A heartwarming novel about what it means to chase the life — and love — of your dreams, from the bestselling author of The Unsinkable Greta James.
As the clock counts down to midnight on New Year’s Eve, Billie — 39, single, an American film editor on a girls’ trip to Florence — makes a this is the year she’s going to have a baby on her own. Less than an hour later, she meets Arthur — 44, single, a Scottish environmentalist celebrating a friend’s stag party — who seems perfect but for his conviction that kids are not for him.
Over the course of the next year, Billie finds herself pursuing both versions of her life, moving back and forth between visits to fertility clinics and romantic getaways around the world as she tries to figure out what she wants most. But as she approaches the inevitable fork in the road, she’ll discover that it’s not so easy to follow your heart when it’s pulling you in two very different directions.
Full of Jennifer E. Smith’s signature heart and warmth, Rabbit Rabbit is a powerful romantic novel about paths not taken…and what happens when you meet the right person at the wrong time.
Jennifer E. Smith is the author of nine books for young adults, including The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight and Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between, both of which were recently adapted for film. She earned her master's degree in creative writing from the University of St. Andrews in Scotland, and her writing has been translated into 33 languages. She currently lives in Los Angeles.
A contemporary fiction meets romance novel, I was completely captivated from the moment our MCs meet and “rabbit rabbit” is uttered. This is so much more than a romance and yet it’s ultimately the epitome of the greatest love story.
Offering a sense of maturity both in characters and content, this book deals with some of life’s pivotal decisions, the lifelong trauma of grief, and how important it is to live a big life out of the smallest of moments. It has found family, female friendship, gorgeous travel, laugh-out-loud banter, and an all-consuming romance you’ll think about long after finishing. I loved every single character and every moment I was able to spend with them.
One element I loved, and that felt so unique, is the format in which this story is told. Beginning on January 1 right as the clock strikes midnight in Florence, we are taken on a month-by-month journey with Billie, a New York film editor transplanted in LA, and Arthur, the perfectly perfect environmentalist from Edinburgh, as they meet up across the globe.
For their hearts, it’s an instant connection, but looming over them is one big divergence in their plans for the future. But each meet-up brings something more— a deepening connection. Though, I have to admit that at times I felt incredibly anxious, unsure how our hero and heroine would fare, and wanted to flip to the end (a rare occurrence for me). But as it turns out, the journey was as significant as the destination.
And as we go bit by bit, month by month, learning more about Billie and Arthur as they learn about one another, we are also treated to a marvelous set of supporting characters who create a rich, well-rounded story. Billie’s friends Jane and Talia were a joy to experience, but it was her relationship with Gran that completely stole my heart.
As we neared the end, the tears began flowing. And if you know me, you know this means it will be an automatic 5⭐️ rating. Friends, if this isn’t on your TBR, I absolutely implore you to add it.
♾️ stars. Favorite romance of the year 💫
Read if you like: ▪️genre mashups ▪️character driven stories ▪️swoony romance ▪️MCs in their 30s and 40s ▪️great supporting characters ▪️emotional depth
A huge thank you to Thousand Voices x Ballantine for my gorgeous gifted galley and ebook copy.
What a sweet book about love in unexpected moments and time.
I was looking for something a little bit more lighthearted. After thinking I could read some heavy-handed books and not being happy with them. This is exactly what I needed.
This book found me at absolutely the right time and I am always HERE for that kind of bookish serendipity. Billie, a film editor who is on the cusp of turning 40 and determining if she wants to try to have a baby on her own, as she has a meet cute with a Scotsman appropriately named Arthur. I just found this relationship so DANG endearing and I constantly found myself thinking about this book when I wasn't ready. I'm still wishing for updates on these characters - I loved the setting(s), I loved the premise, and I loved the payoff. I need to check out more from this author as this was my first by her.
I fell in love with Jennifer E. Smith’s writing when I read Field Notes on Love. It’s one of my all-time favorites. Rabbit Rabbit was another reminder why I enjoy her writing so much. Plus I can’t pass up my family’s tradition of rabbit rabbit rabbit (one extra rabbit for us) in a book.
I couldn’t relate to Billie as a main character because I have no interest in kids of my own. That piece of wanting children/navigating her life was the underlying theme of the book. I’m more of an Arthur in that way. Rabbit Rabbit was sad at times, but I think the book wrapped up nicely. It doesn’t always end up that way.
They say, “If you want to make God laugh, tell Him about your plans.” Billie learns the meaning of this adage fairly quickly, in this heartwarming and emotional book. Thanks so much to Ballantine and NetGalley for the advance copy!! I really loved it.
Billie is a 39-year-old film editor living in Los Angeles. She is on a trip to Florence with her two best friends, and on New Year’s Eve she decides that this will be the year she has a baby. She plans to do IUI or IVF, and although it’s a little scary, she will raise the baby on her own.
Of course, within an hour of making this decision, she meets Arthur, a handsome, intelligent, Scottish environmentalist. They flirt, they wander the city into the wee hours of the morning, and both clearly feel a connection deeper than flirtation. But Arthur isn’t interested in having kids, so as much as they’d both love to pursue a relationship, Billie wants to give the baby thing a try.
They do keep in touch, however. Billie definitely longs to be with Arthur, but she really wants to have a child, too. She spends the next year trying to get pregnant and traveling all over the world to see him. Each time they’re together, they know they don’t want things between them to end, but this is a situation where Billie has to make a choice between Arthur and a baby.
Can she be happy with Arthur without a baby? Or should she have a baby and leave Arthur to his Scottish wildlands? Her heart aches with trying to decide, because she won’t feel complete either way. Meanwhile, other things in life seem to be changing at the same time.
Jennifer E. Smith has written both adult and YA books, and I’m a huge fan of hers. Her books are always imbued with so much emotion and the issues her characters face never feel outlandish. I definitely was in my feelings by the end of this one!!
I am a HUGE Jennifer E. Smith fan, so when I saw she was publishing her next piece of adult fiction with Jenna Bush Hager’s Thousand Voices Media, I knew this was going straight to the top of my “want to read” list this year…
The book opens on New Year’s Eve with a woman proclaiming that THIS is going to be the year. She will have a baby. But does she have a man in her life? Nope! And then she meets one a few minutes later… except there’s one little problem: he doesn’t want children.
What follows is such a remarkable story about the two paths one can take and the choices we’re faced with when trying to figure out love vs. happiness. And ultimately, you have to ask yourself: can there be both?
Jennifer E. Smith is SO good at writing emotion and nuanced, deeply relatable characters. I loved this book, I loved her voice, and I think this is a real winner for Jenna Bush Hager’s imprint.
An enjoyable, heartwarming, at times heartbreaking, but light read with great characters you will connect with and follow along the journey that leads them to what they want in life.
Don't give up too soon.
See if you can guess what the title means. 5/5
Thank you to the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
"Rabbit Rabbit" is a contemporary romance that tiptoes towards a romcom, but with a more serious, realistic edge that middle-aged+ readers will appreciate. Billie, 39, has just decided to have a baby on her own when she meets the potential love-of-her-life — if only he wanted kids, too. The tension is rooted in past trauma rather than a simple-to-solve miscommunication which I appreciated for both its maturity and realism. It's easy to root for Billie and Arthur — I fell in love with both — and while I sometimes feared the story would follow the most obvious, formulaic path forward, I found it took enough quick turns to surprise me and keep it out of Hallmark territory. I breezed right through this as a very quick read. It holds many moral and social quandaries, making it ripe for book club discussion as well. I adored Jennifer E. Smith's "The Unsinkable Greta James" and found this another solid entry into her oeuvre. Read this if you like romcoms with real stakes, later-in-life love stories, or divisive book club discussions.
A big thank you to Ballantine, NetGalley, and Jennifer E. Smith for providing an advance copy for honest review.
Ahhhhhh!!!! This was such a good book!!!!! Truly one that captured my attention and did not let go!! I felt every emotion throughout; I was happy, I was devastated, I was hopeful, I was torn, I was optimistic, and I was joyful!!! Without giving away any spoilers, I cried so hard at the end, it was really an incredible way to wrap the story up 😊
Highly recommend giving this one a try, especially if you like romance with a dash of reality sprinkled in 😊
I received a copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for my honest review !!! Thank you to the Author, the Publisher, and Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this ARC!!
𝗣𝗟𝗢𝗧 The story follows Billie, a 39-year-old single American film editor on a trip to Florence, who decides on New Year’s Eve to have a baby on her own. Shortly after, she meets Arthur, a 44-year-old Scottish conservationist who is a great match except for his firm belief that he does not want children.
💕 Second chance romance 🕰️ Right Person, wrong time ✈️ Long-distance relationship 🫶 Coming of age
𝗠𝗬 𝗧𝗛𝗢𝗨𝗚𝗛𝗧𝗦 I really enjoyed this story. It is a contemporary romance, but it is not sappy, yet it is not simple. I didn’t rush when reading it because I wanted to enjoy it as much as possible. I also appreciated the maturity of both characters. They knew what they wanted from life and navigated it very well. Overall, it is a great story about love, timing, and all the emotions that come with wondering 𝘸𝘩𝘢𝘵 𝘪𝘧?
I inhaled this book. This is the 3rd Jennifer E. Smith I read and loved and I just realized she wrote the book that “Love at First Sight” is based on, one of my favorite romantic comfort movies. This book was beautifully told, well-paced, dreamy but still somehow realistic, with wonderful depictions of incredible places. The gist of this book is one of my favorite romantic realizations which is realizing when you actually need someone in your life versus when you are truly content and want someone in your life. Truly such a great book.
Jennifer E. Smith’s latest, Rabbit Rabbit, is an unconventional love story. Thirty nine year old Billie is in Florence, Italy celebrating New Year’s Eve with her best friends Talia and Jane when two momentous things happen. After years of being single and childless she decides she wants to have a baby. And she meets Arthur.
This initially might seem like fortuitous timing, as it’s clear that Billie and Arthur just fit together, personalities meshing and coming from pasts where they both suffered personal tragedy. The fact that they live nowhere near each other is an obstacle that ends up being surprisingly easy for them to overcome. The fact that Arthur doesn’t want children is a much bigger hurdle in their relationship.
But the connection between the pair is so magnetic that they find it incredibly difficult to quit each other, meeting up and having magical moments around the world.
In Billie’s job of film editing, she makes magic and happy endings happen no matter what kind of film she has to work with, so it’s easy for her to see herself at the center of her own movie, where a happily ever after is inevitable. As she’s increasingly torn between what she wants, she begins to realize that life isn’t like the movies, and it’s quite possible she may have to make a choice between the future she envisioned at the beginning of the year, and the relationship she’s begun.
The story was interesting because it feels so much like Billie and Arthur belong together. I fully admit that from my perspective I wanted her to stop focusing on trying to get pregnant within the year, and see where life with Arthur took her, since he was already a part of it. But her only living family member is her grandmother, who’s starting to lose her memory, meaning that Billie quite likely has a short window if she wants her grandmother to have the opportunity to see and know a child of hers.
Whether you agree with Billie and Arthur’s choices or not, the book is a reminder that not all choices are easy, and that it’s really important for both halves of a pair to be in agreement on things that have a profound impact on their lives. You’ll have to read it to find out what choice Billie makes.
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This was a beautiful, compulsive read. I loved all of the relationships- Billie & Arthur are central to the story, but the sisterhood Billie had with her friends and the relationship she had with Gran were touching as well. The conclusion felt like lots of epilogues, but I thought it worked. In the end it seemed every character’s story made sense, and the overall story felt tender & hopeful.
I was grateful to receive an early copy of Jennifer's new novel.
First things first: This was one of my favorite reads of the year.
The main characters were really well rendered, likable and complex, with a legitimately complicated relationship predicament. This careful attention to story structure kept me invested.
BUT I must admit that the narrative did fall into the trap of so many books in this genre, visiting and revisiting (and revisiting again) the same predicament. Sometimes with long stretches of time passing between the revisiting, which made it increasingly difficult to embrace.
I also thought the ending was far too rushed. If we needed to cover that much time in so few pages, maybe we don't need chapter breaks for each stretch of time (giving us chapters that are only one to two pages long). It threw off the pacing for me.
All of that acknowledged, I did really enjoy this narrative. I think it covers an important topic - and does that topic justice (and again... those main characters!)
Arthur is an environmentalist from Scotland. Billie is a film editor from New York, living in Los Angeles. She was raised by her Gran after her parents died tragically when she was 9 years old. Arthur and Billie meet by chance just after midnight on New Years Day in Florence, Italy. At 39 years old, Billie had just made the decision to try to have a baby by herself. Before her biological clock runs out and while Gran still has a chance to meet her baby.
Can Arthur and Billie reconcile their differences and the distance between them and take a chance on love? Will saying “Rabbit, Rabbit” at the beginning of each new year or month, give them enough luck to work things out between them?
The title of this book first stuck out to me and when I looked up the author, I realized I had long ago read The Unsinkable Greta James. I remembered I found it to be too long and drawn out in the middle so I didn’t finish it. I don’t think this book had that issue. It was a quick read, albeit a bit hard to follow.
As someone who loves international adventures and meeting people from around the world, I found the premise of continuing to meet a love interest in different countries interesting. And I thought it was really cool she wanted to take her fertility into her own hands and pursue having a baby on her own.
However there was a little too much going on in the book and the writing style did not quite connect each narrative well enough. It would skip forward in time and then tell what happened in flash backs. There also wasn’t much chemistry between the two love interests. I needed to hear more I’m depth conversations from them or maybe his perspective to make it believable.
I liked her relationship with her Gran and friends. The love interest could have almost not been part of the book and I would’ve like it still, if not more.
Over all an interesting premise with meaningful themes, but the structure didn’t quite do it justice.
I have enjoyed every single book that Jennifer E Smith has written. I’m so glad she’s writing adult fiction now. I loved this book so much- the full five star experience. We follow Billie on the first day of each month over the course of the year. She’s a film editor in LA who has decided to use a fertility clinic to have a baby. Only on the first day of January, she meets a Scottish man who doesn’t want to have children. The two are drawn together but live far apart and are not on the same page for life goals. Their relationship is doomed before it could even start, yet the two are drawn together over the course of the year. I was prepared for an open ending (like we got in Greta James) and was pleasantly surprised to have some perks into the future at the end. This book was all the feels- I’ll save it a spot on my top 10 list for 2026! *Thanks to Ballantine and NetGalley for the free copy
Thank you NetGalley for the ARC! I truly LOVED this book! I loved the characters and felt like I was watching a movie the entire time I was reading this. From the very beginning, I had this feeling of not wanting to rush through because of how much I was enjoying the story and the characters and their adventures. This was a great feel good story with deep conflicts and emotions throughout (📖)
I felt lucky to snag the ARC of Rabbit, Rabbit from NetGalley and aptly started it on the first of the month! The superstition of saying, “Rabbit, Rabbit,” has been a part of my routine for decades and wish the characters would’ve leaned in more to the title phrase. The book introduces Billie who has decided she wants a child, and Arthur, who has decided he does not. Unfortunately, they fall in love. Both people are aging out of typical love stories and grappling with grief that seems to pile up. Their conflict isn’t very juicy, because every time things heat up for them, they maturely agree to disagree and part ways (like a long ways apart from each other). Luck, superstition, timing and the choices we make because of grief, all work together to create our life story - this book explains how that works out for Billie and Arthur.
Rabbit Rabbit struck a nerve with me. I’m not sure if I’m just not reading the right kind of books or if it’s really this rare to have main characters in their late thirties and mid-forties still figuring out their lives. I’m “only” 33 at the time of reading Rabbit Rabbit but I felt like it was mirroring so many of the life choices I’ve been thinking about and that was just utterly refreshing. Because you can have your job and your group of friends and family members and still want things. You can still have hopes and dreams and desires and feel your internal clock ticking away. You can still be scared or even terrified, maybe even because you want certain things so much and be it timing or a person or a place, but it hasn’t worked out yet.
It was a joy to follow Billie on this journey through the years. I adored getting a glimpse into every month and having all the details provided of what happened in between without necessarily going through it in real time. I felt the love, I felt the joy, I felt the grief and isn’t that exactly what life is about?
If you treat yourself to anything before the end of the year or for the start of the new year, let it be this book. Let it be this heartfelt story of a woman who has to make hard choices, of life having a way of working out despite the pain and of accepting, that not everything is in our control.
Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for an honest review!
This was really well written. It was a generally wholesome read, but the plot execution was lacking for me. Essentially, Billie and Arthur meet, fall in love (a little too quickly for me), but Billie desperately wants kids where Arthur doesn't. The way the book is described, I thought we were going to get alternating perspectives of how life would play out if one choice was made over another. Instead, the two characters just kind of waffle back and forth on what they want and what they want to do. I find the question of whether you will regret having kids or regret not having kids an interesting one, and wished there had been more focus around that. I found it hard to feel the tension and pull of being stuck between two things you desperately want as Arthur and Billie didn't have very deep discussions around how to make things work. I felt like Billie obviously knew what she wanted if she was willing to try to have a child on her own, so every time she would question that decision it didn't land as believable. The end was unsatisfying to me - I would have liked to see Billie and Arthur have more adult conversations and at least discuss compromises. I did like their conversations around shared family trauma and grief. The book has great characters, great writing, and is an enjoyable read - I just found the execution lacking.
From the first page, "Rabbit Rabbit" had me hooked - I literally finished the novel in less than 18 hours.
Much like "Counting the Days" by Laura Chinn, which I read earlier this year, this book felt like it was personally written for me. From the first chapter, I was captivated by Billie - this magical woman who celebrates NYE on Florence rooftop bars and decides to make her wish of having a family a reality. And then of course, a hot sec later, she bumps into Arthur, *the* one that would be perfect for her... if only he wanted the ONE THING that she has set her mind on. And from here, I strapped in for a messy, yet beautiful adventure - for not only Billie and Arthur, but with her grandmother, Jane, and Talia. Each of these women gave Billie the depth and support that she needed to arrive at her ultimate decision.
I held my breath from the moment I started reading, until the very end, wondering what path Billie (and Arthur) would choose. And while I can breathe easily now, I am still thinking about this novel, and how I would feel if Arthur made another choice (leaving it there to avoiding giving spoilers).
Thank you to NetGalley, Ballantine, and Jennifer Smith for the ARC in exchange for my honest review!
PERFECT NYE BOOK! It’s NYE, Billie the FMC turned 39 3 days earlier, she feels like all the possibilities are within her grasps, she decides, she’s going to have a baby this year. And then she meets Arthur. Is it fate? Is it just a one night date? A must read!
The book is not just a romance, it’s about life! It makes you think about all the decisions big and small we make. I loved this book so much!!!
Please pick up this book!!! And thank you so much to NetGalley for this ARC!
This was a fantastic love story that kept me engaged the whole way through. I didn’t want it to end!
I really hope more romance books with stories like this are published. Us older millennials want to read stories that feature characters in our age group, with characters who are navigating real-world problems that are less “college dropout who cannot get her life together” and more “is actually in perimenopause or….”
I have read and enjoyed 5 of Jennifer E. Smith's and was excited to dig into her upcoming release 𝐑𝐚𝐛𝐛𝐢𝐭 𝐑𝐚𝐛𝐛𝐢𝐭 (Pub 12.15)
The book opens in Florence on New Year's Eve, when 39 year old Billie just decided that she's going to have a baby on her own. On that very night she meets a handsome Scot named Arthur and the spark she feels has her questioning which path to take with one hitch- he doesn't want kids.
It's a story about choices, love, and timing unfolds over the next year as a chapter per month. The premise was fresh and the payoff left me all warm inside. This book is well-written and compulsively readable. I loved how Smith constructed the relationships between the characters. I could feel their trepidation and believed their struggle. I was so invested in them and could hardly wait to see where the fork in the road took them. I could feel the emotional tenderness that happens when you realize the only way to have the life you want is to actively choose it.
𝐌𝐎𝐑𝐄: Genre bending. Love story/Contemporary fiction This cover. Gorgeous! MC in their 30s/40s Realistic & emotional Luck & superstition Humor & levity provided by side characters.
This was a great book. I was a little frustrated with their relationship towards the end because I just wanted them to figure it out!! But this was a heartfelt story and well written. Thank you NetGalley and the author for the ARC! Also, i needed an epilogue of their life together 😭
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I am not usually a romance novel fan but the subject of a woman’s biological clock ticking down peaked my interest. This was a sweet and easy love story that was a nice diversion and I thoroughly enjoyed it.
It’s a novel that teeters the line between contemporary fiction and romance but is just a lovely, heartfelt journey.
The story is about Billie who is 39 and single. And Arthur who is also single at 44. One lives in LA and one is from the Scottish highlands. Which as you can imagine is as different as can be. But dig deeper and you’ll see that both of them have experienced grief and loss, combined with not having found the love story they thought they might have. And a chance encounter in Italy changes it all.
I’m not going to give more details except to say that I appreciated @ballantine gifting me this one because it was just such an escape. Not cheesy. Not simple. But a love story that felt real and complicated at times.