What do you think?
Rate this book
We Wish You a Messy Christmas
This Christmas, the perfect gift might just be learning to let go and love the chaos.
It's Christmastime, and Olivia Bradshaw is dating her childhood neighbor, veterinarian Malcolm McEntire. Life should be merry, but Olivia is worried about her mother Jane's reaction to this budding romance. Their families couldn't be more different. Perfectionist Jane cannot tolerate the unorganized, messy, fun-loving McEntires, and the thought of being permanently linked as in-laws will surely send her over the edge.
Desperate to save both Christmas and her romance, Olivia and her dad concoct an intervention to turn Jane's holidays into a big mess. But they barely launch their plan before fate intervenes with a serendipitous mess of its own.
In this delightful Christmas novella full of faith and hope, Melody Carlson delivers small-town charm, family dynamics, and a sweet contemporary romance perfect for the holiday season.
It's Christmastime, and Olivia Bradshaw is dating her childhood neighbor, veterinarian Malcolm McEntire. Life should be merry, but Olivia is worried about her mother Jane's reaction to this budding romance. Their families couldn't be more different. Perfectionist Jane cannot tolerate the unorganized, messy, fun-loving McEntires, and the thought of being permanently linked as in-laws will surely send her over the edge.
Desperate to save both Christmas and her romance, Olivia and her dad concoct an intervention to turn Jane's holidays into a big mess. But they barely launch their plan before fate intervenes with a serendipitous mess of its own.
In this delightful Christmas novella full of faith and hope, Melody Carlson delivers small-town charm, family dynamics, and a sweet contemporary romance perfect for the holiday season.
173 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 1, 2026
About the author
Melody Carlson
424 books3,405 followersMelody Carlson is the award-winning author of over two hundred books, several of them Christmas novellas from Revell, including her much-loved and bestselling book, The Christmas Bus.
She also writes many teen books, including the Diary of a Teenage Girl series, the TrueColors series, and the Carter House Girls series.
Melody was nominated for a Romantic Times Career Achievement Award in the inspirational market for her books, including the Notes from a Spinning Planet series and Finding Alice, which is in production as a Lifetime Television movie. She and her husband serve on the Young Life adult committee in central Oregon.
She also writes many teen books, including the Diary of a Teenage Girl series, the TrueColors series, and the Carter House Girls series.
Melody was nominated for a Romantic Times Career Achievement Award in the inspirational market for her books, including the Notes from a Spinning Planet series and Finding Alice, which is in production as a Lifetime Television movie. She and her husband serve on the Young Life adult committee in central Oregon.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
September 3, 2026
Olivia Bradshaw would strongly disagree that Christmas in the Bradshaw home is ‘the most wonderful time of the year’. She has a feeling that “this year could be a very messy Christmas” because she’s coming home with a new boyfriend and he’s the son of the next-door neighbors and friendly nemeses, the McEntires.
I loved how the author tied in the command to love our neighbor even when they’re difficult and showed us that “God’s perfection is vastly different from ours.” I was encouraged to allow God to intervene in His own way and to show kindness to everyone. It would have been so easy for Cindy McEntire to react to Jane Bradshaw’s cruel treatment in kind, but I loved how she ‘turned the other cheek’ and responded with kindness. I find that difficult sometimes and I know I react rather than respond. It was wonderful having a front seat to Jane’s transformation. I will admit that Olivia’s experience resonated with me, and memories of my own dating experiences flooded back.
I appreciated the message about perfection and bondage and the reminder that none of us is too far from God’s reach.
If you are looking for a light sprinkle of Christmas, a big dusting of emotion and family dynamics that’ll make you shake your head, don’t miss out on this one!
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
I loved how the author tied in the command to love our neighbor even when they’re difficult and showed us that “God’s perfection is vastly different from ours.” I was encouraged to allow God to intervene in His own way and to show kindness to everyone. It would have been so easy for Cindy McEntire to react to Jane Bradshaw’s cruel treatment in kind, but I loved how she ‘turned the other cheek’ and responded with kindness. I find that difficult sometimes and I know I react rather than respond. It was wonderful having a front seat to Jane’s transformation. I will admit that Olivia’s experience resonated with me, and memories of my own dating experiences flooded back.
I appreciated the message about perfection and bondage and the reminder that none of us is too far from God’s reach.
If you are looking for a light sprinkle of Christmas, a big dusting of emotion and family dynamics that’ll make you shake your head, don’t miss out on this one!
I was gifted this copy and was under no obligation to provide a review.
September 7, 2026
A cute and quick Christmas novella that's a lot of fun. This one definitely had a quirky plot with Jane who strives for perfection above all else and her family who's trying to get her not take everything so seriously. I really liked the cast of characters and thought that Melody did an excellent job at coming up with the perfect elements that shook up Jane's world and helped her to see where she could make some much needed changes. I loved the hopeful light that the novella ends with and how Jane's husband used the Christmas story to really help Jane see how her view of perfection differed from God's. A great read with a wonderful message!
I received a copy of this book from the author and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my honest opinion.
I received a copy of this book from the author and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Jane Bradshaw is one crooked ornament away from calling an emergency family meeting, and somehow everybody else thinks Christmas is the perfect time to test this theory. This woman does not decorate for Christmas. She stages it. Every ribbon has a job. Every cookie has a uniform. Every human being in the house is apparently one spontaneous laugh away from ruining the entire season. Meanwhile, the McEntires next door are living like somebody handed a golden retriever control of the holiday calendar, and honestly, they seem much happier.
Olivia is dating Malcolm McEntire, which should be adorable because they grew up next door to each other and he turned into a kind veterinarian with a warm family and a functioning sense of fun. Instead, she is treating this romance like classified information because telling Jane would be roughly the emotional equivalent of throwing a glitter bomb into a showroom kitchen.
And Malcolm really is sweet. He is patient, decent, and somehow willing to walk directly into Bradshaw family tension without faking his own death. His biggest mistake is assuming love can survive a Christmas visit without several people making everything weird. Sir, these families have history. You cannot stroll into that house with good intentions and expect the centerpiece to protect you.
Then Olivia and her dad decide Jane needs an intervention, and their chosen method is to intentionally create a messy Christmas. Not counseling. Not boundaries. Not one honest conversation over coffee. They look at a woman clinging to control with both hands and decide the answer is strategic disorder. This is less an intervention and more a holiday-themed psychological experiment conducted by people with no license.
The problem is that Jane is easy to laugh at until you realize she is exhausting herself trying to make everything perfect because perfect feels safer. She is controlling, sharp, and frequently impossible, but she is also clearly terrified of what happens if she lets anything slip. That part landed. Sometimes the person ruining everyone’s fun is having the least fun of all.
Cindy McEntire deserves actual recognition for continuing to respond to Jane with kindness when most people would have started a neighborhood feud over casserole dishes years ago. The McEntires are messy, loud, and not remotely interested in performing Christmas correctly, but they make room for people. Jane makes room for decorations. That difference becomes harder to ignore every time the families collide.
I did want more time with Olivia and Malcolm because their relationship moves from “whatever this is” to serious commitment at a speed that made me check whether I had skipped a chapter. They are cute together, but I needed them to have at least three more conversations before anybody started mentally shopping for wedding china. Still, the family chaos was doing enough that I stayed happily nosy.
And is it even Christmas without a new Melody Carlson story? At this point, these novellas are part of the seasonal infrastructure. Tree. Lights. Cookies. One small town full of people making emotional decisions near a wreath. I know what I signed up for, and I continue to show up with cocoa and unreasonable expectations for everyone to reconcile before the final page.
This was 3.5 stars for me. Jane completely hijacked the book, the McEntires were the family I wanted to sit with, and the whole messy-Christmas plan had exactly the kind of loving bad judgment I expect from relatives who think they are helping.
Merry Mayhem Prize: For Turning One Woman’s Need for Perfect Garland Into a Full Family Crisis
Thank you to Revell and NetGalley for the ARC. You gave me a veterinarian boyfriend, two neighboring families with incompatible definitions of festive, and one Christmas intervention that should have come with a waiver.
Olivia is dating Malcolm McEntire, which should be adorable because they grew up next door to each other and he turned into a kind veterinarian with a warm family and a functioning sense of fun. Instead, she is treating this romance like classified information because telling Jane would be roughly the emotional equivalent of throwing a glitter bomb into a showroom kitchen.
And Malcolm really is sweet. He is patient, decent, and somehow willing to walk directly into Bradshaw family tension without faking his own death. His biggest mistake is assuming love can survive a Christmas visit without several people making everything weird. Sir, these families have history. You cannot stroll into that house with good intentions and expect the centerpiece to protect you.
Then Olivia and her dad decide Jane needs an intervention, and their chosen method is to intentionally create a messy Christmas. Not counseling. Not boundaries. Not one honest conversation over coffee. They look at a woman clinging to control with both hands and decide the answer is strategic disorder. This is less an intervention and more a holiday-themed psychological experiment conducted by people with no license.
The problem is that Jane is easy to laugh at until you realize she is exhausting herself trying to make everything perfect because perfect feels safer. She is controlling, sharp, and frequently impossible, but she is also clearly terrified of what happens if she lets anything slip. That part landed. Sometimes the person ruining everyone’s fun is having the least fun of all.
Cindy McEntire deserves actual recognition for continuing to respond to Jane with kindness when most people would have started a neighborhood feud over casserole dishes years ago. The McEntires are messy, loud, and not remotely interested in performing Christmas correctly, but they make room for people. Jane makes room for decorations. That difference becomes harder to ignore every time the families collide.
I did want more time with Olivia and Malcolm because their relationship moves from “whatever this is” to serious commitment at a speed that made me check whether I had skipped a chapter. They are cute together, but I needed them to have at least three more conversations before anybody started mentally shopping for wedding china. Still, the family chaos was doing enough that I stayed happily nosy.
And is it even Christmas without a new Melody Carlson story? At this point, these novellas are part of the seasonal infrastructure. Tree. Lights. Cookies. One small town full of people making emotional decisions near a wreath. I know what I signed up for, and I continue to show up with cocoa and unreasonable expectations for everyone to reconcile before the final page.
This was 3.5 stars for me. Jane completely hijacked the book, the McEntires were the family I wanted to sit with, and the whole messy-Christmas plan had exactly the kind of loving bad judgment I expect from relatives who think they are helping.
Merry Mayhem Prize: For Turning One Woman’s Need for Perfect Garland Into a Full Family Crisis
Thank you to Revell and NetGalley for the ARC. You gave me a veterinarian boyfriend, two neighboring families with incompatible definitions of festive, and one Christmas intervention that should have come with a waiver.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
We Wish You a Messy Christmas by Melody Carlson was a great quick Christmas in July read. This book will likely have you laughing and maybe crying a bit. This book is about the Christmas season, which is usually a blessed, fun and happy time, but there are issues discussed in the story that are pretty heavy. I think the author does a great job at not making things too gloomy, but she does not seem to shy away from situations that may be a little uncomfortable that need to be talked about and worked out. There are moderate to strong mentions of faith in Jesus Christ in this book, it seems to be the right amount to encourage Christians to continue following Jesus in righteousness and at the same time to encourage those that do not know Jesus to get to know Him as their Lord and Savior. Ultimately this story, like others seems to point to the relationship we have with Jesus and how sometimes we will go through trials, but trusting in our Savior is always the answer, for He knows what is best for us, even when we do not. In addition, pointing to our relationship with Jesus, we must first love Him as He loved us and then we can love others, to include in a dating relationship and in marriage.
Malcom McEntire is the main male character. He has known Olivia Blake, the main female character pretty much all his life since they were neighbors growing up. His family is pretty laid back and unconcerned with keeping up any appearances for other people. They are a pretty close-knit family and love each other dearly. Malcolm moves away to college to become a veterinarian. While at college he runs into Olivia, they hang out and eventually begin dating.
Malcolm plans to go home for Christmas and wants to invite Olivia so they can officially tell their families about their dating. Malcolm believes his family will be elated to hear the news, but Olivia is not so sure about her parents, particularly her mother Jane. Jane is a perfectionist and more than that it may seem that she has OCD but has not ever been diagnosed. It seems to get worse as the years go by. This is why Olivia thinks her mother will likely have a hard time with her relationship with Malcolm, because Jane dislikes the McEntire’s because they are not as clean as she is or likes, to her they are very messy and she wants nothing to do with them. The reader can see how this might present a big problem for Malcolm and Olivia who may be looking to get married in the future.
Jane and her father devise a plan for a Christmas intervention. They hope that this will show Jane that she has been very difficult to live with, but that they love her and want to see her get better. As with all interventions things could go really well or it could result in a blow-up that will be hard to contain.
I really enjoyed the book, and I thought it had the right pacing for a novella. Some people may have a hard time with how Malcolm and Olivia’s relationship develops, but I think it seemed pretty normal, especially for two people who were neighbors, now moving to a dating relationship. It is worth a note to keep in mind that it is a novella, so it can be difficult to flesh out the characters and story line with enough developmental information without losing people. I think the author did a really good job on keeping these elements spot on. I recommend picking this book up, really was a cozy enjoyable read.
I received a complimentary copy from Revell through Interviews & Reviews for my honest opinion
Malcom McEntire is the main male character. He has known Olivia Blake, the main female character pretty much all his life since they were neighbors growing up. His family is pretty laid back and unconcerned with keeping up any appearances for other people. They are a pretty close-knit family and love each other dearly. Malcolm moves away to college to become a veterinarian. While at college he runs into Olivia, they hang out and eventually begin dating.
Malcolm plans to go home for Christmas and wants to invite Olivia so they can officially tell their families about their dating. Malcolm believes his family will be elated to hear the news, but Olivia is not so sure about her parents, particularly her mother Jane. Jane is a perfectionist and more than that it may seem that she has OCD but has not ever been diagnosed. It seems to get worse as the years go by. This is why Olivia thinks her mother will likely have a hard time with her relationship with Malcolm, because Jane dislikes the McEntire’s because they are not as clean as she is or likes, to her they are very messy and she wants nothing to do with them. The reader can see how this might present a big problem for Malcolm and Olivia who may be looking to get married in the future.
Jane and her father devise a plan for a Christmas intervention. They hope that this will show Jane that she has been very difficult to live with, but that they love her and want to see her get better. As with all interventions things could go really well or it could result in a blow-up that will be hard to contain.
I really enjoyed the book, and I thought it had the right pacing for a novella. Some people may have a hard time with how Malcolm and Olivia’s relationship develops, but I think it seemed pretty normal, especially for two people who were neighbors, now moving to a dating relationship. It is worth a note to keep in mind that it is a novella, so it can be difficult to flesh out the characters and story line with enough developmental information without losing people. I think the author did a really good job on keeping these elements spot on. I recommend picking this book up, really was a cozy enjoyable read.
I received a complimentary copy from Revell through Interviews & Reviews for my honest opinion
September 7, 2026
I loved how this story used four different perspectives! Especially because the different perspectives were relevant to understanding the main characters and the activity taking place. You had Olivia, her boyfriend Malcolm and then her mom and dad's perspective.
Olivia is coming home for Christmas with her new boyfriend, Malcolm. The thing is though, Malcolm was actually her neighbor growing up and so their families know each other very well. Olivia's mother does not like that family and this has Olivia concerned about how her relationship will be viewed and maybe not even accepted. But Olivia's mother Jane has a lot more issues going on than just not liking the neighbors.
Olivia's mother, Jane, has turned into a dangerous perfectionist, angry at everyone and everything that moves or touches her things in a way she doesn't like. It's ruining her relationships with her husband and her daughter, to say the least. So Olivia and her dad have a plan this year, they're going to stage an intervention and try to have the messiest Christmas possible to get Jane to see that's she completely unreasonable. But some divine intervention also plays out and puts Jane in a position where she cannot refuse the intervention.
Having Jane's perspective in the book was actually very helpful. It allowed me to relate with her and understand at least where she was coming from and how she was feeling. Without it, I think she would have felt like a very angry and flat character. She's really struggling inside and it's a battle she just doesn't know how to win. But having the love and support of everyone around her, eventually does help her see some things about herself.
Olivia and Malcolm's relationship was fun to watch develop as well. They're both so busy with their own lives that there are moments when they leave one another confused because of some mixed signals. This is also part of the "messy Christmas" theme in this book. There are literal examples and figurative examples. Malcolm works as a Veterinarian and his schedule is busy, which means him and Olivia can sometimes go long stretches without seeing one another. Even when they return home to see their parents for Christmas, Malcolm tries to stay away from Olivia's home because of her mom.
A quick novella-sized read that took me 24 hours to get through, but filled with so many lessons and heartfelt moments that I had a hard time putting it down. Not to mention that my anxiousness over Olivia's mom certainly kept me reading to see what would happen. Perfectly adorable Christmastime read for someone looking to remember why Christmas is important and how family is central to our celebrations and remembrance of what Christmas truly is.
Olivia is coming home for Christmas with her new boyfriend, Malcolm. The thing is though, Malcolm was actually her neighbor growing up and so their families know each other very well. Olivia's mother does not like that family and this has Olivia concerned about how her relationship will be viewed and maybe not even accepted. But Olivia's mother Jane has a lot more issues going on than just not liking the neighbors.
Olivia's mother, Jane, has turned into a dangerous perfectionist, angry at everyone and everything that moves or touches her things in a way she doesn't like. It's ruining her relationships with her husband and her daughter, to say the least. So Olivia and her dad have a plan this year, they're going to stage an intervention and try to have the messiest Christmas possible to get Jane to see that's she completely unreasonable. But some divine intervention also plays out and puts Jane in a position where she cannot refuse the intervention.
Having Jane's perspective in the book was actually very helpful. It allowed me to relate with her and understand at least where she was coming from and how she was feeling. Without it, I think she would have felt like a very angry and flat character. She's really struggling inside and it's a battle she just doesn't know how to win. But having the love and support of everyone around her, eventually does help her see some things about herself.
Olivia and Malcolm's relationship was fun to watch develop as well. They're both so busy with their own lives that there are moments when they leave one another confused because of some mixed signals. This is also part of the "messy Christmas" theme in this book. There are literal examples and figurative examples. Malcolm works as a Veterinarian and his schedule is busy, which means him and Olivia can sometimes go long stretches without seeing one another. Even when they return home to see their parents for Christmas, Malcolm tries to stay away from Olivia's home because of her mom.
A quick novella-sized read that took me 24 hours to get through, but filled with so many lessons and heartfelt moments that I had a hard time putting it down. Not to mention that my anxiousness over Olivia's mom certainly kept me reading to see what would happen. Perfectly adorable Christmastime read for someone looking to remember why Christmas is important and how family is central to our celebrations and remembrance of what Christmas truly is.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I enjoyed reading We Wish You a Messy Christmas, a charming small town contemporary Christmas novella set in Oregon. Olivia is an only child who loves her parents, lives in the city, and is dreading going home for Christmas. Her difficult mother is an extreme perfectionist who is unlikely to approve of Olivia’s relationship with her new boyfriend, Malcolm. Olivia’s mother can’t stand Malcolm’s messy family who have lived next door for decades.
Olivia’s mother, Jane, lives and breathes order and cleanliness in every area of her life. She has no patience for people who create mess and chaos, including her own free spirited mother, Grandma Lulu. Jane refuses to acknowledge that her attitudes and rigid expectations are causing problems for her husband, daughter, and other people in her life.
Olivia and her father concoct a well meaning plan to try and help Jane by having a fun and messy Christmas season. Unexpected circumstances turn their plans upside down and create many lighthearted and hilarious moments.
I loved how the ensemble cast of fascinating characters were challenged in different ways. The reality of living with mental health issues, including symptoms that resemble Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, are handled with sensitivity and grace. Multiple characters are on a faith journey. Trust and forgiveness themes are explored in the story
I recommend We Wish You a Messy Christmas to contemporary fiction readers who like Christmas novellas with an ensemble cast that includes feuding families, romance, family drama, romcom vibes, mental health issues and strong faith elements in the story.
Many thanks to Revell and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy.
Olivia’s mother, Jane, lives and breathes order and cleanliness in every area of her life. She has no patience for people who create mess and chaos, including her own free spirited mother, Grandma Lulu. Jane refuses to acknowledge that her attitudes and rigid expectations are causing problems for her husband, daughter, and other people in her life.
Olivia and her father concoct a well meaning plan to try and help Jane by having a fun and messy Christmas season. Unexpected circumstances turn their plans upside down and create many lighthearted and hilarious moments.
I loved how the ensemble cast of fascinating characters were challenged in different ways. The reality of living with mental health issues, including symptoms that resemble Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, are handled with sensitivity and grace. Multiple characters are on a faith journey. Trust and forgiveness themes are explored in the story
I recommend We Wish You a Messy Christmas to contemporary fiction readers who like Christmas novellas with an ensemble cast that includes feuding families, romance, family drama, romcom vibes, mental health issues and strong faith elements in the story.
Many thanks to Revell and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thanks to the author for my review copy.
I love the yearly Christmas Novella and again this one didn't disappoint. One thing I love is they are all different. This book features the Bradshaw and McEntire families. Jane the mother who is a perfectionist. Rob the father and accountant and daughter Olivia who now lives and works in the city. On the McEntire side we have Malcolm one of the children who is now a qualified vet and dating Olivia. His family live next door to the Bradshaw's and we see parents Cindy and Erik.
In setting this book up we see multiple points of view mostly the Bradshaws but also Malcolms and it really helps to get a full understanding of how the dynamics work. Jane is difficult her perfectionist is causing a lot of issues. She doesn't like that the neighbours are chaotic and messy in her eyes and it's getting worse. Olivia loves her mother but at the same time struggles as does Rob.
Olivia also worries Malcolm and her may not be able to stay together because of her mothers dislike for his family. There are so many dynamics. But it also highlights how something that seems simple can be hiding a bigger issue. Both Rob and Olivia wonder if Jane may have OCD or another mental health issue and they really want the best for her. The book reads really well and Melody did this book justice. It does deal with dysfunction and complicated family issues but in a good way that brings them to light without victimising people.
I love how the book progresses and loved the ending. Another great read. If you love Melody's Christmas books I am sure you will enjoy this book.
I love the yearly Christmas Novella and again this one didn't disappoint. One thing I love is they are all different. This book features the Bradshaw and McEntire families. Jane the mother who is a perfectionist. Rob the father and accountant and daughter Olivia who now lives and works in the city. On the McEntire side we have Malcolm one of the children who is now a qualified vet and dating Olivia. His family live next door to the Bradshaw's and we see parents Cindy and Erik.
In setting this book up we see multiple points of view mostly the Bradshaws but also Malcolms and it really helps to get a full understanding of how the dynamics work. Jane is difficult her perfectionist is causing a lot of issues. She doesn't like that the neighbours are chaotic and messy in her eyes and it's getting worse. Olivia loves her mother but at the same time struggles as does Rob.
Olivia also worries Malcolm and her may not be able to stay together because of her mothers dislike for his family. There are so many dynamics. But it also highlights how something that seems simple can be hiding a bigger issue. Both Rob and Olivia wonder if Jane may have OCD or another mental health issue and they really want the best for her. The book reads really well and Melody did this book justice. It does deal with dysfunction and complicated family issues but in a good way that brings them to light without victimising people.
I love how the book progresses and loved the ending. Another great read. If you love Melody's Christmas books I am sure you will enjoy this book.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Okay, this was such a fun and festive read and I loved the family, community and faith all intermingled in this story!
Olivia and Malcolm are heading home for Christmas and while they are neighbors who grew up together, their lives couldn’t be more different. Malcolm’s family is fun, easygoing, a little messy and unconventional, but it feels like home. Olivia’s home is quiet, immaculate and impersonal, and her mother is a perfectionist. As Olivia and Malcolm’s relationship gets more serious, she wonders if their different upbringings might make Malcolm hesitate about a future with her. Then her father comes up with a plan for a messy Christmas that brings the families and neighbors together and may help Olivia’s mother realize she needs to let go of perfection and accept help.
This definitely had more of a women’s fiction feel. The romance may have been the catalyst, but it wasn’t the focal point. Honestly, the romance was probably the weakest part for me because their emotions weren’t always evident on the page. The talks of marriage also felt rushed given how little Olivia and Malcolm seemed to communicate. That said, Olivia’s mother’s personal journey was the highlight for me. I really enjoyed watching her learn to let go of perfection with the help of her family and community. Such a sweet, fun, holiday story!
I received a complimentary copy. This review reflects my honest opinion.
Olivia and Malcolm are heading home for Christmas and while they are neighbors who grew up together, their lives couldn’t be more different. Malcolm’s family is fun, easygoing, a little messy and unconventional, but it feels like home. Olivia’s home is quiet, immaculate and impersonal, and her mother is a perfectionist. As Olivia and Malcolm’s relationship gets more serious, she wonders if their different upbringings might make Malcolm hesitate about a future with her. Then her father comes up with a plan for a messy Christmas that brings the families and neighbors together and may help Olivia’s mother realize she needs to let go of perfection and accept help.
This definitely had more of a women’s fiction feel. The romance may have been the catalyst, but it wasn’t the focal point. Honestly, the romance was probably the weakest part for me because their emotions weren’t always evident on the page. The talks of marriage also felt rushed given how little Olivia and Malcolm seemed to communicate. That said, Olivia’s mother’s personal journey was the highlight for me. I really enjoyed watching her learn to let go of perfection with the help of her family and community. Such a sweet, fun, holiday story!
I received a complimentary copy. This review reflects my honest opinion.
September 4, 2026
How do I know when September has arrived? Learning that Melody Carlson's annual Christmas novella is available! This year, Carlson delivers a touching story filled with intriguing characters, an engaging plot, and an inspiring message. Yes, there's a promising romance between the adult children of next-door neighbors, but the drama revolves around the differences between the two families, as in perfection versus realistic living! Jane Bradshaw's need for perfection triggers unfair judgment and actions that adversely affect her family's happiness. Would she really cancel their family Christmas?
We Wish You a Messy Christmas is a wonderful beginning for my 2026 holiday reading! It is chock full of faith, wisdom, and yes, a little messiness! My initial annoyance with Jane soon turned to sympathy and an increasing awareness. I'm certainly not a perfectionist, but am I guilty of allowing the busyness of the season to override the true meaning of Christmas? Do I allow external circumstances to curb my joy of Christmas?
This book is a must-read for all who enjoy contemporary fiction woven with hope, forgiveness, and holiday spirit!
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. There was no obligation for a positive review.
We Wish You a Messy Christmas is a wonderful beginning for my 2026 holiday reading! It is chock full of faith, wisdom, and yes, a little messiness! My initial annoyance with Jane soon turned to sympathy and an increasing awareness. I'm certainly not a perfectionist, but am I guilty of allowing the busyness of the season to override the true meaning of Christmas? Do I allow external circumstances to curb my joy of Christmas?
This book is a must-read for all who enjoy contemporary fiction woven with hope, forgiveness, and holiday spirit!
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. There was no obligation for a positive review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to Revell and NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Melody Carlson brings a new Holiday Christian Fiction novella to the readers with 'We Wish You a Messy Christmas'. As Christmas draws near, Olivia Bradshaw will be returning home for the holidays. She has graduated college and found a job. She has also started dating the boy next door, Malcolm McEntire. This Christmas, she will need to tell her parents. She can't help but be worried about that as her perfectionist mother, Jane doesn't like the messy, fun-loving family that is the McEntires.
In the hopes of saving both Christmas and her romance, Olivia and her father, with the help of Jane's mother decide to hold an intervention. Unfortunately for them, fate steps in with a mess of its own. This novel touches on OCD and its impacts on the family dynamics as well as on the individual. While this theme is heavy, the humorous scenes are a wonderful counterbalance to it all. With the holiday setting, it brings everything into focus for all the characters. In this small town novella, we have charm, romance, faith and hope, exactly what is called for in a holiday read.
Melody Carlson brings a new Holiday Christian Fiction novella to the readers with 'We Wish You a Messy Christmas'. As Christmas draws near, Olivia Bradshaw will be returning home for the holidays. She has graduated college and found a job. She has also started dating the boy next door, Malcolm McEntire. This Christmas, she will need to tell her parents. She can't help but be worried about that as her perfectionist mother, Jane doesn't like the messy, fun-loving family that is the McEntires.
In the hopes of saving both Christmas and her romance, Olivia and her father, with the help of Jane's mother decide to hold an intervention. Unfortunately for them, fate steps in with a mess of its own. This novel touches on OCD and its impacts on the family dynamics as well as on the individual. While this theme is heavy, the humorous scenes are a wonderful counterbalance to it all. With the holiday setting, it brings everything into focus for all the characters. In this small town novella, we have charm, romance, faith and hope, exactly what is called for in a holiday read.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Do you know a perfectionist or someone with OCD? I do. We Wish You a Messy Christmas by Melody Carlson is a Christmas novella with a theme of trying to help someone heal from perfectionism.
Olivia Bradshaw an Malcolm McEntire grew up next door to each other. Then they went their separate ways and saw each other again as Olivia goes to Malcolm's vet clinic with her roommate's cat. Malcolm and Olivia started dating and enjoy time together. However, they have a roadblock to overcome--Olivia's mother doesn't like the McEntire's. She finds them messy and unorganized. For Olivia's mother, Jane, the holidays, and her home on most days, has to be perfect.
In We Wish You a Messy Christmas, both families work together to stage an intervention--although nature sort of takes its course and creates its own intervention. I found this to be an interesting book. I have a close family member that is very much like Jane so I found a lot to relate to in this book. . .
There were some good themes of grace, mercy and redemption in this short book. There was a solid Christmas message. The romance was a bit non-existant for awhile and then picked up towards the end. I see that in most novellas though so I don't take off stars for that. All in all it could be a fun Christmas read for many readers.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Olivia Bradshaw an Malcolm McEntire grew up next door to each other. Then they went their separate ways and saw each other again as Olivia goes to Malcolm's vet clinic with her roommate's cat. Malcolm and Olivia started dating and enjoy time together. However, they have a roadblock to overcome--Olivia's mother doesn't like the McEntire's. She finds them messy and unorganized. For Olivia's mother, Jane, the holidays, and her home on most days, has to be perfect.
In We Wish You a Messy Christmas, both families work together to stage an intervention--although nature sort of takes its course and creates its own intervention. I found this to be an interesting book. I have a close family member that is very much like Jane so I found a lot to relate to in this book. . .
There were some good themes of grace, mercy and redemption in this short book. There was a solid Christmas message. The romance was a bit non-existant for awhile and then picked up towards the end. I see that in most novellas though so I don't take off stars for that. All in all it could be a fun Christmas read for many readers.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I always look forward to Melody Carlson's Christmas novella. I know it will be a great Christmas story with a strong and useful inspirational message.
I realized the title of this book was perfect as soon as I dived in. Jane Bradshaw is perfection with a capital P. There is no room for chaos in her life, but this also means the Christmas spirit has fled the house as well, and her joy is gone. The Bradshaw home is cold and museum like, not like a home.
On the other side of the story, the next door neighbors, the McEntires, were chaos with a capital C, but happiness prevailed in this household and it was warm and inviting inside the chaos. Love abounded everywhere.
So prepare to be a little sad, then happy again while someone needs to learn the true meaning of Christmas and learning to love one's neighbor while also enjoying life without perfection. The sweet romance that is budding adds just the right amount of sweetness.
This was a perfect start to my Christmas book reading list.
Thank you to Revell, NetGalley and the author for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I realized the title of this book was perfect as soon as I dived in. Jane Bradshaw is perfection with a capital P. There is no room for chaos in her life, but this also means the Christmas spirit has fled the house as well, and her joy is gone. The Bradshaw home is cold and museum like, not like a home.
On the other side of the story, the next door neighbors, the McEntires, were chaos with a capital C, but happiness prevailed in this household and it was warm and inviting inside the chaos. Love abounded everywhere.
So prepare to be a little sad, then happy again while someone needs to learn the true meaning of Christmas and learning to love one's neighbor while also enjoying life without perfection. The sweet romance that is budding adds just the right amount of sweetness.
This was a perfect start to my Christmas book reading list.
Thank you to Revell, NetGalley and the author for this ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Jingle bells, messy halls, and a heartwarming lesson or two make We Wish You a Messy Christmas by Melody Carlson a delightful holiday treat. I always look forward to Carlson’s yearly Christmas novella because I know I can count on festive fun, heartfelt moments, and a meaningful takeaway. Her friendly, engaging writing style makes the story easy to settle into, while the humor sprinkled throughout keeps the tone light and cheerful even as the novel thoughtfully explores OCD and the way it affects both an individual and a family. I especially enjoyed how the story reminds readers that Christmas does not have to look the same for everyone. There is no single right or wrong way to celebrate—only the way that best fits your family. I also appreciated seeing the story unfold from different perspectives, along with the gentle thread of faith woven throughout. We Wish You a Messy Christmas is charming, hopeful, and full of holiday heart, with an ending that left me smiling. So, grab a mug of cocoa, ignore the stray tinsel, and enjoy this sweet seasonal story.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
As the holidays near, Olivia Bradshaw is dating her childhood neighbor Malcolm McEntire. This should be a joyful time of year, but their families are not close because Olivia's mother is a judgmental perfectionist. Then one thing after another happens that brings their families together, like it or not - and things start to change. But will they change enough for Olivia and Malcolm to contemplate a life together?
I wanted to read We Wish You a Messy Christmas because I found the Christmas theme appealing. I enjoy Melody Carlson's Christmas novellas and try to read them each year. (You will find a number of reviews of her books here at my blog.)
This was a fun read. There are some sweet rom-com moments, some laugh out loud moments, and some gentle faith moments as well.
I enjoyed the book and wish it had been longer. I would have enjoyed more time with the Bradshaws and the McEntires. (Or even a sequel about what happens next!)
I recommend We Wish You a Messy Christmas for readers who enjoy light Christmas fiction with a heartwarming message.
I wanted to read We Wish You a Messy Christmas because I found the Christmas theme appealing. I enjoy Melody Carlson's Christmas novellas and try to read them each year. (You will find a number of reviews of her books here at my blog.)
This was a fun read. There are some sweet rom-com moments, some laugh out loud moments, and some gentle faith moments as well.
I enjoyed the book and wish it had been longer. I would have enjoyed more time with the Bradshaws and the McEntires. (Or even a sequel about what happens next!)
I recommend We Wish You a Messy Christmas for readers who enjoy light Christmas fiction with a heartwarming message.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I have enjoyed Melody Carlson's books for many years... she was in fact one of my very first introductions to Christian fiction back in high school... so I always know that her books are going to be good. Especially her Christmas stories. This one likewise did not disappoint... and might just be a new recent favorite from her too. The romance between Olivia and Malcolm was really sweet and I enjoyed them together, but I do think for me, Olivia's mom Jane was the star of the story. As someone who struggles with perfectionism (albeit in different ways than Jane), I found her a little too relatable in some of her struggles... but it certainly made for some interesting family dynamics too. This story had many laugh out moments and lots of Christmas cheer (and family drama). And as a novella, it was the perfect bite sized read for the holiday season and one you'll definitely want to add to your TBR.
**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.
**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
One of my Christmas traditions each year is reading Melody Carlson's latest Christmas novella. This year it was Christmas in August for me since I received an Advanced Readers Copy of We Wish You a Messy Christmas from the publisher.
We Wish You a Messy Christmas was well written, as I always expect from Melody, but it had more of a serious tone than the normal light, fun, Christmas romance that I expected. One of the main characters had Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) and that was key to the whole book. I don't mind an author addressing a weighty topic, but this one felt almost offensive to me.
There were two families in the story, the Bradshaws and the McEntires. The McEntire mom was portrayed as fun, loving and kind because she is messy. She has mismatched dishes and doesn't mind if her house is a cluttered and her family unkempt. The Bradshaw mom, on the other hand, has matching dishes and likes her home to be neat and clean, with her family looking presentable. She is portrayed as dull, cold and mean.
Now, I understand that there is a difference between liking things neat and clean and having OCD. However, I felt like I, was being labeled as dull, cold and mean because my dishes match and I don't appreciate a lot of clutter.
To be honest, although the story was good otherwise, had a sweet romance and a happy ending, the labeling (perceived or otherwise) did mar the story for me. I'm still rating it a 4 because I realize I may be the only one who felt that way.
We Wish You a Messy Christmas was well written, as I always expect from Melody, but it had more of a serious tone than the normal light, fun, Christmas romance that I expected. One of the main characters had Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) and that was key to the whole book. I don't mind an author addressing a weighty topic, but this one felt almost offensive to me.
There were two families in the story, the Bradshaws and the McEntires. The McEntire mom was portrayed as fun, loving and kind because she is messy. She has mismatched dishes and doesn't mind if her house is a cluttered and her family unkempt. The Bradshaw mom, on the other hand, has matching dishes and likes her home to be neat and clean, with her family looking presentable. She is portrayed as dull, cold and mean.
Now, I understand that there is a difference between liking things neat and clean and having OCD. However, I felt like I, was being labeled as dull, cold and mean because my dishes match and I don't appreciate a lot of clutter.
To be honest, although the story was good otherwise, had a sweet romance and a happy ending, the labeling (perceived or otherwise) did mar the story for me. I'm still rating it a 4 because I realize I may be the only one who felt that way.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 7, 2026
We Wish You a Messy Christmas by Melody Carlson
What was it about?
Olivia Bradshaw is pursuing a relationship with her childhood neighbor, Malcolm. This should be an exciting time, but Olivia is worried about her mother Jane’s thoughts on her new relationship. Jane is a perfectionist, while Malcolm and his family are more unorganized and messy. Olivia and her father come up with an idea to have an intervention with Jane over her controlling ways, but life starts a mess of its own.
What did I think?
Ms. Carlson's annual holiday book is always a highlight in my year. I know I am in for a sweet, fun, and often hilarious holiday story. I wasn't disappointed. I loved the characters, especially the perfectionist Jane. Her annoyances and uptight characteristics left me smiling and wishing Melody would start a whole new series on Jane and her overbearing antics. If you need a mood boost and want to feel better if your life is a little messy, give this title a read.
What was it about?
Olivia Bradshaw is pursuing a relationship with her childhood neighbor, Malcolm. This should be an exciting time, but Olivia is worried about her mother Jane’s thoughts on her new relationship. Jane is a perfectionist, while Malcolm and his family are more unorganized and messy. Olivia and her father come up with an idea to have an intervention with Jane over her controlling ways, but life starts a mess of its own.
What did I think?
Ms. Carlson's annual holiday book is always a highlight in my year. I know I am in for a sweet, fun, and often hilarious holiday story. I wasn't disappointed. I loved the characters, especially the perfectionist Jane. Her annoyances and uptight characteristics left me smiling and wishing Melody would start a whole new series on Jane and her overbearing antics. If you need a mood boost and want to feel better if your life is a little messy, give this title a read.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The story follows Olivia Bradshaw, who worries how her neat-freak mother, Jane, will react to her dating the veterinarian next door from a very chaotic, messy family.
Jane is obsessed with tidiness to the point of showing OCD tendencies, so the family decides to stage an intervention for her over the Christmas holidays. What will happen when the two families are forced together for Christmas?
This novella is a sweet, Christmas, Christian-based rom-com. It is full of tender and witty moments. The romance in this story seemed a bit awkward and rushed, but it was a quick enjoyable read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for the advance copy of this ebook. All opinions are my own.
Jane is obsessed with tidiness to the point of showing OCD tendencies, so the family decides to stage an intervention for her over the Christmas holidays. What will happen when the two families are forced together for Christmas?
This novella is a sweet, Christmas, Christian-based rom-com. It is full of tender and witty moments. The romance in this story seemed a bit awkward and rushed, but it was a quick enjoyable read.
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for the advance copy of this ebook. All opinions are my own.
September 7, 2026
The plot of this story intrigued me—dating the son of the neighbors her mother despises. The potential for troubles and drama abound. Of course, you want to see the young couple work everything out and succeed. And also for their families to get along and even enjoy each other. I appreciated the faith element and the character growth in this endearing tale, but I did not care for the image that it’s normal for Christians to drink alcohol and gamble. The novel can be enjoyed any time of year. I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own. #WeWishYouaMessyChristmas #NetGalley
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Olivia Bradshaw is dating her childhood neighbour Malcolm McEntire, and keeping their relationship a secret from her mother, Jane, who cannot stand the McEntire family and isn't shy about making her feelings known. Worried about her mother's ever increasing perfectionism, Olivia and her dad concoct a plan to create a 'messy Christmas', but then fate intervenes...
I'm a fan of Christmas novellas, but in this latest one from Melody Carlson it's a bit of a pity that the characters I liked the most didn't include Olivia!
To me it seems that compromise from various people was more helpful than everyone sticking determinedly to their own ways of doing things.
On the positive side, I love the descriptions of the McEntire family, and the kindness of Malcom's parents, especially his long-suffering mother. I also greatly enjoyed meeting Lulu, someone with whom there is definitely more than meets the eye! As you'd expect from a novel by this very experienced and award-winning author, this is a well constructed story with lots of entertaining peripheral detail. It's just a pity that for this reader the romance doesn't really work.
NOTE: I read a pre-publication version supplied by the publisher. No review was required. All comments and opinions above are entirely my own.
I'm a fan of Christmas novellas, but in this latest one from Melody Carlson it's a bit of a pity that the characters I liked the most didn't include Olivia!
To me it seems that compromise from various people was more helpful than everyone sticking determinedly to their own ways of doing things.
On the positive side, I love the descriptions of the McEntire family, and the kindness of Malcom's parents, especially his long-suffering mother. I also greatly enjoyed meeting Lulu, someone with whom there is definitely more than meets the eye! As you'd expect from a novel by this very experienced and award-winning author, this is a well constructed story with lots of entertaining peripheral detail. It's just a pity that for this reader the romance doesn't really work.
NOTE: I read a pre-publication version supplied by the publisher. No review was required. All comments and opinions above are entirely my own.
August 17, 2026
A delightful little read that reminds us to let go of perfection and embrace the messy. The Bradshaw’s and McEntire’s, though neighbors, could not be more different. Jane Bradshaw has created a glass house of perfection for her family often isolating them while Cindy McEntire has embraced the chaos of life in a large family.
This book beautifully highlights the differences between perfection and just living life to the fullest. It shows the hope and happiness that can come from letting go of our ideal life and living in the moment. I feel it is a must read especially for those of us who struggle feeling everything must be perfect.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book by the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are completely my own.
This book beautifully highlights the differences between perfection and just living life to the fullest. It shows the hope and happiness that can come from letting go of our ideal life and living in the moment. I feel it is a must read especially for those of us who struggle feeling everything must be perfect.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book by the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are completely my own.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I love this story! An original topic that reminds us that we all have some sort of burdens in life. Yet, with faith, love, and trust in God, those difficulties can be tackled with hope. This is a great book to share with reading groups. I received a complimentary copy of the book. No review was required.
August 18, 2026
Carlson is my very favorite novella writer. Her Christmas novellas are the best and this one was so messy and fun. I love the kids Mothers finally became friends and the whole intervention was the best. I highly recommend this fast, fun, messy read.
Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required, and all views expressed are our own.
Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required, and all views expressed are our own.
August 31, 2026
Christmas is supposed to be the most wonderful time of the year, but for Olivia’s mother, Jane, perfection is the name of the game. She can’t stand the McEntire family next door, with their tacky decorations, constant stream of family, and decidedly messy way of living. So when Olivia starts falling for their son Malcolm, Jane’s worries about their families becoming permanently connected only grow.
I enjoyed the way this short novella tackled tough family dynamics, perfectionism, and learning to let go. The family even schedules an intervention for Jane in hopes of getting her to see that maybe a little chaos isn’t such a bad thing.
There are moderate faith elements woven throughout the story, along with plenty of Christmas spirit, small-town charm, and a sweet romance with no spice. Because this is a novella, the characters and relationships don’t have quite as much time to develop as they would in a full-length novel, but the overall message was heartfelt.
A quick, cozy holiday read with a reminder that sometimes the best parts of life are the things we can’t perfectly plan or control.
I enjoyed the way this short novella tackled tough family dynamics, perfectionism, and learning to let go. The family even schedules an intervention for Jane in hopes of getting her to see that maybe a little chaos isn’t such a bad thing.
There are moderate faith elements woven throughout the story, along with plenty of Christmas spirit, small-town charm, and a sweet romance with no spice. Because this is a novella, the characters and relationships don’t have quite as much time to develop as they would in a full-length novel, but the overall message was heartfelt.
A quick, cozy holiday read with a reminder that sometimes the best parts of life are the things we can’t perfectly plan or control.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This is a fun book about family dynamics and the chaos it can occur at Christmas time. It points out what is really important and how comprise can bring happiness to all.
September 5, 2026
Cute love story and a story about family
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I absolutely love reading Melody Carlson stories and this is no acception! Another wonderful Christmas novalla. Olivia Bradshaw leaves her stiff house with her stiff mom to go to college and to get a job. The hardest part figuring out who she is after a difficult relationship with her mom.
Jane Bradshaw is struggling to deal with life in general and how to allow anything to be out of her control. One challenging year after year her husband Rob decides to have a Christmas intervention to help his wife.
Malcolm McEntire has spent his child living next store to the Bradshaw's. After a chance run in with Olivia Bradshaw he decides to start a relationship. While visiting his family along with Olivia he is torn after spending time with Olivia's mom.
This is another cute Christmas story. It's funny and serious. There is also a little suspense and also second chances. The biggest lesson is you don't pick your family! I highly recommend this book!
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Revell through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
Jane Bradshaw is struggling to deal with life in general and how to allow anything to be out of her control. One challenging year after year her husband Rob decides to have a Christmas intervention to help his wife.
Malcolm McEntire has spent his child living next store to the Bradshaw's. After a chance run in with Olivia Bradshaw he decides to start a relationship. While visiting his family along with Olivia he is torn after spending time with Olivia's mom.
This is another cute Christmas story. It's funny and serious. There is also a little suspense and also second chances. The biggest lesson is you don't pick your family! I highly recommend this book!
A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Revell through Interviews and Reviews via NetGalley. All opinions are mine alone.*
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews