DEEP IN THE UNDERWORLD, WILL LOVE BLOOM WHERE IT SHOULD NOT SURVIVE?
ORDER your new necromantasy obsession. . .
The Knight and the Moth meets Phantasma in this spellbinding gothic, enemies-to-lovers tale of life, death, and the dangerous bond between two sworn rivals.
Jonquil Foye wields the power of Life.
Her sworn enemy, Edmund Blackburn, wields the power of Death.
On the battlefield, they clash in a deadly duel meant to decide the fate of their warring cities—until their magics entwine and create a volatile being so powerful it drags them both deep into Death itself.
Forced into a reluctant truce, Jonquil and Edmund must navigate the treacherous underworld and confront the horrifying consequences of their own creation.
As time runs out, their alliance sparks a deeper attraction. But truces are fragile, and Death seems determined to ensure they never return to the land of the living. . .
Brutal, gorgeous, and heart-stopping, this gothic dark fantasy romance is perfect for readers who crave high-stakes tension, lushly dark atmospheres, and a slow-burn enemies-to-lovers romance with a touch of horror.
• True enemies to lovers • Yearning • Forced proximity • Gothic Victorian setting • Reylo vibes • Masked MMC • Life & Death magic
Meg Smitherman writes science fiction, fantasy, and horror books (all of which involve kissing). She studied Creative Writing at Brunel University London, where she obtained both her MA and a staggering amount of student loan debt. When not writing, Meg spends her time playing video games, reading fan fiction, and couch rotting. Based in Los Angeles, she shares her life with a chihuahua, a cat, and a handsome Englishman.
HUGE thanks to NetGalley & the publishers for a chance to review this arc!! I know this is only coming out in January but it’s giving Autumn & I’m excited 🥹 3.75-4✨ Deathsworn follows a fmc who wields the powers of life, while the mmc wields the powers of death. They’re on each side of a war that’s been going on for years, and a duel leads them on an impossible adventure.
This novel had the perfect Autumn vibes. It was dark, eerie & atmospheric. I’m happy I decided to read it in October. There’s a scene in the first 25% that really freaked me out. The author is talented in setting up monstrous scenes.
I loved the main characters & their slow burn. I loved how intelligent the fmc was. I think the most unique aspect for me was the fact that they found their equals in their darkness. They didn’t shy away or were disgusted by the other’s deathly actions and I appreciated reading about characters like that.
The magic system was sooo unique & I wanted more! The worldbuilding was amazing as well. I wish the fmc’s friend was better incorporated into the storyline though because it did feel like she appeared when it was convenient.
Now this was a 5 stars read for the first 85%. Unfortunately, the last 15% left me feeling… discontented. I just can’t really wrap my head around the decision that was made. I think the entity’s origin was a bit convoluted or hard to swallow, and then the mc’s decisions at the end… I didn’t like that. But that’s only my opinion. I’m struggling with my rating because the ending did really hinder my whole experience but I’ll leave it at 4 because I did actually love the first 85%.
Overall, I recommend this for an atmospheric Autumn read!
death’s duke wants me, death fears me (and i am the master of both obvs)
you ever duel your enemy so atrociously you’re stuck wandering the forest of the dead together while a construct of y’all’s creation threatens to devour both your cities whole—unless you stop it first?
gothic, horror, scooby doo type escapades (what could be more iconic), dragging your enemy around like a rotten carcass (unfortunate that you also need him to survive), your enemy undone by a single hand touch. basically meg smitherman i owe you my life and i always knew you had it in you!!
thank you netgalley & saturday books for the eARC—all thoughts are my own! ✦ publication date: january 12, 2027
*PILLS RATLLING*
jonquil, who has the power of life, and edmund, who has the power of death, are bitter enemies fighting a war for their cities. during a duel, their opposing magics accidentally mix, creating a dangerous new power that pulls them both down into the underworld of death.
to escape, the two enemies are forced to work together and survive their own creation. as they journey through the dark realm, they start to develop feelings for each other. however, their alliance is fragile, and death is trying everything it can to trap them forever.
okay, so first things first: i have to say that meg smitherman is a genuinely talented author, and i can really see the massive potential she has going forward. one of the most unique things about this book was definitely the magic system, the way it’s split between life and death, and how mixing the two just creates absolute destruction? so cool.
as for the characters, jonquil and edmund are honestly so hot, like HOTTTT. they are a true, slow burn enemies-to-lovers pair, and i lived for that delicious tension and chemistry between them. i also really loved the footnotes the author included throughout the story. they were genuinely helpful and immersive, and you can just tell she did her thorough research.
now for the not so good part. i was beyond excited to dive read this book, but there were definitely a few things that needed some work. sometimes, when an author tries to cram every single popular trope available into one story just to hit all the boxes, it kind of takes away the organic fun of it all. it starts to feel a bit overwhelming. on top of that, i really feel like if this book had just been a bit longer, it wouldn't have had to rush through so many important plot points. instead, the pacing suffered, and the ending felt incomplete in a lot of ways that left me closing the book with lots and lots of unanswered questions.
i'd still recommend this to anyone who loves true enemies to lovers and unique magic system.
What a unique magic system… I really liked how the magic system worked and all the history behind it. How there are two kinds of magic in this world.. life based and death based .. we learn a lot about how both systems work.
The feeling of death is throughout the book… I really enjoyed the lore behind everything and how we also had footnotes like a journal expanding the world building and creating a whole unique system and history to learn about.
One of the footnotes references a scene from a book they liked, The Darkest Path - birthday death story… it was built into story very well and one of my fav parts just for the reference and why it was added to the book…
This is def an enemies to lovers slow burn that had me wanting them together from the start. The chemistry and how their relationship developed was done really well. The freckles …. 🫶🏽💕 cuteee
Other things I liked about the world/lore were how the sky gets more red every year.. would have liked that incorporated into the story more but def thought it was a cool detail. Overall, def got the gothic deathly vibe in the story.
I wasn’t a huge fan of the ending.. I mean I liked everything involved the in the last few pages it was def intense how everything went down in the end … was so good !! the only thing I did not enjoy was the final decision … because why?? lol
Would def recommend this read for lovers of a more deathly vibe with their fantasy reads!
“She was driven by something headier, darker, and far more personal: Revenge.”
As a Scorpio, yes. And right off the bat, I want to mention that I am an absolute sucker for life versus death magic and the concept of animancers versus necromancers and the way it made me think immediately of Alchemised. Not that they’re very alike, on the contrary, but since both use the same base concept I got a feeling of nostalgia instantly. Cue the MMC being a masked death mage, instant Kaine Ferron vibes. This, however is just my brain taking me to my comfort story and characters, Deathsworn is very much its own original tale and MCs.
“War is petty. War is unsporting. The rules exist when they suit me. And just now? They don’t.”
“I might be able to summon a little floating light, if I try very hard. Do you want a little floating light?”
This book smacked me in the face. I did not know your game, miss Meg but I am absolutely paying attention now. The chemistry, banter and tension between the characters was so unexpected, I was experiencing whiplash. In under 400 pages, Deathsworn managed to deliver a full high stakes plot coupled with a very slow burn romance that developed in such a natural and satisfying way. I adored Jonquil, the FMC. I absolutely hated her name and ended up calling her Nyquil in my head 🫣🫣 I am not proud of it, but despite the name, she managed to leave such an impact. As much as I enjoyed the romance, the complicated relationship with her mother and the way it was navigated and explored under unusual circumstances were my main motivators for reading.
This is, amazingly, a standalone that had an ending both so satisfying and bittersweet that I was genuinely shedding tears at the last phrase. I absolutely adored the writing, very witty and accessible. The storytelling, very fluid and it complemented the romance. The world building was small, but I didn’t find it lacking. The best way I can describe Deathsworn is delightful, funny and heartwarming, but make it high stakes and high action instead of cozy.
This book was amazing! A true enemies to lovers! This story was so well done, and I was so invested in Jonquil’s story from the very beginning.
I was honestly shocked by the whole series of events leading up to her getting stuck with the Duke of Death in the underworld. Their trek through the land of Death was filled with multiple near death scenarios, and it was so entertaining.
I loved the subtle shift in the relationship between the Duke, aka Edmond, and Jonquil as they slowly transitioned from hating each other to depending on each other and eventually something more. As they spend more time together, you learn more about each of them individually, which really changed my perspective on both characters.
The last quarter of the book was wild work! So many competing threats that felt like they would overpower them. And that ending has me sat! I hope this is a series because I want more of their story!!
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Deathsworn is a fresh take on the fantasy romance genre--it's macabre yet romantic, and absolutely stunning! I ate up the dynamics between bookish Jonquil and the enigmatic Duke of Death as they are forced to team up to save mankind from the grotesque amalgamation of their magics. The classic battle of life versus death in an immersive, gothic world.
My first thought in writing this review is that I love Edmund. He was pretty much exactly the type of character I generally gravitate toward, so nothing shocking there. The banter was great. Typical for the enemies to lovers realm of romantasy, but I have zero complaints about that. I’m exactly where I want to be. I eat that shit up every time.
I also really liked the magic system in this book. The divide between the animancers and necromancers was interesting. Could have done without the glossary at the beginning though.
When it comes to the romance, I thought they developed/admitted to themselves their feelings for each other a bit earlier than what the constraints of the story warranted, especially as a self-proclaimed slow burn. But I liked the two of them together enough that it didn’t bother me too much.
Also, a significant part of the story was just them walking through the land of the dead. The pacing wasn’t too slow, so it wasn’t a problem for me and I actually enjoyed those parts, but if you’re looking for a story packed with action and plot, this might not be for you.
I didn’t love the resolution, I fear. I’m a firm believer that an ending has the power to make or break a story. I was ready to give this 4.5 stars until I got to the last seven-ish percent. It’s hard to tell you what exactly I didn’t like without revealing what happens, but I’m going to put this the best way I can without spoiling anything.
The first has to do with the “volatile being” created by the clash of Jonquil and Edmund’s magic at the beginning of the story, the main villain of the book. I think there was a lot of good build-up when it came to how they would eventually go about defeating this villain. But the way it happened, and more specifically, the reveal of what this villain was made of, was not something I enjoyed. It added a juvenile, almost hope-core vibe to the book that I just wasn’t a fan of.
The next one is purely a matter of personal taste, and that is regarding a choice made by Jonquil and Edmund at the very end. I simply don’t see why they would make such a decision and would have preferred a different end to their story.
Despite all of that though, I really enjoyed the story overall.
Thank you so much to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an early eARC of this book!
Deathsworn was my first novel of Meg Smitherman’s, and I plan to read more ASAP! In its blurb, Deathsworn is described as The Knight and the Moth meets Phantasma, but there aren’t magical trials and it felt different than both of those to me. If I were to compare it to anything I’ve read, I would say it’s more the war and necromancy of Alchemised meets the journey and realizations of The Everlasting.
I really enjoyed the life and death magic aspect of this, and the exploration of how those aren’t opposites so much as intertwined. The journey these characters go on is dark, and the atmosphere that was created was impeccable! I also loved the chemistry and the development of the relationship between Jonquil and Edmund, as well as their personal developments over the course of the story.
This is a very fast-paced read, that somehow still manages to deftly explore themes of grief and guilt. I would definitely recommend it!
First off thank you to NetGalley & SMP for the ARC!
Deathsworn is a fantastic read, it touches a lot on grief and guilt in such a beautiful way. The atmosphere was so cool and the slow burn, enemies-to-lovers romance and humor were top-notch. I thoroughly enjoyed this book.
I am a little conflicted about this book because I had been craving it (im)patiently ever since the first official announcement dropped on the author's Instagram. And after finally reading Deathsworn... well, I have a lot of thoughts, and unfortunately, not many of them are positive.
Let's start with the footnotes. Yes, I knew they were going to be part of the book, but the sheer amount of them and the information packed inside was, to put it lightly, overwhelming. I appreciate the effort that went into creating such a complex world, but I want to experience that world through the story rather than feel like I'm reading a textbook. It also made me question whether all that background information really needed to be included, especially when some of it could have been woven into the narrative more naturally. Ironically, despite all those explanations, I still struggled to understand the foundations of the actual conflict. We're in the middle of a war, but what are the real motivations behind it? What are either side fighting for, and what are the consequences if they lose? The story never managed to make these questions feel important, leaving the central conflict surprisingly difficult to get invested in. And that's probably my biggest issue with the book: there's so much information about the world, but not enough storytelling to make me care about what happens in it.
Then we have the characters. I was promised a power couple, but that turned out to be a bit of a lie. Both the FMC and MMC had me going ARGH more times than I can count, and I genuinely struggled to understand what was supposed to make them work as a couple. Chemistry? Where? The banter wasn't bantering, and their interactions felt dry and forced, as if the author was constantly trying to convince me: HEY, LOOK, THEY'RE FALLING IN LOVE! Sorry, but I just wasn't buying it. Even the forced proximity trope couldn't save this ship. With neither the central conflict nor the romance giving me much reason to care, I found it increasingly difficult to stay invested in the characters' journey.
Perhaps some of these issues could have worked better if Deathsworn were the first instalment in a larger series, with more room to develop the characters, relationships, and worldbuilding. As a standalone, however, I expected a more cohesive story and a much stronger payoff.
Unfortunately, the premise and initial concept were pretty much the only things keeping me going until the end. I kept hoping something would eventually click and turn things around, but it never happened. The ending was predictable enough that I spent the final chapters waiting for some unexpected plot twist, especially in those last ten pages. Well... it never came.
Such a shame, because the premise had so much potential, and I really wanted this one to work for me.
Thank you to Michael Joseph, Penguin Random House | Michael Joseph and Netgalley for gifting me this eARC in exchange for honest review.
Meg Smitherman does it again, the woman never misses. This was my first full length novel by Meg and boyyyyyy was it banging. The pacing was incredible, short chapters, action packed, full of banter. You can tell Meg writes novellas because she didn’t leave us hanging and gave us exactly what we needed all the way through. This is a SLOOOOW BURN and I was creaming my knickers when they finally gave in, a reluctant infatuation is the BEST. Our FMC is smart, I’m such a simp for intelligent powerful women. I’m also a simp for hot broody men with freckles. I’m so happy Meg has given us a standalone that was absolute fire.
3.25 ⭐️ Dark and fun, but also… confusing??? This definitely had more plot holes than I consider acceptable, and the overall purpose of the story felt pretty unclear and almost nonexistent at times. I did really like the characters and their romance, tho. It was a slow burn as much as it could be, considering this is a standalone, but I felt like the switch from falling for each other to being fully in love happened way too quickly and almost out of nowhere. I’ll admit it didn’t bother me too much in this particular case bc I really liked them, but it’s definitely something I wish had been handled differently.
The ending also felt a little anticlimactic and even somewhat rushed to me. I feel like there was something being slowly built up throughout the story that could have been wrapped up in a completely different and much more interesting way. Unfortunately, this wasn’t a favorite for me, but I can definitely see readers who enjoy books with a more gothic vibe absolutely loving this one.
Thank you to NetGalley and Saturday Books for this eARC for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
The beginning of this book kicked off very strong, but as it went on, I found my ADHD kicking in even stronger, as I would reach for my phone, look up other books, do other things instead of reading the next chapter. I think I started to really feel the lull at around 50%.
Without spoilers, I think the reason why I wasn’t as engaged in the story was that I thought it’d be darker, more macabre, and gothic than it was. The banter between the two main characters was incredibly playful and there wasn’t really the sense yearning, or that “snap” when the tension breaks and the main characters decide they don’t hate each other and instead want to tear one another’s clothes off.
The visual descriptors of the atmosphere, monsters, etc. was also a bit shallow, especially when they were in death (which was the majority of the book). The desert depiction was great, but I was missing that style of writing for the main chunk of the book. The spice was very short and mild, and if it was nixed, this book is easily a YA.
The story felt long and short all at once, and I think it’s likely I’ll forget the story after my next few reads.
I don’t know if authors take back ARC reviews to apply changes, but it looks my review echoes the same feedback as a lot of the 3 star reviews here in goodreads and NetGalley. There’s a lot of potential, but the story needs sharpening.
Thanks to the author and publisher for my arc. The opinions are my own.
I ABSOLUTELY loved this. Deathsworn is now my second book I’ve read from Meg and I plan on devouring them all. This has some Rylo vibes (dark vs light) that I really loved and each character had their own personality and vibe. The atmosphere is PERFECT, dark , gothic… a death forest! The city of the dead?! Perfect. Pacing… perfect. Slow burn with banter and angst and just the right amount of “we shouldn’t/ we can’t /nwe are supposed to hate each other.” Loved this , also really loved that it’s a stand alone with a satisfying ending. Also the little foot notes added to the immersion so well.
Believe me when I say I was not prepared at all for how addictive this book would be. I absolutely DEVOURED IT.
It was dark, immensely interesting and fascinating. I was intrigued basically all the time and I just couldn't stop reading.
Deathsworn introduced me to a new world with a very rich lore, a solid magic system (where life and death are the most important elements), and I really enjoyed following Jonquil and the ominous Duke Of Death in this, let's say, macabre adventure through an even more ominous forest, plagued by spirit-like monsters who were constantly trying to eat them. There's a very ancient war between these two kingdoms, and at some point our main characters are forced to team up and work together to figure out how to destroy a new dangerous evil threatening their homes.
That's a classic that never fails to amaze me 🙂↕️
There's a lot of action too, epic battle scenes and the gothic settings are so beautifully, well described you literally feel like you're right there with the characters. The atmosphere in general was powerful and kinda tangible.
I especially LOVED the whole system the author created for the magic. There's a mechanical process involved in the way they wield that magic and it adapts to whatever purposes the animancers (those who possess life based abilities) and necromancers (with death based abilities) may have for it. Complex but not incomprehensible, which is AWESOME.
This was my first book of Meg Smitherman and I just know I'll be reading more of her stories!
Thank you so much @megsmitherman and @stmartinspress for the digital galley through #netgalley!
3.5⭐️ I was really excited to receive an ARC of this book because the premise sounded like exactly the kind of thing I would love: a dark gothic story where two enemies fighting on opposite sides are forced to become allies and eventually fall in love. Unfortunately, most of the story ended up feeling rather flat and predictable to me…
I’ve read Swallowed and Fervor by Meg Smitherman, and I really enjoyed them, especially their original ideas and atmosphere. For some reason, though, the magic of her writing didn’t quite work for me here. The characters go from “enemies” to “lovers” in the blink of an eye after spending very little time together. Yes, they go through some challenges together, but having mommy issues, saving each other, and realizing they’re not quite what they initially thought they were doesn’t really give me a solid foundation for their love. Personally, I just needed more of an emotional connection between them.
The worldbuilding also felt pretty surface level. There are necromancers, there are animancers, they’re at war even though death is a natural part of life. And don’t even get me started on the secret duel. Who decides the outcome of a war that way? And why didn’t Magnus being killed end the war in Umbra’s favor? Nobody knew he had chickened out at the last moment.
Overall, though, this wasn’t a bad read for a few dark autumn evenings. Smitherman does a really good job with the horror elements, and I definitely enjoyed those. I just wanted more depth and emotional weight, especially when it came to the romance, but unfortunately, it wasn’t quite there for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
On paper, Deathsworn has all of the components I seek out in a fantasy romance: a bit of darkness, a touch of death and a magic system that society abides by with mysterious, skillful main characters. Alas. Ultimately, this shit kinda read like how it feels like to watch an anime. A bad one, too.
I simply could not bring myself to care how or what happened to these characters. Deathsworn was well-written in the sense that I could tell Smitherman is an intelligent, educated author who knows how to craft syntax, but Smitherman's characters are not set up for success - I had no attachment to them or their context. The language is flowery, but the emotion isn't there at all. Their internal struggles felt contrived, their dialogue and conversation very superficial. The banter was not good, it was childish. At one point, Jonquil, our FMC, insults her non-love interest, boorish sexual partner by calling him a "pumpkin" and I thought, "Well, now that's just insulting to pumpkins." Any one character could say or feel the things Jonquil and Edmund felt, and not in a "they're so relatable" kind of way. Even the fight scenes read like how it feels to watch a shonen-style anime fight scene. I don't know how else to describe this.
I'm also not entirely sure of the moment our main characters fell in love, but the only opportunity Smitherman found for closeness to be built between the two was for them to be removed from the context of their everyday via a forced proximity trope, melting away the world they know that reinforced their ideas of each other. Almost like falling in love while away on a secret mission. I can't tell if I appreciate Smitherman's attempt at the forced proximity, but it was disappointing when they had to re-enter their society and I couldn't buy the relationship past its weak start. I was struck with how frequently I found myself thinking, "I don't know why I should care about this war, their cities being saved or not, any of it." The book really started to lose me about 50% of the way through, but much like Edmund and Jonquil trekking through Death, I bore onward.
Now this one is petty, but if I have to read a sentence that started with "Jonquil didn't fear" or about any of the things that Jonquil wasn't afraid of one more time...
With that being said, Jonquil is a talented FMC, I admired that and her quick thinking.
Thank you to NetGalley and the team at St. Martin Press for the ARC.
5 ⭐️ I was blessed with a bound manuscript and YA’LL. ABSOLUTELY IMPECCABLE. I have so many (screaming) notes in the margins, and so many drafts of this review saved, but I need a keyboard & I need to carefully review my giddy thoughts to make sure there are no spoilers, so full review to come but just know I LOVED EVERY BIT OF IT.
4.5/5Thank you Netgalley & St. Martin's Press for the advanced copy! The official comp statement: "The Knight and the Moth meets Phantasma in this spellbinding gothic, enemies-to-lovers tale of life, death, and the dangerous bond between two sworn rivals."
Reader I raise you this: dead beat darlingstern with an enemies to lovers twist oh and did I mention he commands death but only lets her command him? mmmYEAH let's get into it.
As my reading taste evolves, so has my understanding of what makes a solid, standout fantasy (for me): - unique magic system that feels both tangible and costly - tangible stakes through every page and not a footnote for the first and last 10% of the book - a delectable romance that makes you work for it!!!! - solid understanding of pacing
This book not only ticked every single box for me, but it's also the only book I've read since Dead Beat's release that has made me feel anything even remotely in the same realm (I genuinely can't that because the book slump was quite literally knocking at my door).
First of all, the magic system was SO cool and really tickled my STEM nerd brain--not only is the source of the user's magic either from Life or Death, but they also have to create a schematic or "formula" for the spell in addition to an incantation and physical movement. The user also has an energy well that can make or break them in battle so honestly I felt like I was in a video game every time there was a battle sequence. The ebbs and flows of the pacing throughout the book was handled really well, giving you enough time to breath and digest what's going on without taking away from the intensity of the stakes and spending necessary time to really understand the inner workings of each character. My only critique overall is that there were some points in the book that could've been explained or expanded upon more without hindering the overall pacing of the story, but for a standalone I think it did a fantastic job holding its own without feeling overly drawn out.
Jonquil and Edmund <3333333 A true enemies to lovers where you really do get to work for the romance and boy does it really pay off. Throughout the book, we really get to understand these polar opposites (who literally channel Life and Death), why they are the way they are, and witness really well-done character development. They are destined to always be at odds with each other, only succeed at the cost of the others' failure AND YET!!! They must traverse through Death, depending on each other for their survival (and my entertainment hehehe). Ugh they were so delectable, I enjoyed every second, and they really just felt like they lifted off the page with how tangible, funny, and vulnerable they are. Edmund my masked, moody, dramatic, sensitive king I adore you and can’t wait for everyone to yell about you with me.
Genuinely came to really enjoy this book and I need everyone to devour this book come release day on January 12th, 2027!!!!!
Thank you @netgalley and St. Martins Press for the arc!
Deathsworn Meg Smitherman
⭐️⭐️⭐️.75
This book started off with such a bang. Immediately pulls you in on chapter one. Intense yearning, enemies to lovers and self forgiveness. The FMC and MMC relationship had me giggling at points, true King and Queen of Death. I loved the magic system and dark fantasy vibes. I woukd definitely recommend this book!
masked man season is upon us and meg smitherman has blessed us again
life and death as two sides of the war is a unique fantasy take and I really enjoyed seeing the magic system and political sides explored. despite being a standalone and short by typical fantasy standards it wasn’t too complex to follow and came with realistic limitations to their magic.
the banter and slow burn tension between jonquil and edmund (aka duke of death) was exceptional, it’s enemies to lovers but they’re TRUE enemies (like ‘I am actively trying to kill you’ vibes) - that being said we get lots of bickering and back and fourth threats between the two so the payoff is so worth the slow burn
themes of grief and guilt were interwoven throughout and beautifully executed. both characters had their own experiences which shaped them into their political roles - nothing builds a bit of character like generational trauma
the journal footnotes were such a cool touch after each chapter - not only for expanding on the world but also getting more personal history for the characters too
the gothic setting and descriptions were so tangible that at times the environment felt real and tangible and lowkey terrifying
definitely recommend this standalone gothic necromantasy if you saw reylo and masked man and thought yep, that’s a bit of me 🙂↕️
Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin’s Press for the eARC!
Meg Smitherman has always been on my TBR, but I hadn’t gotten around to reading any of her work (most are novella length which isn’t my favorite since I like a slower burn). Deathsworn is a full-length novel, so I was super happy to get my hands on this one early. After finishing, I am even happier because it was so good!
Basically, this book had a lot of my favorite things: enemies to lovers, reluctant allies, (super) slow burn romance, dark fantasy, older-ish leads (late 20s) and Death/ afterlife as a place. The magic system and setting both felt unique. The leads felt three-dimensional. They both had trauma and regrets that shaped their lives. I adored both of them so much. The writing was beautiful. I was sucked into this story from the first page. Also, there was just enough creepiness to satisfy my horror-loving heart. If I didn’t have to work, I would’ve read the book in one sitting.
I highly recommend Deathsworn to anyone who likes a dark (vibes not romance) romantasy with heart. I can’t wait to own this one!
Thank you, NetGalley and Saturday Books, for this ARC. All opinions are my own.
Dear Hells and Rested Spirits, my jaw is on the floor.
This is my first book by Meg Smitherman, but if this is the quality of her work, then I need to read her entire body of work.
I honestly didn't know what to expect going into the book; in fact, I was a little on the fence because the marketing description was just the book blurb. (Seriously, Saturday, you have a masterpiece on your hands; lose the Reylo description and the "The Knight and the Moth" meets "Phantasma" comparison, because aside from the book being a Gothic Fantasy, it doesn't really resemble either.)
That being said, this is absolutely a heart wrenching tale between life, death, humanity and processing grief.
I have no words; the world is dark, the lore is rich, and the levity of the dark humor elevated every aspect of this book. I don't even know how to articulate all the ways in which you should pick up this book without spoiling the whole thing! AND THAT ENDING. I was just staring at a wall, happy-crying. Wow. It's unlike anything else I've read this year. This is just a stunning gothic fantasy, and I just want more because I don't want it to be over.
I want you guys to imagine me on one beautiful morning coming across a marketing post for this book which described it as a Gothic Fantasy Romance, I was like a dog hearing all my fav words so i immediately ran to netgalley to request it because why wouldn't I? The knight and the moth as a comp title?!? Sign me up!! So imagine my surprise when instead of gothic atmosphere, an angsty enemies to lovers and a solid world building I get whatever this is. I have soo many issues with this book i don't even know where to begin.
• ✦ The Plot/World building — Flimsy barely there world building. The scientists are still looking for a reason for the footnotes. The glossary at the beginning felt so lazy so that the author doesn't actually have to explain the system and magic in the actual text. The two kingdoms are at war but the stakes felt so incredibly low. Why are they STILL fighting? Oh idk because the book never tells us that. We barely get answers about anythingg. Like tell us more about Death! The ending was so predictable which necessarily wouldn't have been a bad thing if the execution was good atleast, spoiler alert : it wasn't. How do you write about necromancy and make that boring?!? That is a skill on it's own which we have to applaud.
• ✦ The Characters — Absolutely unbearable. The two main characters suck so much it infuriates me to even think about it. Jonquil our main character is supposed to be this edgy badass woman with mommy issues but omg she was insufferable but somehow the MMC was even worse. He was so pathetic and not even in a good way. There was no character development they were both the same as they in the beginning of this book till the end. He doesn't answer for all his war crimes at all?!? Like i get morally gray characters, my favourite archetype to exist but this was such a bad execution of it. The more I think about them the angrier i get so I'm just gonna move, idc if my review makes no sense.
• ✦ The Romance — Oh buddy don't even get me started. This is a disgrace in the name of a slowburn enemies to lovers. It felt more like a survival trauma bond than an actual connection. For a supposed slow burn among two people who can't stand each other they were just trauma dumping each on each other and where was the yearning where was the angst?!? They were so incredibly civil towards each other for them to be actual enemies they were just all bark and no bite. "I want to kill you" and then they continue walking together merrily?? The one time they fought (the beginning of the book and their technical second meeting) it wasn't because they wanted to fight each other it's because they had to. She immediately forgot every single one of his actual freaking war crimes bc she was attracted to him be fr.
⤿Overall: I know this review made no sense and was all over the place but i simply do want to to linger on it long enough. This is a book which was written. I hate the World-building, hate the writing, hate the characters, hate the romance but i hate myself more for reading this.
Thank you Saturday Books for an advanced copy via NetGalley!
This was my first book by Meg Smitherman, and while not what I expected, I still enjoyed it! What I’d anticipated and my own preferences definitely caught me off guard but that’s absolutely not a reflection of the book.
The magic & political system (necromancers, animancers- war over whose power is “right”), and my interpretation of the theming (judgment, acceptance, does anyone actually win in war?) were the highlights!
The majority of this story is character driven, with a ton of action and plot development placed at the tail end of the book. If you enjoy gothic settings with internal growth/battles, I think you’d really love it!
Having absolutely loved Fervor, I was incredibly excited to dive back into Meg's wonderfully weird mind, and Deathsworn delivered!
Love the concept of the story - life and death magic colliding, two sworn enemies forced to navigate the underworld together and forced to work together to fix their own abomination, the construct was SUCH a great metaphor. Necromantasy is where it is at!
Meg has done a fantastic job of creating an unsettling, gothic atmosphere. The locations in the underworld were wonderfully eerie, and the monsters spectacularly spooky.
This is a very character-driven story, which I actually really enjoyed. Jonquil and Edmund are both carrying an enormous amount of guilt and anger, and their hatred for one another feels real and genuine. They really are ENEMIES!! That just makes their reluctant alliance and painfully slow-burn romance all the more satisfying and juicy. I particularly loved following the Duke's story, seeing glimpses of Edmund emerge beneath that glorious mask. And you really cannot go wrong with a masked MMC. Not in my books.
Despite the dark themes for the book, Jonquil's dry and witty banter did give me a few laughs and giggles throughout the book, the sense of humour to break it up a bit was perfectly merged.
"She saw something like absolution in his eyes. Something like love. Or were they one in the same?"
Absolutely loved this quote as I think it captures the deeper meaning of Deathsworn. I won't go into too much detail because I don't want to spoil anything, but the way certain emotions are represented throughout the story was so clever. I love the idea that love and forgiveness can go hand in hand, and that sometimes you need to learn to forgive yourself in order to accept yourself, even the parts you're not proud of. Such a lovely message at the heart of an otherwise darker story.
If I had one criticism, it's that I wanted MORE WEIRD. Maybe that's just because I know where Meg can go and I wanted something a bit more insane. Don't get me wrong, it's still gritty and gruesome, and the horror elements are very fun, but I would have happily embraced more of that madness.
The final part of Meg's acknowledgements about her husband?! SO bloody cute!!!
Overall, Deathsworn is a thoroughly enjoyable gothic romantasy with an atmospheric journey through Death and a deeper exploration of self-acceptance. The enemies-to-lovers romance is deliciously slow-burning, and I'd definitely recommend it to readers who enjoy their romantasy on the darker side with a cheeky little bit of femdom spice in the mix!
HUGE thank you to Michael Joseph for approving me for this ARC!
Thank you very much to the author and publisher, and to NetGalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Deathsworn is a gothic fantasy romance set in a war between the animancers of Lux City and the necromancers of Umbra City. When Jonquil Foye finds herself duelling the Duke of Death for the outcome of their homelands’ seemingly endless war, their powers clash in ways neither of them can predict. As their fates become inextricably linked, the two enemies must learn to tolerate each other if they’re to survive and save their homes—a feat neither easier said nor done.
I had a wonderful time with this book. The story flows beautifully, and I connected with the protagonists very deeply. I adored Jonquil as a protagonist; she is strong, intelligent, and outspoken without being needlessly confrontational or frustrating. Edmund was also brilliantly developed, and I loved seeing the parts of him that changed (and those that didn’t!). While I would have liked for the living side characters (particularly Dagmar and the Prince) to see more development outside of their direct relationships with the leads, I also structurally understand why other characters had to take precedence in otherwise limited page space.
The pacing of this story is, to my interpretation, extremely meaningful. At the beginning and end, the story races onwards, propelled by a vibrant energy ascribable to being in the land of the living. In the parts of the book spent in Death, the pacing slows, allowing the reader to sink into the forest’s serenity and get to know the characters on an enchantingly profound level. In a way, the chapters in Death feel more distant from the chaos yet never removed from it, and it’s this balance of peace and tension that allows for phenomenal character explorations. I acknowledge that some readers may find the middle portion fairly slow, especially when juxtaposed against the surprisingly quick start, but readers who enjoy slower character explorations will likely enjoy this portion of the book.
The romance in this book was truly delightful. The slow burn was wonderfully slow for a standalone, and their transition from enemies to allies to friends to lovers was gradual and satisfying. I enjoyed seeing the parallels and differences between them, not least of all because Jonquil’s strength and wit never diminishes as she softens towards Edmund. If anything, she becomes even bolder—both towards him and others—without ever being dependent on him for her self-assurance.
That said, even while I understand why the side characters were, well, sidelined, I still think we could have seen more of them—at minimum through flashbacks. We see more of Magnus than Dagmar, and he arguably gets more nuance than she does. Dagmar is perhaps this book’s biggest sacrifice, as she is wholly reduced to being Jonquil’s friend and support system. Though she is given a somewhat satisfying role to play in the end, we don’t see it play out on the page.
I will also say the prose occasionally fell on some slightly cliché turns of phrase. These were by no means egregious, and might not even be noticeable to the untrained or unfamiliar eye. Similarly, to the seasoned fantasy reader, the denouement and technical unraveling of the novel’s mystery in the context of its magic system isn’t wholly fleshed out—we get an answer, but considering the opening chapters have paragraph-long footnotes on the magic system, I would have liked a more technical explanation for it.
In my experience with Meg Smitherman’s recent writing (I recently read and loved her horror/romance novella, Fervor), I’ve found myself encountering junctions in the stories where I could see some readers being elated and others frustrated. This is not a flaw, but rather a symptom of how directly and deliberately Smitherman writes. Her authorial choices may be divisive, and some readers might not even stop at each junction to acknowledge it, but her writing leans unapologetically into her vision for how it should be. This, I believe, is the mark of a truly seasoned author.
Overall, Deathsworn is a wonderfully dark, gothic romantic fantasy with fun banter, excellent protagonists, and powerful explorations of grief, guilt, love, loss, and trauma. Smitherman handles her themes with grace and finesse, packaging a poignant character exploration in an exciting, banter-filled parcel perfect for a winter read.