume going in there probably wouldn’t be much so no actual issues there. A lot of the stuff wouldn’t have happened if they just knew how to communicate better. But all & all I enjoyed the book & would like to read more by Mase.
Profile Image for Michelle.likestoread.
156 reviews10 followers
October 16, 2026
It’s a super cute fall read. Even though Avery hates everything pumpkin spice related, it made me want to curl up with a pumpkin spice latte while reading.

It’s a really cute second-chance story. Avery and Jax are childhood friends-to-lovers, who then are getting a second chance to find their spark.

🫑 This is a no-spice read. There are some kisses but nothing more.

Thank you so much to Mase Evans and Beyond the Books PR for letting me read an ARC.
171 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 6, 2026
I was lucky enough to receive this as an ARC read, here is my honest review.

This was the first book I read from Mase Evan’s.
This was a cute, refreshing, fall read.
Sweet interactions, it moves pretty quickly. You are able to fly write through the book.
Avery and Jax had the tension and the build up which made it amazing.

Can’t wait for more!
Profile Image for Aubrey Hedman.
63 reviews4 followers
October 8, 2026
This was my first read by Mase Evans and I have officially fallen in love with her writing!! I loooved the cozy, warm vibes of this story and this cutie love story is completely heartwarming. If you could have a perfect fall day, curled up with your favorite blanket and drink, this would be it.

Then Until Forever, I'm a fan!

I did receive this as an arc from the author!
Profile Image for Alli Kunkel.
33 reviews
October 11, 2026
ARC REVIEW:

I was given the chance at an early copy of Then Until Forever. While there are several tropes (second chance, he falls first), it is definitely a slow burn. I’m not always a fan of the slow burn, but the friendships and storylines kept me hooked. Mase Evan’s — can’t wait for the rest of the series someday! ❤️
Profile Image for Susan Peterson.
2,140 reviews395 followers
October 18, 2026
sweet romance

Then Until Forever was is a sweet second chance romance. I love second chance romances, because I enjoy seeing how the couple has changed since their breakup. In this story, Jax and Avery were just teenagers when they broke up, and now it’s 4 years later and they have both grown up and matured—is it enough for them to rekindle those old feelings?
Profile Image for Mina.
32 reviews2 followers
October 7, 2026
EEK thank you for this arc!! This gave me such a Hallmark x Gilmore Girls love story kind of vibe! I’d like to preface that I’m not a sucker for second chances ~ because most times miscommunication happens and it irritates me ~ BUT this was TOTALLY different. This man YEARS, has always yearned for her & she’s truly just a girl who had her heart broken. I loved seeing their story come together😭.
75 reviews
October 16, 2026
This was cute and autumn-y and had all the cozy fall vibes I needed this time of year. It is fast-paced, and I could imagine everything happening in front of me just like in a film. Definitely recommended for those of you who are looking for a nice fall romance that can be read in one sitting with a nice coffee and a cinnamon bun. Thanks so much for the ARC!
Profile Image for Bexxy.
713 reviews18 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 30, 2026
What a cute read!

I do love a second chance romance. Add in a small town setting and a cat and I'm in!

Sir Fluffington is adorable!!

Great cosy season read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 194 reviews