Jump to ratings and reviews

Win a free print copy of this book!

23 days and 02:15:09

12 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book

Guilty Treasure

Not yet published
Expected 12 Jan 27

Win a free print copy of this book!

23 days and 02:15:09

12 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book
A fake engagement spirals out of control and into a hunt for pirate's gold on a tropical island.

The universe loves to mess with journalist Sofia Alvarez. She already lost her relationship and her job, forcing her to accept a roommate to afford rent—her way-too-hot former coworker turned foe, Barrett. Now thanks to her ex forgetting to cancel his prearranged kiss cam marriage proposal at a New York Pirates hockey game, Sofia is about to lose her dignity, too. And in front of Barrett, no less.

Barrett “Bear” Winston always had a thing for Sofia. But when a personal emergency had forced Bear back to the UK, he’d all but ruined any chance he had with her all those years ago. Now, as he watches her heart shatter in front of thousands on the Jumbotron, he does what any self-respecting white knight would do to make amends—he drops to one knee and fake-proposes to save Sofia the embarrassment.

But the adventure is only beginning for the would-be bride and groom, as they are surprised by an all-inclusive trip to the island off the coast of Belize that inspired the hockey team’s seafaring mascot. When it looks like there might be real treasure on the island and finding it could be their big career break, Sofia and Bear must decide whether it’s time for a parlay and whether they can finally go from hate to mate.

384 pages, Paperback

Expected publication January 12, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jo Segura

9 books1,031 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (20%)
4 stars
15 (42%)
3 stars
10 (28%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
3 (8%)
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews
Profile Image for Grace Quan.
435 reviews844 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 17, 2026
I ended up having so much fun with Guilty Treasure!

There were a lot of really entertaining tropes that brought Sofia and Bear together and all of the settings for this book were just immaculate. The funny banter was definitely a highlight, I just wish there was MORE of it. I found this was the case for a lot of elements for this book: I just wanted MORE of everything.

🏴‍☠️Tropes:

🪎 Roommates
🪎 Journalist x Journalist
🪎 Fake honeymoon
🪎 Couples retreat
🪎 Second chance
🪎 One Bed
🪎 Tropical Island

First thing I loved and really got me hooked on the story, was definitely Sofia and Bear. I loved each of them individually and of course, I loved them together. Bear was a charming and his British accent was to die for. I thought it was interesting how they were both journalists that used to work together. I just wished there were some more backstory of them working together. I would have loved to see a flashback to add depth and context to their complicated relationship.

I also adored their "enemies-to-lovers" banter. It made every little exchange interesting and helped hold my attention during the slower bits. While the banter was so refreshing and fun, there wasn't nearly enough of it. Sofia and Bear had so much chemistry but I felt there weren't enough meaningful interactions to have them really fall in love. This book could have been SO funny and filled with so many meaning interactions, but it definitely fell short in that respect.

Looking beyond the romance, the side plots were excellent--so no complaints there. I loved the little twist at the end, it definitely helped wrap up the story really nicely.

I also want to take a moment for Jo Segura's writing. It was so good and fit the tone of the book perfectly. The third person felt natural and was easy for me to connect to, which is a rarity for me because I generally do not like third person. I will definitely be checking out more of her writing.

Overall, this book was a fun time. I definitely think there could have been more romantic interactions, banter and conversations, but the writing was so immersive that in the end I could overlook it. I also liked this books's take on the Fake Honeymoon trope.

3.5 stars ⭐️

Thank you to Netgalley and Berkley for the arc in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.

📆 Publication Date: January 12, 2027
Profile Image for Chelsea.
282 reviews10 followers
September 14, 2026
I’m back at it again with another Jo Segura book, and I have ZERO shame. 😂 I love every single one of these adorable reads, and their covers?! COME ON. Aren’t they the cutest?! 😍 Guilty Treasure was such a stunning one, that I needed it immediately.

In this second-chance romance, journalist Sofia is down on her luck. She’s coming out of a relationship where she was left in the lurch, questioning what the hell she’s doing with her life, and now she needs a roommate to help with rent. What she wasn’t expecting? Someone from her past. 👀

Barrett “Bear” let something good slip through his fingers with Sofia, but at the time, his family came first. Now he’s back, always on the move, and somehow ends up staying with Sofia, and making sure she’s actually taking care of herself. These two were SO adorable without even realizing how adorable they were. 🥹

Then an opportunity at a hockey game lands them in a situation neither of them ever expected… a fake engagement. 😂

Because, of course, Sofia’s dumbass ex never canceled the very public engagement. So now Sofia and Bear are pretending to be engaged, which somehow leads them straight to a couples retreat.

And who just happens to be there?

Her ex.
And his new fiancée.

Real nice, dude. 🙄😂

But this is a Jo Segura book, so obviously there’s also a treasure to be found! 🏴‍☠️✨ Jo takes us on another adventure with a couple I couldn’t help but root for from beginning to end.

Another Jo-approved island adventure under my belt, and I can officially say it:

I will always read whatever Jo Segura puts in front of me. 💕
Profile Image for Cristina.
166 reviews4 followers
August 15, 2026

I really enjoyed Guilty Treasure! There was so much about this story that worked for me, especially getting to learn more about Bear, and Sofia. I really liked the background we got for both of them and how different their personalities were. They were total opposites in so many ways, which made their dynamic really fun to follow. At the same time, I did find myself wishing they had cleared the air a lot sooner because, honestly, I didn’t feel like there was THAT much to be angry about! 😂 I kept wanting them to just sit down, talk it out, and move forward.

The absolute highlight of the story for me was the scavenger hunt! I loved the chaotic energy of it and would have happily read even more scenes like that. In fact, I think that’s what I was craving more of throughout the book: the group dynamics and ridiculous situations that come from putting couples together and watching them interact.

Going into this, I was really hoping for more of that “Couples Retreat/Blended” kind of energy; couples having to participate in silly activities together, the witty banter happening in front of everyone, awkward moments, teasing, competition, and just generally watching everyone get themselves into ridiculous situations. 😂
I definitely would have preferred more of those Couple Retreat activities and interactions over some of the spice scenes. The romance was enjoyable, but I think the story had so much potential for fun group moments that I wanted MORE of that!

Overall, though, I had a really good time reading this. It was fun, entertaining, and I loved getting to know the characters and their histories. I just wish I had connected with them on a deeper level, because I think that would have made the story much more memorable for me. As it stands, I really enjoyed my time with it, but I don’t think it’s a story that will stay in my head for very long after finishing.

Still, if you enjoy romance with adventure, a little treasure hunting, forced proximity, and couples thrown into chaotic situations together, this could definitely be a fun one to pick up when it releases next January! 💕

⭐️ 3.5–3.75
Profile Image for Paige Woodrow.
460 reviews44 followers
Read
November 15, 2026
This was such a disappointment! I absolutely love Jo, and her previous books have been fantastic, so I had really high hopes for this one. Unfortunately, it just didn’t work for me.

The book starts off so strong. I was laughing out loud, loved the banter between the characters, and thought the whole setup had so much potential. But once they arrived at the retreat, the dynamic between the FMC and MMC took a turn that I just couldn’t get on board with. What started as playful bickering and banter morphed into them being genuinely, sometimes horribly, mean to each other. It almost felt like the story was trying to shift from rivals-to-lovers into enemies-to-lovers, but that shift didn’t make sense with how their relationship had been established at the beginning.

Honestly, by the middle of the book, I was left wondering why either of them would even want to end up with the other. They were both incredibly hardheaded, and they seemed to use sex as a means of control and even as a weapon against each other. There was so much focus on their physical attraction and very little development of an emotional connection. That just isn’t my preferred kind of romance. If you’re looking for lots of spice with minimal emotional connection, this might be right up your alley, but I wanted so much more from these characters.

The treasure hunt storyline also felt like a last-minute afterthought. It never really seemed to mesh with the rest of the story, and I struggled to see how it fit into everything else.

I’m not sure what happened with this one, but unfortunately, it just wasn’t her best work. I went in expecting to love it, and I walked away feeling pretty disappointed overall.
Profile Image for Olivia Jackson.
Author 2 books98 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 23, 2026
I've read all of Jo Segura's books and loved them all. While Guilty Treasure is slightly less action-adventure and more romance, I still loved it. The setting is beautiful, the banter is fun, and the spice is many peppers hot! This book has my favorite tropes: second chance, fake dating (fake engagement in this case), and forced proximity! Oh, and a micro-trope: slutty little glasses. It's romantic, fun, and swoony. And the cover is so beatiful!
I can't wait for Jo's next book.


Thank you to Jo Segura, Berkley, and NetGalley for an advance copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Karen Brooks - TheTxLitChic.
372 reviews54 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 14, 2026
Guilty Treasure
~ Jo Segura

Guilty Treasure by Jo Segura unfolds a treasure map with grains of sand cascading through time like Blackheart herself. The X marks the spot, but to find it, Sofia and Bear will have to survive a jumbotron disaster, a cramped apartment, and a couples retreat they never signed up for. Arrr, romance and buried treasure make for a complicated voyage!

Journalist Sofia Alvarez has lost her boyfriend, her job, and the earnest money she put down for a condo she was supposed to share with her cheating ex. Now she's eating canned meat and wondering how she's going to make ends meet. Desperate for a roommate, she puts out feelers, but the results are less than savory. When a friend recommends a friend of a friend, Sofia has high hopes. That is, until she discovers the potential roommate is her way-too-handsome former coworker, Barrett “Bear” Winston, the man she shared a night with years ago and still can't get out of her head. Unfortunately, she's not nearly as over him as she'd like to be, especially since he disappeared without a word all those years ago.

With her finances circling the drain, Sofia reluctantly agrees to take Bear on as a roommate. Then she discovers the tickets she bought for herself and her ex, Colorado, to attend a Pirates hockey game. Rather than let them go to waste, she and Bear head to the game together. What could possibly go wrong? Well, when a surprise proposal unfolds on the jumbotron, Sofia is left shattered. Apparently, Colorado forgot to cancel his proposal plans when he forgot he had a girlfriend the night Sofia caught him and Tatiana doing the horizontal mambo at the office.

Bear can't stand to watch Sofia's heart break, so he does what any good guy with questionable impulse control would do: he drops to one knee and fake-proposes in front of thousands of people. Sofia is speechless, the crowd eats it up, and a team representative sweeps them into the back office to award them an all-inclusive trip to the island that inspired the Pirates' mascot, an island also owned by the team's owner.

Sounds like paradise, right? Not so fast.

The resort turns out to be a couples retreat, which, for Sofia, is closer to a tropical nightmare. Her ex, Colorado, and his fiancée, Tatiana, are there. Sofia and Bear are forced to share a cottage with one bed (I mean, what did she think was going to happen?), and apparently, couples counseling is part of the package. Because nothing says romantic getaway quite like airing your emotional baggage in paradise!

When another couple smells fishy to Sofia, her jounalistic instincts kick in. Bear's past research for an article about the legendary female pirate Captain Blackheart, along with rumors that her gold was left behind on the island, gives them a reason to call a truce and embark on a treasure hunt. Will they uncover a career-making story among the tropics, or strike their own fortune beneath the sand?

Segura introduces us to a cast of unique and interesting characters. Sofia is guarded and downright prickly. She wears her emotions on her sleeve and carries her wounds like body armor. She's endured years of grief from her parents for choosing journalism over a law career and refusing to follow in their footsteps. Her struggles make her raw and relatable, but at times, she's so frustrating that readers may find themselves wishing she'd pull her head out of her… well, somewhere. I understood her hurt, but there were moments when I wanted to shake some sense into her.

Bear, on the other hand, is the heart of the book. He carries the remorse of leaving Sofia without an explanation, and his regret is laced with genuine emotion. However, supporting his sister and keeping his personal business private remain his priorities. He's charming and easy to root for, especially once readers learn early on (no spoiler here) why he left. We can understand his reasons while still agreeing that he owed Sofia some kind of explanation.

The supporting characters have potential, but I never felt enough of a connection with them to care much about their roles in the story. I especially wish there had been more development of Irene Maldonado, owner of the Pirates and the island resort. I also would have liked more interaction between Colorado and Sofia at the resort, if only to give their history a little more closure. Honestly, I could have done without Colorado being there at all.

Cayo Rosas is the crown jewel of settings. Segura paints the island so vividly that you can practically feel the sand in your shoes and the sun on your face. The alternating points of view give readers a deeper look into Sofia and Bear, offering firsthand access to their angst, longing, and unresolved feelings. The retreat's ridiculous challenges and scavenger hunt deliver laughs that help balance Sofia's more hostile moments, even when her attitude threatens to send readers overboard. Blackheart's letters add mystery and depth, transforming the pirate's history into something more meaningful than research for Bear's article.

The pacing, however, is a little off. The story begins with the makings of a slow-burn enemies-to-lovers romance, but the pace suddenly picks up around the three-quarter mark. Meanwhile, Sofia and Bear's emotional standoff drags on longer than necessary. Their chemistry is there, but the repeated push and pull occasionally makes you want to commandeer the ship and sail these two straight into a conversation.

Guilty Treasure isn't a flawless chest of gold, but there's enough sparkle to make the dig worthwhile. With its sun-soaked setting, banter-filled romance, pirate lore, and treasure-hunting adventure, it's a fun escape for readers who enjoy their beach reads with a little buried gold and a lot of romantic complications. Just be prepared for a heroine who can test your patience and a romance that takes the scenic route. Overall, this is a breezy, tropical getaway with a pirate flag on top.

Releasing January 12, 2027, from Berkley Romance. Available in Kindle, audiobook, and paperback formats.

I would like to thank Berkley/Penguin Random House, NetGalley, and author Jo Segura for allowing me to preview Guilty Treasure. As always, all opinions and reviews are of my own volition, Karen Brooks aka The Tx Lit Chic. I have not been promised any compensation, current or future, by the author or publisher for a fair and honest review of Guilty Treasure.
Profile Image for Elia Winters.
519 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 6, 2026
Jo Segura does it again! I love her adventure romances and Guilty Treasure was a fun ride! The only reason this is 4.5 instead of 5 ⭐️s is because I felt the adventure portion was pretty small in this book and mostly towards the end but I loved the adventure when it came!

I loved how Sofia and Barrett, "Bear", became roommates after one magical night in the past and him soon leaving for England after. I knew Bear had a reason for leaving so quickly and the readers find out pretty close to the beginning and I was begging Bear to be honest with Sofia about the past so she could understand and cheered when they finally talked about it! It was beautiful to see them finally open up to each other about the past and how they really felt. It felt like a long time coming and it was so satisfying when they finally talked about it!

The way they ended up fake engaged was HILARIOUS, I loved that moment and could envision it! The couples trip made for so many hijinx when they had to act as a couple and play games/go to therapy as an engaged couple.

Of course I loved the addition of a pirate story, Captain Blackheart, and how Bear had done research on her before and now they were on the island she supposedly died on. It was interested to read the letters and see Bear and Sofia work together to piece together what really happened. And near the end, the way Sofia pulled out her astrology knowledge was fantastic! I loved seeing her work through the puzzles and how it helped them with their discovery.

All in all, it was a fun ride that included some adventure, pirates, a couples retreat, romance, and communication about a difficult past to allow for a fantastic future! I look forward to more from Jo Segura!
Profile Image for Christina L..
250 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 18, 2026
This was another great book by Jo Segura! It had all the adventure and romance you would expect from her previous books, although this one was set on an island in Belize where there is supposedly treasure buried by a mysterious female pirate hundreds of years ago. Sofia and Bear end up there at a couples retreat after posing as a couple (and getting fake engaged) on a kiss cam at a hockey game. It was part fake dating and part second chance romance, which I loved. This book really sucked me in—suddenly I was halfway through, and then all the way through not long after.

Although Sofia was not my favorite main character at the start—she was very hot and cold at times, especially with Bear, I did grow to love her as a character by the end, and ended up really enjoying her side of the story. As for Bear…I absolutely loved him, no notes. It was so interesting to get chapters from his pov, usually just to see how head over heels he was for Sofia. He was such a great character, and I also loved getting the little glimpses of their past together, six years before this book took place.

Once they got to the island, it felt a bit like a mix between Survivor and couples therapy—they were given challenges where Bear and Sofia had to (try) to work together, but then were also working through their issues with each other, all the while the subplot about the hidden treasure was building in the background. It was an interesting combination, which I ended up really enjoying.

Thank you to Berkley Publishing Group and NetGalley for an advanced copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Cookie.
1,611 reviews231 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 8, 2026
Sofia's recent breakup has wrecked her life. Not only did she lose her relationship, but she also lost her job and now she needs help with paying the rent. Her friend sends a friend who is looking for a temporary place to sublet, and the friend turns out to be Barrett "Bear" Winston. Bear broke Sofia's heart six years ago, but she can't say no to the money she so badly needs. When Sofia laments that she has tickets to a hockey game that she bought for the ex, Bear offers to go with her. Circumstances lead to them getting fake engaged for the crowd at the game and with the fake engagement comes an all-inclusive prize - a trip to an island where rumors say there is buried treasure.

This was a fun and entertaining read! I love the adventurous stories that Jo Segura cooks up. Her previous books had more archeology and this newest book focused more on lore and treasure hunting. The story of the Blackheart female pirate was intriguing and I loved how it came together in the end.

I love second chance romances because of all of the heartache and pining. Neither Bear nor Sofia have gotten over each other in the six years since they've seen each other and it all bubbled up to the surface when they reconnected. There was tons of tension and that tension burst once they were on the island. Bear and Sofia had amazing chemistry and I loved that it wasn't all sunshine and roses once they hooked up again. They had a lot to work through to get to their HEA.

Pick this one up for a fun and adventurous second chance romance!

Steam level: 🔥🔥🔥

I received a complimentary eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Delaney.
553 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
Review of Advanced Reader’s Copy from Netgalley.

Thank you to Jo Segura, Berkley, and Netgalley for providing the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

To begin, words cannot describe how grateful I was to receive this ARC! I am a huge fan of Jo Segura and the unique romantic adventures she creates. This cover is stunning. Truly, it might be the best one yet.

All that to say, I knew I would like this book, I just wished I loved it. There was so much that was done really well with this book. I loved the nicknames, Bear and Cub are genuinely so sweet! I liked that Jo found a way to keep up with the archeological and adventure theme in a unique way.

I guess where the story fell a bit short for me was in the characters. I didn’t find Sofia or Bear particularly likable. I felt for Sofia, I really did, but she was so hateful to Bear I didn’t know how they overcame it. Further, Bear’s inability to express himself and tell Sofia why he left because of embarrassment didn’t really come through. As a reader, even being in Bear’s head, the embarrassment didn’t really come through. That said the fact that they sort of tortured each other for the entirety of the book then sort of tumbled back together didn’t really work for me.

The setting was incredibly well written. I could really envision the beauty of the remote island.

I also liked the twist with Freja and Sven. I thought it made for a really compelling narrative switch.

All in all, I did enjoy this book these were just not my favorite of Jo’s characters which impacted how I felt about the story.
Profile Image for Tassia da Silva.
91 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 10, 2026
Imagine ‘Couples Retreat’ meets ‘Muppet Treasure Island,’ and the FMC, Sofia is the obnoxious Miss Piggy. Lol. That’s pretty much how I’d describe this book.

And I actually had a lot of fun with it! 🤭😵‍💫☺️A fake engagement, a gorgeous tropical resort in Belize, couples’ activities, and a treasure hunt involving a legendary female pirate? There’s a lot to enjoy here.

I really liked the couples therapy dynamic and I also really enjoyed the historical mystery surrounding Captain Blackheart and her treasure. It added a fun adventure element to the romance, and it was better that there was more going on than just the relationship.

Bear was wonderful. Kind, thoughtful, family-oriented, and genuinely a good guy. I enjoyed the romantic moments between him and Sofia, especially the love confession and the letters. I could absolutely see this being turned into a fun romantic comedy movie.

Now, back to our Miss Piggy… a.k.s Sofia really tested my patience. I understand that she had a complicated history with Bear and reasons to be hurt, but she could be so immature, annoying, and threw big temper tantrums. She kept acting out instead of just having a conversation with him, and it became exhausting.

I liked Bear so much that I wanted to be more invested in their romance, but Sofia made that difficult at times. Still, the setting, the treasure hunt, and the adventure made this an entertaining read. I just wish I’d liked the FMC a little more.

I also thought that were some loose ends in regards to all the other characters.
Profile Image for Katie.
78 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 24, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley, Jo Segura and Berkley for the E-ARC!

For the last year I've been waiting as patiently as I can for a new release from Jo Segura. After binging the entire "Raiders of the Lost Heart" series, I knew I needed more from Segura, so I'm very thankful that I received an E-ARC of her next read! As with her previous books, get ready for the adventure of a lifetime, filled with romance, in-depth characters, a beautiful location, and a bit of mystery.

After being in quite the reading slump in 2026, "Guilty Treasures" was a book that easily held my attention and made me want to keep going back to it. The writing flows well and keeps you engaged throughout, wanting to know more about our romantic leads and about the mystery of Blackheart. Unfortunately Sofia has been my least favourite of Jo Segura's FMCs, her characterization and attitude not what I personally prefer in a lead. Nonetheless, I still really enjoyed learning about her and seeing the development of her relationship with Bear. On the other hand, Bear was such an intriguing character to me, his love for his sister and family really shinning through the pages. I loved learning more about him, about his research into Blackheart and the comparison between her and his sister in the justice system.

If you love adventure romances, you need to pick up a Jo Segura story! You won't be disappointed as she takes you for the ride of your life!
Profile Image for Erica.
442 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 29, 2026
I have enjoyed Jo Segura's other romance novels focused on female archeologists and unique international sites, so I was excited to see this one was coming out in January of next year. Unfortunately, this one fell a bit flat for me.

I'll start with what I liked about the novel:
- The setting was interesting and felt luxurious; I would love to stay at a top-tier couples-themed resort like this someday.
- Barrett seemed like a really great guy, kind, thoughtful, family-oriented, smart, and sexy.
- The side story of Captain Blackheart (Maristela) and her treasure.
- Overall, writing style is accessible/readable, with the plot moving along at a decent pace.

Now, for the less-than-ideal aspects:
- Sofia. Ugh. So immature and judgmental, quick-tempered, and honestly not deserving of Barrett. She irritated me so much.
- The communication (or lack thereof) between the protagonists. I lay most of the blame on Sofia (call me a hater, if you must).
- The 'tension' between the two felt forced.
- As such, the romantic/spicy scenes felt off, and the logistics/physics of some of them made me cringe and ask "What? How is that even comfortable, much less sexy?"

I might try another Segura book in the future if she returns to the world of archeology and more likeable female leads, but for now I'm a bit disappointed.

*Note: I received an Advance Digital Copy of this title from the publisher, via NetGalley, in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Tunrayo Lumpkin.
44 reviews3 followers
September 4, 2026
I received an e-ARC from NetGalley.

Typically, this genre and type of book would be right up my alley, but the writing and the book overall fell flat for me. It was extremely hard to love (let alone like) any of the main characters. I found Sofia to be annoying, bratty, overly rigid, and incredibly immature. Barrett was not much better. His British accent felt forced and honestly quite fake. The “problems” these two had felt insignificant and I struggled to care about them. It almost felt as if they were exaggerating something so insignificant (Barrett feeling the need to hide his sister’s legal battles for fear of Sofia judging him because her parents are criminal prosecutors? Not remotely realistic, I’m sorry😭).

The spicy scenes were legitimately so cringe, I had to skip them. They often happened abruptly and seemingly came out of nowhere where, overall very difficult to read and vulgar in not a good way. The connection between Sofia and Barrett fell so flat for me, I did not see the attraction at all. A lot of the “twists” were not surprising and the writing felt entirely too immature. I truthfully wanted to DNF throughout the entire book, it was pretty bad. Which was disappointing because the premise was intriguing and the story had the potential to be good. Overall, would not recommend, but I’m sure there’s an audience who would enjoy this book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Jennifer.
235 reviews5 followers
November 15, 2026
Oh my gosh, this was such a fun read! It’s a second chance love story with a bit of a mystery. Sofia has been fired from her job (thanks to her ex) and needs a roommate, fast. Her friend Patty’s brother knew a guy, so she met him in the park. It turns out he’s her former coworker Barrett who left the country after their one night together for reasons unknown.

We do get some backstory on their relationship, how it ended with Sofia being heartbroken and Barrett thinking he’d ruined any chance he had with Sofia, and we get some insight into their working relationship at the paper. Both characters are carrying around baggage that made them extremely stubborn when it came to the other, and that was frustrating at times.

I LOVED the adventure of it all! From the night out at the hockey game to the fake engagement to the couples’ retreat to the treasure hunt, I never got bored! The tension and banter between Barrett and Sofia was stretched so tight it had to snap eventually, and it snapped in pieces — in unexpected times and ways!

The twist at the end was absolutely the right one, and I loved the letters between Maristela and her brother as a treasure map. This was my first book by Jo Segura, and it won’t be my last!

4.5/5⭐️

Thank you so much to Berkley via NetGalley for an advance copy of this book!
Profile Image for Sandrine.
332 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 25, 2026
I really liked this romance ! I’ve been a fan of the author since I love how she incorporates treasure hunts into the stories. I was not disappointed with this book. While there was more romance than in the 3 previous books, there was still a good historical treasure intrigue.
After a misunderstanding where they have to fake being engaged to each other, Sofia and Bear are invited to Cayo Rosa in Belize for a week of activities that are supposed to help them build a better relationship. This island is also where a famous pirate may have buried her treasure.
Sofia’s and Bear’s relationship is not easy as they were previously involved. I did think it took a lot of time for them to be honest with their feelings and explain what previously led to their end. Miscommunication was very present. But still, they were able to build trust again. It was a spicy story, the author doesn’t shy away from details. Overall, it was a very good romance with a great adventure subplot ! Readers of the previous books will be happy to see some of the characters returning!

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an arc of this book, opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Anne.
23 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 18, 2026
I’m a huge fan of Jo Segura’s books, and this one didn’t disappoint! It was a fun take on a stuck-on-a-tropical-island adventure, and it had a lot of funny moments, too. The fmc and mmc were both quirky and smart, which the alternating narration really showcased. Even though it took them a quite while to open up to each other (although once they did, things heated up fast!!), their guardedness was understandable. The silly challenges they were put up to as part of the couples retreat were a hoot and I loved the twists at the end. The frame narrative about a woman pirate added an intriguing element, and the parallels between that story and the primary narrative added depth. Brief cameos from a couple of Segura’s previous characters were also a nice treat; I always enjoy those little easter eggs for fans. On another note, I appreciated the book’s subtle commentary on the ways racism and sexism can impact women of color in professional settings. Yet another adventurous love story from an author who’s becoming one of my favorites!
Profile Image for Jazelle.
328 reviews24 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 30, 2026
Slather on some sunscreen and get ready to bask in the warm, tropical sunlight of Cayo Rosa in Belize for a week of romantic action adventure antics in Jo Segura's Guilty Treasure.

This was my first Jo Segura novel, and it certainly sated my curiosity. I'm always game for a second chance romance, but this one is brimming with animosity and miscommunication from the start. Unfortunately, Sofia has a difficult history that's left her a bit bitter, and Bear is withholding essential information that could make all the difference in helping her heal from the past. Guilty Pleasure is high-energy, quick-paced, and sizzling with tension (get ready for smut!); a great pick if you love a lot of healing in your enemies-to-lovers forced proximity second chance romances.

What to Expect:
Second Chance Romance
Fake Proposal / Engagement
Dual POV
Treasure Hunt
Forced Proximity
Banter
Miscommunication / Rebuilding Trust
Slutty Glasses
Interconnected Standalone
Profile Image for Cadence Boudreaux.
Author 2 books4 followers
November 4, 2026
Thank you to Jo Segura, Berkley, and Netgalley for giving me an ARC!

This book was such a treasure ! haha - get it ?

I enjoyed this a lot once the story got going . I do think this would make a wonderful movie or audiobook. I loved the love confession, the letters, the games , and the final ending scene .

There are several things I wasn’t quite so sure of .

- We got a bunch of background characters but no clear ending or tie ins for them.

- Colorado and that whole mess felt unfinished .

- The hate to love was very quick once they had one spicy interaction.

- THE SAND BEFORE INTIMACY??? this was my biggest gripe - do NOT put sand there please .

These are very small things and I would absolutely still recommend reading this . This would pair so nicely with a frozen margarita and a beach vacation! Book a cruise and read guilty treasure .
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Laura Holley.
198 reviews3 followers
October 19, 2026
This was a really cute read! After a bad breakup, Sofia is in need of a roommate. She winds up with Bear, her former professional rival. A staged proposal coordinated by Sofia’s ex goes off the rails, and Bear and Sofia end up on a couples trip on an island rumored to have pirate treasure hidden on it. The major kicker? Sofia’s ex is ALSO there with HIS fiancée. So: fake dating, rivals to lovers, AND a treasure hunt? Excellent.

I loved how the storyline took so many twists and turns! I was pleasantly on the edge of my seat, not stressful like a thriller. I also liked the tie-ins from the author’s other series, but it is absolutely not necessary to have read those to understand this book.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the eARC!
24 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 17, 2026
What a fun book, I'm so glad to have read this one! There was a fantastic mix of adventure, funny moments and great romance, all woven together perfectly. Not only was the story entertaining, but I also got very engrossed in the story of the treasure and uncovering the truth, and I would love a book recounting Blackheart's life.

It was also wonderful to hear about Sophia and Barrett, who were both sweet and loveable, with a romance worth reading about.

First book I've read by this author, and I definitely want to read more. I'm hoping they're just as good.
Profile Image for ShannonXO.
827 reviews153 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
November 4, 2026
Oh but I do love an adventure romance, and it's been a while since I read a book from Jo Segura. First off, I inhaled this. Read half in a day when I had sh*t to do, but no regrets. The story was a little cheesy at times, the characters kind of childish, and I wanted more treasure hunting less bickering, but this was still an entertaining read. These characters are very well-rounded with an intriguing and deep history. Their relationship arc and growth together was great. Also who doesn't like a man with slutty little glasses?
Profile Image for Morgan Sandner.
Author 1 book5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 9, 2026
The real treasure was the love buried deep in their hearts...I didn't love the full letter of exposition at the end explaining that. And, I don't think this should be marketed as a stand alone with how many references it has to the characters from her series. I found myself disappointed that I didn't read the last book in the series before this.

BUT this is still a fun summer read, for all of those impatiently waiting for the new Mummy movie to come out.
Profile Image for Silvia Hakim.
107 reviews2 followers
October 9, 2026
A fun book but the names were cheesy & it needed a bit more suspense for me.
Profile Image for Becky.
3,575 reviews148 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
September 9, 2026
I just...no. Both characters were breathtakingly immature, dead set against talking to each other like grownups, and literally everything that happened here was for the plot and then dropped like a hot potato afterward, never to be mentioned again.

Barely any "rom," any "com" that was here was pretty juvenile, and the sex scenes were all but unreadable. Fourth in the series (I think? She doesn't even have this on her website yet, but other series characters were mentioned/had small parts here so I'm assuming they're all connected), but it worked fine as a standalone. It left me with less than zero desire to read any of the other books, though.

Rating: 1 1/2 stars / D

I voluntarily reviewed an Advance Reader Copy of this book.
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews